How Family and Community Influences Affect Generations of Literacy Challenges
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of New England DUNE: DigitalUNE All Theses And Dissertations Theses and Dissertations 5-2018 Mothers’ Stories: How Family And Community Influences Affect Generations Of Literacy Challenges April Arfaras University of New England Follow this and additional works at: https://dune.une.edu/theses Part of the Educational Leadership Commons © 2018 April Arfaras Preferred Citation Arfaras, April, "Mothers’ Stories: How Family And Community Influences Affect Generations Of Literacy Challenges" (2018). All Theses And Dissertations. 158. https://dune.une.edu/theses/158 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at DUNE: DigitalUNE. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Theses And Dissertations by an authorized administrator of DUNE: DigitalUNE. For more information, please contact [email protected]. MOTHERS’ STORIES: HOW FAMILY AND COMMUNITY INFLUENCES AFFECT GENERATIONS OF LITERACY CHALLENGES By April Arfaras BA (University of South Florida) 1979 MAOM (University of Phoenix) 2006 A DISSERTATION Presented to the Affiliated Faculty of The College of Graduate and Professional Studies at the University of New England In Partial Fulfillment of Requirements For the Degree of Doctor of Education in Leadership Portland & Biddeford, Maine April 10, 2018 Copyright by April Arfaras April 10, 2018 ii April Arfaras April 10, 2018 Educational Leadership MOTHERS’ STORIES: HOW FAMILY AND COMMUNITY INFLUENCES AFFECT GENERATIONS OF LITERACY CHALLENGES Abstract This study critically examines America’s literacy crisis and focuses on the most affected: at-risk single-parent mothers of infant-toddlers. Illiteracy is a social justice concern that contributes to poverty, poor health, and crime, and affects the economy and America’s status as the former world leader in education. There is contention among academic, corporate, private, and government sources regarding the conflicting statistics of the severity of the literacy crisis (Amarao, 2016; Khazan, 2014; Layton, 2015; Rasco, 2017; Sugrue, 2008). Little is known from mothers closest to the problem (Knowles, 2015). The research questions addressed in this study are (1.) How do at-risk mothers describe their role in supporting their children’s language acquisition and literacy development? (2.) Given limited time and resources, what does a mother do to model language and literacy skills with her children? (3.) What strategies and influences do mothers use to ensure their children obtain preschool or early childhood education (ECE) and remain successfully enrolled? (4.) What advice do mothers offer other struggling mothers to address these literacy challenges? What help do they need? The literature review portrays literacy as an essential human right and explores the rudiments of language acquisition. Scholarly activists Paulo Freire, Thomas Paine, Tom Sugrue and Sven Beckert defend literacy as an inalienable right, yet social justice experts condemn the proliferation of the preschool to prison pipeline that impinges freedom of speech and the right to be literate. They fear it iii oppresses marginalized populations due to elitist profit incentives and corporate opportunists (Glaze, 2011; Hood, 2015; Sugrue, 2008). This qualitative phenomenological research study framed in language acquisition and social justice theories gives voice to at-risk mothers to inform the body of research of this imminent social problem by offering hope and viable findings toward resolution. Mothers leverage community and family relationships, resources, and obstacles to obtain literacy for their vulnerable families. An effective preschool program (a vital community resource) helps transform multiple generations of literacy challenges by “teaching mothers to reach their children” (Sticht & McDonald, 1990). Mothers’ best practices in literacy and language development, a showcase of leading literacy programs, and prospective literacy study recommendations, are featured. iv University of New England Doctor of Education Educational Leadership This dissertation was presented by April Arfaras It was presented on April 10, 2018 And approved by: Michelle Collay, Ph.D. Lead Advisor University of New England Andrew Ross, Ph.D. Secondary Advisor University of New England Aisha Howard, M.A. Affiliated Member v Hillsborough County Schools Portland and Biddeford, Maine April 10, 2018 vi DEDICATION It is with heartfelt sincerity that I dedicate this dissertation to my late parents, Paul and Jacquline Arfaras, who upheld unconditional love for their six beloved children and the joy of literacy, song, art, and culture, in the highest regard. A lifetime of thanks goes to the late children’s author Lois Lenski for sharing her inspirational stories and beautiful paintings at the playground near our childhood home in Tarpon Springs, Florida. Also, to Dr. Seuss for becoming the iconic leader of American literacy by inspiring parents and children to love reading and laughter and not allowing the academic establishment to dissuade his effective approach. Forever thanks go to my three adult children, Austin, Andrew, and Aubree for being the most lovable, successful, hilarious, literate creatures on the planet, and for their patience in being my test audience. Love always goes to my siblings Lisa, Claude, Adam, Nicky, and Alex. Respectfully, it is with humble gratitude that I thank my colleagues and dissertation advisors, Dr. Michelle Collay, Dr. Andrew Ross, Aisha Howard, and attorney Sally Campbell for their constant encouragement, recommendations, and support during this momentous journey. Finally, as well as most graciously, I am grateful for the Executive Director, Program Director, Center Director, and courageous mothers at the study centers who welcomed me into their wonderful preschool family to facilitate this study. Infinite thanks go to our Heavenly Father for my life and passion to complete this mission! Because of all of you, I have grown! vii TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ·········································································· 1 Overview ······························································································ 2 The Literacy Crisis: A Cyclical Epidemic ······················································· 3 Literacy & Criminal Justice System······················································ 4 The Context & Setting: Paradise or Paradox ····················································· 6 Problem Statement: Low Literate Mother’s Beliefs About Infant Learning Is Not Well Documented ··················································· 7 The Purpose of the Study: Breaking the Cycle of Illiteracy ··································· 8 Critical Research Questions About Literacy Crisis ············································· 9 Conceptual Framework ············································································· 9 Assumptions, Biases, Limitations, Significance, & Scope ····································13 Mothers’ Perceptions About Child’s Literacy ·········································13 Definition of Terms·················································································14 Researcher Bias ···········································································18 Limitations ··················································································19 Significance & Scope ·····································································19 Researcher Background & Ethics ································································20 Ethics ························································································20 Conclusion ···························································································21 CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ····························································22 Historical Background on Literacy & Democracy ·············································23 Language Acquisition Begins at Home ·················································24 viii The Impact of Speaking to Infants ······················································25 How Language Is Acquired ······························································25 How Babies Learn ·········································································26 Social Justice & The Literacy Crisis ·····························································27 Literacy & Economic Disparity ·························································28 Outdated Calculations & Justice ························································29 Discrepancies in Data Limits Resources ···············································29 Literacy & School Attrition ······························································30 School dropout facts ······························································31 Crime, Literacy & Civil Rights ··························································31 Incarceration facts ································································32 Literacy, Poverty, and Single-Parent Mothers ··················································32 Low Literacy & Poverty ··································································33 At-Risk Population Indicators····························································33 Poor Access to Resources Creates Inequity ············································35 Mothers of Young Children in Deep Poverty ··········································35 Poor Children of Immigrant Parents