Arxiv:1205.3548V1 [Math.CA] 16 May 2012
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SPHERICAL HARMONICS IN p DIMENSIONS CHRISTOPHER R. FRYE& COSTAS EFTHIMIOU Department of Physics UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA arXiv:1205.3548v1 [math.CA] 16 May 2012 VERSION: 1.0 May 10, 2012 c All rights reserved. Please contact Christopher Frye at [email protected] with any comments or corrections. This book was typeset in TEX using the LATEX 2" Document Preparation System. Contents Prefacev Acknowledgements vii 1 Introduction and Motivation1 1.1 Separation of Variables . .2 1.2 Quantum Mechanical Angular Momentum . .8 2 Working in p Dimensions 11 p 2.1 Rotations in R ........................... 11 2.2 Spherical Coordinates in p Dimensions . 13 2.3 The Sphere in Higher Dimensions . 16 2.4 Arc Length in Spherical Coordinates . 19 p 2.5 The Divergence Theorem in R .................. 21 2.6 ∆p in Spherical Coordinates . 25 3 Orthogonal Polynomials 29 3.1 Orthogonality and Expansions . 29 3.2 The Recurrence Formula . 32 3.3 The Rodrigues Formula . 34 3.4 Approximations by Polynomials . 37 3.5 Hilbert Space and Completeness . 41 4 Spherical Harmonics in p Dimensions 47 4.1 Harmonic Homogeneous Polynomials . 47 4.2 Spherical Harmonics and Orthogonality . 53 4.3 Legendre Polynomials . 58 4.4 Boundary Value Problems . 77 Bibliography 87 iii Preface The authors prepared the following booklet in order to make several useful topics from the theory of special functions, in particular the spherical har- p monics and Legendre polynomials of R , available to undergraduates studying physics or mathematics. With this audience in mind, nearly all details of the calculations and proofs are written out, and extensive background material is covered before beginning the main subject matter. The reader is assumed to have knowledge of multivariable calculus and linear algebra (especially inner product spaces) as well as some level of comfort with reading proofs. Literature in this area is scant, and for the undergraduate it is virtually nonexistent. To find the development of the spherical harmonics that arise in 3 R , physics students can look in almost any text on mathematical methods, electrodynamics, or quantum mechanics (see [1], [2], [6], [8], [11], for example), and math students can search any book on boundary value problems, PDEs, or special functions (see [3], [13], for example). However, the undergraduate will have a very difficult time finding accessible material on the corresponding p topics in arbitrary R . The authors used Hochstadt's The Functions of Mathematical Physics [5] as a primary reference (which is, unfortunately, out of print). If the reader seeks a much more concise treatment of spherical harmonics in an arbitrary number of dimensions written at a higher level, [5] is recommended. Much of the theory developed below can be found there. v Acknowledgements The first author worked on this booklet as an undergraduate and is very grate- ful to the second author for his guidance and assistance during this project. The first author would also like to thank Professors Maxim Zinchenko and Alexander Katsevich for their valuable comments and suggestions on the pre- sentation of the ideas. In addition, he thanks his friends Jie Liang, Byron Conley, and Brent Perreault for their feedback after proofreading portions of this manuscript. This work has been supported in part by NSF Award DUE 0963146 as well as UCF SMART and RAMP Awards. The first author is grateful to the Burnett Honors College (BHC), the Office of Undergraduate Research (OUR), and the Research and Mentoring Program (RAMP) at UCF for their generous support during his studies. He would like to thank especially Alvin Wang, Dean of BHC; Martin Dupuis, Assistant Dean of BHC; Kim Schneider, Director of OUR; and Michael Aldarondo-Jeffries, Director of RAMP. Last but not least, he thanks Paul Steidle for providing him a quiet office to work in while writing. vii Chapter 1 Introduction and Motivation Many important equations in physics involve the Laplace operator, which is given by @2 @2 ∆ = + ; (1.1) 2 @x2 @y2 @2 @2 @2 ∆ = + + ; (1.2) 3 @x2 @y2 @z2 in two and three dimensions1, respectively. We will see later (Proposition 2.1) that the Laplace operator is invariant under a rotation of the coordinate sys- tem. Thus, it arises in many physical situations in which there exists spherical symmetry, i.e., where physical quantities depend only on the radial distance r from some center of symmetry O. For example, the electric potential V in free space is found by solving the Laplace equation, ∆Φ = 0; (1.3) which is rotationally invariant. Also, in quantum mechanics, the wave function of a particle in a central field can be found by solving the time-independent Schro¨dinger equation, 2 − ~ ∆ + V (r) = E (1.4) 2m where ~ is Planck's constant, m is the mass of the particle, V (r) is its potential energy, and E is its total energy. We will give a brief introduction to these problems in two and three di- mensions to motivate the main subject of this discussion. In doing this, we will get a preview of some of the properties of spherical harmonics | which, for now, we can just think of as some special set of functions | that we will p develop later in the general setting of R . 1We may drop the subscript if we want to keep the number of dimensions arbitrary. 1 2 1. Introduction and Motivation ............................................................................ 1.1 Separation of Variables Two-Dimensional Case Since we are interested in problems with spherical symmetry, let us rewrite the 2 Laplace operator in spherical coordinates, which in R are just the ordinary polar coordinates2, p y r = x2 + y2; φ = tan−1 : (1.5) x Alternatively, x = r cos φ, y = r sin φ. Using the chain rule, we can rewrite the Laplace operator as @2 1 @ 1 @2 ∆ = + + : (1.6) 2 @r2 r @r r2 @φ2 In checking this result, perhaps it is easiest to begin with (1.6) and recover (1.1). First we compute @ @x @ @y @ @ @ = + = cos φ + sin φ ; (1.7) @r @r @x @r @y @x @y which implies that @2 @2 @2 @2 = cos2 φ + 2 sin φ cos φ + sin2 φ ; @r2 @x2 @x@y @y2 and @ @x @ @y @ @ @ = + = −r sin φ + r cos φ ; @φ @φ @x @φ @y @x @y which gives @2 @2 @2 @2 = r2 sin2 φ − 2r2 sin φ cos φ + r2 cos2 φ : @φ2 @x2 @x@y @y2 Inserting these into (1.6) gives us back (1.1). Thus, (1.3) becomes @2Φ 1 @Φ 1 @2Φ + + = 0: @r2 r @r r2 @φ2 2The polar angle φ actually requires a more elaborate definition, since tan−1 only produces angles in the first and fourth quadrants. However, this detail will not concern us here. 1.1. Separation of Variables3 ............................................................................ To solve this equation it is standard to assume that Φ(r; φ) = χ(r)Y (φ), where χ(r) is a function of r alone and Y (φ) is a function of φ alone. Then d2χ Y dχ χ d2Y Y + + = 0: dr2 r dr r2 dφ2 Multiplying by r2/χY and rearranging, r2 d2χ r dχ −1 d2Y + = : χ dr2 χ dr Y dφ2 We see that a function of r alone (the left side) is equal to a function of φ alone (the right side). Since we can vary r without changing φ, i.e., without changing the right side of the above equation, it must be that the left side of the above equation does not vary with r either. This means the left side of the above equation is not really a function of r but a constant. As a consequence, the right side is the same constant. Thus, for some −λ we can write −1 d2Y r2 d2χ r dχ = −λ = + : (1.8) Y dφ2 χ dr2 χ dr We solve Y 00 = λY to get the linearly independent solutions 8 p p e λφ; e− λφ if λ > 0; <> Y (φ) = 1; φ if λ = 0; :> sin pjλjφ ; cos pjλjφ if λ < 0; but we must reject some of these solutions. Since (r0; φ0) represents the same point as (r0; φ0 +2πk) for any k 2 Z, we require Y (φ) to have period 2π. Thus, we can only accept the linearly independent periodic solutions 1, sin pjλjφ , and cos pjλjφ , where pjλj must be an integer. Then, let us replace λ with −m2 and write our linearly independent solutions to Y 00 = −m2Y as Y1;n = cos (nφ);Y2;m = sin (mφ); (1.9) 3 2 2 where n 2 N0 and m 2 N. Notice from (1.6) that @ =@φ is the angular part of the Laplace operator in two dimensions and that the solutions given in (1.9) are eigenfunctions of the @2=@φ2 operator. We will see in Chapter4 that the functions in (1.9) are actually spherical harmonics; however, since we have not yet given a definition of a spherical harmonic, for now we will just refer to these as functions Y . The reader should keep in mind that characteristics of p the Y 's we comment on here will generalize when we move to R . 3 We use the notation N = f1; 2;::: g and N0 = f0; 1; 2;::: g. 4 1. Introduction and Motivation ............................................................................ We can also solve easily for the functions χ(r) that satisfy (1.8), but this does not concern us here. Let us instead notice a few properties of the functions m n 2 Y . Let us consider these to be functions r sin (mφ), r cos (nφ) on R that have been restricted to the unit circle, where r = 1, and let us analyze the 2 extended functions on R .