Analyzing the Roles and Representation of Women in the City
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Analyzing the Roles and Representation of Women in The City by Amanda Demers A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of B.A. Honours in Urban Systems Department of Geography McGill University Montréal (Québec) Canada December 2018 © 2018 Amanda Demers ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would first and foremost like to thank my thesis supervisor, Professor Benjamin Forest. My research would have been impossible without the guidance and support of Professor Forest, who ultimately let me take the lead on this project while providing me with encouragement and help when I needed. I appreciate his trust in me to take on a topic that has interested him over the years. I would also like to extend my thanks to Professor Sarah Moser, who kindly accepted to be my thesis reader, and to the 2018 Honours Coordinators, Professor Natalie Oswin and Professor Sarah Turner, who have provided their wonderful and insightful guidance along this process as well. Additionally, I would like to thank my friends and family for their support, and the GIC for its availability and convenient hours, as it served as my primary writing spot for this thesis. i TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES………………………………………………………………….……….…iv LIST OF TABLES………………………………………………………………………………iv ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………………………………....v CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION…………………………………………………………….…1 1.1: Research Aim and Questions……………………………………………………….1 1.2: Significance of Research……………………………………………………………2 1.3: Thesis Structure……………………………………………………………………..2 CHAPTER 2: THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK……………………………….………….…4 2.1: Feminist Geography………………………………………………………………...4 2.1.1: “Separate Spheres”: Women in Private Space, Men in Public Space……..4 2.1.2: Women and Consumption in 19th and 20th Century America………………5 2.1.3: Girls in Public Space and Gendered Play………………………………….6 2.1.4: Feminist Geography: Concluding Remarks………………………………..7 2.2: Geography and Film………………………………………………………………...7 2.2.1: Rural and Urban Portrayals in Early 20th Century Film…………………..8 2.2.2: Film Documentaries, Identity Formation, and Place-Making……………..9 2.2.3: Geography and Film: Concluding Remarks………………………………10 2.3: Theoretical Framework Conclusion……………………………………………...10 CHAPTER 3: CONTEXTUALIZATION OF THE CITY…………………………………...12 3.1: Lewis Mumford…………………………………………………………….……...12 3.1.1: The “Dead City” …………………………………………………..……..12 3.1.2: Mumford’s Solution……………………………………………………….13 3.1.3: Lewis Mumford: Concluding Remarks………………………………..…..14 3.2: New York World’s Fair (1939) ………………………………………….………..14 3.3: Greenbelt, Maryland………………………………………………………………16 3.3.1: The History of Greenbelt Cities…………………………………………...16 3.3.2: The Exclusive Community of Greenbelt, Maryland……………………….16 3.3.3: The Place for Women in Greenbelt, Maryland…………………………...18 3.3.4: Greenbelt, Maryland: Concluding Remarks……………………………...19 3.4: The City……………………………………………………………………………..19 3.4.1: The City and Historical Context…………………………………………. 19 3.4.2: The City and Urban Social Reform……………………………………….20 3.4.3: The City: Concluding Remarks……………………………………………21 3.5: Contextualization of The City Conclusion………………………………………..22 CHAPTER 4: QUANTITATIVE STOP-FRAME ANALYSIS…………………………...…23 4.1: Methodology……………………………………………………………………..…23 4.1.1: Coding the Frames………………………………………………………..23 4.1.2: Statistical Analysis………………………………………………………...26 4.2: Data and Analysis………………………………………………………………….27 ii 4.3: Discussion & Conclusion………………………………………………………......31 CHAPTER 5: QUALITATIVE CONTENT ANALYSIS……………………………….…...32 5.1: Methodology………………………………………………………………………..32 5.2: Retrospective Frames……………………………………………………………...32 5.3: Prospective Frames………………………………………………………………...35 5.4: Discussion & Conclusion…………………………………………………………..36 CHAPTER 6: DISCUSSION & CONCLUSION……………………………………………..38 Reference List……………………………………………………………………………………40 iii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 4.1: Frame #357………………………………………………………………………….24 Figure 5.1: Frame #54 and #56…………..………………………………………………….…..33 Figure 5.2: Frame #144 and #150…………..…………………………………………...………34 Figure 5.3: Frame #184 and #230…………..………………………………………………..….35 Figure 5.4: Frame #417 and #460………......…………………………………………………...36 LIST OF TABLES Table 4.1: The City Coding Format……………………………………………………………..24 Table 4.2…………………………..……………………………………………………………..27 Table 4.3: …………………………………………………………………………………………..27 Table 4.4: ……………………………….…………………………………………………………..28 Table 4.5: ……………………………….…………………………………………………………..29 Table 4.6: …………………………………………………………………………………………..29 Table 4.7: ……………………………….…………………………………………………………..30 Table 4.8: ……………………………….…………………………………………………………..30 iv ABSTRACT Lewis Mumford, a 20th century urban visionary, stood out from the public of his time by refusing to blindly praise rapid technological innovation and urbanization. Rather, he professed that a small, democratic, and green community in the form of a “greenbelt town” would be the ultimate living space for humankind to avoid the foreseeable downfalls of urban growth and unstoppable technological progress. Mumford showcased this vision in The City (1939) to millions at the New York World’s Fair. We must be critical as to how truly “democratic” and inclusive these communities were portrayed as on screen, as to see if this film subtly perpetrated social inequalities to a wide audience, despite Mumford’s claims to having conceived of a nearly utopian democratic community. Thus, the aim of my research is to examine specifically the roles and representation of women in Lewis Mumford’s vision in The City. v CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION “The town was us and we were part of it,” declares the narrator, describing an idyllic, democratic living environment in the form of a greenbelt town. Lewis Mumford, a leading 20th century intellect on urban studies and design, shows a planned suburban community in his 1939 film, The City, as a solution to existing and foreseeable urban problems of his time. Urban areas can be easily confounded with negative imagery of crime, pollution, overcrowding, poor sanitation, and lack of green space. On the surface, a small, green suburb may seem like a safe- haven from these urban plights. However, it is important to examine Mumford’s greenbelt fantasy under a critical lens. Did Mumford truly intend for everyone to be part of this town in the same manner? Specifically, I wish to explore how gendered, “separate spheres” of space exist between women and men within this film, and even within the greenbelt town itself. I will focus on the quantitative differences between men and women as shown in the film through a stop-frame analysis and then I will apply statistical analyses to further examine these quantitative relationships. In addition, I will use a qualitative content analysis to assess women’s roles and primary activities within the film, of which are too complex and nuanced to be captured by the quantitative data alone. These analyses will be conducted to test my overall hypothesis that The City, and ultimately Mumford’s greenbelt vision, is plagued with gender inequalities, despite its overall claim as a democratic “safe-haven” from urban issues of the time. More specifically, I hypothesize that: 1) there will be less women than men quantitatively shown in the film; 2) women will be shown in more often in “domestic” roles and activities than men are in the film; and 3) women will be more confined to the private sphere and occupy a more domestic role within “The Green City”, as compared to the other scenes of the film, due to the expected spatial entrapment of women corresponding with suburbanization. These hypotheses are ultimately based on a theoretical framework of feminist geography and geography and film literatures that I will set up in Chapter 2 of my thesis, and they set out to test whether women were envisioned to be a part of greenbelt communities in the same manner as men as showed by Lewis Mumford. 1.1: Research Aim and Questions Lewis Mumford, a 20th century urban visionary, stood out from the public of his time by refusing to blindly praise rapid technological innovation and urbanization. Rather, he professed 1 that a small, democratic, and green community in the form of a “greenbelt town” would be the ultimate living space for humankind to avoid the foreseeable downfalls of urban growth and unstoppable technological progress. Mumford showcased this vision in The City (1939) to millions at the New York World’s Fair. We must be critical as to how truly “democratic” and inclusive these communities were portrayed as on screen, as to see if this film subtly perpetrated social inequalities to a wide audience, despite Mumford’s idyllic portrayal of a seemingly nearly utopian democratic community. My research aim is to examine the roles and representation of women within Lewis Mumford’s greenbelt vision in The City by focusing on the following three research questions: 1. Are women quantitatively represented as much as men in The City? 2. In what roles are women portrayed within The City, as compared to men? 3. Are women found more in the private sphere, occupying domestic roles, in Mumford’s greenbelt vision as compared to the prior scenes of the film? 1.2: Significance of Research Due to the very public nature of The City’s showing during the era of its release, this film was seen by many during the post-Great Depression era, including women. I believe this film helped shape women’s identities and perpetuated the notion that women should remain in the private, domestic sphere to those who have viewed this film, as well as to women who have moved to greenbelt towns in which these societal