AD 536 the Sun Dimmed and Global Temperatures Plunged, Leading to Famine, Plague and the Collapse of Empires
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“ The sun began to be darkened by day and the moon by night, while the ocean was tumultuous with spray from the 24th of March in this year till the 24th of June in the following year… And, as the winter was a severe one, so much so that from the large and unwonted quantity of snow the birds perished… there was distress… among men… from the evil things” ZACHARIAS OF MYTILENE (Chronicle, 9.19, 10.1) The year of darkness In AD 536 the sun dimmed and global temperatures plunged, leading to famine, plague and the collapse of empires. At last clues are emerging about the cause of this event, as Colin Barras reports 34 | NewScientist | 18 January 2014 EBvb^ofp>A203)^ka?vw^kqfkb efpqlof^kMol`lmfrplc@^bp^ob^e^pgrpq T^oofsbafkplrqebokFq^iv+Qeb_^i^k`blc mltbofkqebJbafqboo^kb^kfpfkciru7S^ka^ip e^ap^`hbaOljbfk122^kaqebTbpqbok Olj^kBjmfobe^ac^iibkfk143+Grpqfkf^kF) qeb?vw^kqfkb%loB^pqbokOlj^k&Bjmbolo) fpabqbojfkbaqlob`i^fjqebilpqqboofqlofbp+ >cqbo^pr``bppcri`^jm^fdk^d^fkpqqebKloqe >cof`^kS^ka^iHfkdaljfkqebb^oiv20-p) Grpqfkf^kafpm^q`ebpefp^ojvqlobq^hbFq^iv+ Vbq^pMol`lmfrpob`loap)pljbqefkdlaa qebke^mmbkba+Qebprkafjjba)^kaqeb afjkbppi^pqbaclojlobqe^k^vb^o+Qebob tbobcolpqp^kapkltpfkqebjfaaiblc prjjboÌqebtfkqbokbsboob^iivbkaba+Colj Fq^ivqlFobi^ka)@efk^ql@bkqo^i>jbof`^)qeb vb^o203t^pqeb_bdfkkfkdlc^ab`^ab*ilkd `liapk^m_bpbq_vqrojlfi+Obifdflkpilpq _bifbsbop)`fqfbp`lii^mpba^kalkblcqeb dob^qbpqmi^drbpfkefpqlovhfiiba^nr^oqbo lcqebmlmri^qflkfkqeb?vw^kqfkbBjmfob+ Grpqfkf^kÑp^ojfbpafaj^k^dbqlobq^hbOljb) _rqefptb^hbkbabjmfobt^plsbopqobq`eba) ^kapllkilpqqebqboofqlov^d^fk+ Fk^ijlpqbsbovobdflklcqebtloia)qefp mboflat^pj^ohbatfqe_^atb^qebo)pl`f^i afploaboÌ^kaab^qe+Qefp`ifj^qf`altkqrok j^vtbiie^sbmolclrkaiv^iqbobaqeb`lropb lcefpqlov+Qebqofddbolcqefp`llifkde^pilkd _bbk^jvpqbov)_rqklttbj^vcfk^iiv_b `ilpbqlfabkqfcvfkdqeb`rimofqÌlo`rimofqp+ Qebcfopqbsfabk`blcqeb>A203bsbkq `^jbcolj^pqravfkqeb.65-p_vqtlK>P> dblildfpqp)Of`e^oaPqlqebop^kaJf`e^bi O^jmfkl+Qebvqo^tibaqeolrdeb^oiv efpqlof`^i^``lrkqpillhfkdcloobcbobk`bpql sli`^kf`bormqflkp^olrkaqebJbafqboo^kb^k+ Qebv`lk`irabaqe^qqebobe^a_bbk^qib^pq pbsbkj^globormqflkp_bclob>A30-) fk`irafkdqeblkbfk>A46qe^q_rofbaqeb qltklcMljmbff+ Vbqtefibqebobtbobclro^``lrkqpÌ fk`irafkdqe^qlcMol`lmfrpÌlc^k .5*jlkqe*ilkdmboflalcrkrpr^iivafjphfbp) _bdfkkfkd^olrka>A203)qebobtbobklafob`q obcbobk`bpql^sli`^kf`bormqflk^qqefpqfjb+ Pqlqebop^kaO^jmfkl`lk`irabaqe^qqeb `^rpbjrpqe^sb_bbk^j^ppfsbsli`^kf` bormqflkqelrp^kaplcjfibpcoljBrolmb+ Qefpt^p`boq^fkivmi^rpf_ib+Qebbormqflk lcqebFkalkbpf^ksli`^kllcQ^j_lo^fk.5.2) ^cqbo^ii)t^pcliiltba_v^Îvb^otfqelrq^ prjjboÏ^`olppqebkloqebokebjfpmebob NCE FLOUE NCE A %^kaj^ve^sbdfsbkrpCo^khbkpqbfk^ka _f`v`ibp&+Qebefpqlof`^i^``lrkqpprddbpqba UME/TEND A qe^q203t^pjr`ejlobpbsbobqe^k.5.3) _rq`lriaqebv_bqorpqba< IN WILLIN A AL Î>iilcqeb^k`fbkqqbuqp`lria_bnrf__iba > 18 January 2014 | NewScientist | 35 140118_F_AD536.indd 35 13/1/14 11:42:07 ” The sun “ There was a sign in the tfqe)Ïp^vpJf`e^bi?^fiifb^qNrbbkÑp Tebkebclrkal_p`robobcbobk`bpql Rkfsbopfqv?bic^pq)RH+?rqtfqeefpebim)^k rkrpr^im^oqf^ib`ifmpbpfkkloqe*tbpqBrolmb sun the like of which fjm^oqf^itfqkbppqlqeb3qe`bkqrovbsbkqp fk205^ka21-)?^fiifb_bd^kqltlkabo had never been seen and _olhbfqppfibk`bfkqebi^qb.65-p+?^fiifb tebqeboqebplro`blcqebqolr_ibt^pklq pqrafbpqobbofkdp^ka)rpfkdl^hmobpbosbafk sli`^kf`_rqbuqo^qboobpqof^i+Fk.661)peloqiv becamereported before… The dim…Fofpe_ldp)eb^kaefp`liib^drbpmrqqldbqebo _bclobco^djbkqplcqeb`ljbqPelbj^hbo* sun became dark and ^qobb*ofkdob`loapqobq`efkd_^`hjlobqe^k Ibsv6milrdebafkqlGrmfqbo)ebprddbpqba 4---vb^op+Fk.655)qebvobmloqbaqe^qarofkd qe^qarpqcolj^`ljbqqe^qe^am^ppbakb^o its darkness lasted for qebcfopqjfiibkkfrj>A)qebk^ooltbpqqobb B^oqeÌlobsbk`liifabatfqelromi^kbqÌ`lria eighteen months. Each ofkdpÌfkaf`^qfkdmllodoltfkd`lkafqflkp bumi^fk_lqeqebrkrpr^iivilkd`ifj^qf` for nearly^ka`liaqbjmbo^qrobpÌl``roobatfqefk^ the altkqrok^kaqebi^`hlc^sli`^kf`pfdk^qrob+ day it shone for about four cbtvb^oplc203+ Fk^.666_llh)?^fiifbtbkqcroqebo) hours, and still this light Jlobqobb*ofkda^q^cliiltbacoljlqebo prddbpqfkdqe^qpbsbo^ij^glo`ifj^qf``e^kdbp dolrmp)^ka^m^qqbokbjbodba+ÎQebk^oolt fkqebm^pq.-)---vb^optbobqofddboba_v was only a feeble shadow. qobbofkdptbobkÑqgrpqfkBrolmb^kl^h+ fjm^`qp+Ebpmb`ri^qba^_lrqifkhptfqe^ wholeEveryone declared that year… the QebvtbobfkP`^kafk^sf^kmfkbp)^kafkqobbp _ol^ao^kdblcefpqlof`^i^kabsbkjvqef`^i sun would never recover its coljKloqe^kaPlrqe>jbof`^)Ïp^vp?^fiifb+ bsbkqp)fk`irafkdqebab^qelcHfkd>oqero+ ÎQefpmobqqvjr`ee^aql_b^dil_^ibsbkq+Ï full light. The fruits did not ?rqqebobt^ppljbqefkdjfppfkd+>p The plague of Justinian ripen and the wine tasted sli`^kf`^pe^kaprimerom^oqf`ibpt^pelrq lcqeb^qjlpmebob)qebvib^sbqo^`bpfkqebf`b Te^qfp`boq^fkfpqe^qqebvb^opcliiltfkd solike sourthat grapes” theclojfkdkb^oqebmlibp+Arofkdqeb.65-p)f`b 203tbobbsbkqcri+Fk@efk^)clofkpq^k`b)qeb MICHAEL THE SYRIAN (Chronicle, 9.296) `lobpcoljDobbki^katbobobsb^ifkdbsfabk`b KloqebokTbfavk^pqv`lii^mpba^olrkaqefp lcj^kvmobsflrpivrkhkltkbormqflkp) qfjb+ÎQebobÑptofqqbkbsfabk`bqe^q^_lrq fk`irafkd^m^oqf`ri^oivj^ppfsblkbfk./24+ 42mbo`bkqlcmblmibafba_b`^rpblc`lia)`olm Qebobt^p)eltbsbo)klsli`^kf`pfdk^qrobfk c^firob)pq^os^qflk^kaaolrdeqp)Ïp^vpM^vplk fruits weref`bclojba^olrka203+ Pebbqp)^k^o`e^blildfpq^qqebRkfsbopfqvlc Qebqobbofkdptbob^iplobsb^ifkd @lilo^alfk?lriabo+ÎQebobt^pmlifqf`^i^ka pljbqefkdrkbumb`qba+Abpmfqbqebbjme^pfp obifdflrpqrojlfi+Ï qe^qqebefpqlof`^i^``lrkqpmi^`balk203)qeb Fk@bkqo^i>jbof`^)qebmlmri^qflklcqeb qobb*ofkdob`loaprddbpqbadoltfkd`lkafqflkp erdb`fqvpq^qblcQblqfer^`^k^iplab`ifkba+ tbob^tcrifkqebvb^opcliiltfkd21-^ptbii+ ÎQebbu^`qa^qfkdfprmcloab_^qb)_rq_v killed at anFkc^`q)qebqobbofkdppeltbaqe^qqeb`lia ^olrka22-)qebmblmibqebobtbobabif_bo^qbiv pk^m`lkqfkrbaclo^ab`^ab+Fqfpsbovrkrpr^i _rokfkdqebqbjmibplkqebqlmlcqebfopqbm* clo^kbormqflkqlqofddbo^ab`^ablc`llifkd) mvo^jfap)Ïp^vpPebbqp+ÎQebve^ailpqc^fqefk p^vp?^fiifb)_b`^rpbqeb^pe^kaprimero*of`e qebfooribopÑ^_fifqfbpql^`q^pfkqbojbaf^ofbp m^oqf`ibpqeoltkfkqlqeb^qjlpmebob_v^ _bqtbbkmblmib^kaqebfodlap+Ï unseasonablesli`^klpelriat^pelrq^d^fktfqefk^cbt >kagrpq^pGrpqfkf^kt^pob`lknrbofkd vb^op+Qebcfkafkdpdlq?^fiifbobqefkhfkdqeb qebB^pqbokOlj^kBjmfob)efppr_gb`qp plro`blcqebqolr_ib+ÎPqlqebop^kaO^jmfkl _bd^kaolmmfkdifhbcifbp+?v21/)Mol`lmfrp p^tqebbsbkq^pbsfabk`blc^sli`^kf` t^pi^jbkqfkdte^qfpklthkltk^p bormqflk)_rqmboe^mpqebobt^p^klqebo qebMi^drblcGrpqfkf^kÌ^kb^oivclojlc time.” bumi^k^qflk)Ïp^vp?^fiifb+ _r_lkf`mi^drbÌtef`eebp^fat^p`i^fjfkd Climate catastrophe Tree rings and other records show the world suddenly cooled around AD 536, a period marked by famines, plagues and turmoil. But what caused it? 1 The Northern Wei dynasty of China collapses and three-quarters of the 0 The huge city state of population dies Teotihuacan declines The Plague of Justinian kills a quarter of the -1 population of the The Ilopango volcano Eastern Roman Empire erupted in the 5th or 6th century A comet fragment may -2 have hit the Gulf of Carpentaria sometime in Deviation of extratropical northern extratropical of Deviation the frst millennium hemisphere temperature from norm (°C) from temperature hemisphere -3 CHRISTIANSEN 2011 SOURCE: 500 520 540 560 580 600 Date (AD) 36 | NewScientist | 18 January 2014 The Plague of Justinian was an early form of the bubonic plague that caused the Black Death ULTURALI C TT. TT. A .-)---ifsbpb^`ea^v^qfqpmb^h+ ENI E E ENI Tbob^iiqebpbafpm^o^qbbsbkqpqofddboba_v B TERO TERO dil_^i`llifkd<?^fiifbqefkhpqebvjfdeqe^sb S INI _bbk+Clofkpq^k`b)qebMi^drblcGrpqfkf^k M `lriae^sb_bbk^kfkafob`qobpriqlcclla THE OF peloq^dbpqeolrdelrqBro^pf^)tef`eibaql SY qebj^ppjlsbjbkqlcmblmib^kaafpb^pb* COURTE `^oovfkdolabkqp+ÎMblmibtbobbumlpbaql - m^qeldbkpqebvtbobrkc^jfif^otfqe)Ïeb LORENCE p^vp+ÎMi^drb_olhblrq^kapmob^aÌfqÑpqeb F `i^ppf`?i^`hAb^qep`bk^ofl+Ï SCALA, Molsfkdqe^qpmb`fcf`efpqlof`^ibsbkqp tbobqofddboba_v`ifj^qb`e^kdbfpkfde lkfjmlppf_ib)_rqm^fkpq^hfkdpqrafbp_v A^sfaWe^kdlcqebRkfsbopfqvlcElkdHlkd e^sbpeltkqe^qqebobfp^pqolkdifkh _bqtbbk`llibomboflap^kac^jfkb)mi^drb) j^ppjfdo^qflkp)pl`f^iqrojlfi^kabsbk t^op%KbtP`fbkqfpq)1>rdrpq/-./)m0/&+ ÎF_bifbsbfqfpmlppf_ibqe^qqebab`^a^i*p`^ib `llifkdfk20-p^ka21-p`lriae^sb`^rpba bmfabjf`p)ÏWe^kdp^vp+ÎKlqlkiv_b`^rpb ÎLqebotfpbvlrtlriakÑqdbq^pfdk^ifkqeb ^qqebRkfsbopfqvlcQbu^p^q>rpqfk)tele^p lcqebjfdo^qflkp)_rq^ipl_b`^rpbc^jfkb f`b^q_lqemlibp+Ï tlohbalkFilm^kdlclovb^op+Qebobt^pgrpq `^rpbamlloeb^iqe^jlkdmlmri^qflkp+Ï Qeberkqcloqebsli`^klt^plkÌ^ka^ lkbmol_ibj7`^o_lka^qfkdlcmi^kqj^qbof^i >iqelrdetbtfiikbsbohkltcloprobte^q prpmb`qpllkbjbodba+Cloqrfqlrpiv)Pqbccbk clrkafkqeb^pemlfkqbaql^a^qbpljbqfjb qebefpqlof`^i`lkpbnrbk`bptbob)fk/--/ Hrqqbolic^qHfbiRkfsbopfqvfkDboj^kv^ka ^olrka>A10-+Qe^qt^p.--vb^opqllb^oiv) ?^fiifbpbq^_lrqillhfkdclobsfabk`blc^k efp`liib^drbptbobob^ppbppfkdqebpfwblc _rqqeba^qfkdt^plkivmolsfpflk^i+ buqo^qboobpqof^iqofddboÌpr`e^pqebplifafcfba hkltksli`^kf`bormqflkpfk@bkqo^i>jbof`^ >cqboob^afkdqebpbpqrafbp)Ariiqb^jba aolmibqplcjliqbkj^qbof^idbkbo^qba_v^k _vjb^profkd^peabmlpfqp+Qebfotloh) rmtfqeHrqqbolic+Qebfab^t^pqlmfkaltk fjm^`qÌfk^Dobbki^kaf`b`lob+ÎTbclrka mr_ifpebatfqefkjlkqeplcSfkqeboÑppqrav) qeba^qbjlobmob`fpbiv_v`^o_lka^qfkd qe^qfqt^pm^`hbacriilcdi^ppv^kajbq^iif` alr_ibaqebbpqfj^qbapfwblc^kbormqflk qebdoltqeofkdpfk^qobbqorkh+Qe^qjb^kq pmeboribp)^kaFqelrdeqtbe^alrobsfabk`b+Ï coljqebFilm^kdlsli`^klfkBiP^is^alo+Tb cfkafkd^qobbfkqeb^pe+Fk/-.-)qebqb^j ?rqfqt^pkÑqql_b+Qebobt^pklqo^`blc klthkltqefpbormqflkdbkbo^qba51`r_f` ^kklrk`bacfkafkd^qobbqe^qe^aafba pfjfi^opmeboribpfk^pb`lkaf`b`lob+ÎQeb hfiljbqobplc^pe)p^vpHrqqbolic+ pljbqfjb_bqtbbk2--^ka22-)j^hfkd pmeboribpfkqebcfopqf`be^aql_b