The Evangelization of the Ottoman Christians in Western Anatolia in the Nineteenth Century Merih Erol*
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“All We Hope is a Generous Revival”: The Evangelization of the Ottoman Christians in Western Anatolia in the Nineteenth Century Merih Erol* “Bütün Ümidimiz Cömert Bir Uyanış”: On Dokuzuncu Yüzyılda Batı Anadolu’da Os- manlı Hıristiyanlarının Evanjelizasyonu Öz Bu makalenin konusu 1870 ve 1880’li yıllarda American Board of Commis- sioners for Foreign Missions adlı misyonerlik örgütünün Batı Türkiye Misyonu adlı biriminin kapsamındaki Manisa ve İzmir istasyonlarında yürüttüğü faaliyetler ve bu bölgedeki Rum ve Ermenilere İncil’in mesajını öğretme çabalarıdır. Esas kaynaklar olarak Amerikalı Protestan misyoner Marcellus Bowen’ın 1874-1880 yılları arasın- da Manisa’dan Boston’daki ana merkeze ve Yunanistan kökenli Protestan misyoner George Constantine’in 1880-1889 yılları arasında İzmir’den Boston’a gönderdikleri mektuplar kullanılmıştır. Bu birinci şahıs anlatımlar olguları ve olayları anında ve doğrudan yorumladıkları için çok zengin bir malzeme sunarlar. Bu çalışma, Ameri- kalı misyonerlerin faaliyetlerini İzmir’in çokkültürlü ve çokuluslu toplumuna uyar- lama çabalarını, bölgede yaşayan Rumlara ve Ermenilere vaaz verirken ya da onlara ibadet için seslenirken hangi dilin kullanılması gerektiği konusundaki kanaatlerini ve gerekçelerini, Protestan misyonerlere muhalefet eden İzmir’deki Rum Ortodoks yüksek rütbeli ruhbanlarının başvurduğu yolları ve dini kitap satma, okul ve kilise açma/yapma eylemlerinin Osmanlı yetkililerince hangi şartlara bağlandığını ve yet- kililerin engelleriyle karşılaştıklarında misyonerlerin hangi aracılara başvurduklarını incelemektedir. Anahtar kelimeler: İzmir, Anadolu’da misyonerlik faaliyetleri, Ermeni ve Rum Pro- testanlar, mezhep/din değiştirme, on dokuzuncu yüzyıl. * Özyeğin University. Osmanlı Araştırmaları / The Journal of Ottoman Studies, LV (2020), 243-280 243 “ALL WE HOPE IS A GENEROUS REVIVAL” Introduction Smyrna/İzmir was the first mission station of the American Board of Com- missioners for Foreign Missions in Ottoman Turkey.1 Yet the British Protestants’ arrival in the city was earlier. In 1815, two missionaries of the Anglican Church Missionary Society came to İzmir with the intention of forming a Bible Society. William Jowett and James Connor founded a Bible Society in İzmir with the full approval of the Greek Bishop. Their goal was to further Christian education and missionary endeavor. The two American missionaries sent by the ABCFM Levi Parsons and Pliny Fisk settled in İzmir in 1820, and began learning modern Greek from Neophytos Vamvas, the president of the College of Chios, a Greek cleric and intellectual.2 In the ensuing years, the Greek War of Independence encouraged the American missionaries to undertake missionary work among Greeks hoping that independence from Muslim yoke would be accompanied by a moral and spiritual rejuvenation.3 In the 1830s, in collaboration with the British and Foreign Bible Society, the Greek cleric and educator Vamvas, who had become Professor of Philosophy at the Ionian Academy on the British- dominated island of Corfu, translated the Holy Scriptures into modern Greek.4 Furthermore, in independent Greece, the leading statesmen showed interest in the missionaries’ educational work because such institutions and infrastructure were lacking in the aftermath of the independence. Hence, the first generation 1 I would like to extend my sincere thanks to Ms. Evi Tramantza, Ms. Liza Vachtsevanou, and Ms. Stella Asderi for helping me to use their archival records and collections at Anatolia College. The research trip for this article was supported by Özyeğin University. 2 Chris Royer, “Anglicanism in Smyrna (1815-1923),” www.globalmissiology.org. January 2018, p. 3; (Accessed on December 16, 2018). Pliny Fisk and Alvan Bond, Memoir of the Rev. Pliny Fisk, A.M. Late Missionary to Palestine (Boston: Crocker and Brewster, 1828), p.116; Pavlina Nasioutzik, Αμερικανικά Οράματα στη Σμύρνη τον 19ο Αιώνα: Η συνάντηση της αγγλοσαξονικής σκέψης με την ελλη- νική (American visions in Smyrna in the 19th century: The encounter of the Anglosaxon and the Greek thought), Athens: Estia, 2002, p. 271. 3 Joseph L. Grabill wrote that the young Greeks sent to Amherst and Yale Colleges by the missionaries, influenced some Americans to view the Greek War of Independence as a war between the cross and the crescent. Joseph L. Grabill, Protestant Diplomacy and the Near East. Missionary Influence on American Policy, 1810-1927, (University of Minnesota Press, 1971), p.8. 4 Georgios D. Metallinos, Παράδοση και Αλλοτρίωση (Tradition and Estrangement) (Athens: Domos, 2001[1986]), p. 127. See Richard Clogg, “The Foundation of the Smyrna Bible Society (1818),” Mikrasiatika Chronika, 14 (1970), pp. 31-49. 244 MERIH EROL of missionaries dealt mainly with the translation and publishing of the Bible and religious books, and establishing schools. By the end of the 1830s, as observed by Gerasimos Augustinos, the Protestant missionaries in İzmir, besides financing the charity schools that they had opened in İzmir and neighboring towns, also were continuously producing publications in Greek, including the periodical Apothiki (Storehouse) or “Magazine of Useful Knowledge” which became very popular.5 The Greeks of İzmir were the most influential group in the city thanks both to their demographic and economic weight. Τhere was a rapid process of Graeci- zation in the nineteenth century in İzmir and along the Aegean shore, triggered by migration from the Kingdom of Greece, the Aegean archipelago, and the in- ner Anatolian provinces, as well as the high birth rate of the Greek Orthodox in the region.6 Missionaries were not simple tools of American foreign policy, yet one should not fail to see that they largely shared the American statesmen’s and diplomats’ ambitions of acquiring power and influence in the Ottoman Eastern Mediterranean. Uygur Kocabaşoğlu has pointed to the close collaboration be- tween commerce and missionary work observing that the missionaries shaped the lifestyles and habits of the locals and prepared them as good customers.7 Therefore, ocean surmise that the İzmirian Greeks’ wealth and their economically and socially advantageous position made them a particularly important target population in the view of the American missionaries. In İzmir, Daniel Temple, Henry John van Lennep, and Elias Riggs engaged missionary work among the Greeks until 1844, the year when the ABCFM took the decision to stop working among the Greeks. Henceforth, more emphasis was given to the Armenians of the city. John B. Adger, Elias Riggs, and Rev. Joel 5 Gerasimos Augustinos, ““Enlightened” Christians and the “Oriental” Churches: Protestant Missions to the Greeks in Asia Minor, 1820–1860”, Journal of Modern Greek Studies, vol. 4, no. 2, October (1986), p. 133. 6 Hervé Georgelin, “Armenian Inter-Community Relations in Late Ottoman Smyrna”, in Armenian Smyrna/ İzmir. The Aegean Communities, Richard G. Hovannisian (ed.), UCLA Armenian History and Culture Series, Historic Armenian Cities and Provinces, 11, (Cali- fornia: Mazda Publishers, 2012), p. 179; Vangelis C. Kechriotis, The Greeks of İzmir at the end of the Empire. A Non-Muslim Ottoman Community Between Autonomy and Patriotism, Ph.D. Thesis, (University of Leiden, 2005). 7 Uygur Kocabaşoğlu, Kendi Belgeleriyle Anadolu’daki Amerika: 19. Yüzyılda Osmanlı İmpara- torluğu’ndaki Amerikan Misyoner Okulları, (Istanbul: Arba, 1989), pp.18-20. 245 “ALL WE HOPE IS A GENEROUS REVIVAL” S. Everett engaged in missionary activities into the 1850s.8 By 1853, an Arme- nian evangelical church was formed in İzmir and the first Sabbath was held. The construction of a small chapel was completed in 1858. The American Protestant missionaries’ activities were not limited to the city of İzmir; with no less enthu- siasm they pursued their evangelizing endeavors in the nearby towns of Akhisar (Thyateira) and Manisa. In the 1870s, due to increasing pressure from the native churches in İzmir, the American Board transferred its base in western Anatolia to Manisa. It should be mentioned that the ABCFM organized its missionary activities in Anatolia in three major geographical mission regions: the Western Turkey Mission, the Central Turkey Mission, and the Eastern Turkey Mission. This study focuses on the missionary activities of the ABCFM in the 1870s and 1880s at Manisa and İzmir stations operating under the Western Turkey Mission. It is mainly based on the letters of the missionary Rev. Marcellus Bowen (1874- 1880) sent from Manisa to the headquarters of the ABCFM in Boston, and the letters of Rev. George Constantine (1880-1889) sent from İzmir to the same destination. The Western Turkey Mission had six other stations: Constantino- ple/ Istanbul, Bursa, Trabzon, Marsovan/ Merzifon, Caesarea/Kayseri, and Sivas. The Central Turkey Mission included the stations of Antep, Maraş, Adana, Urfa, and Hacin, and the Eastern Turkey Mission had stations in Erzurum, Bitlis, Van, Harput, and Mardin. Until 1880, Manisa served as the center for the American missionary work in a vast region which contained cities and towns of various sizes, such as İzmir, Ödemiş, Bayındır, Akhisar, Aydın, Alaşehir (Philadelphia), Kula, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Isparta, Burdur, and Konya. In 1880, the central office of the Western Turkey Mission was transferred back to İzmir. Before highlighting some elements of the broader political framework in the post-Reform Edict period, and exploring the activities in the mission stations of Manisa and İzmir in particular, I would like to provide some information on the course