Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of ... Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum, and the relationship between Asian and tropical American species.

Alejandro Zuluaga and Kenneth Cameron Department of Botany University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI 53706

Thomas Croat P. A. Schulze Curator of Botany Missouri Botanical Garden P.O. Box 299, St. Louis, MO 63166

Melanie Medecilo Biological Sciences Department, De La Salle University-Dasmarinas Cavite, Phillipines

ABSTRACT the only disjunct aroid genus between the As part of a broader phylogenetic study of Old and New World Tropics. the subfamily we used three plastid and one nuclear markers to test the INTRODUCTION monophyly of the genus Spathiphyllum. Our results support the tribe Spathiphylleae as With the increased application of sister of the remaining Monsteroideae, and molecular data for phylogenetic analysis, the the monophyly of Spathiphyllum. The understanding of relationships within monotypic genus Holochlamys appears nested has been improved considerably within Spathiphyllum in a clade with the (Cabrera, 2008, Cusimano, 2011, Henríquez, Asian species and S. cannifolium. However, 2014). Additionally, new fossils and support for this clade is low. The section biogeographical studies have helped to Spathiphyllum shows a high support and is elucidate the historical and current sister to the remaining species in the genus. geographic distribution patterns in the As a consequence Spathiphyllum remains as family (Nauheimer, 2012a). As a result, aroid classification has changed

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 107 Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum... dramatically; several genera have been America (Boyce & Croat, 2013). Unlike resurrected; and new genera have been , molecular evidence for the created (Cabrera, 2008, Cusimano, 2011). separation of Neotropical Homalomena is not Nevertheless, many critical issues are still in conclusive (Barabé, 2002, Gauthier, 2008, need of more data. Wong et al., 2013). The most plausible options for the assignment of the Before this molecular era there were Neotropical Homalomena would be the thought to be three geographically disjunct resurrection of the genus Adelomena, or the genera between the old world and new combination of these species of world tropics. Species in the genera Homalomena with Philodendron subgenus Homalomena, Schismatoglottis and Spathiphyllum Pterosmischum in the genus Elopium (Wong et were found in both tropical America and al., 2013). Thus, more extensive sampling tropical Asia, particularly within the Malay and more molecular data are necessary to Archipelago and Melanesia (van Steenis, fully understand the relationships among 1962, Grayum, 1990, Mayo et al., 1997). Homalomena, and the subgenera of However, recent studies (Barabé, 2002, Philodendron. Gauthier, 2008, Wong et al., 2013) have shown evidence challenging the monophyly Finally, we have the genus Spathiphyllum, of disjunct Schismatoglottis and Homalomena which has a different distribution pattern. (they are no longer disjunct in their revised The genus is more diverse in Tropical circumscriptions), leaving Spathiphyllum as America with about 50 species (Cardona, the only remaining aroid genus with a 2004), and only three species in Southeast tropical disjunction. Asia. Spathiphyllum commutatum Schott is widespread in Malesia and reaches The genus Schismatoglottis, with only three Micronesia; S. solomonense Nicolson is species in , and about 150 in restricted to the Solomon Islands; and S. tropical Asia, belongs to the tribe schlechteri (Engl. & K.Krause) Nicolson is Schismatoglottidae that in its current restricted to New Guinea. Neotropical circumscription comprises 11 genera. species are concentrated in the northern Several of these genera are small groups Andes, with only a few species reaching recognized thanks to molecular data (Wong Central America and Mexico (Cardona, et al., 2010a, 2010b, Low, 2014). The three 2004), and one species, S. leave reaches Neotropical species previously recognized Cocos Island in the Pacific Ocean west of in Schismattoglotis are now in the resurrected Costa Rica. No comprehensive phylogenetic genus Philonotion (Wong, 2010c) that belong studies, until now, have included more than to its own tribe Philonotieae. Equally, the three Spathiphyllum from Tropical America, genus Homalomena is considerable more or any of the Asian species. diverse in Tropical Asia with about 500 species, versus only 10 species in Tropical

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 108 Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum...

Spathiphyllum together with Holochlamys As part of a broader systematic study of becarii form the tribe Spathiphylleae in the the subfamily Monsteroideae (Zuluaga, subfamily Monsteroideae (Cabrera, 2008, unpublished data) we tested the monophyly Cusimano, 2011). The relationships of the of Spathiphyllum and Holochlamys, and tribe Spathiphylleae within Monsteroideae investigated the relationships of the Asian have been controversial, but recent studies and American species of Spathiphyllum. strongly support Spathiphylleae as sister to the remaining Monsteroideae (Chartier, 2014, Henriquez, 2014). These two genera METHODS are very similar morphologically and Taxon Sampling and DNA sequencing. ecologically, differing mainly in a few During the sampling for the study of characteristics of the . Whereas systematics of the subfamily Monsteroideae Spathiphyllum species have two to three we sequenced a total of seven accessions of locules and ovules with axillar placentation, the genus Spathiphyllum from Tropical Holochamys has one locule and ovules with America, S. commutatum and S. solomonense basal placentation (Bunting, 1960, Mayoet from Tropical Asia, and one accession of al.,1997). Nevertheless, anatomical studies Holochlamys becarii. Additional sequences for suggest that the Holochlamys ovary could S. phryniifolium were obtained from actually have two locules, and the GENBANK. For this study we used placentation may not be basal (Eyde, 1967, representatives from all ten additional Carvell,1989). Monsteroideae genera, plus six other aroids as outgroups. Currently, Spathiphyllum is divided into four sections based the fusion of the perianth DNA was extracted from silica-dried segments, the form and length of the pistils material using the DNeasy Plant Mini Kit relative to the perianth, and the attachment (Qiagen, Valencia, CA, USA) according to the spathe to the peduncle (Bunting, 1960). the manufacturer's specifications. Some Asian species together with S. cannifolium samples were extracted using a CTAB and S. leave form the section Massowia, method adapted from Doyle & Doyle which is recognized by having the perianth (1987). We sequenced four plastid markers, segments completely connate forming a cup matK, rbcL, trnC-petN spacer, and partial ycf1. around the pistil. This trait led Bunting PCR products were purified using ExoSap- (1960) to propose the monophyly of this It (Cleveland, OH). Sequencing reactions group. However, Williams & Dressler (1967) used the BigDye Terminator Cycle and Grayum (1984, 1990) suggested this Sequencing Kit, and cleaned using could be an artificial group with Holochlamys Agencourt CleanSeq (Beverly, MA) nested within it. Sections Amomophyllum, magnetic beads. BigDye Terminator Cycle Dysspathiphyllum, and Spathiphyllum have free Sequencing Ready Reaction Kit (Applied perianth segments. Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). Samples

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 109 Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum... were sequenced using PE-Biosystems of the subfamily Monsteroideae version3.7 of Sequencing Analysis at the (Unpublished data). University Wisconsin–Madison Biotechnology Center. Trees derived from individual gene analyses are congruent, however the Molecular analysis. All sequences were resolution is low except for a clade manually edited in Geneious6.0 (Biomatters, comprising the species of the section http://www.geneious.com). Sequences were Spathiphyllum. Thus, a combined gene aligned in Geneious6.0 using a combination analysis is presented (Figure 1). All of Muscle (Edgar 2004) and MAFFT individual and combined analyses show the (Katoh 2002). Finally, all alignments were tribe Spathiphylleae as monophyletic and checked manually. We performed individual sister to the remaining Monsteroideae, thus and combined phylogenetic analyses. supporting the topology presented by Analyses for each marker/dataset were Chartier (2014) and Henríquez (2014). performed under Maximum Likelihood Section Spathiphyllum represented by S. using RaxML 7.0 (Statamakis, 2006), and cochlearispathum, S. phryniifolium, and S. wallisii MrBayes 3.1.2 on XSEDE, as implemented shows strong support, and is sister to the in the CIPRES portal. For RaxML, we used remaining Spathiphylleae. The genus the GTRGAMMA model in all cases. For Holochlamys appears nested within Bayesian analysis models were calculated Spathiphyllum in a clade with the Asian using Jmodeltest2 (Darriba, 2012). species and one accession of S. cannifolium (section Massowia). Section Amomophyllum (S. RESULTS. minor, S. floribundum, S. patulinervum) and one accession of S. cannifolium are sister to the So far at least one of the four molecular clade containing Holochlamys. However markers has been successfully sequenced for support for the last two clades is low S. cannifolium (two accessions), S (Figure1). cochlearispathum, S. commutatum, S. floribundum, S. minor, S. patulinervum, S. solomonense, S. DISCUSSION. wallisii, and Holochlamys becarii. Only the trnC- petN spacer was sequenced for the Asian A monophyletic tribe Spathiphylleae has Spathiphyllum. The combined alignment been supported since the first molecular length is 4970 bp with 36% missing data. studies in Araceae, based on only a few Despite using four molecular markers the genes, were published (Tam, 2004, Cabrera, identical sites between pairs of species 2008). However, the position of within Spathiphyllum is more than 97%. This Spathiphyllleae as sister to rest of low variation is common within the genera Monsteroideae is only recovered in the most recent studies with more data included

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 110 Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum...

Figure 1. Maximum likelihood tree from RaxML using four plastid markers (matK, rbcL, trnC-petNspacer, and partial ycf1). Bootstrap supports >75 and Bayesian posterior probabilities >0.85 are shown on the branches.

(Chartier, 2014, Henriquez, 2014). Our striate/polyplicate); spathe soon deciduous results strongly support this topology with a distinct basal abscission (vs. Spathe (Figure 1). Most of the synapomorphies marcescent), large trichosclereids not in defining Monsteroideae as presented in bundles (vs. smaller trichosclereids in Cusimano (2011) seem to be more bundles). The only synapomorphy appropriate to be assigned to the clade remaining for Monsteroideae is the presence containing all Monsteroideae but of trichosclereids. Spathiphylleae. These synapomorphies and the alternative characters in Spathiphylleae Within the tribe Spathiphylleae, the are: pollen zonate (ring-like) (vs. pollen support for the position of H. becarii is not multiaperturate with exine surface conclusive, but some markers suggest this

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 111 Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum... species may belong to the genus Spathiphyllum as proposed by Bunting (1960). Spathiphyllum. Holochlamys appears The only section with strong support consistently embedded in a clade with through all our analysis is the section section Massowia. These two genera are very Spathiphyllum, which is also supported by the similar in habit and morphology morphology of their flowers with a long (Bunting,1960), stem vasculature (French & and conical pistil exceeding the perianth Tomlison, 1981), palynological features (Bunting, 1960). Williams and Dressler (Grayum,1992), and floral anatomy (Carvell, (1967), and Grayum (1984, 1990), discussed 1989). Moreover, Holochlamys shares with hypotheses for the origin and biogeography section Massowia the presence of fused of Spathiphyllum and Holochlamys. We are perianth parts forming a cup around the undertaking additional molecular and pistil (Bunting, 1960, Carvell, 1989). The biogeographical analyses of the subfamily proposed differences between these two Monsteroideae, and more detailed genera - a unilocular ovary, and ovules with discussion on this topic will be presented in basal placentation - have been challenged by subsequent papers. more detailed anatomical studies (Eyde, 1967). Carvell (1989) undertook a very detailed anatomical study of Monsteroideae REFERENCES and Pothoideae, and reported unilocular ovaries, and basal ovules for H. becarii. Barabé, D., A.Bruneau, F. F.orest & However, he also reported the presence of C.Lacroix, 2002. The correlation an incomplete septum in several flowers, between development of atypical and the attachment of some the ovules to bisexual flowers and phylogeny in the that septum. Additionally, Carvell (1989) (Araceae). Plant. Syst. Evol. found considerable intra- and interspecific 232: 1–19. variation in locule, ovules, tepals, and stamen numbers in Spathiphyllum. Despite Boyce, P.C. & T.B.Croat. 2013. The Überlist the fact that we consider there to be no of Araceae, totals for published and strong morphological evidence to separate estimated number of species in aroid Holochlamys from Spathiphyllum (especially genera. Available at from the section Massowia), our analysis http://www.aroid.org/genera/13030 currently lacks adequate resolution within 7uberlist.pdf (accessed November this clade, and so we prefer to be cautious at 2014). this point in time, necessarily gathering more data before proposing any taxonomic changes for these species. Bunting, G. S. 1960. A revision of the genus Spathiphyllum (Araceae). Mem. New Our sampling did not allow a complete York Bot. Gard. 10: 1–54. assessment of the sectional classification in

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 112 Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum...

Cabrera, L. I., G. A. Salazar, M. W. Chase, S. French, J.C. & P.B. Tomlinson. 1981. J. Mayo, J. Bogner, & P. Davila. 2008. Vascular patterns in stems of Phylogenetic relationships of aroids Araceae: subfamily Pothoideae. and duckweeds (Araceae) inferred Amer. J. Bot. 68(5): 713–729. from coding and noncoding plastid DNA. Am. J. Botany 95(9): 1153– Gauthier, M. P.L., D.Barabe & A. Bruneau. 1165. 2008. Molecular phylogeny of the genus Philodendron (Araceae): Cardona F. 2004 Synopsis of the genus delimitation and infrageneric Spathiphyllum (Araceae) in Colombia. classification. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 156(1): Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 91(3): 448– 13–27. 456 Grayum, M.H. 1990. Evolution and Carvell, W.N. 1989. Floral anatomy of the phylogeny of the Araceae. Ann. Pothoideae and Monsteroideae (Araceae). Missouri Bot. Gard. 77: 628–697. PhD Dissertation. Miami University. Miami, FL, USA. Grayum, M.H. 1992. Comparative external pollen ultrastructure of the Araceae Chartier, M., M.Gibernau & S.S.Renner. and putatively related taxa. Monogr. 2013. The evolution of pollinator- Syst. Bot. Mo. Bot. Gard. 43: 1–167. plant Interaction types in the Araceae. Evolution 68(5): 1533–1543 Gonçalves, E.G. 2012. Lorenzia (Araceae- Spathicarpeae): a new genus from Cusimano, N., J. Bogner, S.J. Mayo, P.C. northern supported by matK Boyce, S.Y. Wong, M. Hesse, W.L.A. sequence data. Syst. Bot. 37(1): 48–52. Hetterscheid, R. C. Keating, & J. C. French. 2011. Relationships within Low, S.L., S.Y. Wong & P.C. Boyce. 2014. the Araceae: Comparison of Schottarum (Schismatoglottideae: morphological patterns with Araceae) substantiated based on molecular phylogenies. Am. J. Botany combined nuclear and plastid DNA 98(4): 1–15. sequences. Plant. Syst. Evol. 300(4): 607–617. Eyde, R.H., D.H. Nicolson, & P. Sherwin. 1967. A survey of floral anatomy in Mayo, S.J., J. Bogner & P.C. Boyce. 1997. Araceae. Amer. J. Bot. 54: 478–497. The Genera of Araceae. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, UK.

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 113 Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum...

Nauheimer, L., D. Metzler & S.S. Renner. Stamatakis, A., P. Hoover & J. Rougemont. 2012a. Global history of the ancient 2008. A rapid bootstrap algorithm for monocot family Araceae inferred the RAxML Web servers. Syst. Biol. with models accounting for past 57(5): 758–71. continental positions and previous ranges based on fossils. New Swofford, D.L., 1991. PAUP: Phylogenetic Phytologist 195: 938–950. Analysis Using Parsimony, Version 3.1 Computer program distributed Nauheimer, L., P.C. Boyce & S.S. Renner. by the Illinois Natural History 2012b. Giant taro and its relatives: A Survey, Champaign, Illinois. phylogeny of the large genus Alocasia (Araceae) sheds light on Miocene Steenis, C.G.G.J. van. 1962. The land-bridge floristic exchange in the Malesian theory in botany with particular region. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 63(1): 43- reference to tropical . Blumea 51. 11: 235–372

Nauheimer, L., & P.C. Boyce 2014. Tam, S., P.C. Boyce, T. Upson, D. Barabé, A. Englerarum (Araceae, Aroideae): a new Bruneau, F. Forest & J.S. Parker. genus supported by plastid and 2004. Intergeneric and Infrafamilial nuclear phylogenies. Plant. Syst. Evol. Phylogeny of Subfamily 300(4): 709–715. Monsteroideae (Araceae) Revealed by Chloroplast trnL-F Sequences. Stamatakis, A., 2006a. RAxML-VI-HPC: Am. J. Botany 91(3): 490–498. maximum likelihood-based phylogenetic analyses with Wong, S.Y. & P.C. Boyce. 2010a. Studies on thousands of taxa and mixed models. Schismatoglottideae (Araceae) of Bioinformatics, 22(21): 2688–2690. Borneo IX: A new genus, Hestia, and resurrection of Apoballis. Bot. Stud. Stamatakis, A., 2006b. Phylogenetic models (Taipei), 51: 249–255 of rate heterogeneity: a high performance computing perspective. Wong, S. Y. P.C. & Boyce, P. C. 2010b. In: Proceedings of the 20th Studies on Schismatoglottideae IEEE/ACM International Parallel (Araceae) of Borneo XI: Ooia, a new and Distributed Processing genus, and a new generic delimitation Symposium (IPDPS2006), Rhodos, for Piptospatha. Bot. Stud. (Taipei) 51: Greece. 543–552.

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 114 Zuluaga, Cameron, Croat and Medecilo, 2015 Testing the monophyly of Spathiphyllum...

Wong, S.Y., P.C. Boyce, A.S.B. Othman & Wong, S.Y. T.P. Jean, N.K. Kiaw, A.S.B. L.C. Pin. 2010c. Molecular phylogeny Othman, L.H. Boon, F.B. Ahmad & of tribe Schismatoglottideae P.C. Boyce. 2013. Phylogeny of (Araceae) based on two plastid Asian Homalomena (Araceae) based on markers and recognition of a new the ITS Region Combined with tribe, Philonotieae, from the Morphological and Chemical Data. Neotropics. Taxon 59(1): 117–124. Syst. Bot. 38(3): 589–599.

Aroideana VOL 38E NO 1, 2015 115