Sossidou E. et. al./Scientific Papers: Animal Science and Biotechnologies, 2013, 46 (2)

Sheep and Goat Farming in : Implications and Challenges for the Sustainable Development of Less Favoured Areas

Evangelia Sossidou, Christina Ligda, Ioannis Mastranestasis, Demetrios Tsiokos, Foteini Samartzi

Hellenic Agricultural Organisation-DEMETER, Directorate General of Agricultural Research, Veterinary Research Institute, 57001, Thessaloniki, Greece

Abstract Sheep and goat farming is considered to be one of the most dynamic sectors of the rural economy in Greece, both in terms of employment and overall income. The aim of this paper is to review the levels of sustainability in the small ruminant production systems in two Less Favoured Areas of Greece (LFAs): (1) in the mountainous areas of Epirus, and (2) in the island of Lesvos. In this context, the characteristics of the production systems that have significant impact on the sustainable development of rural areas under study are underlined. The sustainability is examined by the ecological, social and economic points of view, supplemented with cultural and regional elements. The ultimate purpose is to conclude with the challenges for the future rural development in LFAs through the sustainable development of sheep and goat farming. Data is based on surveys undertaken by the SEE-ERA.NET PLUS ‘INDI_SHEEP TRADI_CHEESE’ Project and the ARIMNET ‘DoMEsTIc’ Project, still in process. Keywords: Less Favoured Areas, rural development, sheep and goat farming, sustainability, SWOT analysis

1. Introduction extensive production system is predominant, with 78% of the Greek sheep flocks and 90% of the Sheep and goat farming is considered to be one of goats flocks are being reared in low-input the most dynamic sectors of the rural economy in production systems. [3]. For the year 2005, it was Greece, both in terms of employment and overall estimated that 110.000 farming units with more income. These systems contain elements that can than 10 animals each were operating, while the be proved of high value under the new conditions, average size of a unit was 84 sheep and 99 goats related with the need for the protection of the [3]. On the other hand, under the current environment and biodiversity and with consumer globalized economy, the term improvement in an demands on safe and quality products [1,2]. agricultural system is related to the term Majority (over 85%) of the sheep and goats flocks sustainable and a sustainable agricultural system is are being reared in mountainous and one in which agricultural activities are disadvantageous areas, called as Less Favoured economically, environmentally and socially Areas (LFAs) as defined in Dir.75/268/EEC., sustainable. Indicators of sustainable development having an important economic, social and of a Livestock Production System must therefore ecological role, and also contributing to the address issues in all three areas and the conservation of the environment [3]. The interactions between them [4]. The aim of this paper is to review the levels of sustainability in the small ruminant production systems in two Less  * Corresponding author: E.N. Sossidou, Favoured Areas of Greece (LFAs): (1) in the Tel +3023.1036.5383, Email: [email protected] mountainous areas of Epirus, and (2) in the island

446

Sossidou E. et. al./Scientific Papers: Animal Science and Biotechnologies, 2013, 46 (2)

of Lesvos. In this context, the characteristics of Moreover, a SWOT analysis (Strengths, the production systems that have significant Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) was applied impact on the sustainable development of rural as a valuable adjunct to experimental research for areas under study are underlined. The it helps to organize the information and analyze sustainability is examined by the ecological, social the representation of physical processes [4]. and economic points of view, supplemented with cultural and regional elements. The ultimate 3. Results and discussion purpose is to meet the challenges of the future rural development in LFAs through the 3.1. Lesvos island sustainable development of sheep and goat Results derived from the survey in Lesvos island farming. are presented below [5,6]: Lesvos breed, a fat tailed, mixed-wool type sheep 2. Materials and methods breed, has been produced on the Greek island of Lesvos, probably by crossbreeding local sheep Data is based on surveys undertaken by the SEE- with Chios-breed or fat tailed sheep from Asia ERA.NET PLUS ‘INDI-SHEEP TRADI- Minor. It is reared mainly on Lesvos and Limnos ’ Project (www.indisheep-tradicheese.gr) islands, but also in other regions of Greece, both and the ARIMNET ‘DoMEsTIc’ Project in the mainland and the Aegean islands, usually in (www.arim-domestic.net), still in progress. extensively bred flocks. It is well adapted to the The ‘INDI-SHEEP TRADI-CHEESE’ Project has local climate conditions and the poor mountains been research project under the SEE-ERA.NET pastures. PLUS Call for Joint European Research Projects Almost 80% of the sheep are kept in the (under the topic AgroFood, subtopic “Preservation northwestern part of the island in flocks of 100- of indigenous species and traditional food 150 animals. Most of the sheds are simply products”). The Project aimed to support the local structured, called ‘madria’, in a 5-10 km distance producers in Balkan countries making safe and from the nearest urban area. Sheep are grazing in certified traditional from indigenous- mountainous pastures or under the olive trees sheep-breeds milk. Four sheep breeds or breed while concentrated feeds are provided in most strains, indigenous in the Balkans and four flocks all over the year. The total purebred sheep traditional cheeses usually produced from the milk population amounts to about 300.000 animals. It is of these breeds have been studied, in Greece, a medium sized breed, having an average body Lesvos sheep breed and . weight of 50.0 kg (ewes) to 66.9 kg (rams) and an The DoMEsTIc Project -still in progress- funded average withers height of 60 (55-65) cm (ewes) to under EU FP7 ARIMNet, aims to enhance our 65 (60-70) cm (rams). Colouring varies greatly; knowledge on pastoral and rangeland sheep and Lesvos sheep are either black or red-brown or goats production systems. Case studies from white with small or big (black, brown or reddish) Greece, Cyprus, France and Morocco are analysed spots around the eyes, the ears and the nose and on through field surveys, focussing in livestock the legs. Most rams and some ewes are horned. farming systems, the genetic management of the Ewe-lambs can be first bred at the age of 9-10 breeds, and economical aspects. In Greece, the months. Prolificacy is 1.10 - 1.25 lambs/ewe. The field work is carried out in Epirus, an area with a lambs are usually weaned at 45-50 days. The significant sheep and goats farming sector that average tradable milk yield of controlled flocks faces various challenges towards a sustainable (16.698 ewes) is 175 kg (in 185 days), but there future. are flocks with an average milk yield of 200-280 In both cases, data was first collected from the kg / ewe / milking period. available literature. Then, surveys were conducted About 80% of the milk produced is used for in Lesvos island and in Epirus to study the cheese making (Ladotyri Mytilinis, PDO, characteristics of the productive systems. The Mytilinis PDO, Mytilinis, PDO). collection of data was made by personal During the project implementation, a field trial interviews and discussion groups with randomly was carried out under local conditions on the selected farmers, based on a structured island of Lesvos with both raw and pasteurized questionnaire. milk to investigate and compare the

447

Sossidou E. et. al./Scientific Papers: Animal Science and Biotechnologies, 2013, 46 (2)

microbiological and chemical parameters of one and is based on the exploitation of local cheese and to evaluate the role of which natural resources. It is characterised by small size farms with an excessive fragmentation, ageing of the active rural population, degradation of communal pastures and a high proportion of leased arable and pasture lands. The sheep population presents high variation in morphology and production characteristics and shows excellent adaptability to the local environment [8-11]. The animals belong to dual-purpose breeds (milk and meat). Milk production is the main source of income for sheep and goat farmers. The 75% of the milk production is directed to the principal dairy industry of the region DODONI (a cooperative Figure 1. Lesvos sheep on pasture until November 2012), while other small dairies receive smaller quantities. Milk is transformed to is used for covering the cheese. Three different feta (PDO), (PDO), galotyri cheese-makings were performed, in summer, (PDO), other cheeses and yoghurt. Very few winter and spring using traditional technology. farmers produce dairy products on farm for direct Quality of raw milk was very good to excellent. selling, however all farmers produce cheese, Pathogens (Salmonella spp., Listeria yogurt and other products for self consumption. monocytogenes, Escherichia coli iO157:H7 or Regarding meat production, two main channels Campylobacter spp) were not isolated in any of are described; the majority of the production is the examined milk or the cheese samples during directed to the market through the wholesaler, cheese making or ripening. “Ladotyri Mytilinis” while the remaining is sold directly to the made with raw milk was as safe as the one consumer, or is self consummated. The produced with pasteurized milk and olive oil acted percentages can vary between the farmers. The as a good preservative which prolongs the life of prices are unified in the region, formed by few the product. In conclusion, the findings of this actors. Although farmers have a high appreciation work dictate the need for healthy dairy sheep, for of their products, in most of the cases (only few good hygiene practice during milking, for strict exceptions) they do not have special agreements hygienic conditions in cheese production chain which differentiate the prices according to the and for respecting the long periods of ripening; quality, neither for meat or milk products. In when these conditions are met, a safe and high general the farmers are willing to be engaged in a quality unique traditional cheese is actually process that will allow them to sell their products produced [7]. It was confirmed that the major at a higher price. There are some initiatives threats for Lesvos-sheep breeding are: high cost of towards this direction, mainly for meat feed staff (high transportation costs of feed staff production. imported to the island), low level of The analysis of data demonstrated that the main modernization i.e. milking animals with hands, weaknesses of the sector, are considered the age of overgrazing of the pastures difficulties to access farmers and the lack of successors, the lack of the market (lack of infrastructures) and lack of commercialization strategies, certification and information and training strategy. On the other labeling and the lack of rational organization of hand, Lesvos breed has a high resistance against community pastures. In general, the farmers are parasitic and infectious diseases, while the unique willing to be engaged in a process that will allow flora in pastures and the traditional knowledge of them to sell their products at a higher price. The the farmers result in high quality dairy products. main strategy that all agree towards the sustainability of the sector, is the need to 3.2. Epirus implement policies to improve the infrastructures Preliminary results of the Project are as following in the mountain areas and to take support [1]: The production system is a semi-extensive measures for low input farming systems. As bio-

448

Sossidou E. et. al./Scientific Papers: Animal Science and Biotechnologies, 2013, 46 (2)

physical constraints, it was demonstrated that Symposium ‘Modern Trends in Livestock Production, these LFAs of Epirus include lands that have low October 2-4, 2013 agricultural potential because of limited and 2. Sossidou, E., Ramantanis, S.B., Mantis, F.N., uncertain rainfall, poor soils, steep slopes or other Tserveni, G.: “On Farm Welfare Risks influencing the biophysical constraints. Moreover, these areas Quality of the Traditional Mediterranean Animal Products”, In: Book of Proceedings, MeDiet, often have an absolute disadvantage in producing International Conference “Traditional Mediterranean many types of crops. Low agricultural Diets : Past, Present and Future”, pp. 131-135, 2004 productivity and land degradation are severe in 3. Belibasaki, S., Sossidou, E., Gavojdian, D., Local these areas. Cereal yields of less than one metric Breeds: Can they be a Competitive Solution for ton per hectare are common, and deforestation, Regional Development in the World of overgrazing, soil erosion, and soil nutrient “Globalization”? The Cases of Greek and Romanian depletion are widespread. Local Breeds, 2012, Animal Science and Biotechnologies, 45 (1), pp. 278-284 4. Sossidou, E., Stefanakis, A., Tsiartsiafli, A., Belibasaki S., Sustainable Sheep and Goat Farming in Less Favored Areas: The case of Crete island, In : Book of Abstracts, 12th Seminar of the FAO-CIHEAM Sub-Network on Sheep and Goat Nutrition “Nutritional and foraging ecology of sheep and goats”, Thessaloniki, Greece, October 11-13, pp. 107 5. Sossidou, E., Mastranestasis, I., Samartzi, F., Identifying risks for the sustainable production of Lesvos sheep breed: The case of Lesvos island, Book of Abstracts of Inrenational Workshop ‘Sustainable production of traditional cheeses from local sheep milk, in the Balkans’, December 14, 2012, pp. 31-32 6. Hatzigeorgiou, I., Vallerand, F., Tsimpoukas, K., Zervas, G., The socio-economics of sheep and goat Figure 2. Sheep pasture-based farming in Epiros farming in Greece, and the implications for future rural development, LSIRD BRAY Conference, December 4. Conclusions 1998 7. Samouris, G., Zdragas, A., Ioannidou, M., Giantzi, As a general conclusion derived from both surveys V., Vafeas, G., Microbiological and physicochemical is that the development of the farming system parameters of traditional cheese ‘Ladotyri Mytilinis’, would be based on the necessity of more rational Book of Abstracts of Inrenational Workshop exploitation of local natural resources - including ‘Sustainable production of traditional cheeses from off farm activities - in the framework of local sheep milk, in the Balkans’, December 14, 2012, sustainability on the one hand and of the guarantee pp. 23-24 8. Georgoudis, A., Ligda, CH. Al Tarayreh, J., Genetic of a reasonable standard of life to the area's rural characterization of local genetic resources and its use population on the other. for sustainable management. Editors: R. Ribeiro, A.E.M. Horta, C. Mosconi and A. Rosati. ΕΑΑΡ Acknowledgements publication Νο. 119, 2006, pp. 137-144 9. Hatziminaoglou, J., Epire et Epirotes: Un trajet dans The research was performed in the context of the l’espace et le temps, dans les societes montagnardes. projects ‘INDI-SHEEP TRADI-CHEESE’ funded by Editors : A. Georgoudis, A. Rosati and C. Mosconi. SEE-ERA.NET PLUS and ‘DoMEsTIc’ funded by ΕΑΑΡ publication Νο. 115, 2005, pp. 1-14 ARIMNET. 10. Ligda, CH., Al Tarrayrah, J., Georgoudis, A., Econogene Consortium, Genetic analysis of Greek References sheep breeds using microsatellite markers for setting conservation priorities, Small Ruminant Research, 1. Ligda, Ch, Sossidou, N., Tzouramani, I., Domestic 2009, 83, pp. 42-48 Project: Challenges and strategies for the sustainable 11. Tzouramani, I., Sintori, A., Liontakis, A., development of the pastoral and rangeland sheep and Karanikolas, P., Alexopoulos, G., An assessment of the goat production systems in Ipeiros (Epirus) region in economic performance of organic dairy sheep farming Greece, Proceedings of the 10th International in Greece, Livestock Science, 2011, 141, pp. 136-142

449