Water Quality Standards for Salinity, Colorado River System, October 2005 Review
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Presented below are water quality standards that are in effect for Clean Water Act purposes. EPA is posting these standards as a convenience to users and has made a reasonable effort to assure their accuracy. Additionally, EPA has made a reasonable effort to identify parts of the standards that are not approved, disapproved, or are otherwise not in effect for Clean Water Act purposes. 2005 REVIEW WATER QUALITY STANDARDS FOR SALINITY COLORADO RIVER SYSTEM October 2005 Prepared by Colorado River Basin Salinity Control Forum COLORADO RIVER BASIN SALINITY CONTROL FORUM MEMBERS ARIZONA Thomas G. Carr, Assistant Director, Statewide Conservation and Strategic Planning Department of Water Resources Karen L. Smith, Deputy Director Department of Water Resources Larry R. Dozier, Deputy General Manager Central Arizona Water Conservation District CALIFORNIA Gerald R. Zimmerman, Executive Director Colorado River Board of California Celeste Cantú, Executive Director State Water Resources Control Board Dennis B. Underwood, Chief Executive Officer/General Manager The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California COLORADO Rod Kuharich, Director Colorado Water Conservation Board Department of Natural Resources Mark T. Pifher, Deputy Director of Utilities for Water Resources City of Aurora Kent H. Holsinger, Attorney at Law NEVADA Phillip S. Lehr, Environmental Programs Manager Colorado River Commission of Nevada Allen Biaggi, Director Department of Conservation and Natural Resources Kay Brothers, Deputy General Manager Engineering/Operations Southern Nevada Water Authority NEW MEXICO John R. D’Antonio, Jr., P.E., State Engineer New Mexico State Engineer Office UTAH D. Larry Anderson, Director Division of Water Resources Department of Natural Resources Walt Baker, Director Division of Water Quality Department of Environmental Quality Randy Crozier, General Manager Duchesne County Water Conservancy District WYOMING Patrick T. Tyrrell, State Engineer State Engineer's Office John F. Wagner, Administrator Division of Water Quality Department of Environmental Quality Dan S. Budd, Interstate Stream Commissioner FORUM Jack A. Barnett, Executive Director Colorado River Basin Salinity Control Forum i ii TRANSMITTAL LETTERS The Federal Water Pollution Control Act requires that at least once every three years the Colorado River Basin states review water quality standards relating to the salinity of the waters of the Colorado River. The states collectively initiated this review under the auspices of the Colorado River Basin Salinity Control Forum, prepared a proposed Review; and after holding public meetings, the Forum prepared this final Review. Upon the Forum's adoption of the final Review, it is transmitted by letter to the governors of the individual states for their independent action. The following governors in each of the seven Colorado River Basin states shall receive this Review: Honorable Janet Napolitano Honorable Bill Richardson Governor of Arizona Governor of New Mexico State Capitol State Capitol Phoenix, AZ 85007 Santa Fe, NM 87503 Honorable Arnold Schwarzenegger Honorable Jon M. Huntsman, Jr. Governor of California Governor of Utah State Capitol State Capitol Sacramento, CA 95814 Salt Lake City, UT 84114 Honorable Bill F. Owens Honorable Dave Freudenthal Governor of Colorado Governor of Wyoming State Capitol State Capitol Denver, CO 80203 Cheyenne, WY 82002 Honorable Kenny Guinn Governor of Nevada State Capitol Carson City, NV 89701 iii SUMMARY This Review, the 2005 Review, Water Quality Standards for Salinity, Colorado River System (Review), is a review of the water quality standards for salinity for the Colorado River. It summarizes the Colorado River Basin Salinity Control Program (Program) and its proposed plan of implementation for continued salinity control. Economic damages due to elevated salinity levels have been significantly reduced through the Program at very modest costs. In Arizona, California and Nevada, economic damages have been reduced to about $300 million per year, accomplished at a funding level of about $24 million per year from federal sources and $10 million from Colorado River Basin state funds. The Program is a unique cooperative watershed effort between several federal agencies and seven states designated to meet national, international and state water quality objectives. Section 303 of the Clean Water Act requires that water quality standards be reviewed from time to time, but at least once during each three-year period. Accordingly, the seven-state Colorado River Basin Salinity Control Forum (Forum) has reviewed the existing state-adopted and United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA)-approved water quality standards for salinity consisting of numeric criteria and a plan of implementation for salinity control for the Colorado River System. Since the issuance of the 2002 Review, the United States Bureau of Reclamation (Reclamation) has enhanced a new model to analyze the Colorado River System, including salinity. The model has been used to make new salinity projections for this Review. The Forum=s recommendations as found in this report will be submitted to each of the Colorado River Basin states for consideration as each state proceeds with its three-year water quality review process. The Forum recommends no change in the numeric salinity criteria at the three stations located on the lower main stem of the Colorado River. The numeric criteria at these stations will remain: Station Salinity in mg/L1 Below Hoover Dam 723 Below Parker Dam 747 At Imperial Dam 879 The plan of implementation as set forth in this Review is designed to meet the objective of maintaining the salinity concentrations at or below the numeric criteria while the Colorado River Basin states continue to develop their compact-apportioned waters. The Forum recommends that the plan of implementation described in this Review be carried out. The plan of implementation includes: 1 Flow-weighted average annual salinity. iv 1. Completion of Reclamation, United States Bureau of Land Management (BLM), and United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) salinity control measures to the extent that each unit remains viable and appropriately cost-effective. 2. Implementation of the Forum's recommended and adopted policies for effluent limitations, principally under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program established by Section 402 of the Clean Water Act as amended. The implemented policies (included in Appendix A of this Review) are the following: Policy for Implementation of Colorado River Salinity Standards Through the NPDES Permit Program; NPDES Permit Program for Implementation of Colorado River Salinity Standards; Policy for Use of Brackish and/or Saline Waters for Industrial Purposes; Policy for Implementation of the Colorado River Salinity Standards Through the NPDES Permit Program for Intercepted Ground Water; and Policy for Implementation of the Colorado River Salinity Standards Through the NPDES Permit Program for Fish Hatcheries. 3. Implementation of nonpoint source management plans developed by the states and approved by USEPA. Item 1 of the plan listed above is to be implemented by federal agencies in conjunction with state, local, and private participants. The Forum works jointly with federal agencies on developing measures to be implemented. The Forum also urges the United States Congress (Congress) to ensure that the funds necessary to successfully fulfill this plan of implementation are appropriated as needed. Items 2 and 3 above are primarily implemented by each of the Colorado River Basin states. The probability of exceeding the numeric criteria is low as determined by Reclamation with the use of its computer model. The low probability of exceedance was an important factor in the Forum’s decision that the plan of implementation is acceptable and that the numeric criteria does not need to be changed. The plan of implementation is designed to control enough salt to maintain the numeric criteria under a long-term mean water supply of 15 million acre-feet per year. It is recognized that the river system is subject to highly variable flows. Consequently, salinity will vary from year to year and may temporarily exceed the adopted numeric criteria in some years and remain well below the criteria in others. v TABLE OF CONTENTS COLORADO RIVER BASIN SALINITY CONTROL FORUM MEMBERS............................................. i COLORADO RIVER BASIN MAP.............................................................................................................ii TRANSMITTAL LETTERS .......................................................................................................................iii SUMMARY................................................................................................................................................. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS............................................................................................................................. vi CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................1-1 Purpose of Review ........................................................................................................................1-1 History and Background ...............................................................................................................1-2 CHAPTER 2 – UNDERSTANDING THE SALINITY OF THE COLORADO RIVER .........................2-1