Genomic Evidence for Diving Behavior in the Pygmy Right Whale
Mark S. Springer Department of Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal Biology University of California Riverside
Coauthors: John Gatesy, Phil Morin, Michael Berenbrink, Kevin Campbell, Matthew Collin, Taku Kishida, Gang Li, William Murphy
• Part of larger NSF project on cetacean genomics (“The Phylogeny and Evolution of Cetacea: Resolution of Rapid Radiations and a Molecular Blueprint for Modern Whales, Dolphins, and Porpoises”) • Most samples from Southwest Fisheries • Target for sequence coverage: ~30-35X Illumina PIs/co-PIs: Collaborators: John Gatesy Michael Berenbrink Phil Morin Kevin Campbell Mark Springer Matthew Collin Christopher Emerling Jeffry Fasick Michael Hiller Nikolai Hecker Matthias Huelsmann Jeremy Johnson Takushi Kishida Gang Li Michael McGowen William Murphy Ji Won Oh Maksim Plikus Amy Van Cise Taxon Sampling (New Genomes + Publicly Available Genomes) Family Number of species in Number of sampled family species/individuals Balaenidae 4 3/5 Neobalaenidae 1 1/1 Eschrich idae 1 1/5 Balaenopteridae 9 8/14 Physeteridae 1 1/1 Kogiidae 2 2/3 Ziphiidae 22 15/17 Platanis dae 2 1/1 Lipo dae 1 1/1 Iniidae 3 1/1 Pontoporiidae 1 1/2 Delphinidae 39 33/43 Monodon dae 2 2/4 Phocoenidae 7 4/4 Totals 95 74/101 Caperea marginata (Pygmy Right Whale)
• Smallest mysticete and the only living member of the family Neobalaenidae
• Found in Southern Hemisphere
Phylogenetic Position of Neobalaenidae • Unequivocal based on molecular data
Gatesy et al. (2013) • Equivocal based on morphology
Biscon (2012)
Fordyce and Marx (2012) Vision: Rods and Cones
• Rods: scotopic vision
• Cones: photopic vision Visual Opsins in Vertebrates
SWS1 SWS2 RH2 RH1 LWS
500-501 355 416 467-505 548-558 1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 400 500 600 700 Wavelength (nm) Visual Opsins
• Rods: RH1 • Cones: RH2, SWS1, SWS2, LWS
RH1 RH2 SWS2 SWS1 LWS Loss of Cone Opsins in Mammals
Figure from Jacobs (2013) Trichromatic Vision in Humans and Various Primates Cone monochromacy in a variety of mammals
Carnivora
Table from Cetacea Jacobs (2013)
Chiroptera
Primates
Roden a Are there also rod monochromats?
”…. absolutely cone-free retina which once were duplex, and have lost their cones, are known for a certainty to occur only in deep-sea fishes, the bats, and the armadillo. Some others probably have only rods...the hedge-hog, the guinea-pig, the whales and seals, most lemuroids and Aotus..." (Walls 1942)
”… the histological and chemical evidence suggest that vision in cetacea is based on only one retinal pigment, a rhodopsin." (McFarland 1971) Ziphius cavirostris (Schorr et al. 2014) Inactivation of Opsins in Cetacea
1
2
3 4
5
Meredith et al. (2013, PLoS Genetics) Examples of Frameshift Mutations in LWS Intact LWS and Blueshifted RH1 in Caperea
Meredith et al. (2013, PLoS Genetics) Meredith et al. (2013) Possible Significance of Blueshift in RH1
Light Penetra on in Open Water (Clear Day) Wavelength (nanometers) Pygmy Right Whale Versus Other Mysticetes
LWS Intact RH1 λmax
Pygmy right Yes 479 nm whale Other No 484-493 nm mysticetes
LWS is intact in the pygmy right whale, but is the cone phototransduc on cascade intact? Opsins and Other Retinal Protein Genes
Emerling and Springer 2014, MPE Phototransduction Visual Cycle Cone Monochromatic Cetaceans Physeter macrocephalus Balaena mysticetus
LWS PDE6C CNGA3 LWS PDE6C CNGA3 LWS PDE6C CNGA3 GNAT2 GNAT2 GNAT2
SWS1 PDE6H CNGB3 SWS1 PDE6H CNGB3 SWS1 PDE6H CNGB3 GNB3 GNGT2 GNB3 GNGT2 GNB3 GNGT2
Balaenoptera physalus Balaenoptera bonaerensis Balaenoptera acutorostrata
LWS PDE6C CNGA3 LWS PDE6C CNGA3 LWS PDE6C CNGA3 GNAT2 GNAT2 GNAT2
SWS1 PDE6H CNGB3 SWS1 PDE6H CNGB3 SWS1 PDE6H CNGB3 GNB3 GNGT2 GNB3 GNGT2 GNB3 GNGT2
Springer et al. (2016) What about the pygmy right whale?
Is there any evidence for ablation of the cone phototransduction pathway in this species?
Made use of gap-closed assembly for Caperea
Total bases 2234886559 Min sequence length 1000 Max sequence length 280268 Average sequence length 15245.00 Median sequence length 7945.50 N50 length 31075 N75 length 15891 N90 length 7473 N95 length 4323 As 29.67 % Ts 29.18 % Gs 20.51 % Cs 20.56 % (A + T)s 58.85 % (G + C)s 41.07 % Ns 0.08 %
Conclusion: The cone phototransduction cascade in inactivated in the pygmy right whale even though LWS is intact. What about myoglobin?
Molecular Aqualung: Key protein in muscle that shows evidence for increased net surface charge in elite mammalian divers
Mirceta et al. (2013) Pygmy Right Whale Myoglobin
Additional histidine at position 66 of mature protein
Parallel change with deep diving ziphiids
Surface charges:
Most mysticetes = 3.65 Pygmy right whale = 3.92 Minke whale: 3.94 Sperm whale = 4.15-4.24 Beaked whales = 4.80
Conclusions
• The pygmy right whale is a rod monochromat
• An inactivated cone phototransduction cascade, a blueshifted RH1, and an increased surface charge on myoglobin suggest enhanced diving capabilities in the pygmy right whale