Attitudes Towards the Male Contraceptive Pill: Psychosocial And
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Andrologie (2012) 22:171-179 DOI 10.1007/s12610-012-0185-4 ARTICLE ORIGINAL / ORIGINAL ARTICLE DOSSIER Attitudes towards the male contraceptive pill: psychosocial and cultural explanations for delaying a marketable product Regards sur la pilule contraceptive masculine : enjeux culturels et psychosociaux expliquant le report d’un produit commercialisable A. van Wersch · J. Eberhardt · F. Stringer Revised: February 22nd 2012, Accepted: May 16th 2012 © SALF et Springer-Verlag France 2012 Abstract Even though years of research on the male con- essais cliniques), la confiance – les femmes feraient-elles traceptive pill have been conducted, a marketable product confiance à leur partenaire pour utiliser une pilule masculine is still absent from the arsenal of male and female products efficacement, et les hommes auraient-ils confiance en eux- of contraception. In this paper, the following psychosocial mêmes –, la peur des effets secondaires, les perceptions de la and cultural factors have been elicited from the literature in responsabilité contraceptive et enfin la peur de la perte de order to reveal explanations for this delay: acceptability, masculinité. trust, fear of side-effects, perceptions of contraceptive Sans se soucier des variations culturelles, il semble glo- responsibility and fear of losing connotations of masculinity. balement exister une attitude positive à la fois des hommes et Regardless of cultural variation, overall there seems to be a des femmes en ce qui concerne l’acceptabilité d’une contra- positive attitude towards the acceptability of male contracep- ception masculine, plus particulièrement pour les hommes tive for both males and females, especially males in stable qui sont dans une relation stable. relationships. Some indication shows that the media have Il existe par ailleurs quelques indices laissant percevoir played an important role in distorting the results of research que les medias ont joué un rôle important en dénaturant les regarding male and female trust. Ongoing and future résultats de la recherche concernant la confiance des researches into several projects on psychosocial and cultural hommes et des femmes en l’utilisation d’une contraception factors are described. masculine. Les auteurs développent enfin plusieurs projets de Keywords Acceptability · Attitudes · Contraceptive recherche en cours sur les facteurs culturels et psychoso- ’ responsibility · Male pill · Masculinity · Psychosocial ciaux. Ils soulèvent aussi la nécessité d un modèle intégré factors de ces facteurs qui formatent les attitudes envers la pilule masculine, modèle nécessaire à l’évaluation de la variation psychosociale globale qui distingue les hommes les uns des Résumé Alors même que la pilule contraceptive masculine a autres dans la compréhension de la contraception hormonale fait l’objet d’années de recherche, sa commercialisation est masculine. toujours absente de l’arsenal des méthodes de contraception pour les hommes et les femmes. Mots clés Acceptabilité · Regards · Responsabilité Cet article a pour but de mettre à jour des explications à ce de la contraception · Pilule masculine · Masculinité · retard. Par une analyse de la littérature, menée par une Facteurs psychosociaux recherche sur sept bases de données en utilisant une combi- naison de plusieurs mots clés (pilule masculine, contracep- tion masculine hormonale, attitudes, et psychologie), les auteurs ont mis en évidence les facteurs culturels et psycho- Introduction sociaux suivants : l’acceptabilité (hypothétique et dans les Choices in male contraceptive methods are still limited to coitus interruptus, periodic abstinence, condom use or vasec- * A. van Wersch ( ) · J. Eberhardt · F. Stringer tomy. These methods have been criticised for being irrevers- Teesside University, Faculty of Social Science and Law, Middlesbrough, TS1 3BA, United Kingdom ible (vasectomy), as well as being inadequate (coitus inter- e-mail : [email protected] ruptus and periodic abstinence) [1]. Furthermore, condoms 172 Andrologie (2012) 22:171-179 are typically used in casual sexual encounters or the early contraceptive product which form the focus of this article. stages of a relationship, and are often abandoned once a rela- In addition, ways forward are presented in order to consider tionship becomes ‘serious’ [2]; they have also been criticised current research that is underway to aid progression in MHC for having an unacceptably high failure rate [3,4]. Female implementation. contraceptive methods, on the other hand, have been shown to be more reliable and successful, especially since the introduction of the female pill in the sixties. Nonetheless, Method 50% of the 1,000,000 conceptions occurring daily have been reported to still be unplanned [5]. In times of governmental A literature search was carried out on the following seven pleas for declining birth-rates around the globe and observed data bases: PsychINFO, ASSIA, Scopus, ScienceDirect, changes in the traditional gender roles in family life, the Ingenta, Medline and ISI for the time period 1990–2012. development and introduction of a male contraceptive pill, Several combinations of the following search words were which interestingly according to Manetti and Honig [6] used: male pill, male hormonal contraception, MHC, atti- predated the female pill through research on the effects of tudes and psychology. The papers were read and re-read testosterone on the suppression of spermatogenesis in until the most important findings started to emerge, which 1939, “… is surely long overdue”; especially since “men were subsequently summarised under the following themes: enjoy the pleasures of sex, but can do a little to contribute 1. acceptability; 2. trust; 3. fear of side-effects; 4. perceptions to the task of family planning” [5]. of contraceptive responsibility; and 5. fear of losing conno- For decennia, researchers have recognised the importance tations of masculinity. of developing less invasive, more reversible and tolerable methods of male contraception ideally with success rates equivalent to those of female contraception. Consequently, Psychosocial and cultural factors pharmaceutical research has continued to improve the substances necessary for this ideal male “pill”. In a recent Acceptability review, Manetti and Honig [6] presented the outcomes of these studies and listed the pros and cons of 16 male hor- A sizeable body of research has focused on attitudes and monal contraceptive options in four different clusters (testos- acceptability of a male contraceptive pill. These studies terone, testosterone-progestin combinations, testosterone have either examined the attitudes of those participating in with GnRH analogues and selective androgen receptor mod- MHC trials [8–11] or asked respondents about the hypothet- ulations) which have been tested and refined in international ical concept of a male contraceptive pill being made widely studies for over 40 years in various presentations (injections, available to the public [12–14]. Both types of studies oral pill, gel, plasters, implants, etc.). They concluded that have yielded largely encouraging results, as revealed in the male hormonal contraception (MHC) is reaching the high following sections. standard set by the female pill and vasectomy regarding effective prevention of conception, and is as such pharmaco- Hypothetical acceptability logically ready for implementation. Nonetheless, a market- able male pill remains elusive and unavailable for the gen- Whilst primarily regarding the hypothetical response, Hoesl eral public [7]. The reason behind this remains a mystery. et al. [1] carried out a literature research of PubMed publica- According to Manetti and Honig [6], this is due to concerns tions. They reported on cross cultural surveys, conducted in around long-term effects and male health implications. How- Scotland, China and South Africa by Anderson and Baird ever surely that would be very unfair considering that the [15] and Martin et al. [16], which showed that the majority female pill was introduced to the market less than ten years of females across these cultures generally accepted the pos- after its development, with refinement taking place along- sibility of a male pill, with 87% feeling it would serve as a side its use in practice during which side-effects and health viable means of contraception. Males also agreed with and problems became apparent. Does this mean that the image of accepted the usefulness of a new method of male contracep- the man as “Supermensch” and the woman as second-class tion. However, there was a disparity across the three cultures citizen is still very much alive in the 21st century? regarding the form of administration, with Scottish males On the whole, one does not seem to follow this line of preferring an oral presentation over implants, whereas the reasoning, since academics mostly refer to the socio- oral option proved the least favourable amongst Chinese political facets and the underlying psychosocial cultural fac- males. This is in line with a study conducted by Weston tors that play a role in the unmarketable pill [7]. It is the latter et al. [13], who found similar disagreement regarding the factors and their involvement in generating the powerful method of administration. Based on a survey comparing barriers that hinder the production and marketing of this seventy-six English speaking fathers born in South-East Andrologie (2012) 22:171-179 173 Asia or the Indian sub-continent with 116 Australian-born of contraception in