DOCSLIB.ORG

Individual Assessment of Suspected Or Accused Children: Insights Into Good Practice in the Light of the Directive (EU) 2016/800

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Individual Assessment of Suspected Or Accused Children: Insights Into Good Practice in the Light of the Directive (EU) 2016/800 INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT LDREN I OF SUSPECTED OR ACCUSED CHILDREN: insights into good practice in the light of the Directive (EU) 2016/800 Edited by Rūta Vaičiūnienė DUAL ASSESSMENT OF SUSPECTED OR ACCUSED CH OR ACCUSED DUAL ASSESSMENT OF SUSPECTED I V I IND INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT OF SUSPECTED OR ACCUSED CHILDREN: insights into good practice in the light of the Directive (EU) 2016/800 INDIVIDUAL ASSESSMENT OF SUSPECTED OR ACCUSED CHILDREN: insights into good practice in the light of the Directive (EU) 2016/800 Edited by Rūta Vaičiūnienė Vilnius, 2020 SCIENTIFIC EDITOR Rūta Vaičiūnienė (Law Institute of Lithuanian Centre for Social Science) AUTHORS Dr Rūta Vaičiūnienė (chapters 1, 3, 4, 8) Dr Simonas Nikartas (chapters 2, 4) Dr Jolanta Apolevič (chapters 1, 3, 4, 8) Vita Povilaitytė (chapters 3) Assist. Prof. dr Dora Dodig Hundrić (chapter 7) Assoc. Prof. dr Neven Ricijaš (chapter 7) Assist. Prof. dr Anja Mirosavljević (chapter 7) PhD Fellow Sabina Mandić (chapters 3, 7) Prof. dr Angelika Pitsela (chapter 5) Dr Georgios Nouskalis (chapter 5) Dr Charalampos Karagiannidis (chapter 5) PhD Fellow Anastasia Giagkou (chapter 5) Christine Mavrou (chapters 6) REVIEWERS Assoc. Prof. dr Ivana Borić (Faculty of Education and Rehabilitation Sciences, University of Zagreb) Prof. dr Odeta Merfeldaitė (Faculty of Human and Social Sciences, Mykolas Riomeris University) Dr Tautvydas Žėkas (Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Lithuania) The book as whole and each chapter were triple blind peer reviewed Authors as indicated in the book reserve their copyright. Copying is permitted only for non-commer- cial purposes and provided that the source is cited. Each author is responsible for his or her own chapter or part of the chapter and the publisher accepts no liability for any use of the contents or violations of third party rights. This book is published as a part of the EU co-funded Justice pro- gramme Project “Procedural safeguards of accused or suspected children: improving the implementation of the right to individual assessment” (IA-CHILD) No. 802059–JUST-JACC-AG-2017 and is available for downloading in the English, Lithuanian, Croatian and Greek languages at the IA-CHILD Project website: //teise.org/ en/lti-veikla/projektines-veiklos/ia-child/ The content of this book represents the views of the authors only and is their sole responsibility. The European Commission does not accept any responsibility for use that may be made of the information it contains. EDITOR Avril Calder (IAYFJM International Association of Youth and Family Judges and Magistrates) Publisher © Rūta Vaičiūnienė, Simonas Nikartas, Jolanta Apolevič, Žara, Vita Povilaitytė, Dora Dodig Hundrić, Neven Ricijaš, Akademijos str. 4, Vilnius, Anja Mirosavljević, Sabina Mandić, Lithuania LT-08412 Anastasia Giagkou, Angelika Pitsela, www.zara.lt; [email protected] Georgios Nouskalis, Charalampos Karagiannidis, Publication Year 2020 Christine Mavrou, 2020 ISBN 978-9986-34-370-7 © Law Institute of the Lithuanian Centre for Social Sciences, 2020 © Žara, 2020 Contents Foreword .......................................................................................................................... 7 1 Procedural Safeguards and Individual Assessment of Accused or Suspected Children in Criminal Proceedings: Introduction ..........................................11 1.1. Children’s Rights in Criminal Proceedings: International Legal Developments ...........................................................................14 1.2. Strengthening Procedural Safeguards in the EU: Directive 2016/800 and Individual Assessment ......................................................19 1.3. In Conclusion: the Importance of Procedural Justice in Juvenile Criminal Proceedings ................................................................................................25 2 Towards the Effective Implementation of the Directive: Review and Recommendations for the Individual Assessment of the Child ....................................29 2.1. Introduction: Ensuring the Needs of the Child as a Precondition for Individual Assessment ...............................................................................................29 2.2. The Goals of Individual Assessment ........................................................................33 2.3. What Instruments Should be Used for Conducting Individual Assessment? .....40 2.4. Who is Entitled to Carry out the Individual Assessment? .....................................43 2.5. Who Has the Right to an Individual Assessment? ..................................................45 2.6. When Should an Individual Assessment be Carried out? .....................................49 3 Conceptualizing Forensic Juvenile Assessment: Main Concepts, Theoretical Approaches and Debates .........................................................................53 3.1. Forensic Assessment: Main Concepts and Approaches .........................................54 3.2. Juvenile Forensic Assessment ..................................................................................... 58 3.3. Risk Assessment Paradigms ......................................................................................67 4 Implementation Of Individual Assessment In Lithuania .............................................85 4.1. Legal Background and Regulation of the Juvenile Justice System in Lithuania ................................................................................................................85 4.1.1. A System of Measures for Offending Behaviour by Children .................................... 85 5 4.1.2. Institutions Responsible for Criminal Proceedings Against Juveniles ...................... 95 4.1.3. Institutions Responsible for The Enforcement of Sanctions on Juvenile Offenders ........................................................................................................... 97 4.2 Legal Background and Regulation of Individual Assessment ...............................97 4.3. Implementation of the an Individual Assessment from the Experts’ Point of View ............................................................................................................104 4.4. Conclusion and Recommendations .......................................................................110 5 Implementation of Individual Assessment in Greece ................................................115 5.1. Legal Background and Juvenile Justice System in Greece ...................................115 5.2. Individual Assessment in Greece ...........................................................................132 5.3. Research on Implementation of Individual Assessment in Greece ....................140 6 Implementation of Individual Assessment in Cyprus ................................................153 6.1. Legal Background and Regulation of Juvenile Justice in Cyprus .......................153 6.2. Individual Assessment of Juvenile Offenders .......................................................160 6.3. Research on the Implementation of Individual Assessment in Cyprus .............162 7 Implementation of Individual Assessment in Croatia ................................................167 7.1. Legal Framework and Juvenile Justice System in Croatia ....................................167 7.2 Conceptual and Practical Framework of Individual Assessment in Croatia .....181 7.3. Methodology for the Implementation of Individual Assessment: Assessment, Planning and Reporting .....................................................................195 7.4. What can be Learned from Research on Individual Assessment Implementation in Croatia? .....................................................................................204 8 Concluding Remarks ...............................................................................................213 6 Foreword We all know that children and young people are the future of our societies and that we should do everything we can to nurture and protect them until they are fully developed. If a child or young person is going off the rails we need to find the best way of helping them back on track. That is why individual assessment of young people involved with the law is so important. We want to find the par- ticular strategy with the best chance of working for that particular young person. An individual assessment also offers the best way of involving the young person in their own future. It therefore gives me great pleasure to contribute the foreword to this book which is rich in information about individual assessment (IA) in four countries—Lith- uania, the lead partner in the project, Croatia, Cyprus and Greece. In detail, the partners are the Law Institute of the Lithuanian Centre for Social Sciences (Lith- uania), the Faculty of Education and Rehabilitation Sciences of the University of Zagreb (Croatia), HFC Hope for Children Policy Center (Cyprus) and the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki (Greece), The project’s second workshop was in March 2020, and, as I said in my introduc- tory speech to that workshop: ….this Individual Assessment Project is extremely valuable. I know, be- cause as a Youth Court Magistrate of 35 years’ standing in Inner Lon- don, I can truly say that without the input of the Youth Offending Service (YOS) officers who prepare individual assessments, absolutely tailored for each child, my decisions, the decisions of the bench, would have been less well based and outcomes for each child less focused on good outcomes. It has been interesting
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Illegal Migration As a Political Weapon
    August 5, 2021 Foundation Office Belarus/Lithuania Illegal migration as a political weapon About the situation on the Belarusian-Lithuanian border Jakob Wöllenstein, Elisabeth Bauer, Fausta Šimaitytė Belarus will even double and take place from a total The Belarusian ruler Alexander Lukashenko has of four Iraqi cities. repeatedly threatened the EU to allow refugees Border security is currently given priority. Barbed from war zones to enter the EU in response to the wire is to be built along the entire border. The sanctions imposed on his country. The main establishment of a permanent border location is also target is Lithuania, which has an almost 680 under discussion. The technical means for border kilometer long and mostly unprotected border surveillance alone would cost 400 million euros. The with Belarus. The increase in illegal migrant EU has so far pledged 12 million euros. So far, the flows from Iraq and African countries is actively Lithuanian government has budgeted 100 million promoted by the Belarusian regime. According to euros for overcoming the crisis. Ylva Johansson, the EU Commissioner for Home Affairs, this is not just a migration crisis, but an (Re) actions by Lithuania and the EU act of aggression aimed at destabilization. On July 2nd the Lithuanian government declared a Data on illegal migration to Lithuania from third state of emergency2 due to the migration crisis and countries via Belarus called the European border protection agency FRONTEX for support on July 9th. FRONTEX The number of illegal migrants who have entered announced on July 12th a Rapid Border Intervention Lithuania via Belarus since the beginning of 2021 is Mission to the Lithuanian-Belarusian border.
    [Show full text]
  • Speech by Ingrida Šimonytė, Prime Minister of Lithuania
    Speech by Ingrida Šimonytė, Prime Minister of Lithuania The Europa-Forum Wachau June 12, 2021, Austria Dear Federal Chancellor, Commissioner, Ladies and Gentlemen, I am pleased and honored to be here with you today at Göttweig Abbey, a Baroque masterpiece: truly unique yet so familiar to someone like me, who was born and raised surrounded by the Baroque churches of the old Vilnius. While arriving here, I was immersed in the stunning beauty of hills, forests, and vineyards. I caught glimpses of the mighty Danube flowing calmly through centuries, countries, history, and cultural heritage – from "An der schönen, blauen Donau" by Johann Strauss to Lithuanian folk songs (surprising, but it’s true). And as we got to the top of this hill and I looked around, I thought there could be no better place to discuss Europe, heading to new horizons! Horizons that are vast. That might seem somewhat different, depending on where each of us stands, and what perspective we look from. Horizons that might seem distant, at first. But then each of us brings their snapshot to the table and we realise they all cling together like perfectly fitting pieces of a jigsaw puzzle. Because they might differ, but they all have connection points. They are all parts of something bigger. And when assembled, they become one whole. They become stronger. And that horizon that might have seemed remote, it isn’t anymore. It becomes clear, simple, and easier to reach – because it’s common to all of us. For me, that’s what Europe is. That jigsaw puzzle.
    [Show full text]
  • Implementation of the EEA and Norwegian Financial Mechanisms 2014-2021 in Lithuania
    Implementation of the EEA and Norwegian Financial Mechanisms 2014-2021 in Lithuania Strategic Report Reporting period: 19 March 2018 – 19 March 2019 Prepared by the National Focal Point (Ministry of Finance) Contents Abbreviations ..................................................................................................................................................... 3 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...................................................................................................... 4 2. POLITICAL, ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL CONTEXT ......................................................... 5 3. EFFECTS OF THE GRANTS .................................................................................................. 6 4. STATUS OF PROGRAMMES ................................................................................................ 6 5. STATUS OF BILATERAL FUNDS ...................................................................................... 16 6. MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION ..................................................................... 20 a. Management and control system .................................................................................................... 20 b. Complaints........................................................................................................................................ 23 c. Irregularities ..................................................................................................................................... 23 d. Audit ................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Political Scientist Kestutis Girnius: “President Gitanas Nauseda Has
    June 30, 2020 – July 28, 2020 The opening of an open-air beach in Lukiskiu1 square in the heart of Vilnius has triggered a major firestorm, which perhaps can first be chalked off to the nearing parliamentary election in Lithuania in October. The square is sacred to many for its vivid bloody history: tsarist Russia’s general and governor of Vilnius, Mikhail Muravyov, nicknamed “hangman” for his cruelty, hung Lithuanian insurgents against the tsarist regime in the square in 1863–1864. Page 12 The Baltics’ independent news source since 1992 • www.baltictimes.com • June 30, 2020 – July 28, 2020 Vol. 22 #943 Ukraine’s Lithuania Ambassador: “We are not only strategic OUR COMMENTARY When memory is snubbed partners – we are strategically like-minded sworn brothers” Page 2 Linas JEGELEVICIUS In the last decade, few countries have become so intricately inter- twined with Lithuania as Ukraine, Q/A which after the historic Maidan in 2014 chose the European path of Lithuania’s Conservatives development, never looking back. – an “eternal” opposition? Both countries boast impressive trade volumes and tightly-knit hu- Page 4 man ties. The Baltic Times sat down to speak about the bilateral relations with Volodymyr Yatsenkivskyi, SPIRITUAL LIFE Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Ukraine in the When words cut to the Republic of Lithuania. essence of the issue at How is Ukraine grappling with hand the COVID-19 pandemic? Well, the first case of COVID-19 Page 6 disease was registered in Ukraine on March 3. As of June 10, 28 381 cases have been confirmed with 833 dead and 12 769 recovered.
    [Show full text]
  • Call for Outcome 3 Projects
    Open Lithuania Foundation, OSFL Projects and Geri Norai LT on behalf of a consortium of the Active Citizens Fund announces an open call for projects focused on the INCREASED SUPPORT FOR HUMAN RIGHTS Outcome 3 Call 2 EEA Grants 2014 - 2021 CONCEPT NOTES. Deadline for submission 30th September 2021, 23:59 Lithuanian time FULL PROJECT PROPOSALS. Indicative deadline for submission 17th January 2022, 23:59 Lithuanian time Applicants can contact Fund Operator by e-mail [email protected] Outcome 3 Who can apply Grant size and Funds project duration Lithuanian NGOs Small (€5,000 – 15,000; Lithuanian NGOs established €195,000 6-18 months) as the legal entities for at Medium (€15,001 – 80,000; least 1 year 6-18 months) Partners (not obligatory) Any public or private entity (commercial or non- commercial) or NGO Increased International organization Capacity building Informal group 10 - 15% of each project support for budget must be allocated to capacity building activities in Lithuania or other aimed at increasing the Beneficiary country human capacity and organizational in Iceland, Liechtenshtein sustainability of the project or Norway rights promoter organization(s) based in a country outside the on individual assessments EEA that has a common of organisational capacity. border with Lithuania Outputs to be What can be done reached Advocacy campaigns related to the promotion of human rights Implementation of and equal treatment; international human rights Watchdog initiatives for the defense of human rights; standards promoted Awareness-raising initiatives
    [Show full text]
  • 1 1 T H Baltic Theriological Conference Abstract Book
    11TH B A L T I C THERIOLOGICAL CONFERENCE 25- 27 JANUARY 2021 KAUNAS LITHUANIA ABSTRACT BOOK SPONSORS ORGANIZERS Chairman: Algimantas Paulauskas, Head of Center of Enviromental Research, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Jana Radzijevskaja, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Asta Aleksandravičienė, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Matas Galdikas, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Loreta Griciuvienė, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Vesta Jonikė, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Artūras Kibiša, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Indrė Lipatova, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Evelina Kaminskienė, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Deivydas Kiznys, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Miglė Razgūnaitė, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Povilas Sakalauskas, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Paulė Drigotaitė, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Romualdas Lapickis, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania SCIENTIFIC COM MITTEE Chairman: Algimantas Paulauskas, Head of Center of Environmental Research, Vytautas Magnus University, Lithuania Linas Balčiauskas, Nature Research Centre, Lithuania Janis Ozolinš, Latvian State Forest Research Institute “Silava”, Latvia Peep Mannil, Estonian Environment Agency, Estonia Jos Stratford, Nature Research Centre, Lithuania Uudo Timm, Estonian Environment Agency, Estonia eISBN 978-609-454-510-8 The organisers are not responsible for the contents of the abstracts published in this book 2 Table of Contents FULL PRESENTATIONS STORY OF A SINGLE MEADOW: LONG TERM CHANGES
    [Show full text]
  • Lithuania 2021 Energy Policy Review INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY
    Lithuania 2021 Energy Policy Review INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY The IEA examines the IEA member IEA association full spectrum countries: countries: of energy issues including oil, gas and Australia Brazil coal supply and Austria China demand, renewable Belgium India energy technologies, Canada Indonesia electricity markets, Czech Republic Morocco energy efficiency, Denmark Singapore access to energy, Estonia South Africa demand side Finland Thailand management and France much more. Through Germany its work, the IEA Greece advocates policies Hungary that will enhance the reliability, affordability Ireland and sustainability of Italy energy in its Japan 30 member countries, Korea 8 association Luxembourg countries and beyond. Mexico Netherlands New Zealand Norway Poland Portugal Please note that this Slovak Republic publication is subject to Spain specific restrictions that limit Sweden its use and distribution. The terms and conditions are Switzerland available online at Turkey www.iea.org/t&c/ United Kingdom United States This publication and any The European map included herein are without prejudice to the Commission also status of or sovereignty over participates in the any territory, to the work of the IEA delimitation of international frontiers and boundaries and to the name of any territory, city or area. Source: IEA. All rights reserved. International Energy Agency Website: www.iea.org Foreword The International Energy Agency (IEA) has conducted in-depth peer reviews of its member countries’ energy policies since 1976. This process not only supports energy policy development, but also encourages the exchange of and learning from international best practices and experiences. By seeing what has worked – or not – in the “real world,” these reviews help to identify policies that deliver concrete results.
    [Show full text]
  • Work Plan Revised on 23 December, 2020
    ADOPTED by the Joint Committee for the Bilateral Funds 2014-2021 in Lithuania on 26 February, 2019 (written procedure), Work Plan revised on 23 December, 2020 FUND FOR BILATERAL RELATIONS (hereinafter – FBR) (In accordance with Article 2.4 of the Bilateral Fund Agreement and Article 4.2 of the Regulations on the implementation of the EEA and Norwegian Financial Mechanisms 2014-2021) [Lithuania] 1. Background Please refer briefly to any major fields of cooperation characterising the existing bilateral relations between the BS and the DS. Lithuania has diplomatic relations with all three donor countries: the Republic of Iceland (hereinafter – Iceland), Kingdom of Norway (hereinafter – Norway) and the Principality of Liechtenstein (hereinafter – Liechtenstein). Iceland is the first foreign state which recognized the restoration of independence of Lithuania on 11 February 1991. Diplomatic relations with Iceland were established on 26 August of the same year. At present, the relations between Iceland and Lithuania in various fields are regulated by 6 bilateral treaties. On 24 August 1991 the restored independent State of Lithuania was recognized by Norway, and several days later (on 27 August) the diplomatic relations between the countries were established. The relations between Norway and Lithuania in various fields are regulated by 12 bilateral treaties. On 27 March 2001 Lithuania established diplomatic relations with Liechtenstein. Lithuania and donor countries are members of the United Nations, Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe and the World Trade Organisation. Together with Norway and Iceland, Lithuania is a member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (hereinafter – NATO). Lithuania and Norway share not only strong political ties, the countries maintain close business and cultural cooperation, as well as close cooperation between academic community, civil society and public authorities.
    [Show full text]