A Georgist Perspective on Thomas Piketty's Book

Like 10k

Sign in/Sign up/Submit Site Contents Directory Sections Support OpEdNews Ad Rates Signin/Signup/Submit Free Newsletter Go Search Site Web

Advertisement Like 36 1 9 1 (11 Shares) Translate Page

View Stats 1 comment, In Series: Georgism

Life Arts 9/17/2014 at 01:39:56 A Georgist Perspective on Thomas Piketty's book: "Capital in the 21st Century." By Mason Gaffney (about the author) Permalink (Page 1 of 7 pages) Related Topic(s): Capitalism; Capitalism Failures; Economic; Economics; Economists; Economy; Georgist; Thomas Piketty, Add Tags Add to My Group(s) Become a Fan 1 1 1 opednews.com Headlined to H4 9/17/14 (9 fans) View Ratings | Rate It

Capital in the 21st Century by Thomas Piketty (image by swanksalot) DMCA

Intro

Thomas Piketty's new book is kicking up a storm. It brings the Distribution of Wealth and Income back into the center of economic discourse, where it was in the 18th and 19th Centuries the era of "classical political economy". From the 1890s the "Neoclassicals" slowly and slyly redefined the subject as the study of allocating limited resources among competing ends. The new thrust was to maximize, and then to grow total output, never mind who gets it, or why, or how it is measured. Policies to help the working poor would only obstruct the new priority. By coincidence or design, neoclassical views took over economics discourse shortly after Progress and Poverty kicked off the original "War on Poverty", and outsold all other books on economics.

Piketty's book is timely and will do a lot of good. We itemize below its good elements and then, sadly, its failings. The most basic of these is his conflating land with capital. Piketty's policy conclusions, the bottom line of it all, feature a revival of the property tax, but in a totally impracticable form. Capital in the 21st Century will fuel cocktail party chatter for a year or two and then be nitpicked to death. Meantime, for Georgists, it opens a new entry into the public dialogue. Let us enter!

A. Good elements

1. Brought distribution of wealth and income back into the public dialogue (or at least the academic one)

a. However, classical economics dealt with FACTOR distribution, while Piketty conflates land and capital, spiting and misquoting Ricardo.

b. There has been a steady drumbeat in the background for years, including work by Piketty and Saez, including Gaffney's publications on concentration of farmland, including Oxfam, and many others. It's just that leaders of "the conventional wisdom" have relegated this work to little insulated boxes hidden deep under the "commanding heights" they control and flaunt.

Advertisement c. Through some mixture of good timing, mystique, and voluminous research, Piketty has thrust distribution back Advertisement into the limelight. This is partly due to his immodest claims (itemized in Section B, below), given some credibility by voluminous research. d. Piketty himself says that today distribution of income and wealth is already a most widely discussed issue, so he does share credit with some others, e.g. Oxfam, which has been saying this for some time. In lower tiers of the academic hierarchy "heterodox" and "radical" economists, e.g. Pizzigati, may harp on this theme continually, but popular Nobelists and journalists who are the face of the profession to the media and the lay world say little about it.

2. Piketty agrees with Kuznets that economics should be quantitative and databased, but at the same time he faults the "balanced growth" models of Kuznets and Solow. Piketty sees capital "accumulation" overtaking GDP and/or income, so the capital/income (K/Y) ratio keeps rising. He does not, like Hirschman, see Unbalanced growth as a key to successful development. He disputes Kuznets and Solow, who said that growth of K need not lead to higher concentration of ownership or of income. He is right to note that the KuznetsSolow view ranks high in today's "conventional wisdom", but he overstates the novelty of this finding. Piketty should give credit to Turgot with his denier, generations of stock and r.e. traders with their P/e ratios, Austrians with their emphasis on capital structure, CaseShiller with their warnings based on irrational expectations, Clyde Chambers, Ag Ecst of the 1920s, who warned of overpriced farmland, or Philip Cornick's analysis of land pricing, 1934.

3. Supports his case with mountains of data going back more than 200 years, from many nations. a. But many of his data are from government sources, which he then warns are a "chaste veil" over the awful truth.

Advertisement 4. Notes drop in K/Y ratio during and brought on by two world wars.

a. Fails to see this was a product of Gt Depression, 192950, and then The Cold War, and not just the two major shooting wars

b. Fails to see this as a regular cycle, e.g. during Hoyt's cycles of 19th Century SAMPLE: One Shoulder Tulle Ball c. Fails to see that a big element in his "K" is land, and land prices Gown Wedding Dres... depend on expectations, and on i.r.s, giving different values to same quanta of land and capital. The writer has shown that raising $1,100 the i.r. actually DOES lower the real quantum of capital in $548.48 durables, because a higher fraction of the cash flow now goes for interest, leaving less for capital recovery (or Capital Consumption Shop Allowance, "CCA"). To a lesser extent it lowers the rentability of Ad info: click here land, hence its "quantity" when measured in money. That kind of financial insight is missing from Piketty's work.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 TOP EDITORIALS: TOP LIFE NEWS: Truth Is Washington's Enemy Passion Plays and Oratorios, by Paul Craig Roberts 'Christ Killers,' and the Magic Who Speaks for Sincere Trick of 'Deus Ex Machina' http://masongaffney.org/ Believers of All Faith by Bernard Starr Traditions? Third American Constitution by Robert De Filippis Direct Democracy Installment Mason Gaffney first read Henry George when a high school junior OMAN & ITS SPECIAL 11 Article 1 Sections 4,5 , and became notorious among his classmates for preaching LVT HISTORY: Retrospect, and 6 to them . H e served in the S.W. Pacific during W.W. II, where he Present, & Future? by Daniel Penisten observed the results of land monopoly in The (more...) by Kevin Anthony Stoda Slow Down, My Brother is America's Start is Setting Talking (Book Excerpt) Another Idiotic Plan to Hurt by Tsara Shelton Russia Book Review of David Ray by Mike Whitney Griffin's Unprecedented, Can CARERS Act protects medical Civilization Survive The C02 Pledge to End Global Poverty by 2030 marijuana patients, expands Crisis? research. by Mark Taliano author: Global Citizen Go To Commenting by M. Martin Hine A Passionate Call for Radical signatures: 38,246 The Magical Illusion of a Change in Radical Times to Christian America Deal with a Radical Disease sign petition by RF Schatten by Burl Hall Battlefield America: The War Take Note of Jonathan on the American People Gottschall's New Book Powered by Care2's Take Action Platform™ by John Whitehead (REVIEW ESSAY) A Look At The Fast Track Bill by Thomas Farrell Shows It's The Wrong Thing The Vanishing Voices of Series: "Georgism" To Do Dissent by Dave Johnson by Bob Patterson Extreme Prejudice; Raising a Letter from a School Librarian View All 1 Articles in "Georgism" Fresh Crop of Haters in Grahamstown, South Africa by Kathy Malloy by Katie Singer For the Conference on the The Universal Gaia Concept: Israel Lobby Press Where to begin? The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect Blackout at the Press Club by Anthony J. Gerst those of this website or its editors. by Ralph Nader "The Diary of Anne Frank" The West Snubs Russia over What Can There Possibly Be VE Day Left to Say? by Ray McGovern by Joan Brunwasser A FactResistant "Group No hurry Think" on Syria by Gary Lindorff Contact Author Contact Editor View Authors' Articles by Robert Parry The Path of Questioning Fracking's Joy Ride Will End by Burl Hall Related Topic(s): Capitalism; Capitalism Failures; Economic; Economics; Economists; Economy; Georgist; Thomas Piketty, Add Tags by Robert Weiner Letting Go of God for the Sake Kenya's Sorrow: The U.S. of God Related Content Connection by Burl Hall by Conn Hallinan The Devolution of Humanity You May Rape Your Wife and the Evolutionary Ideas of (Just Don't Eat Beef Steak Daniel Geery Afterwards) by Burl Hall by Zubin Madon Sherry Salman's book DREAMS The Decline and Fall of the OF TOTALITY is worth engaging United States with (REVIEW ESSAY) by David Swanson by Thomas Farrell The Killing Fields The Cosmic Story: by Thelma Mueller Moon 2015 No Room for Business as by Cathy Lynn Pagano Usual at the Summit of the Third American Constitution Land Tax Justice at last Eurasia as we (and the Are YOU willing to rebuild Americas Direct Democracy Installment in NYC?; My new Book U.S.) knew it is dead the American Dream? by Medea Benjamin 10 Article 1 Section 3 Did Ahmed Die Defending Items 1 thru 10 Charlie's Freedom of Speech? by Daniel Penisten by Zubin Madon The Debt Owed to Eduardo The Lost Wars: Poverty, Galeano Advertisement Drugs, Slavery by Dave Zirin From The Web Sponsored Links by Taboola by Marcello Rollando How Many Is Too Many? The Ethelbert Miller: A Sustaining Progressive Argument for Presence is Forced Out and Reducing Immigration into the Everyone Loses United States by Arlene Goldbard by Frosty Wooldridge The Changing Climate of San CODE RED: Jonathan Simon's Francisco Compassion: Has HailMary for Democracy "The Sanctuary City" by Joan Brunwasser Acquired A Mean Reputation? What's it like living next door by Rev. Dan Vojir to WarTorn Yemen? (Part 3): More on Empathy & Reflections by Kevin Anthony Stoda Warren Buffett Tells You Paying Interest On Credit Generation Of Seniors Which Song Was Actually A Change of Plan by Catherine Lawrence How to Turn $40 Into $10 Card Balances Is Not Lose 70% Of Savings, Written About YOU? Million Necessary, See Why Doomed To Poor House Articlesbase Quiz Advertisement The Motley Fool NextAdvisor Newsmax

The Last War Crime movie What if there was only one chance for justice?

Are Latinos in the US 11 Worst Car Names In A Very Smart Trick To Top 10 Cheesecake Conservative Or Liberal? History Pay Off Your Mortgage Recipes LatinosUSA.today Odometer AmeriVALUE TasteofHome.com

Most Popular Articles by this Author: (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Land as a Distinctive Factor of Production

Land Booms, Capital StretchOut, And Banking Collapse

What's The Matter With Michigan? The Rise And Collapse Of An Economic Wonder. Traces the pathway the Republican Salestax bias against turnover and jobs Christian Alliance took, from historical reality to an alltoopredictable dystopic Europe's Fatal Affair with VAT future What if there was only one chance for justice? The Incredible Shrinking Dollar

Classics of Liberal Thinking

Progressive Radio Links Comments

The time limit for entering new comments on this article has expired.

This limit can be removed. Our paid membership program is designed to give you many benefits, such as removing this time limit. To learn more, please click here.

Comments: Expand Shrink Hide

1 people are discussing this page, with 1 comments (Or you can set your preferences to To view all comments: show all comments, always)

Modelling AspectsIt is all very well criticising w... by David Chester on Wednesday, Sep 17, 2014 at 3:14:45 AM

Tell a Friend: