FORENSIC ODONTOLOGY Proceedings 2002-2011
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FORENSIC ODONTOLOGY Proceedings 2002-2011 FFoorreennssiicc Odontology Odontology American Academy of Forensic Sciences Proceedings 2002-p1 ii FFoorreennssiicc OOddoonnttoollooggyy iii AMERICAN ACADEMY OF FORENSIC SCIENCES 410 North 21st Street Colorado Springs, CO 80904 www.aafs.org The Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences is an official publication of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) and includes various areas of the forensic sciences such as pathology, toxicology, physical anthropology, psychiatry, odontology, jurisprudence, criminalistics, questioned documents, digital sciences, engineering sciences and other disciplines. The proceedings herein are from the Forensic Odontology section for the years 2002 to 2011. As with the Proceedings in which these abstracts were originally published, there is no implication or assertion that the AAFS, any of its sections, or any member of the AAFS have verified the statements and/or conclusions of the abstracts. The views expressed in this publication are not those of the AAFS or individual members. In short, the data and opinions appearing in the abstracts are the responsibility of the individual authors alone. All contents copyright 2002-2011 by the AAFS. Unless stated otherwise, noncommercial reproduction of material contained herein is permitted by the AAFS provided that the copying is faithful to the original. No other reproduction of any form may be done without prior written permission from the AAFS. Printed in the United States of America. iv Preface The American Academy of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) is a multi-disciplinary professional organization created and maintained to provide leadership in the application of science to the legal system. A premier forensic science organization, its specific objectives are to promote professionalism, integrity, competency and education, and to foster scientific research, improvements in the practice of forensic science, and collaboration within the many fields of forensic science. For sixty-three years, since its founding in 1948, the AAFS has served a distinguished and diverse membership. It comprises eleven different sections representing the broad range of expertise and interest of its members, now numbering over 6500. Included among them are physicians, attorneys, dentists, toxicologists, physical anthropologists, document examiners, psychiatrists, physicists, engineers, criminalists, educators, and digital evidence specialists. Representing all fifty US states, all ten Canadian provinces and 61 other countries from all corners of the world, AAFS members actively practice forensic science. In many cases, AAFS members also teach and conduct research in the field, producing hundreds of refereed publications and books. This collection of AAFS proceedings relating to the field of Forensic Odontology reflects the diversity of the field, which can broadly be defined as encompassing all of those instances where dentistry and odontology interact with the judicial system, law enforcement, and/or death investigation. This encompasses human identification and aging, disaster victim identification, analysis and comparison of bite injuries, abuse of children and adults, and dental malpractice or civil litigation involving dental injury or trauma. The authors of the abstracts contained herein represent varied experience levels, methodological protocols, and points of view. Collectively, they epitomize the cream of the crop in the broad field of Forensic Odontology. The goals of the Forensic Odontology section reflect those of the AAFS as a whole: promoting education and research in the forensic sciences, encouraging study, improving the practice, elevating the standards, and advancing the cause, of forensic odontology. We believe that we often learn best from the experience of our colleagues. Toward this educational goal, this volume marks the 41st year anniversary of forensic odontology in the AAFS. Forensic Odontology proceedings span conferences from 1991- v 2011. We are committed to sharing, teaching, and presenting research of new methodologies relating to the field of forensics, including those that are different from our own, to challenge our thinking and elevate the depth of our commitment to equitable scientific balance. The editors express gratitude to the past and present AAFS leadership, especially the AAFS staff headed by Executive Director Anne Warren and the AAFS Presidents since 1949. Academy Presidents Robert E. Barsley, DDS, JD 2012-13 Douglas H. Ubelaker, PhD 2011-12 Lowell J. Levine, DDS 1980-81 Joseph P. Bono, MA 2010-11 June K. Jones, MS 1979-80 Thomas L. Bohan, PhD, JD 2009-10 Kurt M. Dubowski, PhD 1978-79 Carol E. Henderson, JD 2008-09 B. Edward Whittaker, BS 1977-78 Bruce A. Goldberger, PhD 2007-08 James T. Weston, MD 1976-77 James G. Young, MD 2006-07 Robert J. Joling, JD 1975-76 Edmund R. Donoghue, MD 2005-06 David A. Crown, DCrim 1974-75 Ronald L. Singer, MS 2004-05 Morton F. Mason, PhD 1973-74 Kenneth E. Melson, JD 2003-04 Douglas M. Lucas, MSc, DSc 1972-73 Graham R. Jones, PhD 2002-03 Cyril H. Wecht, MD, JD 1971-72 Mary Fran Ernst, BLS 2001-02 Edwin C. Conrad, JD, PhD 1970-71 John D. McDowell, DDS, MS 2000-01 James W. Osterburg, MPA 1969-70 Patricia J. McFeeley, MD 1999-00 Maier I. Tuchler, MD 1968-69 Barry A.J. Fisher, MS, MBA. 1998-99 Charles S. Petty 1967-68 Michael A. Peat, PhD 1997-98 Jack L. Sachs, JD 1966-67 Richard Rosner, MD 1996-97 Robert B. Forney, PhD 1965-66 Haskell M. Pitluck, JD 1995-96 Dwight M. Palmer, MD 1964-65 Steven C. Batterman, PhD 1994-95 Oliver C. Schroeder, Jr., JD 1963-64 Enrico N. Togneri, BA 1993-94 Milton Helpern, MD 1962-63 Marina Stajic, PhD. 1992-93 S.R. Gerber, MD, LLB 1961-62 Homer R. Campbell, Jr., DDS 1991-92 Russel S. Fisher, MD 1960-61 Ellis R. Kerley, PhD. 1990-91 Ordway Hilton, MA 1959-60 Richard C. Froede, MD 1989-90 John F. Williams, BS 1958-59 Richard S. Frank, BS 1988-89 Val B. Satterfield, MD 1957-58 Yale H. Caplan, PhD 1987-88 Alan R. Moritz 1956-57 Don Harper Mills, JD, MD 1986-87 Fred E. Inbau, BS, LLB, 1955-56 Arthur D. Goldman, DMD 1985-86 A.W. Freireich, MD 1954-55 Maureen Casey Owens, AB 1984-85 Louis P. Regan, MD, LLB 1953-54 George E. Gantner, MD 1983-84 R.N. Harger, PhD 1952-53 Anthony Longhetti, BA 1982-83 S.A. Levinson, MD, PhD 1951-52 Joseph H. Davis, MD 1981-82 R.B.H. Gradwohl, MD 1949-51 vi Forensic Odontology Section Board of Directors Representatives and Chairs Board of Directors Representative Chair 2011-2012 Robert B.J. Dorion, DDS Richard A. Weems, DMD, MS 2010-2011 Robert B.J. Dorion, DDS Richard A. Weems, DMD, MS 2009-2010 Robert B.J. Dorion, DDS Gary M. Berman, DDS 2008-2009 Robert B.J. Dorion, DDS Gary M. Berman, DDS 2007-2008 Robert B.J. Dorion, DDS Thomas J. David, DDS 2006-2007 Robert E. Barsley, DDS, JD Thomas J. David, DDS 2005-2006 Robert E. Barsley, DDS, JD Bryan Chrz, DDS 2004-2005 Robert E. Barsley, DDS, JD Bryan Chrz, DDS 2003-2004 Robert E. Barsley, DDS, JD Pamela Hammel, DDS 2002-2003 Robert E. Barsley, DDS, JD Pamela Hammel, DDS 2001-2002 Robert E. Barsley, DDS, JD Franklin D. Wright, DMD 2000-2001 James McGivney, DMD Franklin D. Wright, DMD 1999-2000 James McGivney, DMD Michael P. Tabor, DDS 1998-1999 James McGivney, DMD Michael P. Tabor, DDS 1997-1998 Jeffrey R. Burkes, DDS Allan J. Warnick, DDS 1996-1997 Jeffrey R. Burkes, DDS Allan J. Warnick, DDS 1995-1996 Jeffrey R. Burkes, DDS James McGivney, DMD 1994-1995 John D. McDowell, DDS James McGivney, DMD 1993-1994 John D. McDowell, DDS Jeffrey R. Burkes, DDS 1992-1993 John D. McDowell, DDS Jeffrey R. Burkes, DDS 1991-1992 Norman D. Sperber, DDS John D. McDowell, DDS 1990-1991 Norman D. Sperber, DDS John D. McDowell, DDS 1989-1990 Norman D. Sperber, DDS Gregory S. Golden, DDS 1988-1989 Edward E. Herschaft, DDS, MA Gregory S. Golden, DDS 1987-1988 Edward E. Herschaft, DDS, MA Norman D. Sperber, DDS 1986-1987 Edward E. Herschaft, DDS, MA Norman D. Sperber, DDS 1985-1986 William S. Giles, DDS, MSD Edward E. Herschaft, DDS, MA 1984-1985 William S. Giles, DDS, MSD Edward E. Herschaft, DDS, MA 1983-1984 William S. Giles, DDS, MSD Raymond D. Rawson, DDS, MA 1982-1983 Homer R. Campbell, Jr., DDS Raymond D. Rawson, DDS, MA 1981-1982 Homer R. Campbell, Jr., DDS William S. Giles, DDS, MSD 1980-1981 Homer R. Campbell, Jr., DDS William S. Giles, DDS, MSD 1979-1980 Arthur D. Goldman, DMD John W. Beckstead, DDS 1978-1979 Arthur D. Goldman, DMD John W. Beckstead, DDS 1977-1978 Arthur D. Goldman, DMD Stanley Schwartz, DMD 1976-1977 Lowell J. Levine, DDS Arthur D. Goldman, DMD 1975-1976 Lowell J. Levine, DDS Arthur D. Goldman, DMD 1974-1975 Lowell J. Levine, DDS Edward Woolridge, Jr., DDS, LLB 1973-1974 Lester L. Luntz, DDS Lowell J. Levine, DDS 1972-1973 Lester L. Luntz, DDS Lowell J. Levine, DDS 1971-1972 Lester L. Luntz, DDS Lowell J. Levine, DDS vii This further acknowledges the excellent work of all our forensic odontology authors and colleagues worldwide who are willing to share their work for educational purpose. Robert E. Barsley, DDS, JD Robert B. J. Dorion, DDS Prepared by: 1 Laura L. Liptai, PhD Engineering Sciences 1 The Executive Committee of The American Academy of Forensic Sciences has directed Laura Liptai, Ph.D. of the Engineering Sciences Section to prepare this volume for publication. viii Table of Contents Index of Title by Year 2011 .......................................................................................................................................................................... Index 1 2010 .........................................................................................................................................................................