Asymptotic Medicine by Karmen Lončarek [email protected]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HeAltH of tHe HeAltH SySteM 83 doi: 10.3325/cmj.2009.50.83 Asymptotic Medicine By Karmen Lončarek [email protected] Medicine and “Big Pharma” (1), as its strongest ally, are rap- although extreme, example: suppose there was a medi- idly reorienting toward treating the healthy people, which cation that could make everybody’s skin color exactly the is well reflected in the Ray Moynihan’s term of disease same. If everyone took the medication, discrimination mongering (2) and Richard Smith’s list of non-diseases (3). based on skin color would certainly be eliminated. How- The most obvious and commonest reasons for this trend ever, having the “wrong” skin color is not a “lifestyle prob- are profit (healthy people are more numerous and wealth- lem,” nor are aging, menopause, or shyness (13). Obviously, ier than ill people), defensive medicine (fear from lawsuits medicine plays a role of strong social regulator, concealing for malpractice) (4), greater personal satisfaction, and bet- some aspects of social injustice and inequality. ter health outcomes (generally, healthy people have bet- ter outcomes than the sick ones). However, there are some TECHNOLOGY OF USELESSNESS other, less obvious, reasons why physicians choose to treat healthy people. Besides physician-healthy patient relation, there is also a second important element of modern medicine – medi- Let us take a look at the list of the most prevalent medical cal technology. procedures (Box 1) and the most common pharmaceuti- cal interventions (Box 2) aimed at healthy people (lifestyle There are two scenarios about the future of technology – pharmacology), which pervade almost all medical special- one is that totally useful technology would finally bring us to ties (5-9). the Utopia and the other that technology would overpower us and create the Dystopia. Today, a third scenario is emerg- FEEL-GOOD DRUGS AND COERCIVE NORMALITY ing: the rise of useless technology or the technology of use- lessness. We still remember the technology of Star Wars, but The above-listed medical procedures and pharmaceuticals we are also aware of the huge amounts of nuclear weap- make the patient feel better without curative properties. ons that could destroy the planet not only once, but many Furthermore, most of these treatments and medications times: all of these extremely elaborate and extremely expen- are basically targeted less to help the patient, or “patient,” sive items are genuinely and undeniably useless. Moreover, and more to “help” the society by “normalizing” the patients their real value is mainly in their uselessness – their creation and, subsequently, by homogenizing the population. and production was from the beginning driven by the idea that these weapons will never be activated (14). Virtually, any unpleasant or socially unwanted human con- dition can become the object of medical-pharmaceutical LOW-HANGING FRUIT treatment, and justification is almost universal: in today’s globalized culture, physical and mental well-being (euphe- Similar technology of uselessness can be detected in health mism for “normality” or coercive normality) are highly ap- care systems, especially in many transitional countries, ie, preciated and of a great social value and any aberration diagnostic image devices that cannot be used because no from this socially demanded “normality” has a great impact staff was trained to use them (I cannot corroborate my ob- on patient’s quality of life (12). servation by any reference because this problem is not the one that local physicians or journalists are allowed to re- In other words, physicians are dealing with social injustices search or write about). by prescribing drugs to render their patients more similar to the norm, and thus concealing the fact that it is up to so- Many expensive medications can be described as a high- ciety to eliminate injustice while retaining the population’s hanging fruit, ie, they are extremely complicated to de- heterogeneity. velop, extremely expensive, and of very little benefit. When we compare the cost-benefit ratio of low-hang- It is not so annoying when a physician deals with patient’s ing medical fruits like soap and running water used in prominent ears or snub nose, but let us take an illustrative, the prevention of infectious diseases (15) with that www.cmj.hr 84 HeAltH of tHe HeAltH SySteM Croat Med J. 2009; 50: 83-6 of modern high-hanging fruits (like extremely expensive SHRINKING AREAS OF PEAK-SHAPED KNOWLEDGE cytostatics that extend the life for only a few weeks or ex- tremely expensive medical apparatuses, like 25-gauge vit- There is also a third important element of modern med- rectomy, that provide relatively small benefit compared icine, ie, medical education. We can see that it has been with smaller gauge vitrectomies) (16,17), we see that the taken over by a trend of fragmentation into narrowly con- latter asymptotically approaches the infinity – to the point fined specializations and sub-specializations, and that phy- of medical l’art pour l’art, pure medical technology eman- sicians are forced to develop a peak-shaped knowledge by cipated and liberated of usefulness. learning more and more on progressively shrinking areas Box 1.. List of the most prevalent medical procedures aimed for healthy people Pediatrics sliding genioplasty of the jawbone) Esthetic dentistry (7) Routine circumcision of neonates Cheek augmentation Tooth whitening Umbilical cord blood banking Collagen, fat, and other tissue filler injec- Tooth contouring tions (eg, hyaluronic acid) Dermatology Enamel-shaping (or tooth bonding; an Scalp advancement Skin lightening (with kojic acid, polyphe- enamel-like dental composite material is nol extract from acerola, arbutine; laser Facial implants applied to a tooth’s surface) treatments) Ophthalmology Dental bridges Cosmetic tattooing Subconjunctival decorative implants Cosmetic porcelain veneers Hair transplantation Eyelash transplantation Gingivoplasty (gum lift) Permanent hair removal (laser epilation) Laser pupilloplasty (permanent dilation of Gingivectomy Injection of botulinum toxin pupils) Dental implants Injectable facial implants (collagen, hyal- Blepharoplasty, including Asian blepharo- Microabrasion uronic acid, autologous fat tissue) plasty in order to look more Caucasian Crowns Laser skin resurfacing Eyelash-lengthening drug tradename Orthodontic treatments Chemical peeling Latisse, bimatoprost solution 0.03%, pro- Jaw wiring (orthodontic brackets prevent- duced by Allergan, was developed from Mesotherapy ing the eating of solid foods) Microdermabrasion drug used for the treatment of glaucoma) Orthopedics Aesthetic treatment of leg veins (sclero- Andrology/male urology therapy, laser therapy) Scrotal implants Rib removal (the lowest ribs surgically removed to make the waist thinner) General surgery: procedures of body Penis enlargement (with a filler injections contouring or fat grafting) Leg lengthening surgery (Ilizarov tech- Abdominoplasty (“tummy tuck”) nique of surgical lengthening of leg bones) Gynecology and obstetrics (5) Mammoplasty (breast reshaping): breast Cosmetic surgery of the feet (eg, shorten- Labiaplasty augmentation (fat grafting, saline or ing of the secnd toe) silicone gel prosthetics); breast reduction; Cosmetic genitoplasty Otorhinolaringology breast lift Vaginal rejuvenation Rhinoplasty Male pectoral implant Designer vaginoplasty Otoplasty Buttock augmentation (silicone implants Hymenorrhaphy (revirgination) or fat grafting) G-spot amplification Non-surgical therapy of non-apnoic snor- Liposuction Elective Cesarean section on term ing Mandibular advancement splints “Abdominal etching” liposuction tech- Digestive surgery (different procedures nique (creates definition of “six-pack abs”) of bariatric surgery or weight loss Continuous positive airway pressure Brachioplasty (surgical treatment for upper surgery) (6) devices arm soft tissue excess and laxity) Biliopancreatic diversion Surgical therapy of non- apnoic snoring “Thighplasty” Jejuno-ileal bypass Uvulopalatopharyngoplasty Scar revision Vertical banded gastroplasty Laser-assisted uvulopalatoplasty Radical surgical makeover (4-5 surgical Adjustable gastric band Palatal stiffening techniques procedures at a time) Sleeve gastrectomy Pillar implants Maxillofacial surgery Gastric bypass surgery Injection snoreplasty Rhytidectomy (“face lift”) Sleeve gastrectomy with duodenal switch Radiofrequency ablation of the soft palate Chin augmentation (with an implant or by Implantable gastric stimulation or tongue base www.cmj.hr Lončarek 85 Box 2. List of lifestyle pharmaceuticals (8) Drug therapy for obesity: sibutramine, orlistat, phentermine, diethylpropion, fluoxetine, bupropion, amphetamine, methamphetamine; sertraline, topiramate, zonisamide, rimonabant Use of human growth hormone for normal, healthy, aging adults (9) Norethisterone for postponing the menstruation Pharmaceuticals targeted to alleviate the menopausal “symptoms” (hormone replacement therapy, local therapy for vaginal dryness, nutritional supplements, black cohosh extract...) Pharmaceuticals targeted to alleviate the “symptoms” of normal aging or “somatopause” (nootropics; psychopharmaca; hormones; ecodrugs ie, plants and herbs with known hallucinogenic, sedative or stimulating effects) (10) Pharmaceuticals for erectile dysfunction (sildenafil, vardenafil, tadalafil, phentolamine, apomorphine) Dapoxetine against premature ejaculation Pharmaceuticals for androgenetic baldness (finasteride, dutasteride, minoxidil, topical caffeine) Testosterone