The Selective Oxidation of Sulfides to Sulfoxides Or Sulfones with Hydrogen Peroxide Catalyzed by a Dendritic Phosphomolybdate H
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
catalysts Article The Selective Oxidation of Sulfides to Sulfoxides or Sulfones with Hydrogen Peroxide Catalyzed by a Dendritic Phosphomolybdate Hybrid Qiao-Lin Tong y, Zhan-Fang Fan y, Jian-Wen Yang, Qi Li, Yi-Xuan Chen, Mao-Sheng Cheng and Yang Liu * Key Laboratory of Structure-Based Drug Design & Discovery of Ministry of Education, School of Pharmaceutical Engineering, Shenyang Pharmaceutical University, Shenyang 110016, China; [email protected] (Q.-L.T.); [email protected] (Z.-F.F.); [email protected] (J.-W.Y.); [email protected] (Q.L.); [email protected] (Y.-X.C.); [email protected] (M.-S.C.) * Correspondence: [email protected] Qiao-Lin Tong and Zhan-Fang Fan contributed equally to this work. y Received: 6 September 2019; Accepted: 20 September 2019; Published: 22 September 2019 Abstract: The oxidation of sulfides to their corresponding sulfoxides or sulfones has been achieved using a low-cost poly(amidoamine) with a first-generation coupled phosphomolybdate hybrid as the catalyst and aqueous hydrogen peroxide as the oxidant. The reusability of the catalyst was revealed in extensive experiments. The practice of this method in the preparation of a smart drug Modafinil has proved its good applicability. Keywords: dendritic phosphomolybdate hybrid; sulfides; selective oxidation; hydrogen peroxide; reusability 1. Introduction Many biologically and chemically active molecules are constructed from sulfoxides and sulfones [1–5]. The oxidation of sulfides is a fundamental reaction as one of the most straightforward methods to afford sulfoxides and sulfones [6]. Many reagents, including peracids and halogen derivatives, are used in the common approaches of sulfoxidation reactions [7,8]. However, these common reactions often suffer from the formation of many environmentally unfriendly byproducts and low oxygen atom efficiency [6,9]. The development of environmentally benign catalysts and oxidants has become a research hotspot in recent green chemistry pursuits. Among various oxidants, aqueous hydrogen peroxide, which is inexpensive, is readily available, has a high effective oxygen content, is safe in operation and storage, and yields stoichiometric amounts of environmentally friendly water as a byproduct, is generally considered one of the most environmentally benign “green oxidants”. These characteristics of aqueous hydrogen peroxide have led to the development of many valuable methods for the oxidation of sulfides to sulfoxides and sulfones with various transition metal catalysts, including Ti(SO4)2/GOF [10], PDDA-SiV2W10 [11], the cobalt(III)–salen ion [12], TiO /AA/MoO [13], a copper–Schiff base complex [14], (C H N) [MoO(O ) (C O )] H O[6], 2 2 19 42 2 2 2 2 4 · 2 vanadium Schiff base complexes [15], and so on [16–19]. Polyoxometalates (POMs), which are composed of anionic transition metal–oxygen clusters [20–23], have been widely studied in the field of catalysis due to their excellent catalytic characteristics, including efficient catalytic activity and selectivity, controllable redox potential and acidity through the choice of the countercations and constituent elements [24,25]. Among these POMs, Keggin-type phosphomolybdic acid (H3Mo12O40, HPMo) has shown excellent catalytic performance in oxidation reactions with aqueous hydrogen peroxide [26–29]. Catalysts 2019, 9, 791; doi:10.3390/catal9100791 www.mdpi.com/journal/catalysts Catalysts 2019, 9, x FOR PEER REVIEW 2 of 10 Catalysts 2019, 9, 791 2 of 10 Dendritic poly(amidoamine) (PAMAM), which contains many amino groups, is an excellent organicDendritic modifier poly(amidoamine) for POMs [30–32]. (PAMAM), PAMAMs can which be functionalized contains many to amino couple groups, to various is an POMs, excellent and theorganic dendritic modifier structure, for POMs which [30 –is32 different]. PAMAMs from can the be common functionalized organic to modifier, couple to can various provide POMs, a local and microenvironmentthe dendritic structure, for the which POMs, is diwhichfferent may from result the commonin a help organicful “dendritic modifier, effect” can on provide the reaction a local [microenvironment33,34]. PAMAM-G for1 (poly(amidoamine) the POMs, which may with result the in first a helpful generation) “dendritic dendrimers effect” on have the reaction been used [33,34 in]. industrialPAMAM-G1 production (poly(amidoamine) and are relatively with the inexpensive. first generation) Moreover, dendrimers the amino have groups been used of the in PAMAM industrial- G1production dendrimer and can are be relatively protonated inexpensive. by HPMo, Moreover, and the PMo the amino anions groups and PAMAM of the PAMAM-G1-G1 can strongly dendrimer bond togethercan be protonated through electrostatic by HPMo, and interactions the PMo anions [35]. and PAMAM-G1 can strongly bond together through electrostaticHerein, interactionswe report a [35 heterogeneous,]. simple, recyclable, efficient, and green protocol for the oxidationHerein, of sulfides we report to sulfoxides a heterogeneous, and sulfones simple, with recyclable, 30 wt% H2 eOffi2 undercient, andmild greenconditions protocol in excellent for the yield, catalyzed by a composite based on PAMAM-G1 and HPMo (denoted as PAMAM-G1-PMo). To oxidation of sulfides to sulfoxides and sulfones with 30 wt% H2O2 under mild conditions in excellent theyield, best catalyzed of our knowledge, by a composite this basedis the first on PAMAM-G1 report of PAMAM and HPMo-G1-PMo (denoted as the as catalyst PAMAM-G1-PMo). used in the Tooxidation the best of of sulfides our knowledge, to sulfoxides this and is the sulfones. first report of PAMAM-G1-PMo as the catalyst used in the oxidation of sulfides to sulfoxides and sulfones. 2. Results and Discussion 2. Results and Discussion In this oxidation system, PAMAM-G1-PMo is utilized as the catalyst, and 30 wt% H2O2 is used as theIn oxidant. this oxidation We selected system, thioanisole PAMAM-G1-PMo (1a) as a ismodel utilized substrate as the catalyst,and found and that 30 less wt% than H2O 5%2 is of used 1a couldas the be oxidant. directly We oxidized selected by thioanisole 30 wt% H2O (1a)2 alone as a, even model when substrate the reaction and found time lasted that less to 6 than hours 5% (Table of 1a 1could, entry be 1) directly. However, oxidized when by 50 30 mg wt% of HPAMAM2O2 alone,-G1PMo even whenwas added the reaction to the timeabove lasted mixture, to 6 hsulfoxide (Table1, (entry1b) was 1). generated However, whensoon as 50 the mg oxidation of PAMAM-G1PMo product. In wasaddition, added control to the experiments above mixture, were sulfoxide performed (1b) wasto assess generated the individually soon as the catalytic oxidation activity product. of HPMo In addition, and PAMAM control-G1 experiments dendrimer. were Regrettably, performed only to 8%assess of starting the individually material could catalytic be activityoxidized of by HPMo 30 wt% and H PAMAM-G12O2 catalyzing dendrimer. by HPMo alone Regrettably, (Table only1, entry 8% 2),of startingand much material less yield could was be oxidizedobtained bywhen 30 wt% catalyzing H2O2 catalyzing by PAMAM by- HPMoG1 dendrimer alone (Table alone1, ( entryTable 2), 1, entryand much 3). When less yield the reaction was obtained was carried when catalyzing out in the by presence PAMAM-G1 of PAMAM dendrimer-G1- alonePMo, (Tableup to 185%, entry of 3).1a Whencould be the oxidized reaction within was carried 4 hours out (Table in the 1, presenceentry 4), indicating of PAMAM-G1-PMo, that PAMAM up-G1 to- 85%PMo ofpla 1ayed could a very be significantoxidized within role in 4 prompting h (Table1, entry the process 4), indicating of this thatoxidation PAMAM-G1-PMo effectively. played a very significant role in prompting the process of this oxidation effectively. Table 1. Control experiments with different components as catalyst a. Table 1. Control experiments with different components as catalyst a. b Entry Catalyst Time (h) Temperature (◦C) Yield (%) Entry Catalyst Time (h) Temperature (°C ) Yield b (%) 1 — 6.0 25 4 1 — 6.0 25 4 2 HPMo 8.0 25 8 32 PAMAM-G1HPMo 8.0 8.0 25 258 0.5 43 PAMAM-G1-PMoPAMAM-G1 8.0 4.0 25 250.5 85 4 PAMAM-G1-PMo 4.0 25 85 a a Reaction conditions: 1a (62 mg, 0.5 mmol), solvent (8 mL), catalyst (50 mg), 30 wt% H2O2 (63 mg, 0.55 mmol); bReactionIsolated yield.conditions: HPMo: 1a Keggin-type (62 mg, 0.5 phosphomolybdicmmol), solvent (8 acid. mL), PAMAM-G1:catalyst (50 mg), poly(amidoamine) 30 wt% H2O2 with(63 mg, the 0.55 first mmol);generation. b Isolated PAMAM-G1-PMo: yield. HPM compositeo: Keggin based-type on phosphomolybdic PAMAM-G1 and HPMo. acid. PAMAM-G1: poly(amidoamine) with the first generation. PAMAM-G1-PMo: composite based on PAMAM-G1 and HPMo. TToo optimize the conditions for the oxidation of sulfides sulfides to sulfoxides,sulfoxides, we firstfirst investigated the effectseffects of the solvent in thethe PAMAM-G1-PMo-catalyzedPAMAM-G1-PMo-catalyzed reactionreaction system.system. The The results results are listed in Table1 1.. After screening different di fferent solvents, solvents, we we observed observed that that when when MeOH MeOH or or95% 95% EtOH EtOH was was used used as theas the solvent solvent in the in the presence presence of PAMAM of PAMAM-G1-PMo,-G1-PMo, we we obtained obtained the the desired desired sulfoxide sulfoxide products products (1b (1b)) in relativelyin relatively high high yields yields of 85 of– 85–90%90% and and a minor a minor amount amount of starting of starting material material (1a) (1a)remained remained,, without without any sulfonesany sulfones (Table (Table 2, entries2, entries 1–2). 1–2). However, However, the conversion the conversion was wasrelatively relatively poor poor when when the reaction the reaction was was carried out in other solvents, including EtOH, CH COCH , CH COOC H and i-PrOH (Table2, carried out in other solvents, including EtOH, CH3COCH3 3, 3CH3COOC3 2H25, 5,and i-PrOH (Table 2, entries 3–6).3–6).