DOCSLIB.ORG

363 Christ & the Tao. by Heup Young Kim. Hong Kong, China

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
363 Christ & the Tao. by Heup Young Kim. Hong Kong, China Book Reviews / Mission Studies 24 (2007) 333–364 363 Christ & the Tao. By Heup Young Kim. Hong Kong, China, Christian Confer- ence of Asia 2003. Pp. x + 186 pp. $18.00. Th is unique book provides stimulating ideas for a Korean-American Christian like me. I have often wondered whether the Confucian assumptions of a Korean person can find any resonance or co-existence with the Christian mes- sage without contradicting or compromising either religious and/or philo- sophical tradition. An ordained Presbyterian minister raised in a strict Confucian environment in South Korea, Kim formulates a new theology or hermeneutical paradigm in which Jesus Christ and his message are contextual- ized in the Confucian mindset of Korean Christians. Kim urges the contextu- alizing of Christianity to the Korean experience, warning that “a blind application of Christian doctrines without a proper consideration of the con- text could cause serious and long-lasting damage to the church and society as a whole” (126). In order to develop his new hermeneutical paradigm reflecting Christianity with an East Asian and Confucian backdrop, Kim coins the phrases “theo-tao” and “Christo-tao,” and argues that the “tao (way), a cardinal religio-cultural metaphor of East Asian people, is the root-metaphor, [one] that is more appro- priate and Biblical for Christian theology in the coming millennium than the logos and the praxis” (132). Kim asserts that the Christian message is universal and can appear, albeit in disguise, in Confucian teachings, if one looks closely and identifies similar concepts. He observes parallels among and between two seminal Confucian and two seminal Christian thinkers: Wang Yang-ming (15th century), Karl Barth, Yi T’oegye (16th century), and John Calvin. Th e author resurrects the ideas of these four in order to engage in Confucian- Christian dialogues, which are presented in a series of six essays, divided into two parts, each containing three essays. Part I is entitled “Christ and the Tao: Confucian-Christian Dialogue,” and Part II is “Christ as the Tao: East Asian Constructive Th eology.” Perhaps Kim’s most significant contribution is to provide a common arena where Confucians and Christians can have a stimulating and mutually beneficial dialogue, especially in regards to human concerns, cultivating rela- tionship with one another, finding a common original humanity, and realizing full humanity. Quoting the works of his four thinkers allows Kim to identify and expound parallel concepts found in Christianity and Confucianism, such as the following pairs: agape (unconditional love) and ch’eng (sincerity); liang- chih (the Inner Sage) and humanitas Christi; and t’ien-ming (the mandate of Heaven) and imago Dei. © Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2007 DOI: 10.1163/157338307X235085 MMISTIST 224,2_f11_333-364.indd4,2_f11_333-364.indd 336363 111/8/071/8/07 44:12:50:12:50 PPMM 364 Book Reviews / Mission Studies 24 (2007) 333–364 While his observations and insights are noteworthy, Kim’s effort to build bridges between Christianity and Confucianism favors a humanistic interpre- tation of the Christian message. In doing so he deemphasizes the salvific mes- sage of the gospel, which is embodied in the incarnate logos, Jesus Christ, whose message cannot be simply removed from the Judeo-Christian context of the Middle East. In other words, in his attempt to contextualize the Chris- tian message for Korean Confucian believers, Kim takes the Christian message out of context, and then filters in the humanistic elements that resonate with Confucian principles. Certainly Kim makes a significant contribution by raising the question of the relevance of Western Christianity to the Korean experience. He challenges Asian Christians to formulate a theology that takes account of cultural con- text, and identifies important aspects of the Korean context for the formation of Korean Christian theology. Th ese include the liberation theology emerging from Korea’s internal wars, the occupation by the Japanese, the treatment of women, and interactions with indigenous philosophies and religious tradi- tions. Yet in the daunting task of formulating Korean Christian theology, it is important to remember that culture should not replace the centrality of Christ. Above all, Asian theologians must keep the integrity of the Christian message intact as they endeavor to contextualize theology in light of their milieu. Kenneth D. Lee California State University, Northridge, US MMISTIST 224,2_f11_333-364.indd4,2_f11_333-364.indd 336464 111/8/071/8/07 44:12:50:12:50 PPMM.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Or Bis Book S
    Spring 2017 Pope Francis WITH THE SMELL OF THE SHEEP See Page 3 Orbis Books A World of Books That Matter Maryknoll, NY 800.258.5838 ORBISBOOKS.COM MORNING HOMILIES IV Pope Francis “Each morning since Pope Francis’s election, I have read his beautiful morning homilies . These homilies—clear, brief, often funny and always grounded in experience, are my favorite of all the pope’s talks and writings. It never fails to astonish how Pope Francis can find something new in these familiar Bible passages, and I hope that his sur- prising insights will lead you deeper into Scripture and help you encounter God in a new way." —James Martin, SJ, author, Jesus: A Pilgrimage ach day Pope Francis says Mass and offers a short homily for fellow residents and Eguests in the chapel of St. Martha’s Guest- house, where he has chosen to live. Through these accounts of his morning homilies, drawn from July to November 2014, it is now possible for those who were not present to experience and enjoy his lively manner of speaking, and his capacity to engage his listeners and their daily lives with the joy of the gospel message. APRIL 3 192pp., 5 /8 x 8¼ $18 softcover ISBN 978-1-62698-228-4 RELIGION/Christianity/Catholic RELIGION/Sermons/Christian MORE MORNING HOMILIES MORNING HOMILIES I MORNING HOMILIES II MORNING HOMILIES III (MAR.-AUG. 2013) (SEP. 2013-JAN. 2014) (FEB.-JUN. 2014) ISBN 978-1-62698-111-9 ISBN 978-1-62698-179-9 ISBN 978-1-62698-147-8 $18 softcover $18 softcover $18 softcover Dear Friends, When Orbis first launched our Modern Spiritual MORNING HOMILIES IV Masters Series twenty years ago, the “masters” were Pope Francis mostly historical figures.
    [Show full text]
  • Opening Remarks Guo Changgang: Good Morning
    Opening Remarks Guo Changgang: Good morning. Let’s start our workshop. First, I want to say many, many thanks to our dear guests and colleagues who took their time to participate in this event. And I should also firstly thank Professor Mark Juergensmeyer. Actually, he had this idea when we met last year in Chicago, where we talked about it. In recent years, my field and my interest is in religion and its’ globalizing force, the role of religion and its’ globalizing force in some specific religious countries; the role of religion and also the tension between religion and nation-states. So when we talked together, we came to this idea to make this joint event. So I should thank Mark Juergensmeyer actually for making this event possible. And also thanks to Dinah. Dinah, you actually give a big support to Mark Juergensmeyer’s project. Guo Changgang: Now I’d like to introduce our colleagues and every participant. Professor Tajima Tadaatsu. Oh, Tadaatsu Tajima. Can we just call you Tad? He is a professor from Tenshi College, Japan. Dr. Greg Auberry from Catholic Relief Services, Center in Cambodia. Professor Zhang Zhigang, he is still on the way he is a Professor from Peking University. He’s still on the way up here. Professor David A. Palmer from Hong Kong University. I think your field is Taoism. Chinese religion and Taoism, and director She Hongye from the Amity Foundation. Dr. Victor from UCSB center of Santa Barbara and colleague to Mark. Mark Juergensmeyer : More than a colleague. He is my right hand man.
    [Show full text]
  • Currents Fall 2009
    fb_fall 09 currents2_!!GTU_Currents Redesign Draft 2 10/8/09 2:51 PM Page 1 GTU Where religion meets the world news of the G raduate t heoloGical u nion fall 2009 INSIDE THIS ISSUE: 2 A Prophetic Voice on Social Justice 4 Finding Slavery in Your Own Back Yard 5 A-twitter with American Buddhist Monk Heng Sure 9 The Gift Always Comes Back 10 News The Moan 11 New Books and the Shout James Noel on African American Religious Experience Background: “Continuity,” painted by James Noel ake a black sermon, print it in a book, then read it, and you have no idea what it means because it has been abstracted from the living worship of the black church, says T the Rev. Dr. James Noel, (Ph.D. ’99), Farlough Professor of African American Christianity at the San Francisco Theological Seminary. The sermon’s meaning, he says, is deter - mined by the hymns sung, the testimonials, the prayers said before and after the sermon’s deliv - ery, as well as what went on that week for parishioners. Coltrane “My fascination is with religious experience and its various modes of expression,” he says, “espe - “ cially African American religious experience, which is different than that of Europeans or white and the church Americans. The disciplines generated by both the Protestant Reformation and the Enlightenment — it’s the same aren’t adequate for elucidating black religion, and this has implications for theological education.” thing. Noel’s holistic view of African American religious experience and expression is reflected in his own life.
    [Show full text]
  • The Contemporary Confucian-Christian Encounter: Interreligious Or Intrareligious Dialogue?*
    San Jose State University SJSU ScholarWorks Faculty Publications Humanities January 1995 The onC temporary Confucian-Christian Encounter: Interreligious or Intrareligious Dialogue Christian Jochim San Jose State University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.sjsu.edu/humanities_pub Part of the Arts and Humanities Commons Recommended Citation Christian Jochim. "The onC temporary Confucian-Christian Encounter: Interreligious or Intrareligious Dialogue" Journal of Ecumenical Studies (1995): 35-62. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Humanities at SJSU ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of SJSU ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Journal of Ecumenical Studies, 32:1, Winter 1995 THE CONTEMPORARY CONFUCIAN-CHRISTIAN ENCOUNTER: INTERRELIGIOUS OR INTRARELIGIOUS DIALOGUE?* Christian Jochim PRECIS The discipline of comparative religions has paid little attention to perhaps the most important religious phenomenon of the late twentieth century: interreligious dialogue. Avail­ able scholarship on this topic is largely written by and for participants in various dialogues. This scholarship is mainly on the normative issues that concern participants, thus leaving the need for descriptive, analytical scholarship largely unfilled. This essay engages in descriptive analysis of a relatively new twentieth-century dialogue— the Confucian-Christian dialogue —which, nevertheless, has deep historical roots. The essay turns, first, to history, summarizing two different periods of past Confucian-Christian en­ counter: the period from Matteo Ricci (1552-1610) to the World's Parliament of Religions (1893), and the twentieth-century period leading up to the recent international Confucian- Christian conferences. It turns, second, to the specific nature of the first, second, and third international Confucian-Christian international conferences (1988,1991, and 1994).
    [Show full text]
  • Many Yet One?
    Many yet One? MANY YET ONE? Multiple Religious Belonging Edited by Peniel Jesudason Rufus Rajkumar and Joseph Prabhakar Dayam MANY YET ONE? Multiple Religious Belonging Edited by Peniel Jesudason Rufus Rajkumar and Joseph Prabhakar Dayam Copyright © 2016 WCC Publications. All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in notices or reviews, no part of this book may be reproduced in any manner without prior written permission from the publisher. Write: pub- lications@wcc-coe. org. WCC Publications is the book publishing programme of the World Council of Churches. Founded in 1948, the WCC promotes Christian unity in faith, witness and service for a just and peaceful world. A global fellowship, the WCC brings together 345 Protestant, Or- thodox, Anglican and other churches representing more than 550 million Christians in 110 countries and works cooperatively with the Roman Catholic Church. Opinions expressed in WCC Publications are those of the authors. Scripture quotations are from the New Revised Standard Version Bible, © copyright 1989 by the Division of Christian Education of the National Council of the Churches of Christ in the USA. Used by permission. Cover design: Adele Robey, Phoenix Graphics, Inc. Book design and typesetting: Michelle Cook / 4 Seasons Book Design ISBN: 978-2-8254-1669-3 World Council of Churches 150 route de Ferney, P. O. Box 2100 1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland http://publications. oikoumene. org CONTENTS Contributors vii Introduction Peniel Jesudason Rufus Rajkumar and 1 Joseph Prabhakar Dayam 1. Eucharist Upstairs, Yoga Downstairs: On Multiple 5 Religious Participation John J. Thatamanil 2. On Doing as Others Do: Theological Perspectives 27 on Multiple Religious Practice S.
    [Show full text]
  • The Heart of Policy
    currents GTU NEWS OF THE G RADUATE T HEOLOGICAL U NION Where religion meets the world Spring 2006 what’s inside The Heart of Policy 3 Opening a Conversation “ t’s not that I’m advocating war, but there are cases where military force might 4 Bonnie Hardwick Looks Ibe necessary, and we’d better have a rational or ethical way to decide whether Back–and Forward it’s just or not.” 5 Adams Receives Sarlo Award Military intervention may not seem an intuitive area of study for the seminary, but for 2006 GTU doctoral graduate, lawyer, and mother Eileen Chamberlain 7 A Greater Effect for Good of Portola Valley, California, there is no incongruity. “My concern, which flows 10 Point of View: out of the moral concern, is that our current norms on using force can’t be Christian Mission squared necessarily within an ethical framework, and I’m trying to bring them into that framework.” Eileen Chamberlain, 12 News and Notes Ph.D. ’06 13 Commencement In her dissertation, Humanitarian Military Intervention: The Moral Imperative Versus the Rule of Law, Chamberlain examines both the ethical and legal justifications for using peacekeeping forces. She points out an egregious disconnect between theory and reality that undermines the rule of law and makes humanitarian policy less effective. Focusing her work ended up being “as simple as reading the newspaper. I just followed what seemed to matter to me,” she said. “I’ve always been interested in international law, and have done human rights work. When I first came to the Graduate Theological Union I had no idea that I would write about this, but the topic really brought together my passions.” A lawyer who had taken a hiatus when her third of four children was born, Chamberlain chose the GTU to I started“ with the follow a deeper calling.
    [Show full text]
  • Excerpts from Thinking Theologically About
    Thinking Theologically about Religious Others: Christian Theologies of Religions David R. Brockman Excerpted from David R. Brockman and Ruben L. F. Habito, ed., The Gospel among Religions: Christian Ministry, Theology, and Spirituality in a Multifaith World (Orbis Books, 2010), pp. 17-46. Copyright © 2010 by David R. Brockman and Ruben L. F. Habito. This excerpt is reproduced by permission of the copyright holders and may not be reproduced without explicit permission from Orbis Books. We explain the fact that the Milky Way is there by the doctrine of creation, but how do we explain the fact that the Bhagavad Gita is there?1 Wilfred Cantwell Smith’s question crystallizes a central concern of the Christian theology of religions. It is a question of origins: How do we as Christians account theologically for the existence of religions other than Christianity? If God is one, why are there so many religions?2 However, Christian theologies of religions rarely if ever stop at this etiological problem. They also wrestle with two other questions (or, more accurately, two constellations of questions). First, what is the relation of other religions to the Christian “thing”? Commonly—though by no means exclusively—this question is framed in soteriological terms: Are religious others3 in any sense “saved”? Does the fact that they do not believe in Christ place them beyond the scope of his saving work? The question of relations can also be framed in terms of validity: Does the fact that other religions differ in important respects from Christianity
    [Show full text]
  • A Critical Reflection of Christian Anthropocentrism and Ecological Crisis from a Taoist Perspective: a Contribution to Christian-Taoist Eco-Theology
    A Critical Reflection of Christian Anthropocentrism and Ecological Crisis from a Taoist Perspective: A Contribution to Christian-Taoist Eco-Theology by Wu, Tsui-Jung A thesis submitted to the University of Birmingham for the degree of MASTER OF PHILOSOPHY Department of Theology and Religion School of Philosophy, Theology and Religion College of Arts and Law The University of Birmingham December 2011 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................................... I ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ......................................................................................................................... II NOTES ON USE OF BIBLICAL AND TAOIST TEXTS ...................................................................... III GLOSSARY OF CHINESE TERMS ........................................................................................................ IV CHAPTER
    [Show full text]
  • CV Farhadian Updated
    CHARLES E. FARHADIAN Westmont College Department of Religious Studies Professor of World Religions and Christian Mission Office: 805.565.7094; Home: 805.969.3311 Email: [email protected] EDUCATION Seattle Pacific University, B.A. 1986 Yale University, M.Div. 1991 San Francisco Theological Seminary, Special student. 1993-1994 Boston University, Division of Religious and Theological Studies, Ph.D. 2001 Dissertation: A Social History of Urban Dani Christians in New Order Indonesia: An Examination of Western Missions, Indonesian Nation-State, and Modern Dani Identity in a Plural World. Comprehensive examinations in History of Christian Mission, Missiology, Anthropology of Religion. Chair, Dana Robert. TEACHING Underwood Distinguished Professor, Yonsei University, United Graduate School of Theology, Seoul, South Korea, fall semester, 2014. Taught one undergraduate and one doctoral course. Full Professor of World Religions and Christian Mission, Westmont College, Santa Barbara, CA. 2013-present. Additionally, Co-director of the World Christianity and Global Encounters of the 21st Century Lecture Series and Director of the Adams Mission fund, which supports mission-related lectures and research. Chair of the Department, beginning fall of 2013. Associate Professor of World Religions and Christian Mission, Westmont College, Santa Barbara, CA. 2007-present. Additionally, Co-director of the World Christianity and Global Encounters of the 21st Century Lecture Series and Director of the Adams Mission fund, which supports mission-related lectures and research. Tenure granted, 2010. Assistant Professor of World Religions and Christian Mission, Westmont College, Santa Barbara, CA, 2004 to 2007. Tenure-track teaching position in world religions and Christian mission. Additionally, co-director of the World Christianity and Global Encounters of the 21st Century Lecture Series.
    [Show full text]
  • About the Authors
    About the authors Seforosa Carroll (b. 1969) is a Fiji-born Rotuman. She spent her formative years growing up in Fiji, a multi-religious/multicultural context. She has lived in Australia since 1987. She was ordained as a Minister of the Word in the Uniting Church in Australia in 1999. Her theological research interests fall into two areas: cross cultural relationships/diasporic theologies and Christian theologies of other faiths, interfaith dialogue and encounters. Sef is currently a full time doctoral student at the School of Theology, Charles Sturt University. Her PhD research is on a feminist diasporic reading of interfaith dialogue and encounters in Australia. Sef is also the Administrator of Manah- ine Pasefika (Association of Oceanian Women Theologians) whose primary objective is to “make Oceanian women’s voices heard through print”. Sef has served both as a congregational minister at Caves Beach and Chaplain to MLC School, Burwood. Sef has been a visiting lecturer at the United Theo- logical College since 2000. Sef is married to Ralph and they have a daughter Sarah. Charles Farhadian ( b. 1964) holds a MDiv from Yale University and a PhD from Boston University. He is Associate Professor of World Religions and Christian Mission at Westmont College, Santa Barbara. Farhadian’s research is in Southeast Asia and Melanesia. His books include Christianity, Islam, and Nationalism in Indonesia (Routledge, 2005), Christian Worship World- wide: Expanding Horizons, Deepening Practices (Eerdmans, 2007), and The Testimony Project: Papua (Deiyai: West Papua, Indonesia, 2007). Currently he is editing, with co-editor Lewis Rambo, The Oxford Handbook of Reli- gious Religious Conversion.
    [Show full text]
  • Rev. Dr. J. Jayakiran Sebastian Dean of the Seminary and H
    Rev. Dr. J. Jayakiran Sebastian Dean of the Seminary and H. George Anderson Professor of Mission and Cultures United Lutheran Seminary | Gettysburg + Philadelphia Philadelphia campus: Gettysburg campus: 7301 Germantown Avenue 61 Seminary Ridge Philadelphia, PA 19119 Gettysburg, PA 17325 (Office) 215-248-7378 email: [email protected] Education: 1997 Doctor of Theology (Dr. theol.) University of Hamburg, Germany Magna cum laude 1991 Master of Theology (M.Th) Federated Faculty for Research in Religion and Culture, Kottayam First class. Prize: Master's Prize of the Senate of Serampore College for the highest grade in all branches of M.Th. Studies 1984 Bachelor of Divinity (B.D.) United Theological College, Bangalore First class. Prize: Senate of Serampore College Prize for highest grade in the B.D. Examination (Autonomous Colleges) 1980 Bachelor of Science (B.Sc.) Bangalore University, St. Joseph's College of Arts and Science, Bangalore First class Positions held: The United Lutheran Seminary (Gettysburg + Philadelphia) Dean of the Seminary (January 2018 – onward); Co-Dean of the Seminary (July 2017 – December 2017); H. George Anderson Professor of Mission and Cultures (July 2007 – onward) The Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia, Philadelphia, PA. (July 2007 – June2017) Dean of the Seminary (July 2012 – June 2017); H. George Anderson Professor of Mission and Cultures; Director, Multicultural Mission Resource Center; Seminary Chaplain (from July 2009 – June 2012) United Theological College, Bangalore, India. (June 1988 – August 2009) Positions held include: Professor of Theology and Ethics; Chairperson, Department of Theology and Ethics; Dean, Doctoral Division; Secretary of the Governing Council; and Editor, Bangalore Theological Forum. Minister of the Church of South India (1984 onward) Parish Ministry, full-time in rural and urban parishes of the Karnataka Central Diocese, and as an honorary Associate Presbyter; Currently regular preaching and presiding/celebrating at churches in the greater Philadelphia area.
    [Show full text]
  • Revisiting the Confucian Norms in Korean Church Growth
    International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Vol. 1 No. 13 [Special Issue – September 2011] Revisiting the Confucian Norms in Korean Church Growth Dr. Song-Chong Lee Assistant Professor Religious Studies and Philosophy The University of Findlay 334 Frazer Street #E, Findlay, OH 45840 United States of America Abstract This paper will explore the Confucian cultural norms, which the author believes have played a crucial role for the Korean church growth. There have been a considerable number of works dealing with the common aspects of Korean Christian and Confucian thoughts. However, not much comprehensive research has been done on the role of Confucianism particularly for the Korean church's growth. The author will discuss five major Confucian cultural norms: 1.Collectivism or Community-centered Value, 2. Heavy emphasis on education, 3. Heavy emphasis on excellent leadership, 4. The obsession with the orthodoxy and 5. The role as civil religion. I. Introduction Church growth in South Korea is one of the most interesting yet least studied topics, particularly in the field of religious studies. Many Christian leaders and scholars are well aware of the Korean church‟s explosive growth and overwhelming number of megachurches.1 The Protestant population in particular had consistently grown by the late 1990s and reached almost 30% of the entire population in 2002.2 In exploring the driving force of such an unprecedented phenomenon in church history, the insiders, without hesitation, would attribute it to the exclusive work of the Holy Spirit and the restless hard work and devotion of the Korean Christians.3 The outsiders, especially scholars of religious studies and sociology, however, may feel the necessity of a different kind of explanation that could consider diverse socio-cultural factors beyond the spiritual discourse.
    [Show full text]