BOWDOINWinter 2003 Volume 74, Number 2 Take YourBest Shot Nick Pierpan ’95, Oxford scholar, boxing champ, and award-winning playwright contentswinter2003 Where “Credit” Is Due 12 By Lisa Wesel Photographs by James Marshall In a world where reality tv passes for authenticity, where politicians parse every sentence, and where Pulitizer prize-winners sometimes get caught making things up, it’s not surpris- ing that there can be some confusion about the proper way to cite sources and attribute ideas. Read how a faculty working group has been developing ways to help. 12 Take Your Best Shot 20 Interview by William Watterson Photographs by Stephen Hyde Nick Pierpan ‘95, Oxford scholar, boxing champ, and award-winning playwright, talks about combining divergent interests, the problem of “home,” and how the acts of putting one’s work out on the stage and one’s self into the ring require similar leaps of faith. Bowdoin College Land Grant 28 The Heart of Maine’s Wilderness has Bowoin History 20 By Edgar Allen Beem Photographs by Alan LaVallee Departments Bowdoin’s roots go deeper in Maine than the mid-coast area — in fact, they are deep in the land least traveled. Ed Beem explains how Bowdoin history can be found in what is Mailbox 2 still Maine’s wilderness, where the Bowdoin College Land Grants encompass two tracts Bookshelf 3 of land that total nearly 50,000 acres, including some of the most beautiful and wild stretches of the Appalachian Trail. College & Maine 4 Weddings 36 Class News 39 Obituaries 68 28 BOWDOINeditor’s note staff Volume 74, Number 2 Winter, 2003 MAGAZINE STAFF There’s nothing like talk of what’s right to get people to start obsessing. In twen- ty-first century America, everything having to do with virtue can seem to be Editor some shade of gray (after all, it depends on what the definition of “is” is), and it Alison M. Bennie can be hard to find any black and white that would help you make a decision. Assistant Editor It’s not just politics, sexual and otherwise, it’s issues of reporting social security Matthew J. O’Donnell wages to household help, debates about stem cell research, the question of how Design much acting is actually permissible in reality TV, even wondering how much you Pennisi & Company should seek in the way of damages after an auto accident. The line you know Falmouth, Maine you shouldn’t cross over is sort of like that yellow first-down line on the tele- Obituary Editor vised football field. It’s not always visible, and there’s always somebody who John R. Cross ’76 wishes it were somewhere else. Contributors Allyson Algeo But, though it might seem so to some, academic honesty is not one of those James Caton questionable areas. You might be able to get away with presenting ideas or turns- Susan Danforth Caitlin Fowkes ’03 of-phrase or scientific findings as if they were your own scintillating notions at a Ann Sullivan ’06 dinner party, but you’re not going to pull it off in a Bowdoin paper. And, as Scott W. Hood you’ll read in Lisa Wesel’s story about the subject, it’s not that faculty are being harsh or punitive, it’s that something much larger is at stake – the integrity of the Photographs by Brian Beard, Dennis academy. Building on the ideas of others is of course how knowledge is Griggs, Stephen Hyde, Howard A. advanced, and that is why collaboration is emphasized in today’s colleges and Law IV ’05, James Marshall, and Bowdoin College Archives. universities. Two heads are better than one, and all that. But original work is cur- rency, and not just because there are royalties to be made. Original thought and BOWDOIN (ISSN, 0895-2604) is published four times a year by Bowdoin research and scholarship are the currency of an academic community in other College, 4104 College Station, ways as well. They are what build careers, make reputations, and serve as build- Brunswick, Maine 04011. Printed by ing blocks for other scholars to follow, and their original authorship simply must Dartmouth Printing, Hanover, New Hampshire. Third-class postage paid at be respected. Hanover, New Hampshire. Sent free of charge to all Bowdoin alumni/ae, parents But knowing that doesn’t make it easy. Lisa confessed to the highest level of care of current and recent undergraduates, faculty and staff, seniors, and selected in her note-taking while researching this article, not wanting to miss a quote or a members of the Association of Bowdoin citation anywhere. And I worried, because it was in the same issue, about being Friends. certain that every photo we used in the Bowdoin land grant story was in fact Opinions expressed in this magazine actually taken in that area. A Maine tree might be a Maine tree, but I sure wanted are those of the authors. to be sure these particular ones were in the land grant. These are literally every- day examples, but all of that uber-awareness just goes to show that sometimes Send class news to classnews@bow- doin.edu or mail to the address above. we aren’t worried about it the way we should be. Advertising inquiries? Please e-mail [email protected] or fax 207-725-3003. Please send address For Bowdoin students, the happy result of a great deal of work on the part of a changes to the mailing address above. faculty committee is that there are now lots of resources available to them to Send ideas or letters to the editor to check themselves when they aren’t sure, can’t find out, even if they don’t espe- that address or by e-mail to [email protected]. cially want to know. Suddenly, being right is a lot easier. But I still wouldn’t count on reality TV to be anything of the sort. Cover: Nick Pierpen ’95 photographed in London on January 24, 2003. Photograph by Stephen Hyde. AMB BOWDOIN WINTER 2003 1 mailbox Inspired by Tim and Jen film study, dance, acting, and entire I repeat my nomination of Brud Dear Editor: departments focused on gender, per- Stover as the athlete of the last 50 What a wonderful article you pub- haps it could rediscover a niche in the years. He was the star and captain of lished about Tim and Jennifer (“Tim’s curriculum for oral communication. football, basketball, and baseball for Gift,” Fall 2002). My gratitude and For a strictly utilitarian justification, the three years he could participate. To respect go to you, and Mel Allen, who tune in to nearly any televised watch him play was a joy. He partici- wrote such a moving and beautiful candidates’ “debate” and observe the pated with little teammate support as is piece. Thanks to you two, the end of dismal state of public discourse. May now with an administration that is Jennifer’s life is not the end Jennifer’s Bowdoin’s new generation of debaters anti-athletics. Bowdoin still participates life. Her story—and Tim’s—will inspire flourish. in football ECAC so that Williams, me, and many others, for a long time. Amherst, Trinity, and Wesleyan will I have long believed that we cannot be Clark T. Irwin ’70 have a team to beat during the eight- responsible for outcomes, only actions week season. and intentions. Unhappy with Hall of Everett Strong ’58 There are many ways to give life; Famers this article is one of them. To the Editor: Scott Meiklejohn, Associate Vice President The article on the supposed “Hall of for Development and Alumni Relations, Sincerely, Fame for Bowdoin Athletes” left me responds: Bowdoin’s Athletic Hall of Honor Ellen Cooper Klyce confused. I had to put on the back honors men and—and in this 30th year of burner that Bowdoin has been and still co-education—women “who have brought Bravo Rhetoric is a hot bed of political correctness. distinction, honor, and excellence to To the Editor: I’m curious as to the make-up of the Bowdoin through their accomplishments in Bravo for Alison Rau ’04 and her com- selection committee. I’ll bet half or athletics.” Coaches and others who accom- rades who have revived debating at more were women who wouldn’t know plish that (not necessarily on the field) will Bowdoin (“What’s Old is New Again,” a post route, a squeeze play, or a slam- almost certainly be part of future cere- Winter 2002). I had the good fortune dunk. I’ll also bet that most were from monies, as they were this year with Sid to be coached in debate and extempo- the liberal faculty, liberal administra- and Nels. The Selection Committee is raneous speaking for three years by tion, or brainwashed students. composed of graduates who are highly Prof. Albert R. Thayer ’22, and to com- The initial selections—Nels Cory interested in Bowdoin athletics and well- pete beside first-rate teammates like and Sid Watson—were great coaches informed about our athletic traditions. A Bruce Cain, Jeff Emerson, Gordon and athletic directors. However, my number of them were also college All- Grimes, and George Isaacson. understanding was that this recogni- Americans or otherwise distinguished in It is remarkable that rhetoric and tion was to be for sports played while their sports while at Bowdoin. The student oratory—a keystone of the original at Bowdoin. Sid, for example, made his and alumni response to the Hall has been seven liberal arts—has disappeared mark in sports as a DB for the very positive.