DOCSLIB.ORG

Glpe-PUNE-008488

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Glpe-PUNE-008488 Dhananjayarao Glldgil Libra~ 1111111 11111 11111 11111 IllD miD 1111 liD GlPE-PUNE-008488 THE ECONOMfC7 CO-NSEQUENCES OF SOCIALISM The Westminster Library A Series of Volome5 dea1inC with the History, Politics, and Economic Life of the British Empire. a-dla aatIa 1/6"""" TM loUollli", 110/.. _ Are pu6lis,," : THE EMPIRE: A FAMILY AFFAIR By PERCY HURD, •.•• THE LEGACY OF LIBERALISM By AI.. CARTHILr. STATE SOCIALISM IN PRACTICE By ARCHIBALD HURD TRADE UNIONS By W. A. APPLETON, C••• Il. THE FINANCE OF GOVERNMENT By MAJOR J. W. HILLS THE PROBLEM OF 'DEFENCE . By SIa GEORGE ASTON SOME HISTORICAL··PRINCIPLES OF THE CONSTITIJTION By KENNETH PICKTHORN THE GROWTH OF THE CONSTITIJ­ TION By Eo W; JrL BALFOUR·MELVILLE POLITICS RETOLD • • By P. G. CAMBRA Y THE COST OF LIVING By NORMAN DEARLE THE ORIGINS OF EMPIRE By IAN COLVIN THE SOCIALIST MOVEMENT Part I, 1824-1914: Part II, 19J4~ By Da. A. SHADWELL THE ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF SOCIALISM By GEORGE W. GOUGH LONDON: PHILIP ALLAN & CO., LTD. QUALITY COURT Firs' J'ffblishe4 j,. 1926 CONTENTS CHAP. PAGE I. OUR SCOPE AND OBJECT I II. SOCIALIST CHARGES AGAINST CAPITALISM 6 III. THE CAPITALIST SYSTEM 23 IV. SCHOOLS OF SOCIALISM 50 V. THE NEW SOCIAL ORDER 64 ·VI. INDUSTRY ON A RAZOR'S EDGE 86 VII. CAUTIONS AND PRECAUTIONS 103 VIII. THE CORE OF THE CASE II4 IX. SOCIALISM AND MARKETS 144 X. ENGLAND UNDER SOCIALISM. 159 BOOKS by GEORGE W. GOUGH ECONOMICS Wealth ana Work Talks with Workers NOVELS The Yeoman Adventurer The Terror by Night My Lady Vamp PREFACE SINCE • His Majesty's Opposition' is definitely a Socialist Party, in its leadership, its creed and its immediate proposals, a knowledge of Socialism is no longer a merely academic attainment but the necessary equipment of every good citizen. to the Westminster Library Dr. Shadwell has already contributed a masterly history of The Socialise Movement, to which my own book is in some sort a sequel and companion. I have tried to explain clearly what Socialism is, and what are the chief economic characteristics of the country to which its advocates wish to apply its principles. I then examine these principles, always with special reference to British conditions, and seek to establish the conclusion that grave and immediate damage would be done to the economic structure of this country i~ British Socialists were ever permitted to make a. beginning with their plans for constructing what they are pleased to call • A New Social Order.' Economics is not an exact science, but it is exact enough to enable its criteria to be applied to the problem of forecasting the effects of British Socialism on British trade and industry, and that is what I have tried to do. This is obviously a department of economic study vii viii PREFACE in which the writer. must clearly set forth the con­ clusions to which he has come on the.matters before him. In that sense only, this book is a c:"ontribution to a great controversy, and I have not avoided plainness of speech where I deemed it called for; but, while not concealing iny own view that Socialism is a deadly enemy of social progress, I have throughout stated the case for Socialism as emphatically as if I were myself a Socialist. The economic future of this country depends upon an ever-growing efficiency in manufacturing and marketing its products. Failure here means failure everywhere, hopeless and irremediable. Economic analysis shows that Socialism inevitably means failure here. Such is the position I seek to establish. G.W.G. August, I926. P.S.-It may be well to point out that this book was not only written but in type before the pUblication of Mr. H .. G. Wells' World o/William Clissold. My acCount of the fallacy-breeding word 'system' is therefore quite independent of, though so closely similar to, the brilliant pages which he devotes to the same topic. The Economic Consequences of Socialism CHAPTER I OUR SCOPE AND OBJECT No man can set himseU a higher or more honourable task than that of improving the organised frame­ work of institutions within which his fellow-men must of necessity do their work and live their daily lives. Whatever a man, or a society of like-minded men, honestly proposes with this end in view is well worth close examination in order to find out whether all or any of it, if it is in its nature capable of adop­ tion and were actually adopted, would serve its proposed purpose. A- , Socialist' is one who believes that he has definite plans and proposals which could be adopted and, if adopted, would do this most desirable thing: and the name given to these plans and proposals, and to the underlying theories and beliefs on which they are based, is 'Socialism: It need not give the student any trouble to learn that there are over two hundred definitions of Socialism. In strict truth, there are probably as many definitions of Socialism as there are Socialists. The Scotch fisher­ man who told Sir Robert Peel that he was ' a free 2 OUR SCOPE AND OBJECT trader in everything but herrings,' had innumerable ancestors, and has had countless successors, in aU spheres of political life, not excluding Socialism. But, however numerous the definitions of Socialism may be, there is one thing common to them all, and it is this one common thing, the final preci. pitate of all Socialisms, to which attention will be almost exclusively directed in this little book. Socialism, however defined, always comprises two main 'elements or J>ropositions. Both of them will be found in any of the authentic treatises which expound the faith for the instruction of the elect, and both of them will be heard in any open-air by· - election speech intended to get votes for a Socialist candidate. The first of these two fundamental propositions of Socialism is that social evils, the existence of which all admit because they are patent to the eye, art! due exclusively to the private ownership of capital and the conduct of business by private individuals in order to make profits for the private owners of this capital; . the second of them is that the one and only way to remove the admitted evils is to remove the alleged cause of them, and set up a new form of society in which there shall be no privately-owned capital and no making of business 'profits for its owners.. The differences between Socialists and schools of Socialists, which account for the two hundred definitions of Socialism and the unending wrangles and mutual antagonisms of Socialists, begin after these two main propositions have been accepted by THE CENTRAL CORE 3 all of them as their common basis of belief and ground of action. A Fabian lea1let on municipalised milk and a • Left Wing' volume on Direct Action have them in common. Mr. Zinoviev would heartily agree concerning them with Mr. Sidney Webb before proceeding to shoot him as a reactionary. This central core of Socialism, which it is our special purpose to examine, is economic in its nature and structure. This implies that we shall be occupied in examining Socialism from the special view-point of the economist. Socialism may be profitably examined from other angles. Oscar Wilde, for instance, wrote a study of • the soul of man under Socialism.' August Bebel, the German Socialist leader, wrote at length on the subject of • Woman under Socialism.' Mr. J. H. Thomas, again, has paid careful attention to the position of the monarch • when Labour rules,' and Mr. and Mrs. Webb have drawn up the • Constitution' of the coming • Socialist Commonwealth.' Indeed, it is difficult to think of any side of life which would not be profoundly modified by a change over to Socialism, and, consequently, the student of Socialism must • see life steadily and see it whole' if he is to come to sound conclusions concerning it. If he sees economic loss as a possible outcome of Socialism, he must consider whether it might not be more than compensated by- non-economic gains. The narrowness of our own special study is deliber­ ately adopted, and pointed attention is drawn to the fact, to prevent misconception on the reader's 4 OUR SCOPE AND OBJECT part. Narrow as it is, it is, however, decisive. Socialism is a scheme, a system, a plan, for remedying economic evils. To this all other purposes are sub­ ordinate. If it has other objects they are as a matter of fact not often or specially expounded. Socialists themselves put all the stress on the economics of Socialism. We shall do the same. Moreover, in a; very short book on Socialism written for English readers it is necessary to limit the field to be covered even more drastically than has been indicated. Unlike John Wesley and Lenin I do not regarcJ. the whole world as my parish. The whole art of mastering a subject of study is to -get hold from the very first of its central positions. It is greatly to be wished that we had full, accurate and authentic information of what has happened, and is now happening, in Russia under Sovietism; but if our information were as encyclop:edic as it is in fact scanty, there would be little or no use for it here. For I propose to study Socialism with special reference to economic conditions in our own ~~try. - In the space available one cannot do m~, and I shall not subordinate the urgent neces­ sity of being thorough to a vain attempt to be comprehensive.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • This Essay Explains Benjamin Disraeli Parliamentary Response to The
    Conservatism and British imperialism in India: finding the local roots of empire in Britain and India by Matthew Stubbings A thesis presented to the University of Waterloo in fulfillment of the thesis requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, 2015 © Matthew Stubbings 2015 Author’s Declaration I hereby declare that I am the sole author of this thesis. This is a true copy of the thesis, including any required final revisions, as accepted by my examiners. I understand that my thesis may be made electronically available to the public ii Abstract This thesis explores the importance of political conservatism in shaping the ideological and political foundations of British imperialism in India between 1857 and 1914. From the Indian Revolt to the rise of Indian nationalism, it examines how British and Indian conservatives attempted to define a conceptual and institutional framework of empire which politically opposed liberal imperialism to the First World War. It relies upon a biographical analysis to examine how intellectual configurations defined distinct political positions on Indian empire. This study reveals the extent that local conservative inclination and action, through political actors such as Lord Ellenborough, Benjamin Disraeli, Lord Mayo, Lord Lytton, the Kathiawar States, Roper Lethbridge, and M.M. Bhownaggree, shaped public and partisan discourse on empire. It argues that British and Indian conservatives evoked shared principles centered in locality, prescription, and imagination to challenge, mollify, and supplant the universal and centralizing ambitions of liberal imperialists and nationalists with the employment of pre-modern ideas and institutions. It is argued that this response to liberalism conditioned their shared contribution and collaboration towards an imperial framework predicated principally upon respecting and supporting local autonomy and traditional authority in a hierarchical and divided India.
    [Show full text]
  • Coversheet for Thesis in Sussex Research Online
    A University of Sussex PhD thesis Available online via Sussex Research Online: http://sro.sussex.ac.uk/ This thesis is protected by copyright which belongs to the author. This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the Author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the Author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Please visit Sussex Research Online for more information and further details EMPIRE and EUROPE: A REASSESSMENT of BRITISH FOREIGN POLICIES 1919-1925 Christopher Thomas Crook Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Sussex October 2017 ii I hereby declare that this thesis has not and will not be submitted in whole or in part to another University for the award of any other degree: Signature: [Christopher Thomas Crook] ORCID iD 0000-0002-8515-0491 iii Empire and Europe: A Reassessment of British Foreign Policies 1919-1925 Summary This thesis is a reassessment of British foreign policies from the Treaty of Versailles in 1919 until the Treaties of Locarno in 1925. It initially argues that much of the historiography of this period is unbalanced in its judgement of the different governments because it views them from a teleological perspective that fails to differentiate this period from the inter-war years as a whole. The problem with this approach is that the rise of Hitler and the causes of the Second World War became so dominant in such analyses that most issues within these years have only been judged within that wider context.
    [Show full text]
  • Hewins Mss. Scope
    University of Sheffield Library. Special Collections and Archives Ref: MS 74 Title: Hewins Mss. Scope: The papers and correspondence of W.A.S. Hewins, economist, historian and politician, and first director of the London School of Economics, c. 1866 to 1931. The collection includes the unlisted papers of his son, M.G. Hewins. Dates: 1848, 1866-1931 Level: Fonds Extent: 231 boxes Name of creator: William Albert Samuel Hewins; Maurice Gravenor Hewins Administrative / biographical history: The archive consists of the papers of William Albert Samuel Hewins (1865-1931), economist, historian and Conservative politician, together with those of his son Maurice Gravenor Hewins (though the latter remain unlisted). The documents include official government papers, notes, lecture notes and diaries, together with an extensive and important correspondence involving leading politicians and dignitaries of the day. (For details of Hewins’ collection of original nineteenth-century broadside ballads included in the Papers see separate entry under “Hewins Ballads”). W.A.S. Hewins was born in 1865, and educated at Wolverhampton G.S. and Pembroke College, Oxford. He undertook postgraduate research in History under Sir Charles Harding Firth, and on leaving Oxford took part in university extension work. In 1895 he was invited to organise the London School of Economics, of which he was Director until 1903. He was also Tooke Professor of Economic Science and Statistics at King’s College, London from 1897 to 1903 and held the chair of Modern Economic History at that University from 1902 to 1903. In 1903 he was invited by Joseph Chamberlain to become Secretary of the Tariff Reform Commission, intended to promote Chamberlain’s policy of safeguarding British industry and encouraging Imperial economic unity, a post which he held until 1917, serving as Chairman from 1920 to 1922.
    [Show full text]
  • 72 White Coalition in the Arch
    coalition in tHe ArcHives A perspective from tHe pApers of frAnces JosepHy The papers of the Liberal activist Frances Josephy, held at LSE Archives, have recently been catalogued.1 The collection has much of interest to those studying Liberal history in the inter-war years.2 It is particularly useful as Josephy was a woman of forthright views which she was not afraid of expressing. Although she did not make it to parliament, her central role on the National League of Young Liberals (NLYL) is another reason to study these papers. Indeed, one of the stories of the or this paper the archive Andrews University and Newnham has been used to ask two College, Cambridge. By the mid- inter-war period is the questions regarding 1920s, Miss Josephy was already an her views, mainly for active member of the NLYL, speak- ever-growing number the period from around ing at events across the country and of Liberal activists who F1925–35. First, does she have any moving resolutions at the League’s opinions on working with other annual meetings. Her speeches from did not become MPs. parties? Second, what views does 1925 were on various aspects of she express about the National industrial policy, but by the end of Nick White uses the Government, particularly in rela- the decade the range of topics wid- archives to tell the story tion to the Liberal Party? ens, from the need for free trade to Frances Louise Josephy was her defence of Liberalism. Josephy of Frances Josephy. born in 1900 and was educated at St also wrote articles, especially for 52 Journal of Liberal History 72 Autumn 2011 coalition in tHe ArcHives A perspective from tHe pApers of frAnces JosepHy the Young Liberals’ newspaper, the of the papers relate to her European she had spoken at a women’s meet- Forward View.
    [Show full text]
  • Farming, Fascism and Ecology
    FARMING, FASCISM AND ECOLOGY The life of Jorian Jenks (1899–1963) has great potential to upset settled assumptions. Why did a sensitive and intelligent man from a liberal family become a fascist? How did a Blackshirt go green? The son of an eminent academic, from his childhood onwards Jenks instead longed to farm. Lacking the means to do so, he worked as a farm bailiff and then, in New Zealand, as a government agricultural instructor. Finally, a legacy permitted him to come home and become a tenant farmer. Struggling to survive in the eco- nomic depression of the 1930s, he became an author and activist for rural recon- struction. Then, having lost faith in the established parties, he joined the British Union of Fascists. Becoming one of the Blackshirts’ leading figures, he was impris- oned without trial during the war. On his release, Jenks returned to the struggle, this time in the cause of ecology, becoming a pioneer of today’s organic movement and a founder of the Soil Association. This book draws on an extensive range of sources, a large proportion of which was previously unseen by historians. For the first time, it portrays the private and public life of this unusual man, revealing many hitherto un-glimpsed facets of Jenks’ life. Philip M. Coupland is a researcher and author. He has published a book on the British churches and European integration, and has written widely on aspects of British interwar fascism. Routledge Studies in Fascism and the Far Right Series editors: Nigel Copsey, Teesside University, and Graham Macklin, Teesside University This new book series focuses upon fascist, far right-wing and right-wing politics within a historical context.
    [Show full text]
  • Council London
    Leopold Louis Harris Forrest Thomas Byrne Frederick Herbert Charles Field Bridget Princess Margaret Mr Oxley Cheese Sir Stafford Cripps Lord Herbert Hervey Derek Gordon Abrahams Lord Weardale George Thompson Sir Anthony Lindsay- Hogg Gnome Captain Burlton Nora Glenn Cullompton Mrs Casserley Mr Paul P Joseph Myers Stephen Parnell Marie Goulding Thomas Francis Phelan Mr Justice Goddard Goddard Patients Sergeant Stanwix Ned Lawn Mowers — E Nugent Head Quaker Hull Nov John William Bell John William Bell Burton S Sponsible John William Bell Catherine West Bradninch Salvation Army Band Official Appointment Superintendent Jilbert's Horace Cyril Bate W Page Stone Co Johnstone Henry Tom Harris Tony Richard Henry Johnson Service Buses Favourable Geoffrey Macadam Miss Peggy Salaman Lawn Mower Ground Ways Miss Aylward Mrs Anderson Adam Edward Albert Cunningham James Gerrard Eve London Nov Certification Centre Modern Civilisation Daniel Gilbert Guarantee Glass Decanter Kingston E F Savings Jos President Lebrun Weymouth Entrance Book William James Bonnin Prevention Private Arthur Thomas Toon Fishers Agency Book Newton Cup Mr Gordon Store Angela Madame Shepherd Joseph Hay Turner Likely Gerald C Millard Friday Night Wadhurst Sale Yard Furnishings Tricks Mall Urns Candelabra Percy William Peachey Percy William Peachey Motor- Cycles — Daniel Gilbert Daniel Gilbert Fate Better Jameson Penguin Craigie 1 Donald Burton Westcliff Joan Spot M Wanted Spring Mattresses Webster Sunloch George-street Manufacturing Co Week Sailing Gaiety Theatre Cawsey Lord Chief
    [Show full text]
  • London Company Sarah Barber John Smith Commissioners Mr Amer Charity Ironmonger Nationalists
    Leary Mr John Campbell Cream V C Confectioner J R Lawson Miss Barbara Pyman Frank Ward Beatrice Marie Belmore Palmolive H Wells Bullet Mackenzie Hall Leonard Bilsiter Worshipful Company Miss H Quiet Id John Adams Phyllis H Brown Noreen Crowe Vincent Trevor Weyburn Mrs Palmer G Mayer Charming Graces Sir Henry Curtis Bennett British Analytical Control Ltd Sir Henry Curtis Bennett's Lordship Love Divine Duo- Formula Ridge * * Echo ” Office Mr Redding Cuticura Talcum Avril Abbleway Mr Arthur Richards C W Board Stanley C W S W Options Mr Felix Main Harry Gould Runners-up Rodine Stella Richard Endellion Mark Corven Echo Office Invitation Gene Tunney Sir Francis Drake Police-constable Meakin Pied Piper Hooker “ Echo ” Office Ideal Powder Card Excelling Hall Wine Esau Mary Trescobell Perkins Violet Ellen Cass Tweed Trouser Horace Hayden Townsend Advertisements Viola Blake's Cyril Bostle Silver Medals Miss Miller Francis William Gardner Promnitz Walter's Lordship Patients Mr B Russell's Sir Richard Lulworth Minister State John G Elizabeth Mason Mother Humber Memorial Fund Hull SamplesPhearJessie Park Matthews Busson Mailey Bride House Shop Mom Superintendent Osborne Icumen Vale H Bishop Crabs Lobsters Lyttelton Name Address Novorossisk Detective- Inspector Willis Hail Hard Wear Value Bert Chapman William Griffiths Mrs Kata Glithner Lighting Bill Inspector Gee Kingston July Nauru Insertions Russell W Place Morn Sterling Walter Inspector Thornton Nelson Summer Pay Rent — General Secretary Table Bowlers Prince Edward Mrs Mabel White Colon July %
    [Show full text]