030513 MDL 2179 PM1314 JS Spot Ckd Rest Merged In
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1815 1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 2 EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA 3 4 IN RE: OIL SPILL BY THE OIL RIG * Docket 10-MD-2179 DEEPWATER HORIZON IN THE * 5 GULF OF MEXICO ON APRIL 20, 2010 * Section J * 6 Applies to: * New Orleans, Louisiana * 7 Docket 10-CV-02771, * March 5, 2013 IN RE: THE COMPLAINT AND * 8 PETITION OF TRITON ASSET * LEASING GmbH, et al * 9 * Docket 10-CV-4536, * 10 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. * BP EXPLORATION & PRODUCTION, * 11 INC., et al * * 12 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 13 14 DAY 6, AFTERNOON SESSION TRANSCRIPT OF NONJURY TRIAL 15 BEFORE THE HONORABLE CARL J. BARBIER UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE 16 17 Appearances : 18 For the Plaintiffs: Domengeaux Wright Roy 19 & Edwards, LLC BY: JAMES P. ROY, ESQ. 20 556 Jefferson Street, Suite 500 Post Office Box 3668 21 Lafayette, Louisiana 70502 22 For the Plaintiffs: Herman Herman & Katz, LLC 23 BY: STEPHEN J. HERMAN, ESQ. 820 O'Keefe Avenue 24 New Orleans, Louisiana 70113 25 OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT 1816 1 Appearances : 2 For the Plaintiffs: Cunningham Bounds, LLC 3 BY: ROBERT T. CUNNINGHAM, ESQ. 1601 Dauphin Street 4 Mobile, Alabama 36604 5 For the Plaintiffs: Lewis Kullman Sterbcow & Abramson 6 BY: PAUL M. STERBCOW, ESQ. 601 Poydras Street, Suite 2615 7 New Orleans, Louisiana 70130 8 For the Plaintiffs: Breit Drescher Imprevento 9 & Walker, PC BY: JEFFREY A. BREIT, ESQ. 10 600 22nd Street, Suite 402 Virginia Beach, Virginia 23451 11 12 For the Plaintiffs: Leger & Shaw BY: WALTER J. LEGER JR., ESQ. 13 600 Carondelet Street, 9th Floor New Orleans, Louisiana 70130 14 15 For the Plaintiffs: Watts Guerra Craft, LLP BY: MIKAL C. WATTS, ESQ. 16 4 Dominion Drive Building 3, Suite 100 17 San Antonio, Texas 78257 18 For the Plaintiffs: Williams Law Group, LLC 19 BY: CONRAD "DUKE" WILLIAMS, ESQ. 435 Corporate Drive, Suite 101 20 Houma, Louisiana 70360 21 For the Plaintiffs: Thornhill Law Firm 22 BY: TOM THORNHILL, ESQ. 1308 Ninth Street 23 Slidell, Louisiana 70458 24 25 OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT 1817 1 Appearances : 2 For the Plaintiffs: deGravelles Palmintier Holthaus & Frugé, LLP 3 BY: JOHN W. DEGRAVELLES, ESQ. 618 Main Street 4 Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70801 5 For the Plaintiffs: Williamson & Rusnak 6 BY: JIMMY WILLIAMSON, ESQ. 4310 Yoakum Boulevard 7 Houston, Texas 77006 8 For the Plaintiffs: Irpino Law Firm 9 BY: ANTHONY IRPINO, ESQ. 2216 Magazine Street 10 New Orleans, Louisiana 70130 11 For the United States U.S. Department of Justice 12 of America: Torts Branch, Civil Division BY: R. MICHAEL UNDERHILL, ESQ. 13 450 Golden Gate Avenue 7-5395 Federal Bldg., Box 36028 14 San Francisco, California 94102 15 For the United States U.S. Department of Justice 16 of America: Environment & Natural Resources Environmental Enforcement Section 17 BY: STEVEN O'ROURKE, ESQ. SCOTT CERNICH, ESQ. 18 DEANNA CHANG, ESQ. RACHEL HANKEY, ESQ. 19 A. NATHANIEL CHAKERES, ESQ. Post Office Box 7611 20 Washington, D.C. 20044 21 For the United States U.S. Department of Justice 22 of America: Torts Branch, Civil Division BY: JESSICA McCLELLAN, ESQ. 23 MICHELLE DELEMARRE, ESQ. JESSICA SULLIVAN, ESQ. 24 SHARON SHUTLER, ESQ. MALINDA LAWRENCE, ESQ. 25 Post Office Box 14271 Washington, D.C. 20004 OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT 1818 1 Appearances : 2 For the United States U.S. Department of Justice 3 of America: Fraud Section Commercial Litigation Branch 4 BY: DANIEL SPIRO, ESQ. KELLEY HAUSER, ESQ. 5 ELIZABETH YOUNG, ESQ. Ben Franklin Station 6 Washington, D.C. 20044 7 For the State of Attorney General of Alabama 8 Alabama: BY: LUTHER STRANGE, ESQ. COREY L. MAZE, ESQ. 9 WINFIELD J. SINCLAIR, ESQ. 500 Dexter Avenue 10 Montgomery, Alabama 36130 11 For the State of Attorney General of Louisiana 12 Louisiana: BY: JAMES D. CALDWELL, ESQ. 1885 North Third Street 13 Post Office Box 94005 Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70804 14 15 For the State of Kanner & Whiteley, LLC Louisiana: BY: ALLAN KANNER, ESQ. 16 DOUGLAS R. KRAUS, ESQ. 701 Camp Street 17 New Orleans, Louisiana 70130 18 For BP Exploration & Liskow & Lewis, APLC 19 Production Inc., BY: DON K. HAYCRAFT, ESQ. BP America Production 701 Poydras Street, Suite 5000 20 Company, BP PLC: New Orleans, Louisiana 70139 21 For BP Exploration & Kirkland & Ellis, LLP 22 Production Inc., BY: J. ANDREW LANGAN, ESQ. BP America Production HARIKLIA "CARRIE" KARIS, ESQ. 23 Company, BP PLC: MATTHEW T. REGAN, ESQ. 300 N. Lasalle 24 Chicago, Illinois 60654 25 OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT 1819 1 Appearances : 2 For BP Exploration & Covington & Burling, LLP 3 Production Inc., BY: ROBERT C. "MIKE" BROCK, ESQ. BP America Production 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW 4 Company, BP PLC: Washington, D.C. 20004 5 For Transocean Holdings Frilot, LLC 6 LLC, Transocean Offshore BY: KERRY J. MILLER, ESQ. Deepwater Drilling Inc., 1100 Poydras Street, Suite 3700 7 Transocean Deepwater Inc.: New Orleans, Louisiana 70163 8 For Transocean Holdings Sutherland Asbill & Brennan, LLP 9 LLC, Transocean Offshore BY: STEVEN L. ROBERTS, ESQ. Deepwater Drilling Inc., RACHEL G. CLINGMAN, ESQ. 10 Transocean Deepwater Inc.: 1001 Fannin Street, Suite 3700 Houston, Texas 77002 11 12 For Transocean Holdings Munger Tolles & Olson, LLP LLC, Transocean Offshore BY: MICHAEL R. DOYEN, ESQ. 13 Deepwater Drilling Inc., BRAD D. BRIAN, ESQ. Transocean Deepwater Inc.: LUIS LI, ESQ. 14 335 S. Grand Avenue, 35th Floor Los Angeles, California 90071 15 16 For Transocean Holdings Mahtook & Lafleur LLC, Transocean Offshore BY: RICHARD J. HYMEL, ESQ. 17 Deepwater Drilling Inc., 600 Jefferson Street, Suite 1000 Transocean Deepwater Inc.: Post Office Box 3089 18 Lafayette, Louisiana 70501 19 For Transocean Holdings Hughes Arrell Kinchen, LLP 20 LLC, Transocean Offshore BY: JOHN KINCHEN, ESQ. Deepwater Drilling Inc., 2211 Norfolk, Suite 1110 21 Transocean Deepwater Inc.: Houston, Texas 77098 22 For Cameron International Stone Pigman Walther Wittmann, LLC 23 Corporation: BY: PHILLIP A. WITTMANN, ESQ. 546 Carondelet Street 24 New Orleans, Louisiana 70130 25 OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT 1820 1 Appearances : 2 For Cameron International Beck Redden & Secrest, LLP 3 Corporation: BY: DAVID J. BECK, ESQ. DAVID W. JONES, ESQ. 4 GEOFFREY GANNAWAY, ESQ. ALEX B. ROBERTS, ESQ. 5 1221 McKinney Street, Suite 4500 Houston, Texas 77010 6 7 For Halliburton Energy Godwin Lewis, PC Services, Inc.: BY: DONALD E. GODWIN, ESQ. 8 BRUCE W. BOWMAN JR., ESQ. FLOYD R. HARTLEY JR., ESQ. 9 GAVIN HILL, ESQ. 1201 Elm Street, Suite 1700 10 Dallas, Texas 75270 11 For Halliburton Energy: Godwin Lewis, PC 12 Services, Inc.: BY: JERRY C. VON STERNBERG, ESQ. 1331 Lamar, Suite 1665 13 Houston, Texas 77010 14 For M-I, LLC: Morgan Lewis & Bockius 15 BY: HUGH E. TANNER, ESQ. DENISE SCOFIELD, ESQ. 16 JOHN C. FUNDERBURK, ESQ. 1000 Louisiana Street, Suite 4000 17 Houston, Texas 77002 18 Official Court Reporter: Jodi Simcox, RMR, FCRR 19 500 Poydras Street, Room HB-406 New Orleans, Louisiana 70130 20 (504) 589-7780 [email protected] 21 22 23 24 Proceedings recorded by mechanical stenography using computer-aided transcription software. 25 OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT 1821 2:13PM 1 I N D E X 2:13PM 2 Page 2:13PM 3 2:13PM Miles Randal Ezell 2:13PM 4 Cross-Examination By Mr. Hartley: 1822 2:13PM Cross-Examination By Mr. Brock: 1847 2:13PM 5 Cross-Examination By Mr. Beck: 1880 2:13PM Redirect Examination By Mr. Sterbcow: 1887 2:13PM 6 Redirect Examination By Ms. Clingman: 1903 2:13PM 2:13PM 7 Ronnie W. Sepulvado 2:13PM Direct Examination By Mr. Williams: 1918 2:13PM 8 Cross-Examination By Mr. Underhill: 1947 2:13PM Cross-Examination By Mr. Kraus: 1954 2:13PM 9 Direct Examination By Ms. Karis: 1958 2:13PM 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT 1822 MILES RANDAL EZELL - CROSS 1:14PM 1 AFTERNOON SESSION 1:14PM 2 (March 5, 2013) 1:21PM 3 * * * * * 1:38PM 4 THE DEPUTY CLERK: All rise. 1:38PM 5 THE COURT: All right. Good afternoon, everyone, 1:38PM 6 again. Please be seated. 1:38PM 7 Let's see. Who's up next? Halliburton? 1:39PM 8 MR. GODWIN: Yes, Your Honor. 1:39PM 9 THE COURT: Okay. 1:39PM 10 MR. HARTLEY: Thank you, Your Honor. Floyd Hartley 1:39PM 11 for Halliburton, I'll be taking Mr. Ezell on cross. 10:32AM 12 (WHEREUPON, MILES RANDAL EZELL , having been 10:32AM 13 previously duly sworn, testified as follows.) 1:39PM 14 CROSS-EXAMINATION 1:39PM 15 BY MR. HARTLEY: 1:39PM 16 Q. Good afternoon, Mr. Ezell. 1:39PM 17 A. Good afternoon. 1:39PM 18 Q. I want to start with the morning meeting that you had on 1:39PM 19 the morning of April 20th, 2010. I think, in response to both 1:39PM 20 Mr. Sterbcow's question and Ms. Clingman's, you said that there 1:39PM 21 was at least some discussion about the cement job. Is that 1:39PM 22 right? 1:39PM 23 A. Yes. 1:39PM 24 Q. And if I heard correctly, you said that it was deemed to 1:39PM 25 be a successful cement job? OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT 1823 MILES RANDAL EZELL - CROSS 1:39PM 1 A. To the best of my recollection, yes. 1:39PM 2 Q. This was a BP engineer on shore that's conveying that 1:39PM 3 information? 1:39PM 4 A. My memory's not clear exactly who it was that conveyed it, 1:39PM 5 but I heard it. 1:39PM 6 Q. And as a result, that they were not going to run a cement 1:39PM 7 bond log? 1:39PM 8 A. Yes. 1:39PM 9 Q. There were cement bond log tools on the rig that morning? 1:39PM 10 A.