DOCSLIB.ORG

ESG Scores and Firm Performance

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
ESG Scores and Firm Performance The Impact of ESG Scores on Firm Performance: A Comparison of the European Market Before and After the 2008 Financial Crisis Master’s Thesis 15 credits Specialization: Financial Management Department of Business Studies Uppsala University Spring Semester of 2021 Date of Submission: 2021-06-02 Arran Pickwick Jacob Sewelén Supervisor: Shruti Kashyap Abstract This study explores the impact of ESG Scores on firm performance and seeks to establish whether the impact increased since the 2008 financial crisis. This is done by performing regressions on ESG Scores, and the respective pillars of Environmental, Social, and Governance, and firm performance, measured as both accounting-based performance, using ROA, and market-based performance, using Tobin’s Q. The study adopts a quantitative approach, utilising a random-effects model to analyse panel data across two sample periods - a pre-crisis period, from 2003-2006, and a post-crisis period, from 2010-2019. In addition, t-tests were performed to see if the impact changed significantly from the pre-crisis to post-crisis period. The study analyses data from 218 firms from the STOXX Europe 600 index, with four smaller sub-samples. The results indicate that ESG Scores have a positive impact on firm performance, with market-based firm performance being significantly correlated both before and after the crisis. Accounting-based performance, however, was only significantly correlated with ESG Scores before the crisis. In addition, the Environmental pillar was positively correlated with both measures of performance before and after the crisis, and the same was true for the Social pillar, except for with post-crisis accounting-based performance. Interestingly, the Governance pillar was not significantly correlated with performance in any of the regressions. Finally, while the average ESG Score among the observed companies increased in the post-crisis period, the impact of ESG performance on firm performance did not change significantly. The results of this study are supportive of the stakeholder theory perspective over the principal-agent theory, and show that ESG performance does indeed positively impact firm performance. Future research could explore whether other events have played a significant role in the rising importance of ESG, or if the results of the present study can be replicated across different time periods and geographical regions. Key words: ESG, CSR, firm performance, Europe, EU, 2008 financial crisis, principal-agent theory Acknowledgments We would like to take this opportunity to thank our seminar participants for their useful feedback each week. Most of all, we would also like to thank our supervisor, Shruti Kashyap, for providing us with truly invaluable support, insight, and guidance, from start to finish. Without this support, writing this thesis would not have been possible. Thank you. Arran Pickwick & Jacob Sewelén Table of Contents 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Research Gap ............................................................................................................................................... 3 1.2 Research Questions ...................................................................................................................................... 5 2. Theoretical Background and Previous Literature .......................................................................................... 6 2.1 Theoretical Background ............................................................................................................................... 6 2.1.1 ESG and CSR ........................................................................................................................................ 6 2.1.2 ESG Scores ........................................................................................................................................... 7 2.1.3 Differing Perspectives of ESG .............................................................................................................. 7 2.1.4 The Principal-Agent Theory Perspective of ESG ................................................................................. 8 2.2 Previous Literature ....................................................................................................................................... 9 2.2.1 The Increasing Importance of ESG ....................................................................................................... 9 2.2.2 The Impact of ESG on Firm Performance .......................................................................................... 10 2.3 Development of Hypotheses ...................................................................................................................... 11 2.3.1 The Impact of ESG on Accounting-Based Firm Performance ............................................................ 12 2.3.2 The Impact of ESG on Market-Based Firm Performance ................................................................... 12 2.3.3 Growth in the Impact of ESG on Firm Performance ........................................................................... 13 2.4 Summary of Theory and Literature ............................................................................................................ 15 3. Methodology ............................................................................................................................................... 16 3.1 Research Design ......................................................................................................................................... 16 3.2 Operationalisation ...................................................................................................................................... 16 3.3 Data Collection and Sample ....................................................................................................................... 18 3.4 Data Analysis ............................................................................................................................................. 20 3.4.1 Properties of the Estimators- Unbiasedness, Consistency, and Efficiency ......................................... 21 3.4.2 Generalised Least Squares .................................................................................................................. 21 3.4.3 Fixed Effects and Random Effects ...................................................................................................... 22 3.4.4 T-Tests ................................................................................................................................................ 23 3.4.5 Hypothesis Testing .............................................................................................................................. 23 3.5 Reliability and Validity .............................................................................................................................. 23 3.6 Summary of Methodology ......................................................................................................................... 24 4. Results ......................................................................................................................................................... 25 4.1 Descriptive Statistics .................................................................................................................................. 25 4.2 Pre-Crisis Accounting-Based Firm Performance Results .......................................................................... 25 4.3 Post-Crisis Accounting-Based Firm Performance Results ......................................................................... 28 4.4 Pre-Crisis Market-Based Firm Performance Results ................................................................................. 30 4.5 Post-Crisis Market-Based Firm Performance Results ................................................................................ 33 4.6 Test of Change in Coefficients for ESG Scores and ROA ......................................................................... 35 4.7 Test of Change in Coefficients for ESG Scores and Tobin’s Q ................................................................. 36 4.8 Test of Change in Mean ESG Scores ......................................................................................................... 36 4.9 Summary of the Results ............................................................................................................................. 37 5. Analysis....................................................................................................................................................... 38 5.1 ESG Scores and Accounting-Based Firm Performance ............................................................................. 38 5.2 ESG Scores and Market-Based Firm Performance .................................................................................... 40 5.3 Change in Impact of ESG Score on Firm Performance ............................................................................. 43 5.4 Limitations ................................................................................................................................................. 45 6. Conclusion .................................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sustainable Banking. Implications for an Ethical Dimension of Finance of Social Enterprise Performance
    STUDIA PRAWNO-EKONOMICZNE, t. CIV, 2017 PL ISSN 0081-6841; e-ISSN 2450-8179 s. 287–301 DOI: 10.26485/SPE/2017/104/16 Paweł MIKOŁAJCZAK* SUSTAINABLE BANKING. IMPLICATIONS FOR AN ETHICAL DIMENSION OF FINANCE OF SOCIAL ENTERPRISE PERFORMANCE (Summary) The article evaluates potential of sustainable banking as an important element of ethical finance system, supporting social enterprises financially. The article describes an alternative character of ethical banking against the risks resulting from the involvement of social external investors into investment ventures realized by social enterprises. Thus, it analyzes selected financial indexes of ethical banks against commercial banking institutions and it also assesses principles and criteria of finance by sustainable banking. Conclusions refer to non-credit forms of social enterprise finance. Keywords: sustainable banking; social entrepreneurship; credit; ethical finance JEL Classification: G01, G22, G23, L31 1. Introduction Modern commercial banks are strongly oriented to using a financial leverage to maximize profits, contributing to excessive financialization of economy and creating conditions for crisis1. Increase in importance and value of financial assets in comparison to tangible assets occurs. Also, importance of financial motives increases, most of all, of those referring to the profit and risk in a process of making economic decisions, and their influence on an effective performance of economic entities and social behaviors2. Financialization may contribute to conflicts between * Ph.D., The Department of Money and Banking at Poznań University of Economics; e-mail: [email protected] 1 M. Ratajczak, Ekonomia i edukacja ekonomiczna w dobie finansyzacji gospodarki, Ekonomista 2012/2, pp. 207–220. 2 K. Jajuga, W poszukiwaniu miar ryzyka finansowego, in: J.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Ethical Banking
    What is... ethical banking? Track “Ethical banking” refers to financial services Ethical investments that are designed to promote equity and sustainable development. So-called 'ethical Ethical banks, as well as regular banks and banks' believe that profitability should not investment companies, have developed all kinds of only be measured in financial terms, but also “ethical funds” [also called “socially responsible in social terms. In principle, the term “banking” investment” (SRI), social or green funds]. These refers to services like deposit taking and payment funds invest in financial assets just like a regular services. But in practice, the financial services mutual fund. But in contrast with a regular fund, offered by these ethical banks go beyond mere ethical funds look very closely at the entities issuing banking to include investment and insurance the securities. Different indicators are taken into services. Increasingly, traditional banks are account to judge a firm or organization's beginning to offer ethical products as well. sustainability, including: (1) How it operates in- house: the social and environmental aspects of its Ethical banking own operations such as labour and work conditions, Ethical banks offer customers the ability to open an recycling and energy consumption; (2) How its account and lodge their savings as a basic or time policies, services and products impact society; and deposit. With basic deposits, customers are able to (3) how the issuer actively helps promote withdraw their money at any time; with time sustainable development: e.g. by designing new deposits, they are restricted from withdrawing their products that favour better social or environmental funds before a certain date.
    [Show full text]
  • Study on Economic Actors' Societal Responsibility
    STUDY ON ECONOMIC ACTORS’ SOCIETAL RESPONSIBILITY Research Report on the Situation in Economic agent’s social responsibility in the Europe The role of companies and their stakeholders Vincent Commenne 10/05/05 CONTENTS Methodological preliminary i. CSR’s historic and definition A. CSR genesis B. Approach of an "a priori" definition and specificity of the European context C. creation of a context by activating agents who don’t belong to the companies’ world 2. Standards and Labels 3. Institutional context 4. Different perceptions of the CSR by European companies 5. Concrete involvement of European actors A. In EU-15 B In EU-10 C. Outside EU : the Russian example 6. Divergences between the agents and importance of the dialogue to build 7. Ten Case Studies 8. European needs in the SREA matter A. Summary of the data compiled as a result of the case studies B. Issues in the European CSR C. What is a good quality CSR process? D. Favourable Factors to CSR Development BIBLIOGRAPHY Methodological preliminary The term Societal Responsibility of Economic Actors (SREA) is used, in this context, to refer to the positions occupied by the various economic players. (NGOs, Trade unions, consumer organizations, shareholders, local communities, authorities) concerning Corporate social responsibility (CSR)." 1. CSR’s historic and definition 2. CSR genesis Economic processes observers are unanimous to notify that the production and commercialisation of products and services has an increasingly large impact, directly or indirectly, in issues such as: the natural environment, the public health, social conditions, child labour, etc. And this established fact follows the reality that these impacts have consequences not only in the South countries, but also in our “developed” countries and in a social, ecological context by affecting our present and future generations.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Impact of Value-Based Banking: Best Practises and a Continuity Framework
    sustainability Article Social Impact of Value-Based Banking: Best Practises and a Continuity Framework Adriana Kocornik-Mina 1,*, Ramon Bastida-Vialcanet 2 and Marcos Eguiguren Huerta 3 1 Metrics and Research, Global Alliance for Banking on Values, 1092AD Amsterdam, The Netherlands 2 Department of Finance, Accounting and Control, UPF–Barcelona School of Management, 08008 Barcelona, Spain; [email protected] 3 UPF–Barcelona School of Management, 08008 Barcelona, Spain; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: How do financial institutions enable social impact? We examined this question in the context of values-based financial institutions, which are amongst the most experienced institutions around the world in addressing the very real banking needs of enterprises and individuals within their communities. There is, indeed, an urgency today to have the banking industry consider its social impact in a holistic way. This paper expands our understanding of how these financial institutions, all members of the Global Alliance for Banking on Values, define, design, implement, monitor and scale-up social impact. We used a multiple-case studies design to investigate their approach and inductive analysis to derive a model. From a theoretical perspective, we found that a social impact virtuous circular model best reflects how values-based financial institutions approach and practise Citation: Kocornik-Mina, A.; social impact. Each step of the circular model clearly shows the way in which these institutions Bastida-Vialcanet, R.; Eguiguren address and achieve social impact. Our findings have important implications for academic research Huerta, M. Social Impact of focussed on understanding how finance can generate social impact.
    [Show full text]
  • Creating an Ethical Organizational Environment in Banking Svenja Nitsche Walden University
    Walden University ScholarWorks Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies Collection 2017 Creating an Ethical Organizational Environment in Banking Svenja Nitsche Walden University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/dissertations Part of the Business Administration, Management, and Operations Commons, Finance and Financial Management Commons, and the Management Sciences and Quantitative Methods Commons This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies Collection at ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Walden University College of Management and Technology This is to certify that the doctoral study by Svenja Nitsche has been found to be complete and satisfactory in all respects, and that any and all revisions required by the review committee have been made. Review Committee Dr. Karin Mae, Committee Chairperson, Doctor of Business Administration Faculty Dr. Richard Johnson, Committee Member, Doctor of Business Administration Faculty Dr. Roger Mayer, University Reviewer, Doctor of Business Administration Faculty Chief Academic Officer Eric Riedel, Ph.D. Walden University 2017 Abstract Creating an Ethical Organizational Environment in Banking by Svenja Nitsche MA, Leeds Metropolitan University, 2012 BCom(Hons), Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, 2010 Doctoral Study Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Business Administration Walden University April 2017 Abstract An ethical organizational environment ensures a trustworthy organization. This case study explored strategies that banking managers in the United Arab Emirates used to create an ethical organizational environment, one that emphasized the inclusion of ethical values, moral principles, and commitment to society.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Finance and Banking Research As a Driver for Sustainable Development: a Bibliometric Analysis
    sustainability Article Social Finance and Banking Research as a Driver for Sustainable Development: A Bibliometric Analysis Silvana Secinaro 1, Davide Calandra 1,* , Denisa Petricean 2 and Federico Chmet 1 1 Department of Management, University of Turin, 10134 Turin, Italy; [email protected] (S.S.); [email protected] (F.C.) 2 Department of Economics and Finance, Brunel University London, London UB8 3PH, UK; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: Social finance and banking with an embedded social purpose have been on the rise in recent decades. Social entrepreneurs have repeatedly stressed the critical need for financial support from social banks. This study aims to provide a bibliometric analysis of the status of the field in social finance and banking, recognising main topics from existing research and establishing future re-search challenges. Our study used science mapping workflow and multiple research questions to investigate the broad literature about social banking and finance. With in-depth bibliometric analysis, authors examined qualitative and quantitative variables as primary research infor-mation, relevant sources, subject areas, authors data, social, thematic and intellectual structure. The data was retrieved from Web of Science (WOS) and then analysed using Bibliometrix R-package. The analysis was based on a sample of 270 articles and demonstrates a multidisciplinary vision of the research flow investigated. Our results show several insights regarding journals, authors and geographical interest of this research stream. Specifically, the literature, although dwelling on social finance and banking, includes five theoretical and practical clusters as (1) people’s well-being, combined with technological innovation, (2) governance, (3) ethical investment and sustainable development, (4) corporate social responsibility (CSR), and (5) transparency.
    [Show full text]
  • Globalisation and Ethical Banking: Challenges and Prospects
    Journal of Association of Professional Bankers in Education (JAPBE) Nigeria Vol., I No 1, November 2017 http://apbe-cibn.org.ng ISSN 2645-3231 GLOBALISATION AND ETHICAL BANKING: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS Sheriffdeen A. Tella, Ph.D. Department of Economics OlabisiOnabanjo University Ago-Iwoye, Ogun State. E-mail address: [email protected] INTRODUCTION Globalisation remains topical even though it has appeared in the horizon since early 1960s, and, it will remain a global phenomenon for unforeseeable future, particularly with the unstoppable blossoming of information and telecommunication technology (ICT). While globalisation has shrunk the world into what Marshal McLuhan (1964) called a global village, the ICT has networked everywhere into a cobweb design. It is widely accepted that we all live in a globalising world where human dynamics, institutional changes, political relations and the global environment have become increasingly more intertwined (Martens, Dreher& Gaston, 2008).Increased global economic integration, global forms of governance, globally inter-linked social and environmental developments are evidences of this globalised world (Martens,et al, 2008). Without much gainsaying, the increased globalization of the world economies has made business practises converge towards some level of uniformity. The structure and organization of firms, manufacturing technologies, thesocial organization of production, customer relations,product development, and 149 GLOBALISATION AND ETHICAL BANKING: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS marketing – are all becoming increasingly similar (Vogel, 1992). However, it remains a question if the trend is similar with respect to the principles and practices of business ethics involving a set of moral rules that govern how businesses operate. Business ethics is crucial to the survival of businesses particularly for the banking sector which is at the core of this paper.
    [Show full text]
  • Ethical Consumer, Issue 186, Sept/Oct 2020
    £4·25 186 Sep/Oct 2020 www.ethicalconsumer.org CHOOSING A BANK WITH A MORAL COMPASS SHOPPING GUIDES TO Current Accounts Savings Accounts Ethical Investment Funds 2 Ethical Consumer Sept/Oct 2020 ETHICAL CONSUMER Editorial WHO’S WHO A year of climate action that suggested that moving your THIS ISSUE’S EDITOR Rob Harrison pension to sustainable funds can save PROOFING Ciara Maginness (Little Blue Pencil) WRITERS/RESEARCHERS Jane Turner, Tim Hunt, In January, before COVID 19 had moved around 2,200 tonnes of CO2 emissions, Rob Harrison, Anna Clayton, Josie Wexler, the goalposts for everyone, Ethical whereas taking one less international Ruth Strange, Mackenzie Denyer, Clare Carlile, Consumer staff decided at an annual flight a year will save around 19 tonnes.1 Francesca de la Torre, Alex Crumbie, Tom Bryson, strategy day that 2020 would, for us, be We’ve been scratching our heads on this Billy Saundry, Jasmine Owens REGULAR CONTRIBUTORS Simon Birch, Colin Birch the year of carbon. We would use what this one because we felt that although DESIGN Tom Lynton resources we could muster to focus on it might be illustrating the very point LAYOUT Adele Armistead (Moonloft), Jane Turner increasing our impact in this space. we wanted to make, there is a danger it COVER Tom Lynton Although for a while, the pandemic is overstating it somewhat! We hope to CARTOONS Marc Roberts, Mike Bryson, Andy Vine, gave pause to the idea that anyone had explore this in more detail later. Alex Crumbie control over their own destiny, it now As we discuss throughout this AD SALES Simon Birch SUBSCRIPTIONS Elizabeth Chater, feels like we are beginning to get back magazine, the decisions that banks Francesca Thomas, Nadine Oliver on track with some of the plans we once make determine the direction of travel PRESS ENQUIRIES Simon Birch, Tim Hunt had.
    [Show full text]
  • Banking on Ethics
    Banking on ethics Challenges and opportunities for the European ethical banking industry in the aftermath of the financial crisis Banking on ethics Summary Author: Valerio Carboni Editing: Andrea Baranes, Antonio Tricarico Executive Summary p. 2 Graphic design: Carlo Dojmi di Delupis Introduction p. 4 CRBM - Campagna per la Riforma della Banca 1. Industry overview p. 6 Mondiale Via Tommaso da Celano 15 1.1. Industry characteristics Roma (Italy) tel. +39.06.7826855 Fax. +39.06.7858100 2. The impact of the financial crisis on ethical banking p. 11 web: www.crbm.org email: [email protected] 2.1. The cost of the financial crisis 2.2. Ethical banks’ performance in a challenging environment This publication has been 2.3. Basel III Accord on capital requirements produced with the kind support 2.4. Which challenges from Basel III for the ethical banking industry? of the Ford Foundation and the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation. 3. Ethical banking with social goals p. 16 March, 2011 3.1. The French new economic regulation 3.2. The UK community banking experience 4. Ethical banking with environmental goals p. 26 4.1. The Dutch Green Fund scheme 4.2. Green Fund scheme overview 4.3. The case of Banca Etica in Italy 5. Conclusions p. 33 Bibliography p.36 Banking on ethics 1 Executive summary The 2008 global financial meltdown model of society where social and environmental variables are taken into account by investors’ and savers’ decisions. has clearly revealed to which extent The European ethical banking industry is a multifaceted financial institutions operating in a free, landscape characterized by a wide range of actors and unregulated and self interest mode can practices.
    [Show full text]
  • Case TRIODOS BANK ENGLISH + Teaching Note 3 8 2016
    TRIODOS BANK: Bank with values to improve the World and the people 1 “In bank with values, a sustainable bank means that money serves people and not that people serve money” Peter Blom, CEO, Triodos Bank 1. CONVENTIONAL BANKING VS ETHICAL BANKING Especially after the last financial crisis, the banking sector has been facing an important problem of credibility. In fact, based on the Grayling (2015) report, 76% of people do not trust banks. On the other hand, there are more and more people interested in topics of sustainability because of the increasing information about the problems the world is facing. As an example, we can mention that according to Foretica (2016) 6 consumers over 10 say that when choosing between two products with similar characteristics, they would always choose the most responsible even if more expensive. These are factors that explain the growing interest for ethical banking. Throughout the years the banking sector has been playing a fundamental role for society which is the intermediary role between borrowers and lenders. Banks played this role focusing on profitability and people took advantage of the easy access to money these institutions used to provide. This system seemed to work until the financial crisis of 2008-2009 when Governments had to intervene in order to save banks from bankruptcy. It is exactly at this point that two main streams of thoughts started developing. The first one focusing on how to develop regulations for financial institutions able to prevent what happened in 2008-2009. The second one, it is a more disruptive initiative.
    [Show full text]
  • Citizen Initiated Internet Politics
    Net Working/Networking: Citizen Initiated Internet Politics TAPIO HÄYHTIÖ & JARMO RINNE (EDS.) Net Working/Networking: Citizen Initiated Internet Politics ISBN 978-951-44-7632-7(pdf) Copyright ©2008 Tampere University Press and the writers Sales BookShop TAJU Street address: Kalevantie 5 P.O. Box 617 33014 University of Tampere tel. (03) 3551 6055 fax (03) 3551 7685 taju@uta.fi www.uta.fi /taju http://granum.uta.fi Typography & Layout Maaret Kihlakaski Cover Mikko Reinikka ISBN 978-951-44-7464-4 Tampereen Yliopistopaino Oy – Juvenes Print Tampere 2008 Contents About the contributors .............................................................................7 Tapio Häyhtiö & Jarmo Rinne Introduction: Seeking the citizenry on the Internet – Emerging virtual creativity ................................................................ 11 Part I Democratic e-innovations and citizen-oriented empowerment through the Internet Lorenzo Mosca A double-faced medium? The challenges and opportunities of the Internet for social movements .......................................................41 Kevin Gillan Diverging attitudes to technology and innovation in Anti-War movement organisations .............................74 Ariadne Vromen Political change and the internet in Australia: introducing GetUp ........103 Francesco Molinari (e-)Participation: a complement to good legislation? .............................127 Pauliina Lehtonen Civic expression on the Net: Different faces of public engagement ......163 Lauri Paltemaa These bytes can bite – Chinese
    [Show full text]
  • THE FINANCIAL Crisiss IMPACT on ETHICAL FINANCIAL
    THE FINANCIAL CRISIS ̓ IMPACT ON ETHICAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by Research Papers in Economics Barbu Teodora Cristina ASE Bucuresti, facultatea de Finante, Asigurari, Banci si Burse de Valori, [email protected], 0721336604 Boitan Iustina Alina ASE Bucuresti, facultatea de Finante, Asigurari, Banci si Burse de Valori, [email protected], 0744403356 Into the broad context of the ethical behavior topic in economy, outlined mainly during the last two decades, the appearance of ethical banking was an event with a particular social, economic and competitive incidence. Banking ethics had become an imperative and a reference point in the context of sustainable development, revaluating the report between economic and social return. Our study aims to examine the specific characteristics of ethical banks, compared with those of traditional ones, and provides a picture of the extent of this phenomenon in the European area. In addition, we analyze the extent to which the current international context, characterized by uncertainty and turbulence on financial markets, emphasizes the discrepancies existing between the two categories of credit institutions. Keywords: ethical bank; sustainability indices; ethical financial products; financial crisis; data envelopment analysis. Cod JEL: C14, G21. Introduction The idea that the current financial crisis is one of ethical proportions, which requires the focus towards a new fiduciary society, catches more clearly shape and brings in the center of concerns new concepts and approaches to finance and business. Thus, the idea of socially responsible investment or ethical investment is potentiated by the current financial climate, characterized by instability and turbulence on financial markets.
    [Show full text]