Facebook Response to the Digital Markets Taskforce Call for Information on a New Pro-Competition Approach for Digital Markets in the UK
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
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`08%500%:9.<<:-:.95%A<08%.L,37#.%,%78:95%,;G.85%26:-6%3:>65%09#$%/.%8.#.G,95%50% ,%<8,-5:09%0<%,%7"/#:-,5:09H4%8.,;.84DE%@0;,$(%0G.8%)%3:##:09%YZ%/"4:9.44.4%6,G.%,%78.4.9-.%09% +,-./001%,9;%&a^%3:##:09%7.07#.%,80"9;%56.%208#;%,8.%-099.-5.;%50%,%YZ%/"4:9.44%09%+,-./001E% +,-./001H4%4.8G:-.4%.9,/#.%.95.878:4.4%0<%,##%4:b.4(%,9;%43,##%,9;%3.;:"3%.95.878:4.4%AX?O4D%:9% 7,85:-"#,8(%50%8"9%,<<08;,/#.%,9;%.<<:-:.95%3,81.5:9>%-,37,:>94%,-8044%56.%YZ%,9;%:95.89,5:09,##$% 50% <:9;% 9.2% -033.8-:,#% 077085"9:5:.4(% 4-,#.% 56.:8% /"4:9.44(% ,9;% :9-8.,4.% -8044Q/08;.8% 58,;.E% c"4:9.44.4% -,9% 8.,-6% 5,8>.5% ,";:.9-.4% 308.% .<<:-:.95#$% ,9;% -045Q.<<.-5:G.#$(% ,##02:9>% 56.3% 50% -6,##.9>.%,9;%"#5:3,5.#$%-037.5.%,#09>4:;.%3"-6%#,8>.8(%308.%.45,/#:46.;%/"4:9.44.4(%:9-#";:9>% :9% 308.% -09-.958,5.;% :9;"458:.4E% S% 8.-.95% 45";$(% 780;"-.;% /$% N07.96,>.9% O-0903:-4% ,9;% -033:44:09.;%/$%+,-./001(%,9,#$4:9>%X?O4%"4:9>%+,-./001%,774%,9;%5.-690#0>:.4%:9%'^%-0"958:.4% ,-8044%O"807.(%:9-#";:9>%56.%YZ(%905.;%56,5R% % ! "! A,D%\ad%<:9;%56.%,774%6.#7<"#%50%45,85%,%9.2%/"4:9.44e% A/D%^fd%8.7085%56,5%56.%,774%,8.%:37085,95%<08%>802:9>%56.:8%/"4:9.44e% A-D%^gd%<:9;%56.%,774%6.#7<"#%:9%#02.8:9>%56.:8%3,81.5:9>%-0454e%,9;%% A;D%^^d%-094:;.8%56.3%:9458"3.95,#%:9%.95.8:9>%9.2%>.0>8,76:-,#%3,81.54E$%% % @6.%45";$%<"856.8%905.4%56,5%5680">6%:54%4.8G:-.4(%+,-./001%6.#7.;%5604.%/"4:9.44.4%>.9.8,5.% 4,#.4%-088.4709;:9>%50%,9%.45:3,5.;%OYI%)*g%/:##:09%:9%.-0903:-%,-5:G:5$%:9%)*'f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f%-8:4:4%:4%.L:45.95:,#%<08%3,9$%X?O4E%S%9.2%8.7085%/$%56.%N.958.%<08%V0#:-$%X5";:.4%ANVXD% "9;.85,1.9%2:56%+,-./001H4%4"77085%6,4%46029%56,5%0G.8%h*d%0<%X?O4%4"8G.$.;%560">65%56,5% 2:560"5% ;:>:5,#% 7#,5<0834% :5% 20"#;% 6,G.% /..9% 6,8;.8% <08% 56.3% 50% 07.8,5.% ;"8:9>% NP_K=Q'fE%% K9;..;(%^)d%0<%YZ%X?O4%,>8..%56,5%56.:8%/"4:9.44%:4%45809>.8%50;,$%/.-,"4.%0<%+,-./001H4%4":5.% 0<%780;"-54%,9;%4.8G:-.4E%% % K9%?,$%)*)*(%,4%7,85%0<%,9%09>0:9>%-0##,/08,5:09%/.52..9%+,-./001(%56.%U08#;%c,91(%,9;%56.% P8>,9:4,5:09%<08%O-0903:-%N0Q07.8,5:09%,9;%=.G.#073.95%APON=D(&%+,-./001%4"8G.$.;%X?O4%:9% 308.%56,9%^*%-0"958:.4%,9;%8.>:094(%50%"9;.845,9;%56.:8%.L7.8:.9-.4%,9;%9..;%<08%4"77085E%@6.% 8.4.,8-6% ;.309458,5.;% 2:;.478.,;% .<<.-54% 0<% 56.% 7,9;.3:-% 09% X?O4(% 7,85:-"#,8#$% ,309>% -094"3.8Q<0-"4.;%4.-5084(%<.3,#.Q#.;%/"4:9.44.4(%,9;%3:-80Q/"4:9.44.4E%K9%'^%0<%56.%-0"958:.4% 4"8G.$.;(%308.%56,9%09.Q6,#<%0<%/"4:9.44.4%2.8.%3,1:9>%,5%#.,45%)^d%0<%56.:8%4,#.4%09#:9.E%@6:4%:4% :37085,95%:9%56.%-"88.95%-#:3,5.%,4%56.%4"8G.$%,#40%4602.;%56,5%\'d%0<%07.8,5:09,#%X?O4%09% +,-./001%.L7.-5%-,46%<#02%50%/.%,%-6,##.9>.%:9%56.%9.L5%<.2%309564E%+,-./001%20"#;%#:1.%50% -095:9".% -0958:/"5:9>% 50% /"4:9.44.4H% ,/:#:5$% 50% 568:G.% /$% "4:9>% 0"8% 4.8G:-.4E% S9$% 8.>"#,5:09% :9580;"-.;%460"#;%4..1%50%78.4.8G.%,9;%"9#0-1%<"856.8%.-0903:-%077085"9:5$E%% % ! $!O/#$)+%.$)!P2/)/=(2-!Q6464R<!S+$!T%2$B//>!O/=#%)K!?!P=#/;$&().!*+$!PA&/#$%)!UA-()$--! P2/-K-*$=5!%M%(C%BC$!%*9!+**#-9::;;;<2/#$)+%.$)$2/)/=(2-<2/=:#ABC(2%*(/)-:#ABC(2%*(/):$=#/;$&().? *+$?$A&/#$%)?BA-()$--?$2/-K-*$=! %!O$)*$&!D/&!0/C(2K!L*A'($-!QNACK!6464R5!0C%*D/&=-!D/&!V&/;*+9!W/;!)$;!'(.(*%C!*$2+)/C/.($-!2%)!B//-*! #&/'A2*(M(*K!()!U&(*%()X-!-=%CC!BA-()$--$-9!+**#-9::;;;<2#-</&.<A>:D(C$-:&$#/&*-:/&(.()%C:644H4E7EFG3E?