LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL UNANSWERED QUESTIONS on NOTICE Edition No

LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL UNANSWERED QUESTIONS ON NOTICE Edition No. 19

As at 6 March 2020

(Notice received 29 May 2019)

47418 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2019-20 State Budget that indicates that the estimated completion date for the South Road upgrade (Moorabbin) is listed as ‘tbc’: In which year will this project finally be completed.

47718 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2019-20 State Budget that indicates that the estimated completion date for the Western Port Highway (Skye) is listed as ‘tbc’: In which year will this project finally be completed.

48018 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2019-20 State Budget that indicates that the estimated completion date for the Barwon Heads Road upgrade (Barwon Heads) is listed as ‘tbc’: In which year will this project finally be completed.

(Notice received 13 August 2019)

630 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the 2015-16 Bus Package which describes the deliverables of this project as ‘Victoria’s bus networks will be improved by adding more routes, expanding others, restoring cut services and fixing missing links in Melbourne’s growth areas’ on page 25 in the 2015-16 Budget Paper No. 3: (1) Could the Minister provide, expressed in table form — (a) the cut services that were restored in — (i) 2015-16; (ii) 2016-17; (iii) 2017-18; (iv) 2018-19; (b) the commencement date of each cut service that was restored; and (c) the output cost for each cut service restored, in the year it started and each successive year to 2018-19. (2) What is the ongoing cost for restoring each cut service in 2019-20, and over the forward estimates, expressed in table form. (3) Do the output costs include annual indexation, and if so — (a) what is the percentage indexation; 6 March 2020 2

(b) what is the indexation dollar amount per year in — (i) 2015-16; (ii) 2016-17; (iii) 2017-18; and (iv) 2018-19. (4) What is the percentage indexation in 2019-20 and the assumed base indexation over the forward estimates. (5) If annual indexation has not been factored into the output cost, how have these costs been met by the service provider.

63820 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to daily passenger movements, that is passengers moving into and out of the station and actual daily passenger interchanges, at Bairnsdale Railway Station: (1) Between 2009-10 and 2019 — (a) when have changes in methodology for tracking passenger movement occurred; (b) what were the changes in methodology and what was the impact on the accuracy of the data collected; (c) notwithstanding the changes in methodology, by year, what are the actual daily passenger movements, expressed in table form; (d) by year, what are the average passenger movements, expressed in table form — (i) on weekdays; (ii) on weekends; and (iii) between mid-December and the end of January. (2) What methodology was used and what assumptions were made in forecasting passenger movements to be 234,000 annual entries by 2031.

63921 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to daily passenger movements, that is passengers moving into and out of the station and actual daily passenger interchanges, at Ballarat Railway Station: (1) Between 2009-10 and 2019 — (a) when have changes in methodology for tracking passenger movement occurred; (b) what were the changes in methodology and what was the impact on the accuracy of the data collected; (c) notwithstanding the changes in methodology, by year, what are the actual daily passenger movements, expressed in table form; (d) by year, what are the average passenger movements, expressed in table form — (i) on weekdays; (ii) on weekends; and (iii) between mid-December and the end of January. (2) What methodology was used and what assumptions were made in forecasting passenger movements to be 802,000 annual entries by 2031.

64021 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to daily passenger movements, that is passengers moving into and out of the station and actual daily passenger interchanges, at Bendigo Railway Station: (1) Between 2009-10 and 2019 — (a) when have changes in methodology for tracking passenger movement occurred; (b) what were the changes in methodology and what was the impact on the accuracy of the data collected; (c) notwithstanding the changes in methodology, by year, what are the actual daily passenger movements, expressed in table form; (d) by year, what are the average passenger movements, expressed in table form — (i) on weekdays; (ii) on weekends; and 6 March 2020 3

(iii) between mid-December and the end of January. (2) What methodology was used and what assumptions were made in forecasting passenger movements to be 535,000 annual entries by 2031.

65521 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to daily passenger movements, that is passengers moving into and out of the station and actual daily passenger interchanges, at Wodonga Railway Station: (1) Between 2011-12, the year the station opened, and 2019 — (a) when have changes in methodology for tracking passenger movement occurred; (b) what were the changes in methodology and what was the impact on the accuracy of the data collected; (c) notwithstanding the changes in methodology, by year, what are the actual daily passenger movements, expressed in table form; (d) by year, what are the average passenger movements, expressed in table form — (i) on weekdays; (ii) on weekends; and (iii) between mid-December and the end of January. (2) What methodology was used and what assumptions were made in forecasting passenger movements to be 30,000 annual entries by 2031.

65621 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to daily passenger movements, that is passengers moving into and out of the station and actual daily passenger interchanges, at Warrnambool Railway Station: (1) Between 2009-10 and 2019 — (a) when have changes in methodology for tracking passenger movement occurred; (b) what were the changes in methodology and what was the impact on the accuracy of the data collected; (c) notwithstanding the changes in methodology, by year, what are the actual daily passenger movements, expressed in table form; (d) by year, what are the average passenger movements, expressed in table form — (i) on weekdays; (ii) on weekends; and (iii) between mid-December and the end of January. (2) What methodology was used and what assumptions were made in forecasting passenger movements to be 201,000 annual entries by 2031.

65721 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to daily passenger movements, that is passengers moving into and out of the station and actual daily passenger interchanges, at Traralgon Railway Station: (1) Between 2009-10 and 2019 — (a) when have changes in methodology for tracking passenger movement occurred; (b) what were the changes in methodology and what was the impact on the accuracy of the data collected; (c) notwithstanding the changes in methodology, by year, what are the actual daily passenger movements, expressed in table form; (d) by year, what are the average passenger movements, expressed in table form — (i) on weekdays; (ii) on weekends; and (iii) between mid-December and the end of January. (2) What methodology was used and what assumptions were made in forecasting passenger movements to be 234,000 annual entries by 2031.

6 March 2020 4

65821 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to daily passenger movements, that is passengers moving into and out of the station and actual daily passenger interchanges, at Swan Hill Railway Station: (1) Between 2009-10 and 2019 — (a) when have changes in methodology for tracking passenger movement occurred; (b) what were the changes in methodology and what was the impact on the accuracy of the data collected; (c) notwithstanding the changes in methodology, by year, what are the actual daily passenger movements, expressed in table form; (d) by year, what are the average passenger movements, expressed in table form — (i) on weekdays; (ii) on weekends; and (iii) between mid-December and the end of January. (2) What methodology was used and what assumptions were made in forecasting passenger movements to be 50,000 annual entries by 2031.

65921 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to daily passenger movements, that is passengers moving into and out of the station and actual daily passenger interchanges, at Seymour Railway Station: (1) Between 2009-10 and 2019 — (a) when have changes in methodology for tracking passenger movement occurred; (b) what were the changes in methodology and what was the impact on the accuracy of the data collected; (c) notwithstanding the changes in methodology, by year, what are the actual daily passenger movements, expressed in table form; (d) by year, what are the average passenger movements, expressed in table form — (i) on weekdays; (ii) on weekends; and (iii) between mid-December and the end of January. (2) What methodology was used and what assumptions were made in forecasting passenger movements to be 84,000 annual entries by 2031.

(Notice received 28 August 2019)

786 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the specialist appointments funded this year for regional Victorians, how many cancer appointments have been funded for — (a) Bendigo Health; (b) Goulburn Valley Health; (c) Ballarat Health Services; and (d) Latrobe Regional Hospital.

787 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the specialist appointments funded this year for regional Victorians, how many diabetes appointments have been funded for — (a) Bendigo Health; (b) Goulburn Valley Health; (c) Ballarat Health Services; and (d) Latrobe Regional Hospital.

788 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the specialist appointments funded this year for regional Victorians, how many cardiac appointments have been funded for — (a) Bendigo Health; (b) Goulburn Valley Health; 6 March 2020 5

789 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the specialist appointments funded this year for regional Victorians, how many chronic pain appointments have been funded for — (a) Bendigo Health; (b) Goulburn Valley Health; (c) Ballarat Health Services; and (d) Latrobe Regional Hospital.

(Notice received 10 September 2019)

812 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Local Government (for the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Major Events): In relation to the Government's pre-election commitment to protect the open space of the Maribyrnong River as part of the Waterways of the West Project, and the subsequent approval for the construction of three soccer grounds on the Footscray Park floodplain by the Melbourne Victory Football Club: (1) Has the impact of the proposed floodlight poles on nocturnal animals been taken into account. (2) Given that Footscray Park is an important asset offering a rare off-leash dog area, what impact will the soccer grounds proposal have on recreational dog walkers.

(Notice received 15 October 2019)

840 MS MAXWELL — To ask the Minister for Local Government (for the Minister for Jobs, Innovation and Trade): In relation to mobile phone black spots: Does the Government maintain an official, regularly updated, list of mobile black spot locations across the state, and if so — (a) how frequently is the list updated; (b) what are the basic criteria for a location to be classified as a mobile black spot on the list; and (c) where can a member of the public see a copy of the most up-to-date version of the list.

846 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to the demolition of certain Victorian properties: Will the Minister intervene, as he did with Currajong House, to stop the demolition of — (a) 88 Belford Road, Kew East; (b) 980 Toorak Road, Camberwell; (c) 19 Moir Street, Hawthorn; (d) 360 Auburn Road, Hawthorn East; and (e) 778 Burwood Road, Hawthorn East.

(Notice received 29 October 2019)

101822 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the 2015-16 Bus Package where the deliverables are described on page 25 of the 2015- 16 Budget papers as ‘Victoria’s bus networks will be improved by adding more routes, expanding others, restoring cut services and fixing missing links in Melbourne’s growth areas’: (1) How many cut services were restored. (2) What are the route numbers of each cut service that was restored. (3) When did each restored service commence delivering passenger services. (4) What is the weekday and weekend timetable for each bus service restored. (5) Which bus company is delivering each individual cut service that was restored.

6 March 2020 6

102022 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the 2015-16 Bus Package where the deliverables are described on page 25 of the 2015- 16 Budget papers as ‘Victoria’s bus networks will be improved by adding more routes, expanding others, restoring cut services and fixing missing links in Melbourne’s growth areas’: What were the actual output costs between 1 July 2015 and 30 June 2019, by year, of this initiative.

102122 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the 2015-16 Bus Package where the deliverables are described on page 25 of the 2015- 16 Budget papers as ‘Victoria’s bus networks will be improved by adding more routes, expanding others, restoring cut services and fixing missing links in Melbourne’s growth areas’: What were the actual output costs between 1 July 2015 and 30 June 2019, by year, for additional bus routes delivered.

102222 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the 2015-16 Bus Package where the deliverables are described on page 25 of the 2015- 16 Budget papers as ‘Victoria’s bus networks will be improved by adding more routes, expanding others, restoring cut services and fixing missing links in Melbourne’s growth areas’: What were the actual output costs between 1 July 2015 and 30 June 2019, by year, for expanded bus routes delivered.

102322 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the 2015-16 Bus Package where the deliverables are described on page 25 of the 2015- 16 Budget papers as ‘Victoria’s bus networks will be improved by adding more routes, expanding others, restoring cut services and fixing missing links in Melbourne’s growth areas’: What were the actual output costs between 1 July 2015 and 30 June 2019, by year, for bus services that were cut and have been restored.

102722 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the 2015-16 Bus Package where the deliverables are described on page 25 of the 2015- 16 Budget papers as ‘Victoria’s bus networks will be improved by adding more routes, expanding others, restoring cut services and fixing missing links in Melbourne’s growth areas’: (1) When considering funding, how many bus route expansions were identified as necessary to improve bus networks. (2) What are the bus route numbers for each bus route expansion identified in Question 1. (3) What were the start and end points of each bus route expansion, as identified in Question 1.

1032 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the Murray Basin Rail Project: (1) Is the Minister aware that the Project supported a mode shift in freight traffic from the roads to the rail network, removing approximately 20,000 truck trips from roads to the ports. (2) Is the Minister aware that the Project is not proceeding and as a result will lead to increased freight traffic on the roads. (3) What is the expected increase in greenhouse gas emissions as a result of the Rail Project not proceeding.

1037 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Planning): Can the Minister advise if Presentation College, Windsor is subject to any heritage overlays and has it been subject to any heritage assessment.

6 March 2020 7

(Notice received 30 October 2019)

1056 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the $200 million flu funding package announced by the Government, can the Minister provide for each of the following hospitals the amount they will each receive — (a) Albury Wodonga Health; (b) Alexandra District Health; (c) Alfred Health; (d) Alpine Health; (e) Angliss Hospital; (f) Austin Health; (g) Austin Health — Austin Hospital; (h) Austin Health — Heidelberg Repatriation Hospital; (i) Barwon Health; (j) Bass Coast Health; (k) Benalla Health; (l) Bendigo Health Care Group; (m) Boort District Health; (n) Box Hill Hospital; (o) Calvary Health Care Bethlehem Ltd; (p) Caritas Christi Hospice Ltd; (q) Casey Hospital; (r) Casterton Memorial Hospital; (s) Castlemaine Health; (t) Caulfield Hospital; (u) Cobram District Health; (v) Cohuna District Hospital; (w) Colac Area Health; (x) Corryong Health; (y) Cranbourne Integrated Care Centre; (z) Dandenong Hospital; (aa) Eastern Health; (bb) Echuca Regional Health; (cc) Edenhope and District Hospital; (dd) Footscray Hospital; (ee) Frankston Hospital; (ff) Goulburn Valley Health; (gg) Healesville and District Hospital; (hh) Heathcote Health; (ii) Heywood Rural Health; (jj) Kerang District Health; (kk) Kilmore and District Hospital; (ll) Kingston Centre; (mm) Latrobe Regional Hospital; (nn) Lorne Community Hospital; (oo) Maldon Hospital; (pp) Mansfield District Hospital; (qq) Maroondah Hospital; (rr) Melbourne Health; (ss) Melton Health; (tt) Mercy Health — O'Connell Family Centre; (uu) Mercy Hospital for Women; (vv) Mercy Hospitals Victoria Limited; 6 March 2020 8

(ww) Mildura Base Hospital; (xx) Monash Health; (yy) Monash Medical Centre, Clayton Campus; (zz) Monash Medical Centre, Moorabbin Campus; (aaa) Mount Eliza Rehabilitation, Aged and Palliative Care; (bbb) Nathalia District Hospital; (ccc) Northeast Health Wangaratta; (ddd) Northern Health; (eee) Omeo District Health; (fff) Orbost Regional Health; (ggg) Otway Health; (hhh) Peninsula Health; (iii) Peter James Centre, The; (jjj) Peter MacCallum Cancer Institute; (kkk) Portland District Health; (lll) Queen Elizabeth Centre; (mmm) Regional Public Hospitals; (nnn) Rosebud Hospital; (ooo) Royal Melbourne Hospital — City Campus; (ppp) Royal Melbourne Hospital — Royal Park Campus; (qqq) Royal Talbot Rehabilitation Centre; (rrr) Rural Northwest Health; (sss) Sandringham Hospital; (ttt) Seymour Health; (uuu) South Gippsland Hospital; (vvv) South West Healthcare; (www) South West Healthcare, Camperdown Campus; (xxx) South West Healthcare, Warrnambool Campus; (yyy) St Vincent's Health; (zzz) St Vincent's Hospital (Melbourne) Ltd; (aaaa) Stawell Regional Health; (bbbb) Sunshine Hospital; (cccc) Swan Hill District Health; (dddd) The Alfred; (eeee) The Northern Hospital; (ffff) The Royal Children's Hospital; (gggg) The Royal Victorian Eye and Ear Hospital; (hhhh) The Royal Women's Hospital; (iiii) Wantirna Health; (jjjj) Werribee Mercy Hospital; (kkkk) West Gippsland Healthcare Group; (llll) West Wimmera Health Service; (mmmm) Western District Health Service; (nnnn) Western District Health Service, Coleraine Campus; (oooo) Western Health; (pppp) Williamstown Hospital; (qqqq) Wimmera Health Care Group; (rrrr) Yarra Ranges Health; (ssss) Yarram and District Health Service; (tttt) Yarrawonga Health; (uuuu) Yea and District Memorial Hospital.

6 March 2020 9

1057 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the $200 million flu funding package announced by the Government: Will any of the $200 million go toward settling the funding required from the recent wage increase for Victorian doctors and nurses.

105922 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Alamein Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106022 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Belgrave Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106122 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Craigieburn Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106222 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Cranbourne Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106322 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Frankston Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106422 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Glen Waverley Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works. 6 March 2020 10

106522 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Hurtsbridge Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106622 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Lilydale Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106722 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Mernda Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106822 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Pakenham Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

106922 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Sandringham Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

107022 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Stony Point Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

6 March 2020 11

107122 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Sunbury Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

107222 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Upfield Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

107322 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Werribee Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

107422 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the scheduled works on the Williamstown Line: (1) How many instances of scheduled works are planned during the period 1 July 2019 to 30 June 2020. (2) What is the scheduled start date and scheduled completion date of each instance of scheduled works. (3) What works are to be undertaken during each instance of scheduled works. (4) What is the budget for each instance of scheduled works.

(Notice received 31 October 2019)

1075 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the Sunshine Avenue to Calder Freeway component of the M80 Ring Road Upgrade Project, which has a total estimated investment of $300 million, with the Federal Government contributing $150 million, and corporate costs of $6.13 million funded by moving money from the capital funding pool to the output funding pool: (1) Why were the capital/output costs not properly identified, apportioned and phased over the forward estimates at the start of the Project. (2) Will the Minister provide a breakdown of the $6.13 million allocated to corporate costs for this Project, in table form.

1078 DR RATNAM — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Workplace Safety): In relation to an agreement between the Environment Protection Authority and Veolia that resulted in hazardous waste being transported to South Australia in August 2019 due to the recent discovery of stockpiles: (1) Did WorkSafe Victoria pay for the transfer, and if not, which Government department or statutory body paid for this transfer. (2) How much did this transfer and treatment cost.

6 March 2020 12

1079 DR RATNAM — To ask the Minister for Local Government: In relation to the feedback sought on six new reforms to the Local Government Act 1989 outlined in the Local Government Bill Reform Paper: (1) How many responses supported Reform 2 - Electoral Structures. (2) How many responses opposed Reform 2 - Electoral Structures.

1080 DR RATNAM — To ask the Minister for Roads: In relation to the homes acquired by the Government for the East-West Link Project: (1) How many homes in total were acquired by the Government as a direct consequence of the previous Liberal Government's East-West Link Project. (2) How many of these homes have been sold on the private market.

(Notice received 12 November 2019)

108122 MR DAVIS — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Premier): In relation to the Premier’s visits to the People’s Republic of China: With whom did the Premier meet on each day of the visit and what positions did they hold with each entity during visits on — (1) 25 to 29 April 2019; (2) 29 May to 1 June 2018; (3) 13 to 18 May 2017; and (4) 20 to 27 September 2015.

108222 MR DAVIS — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Premier): In relation to the Premier’s visit to the People’s Republic of China and Japan from 19 to 28 September 2016: With whom did the Premier meet on each day of the visit to the People’s Republic of China and what positions did they hold with which entity.

1087 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $498,766,000 for Alfred Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1088 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $397,821,000 for Austin Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1089 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $156,107,000 for Ballarat Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1090 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $291,048,000 for Barwon Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1091 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $486,088,000 for Eastern Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1092 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $425,705,000 for Melbourne Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES. 6 March 2020 13

1093 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $236,965,000 for Mercy Hospitals Victoria Pty Ltd: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1094 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $832,306,000 for Monash Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1095 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WEIS) budget of $345,597,000 for Northern Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1096 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WEIS) budget of $303,061,000 for Peninsula Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1097 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WEIS) budget of $106,330,000 for Peter MacCallum Cancer Institute: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1098 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WEIS) budget of $273,613,000 for St Vincent’s Hospital (Melbourne) Limited: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1099 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WEIS) budget of $281,218,000 for The Royal Children’s Hospital: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1100 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $57,231,000 for The Royal Victorian Eye and Ear Hospital: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1101 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $161,533,000 for The Royal Women’s Hospital: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

1102 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 2019-20 acute weighted inlier equivalent separation (WIES) budget of $411,259,000 for Western Health: (1) What is the budget amount for public WIES. (2) What is the budget amount for private WIES.

6 March 2020 14

110322 MR DAVIS — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Premier): In relation to the Premier’s visits to various countries between 2016 and 2018: With whom did the Premier meet on each day of the visit and what positions did they hold with each entity during visits to — (a) the United States of America from 22 to 27 February 2018; (b) India from 15 to 20 January 2018; (c) Israel and Greece from 5 to 10 December 2017; and (d) the United States of America from 27 May to 5 June 2016.

112122 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to metropolitan bus network punctuality: Could the Minister provide, in table form, the whole of metropolitan bus network punctuality, by month, from December 2015 to October 2019.

112222 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to metropolitan bus network punctuality: Could the Minister provide, in table form, the whole of metropolitan bus network punctuality, by day, from 1 January 2019 to 31 October 2019.

112323 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the monthly metropolitan bus network punctuality: (1) What is the methodology used to calculate the monthly bus network punctuality figure. (2) What are the counting rules used to calculate the monthly bus network punctuality figure. (3) Has there been a change in methodology for calculating the monthly punctuality, and if so, please provide details about the change.

112423 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the daily metropolitan bus network punctuality: (1) What is the methodology used to calculate the daily bus network punctuality figure. (2) What are the counting rules used to calculate the daily bus network punctuality figure. (3) Has there been a change in methodology for calculating the daily punctuality, and if so, please provide details about the change.

(Notice received 26 November 2019)

1129 MR HAYES — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): Will the Minister step in to save the Australasian Bittern, a Commonwealth endangered species, from extinction by stopping the Mordialloc Freeway Extension from destroying wetlands that can never be relocated.

1131 MR LIMBRICK — To ask the Minister for Roads: In relation to the offence of riding a bicycle without a helmet under Rule 256 of the Road Safety Road Rules 2017: (1) What is the rationale for the heavy penalty of 5 penalty units, which currently equates to $826. (2) What evidence is there to suggest that a high fine correlates to reducing road trauma. (3) How many cyclists are issued with fines each year for failing to wear a helmet.

1132 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to the Victorian Building Authority (VBA): (1) Is it correct that the Queensland Building and Construction Commission sanctions more builders in a fortnight than the VBA does in a year. (2) Will the Minister now require the VBA to provide regular updates on its activity in the same manner as is provided by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission.

1134 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2015 contract awarded to the John Holland and KBR consortium for the removal of level crossings at Centre Road in Bentleigh, North Road in Ormond, McKinnon Road in McKinnon, and Burke Road in Glen Iris: 6 March 2020 15

(1) What was the total payment, including payments for contract variations, at contract close. (2) For each level crossing, on what dates — (a) were regular services disrupted due to level crossing removal works; and (b) did regular services resume post level crossing removal. (3) How many jobs were created under this contract.

1135 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2015 contract awarded to the Leighton Contractors, Aurecon and Hyder Consulting alliance for the removal of level crossings at Blackburn Road in Blackburn, Heatherdale Road in Mitcham, and Furlong and Main Roads in St Albans: (1) What was the total payment, including payments for contract variations, at contract close. (2) For each level crossing, on what dates — (a) were regular services disrupted due to level crossing removal works; and (b) did regular services resume post level crossing removal. (3) For the vehicles that use each level crossing, by how much has road congestion been reduced. (4) Since the completion of works, how many additional services have been run on the Belgrave and Sunbury lines.

1136 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2017 contract awarded to the Laing O’Rourke, Fulton Hogan and Jacobs alliance for the removal of level crossings at Lower Plenty Road in Rosanna, Grange Road in Alphington, the rebuild of Rosanna Station, and duplication of the Hurstbridge line: (1) What was the total payment, including payments for contract variations, at contract close. (2) For the Lower Plenty Road and Grange Road level crossings, on what dates — (a) were regular services disrupted due to level crossing removal works; and (b) did regular services resume post level crossing removal. (3) For the rebuild of Rosanna Station, on what date — (a) did works begin; (b) was it open to commuters; (c) did car park works begin; and (d) were the car park works completed. (4) For the Hurstbridge line duplication — (a) on what dates were regular services disrupted; (b) on what dates did regular services resume; (c) how many additional train services were added; and (d) what is the increase in service frequency since the removal of the level crossings and line duplication.

1137 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2016 contract awarded to the Lendlease, CPB Contractors, WSP Parsons Brinckerhoff, Aurecon and Metro Trains Melbourne alliance for the Caulfield to Dandenong Level Crossing Removal Project: (1) What was the total payment, including payments for contract variations, at contract close. (2) On what date were regular services disrupted due to the level crossing removal works. (3) On what date did regular services resume post level crossing removals. (4) How has this project improved the reliability of metropolitan, regional and freight services, including trains arriving on time and more often.

1138 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2017 contract awarded to the McConnell Dowell, Arup and Mott McDonald alliance for the removal of the level crossing at Kororoit Creek Road in Williamstown North, part duplication of the Altona loop, and potential removal of level crossings at Abbotts Road in Dandenong South, Aviation Road in Laverton, Ferguson Street in Williamstown and Cherry and Werribee Streets in Werribee: (1) What was the contract price for the delivery of the Kororoit Creek Road level crossing removal and part duplication of the Altona loop. 6 March 2020 16

(2) What was the total payment, including payments for contract variations, for works specified in question (1). (3) What additional funding was awarded for each listed potential level crossing removal. (4) What is the completion date scheduled for the removal of level crossings at — (a) Ferguson Street; (b) Cherry Street; and (c) Werribee Street. (5) What is the total spend for both components of the contract, as at 30 September 2019.

1139 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2017 contract awarded to the John Holland and KBR alliance for the removal of level crossings at Camp Road in Campbellfield, Skye/Overton Road in Frankston, Buckley Street in Essendon, and the potential removal of level crossings at Moreland Road in Brunswick, Bell Street in Coburg, and Glenroy Road in Glenroy: (1) What was the contract price for the delivery of the removal of level crossings at Camp Road, Skye/Overton Road, and Buckley Street. (2) What was the total payment, including payments for contract variations, for works specified in question (1). (3) What additional funding was awarded for level crossing removals for each listed potential level crossing removal. (4) What is the scheduled completion date for each listed potential level crossing removal. (5) What is the total spend for both components of the contract, as at 30 September 2019.

1140 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2018 contract awarded to the John Holland, KBR and MTM alliance for the removal of the level crossing at High Street in Reservoir: (1) What is the total spend under this contract to 30 September 2019. (2) What is the scheduled completion date.

1141 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the 2018 contract awarded to the Laing O'Rourke, Jacobs and Metro (MTM) alliance for the removal of the level crossing at Toorak Road in Kooyong: (1) What is the total spend under this contract to 30 September 2019. (2) What is the scheduled completion date.

1142 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to 2019 contract awarded to the Lendlease, Acciona Coleman Rail, WSP and Metro Trains alliance for the removal of level crossings at Park and Charman Roads in Cheltenham and Balcombe Road in Mentone: (1) What is the total spend under this contract to 30 September 2019. (2) What is the scheduled completion date for each level crossing removal.

1149 MR LIMBRICK – To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the use of cannabis and medical emergency cases: (1) How many patients presented with the following at each Victorian hospital Emergency Department, between March 2017 and February 2018 — (a) cannabinoid related psychosis; (b) cannabis dependency; (c) cannabis withdrawal symptoms; (d) acute cannabis intoxication; (e) symptoms of harmful use cannabis; (f) late onset psychosis related to cannabis; and (g) any sort of substance issue, including cannabis. (2) How many patients were treated overall by the Emergency Response Department.

6 March 2020 17

1152 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads: In relation to KPMG’s ‘scoping study’ into VicRoads: (1) Is contracting out or privatisation an option being considered by KPMG, or part of their brief, and if so — (a) what guarantees can the Government provide concerning the privacy of name and address information, driving records and other data presently held by VicRoads; and (b) what steps will the Government put in place to prevent identity fraud, given that driver licences are routinely accepted by banks and other places as proof of identity. (2) Can the Government guarantee that no VicRoads call centre or other jobs will be offshored as a result of this process. (3) Will the Government and KPMG take into account the value, particularly to older people, of face to face service provision at VicRoads shopfronts, and the less accessible service which comes with their replacement by online or call centre based service delivery.

1153 MR HAYES — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): Is the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning assessing the impact of ‘fuel reduction’ burning on tree recruitment and the ability for younger trees to grow to maturity to replace the larger and older trees when they die.

1154 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many cases of the flu were diagnosed from 1 January to 25 November 2019 at the following public hospitals — (a) Alfred Health; (b) Angliss Hospital; (c) Austin Health; (d) Box Hill Hospital; (e) Broadmeadows Health Service; (f) Calvary Health Care Bethlehem Limited; (g) Casey Hospital; (h) Caulfield Hospital; (i) Craigieburn Health Service; (j) Dandenong Hospital; (k) Eastern Health; (l) Frankston Hospital; (m) Healesville and District Hospital; (n) Kingston Centre; (o) Maroondah Hospital; (p) Melbourne Health; (q) Mercy Public Hospitals Incorporated; (r) Monash Health; (s) Northern Health; (t) Peninsula Health; (u) Rosebud Hospital; (v) Royal Melbourne Hospital; (w) Sandringham Hospital; (x) St George's Health Service; (y) St Vincent's Health; (z) Sunshine Hospital; (aa) The Royal Children's Hospital; (bb) The Royal Women's Hospital; (cc) Wantirna Health; (dd) Western Health; (ee) Williamstown Hospital; (ff) Yarra Ranges Health; (gg) Albury Wodonga Health; 6 March 2020 18

(hh) Alexandra District Hospital; (ii) Alpine Health; (jj) Bairnsdale Regional Health Service; (kk) Ballarat Health Services; (ll) Barwon Health; (mm) Bass Coast Health; (nn) Beaufort and Skipton Health Service; (oo) Beechworth Health Service; (pp) Benalla Health; (qq) Bendigo Health Care Group; (rr) Boort District Health; (ss) Casterton Memorial Hospital; (tt) Castlemaine Health; (uu) Central Gippsland Health Service; (vv) Cobram District Health; (ww) Cohuna District Hospital; (xx) Colac Area Health; (yy) Djerriwarrh Health Services; (zz) Dunmunkle Health Services; (aaa) East Grampians Health Service; (bbb) East Wimmera Health Service; (ccc) Echuca Regional Health; (ddd) Edenhope and District Hospital; (eee) Gippsland Southern Health Service; (fff) Goulburn Valley Health; (ggg) Heathcote Health; (hhh) Hepburn Health Service; (iii) Hesse Rural Health Service; (jjj) Heywood Rural Health; (kkk) Inglewood and District Health Service; (lll) Kerang District Health; (mmm) Kilmore and District Hospital; (nnn) Kooweerup Regional Health Service; (ooo) Kyabram and District Health Service; (ppp) Kyneton District Health Service; (qqq) Latrobe Regional Hospital; (rrr) Lorne Community Hospital; (sss) Maldon Hospital; (ttt) Maryborough District Health Service; (uuu) Melton Health; (vvv) Mildura Base Hospital; (www) Moyne Health Services; (xxx) Nathalia District Hospital; (yyy) Northeast Health Wangaratta; (zzz) Numurkah District Health Service; (aaaa) Omeo District Health; (bbbb) Orbost Regional Health; (cccc) Otway Health and Community Services; (dddd) Portland District Health; (eeee) Robinvale District Health Services; (ffff) Rochester and Elmore District Health Service; (gggg) Rural Northwest Health; (hhhh) Seymour Health; 6 March 2020 19

(iiii) South Gippsland Hospital; (jjjj) South West Healthcare; (kkkk) Stawell Regional Health; (llll) Swan Hill District Health; (mmmm) Tallangatta Health Service; (nnnn) Terang and Mortlake Health Service; (oooo) Timboon and District Healthcare Service; (pppp) Upper Murray Health and Community Services; (qqqq) West Gippsland Healthcare Group; (rrrr) West Wimmera Health Service; (ssss) Western District Health Service; (tttt) Wimmera Health Care Group; (uuuu) Yarram and District Health Service; (vvvv) Yarrawonga Health; and (wwww) Yea and District Memorial Hospital.

1253 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Alfred Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1254 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Angliss Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1255 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Austin Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1256 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Box Hill Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1257 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Broadmeadows Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1258 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Calvary Health Care Bethlehem Limited’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1259 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Casey Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1260 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Caulfield Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1261 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Craigieburn Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1262 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Dandenong Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 20

1263 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Eastern Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1264 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Frankston Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1265 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Healesville and District Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1266 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Maroondah Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1267 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Melbourne Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1268 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Mercy Public Hospitals Incorporated’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1269 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Monash Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1270 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Northern Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1271 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Peninsula Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1272 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Rosebud Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1273 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Royal Melbourne Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1274 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Sandringham Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1275 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at St George’s Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1276 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at St Vincent’s Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 21

1277 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Sunshine Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1278 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at The Royal Children’s Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1279 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at The Royal Women’s Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1280 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Tweddle Child and Family Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1281 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Wantirna Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1282 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Werribee Mercy Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1283 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Western Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1284 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Williamstown Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1285 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Yarra Ranges Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1286 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Albury Wodonga Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1287 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Alexandra District Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1288 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Alpine Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1289 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Bairnsdale Regional Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1290 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Ballarat Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 22

1291 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Barwon Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1292 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Bass Coast Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1293 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Austin Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1294 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Beaufort and Skipton Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1295 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Benalla Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1296 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Bendigo Health Care Group’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1297 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Boort District Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1298 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Casterton Memorial Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1299 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Central Gippsland Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1300 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Cobram District Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1301 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Cohuna District Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1302 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Djerriwarrh Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1303 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Dunmunkle Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1304 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at East Grampians Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 23

1305 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at East Wimmera Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1306 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Echuca Regional Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1307 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Edenhope and District Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1308 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Gippsland Southern Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1309 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Goulburn Valley Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1310 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Heathcote Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1311 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Hepburn Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1312 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Hesse Rural Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1313 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Heywood Rural Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1314 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Inglewood and District Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1315 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Kerang District Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1316 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Kooweerup Regional Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1317 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Kyabram and District Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1318 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Kyneton District Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 24

1319 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Latrobe Regional Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1320 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Lorne Community Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1321 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Maldon Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1322 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Maryborough District Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1323 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Melton Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1324 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Mildura Base Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1325 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Moyne Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1326 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Nathalia District Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1327 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Northeast Health Wangaratta’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1328 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Numurkah District Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1329 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Omeo District Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1330 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Orbost Regional Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1331 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Otway Health and Community Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1332 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Portland District Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 25

1333 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Robinvale District Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1334 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Rochester and Elmore District Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1335 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Rural Northwest Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1336 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Seymour Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1337 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at South Gippsland Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1338 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at South West Healthcare’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1339 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Stawell Regional Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1340 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Swan Hill District Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1341 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Tallangatta Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1342 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Terang and Mortlake Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1343 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Timboon and District Healthcare Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1344 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Upper Murray Health and Community Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1345 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at West Gippsland Healthcare Group’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1346 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Wimmera Health Care Group’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 26

1347 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Yarram and District Health Service’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1348 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Yarrawonga Health’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1349 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: How many patients with the flu presented themselves at Yea and District Memorial Hospital’s emergency department from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1350 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Alfred Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1351 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Angliss Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1352 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Austin Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1353 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Box Hill Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1354 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Broadmeadows Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1355 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Calvary Health Care Bethlehem Limited from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1356 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Casey Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1357 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Caulfield Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1358 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Craigieburn Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1359 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Dandenong Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1360 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Dental Health Services Victoria from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1361 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Eastern Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1362 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Frankston Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 27

1363 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Healesville and District Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1364 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Maroondah Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1365 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Melbourne Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1366 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Mercy Public Hospitals Incorporated from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1367 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Monash Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1368 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Northern Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1369 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Peninsula Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1370 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1371 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Rosebud Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1372 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Royal Melbourne Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1373 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Sandringham Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1374 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at St George’s Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1375 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at St Vincent’s Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1376 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Sunshine Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1377 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at The Royal Children’s Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1378 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at The Royal Victorian Eye and Ear Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 28

1379 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at The Royal Women’s Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1380 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Wantirna Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1381 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Werribee Mercy Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1382 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Western Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1383 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Williamstown Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1384 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Yarra Ranges Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1385 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Albury Wodonga Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1386 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Alexandra District Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1387 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Alpine Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1388 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Bairnsdale Regional Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1389 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Ballarat Health Services from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1390 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Barwon Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1391 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Bass Coast Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1392 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Beaufort and Skipton Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1393 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Beechworth Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1394 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Benalla Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1395 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Bendigo Health Care Group from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 29

1396 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Boort District Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1397 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Casterton Memorial Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1398 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Castlemaine Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1399 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Central Gippsland Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1400 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Cobram District Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1401 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Cohuna District Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1402 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Colac Area Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1403 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Djerriwarrh Health Services from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1404 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Dunmunkle Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1405 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at East Grampians Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1406 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at East Wimmera Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1407 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Echuca Regional Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1408 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Edenhope and District Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1409 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Gippsland Southern Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1410 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Goulburn Valley Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1411 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Heathcote Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 30

1412 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Hepburn Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1413 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Heywood Rural Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1414 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Inglewood and District Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1415 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Kerang District Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1416 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Kooweerup Regional Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1417 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Kyabram and District Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1418 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Kyneton District Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1419 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Latrobe Regional Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1420 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Lorne Community Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1421 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Maldon Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1422 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Maryborough District Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1423 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Melton Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1424 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Mildura Base Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1425 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Moyne Health Services from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1426 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Nathalia District Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1427 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Northeast Health Wangaratta from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 31

1428 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Numurkah District Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1429 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Omeo District Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1430 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Orbost Regional Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1431 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Otway Health and Community Services from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1432 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Portland District Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1433 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Robinvale District Health Services from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1434 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Rochester and Elmore District Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1435 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Rural Northwest Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1436 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Seymour Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1437 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at South Gippsland Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1438 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at South West Healthcare from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1439 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Stawell Regional Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1440 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Swan Hill District Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1441 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Tallangatta Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1442 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Terang and Mortlake Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1443 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Timboon and District Healthcare Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

6 March 2020 32

1444 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Upper Murray Health and Community Services from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1445 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at West Gippsland Healthcare Group from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1446 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at West Wimmera Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1447 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Western District Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1448 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Wimmera Health Care Group from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive. 1449 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Yarram and District Health Service from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1450 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Yarrawonga Health from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

1451 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the number of flu related admissions at Yea and District Memorial Hospital from 1 January 2019 to 25 November 2019 inclusive.

(Notice received 4 February 2020)

1475 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Fishing and Boating: Why did the Safe and Accessible Waterways Strategy Discussion Paper, Public Feedback Report, published in May 2017, make no reference to the submissions it received from submitters who raised the issue of the impact of duck shooters on the waterways.

1476 MR HAYES — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): Will the Government pursue, either through the Council of Australian Governments (COAG) or through the COAG Energy Council, a co-ordinated policy to ensure Australian gas reserves benefit Australian manufacturers and consumers, by promoting — (a) domestic gas reservation policy; (b) financial incentives for consumers to switch from gas to electricity; and (c) consistent and transparent disclosure through the ACCC and ASX of what happens to gas produced in Australia.

1477 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the 360 Marketing Communications consultancy expenditure of $133,923: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. 6 March 2020 33

(5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1478 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to 360 Marketing Communications contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that 360 Marketing Communications were awarded one consultancy contract of $133,923: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1479 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the AALTO Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $90,755: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1480 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the AALTO Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $88,182: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1481 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to AALTO Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that AALTO Pty Ltd were awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $178,937: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

6 March 2020 34

1482 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the ACIL Allen Consulting consultancy expenditure of $160,523: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1483 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the ACIL Allen Consulting consultancy expenditure of $59,914: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1484 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to ACIL Allen Consulting contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that ACIL Allen Consulting were awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $220,437: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1485 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Advisian Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $160,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract. 6 March 2020 35

1486 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Advisian Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $23,370: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1487 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Advisian Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018- 19 which shows that Advisian Pty Ltd were awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $183,370: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1488 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Aither Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $104,560: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1489 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Aither Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Aither Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $104,560: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1490 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Allens consultancy expenditure of $20,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. 6 March 2020 36

(3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1491 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Allens contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Allens was awarded one consultancy contract of $20,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1492 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Alphabet Advisors Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $20,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1493 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Alphabet Advisors Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Alphabet Advisors Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $20,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1494 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Andrew Bleby and Associates Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $23,700: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. 6 March 2020 37

(6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1495 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Andrew Bleby and Associates Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Andrew Bleby and Associates Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $23,700: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1496 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Anstra Associates Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $22,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1497 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Anstra Associates Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Anstra Associates Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $22,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1498 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the ArcBlue consultancy expenditure of $31,450: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

6 March 2020 38

1499 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the ArcBlue consultancy expenditure of $25,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract. 1500 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the ArcBlue consultancy expenditure of $20,160: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1501 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to ArcBlue contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that ArcBlue was awarded three consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $76,610: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1502 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Artisan Recruitment Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $19,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

6 March 2020 39

1503 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Artisan Recruitment Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Artisan Recruitment Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $19,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1504 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Arup Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $1,258,657: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1505 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Arup Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $17,200: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1506 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Arup Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Arup Pty Ltd was awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $1,275,857: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1507 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the ASG Group Ltd consultancy expenditure of $16,400: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. 6 March 2020 40

(2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1508 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the ASG Group Ltd consultancy expenditure of $156,288: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1509 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to ASG Group Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that ASG Group Ltd was awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $172,688: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1510 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Box Hill Institute of TAFE consultancy expenditure of $30,850: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1511 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Box Hill Institute of TAFE contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that the Box Hill Institute of TAFE was awarded one consultancy contract of $30,850: 6 March 2020 41

(1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1512 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Brave TV Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $110,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1513 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Brave TV Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $68,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1514 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Brave TV Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018- 19 which shows that Brave TV Pty Ltd was awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $178,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1515 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Capire consultancy expenditure of $90,263: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — 6 March 2020 42

(a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1516 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Capire contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Capire was awarded one consultancy contract of $90,263: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1517 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Carfi consultancy expenditure of $94,534: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1518 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Carfi contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Carfi was awarded one consultancy contract of $94,534: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1519 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Centre for International Economics consultancy expenditure of $306,989: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

6 March 2020 43

1520 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Centre for International Economics contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Centre for International Economics was awarded one consultancy contract of $306,989: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1521 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Christopher Jordan Architecture and Design consultancy expenditure of $58,182: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1522 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Christopher Jordan Architecture and Design contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Christopher Jordan Architecture and Design was awarded one consultancy contract of $58,182: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1523 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Civinfra Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $479,300: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1524 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Civinfra Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Civinfra Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $479,300: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — 6 March 2020 44

(a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1525 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the CLE Consulting Australia consultancy expenditure of $45,418: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1526 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to CLE Consulting Australia contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that CLE Consulting Australia was awarded one consultancy contract of $45,418: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1527 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Clear Horizons Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $90,195: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1528 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Clear Horizons Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $61,046: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and 6 March 2020 45

(b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1529 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Clear Horizons Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $43,340: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1530 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation Clear Horizons Consulting Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Clear Horizons Consulting Pty Ltd was awarded three consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $194,581: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1531 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Clockwork Projects and Events consultancy expenditure of $149,036: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1532 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Clockwork Projects and Events contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Clockwork Projects and Events was awarded one consultancy contract of $149,036: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded. 6 March 2020 46

1533 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Coffey Services Australia Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $86,364: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract. 1534 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Coffey Services Australia Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $22,674: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1535 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Coffey Services Australia Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Coffey Services Australia Pty Ltd was awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $109,083: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1536 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Colere Group Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $210,910: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract. 6 March 2020 47

1537 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Colere Group Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Colere Group Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $210,910: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1538 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Corrs Chambers Westgarth consultancy expenditure of $16,500: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1539 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Corrs Chambers Westgarth consultancy expenditure of $15,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1540 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Corrs Chambers Westgarth contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Corrs Chambers Westgarth was awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $31,500: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1541 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the CPSU SPSF Group Victorian Branch consultancy expenditure of $50,000: 6 March 2020 48

(1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1542 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to CPSU SPSF Group Victorian Branch contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that CPSU SPSF Group Victorian Branch was awarded one consultancy contract of $50,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1543 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Crossbow Consulting Services consultancy expenditure of $13,275: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1544 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Crossbow Consulting Services contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Crossbow Consulting Services was awarded one consultancy contract of $13,275: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1545 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the CSIRO consultancy expenditure of $220,617: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. 6 March 2020 49

(4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1546 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the CSIRO consultancy expenditure of $85,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1547 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to CSIRO contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that CSIRO was awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $305,617: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1548 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Cube Group Management Consulting (Australia) Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $151,450: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1549 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Cube Group Management Consulting (Australia) Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $90,625: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. 6 March 2020 50

1550 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation Cube Group Management Consulting (Australia) Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Cube Group Management Consulting (Australia) Pty Ltd was awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $212,075: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1551 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deakin University consultancy expenditure of $135,627: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1552 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Deakin University contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018- 19 which shows that Deakin University was awarded one consultancy contract of $135,627: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1553 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Access Economics Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $149,960: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and 6 March 2020 51

1554 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Access Economics Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $81,411: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1555 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Deloitte Access Economics Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Deloitte Access Economics Pty Ltd was awarded two consultancy contracts of $231,371: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1556 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu consultancy expenditure of $2,721,970: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1557 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu consultancy expenditure of $571,001: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — 6 March 2020 52

1558 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu consultancy expenditure of $409,091: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1559 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu consultancy expenditure of $147,682: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1560 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu consultancy expenditure of $131,557: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

6 March 2020 53

1561 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu consultancy expenditure of $70,650: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1562 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu consultancy expenditure of $22,727: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1563 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu was awarded seven consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $4,074,678: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1564 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Donald Cant Watts Corke (Infrastructure) Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $996,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money.

6 March 2020 54

1565 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Donald Cant Watts Corke (Infrastructure) Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Donald Cant Watts Corke (Infrastructure) Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $996,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1566 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Earl Brand Space consultancy expenditure of $188,788: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1567 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Earl Brand Space contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018- 19 which shows that Earl Brand Space was awarded one consultancy contract of $188,788: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1568 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Effective Change Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $107,100: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

6 March 2020 55

1569 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Effective Change Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Effective Change Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $107,100: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1570 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Ernst & Young consultancy expenditure of $1,814,637: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1571 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Ernst & Young consultancy expenditure of $1,705,419: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1572 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Ernst & Young consultancy expenditure of $530,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract. 6 March 2020 56

1573 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Ernst & Young consultancy expenditure of $20,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1574 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Ernst & Young contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Ernst & Young was awarded four consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $4,070,056: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1575 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Essential Economics Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $25,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1576 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Essential Economics Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Essential Economics Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $25,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1577 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Eyres and Associates consultancy expenditure of $18,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. 6 March 2020 57

1578 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Eyres and Associates contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Eyres and Associates was awarded one consultancy contract of $18,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1579 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Federation University Australia consultancy expenditure of $18,182: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1580 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Federation University Australia contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Federation University Australia was awarded one consultancy contract of $18,182: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1581 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the First Point Consulting consultancy expenditure of $20,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and 6 March 2020 58

1582 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to First Point Consulting contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that First Point Consulting was awarded one consultancy contract of $20,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1583 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Fishbowl PR consultancy expenditure of $24,998: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1584 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Fishbowl PR contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Fishbowl PR was awarded one consultancy contract of $24,998: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1585 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the FPL Advisory Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $22,500: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

6 March 2020 59

1586 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to FPL Advisory Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that FPL Advisory Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $22,500: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1587 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Galexia Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $69,030: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1588 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Galexia Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Galexia Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $69,030: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1589 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Geosim Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $18,181: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1590 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Geosim Consulting Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Geosim Consulting Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $18,181: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and 6 March 2020 60

(b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1591 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the GHD Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $424,070: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1592 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the GHD Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $68,950: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1593 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to GHD Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that GHD Pty Ltd was awarded two consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $493,020: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1594 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Gippsland Tech Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $100,000: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. 6 March 2020 61

1595 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Gippsland Tech Consulting Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Gippsland Tech Consulting Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $100,000: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1596 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Greenshot Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $53,019: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1597 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Greenshot Consulting Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Greenshot Consulting Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $53,019: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1598 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Grosvenor Management Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $104,744: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract. 6 March 2020 62

1599 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Grosvenor Management Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $46,037: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1600 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Grosvenor Management Consulting Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $19,090: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1601 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Grosvenor Management Consulting Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Grosvenor Management Consulting Pty Ltd was awarded three consultancy contracts with a combined fee of $169,871: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1602 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the GTA Consultants consultancy expenditure of $22,329: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. 6 March 2020 63

1603 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to GTA Consultants contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018- 19 which shows that GTA Consultants was awarded one consultancy contract of $22,329: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1604 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the consultancy expenditure shown in Appendix 9 of the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 and the Hillside Advisory Services Pty Ltd consultancy expenditure of $20,320: (1) What outcome of the needs identification process justified the purchase of consultancy services. (2) What needs were identified during the needs analysis of the procurement process. (3) What were the defined deliverables and outcomes of the procurement process. (4) Was the consultancy subject to a competitive tender process, and if not, why not, and if so — (a) how many bids were received; and (b) what evaluation criteria was used to evaluate each bid. (5) How was it established that the procurement delivered value for public money. (6) How were probity requirements maintained and conflicts of interests managed during the procurement and delivery phases of the consultancy. (7) What criteria was applied to evaluate delivery of the consultancy contract.

1605 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Hillside Advisory Services Pty Ltd contractors for 2018-19 and the Department of Transport Report, 2018-19 which shows that Hillside Advisory Services Pty Ltd was awarded one consultancy contract of $20,320: (1) Were any consultancy contracts of less than $10,000 awarded, and if so — (a) how many; and (b) what is the total approved project fee for each consultancy. (2) Have any contractor contracts been awarded, and if so, what is the total approved project fee for each contractor contract awarded.

1606 MRS MCARTHUR — To ask the Minister for Agriculture: In relation to the registration of dogs and cats required by the Domestic Animals Act 1994 and administered by the Department of Jobs, Precincts and Regions, what is the total number of registrations across all local councils in the last three years for — (a) dogs; and (b) cats.

1608 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In 2019, did the Minister or any of the Minister’s staff meet with John Woodman, and if so — (a) on what dates; (b) with whom; (c) for what purpose; and (d) were notetakers from the department responsible for transport present.

1609 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In 2018, did the Minister or any of the Minister’s staff meet with John Woodman, and if so — (a) on what dates; (b) with whom; 6 March 2020 64

1610 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In 2017, did the Minister or any of the Minister’s staff meet with John Woodman, and if so — (a) on what dates; (b) with whom; (c) for what purpose; and (d) were notetakers from the department responsible for transport present.

1611 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In 2016, did the Minister or any of the Minister’s staff meet with John Woodman, and if so — (a) on what dates; (b) with whom; (c) for what purpose; and (d) were notetakers from the department responsible for transport present.

1612 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In 2015, did the Minister or any of the Minister’s staff meet with John Woodman, and if so — (a) on what dates; (b) with whom; (c) for what purpose; and (d) were notetakers from the department responsible for transport present.

1613 MR LIMBRICK — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): In relation to the Justice Legislation Amendment (Police and Other Matters) Act 2019: How many times have the DNA seizing powers in the Justice Legislation Amendment (Police and Other Matters) Act 2019 been used.

1614 MR LIMBRICK — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): In relation to the sniffer dog operation at the By the Bay 2020 – Bayside Beach Festival on 11 January 2020: (1) How many — (a) searches were conducted; (b) positive detections were found; (c) strip searches were conducted; and (d) people were charged for possession. (2) What was the total cost of the operation.

1615 MR GRIMLEY — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Education): In relation to the National School Chaplaincy Program in Victorian government schools: (1) Have any organisations with contractual provider agreements failed to comply with the terms of their agreements, and if so — (a) how many complaints have the Department of Education and Training received in 2019; and (b) what actions were taken in response to those complaints. (2) What action does the Department of Education and Training take to eliminate discrimination within the operation of Program.

1616 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads: In relation to the Minister’s answer to Question on Notice No. 1041: What assessment criteria was undertaken to ensure that large advertising signs are not a distraction to drivers on Victorian roads.

1617 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the new Federal Court ruling protecting the Indigenous sacred trees on the proposed Western Highway extension: Will the Government rethink this project.

6 March 2020 65

1619 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the Australasian Bittern, a Commonwealth endangered species: What is the Minister doing to protect and relocate the species which will be greatly affected by the proposed Mordialloc Freeway extension.

1620 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Education): In relation to Victoria being the only state that does not have a dedicated police-in-schools program: Will the Minister advise if this program is something the Government will look at introducing.

1623 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the World Health Organisation stating that the only safe level of particle pollution is zero and noting that the North East Link truck numbers will increase from 6,000 per day to 21,000 per day plus an increase of 80,000 cars: How does the Government propose to prevent serious adverse health consequences caused by the increased particle pollution near homes, schools, kindergartens and sporting precincts.

1624 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Agriculture: In relation to the Minister’s answer to Question on Notice No. 815 and noting the Minister stated that there are six species of duck which have increased in numbers since 2017: Which are the six species.

1625 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Agriculture: In relation to the Minister’s answer to a Question on Notice stating that cruelty in duck shooting is being addressed: Is the Minister aware of findings by ballistics experts that at least one in four birds are not killed outright, noting that computer simulations have shown the figure could be as high as one in two, and if so, how is it possible to address animal cruelty issues.

1626 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Agriculture: What public consultation has taken place with landholders adjacent to public waterways around Victoria where unmonitored duck shooting is permitted.

1627 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the widening of the Western Highway to accommodate a seven-fold increase in traffic, from 6,000 vehicles per day to 40,000 at capacity, and noting that forecasts for growth are approximately two per cent increase per year: (1) Does the Minister believe this project is excessive for the state’s current and future needs. (2) Has this project been designed to accommodate Victoria’s rapid excessive population growth.

1628 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: In relation to the Can-Am Spyder, a three-wheeled motorcycle which has a single rear drive wheel and two wheels in front for steering and lacks the essential elements of a car: Why does VicRoads classify the Can-Am Spyder as a light motor vehicle, that is a car with a body type of a tri-car, rather than a motorcycle.

1629 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: In relation to the VicRoads classification of the Can-Am Spyder as a motor vehicle for registration purposes: Why is the operator of this type of vehicle required to obtain a motorcycle licence.

1630 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: In relation to the Towards Zero campaign where raised intersections were identified as one type of the safety features that are being installed to improve the safety of intersections across Victoria: (1) How many high-risk intersections were identified under this program. (2) What intersections that were identified as high risk, were installed with a raised intersection in 2019. 6 March 2020 66

(3) What high risk intersections have been identified for installation of a raised intersection in 2020.

1631 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: In relation to the Towards Safer Speeds Challenge, which provides one-off grants of up to $50,000 to support the development and implantation of new, creative and innovative approaches to address safer speeds at a community level: (1) How many grants were awarded under this scheme. (2) What is the total cost of grants awarded. (3) Of the grants awarded, what initiatives have been implemented.

1632 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: How many road issues have been reported to VicRoads via the ‘Report a Road Issue’ section of the VicRoads website in the following calendar years — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1634 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: How many road issues have been reported to VicRoads via the ‘Snap Send Solve’ application in the following calendar years — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1635 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the Government announcement on 26 May 2019 relating to the commencement of the dental vans program to schools in Box Hill, Barwon South, Cranbourne and Wodonga: Of the schools visited in term four of 2019: (1) What percentage of students received a check-up. (2) What percentage of students received treatment.

1636 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to a media release in August 2019 relating to the dental vans program and the statement that there would be 22 schools included in the initial roll out of the program, and noting that only 19 schools were listed at the end of the media release: Can the Minister confirm the three schools that were not listed.

1637 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the dental vans program, can the Minister provide a breakdown of the qualifications and the experience required for the following treatment staff — (a) dentists; (b) oral hygienists; (c) therapists; and (d) student dentists.

1638 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the dental vans program, how many of the following treatment staff have been employed as — (a) dentists; (b) oral hygienists; 6 March 2020 67

1639 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the dental vans program, what is the average remuneration for each of the following treatment staff — (a) dentists; (b) oral hygienists; (c) therapists; and (d) student dentists.

1640 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the dental vans program: Have all employees received a current Working With Children check.

1641 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the dental vans program: How many phone calls from treatment staff were made to parents relating to their children requiring further dental care action.

1642 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the dental vans program: How many parents received written communication from treatment staff relating to their children requiring further dental care action.

1643 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the Government’s dental van proof of concept: (1) Have any program or dental staff made a mandatory report to the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) under section 184 of the Children Youth and Families Act 2005 as a result of treating children within this program, and if so, how many reports were made. (2) Does DHHS have a policy in place for working alongside the Department of Education and Training in managing these types of situations.

1644 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the Minister’s answer to Question on Notice No. 1043 of 27 November 2019 regarding the dental van proof of concept and the statement that 24 schools had been visited in Barwon South, Cranbourne, Box Hill and Wodonga South in term three: Can the Minister list the schools visited.

1645 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the total number of schools eligible to be visited by the dental van proof of concept program: How many schools declined to take part in the program in — (a) Barwon South; (b) Box Hill; (c) Cranbourne; and (d) Wodonga South.

1646 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Alfred Health.

1647 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Austin Health.

1648 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 6 March 2020 68

February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Calvary Health Care Bethlehem.

1649 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Melbourne Health.

1650 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Mercy Hospitals Victoria Limited.

1651 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Monash Health.

1652 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Northern Health.

1653 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Peninsula Health.

1654 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to The Royal Children’s Hospital.

1655 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to The Royal Women’s Hospital.

1656 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to St Vincent’s Hospital Melbourne Limited.

1657 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Western Health.

1658 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Barwon Health.

1659 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Casterton Memorial Hospital. 6 March 2020 69

1660 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Colac Area Health.

1661 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Great Ocean Road Health.

1662 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Hesse Rural Health Service.

1663 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Heywood Rural Health.

1664 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Moyne Health Service.

1665 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Portland District Health.

1666 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to South West Healthcare.

1667 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Terang and Mortlake Health Service.

1668 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Western District Health Service.

1669 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Bairnsdale Regional Health Service.

1670 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Bass Coast Health.

6 March 2020 70

1671 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Central Gippsland Health Service.

1672 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Gippsland Southern Health Service.

1673 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Kooweerup Regional Health Service. 1674 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Latrobe Regional Hospital.

1675 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Omeo District Health.

1676 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to South Gippsland Hospital.

1677 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to West Gippsland Healthcare Group.

1678 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Yarram and District Health Service.

1679 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Ballarat Health Services.

1680 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Djerriwarrh Health Services.

1681 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to South Gippsland Hospital.

1682 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 6 March 2020 71

February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to East Grampians Health Service.

1683 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to East Wimmera Health Service.

1684 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Edenhope and District Memorial Hospital.

1685 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Hepburn Health Service.

1686 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Rural Northwest Health.

1687 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Stawell Regional Health.

1688 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to West Wimmera Health Service.

1689 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Wimmera Health Care Group.

1690 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Albury Wodonga Health.

1691 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Office, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Alexandra District Health.

1692 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Beechworth Health Service.

1693 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Benalla Health. 6 March 2020 72

1694 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Goulburn Valley Health.

1695 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Mansfield District Hospital.

1696 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to NCN Health.

1697 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Northeast Health Wangaratta.

1698 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Seymour Health.

1699 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Tallangatta Health Service.

1700 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Kilmore and District Hospital. 1701 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Yarrawonga Health.

1702 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Yea and District Memorial Hospital.

1703 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Bendigo Health.

1704 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Boort District Health.

1705 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 6 March 2020 73

February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Castlemaine Health.

1706 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Cohuna District Hospital.

1707 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Echuca Regional Health.

1708 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Heathcote Health.

1709 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Inglewood and Districts Health Service.

1710 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Kerang District Health Service.

1711 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Kyabram District Health Service.

1712 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Kyneton District Health Service.

1713 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Maldon Hospital.

1714 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Maryborough District Health Service.

1715 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Mildura Base Hospital.

1716 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Rochester and Elmore District Health Service. 6 March 2020 74

1717 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the public health warning from Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Dr Brett Sutton, on 6 January 2020: Between 6 January to 4 February 2020, what were the number of lung disease, asthma, heart disease and other respiratory related admissions to Swan Hill District Health.

1718 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the total number of Ambulance Victoria callouts in the Gippsland region on each day between 31 December 2019 to 15 January 2020, inclusive.

1719 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: What were the total number of Ambulance Victoria callouts in the Hume region on each day between 31 December 2019 to 15 January 2020, inclusive.

1720 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 31 December 2019 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1721 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 1 January 2020 — How many were transported to an emergency department. (a) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (b) how many were treated on site.

1722 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 2 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1723 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 3 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1724 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 4 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1725 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 5 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1726 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 6 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site. 6 March 2020 75

1727 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 7 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1728 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 8 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1729 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 9 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1730 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 10 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1731 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 11 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1732 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 12 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1733 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 13 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1734 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 14 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site.

1735 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to respiratory related illness: Of the callouts in Victoria for respiratory related illness on 15 January 2020 — (a) how many were transported to an emergency department; (b) how many were referred to a general practitioner; and (c) how many were treated on site. 6 March 2020 76

1736 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to Bairnsdale Regional Health Service.

1737 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to Bass Coast Health.

1738 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to Central Gippsland Health Service.

1739 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to Gippsland Southern Health Service.

1740 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to Kooweerup Regional Health Service.

1741 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to Latrobe Regional Hospital.

1742 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to Omeo District Health.

1743 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to South Gippsland Hospital.

1744 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to West Gippsland Healthcare Group.

1745 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to P2 masks: How many P2 masks were provided to Yarram and District Health Service.

1746 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to Working with Children checks: What has the Department of Health and Human Services done to ensure that all employees in Victoria’s state health system have up-to-date Working with Children checks.

1747 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the 3AW report on 24 January 2020 that Working with Children checks are not required to work at a major hospitals: Will the Department of Health and Human Services be conducting an audit to verify this claim.

1748 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the Novel Coronavirus (2019- nCoV): What advice has the Department of Health and Human Services received in relation to the case of Coronavirus in Victoria.

1749 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to the Novel Coronavirus (2019- nCoV) originating in Wuhan, China: (1) What is the Government doing to ensure the virus does not spread throughout Victoria. (2) What advice has the Department of Health and Human Services received from — (a) the Commonwealth Government; (b) other state governments; (c) the World Health Organisation; and (d) other public health entities. (3) Has the Government allocated any funding to implement preventative measures to stop the spread of the virus.

1750 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to The Royal Children’s Hospital Gender Service: Of the 325 referrals to the hospital from the 21 September 2018 to 21 September 2019, how many patients saw a — 6 March 2020 77

(a) clinical nurse consultant; (b) psychologist; (c) psychiatrist; (d) speech pathologist; (e) mental health nurse; (f) paediatrician; and (g) paediatric endocrinologist.

1751 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to The Royal Children’s Hospital Gender Service: Of the 228 referrals to the hospital as at 11 September 2018, how many patients saw a — (a) clinical nurse consultant; (b) psychologist; (c) psychiatrist; (d) speech pathologist; (e) mental health nurse; (f) paediatrician; and (g) paediatric endocrinologist.

1752 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to The Royal Children’s Hospital Gender Service: Of the 253 referrals to the hospital as at 11 September 2017, how many patients saw a — (a) clinical nurse consultant; (b) psychologist; (c) psychiatrist; (d) speech pathologist; (e) mental health nurse; (f) paediatrician; and (g) paediatric endocrinologist.

1753 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to The Royal Children’s Hospital Gender Service: Of the 226 referrals to the hospital as at 11 September 2016, how many patients saw a — (a) clinical nurse consultant; (b) psychologist; (c) psychiatrist; (d) speech pathologist; (e) mental health nurse; (f) paediatrician; and (g) paediatric endocrinologist.

1754 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to The Royal Children’s Hospital Gender Service: Of the 170 referrals to the hospital as at 11 September 2015, how many patients saw a — (a) clinical nurse consultant; (b) psychologist; (c) psychiatrist; (d) speech pathologist; (e) mental health nurse; (f) paediatrician; and (g) paediatric endocrinologist.

6 March 2020 78

1755 MS CROZIER — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to The Royal Children’s Hospital Gender Service: Of the 104 referrals to the hospital as at 11 September 2014, how many patients saw a — (a) clinical nurse consultant; (b) psychologist; (c) psychiatrist; (d) speech pathologist; (e) mental health nurse; (f) paediatrician; and (g) paediatric endocrinologist.

(Notice received 6 February 2020)

1756 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the North East Link project: Why is the North East Link failing to comply with the Project Scoping Requirements for Road Traffic Noise for the day time and night time, therefore adversely impacting on the health of most of the 8,000 residences along the North East Link route.

1757 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the North East Link project: (1) Given that all three affected local councils who represent close to one million people do not want the North East Link project to go ahead in its current format, why will the Government not listen to the opposition to Option A of the North East Link. (2) Will the Minister consider the significant issues raised by local council which warrants changes to this project. (3) Is the Minister aware of the negative consequences on most of the 20,000 dwellings located within 500 metres of this project that were raised in the Public Place document titled Overview of Social Impacts of the North East Link Project.

1758 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the Minister’s answer to a Constituency Question on 12 September 2019 stating that “Mr O’Brien has no experience in freeway design”: Has the Minister seen Mr O’Brien’s extensive resume which spans 45 years in transport planning and traffic engineering.

1759 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the compulsory acquisition of 36 homes and 96 businesses that is a requirement of Option A of the North East Link project: Does the Minister understand the impact that the North East Link will have on local families who have children at local schools and connections to the neighborhood, as well as businesses who survive on their local customer service base.

1760 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to Option A of the North East Link project: (1) How does the Minister plan to rehome all of the wildlife displaced by the removal of 20 per cent of the Koonung Creek Reserve and parts of Bulleen Park. (2) How will the 25,000 trees removed for this project and the over 52 hectares of lost open space be replaced.

1761 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to Option A of the North East Link project: (1) Is the Minister aware of the impact of Option A of the North East Link on the 100,000 people who use the Boroondara Tennis Centre annually, as well as the Bulleen Swim Centre, Freeway Golf course and parts of the Carey Grammar sporting complex. (2) How will the Minister combat the social impact on local sporting clubs with the loss of club space in the area.

6 March 2020 79

1762 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the North East Link project and the environmental impact assessment process where an independent panel was appointed to advise on the environmental acceptability of the project: Why is the Minister dismissing the recommendations of the independent panel who found that, after a nine week hearing of over 50 expert witnesses, the project is not environmentally acceptable unless significant changes are made.

1763 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): In relation to the Country Fire Authority (CFA): (1) Is the Minister able to address the ongoing insufficient level of ongoing funding for the CFA’s capital budget. (2) Is the Minister able to consider planning for continuous funding to replace ageing assets, rather than single year grants or one-off project funding that prevents the CFA from being able to establish or plan for long-term sustainable asset replacement. (3) Is the CFA able to get funding to the same high standards as other fire services in Victoria. (4) Do CFA volunteers have the same legal rights and protections as employees, given the high risk in their jobs, and if not, is there a system that could be introduced to support these volunteers.

1764 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): In relation to the Country Fire Authority (CFA), and noting the stories of volunteers emerging as heroes with the current bushfire crisis, and further noting that these volunteers are dissatisfied with the training arrangements they are receiving as well as exhausted from having to ‘rattle tins’ to fundraise for their areas in between fighting fires for extended periods: Is the Minister looking into better support services for the CFA and their volunteer network to improve volunteer numbers.

1765 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to the bushfire risk to schools in the Southern Green Wedge, and noting school closure dates with total fire bans and inappropriate sites being considered: Will the Minister consider adding bushfire risk as something that must be considered when new school and church planning applications are received.

1766 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the removal of a number of 100-year-old trees at Moreland Railway Station for the Level Crossing Removal Project: (1) Is the Minister aware that Moreland has one of the lowest rates of tree canopy cover in Victoria at just 14 per cent. (2) Does the Minister accept the advice of climate scientists that Melbourne is getting hotter and will need more, rather than less, tree canopy cover to protect its residents from excessive heat. (3) Did the Government examine advice from an Upfield Corridor Coalition Civil Engineer that the Level Crossing Removal Project could be completed without the need for the removal of large, old trees. (4) Has the Minister sought advice on how long it will take the replacement seedlings to provide a similar benefit to that of the trees the project has removed in terms of shade, wildlife habitat, and the physical and mental health of local residents.

(Notice received 18 February 2020)

1768 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to the admission made by the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning (DELWP) in its letter of 20 January 2020 'that DELWP became aware in September/October 2018 that the use of land in the Public Conservation and Resource Zone for commercial racehorse training may be prohibited’: (1) Is the Minister aware of this admission. 6 March 2020 80

(2) Will the Minister remove the amendment to the planning laws that permits commercial racehorse training in the Belfast Coastal Reserve.

1769 MR HAYES — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): In relation to the admission made by the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning (DELWP) in its letter of 20 January 2020 ‘that DELWP became aware in September/October 2018 that the use of land in the Public Conservation and Resource Zone for commercial racehorse training may be prohibited’: (1) Is the Minister aware of this admission. (2) Will the Minister review the Belfast Coastal Reserve Management Plan, as a matter of urgency, in order to protect the internationally significant Cultural Landscape between Moyjil and Budj Bim in South West Victoria.

1770 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Frankston line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1771 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Cranbourne line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1772 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Pakenham line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station. 6 March 2020 81

1773 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Lilydale line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1774 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Sunbury line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1775 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Glen Waverley line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1776 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Belgrave line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. 6 March 2020 82

(9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1777 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Craigieburn line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1778 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Werribee line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1779 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Upfield line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1780 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Williamstown line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. 6 March 2020 83

(6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1781 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Mernda line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1782 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Stony Point line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1783 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Sandringham line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1784 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Hurstbridge line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. 6 March 2020 84

(3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1785 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Alamein line over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage by station. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries by station. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries by station on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries by station. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak by station. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak by station. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak by station. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak by station. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late by station.

1786 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the Train Station Entry Reports for the Metro rail network over the period of 2015-2019: For each financial year between 2015 and 2019: (1) What is the estimated annual patronage. (2) What is the estimated average weekday entries. (3) What is the estimated average daily entries on a normal weekday. (4) What is the estimated average daily entries on a Saturday. (5) What is the estimated average daily entries on a Sunday. (6) What is the estimated average weekly entries. (7) What is the estimated weekday entries at pre-AM peak. (8) What is the estimated weekday entries at AM peak. (9) What is the estimated weekday entries at interpeak. (10) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM peak. (11) What is the estimated weekday entries at PM late.

1787 MR HAYES — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): In relation to the Minister’s response to Question on Notice No. 1128: When will the next stage of restorations specific to the Chalet homestead be completed and is there a plan to reopen the homestead as a hotel.

1788 MR HAYES — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): How will the Government meet Western Grassland Reserve targets by 2020 and has there ever been any detailed economic analysis of this program done.

1789 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): In relation to the Interim Report 2, published by the Victorian Bushfires Royal Commission in 2009, calling for an approved standard design for private householder bushfire shelters, and noting that this standard was established before the Royal Commission’s final report in July 2010: (1) What programs have been set in place since 2009 to publish the importance of community understanding of the safety advantages of a private bushfire shelter of an approved design. 6 March 2020 85

(2) Has there been any assistance, such as low or no interest loans, given for the installation of private shelters for households in fire risk areas. (3) Given that a CSIRO report rates approved private shelters as a highly effective life-saving strategy, why are these important life protection measures not mandated for new homes in high fire risk areas.

1790 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Small Business: Is the Minister aware that over 80 shopfronts on the street level alone are closed along Chapel Street at present, and if so, is the Minister looking at ways to address this issue with retail trading.

1791 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Water): In relation to the Victorian wetlands on the Ramsar Convention’s List of Wetlands of International Importance: (1) What action has the Government taken to protect the wetlands in Victoria. (2) Are the wetlands signposted so that visitors can identify that they are visiting a Ramsar listed wetland.

1792 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Water): In relation to the tabled answer to Question on Notice No. 383 which referred to ‘implementation of onground actions at Ramsar sites’: Who decides what actions are undertaken and who implements these actions.

1793 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Water): In relation to recommendations 2 and 3 in the Auditor-General’s Report on Meeting Obligations to Protect Ramsar Wetlands, September 2016: What action has been taken to implement these recommendations.

1794 MR HAYES — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Assistant Treasurer): In relation to the state-owned land near Glen Waverley Railway Station, between O’Sullivan Road, Railway Parade North and Euneva Avenue: Is this land earmarked for sale by the Government, and if so, has the Minister taken into account its importance in the proposed Suburban Rail Loop.

1795 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: How many drivers, who have resided in Victoria for a period of six months or more, have been fined by Victoria Police for driving on a non-Victorian licence in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1796 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: How many drivers, who have resided in Victoria for a period of six months or more, have been fined by Victoria Police for driving on an overseas licence in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1797 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: How many drivers have been fined by Victoria Police for driving whilst their licence has been disqualified in another jurisdiction in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

6 March 2020 86

1798 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: How many drivers have been fined by Victoria Police for driving whilst their licence has been suspended in another jurisdiction in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1799 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: How many drivers have been fined by Victoria Police for driving whilst their licence has been disqualified in another country in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1800 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Roads: How many drivers have been fined by Victoria Police for driving whilst their licence has been suspended in another country in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1801 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Housing): How many people, within the City of Greater Dandenong, were registered on the Victorian Housing Register in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1802 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Housing): How many people within the City of Greater Dandenong, who were registered on the Victorian Housing Register, were provided housing in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1803 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Housing): How many people, within the City of Greater Dandenong, contacted the Health and Human Services 24-hour statewide toll number, 1800 825 955, seeking help for crisis accommodation due to their homelessness in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1804 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Housing): How many people, within the City of Greater Dandenong, who sought help for homelessness by contacting the Health and Human Services 24-hour statewide toll number, 1800 825 955, were provided crisis accommodation in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019. 1805 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Housing): How many people, within the City of Greater Dandenong, have sought assistance from WAYSS Ltd for government housing in — 6 March 2020 87

1806 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Housing): How many people, within the City of Greater Dandenong, have sought assistance from WAYSS Ltd for crisis accommodation due to homelessness in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1807 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Housing): How many people, within the City of Greater Dandenong, have utilised the Launch Housing Dandenong (Bob’s Place) crisis accommodation site in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1808 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Housing): How many people, within the City of Greater Dandenong, have utilised the Launch Housing Dandenong (Bob’s Place) Rough Sleepers Initiative in — (a) 2016; (b) 2017; (c) 2018; and (d) 2019.

1809 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): What is Victoria Police’s average whole of life lease cost budgeted for each of the BMW 530d vehicles.

1810 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): What is Victoria Police’s average whole of life lease cost budgeted for each of the Volkswagen Passat Turbo vehicles.

1811 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): Why did Victoria Police elect to purchase 79 of the more expensive BMW 530d vehicles, given that both the BMW 530d and the Volkswagen Passat Turbo vehicles meet Victoria Police’s criteria for general duties and highway patrol work, including pursuit duties.

1812 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): Following the 12 months loan to Victoria Police of the BMW M5, will these vehicles be purchased instead of the current BMW 530d vehicles.

1813 MR RICH-PHILLIPS — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): What high performance vehicles other than the BMW 530d and Volkswagen Passat Turbo is Victoria Police leasing for their fleet.

1814 MR O'DONOHUE — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Corrections): In relation to orders for costs made by the court against Corrections Victoria for the failure to present prisoners to court from 14 September 2019 to 31 January 2020 — (a) how many orders for costs have been made by the court; and (b) what is the total quantum of these orders.

6 March 2020 88

1815 MR O'DONOHUE — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): How many female prisoners were held in police cells at 7.00 a.m. on — (a) 31 August 2018; (b) 30 September 2018; (c) 30 June 2019; (d) 31 July 2019; (e) 31 August 2019; (f) 30 September 2019; (g) 31 October 2019; (h) 30 November 2019; (i) 31 December 2019; and (j) 31 January 2020.

1816 MR O'DONOHUE — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): How many male prisoners were held in police cells at 7.00 a.m. on — (a) 31 August 2018; (b) 30 September 2018; (c) 30 June 2019; (d) 31 July 2019; (e) 31 August 2019; (f) 30 September 2019; (g) 31 October 2019; (h) 30 November 2019; (i) 31 December 2019; and (j) 31 January 2020.

1817 MR O'DONOHUE — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Minister for Police and Emergency Services): How many people in Victoria had their identities stolen in — (a) 2015; (b) 2016; (c) 2017; (d) 2018; and (e) 2019.

(Notice received 19 February 2020)

1818 MS MAXWELL — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Attorney-General): In relation to the Coghlan Review, established in 2017 to advise the Government on how Victoria’s bail system should be reformed to best manage risk and to maximise community safety: (1) Which of the 37 recommendations of the Coghlan Review did the Government — (a) reject; (b) accept in full; and (c) accept in principle. (2) Which of the recommendations were accepted in full and have been wholly implemented. (3) Which of the recommendations were accepted in full but have not been wholly implemented and why. (4) Has the Government wholly implemented any of the recommendations that it accepted in principle, and if so, which ones. (5) Has the Government only partly implemented any of the recommendations that it accepted in principle, and if so, which ones. (6) Have any of the recommendations that were accepted in principle still not been implemented in any way by the Government, and if so, which ones. (7) Has the Government implemented Recommendation 37, and if not, what are the reasons for that decision. 6 March 2020 89

(8) How can a member of the public access, at any time, the most up-to-date report of the Government’s progress in implementing each of the recommendations of the Review.

1819 MS MAXWELL — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Attorney-General): In relation to meetings within the Attorney-General’s portfolio: (1) Since 1 January 2015 inclusive, on what dates have there been meetings of the — (a) Criminal Justice System Steering Committee; (b) Hate Crime Review Working Group; and (c) Bail Steering Committee. (2) Were formal minutes of any of the meetings in paragraph (1) taken, and if so, for which meetings and how can copies of these minutes be accessed by members of the public.

1820 MS MAXWELL — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Attorney-General): In relation to a $28.8 million commitment referenced in the 2019-2020 Budget Overview, aimed at decreasing re-offending and keeping communities safe with programs targeting young people at risk within the Attorney-General’s portfolio: (1) Given that they pertain to the Bail Access Program and the Bail and Remand Court, have these initiatives subsequently decreased the time spent by Victorians on remand, and, if so, by how much. (2) What have been the outcomes since the inception of the Court Integrated Services Program (CISP), in particular in Northern Victoria. (3) Which organisations provide CISP to offenders.

1821 MS MAXWELL — To ask the Minister for Training and Skills (for the Attorney-General): In relation to the incarceration of Indigenous people in Victoria: (1) Since 2014, how many different programs has the Government administered that have been directly aimed at reducing the number of Indigenous people incarcerated in Victoria, and — (a) what are the names of each of these programs; and (b) what has been the total funding allocated to each of these programs, per financial year. (2) What was the total number of Indigenous people in incarceration in Victoria at 1 January 2015. (3) What was the total number of Indigenous people in incarceration in Victoria at 20 February 2020.

1822 MS MAXWELL — To ask the Minister for Agriculture: In relation to the ‘Engage youth in invasive species management’ initiative in Wangaratta under the Weeds and Rabbits Project: Will there be any trips by the participants to farming areas and national parks in the Shire of Wangaratta to look at the number of weeds and potential implementation of a control measure, in particular for the Paterson’s Curse.

1823 MS MAXWELL — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to rail replacement coach services on the North East Railway line: (1) How many individual compensation payments were issued to passengers on that line in respect of delays to V/Line services during — (a) 2014; (b) 2015; (c) 2016; (d) 2017; (e) 2018; (f) 2019; and (g) 2020. (2) What has been the total amount of compensation payments issued to passengers on that line in respect of delays to V/Line services during — (a) 2014; (b) 2015; 6 March 2020 90

(c) 2016; (d) 2017; (e) 2018; (f) 2019; and (g) 2020. (3) During the period from 1 January 2014 to the day on which this answer is provided, what have been the — (a) five travel dates in respect of which the highest total compensation payments were issued to passengers in respect of delays to V/Line services; and (b) what were the total amounts of compensation payments issued to passengers in respect of delays to V/Line services for each of these five dates, respectively.

1824 MR QUILTY — To ask the Minister for Health: In relation to Community Emergency Response volunteers with first aid training, but who are not paramedics, enlisted by the Government to address inadequate ambulance response times in Indigo Shire: For the last 12 months, what proportion of ambulances dispatched to patients in Indigo Shire were manned by paramedics.

(Notice received 3 March 2020)

1825 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows that 64,415 services were scheduled in January 2020 and that 57,426 of scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 6,989 were either cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 2,115 missing services out of the 6,989: (1) How are performances on cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the metro system. (2) For the January 2020 performance data — (a) why have 4,874 scheduled missing services not been accounted for; (b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 1,087 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 690 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the 233 bypasses reported; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the 105 station skips reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1826 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Alamein Line, 3,800 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 3,747 of scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 53 were either cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV shows that 93 services went missing: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Alamein Line. (2) Why does it appear that 40 more services were reported as cancelled, short trips, bypassed or skipped. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1827 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Belgrave Line, 3,380 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 3,227 of scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 153 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips, or failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 115 missing services out of the 153: 6 March 2020 91

(1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Belgrave Line. (2) For the January 2020 performance data on the Belgrave Line — (a) why have 38 scheduled missing services not been accounted for; (b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 40 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 45 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the 27 bypasses reported; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the three station skips reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1828 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Craigieburn Line, 3,840 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 3,741 of scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 99 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips, or failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV shows that 130 services went missing: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Craigieburn Line. (2) Why does it appear that 31 more services were reported as cancelled, short, bypassed or skipped. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1829 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Cranbourne Line, 3,515 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 2,441 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 1,074 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips, or failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 116 missing services out of the 1,074: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Cranbourne Line. (2) For the January 2020 performance data on the Cranbourne Line — (a) why have 958 scheduled missing services not been accounted for; (b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 86 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 10 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the 77 bypasses reported; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the three station skips reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1830 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Frankston Line, 5,746 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 3,344 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 2,402 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips, or failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 264 missing services out of the 2,402: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Frankston line. (2) For the January 2020 performance data on the Frankston Line — (a) why have 2,138 scheduled missing services not been accounted for; 6 March 2020 92

(b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 204 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 38 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the 17 bypasses reported; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the five station skips reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1831 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Glen Waverley Line, 4,245 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 4,197 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 48 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV shows that 118 services went missing: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Glen Waverley line. (2) Why does it appear that 70 more services were reported as cancelled, short services, bypassed or skipped. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1832 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Hurstbridge Line, 4,322 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 4,182 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 140 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or not delivered scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 88 missing services: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Hurstbridge Line. (2) For the January 2020 performance data on the Hurstbridge Line — (a) why have 52 scheduled missing services not been accounted for; (b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 34 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 52 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the one bypass reported; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the one station skip reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1833 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Lilydale Line, 5,231 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 4,968 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 263 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or not delivered scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV shows that 319 services went missing: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Glen Waverley line. (2) Why does it appear that 56 more services were reported as cancelled, short, bypassed or skipped. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1834 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Mernda Line, 4,460 services were scheduled in January 6 March 2020 93

2020 and 4,251 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 209 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or otherwise not delivered scheduled services, and also noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 140 missing services out of the 209: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Mernda line. (2) For the January 2020 performance data on the Mernda Line — (a) why have 69 scheduled missing services not been accounted for; (b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 47 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 86 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the five bypasses reported; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the two skips reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1835 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, shows that, for the Pakenham Line, 4,437 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 2,571 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 1,866 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or otherwise failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 246 missing services out of the 1,866: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Pakenham line. (2) For the January 2020 performance data on the Pakenham Line — (a) why have 1,620 scheduled missing services not been accounted; (b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 188 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 24 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the 32 bypasses report; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the two skips reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1836 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Sandringham Line, 4,868 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 4,700 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 168 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or otherwise failed to run scheduled services, and noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 105 missing services: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Sandringham Line. (2) For the January 2020 performance data on the Sandringham Line — (a) why have 63 scheduled missing services not been accounted for; (b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 65 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 37 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the two bypasses reported; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the one skipped service reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data. 6 March 2020 94

1837 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to Public Transport Victoria’s (PTV) Public transport monthly operational performance report, January 2020, that shows, for the Werribee Line, 5,575 services were scheduled in January 2020 and 5,256 of the scheduled services reached their destination, meaning that 319 were cancelled, short trips, bypasses, station skips or otherwise failed to run scheduled service, and noting that the data reported by PTV only accounts for 162 missing services: (1) How are cancelled, short trips, bypasses and station skips recorded on the Werribee Line. (2) For the January 2020 performance data on the Werribee Line — (a) why have 157 scheduled missing services not been accounted for; (b) how many additional services were cancelled and not reported in the 70 cancelled services reported; (c) how many additional short trips occurred and were not included in the 61 short services reported; (d) how many additional bypasses occurred and were not included in the 27 bypasses reported; and (e) how many additional station skips occurred and were not included in the four skipped service reported. (3) How accurate is the PTV performance data.

1838 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to funding for the Overland rail service: (1) What was the budget allocation and the actual payment made to the operator in 2018- 19. (2) What is the budget allocation to the operator in 2019-20. (3) What budget allocation per year over the forward estimates are in place to the operator.

1839 MRS MCARTHUR — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to the contaminated soil disposal from the West Gate Tunnel project: Prior to the project commencement, was the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning aware of the 2017 submission from the Environment Protection Authority Victoria that recommended that the West Gate Tunnel project address the management, treatment and disposal of PFAS-contaminated groundwater and land.

1840 MRS MCARTHUR — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to the contaminated soil disposal from the West Gate Tunnel project: Why have the nine technical impact assessments on the environmental, socio-economic, amenity and traffic impacts of the proposal to store, categorise and dispose of contaminated soil in Maddingley Brown Coal, not been made available to the public or the Moorabool Shire Council.

1841 MRS MCARTHUR — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to the reports from residents in the Maddingley and Bacchus Marsh area that trucks have been dumping materials on the Maddingley Brown Coal premises over the last three weeks, and noting that no official agreement has been made with Maddingley Brown Coal over the disposal of the PFAS-contaminated soil from the West Gate Tunnel project: What is the material that has been dumped and where is it coming from.

1842 MRS MCARTHUR — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to potential amendments to the Moorabool Planning Scheme under section 20(4) of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 to enable contaminated soil to be dumped at Maddingley Brown Coal: (1) Will the soil be classified according to the level of its hazard prior to the moving of the soil to the site, or upon its arrival. (2) What is the timeline being considered for the decision of whether an amendment is to be made. 6 March 2020 95

1843 MRS MCARTHUR — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to Maddingley Brown Coal’s website that states that the site is not licensed to accept asbestos contaminated waste: Given that reports suggest that the soil from the West Gate Tunnel project is not only contaminated with PFAS chemicals but also with asbestos, why is the Government considering Maddingley Brown Coal as a potential site for disposal.

1844 MRS MCARTHUR — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to the Maddingley Brown Coal site as a disposal site for the contaminated soil from the West Gate Tunnel project: (1) If soil is disposed of at the site, who will be responsible for the testing, storage and treatment of the soil. (2) Who would be liable for serious environmental or health consequences resulting from soil disposal at the site. (3) Have any alternative sites for contaminated soil disposal been considered that are not near residential areas. (4) Will the Bacchus Marsh and surrounding communities be guaranteed safety from contamination.

1845 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to the proposed 2-kilometre-long Upfield rail track: Why is the proposed track to be a ballasted track when Metro Trains Melbourne’s Engineering Standards for a bridge building mandates the use of ballastless tracks for elevated sections of rail greater than 500 metres in length.

1846 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to the proposed North East Link (NEL): (1) Why was a proper Air Quality State Environment Protection Policy study not completed as part of the Environment Effects Statement. (2) Does the Minister have modelled truck numbers for the night time. (3) Have the World Health Organisation’s 2009 road traffic night time noise scoping requirements for the NEL been breached with the proposal.

1847 MR HAYES — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): Are existing State Environment Protection Policy Air Quality limits being breached on the Eastern Freeway.

1848 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Agriculture: In relation to the areas that duck shooting is permitted: (1) What is the number of public lakes, rivers, wetlands, creeks, waterways and streams where shooting is allowed. (2) When will complete and accurate maps showing the permissible shooting areas be available to the public. (3) What is the minimum safety buffer distance from people’s homes that shooting is allowed.

1849 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Agriculture: Given that a distance of 30 metres appears to be in breach of the Firearm Safety Code, what studies or risk assessments have been carried out regarding the proximity of duck shooting to people’s homes.

1850 MR RICH-PHILLPS — To ask the Minister for Road Safety and the TAC: In relation to fatalities on Victorian roads: How many fatalities were recorded in a 40 km per hour speed zone during — (a) January 2019; (b) February 2019; (c) March 2019; (d) April 2019; (e) May 2019; 6 March 2020 96

(f) June 2019; (g) July 2019; (h) August 2019; (i) September 2019; (j) October 2019; (k) November 2019; and (l) December 2019.

1851 MR RICH-PHILLPS — To ask the Minister for Road Safety and the TAC: In relation to fatalities on Victorian roads: How many fatalities were recorded in a 50 km per hour speed zone during — (a) January 2019; (b) February 2019; (c) March 2019; (d) April 2019; (e) May 2019; (f) June 2019; (g) July 2019; (h) August 2019; (i) September 2019; (j) October 2019; (k) November 2019; and (l) December 2019.

1852 MR RICH-PHILLPS — To ask the Minister for Road Safety and the TAC: In relation to fatalities on Victorian roads: How many fatalities were recorded in a 60 km per hour speed zone during — (a) January 2019; (b) February 2019; (c) March 2019; (d) April 2019; (e) May 2019; (f) June 2019; (g) July 2019; (h) August 2019; (i) September 2019; (j) October 2019; (k) November 2019; and (l) December 2019.

1853 MR RICH-PHILLPS — To ask the Minister for Road Safety and the TAC: In relation to fatalities on Victorian roads: How many fatalities were recorded in a 70 km per hour speed zone during — (a) January 2019; (b) February 2019; (c) March 2019; (d) April 2019; (e) May 2019; (f) June 2019; (g) July 2019; (h) August 2019; (i) September 2019; (j) October 2019; (k) November 2019; and (l) December 2019.

6 March 2020 97

1854 MR RICH-PHILLPS — To ask the Minister for Road Safety and the TAC: In relation to fatalities on Victorian roads: How many fatalities were recorded in an 80 km per hour speed zone during — (a) January 2019; (b) February 2019; (c) March 2019; (d) April 2019; (e) May 2019; (f) June 2019; (g) July 2019; (h) August 2019; (i) September 2019; (j) October 2019; (k) November 2019; and (l) December 2019.

1855 MR RICH-PHILLPS — To ask the Minister for Road Safety and the TAC: In relation to fatalities on Victorian roads: How many fatalities were recorded in a 90 km per hour speed zone during — (a) January 2019; (b) February 2019; (c) March 2019; (d) April 2019; (e) May 2019; (f) June 2019; (g) July 2019; (h) August 2019; (i) September 2019; (j) October 2019; (k) November 2019; and (l) December 2019.

1856 MR RICH-PHILLPS — To ask the Minister for Road Safety and the TAC: In relation to fatalities on Victorian roads: How many fatalities were recorded in a 100 km per hour speed zone during — (a) January 2019; (b) February 2019; (c) March 2019; (d) April 2019; (e) May 2019; (f) June 2019; (g) July 2019; (h) August 2019; (i) September 2019; (j) October 2019; (k) November 2019; and (l) December 2019.

1857 MR RICH-PHILLPS — To ask the Minister for Road Safety and the TAC: In relation to fatalities on Victorian roads: How many fatalities were recorded in a 110 km per hour speed zone during — (a) January 2019; (b) February 2019; (c) March 2019; (d) April 2019; (e) May 2019; (f) June 2019; 6 March 2020 98

(g) July 2019; (h) August 2019; (i) September 2019; (j) October 2019; (k) November 2019; and (l) December 2019.

1858 MR DAVIS — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Public Transport): In relation to VicTrack land leased to the Australian Rail Track Corporation (ARTC): (1) What is the amount of rent received by Victoria from the ARTC for each of the past five years. (2) What is the amount paid by Victorian agencies to the ARTC to use its leased lines for each of the past five years.

1859 MR BOURMAN — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): In relation to Lake Mokoan: How many visitors travelled to Lake Mokoan in — (a) 2001; (b) 2002; (c) 2003; (d) 2004; (e) 2005; (f) 2006; (g) 2007; (h) 2008; (i) 2009; and (j) 2010.

1860 MR BOURMAN — To ask the Special Minister of State (for the Minister for Energy, Environment and Climate Change): In relation to the Winton Wetlands: How many visitors travelled to the Winton Wetlands in — (a) 2011; (b) 2012; (c) 2013; (d) 2014; (e) 2015; (f) 2016; (g) 2017; (h) 2018; and (i) 2019.

(Notice received 4 March 2020)

1861 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Roads (for the Minister for Transport Infrastructure): In relation to reports in the Herald Sun on 3 March 2020 that the Mayors of Wyndham City Council and City of Greater Geelong Council have written to the Minister urging the Government to put in place the extra rail services identified in its Western Rail Plan: (1) Is it correct that patronage on the Geelong railway line has increased over the past five years from 4.24 million trips to 9.83 million trips per annum, an increase of over 130 per cent. (2) What action is the Minister taking, or intending to take, to accommodate this skyrocketing patronage.

1862 MR HAYES — To ask the Minister for Regional Development (for the Minister for Planning): In relation to developments and redevelopments: (1) Is the Minister aware that for some developments, Tasmanian law prohibits re-application for the same proposal for a two year period. 6 March 2020 99

(2) Given that the ability to constantly re-apply for the same or similar development disadvantages residents and corrupts the public approval process, will the Minister consider a similar restriction to that which applies in Tasmania. (3) Given that alterations to applications for development during proceedings disadvantage residents who may be unaware of the change and therefore not be in a position to respond or be heard, will the Minister consider requiring applicants and responsible authorities to advertise amendments to development applications.

______

18 Question on Notice reinstated by Order of the President on 5 February 2020. 20 Parts 1(d)(ii), 1(d)(iii) and Part 2 of Question on Notice reinstated by Order of the President on 4 March 2020. 21 Parts 1(d)(ii) and 1(d)(iii) of Question on Notice reinstated by Order of the President on 4 March 2020. 22 Question on Notice reinstated by Order of the President on 4 March 2020. 23 Part 3 of Question on Notice reinstated by Order of the President on 4 March 2020.