Accessing Justice, Rationing Law
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
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eflections, Old St. Louis County Courthouse. Photographer: William Clift © Image reproduced courtesy of the photographer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`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a$0"+%&+<&0C1&"B1$,38&$3&:1,,&$3&0C1&5C$,,1%613&$%B& 01%3"+%3&A2+B.51B&;>&3.;30$%0"K1&1%0"0,1#1%03&0+&5+.203G&& & &&& & V86/W//I/B0!69!45061./X!!*;/!-686/!9=!-686/!"95B607!EFCE! & & /+30& 30$01& 5+%30"0.0"+%3& 6.$2$%011& b+A1%& 5+.203c& $%B& 2"6C03& 0+& 21#1B"13G& & =.20C128& "%& )V`?8& !"#$%&' ()' *+"&,-"./0& 130$;,"3C1B& $& 5+%30"0.0"+%$,& 2"6C0& 0+& 5+.%31,& <+2& "%B"61%0& B1<1%B$%03& <$5"%6& <1,+%>& 5C$2613G& & E#A,1#1%0$0"+%& +<& 0C131& 2"6C038& C+:1K128& 5+%0"%.13& 0+& +55.A>& 0C1& ,16$,& A2+<133"+%G& &&4& '((X& 21A+20& ;>& 0C1& 4#12"5$%& Q$2& 433+5"$0"+%& 21$5C1B& b0C1& B"30.2;"%6&5+%5,.3"+%&0C$0&0C+.3$%B3&+<&A123+%3&$21&A2+51331B&0C2+.6C&4#12"5$d3&5+.203&1K12>& >1$2&1"0C12&:"0C&%+&,$:>12&$0&$,,&+2&:"0C&$&,$:>12&:C+&B+13&%+0&C$K1&0C1&0"#18&213+.25138&+2&"%& 3+#1& 5$313& 0C1& "%5,"%$0"+%& 0+& A2+K"B1& 1<<150"K1& 21A2131%0$0"+%Gc& & F%& 0C1& 5"K",& 3"B18& *$,"<+2%"$& 5+.%01B& XG?& #",,"+%& 5"K",& ,"0"6$%03& :"0C+.0& ,$:>123& "%& "03& 5+.203& "%& '((Ve& R1:& L+2H& 0$,,"1B& 'G?& #",,"+%&"%&'()(8&$%B&0C$0&%.#;12&"%5,.B13&$,#+30&$,,&<$5"%6&1K"50"+%3&$%B&V[&A1251%0&+<&0C+31&"%& <$#",>&5+%<,"503G&& & & MC1&1f512A03&;1,+:8&<2+#&4,$;$#$8&*$,"<+2%"$8&*+%%150"5.08&E%B"$%$8&/$33$5C.310038&R1:& L+2H8& $%B& M1f$38& $3& :1,,& $3& B$0$& <2+#& 0C1"2& $%B& 0C1& <1B12$,& 5+.20& 3>301#38& 1fA,+21& 0C1& 5C$,,1%613&5+.203&<$51&"%&213A+%31&0+&B1#$%B&<+2&0C1"2&312K"513G& & g,"#A3"%6&0C1&Z+5H10& & J0$01&*+.20&=","%638&)V\`@'((UG& & *+#A$2"%6&0C1&_+,.#1&+<&=","%63h&J0$01&$%B&=1B12$,&*+.2038&'(()G& & *+%%150"5.0&=","%638&4&*+#A$2"3+%h&'((`@(\I&'((V@'()(G& J.1&Q1,,&*+;;8&J0$01&+<&0C1&7.B"5"$2>8&4,$;$#$&T7$%G&'`8&'()(WG& M$%"&*$%0",@J$H$.>18&="230&4%%.$,&4BB2133&0+&0C1&J0$01&Q$2&+<&*$,"<+2%"$&&TJ1A0G&)\8&'())WG& J$261%0&JC2"K12&*"K",&*+.%31,&4508&*4!G&gF_G&*FZP&S&`U`[)&T1<<G&7.,>&)8&'())WG& P,H"%3&KG&J.A12"+2&*+.20&+<&*+%02$&*+30$&*+G8&X)&*$,G&X0C&)??\&T'((\WG& *C$31&MG&9+61238&J0$01&+<&0C1&7.B"5"$2>8&*+%%150"5.0&T4A2G&)?8&'())WG& 9$%B$,,&MG&JC1A$2B8&MC1&J1,<@91A2131%01B&!"0"6$%0h&E#A,"5$0"+%3&<+2&0C1&Q1%5C&$%B&Q$2& iE%B"$%$j8&XU&=4/E!L&*FY9M&9P_EP]&`(\&T'()(WG& /$26$210&NG&/$23C$,,8&D.00"%6&"0&4,,&M+610C12h&F2&]C$0&*$%&]1&Z+&R+:k8&4BB2133&$0&0C1& O1%0.5H>&!$:&7+.2%$,&J>#A+3".#&TJ1A0G&'X8&'())WG& 7+%$0C$%&!"AA#$%8&!$:&"%&0C1&')30&*1%0.2>h&&P%B.2"%6&M2$B"0"+%38&P#126"%6&*C$,,1%6138&& 91#$2H3&+%&!$:&Z$>&T/$>&?8&'()(WG& MC1&M$3H&=+251&0+&PfA$%B&455133&0+&*"K",&!16$,&J12K"513&"%&R1:&L+2H8&& & & *C$"28&N1,$"%1&Q$2%1008&Pf15.0"K1&J.##$2>&TR+KG&'()'WG& ]$,,$51&QG&71<<123+%&l&R$0C$%&N15C08&!10012&0+&9+>51&]1308&M1f$3&J0$01&J1%$01&& & & T7.%1&)8&'())WG& ]$,,$51&QG&71<<123+%8&J0$01&+<&0C1&7.B"5"$2>8&M1f$3&T=1;G&'?8&'())WG& !"#$%&'()'&5+,,+-.".#&/$012"$,3&&<2+%0&A$613&&=1;2.$2>&U8&'()'& & "& & & & D2133&91,1$318&E%5+#"%6&4#12"5$%&Q$2&433+5"$0"+%&D213"B1%0&0+&4AA+"%0&M1B&F,3+%&$%B& Z$K"B&Q+"13&0+&M$3H&=+251&+%&7.30"51&J>301#8&4#12"5$%&Q$2&433+5"$0"+%8&4.6G&`& '()(G& 4Q4&913+.251&*1%0128&455133&0+&*"K",&7.30"51&<+2&!+:@E%5+#1&D1+A,1h&9151%0& Z1K1,+A#1%03&4.6.30&'())@7$%.$2>&'()'&T7$%G&'()'WG& 9"6C03&0+&91#1B"13h&4&*+#A1%B".#&+<&J0$01&*+%30"0.0"+%$,&*+##"0#1%03&T'()'WG& & & /16C$%&/5*+2#$5H&TL!J&'()?W&$%B&7$3+%&g,"5H&TL!J&'()'WG& & & "#$%&'!,/L1L/KX!!"B1?128>!Y/=/2K82607!<1282.18>!)506/B16M7!82K!#L/B.B1?128>1U86192!! & 43&30$01&5+.203&1fA12"1%51&31K121&5.038&,$>+<<38&$%B&<.2,+.6C38&0C1&52"#"%$,&m.30"51&3>301#& 5+%0"%.13&0+&A2+B.51&B1<1%B$%038&B10$"%1138&$%B&A2"3+%123G&/+21&0C$%&$&C$,<&51%0.2>&$6+8&0C1& B1;$01& :$3& :C10C12& 0C1& <1B12$,& 5+%30"0.0"+%& #$%B$01B& 0C$0& "%B"61%0& 52"#"%$,& <1,+%>& B1<1%B$%03& ;1& A2+K"B1B& 30$01@A$"B& ,$:>123G& & 4& )V`'& ;2"1<& T1f512A01B& ;1,+:W& <2+#& $& 30$01& +AA+3"%6&0C$0&2"6C0&A2+K"B13&$&:"%B+:&"%0+&;+0C&0C1&02$%3<+2#$0"+%3&0C$0&!"#$%&&A2+B.51B&$%B& 0C1& B16211& 0+& :C"5C& 5+%01#A+2$2>& $26.#1%03& A$2$,,1,& 5,$"#3& #$B1& B15$B13& $6+G& & MC1& YGJG& J.A21#1& *+.20d3& 5+##"0#1%0& 0+& !"#$%&& 5+%0"%.13& "%& 0C1& '((U& 1%0/.$-2' B15"3"+%8& :C",1& 0C1& B"331%03&2$"31&-.130"+%3&$;+.0&!"#$%&33&35+A1G& & E#A,1#1%0$0"+%& 21#$"%3& "%5+#A,1018& $3& +0C12& #$012"$,3& ;1,+:& B10$",G& J+#1& 30$01& 5+.203& C$K1&213A+%B1B&;>&521$0"%6C$%"3#3&<+2&A.;,"5&B1<1%B123&0+&B15,"%1&$33"6%#1%03&$%B&;>& 215+6%"a"%6& A21@5+%K"50"+%& C$;1$3& 21K"1:& +<& "%1<<150"K1& $33"30$%51& +<& 5+.%31,G&&4BB"0"+%$,& 213A+%313&"%5,.B1&0$3H&<+25138&B"K123"+%&A2+62$#38&$%B&31%01%5"%6&21<+2#3G&&& & MC131&#$012"$,3&A2+#A0&$&312"13&+<&-.130"+%3G&&]C$0&21#1B"13&5$%&5+.203&+2B128&$%B&:C$0& $21& 0C1& ,"#"03& +%& :C$0& m.B613& 5$%& B+k& & JC+.,B& ,$:>123& B15,"%1& $AA+"%0#1%03& :C1%& 0C1"2& 5$31,+$B3&;15+#1&0++&,$261k&&]C$0&2+,1&#"6C0&A2+315.0+23&A,$>&"%&31,150"%6&5$313k&&]C$0&5$%& 0C1& 1f15.0"K1& ;2$%5C& B+k& & ]C$0& <+2#3& +<& 2$0"+%"%68& ;>& :C"5C& "%30"0.0"+%38& $21& $551A0$;,1k& JC+.,B&0C1&%$22$0"K1&;1&+%1&+<&A2+62133"K1&21$,"a$0"+%&+<&5+%30"0.0"+%$,&"B1$,3&+2&+<&$&<$",.21&+<& A+,"0"5$,&:",,&0+&3.AA+20&5+.203&$%B&,"0"6$%03k& & Q2"1<&4#"5.3&*.2"$18&<+2&0C1&J0$01&+<&4,$;$#$&"%&3.AA+20&+<&=,+2"B$8&g"B1+%&KG& ]$"%:2"6C08&R+G&)[[8&?\'&YGJG&??[&T)V`?WG& 4%0C+%>&!1:"38&4#12"5$%&!$:>123h&&g"B1+%d3&42#>k&[(&*F9RP!!&!4]&nY49MP9!L&)[[& T)V`[WG& 9+0C612>&KG&g",,13A"1&*+.%0>8&[[X&YGJG&)V)&T'((UWG& 7YJME*P&ZPREPZh&&4/P9E*4dJ&*FRMERYERg&RPg!P*M&F=&FY9&*FRJMEMYMEFR4!&9EgNM&MF&*FYRJP!h& 9PDF9M&F=&MNP&R4MEFR4!&9EgNM&MF&*FYRJP!&*F//EMMPP&TMC1&*+%30"0.0"+%&D2+m1508&4A2",& '((VWG& J0$01&KG&D2$0018&'VU&JG]G?B&U\(&T/+G&Q$%5&'((VWG& 91A+20&+<&0C1&JA15"$,&/$3012&"%&/"33+.2"&J>3G&+<&D.;,"5&Z1<1%B123&KG&]$0123&T=1;G&V8& '())WG& N.221,,@N$22"%6&KG&R1:&L+2H8&V?(&RGPG'B&')\&TRGLG&'()(WG&