Being Métis in Canada: an Unsettled Identity

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Being Métis in Canada: an Unsettled Identity BEING MÉTIS IN CANADA: AN UNSETTLED IDENTITY A thesis submitted to the University of Manchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities. 2017 SINÉAD O’SULLIVAN SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCE Table of Contents Table of Contents ................................................................................................................................ 2 Acronyms ............................................................................................................................................ 4 List of Images ...................................................................................................................................... 5 Abstract ............................................................................................................................................... 6 Declaration .......................................................................................................................................... 7 Copyright Statement ........................................................................................................................... 7 Dedication ........................................................................................................................................... 8 Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................................. 8 Chapter 1. Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 9 General introduction ....................................................................................................................... 9 A short history of Métis ................................................................................................................ 11 Research questions ....................................................................................................................... 28 Methods ........................................................................................................................................ 32 Structure of this thesis .................................................................................................................. 40 Chapter 2. “Seeing no feathers or beads, the white authorities saw no Indians at all”: the background to Métis aboriginal rights claims ................................................................................... 47 Introduction: legal aboriginality in Canada ................................................................................... 47 The legal category of “Indian” ...................................................................................................... 50 The legal category of “Métis” ....................................................................................................... 56 Political organisations and the 1982 Constitution ........................................................................ 60 One Métis Nation, or several Métis peoples? .............................................................................. 64 The concept of aboriginal rights ................................................................................................... 74 Aboriginal rights in other post-colonial contexts .......................................................................... 76 The judicialisation of aboriginal rights in Canada ......................................................................... 84 Métis aboriginal rights .................................................................................................................. 89 Chapter 3. Métis in the courts: R. v. Hirsekorn, 2013 ....................................................................... 93 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 93 Background to the Hirsekorn case ................................................................................................ 98 The Hirsekorn trial ...................................................................................................................... 108 Hirsekorn at the Calgary Court of Appeal ................................................................................... 115 Conclusion: Métis in the courts .................................................................................................. 140 Chapter 4. “Beads, bibles and buffalo”: Métis in museums and festivals ...................................... 149 2 Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 149 Museums and aboriginal peoples: a brief discussion ................................................................. 151 Indigenous museums .................................................................................................................. 162 The Michif Cultural and Resource Centre (the Michif museum), St Albert ................................ 168 The Michif museum as a community or ‘gathering place’ .......................................................... 179 A Métis community beyond the Michif: in the ‘Festival City’ of Edmonton ............................... 186 The Métis Spring Festival, May 2013 .......................................................................................... 188 Conclusions ................................................................................................................................. 198 Chapter 5. “I used to be Métis” ...................................................................................................... 202 Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 202 ‘I’m Aboriginal; I should be able to do this!’ ............................................................................... 207 Identity, ethnicity, and groups: borders and boundaries ........................................................... 222 ‘I used to be Métis’: the borders of Métisness ........................................................................... 227 ‘Aboriginal heritage, but not aboriginal’ ..................................................................................... 234 Conclusions: The boundaries of Métis identity .......................................................................... 248 Chapter 6. Conclusions: ‘The struggle for recognition is gradually transformed into the struggle for “definition”’ .................................................................................................................................... 252 Afterword: the context in 2017 .................................................................................................. 266 Reference List .................................................................................................................................. 270 Books and Articles ....................................................................................................................... 270 Jurisprudence .............................................................................................................................. 295 Laws and statutes ....................................................................................................................... 296 Final word count: 79,171 words 3 Acronyms AFN Assembly of First Nations CAP Congress of Aboriginal Peoples HBC Hudson’s Bay Company IMHA Interim Métis Harvesting Agreement MCA Métis Constitutional Alliance MCC Métis Constitutional Council MHA Métis Harvesting in Alberta MMF Manitoba Métis Federation MNA Métis Nation of Alberta MNAHP Métis Nation of Alberta Harvesting Policy MNC Métis National Council MNS Métis Nation of Saskatchewan NCC Native Council of Canada NDP New Democratic Party RCAP Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples RCMP Royal Canadian Mounted Police 4 List of Images Fig. 1.1 Métis trade routes map, p.13. Fig. 2.1 National definition of Métis, image, p.66. Fig. 3.1 Map of Alberta, p.106. Fig. 3.2 Métis beaded jacket, photograph, p.115. Fig. 3.3 Métis Homeland map, p.128. Fig. 3.4 First Nations in Alberta, map, p.135. Fig. 4.1 Historic Juneau House, image, p.168. Fig. 4.2 Métis beadwork, photograph, p.173. Fig. 4.3 The Sash, image, p.194. Fig. 5.1 Moccasins, photograph, p.208. Fig. 5.2 Hand-made moccasins, photograph, p.212. 5 Abstract The University of Manchester Sinéad O’Sullivan PhD Social Anthropology Being Métis in Canada: An Unsettled Identity March 2017 Abstract In 1982, the Canadian constitution included Métis as one of the aboriginal peoples of Canada, who may be entitled to certain aboriginal rights. Making aboriginal rights claims has required Métis, as a category, to be understood in a bounded, rigid manner, to fit with the wider legal system of categories of aboriginal peoples (First Nations, Inuit). Métis, as an identity, has been seen as a category based on aboriginality and mixed ancestry, but it is contested by many actors including the Canadian state, Métis organisations, academics and Métis themselves whether this means mixedness of ancestry in general (a residual category of aboriginal but not First Nations/Inuit), or a specific case of mixed ancestry in the Canadian interior in the 18th- and 19th-centuries (the Red River/Historic Métis Nation). The category of Métis is not only uncertain
Recommended publications
  • Emergence Andevolution of Themétis Nation
    Emergence and Evolution of the Métis Nation Métis National Council September 2019 People of mixed ancestry appeared in eastern Canada soon after initial contact between Indians and Europeans. With large-scale European immigration and agricultural settlement in eastern Canada, these people of mixedBy ancestry President were generally Clément absorbed into Chartier, the settler or QCIndian populations. It was on the isolated Métisplains of westernNational North AmericaCouncil during the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries that people of mixed ancestry emerged as a new and distinct people and nation. TheINVESTING fur trade companies operating IN ABORIGINAL in this territory - the Hudson’s CANADA Bay Company 2014 and! the North West Company - had a common interest in blocking agricultural settlement and large-scale immigration onto the westernOttawa,ON plains from! the British colonies to the east. December 9, 2014! Hence, the mixed offspring of French fur traders from the North West Company or Scottish fur traders from the Hudson’s Bay Company1 and their Cree, Ojibwe, or Dene wives formed an ever- increasing proportion of the fur trade population. As the numbers of the mixed offspring grew and married among themselves, they developed a new culture, neither European nor Indian, but a fusion of the two. Thus, the Métis people emerged. 4 Emergence and Evolution of the Métis Nation Their Michif language mixed the French, Cree, and Ojibwe languages. Their dance form combined the reels of Scotland with the intricate steps of Plains Indians. Their dress, as can be seen in this photo, was semi-European, semi- Indian in style but of European cut and was often decorated with glass beads and quills.
    [Show full text]
  • Cross-Border Employment in the Windsor-Essex & Southeastern
    Cross-Border Employment in the Windsor-Essex & Southeastern Michigan Corridor Photo Credit: Windsor-Essex Economic Development Corporation We would like to thank everyone who contributed their time, ideas and expertise to the Cross-Border Employment in the Windsor-Essex and Southeastern Michigan Corridor report. Workforce WindsorEssex would also like to thank Katie Renaud, Tashlyn Teskey, Heather Gregg, and Tanya Antoniw for their work in developing and authoring this report. Thanks are also due to the Ministry of Advanced Education and Skills Development for their support. Front and back cover designs by Imaginative Imaging Printing by Imaginative Imaging How did we do? We invite your feedback on all publications produced by Workforce WindsorEssex. www.workforcewindsoressex.com 880 N Service Rd #201, Windsor ON N8X 3J5 Phone: 226-674-3220 [email protected] This document may be freely quoted and reproduced without permission from Workforce WindsorEssex provided that the content remains the same and that the organization is acknowledged as the author of this document. Workforce WindsorEssex is committed to ongoing research to enhance local labour market planning in the Windsor-Essex region. Workforce WindsorEssex assumes no responsibility for its use or for the consequences of any errors or omissions. The views expressed in this document do not necessarily reflect those of the Government of Ontario or the Government of Canada. Ce projet est financè par le Gouvernement de l’Ontario 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ...........................................................................................4
    [Show full text]
  • Métis Government Recognition and Self-Government Agreement
    Métis Government Recognition and Self-Government Agreement -between- Métis Nation of Ontario -and- Canada TABLE OF CONTENTS PART I DEFINITIONS, PURPOSE, RECOGNITION, AND FEDERAL RECOGNITION LEGISLATION ....................................................................3 Chapter 1: Definitions and Interpretation ...............................................................3 Definitions ..........................................................................................................3 Interpretation .....................................................................................................6 Chapter 2: Purpose ...................................................................................................6 Chapter 3: Federal Recognition ................................................................................7 Chapter 4: Federal Recognition Legislation.............................................................8 PART II SELF-GOVERNMENT IMPLEMENTATION ...............................................9 Chapter 5: Requirements ..........................................................................................9 PART III MÉTIS GOVERNMENT’S CONSTITUTION ................................................9 Chapter 6: Constitution ............................................................................................9 PART IV MÉTIS GOVERNMENT’S LEGAL STATUS, ROLE, JURISDICTION, LAWS, AND AUTHORITY ............................................................................ 11 Chapter 7: Legal Status and Capacity
    [Show full text]
  • National Inquiry Into Murdered and Missing Indigenous Women and Girls
    Registrar's note: Portions of this Final Written Submission have been redacted pursuant to Rule 55 of the Commission's Legal Path: Rules of Respectful Practice. National Inquiry into Murdered and Missing Indigenous Women and Girls AFFIDAVIT OF MELANIE OMENIHO, PRESIDENT Women of the Métis Nation/Les Femmes Michif Otipemisiwak I, MELANIE OMENIHO, of the City of Edmonton, in the Province of Alberta, MAKE OATH AND SAY: 1) My name is Melanie Omeniho. I am a Métis woman and a citizen of the Métis Nation. I am President of the one national organization that represents only Métis women – the Women of the Métis Nation/Les Femmes Michif Otipemisiwak (the “WMN/LFMO”). I have personal knowledge of the matters to which I hereinafter depose, except where stated to be on information and belief, and as to these last said matters I verily believe them to be true. My Background 2) I was born and raised in and around Edmonton. I have lived here all my life. I was raised to be a proud Métis woman and I have learned about my Métis Nation culture and history from my family, my community, my direct experience working for the Métis Nation and from the time I have spent with our Métis elders. 3) I have worked for the Métis Nation since 1986. I began working for my people in a variety of consulting and management positions. I first actively worked on issues concerning Métis women in 1986. I worked on Métis women’s issues for the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples, during the Meech Lake Accord, the Charlottetown constitutional negotiations, the Kelowna Accord and many other significant national events.
    [Show full text]
  • The 2006 Federal Liberal and Alberta Conservative Leadership Campaigns
    Choice or Consensus?: The 2006 Federal Liberal and Alberta Conservative Leadership Campaigns Jared J. Wesley PhD Candidate Department of Political Science University of Calgary Paper for Presentation at: The Annual Meeting of the Canadian Political Science Association University of Saskatchewan Saskatoon, Saskatchewan May 30, 2007 Comments welcome. Please do not cite without permission. CHOICE OR CONSENSUS?: THE 2006 FEDERAL LIBERAL AND ALBERTA CONSERVATIVE LEADERSHIP CAMPAIGNS INTRODUCTION Two of Canada’s most prominent political dynasties experienced power-shifts on the same weekend in December 2006. The Liberal Party of Canada and the Progressive Conservative Party of Alberta undertook leadership campaigns, which, while different in context, process and substance, produced remarkably similar outcomes. In both instances, so-called ‘dark-horse’ candidates emerged victorious, with Stéphane Dion and Ed Stelmach defeating frontrunners like Michael Ignatieff, Bob Rae, Jim Dinning, and Ted Morton. During the campaigns and since, Dion and Stelmach have been labeled as less charismatic than either their predecessors or their opponents, and both of the new leaders have drawn skepticism for their ability to win the next general election.1 This pair of surprising results raises interesting questions about the nature of leadership selection in Canada. Considering that each race was run in an entirely different context, and under an entirely different set of rules, which common factors may have contributed to the similar outcomes? The following study offers a partial answer. In analyzing the platforms of the major contenders in each campaign, the analysis suggests that candidates’ strategies played a significant role in determining the results. Whereas leading contenders opted to pursue direct confrontation over specific policy issues, Dion and Stelmach appeared to benefit by avoiding such conflict.
    [Show full text]
  • Border Crossings in Michigan
    ReasonReason forfor PresentationPresentation ►►ProvideProvide informationinformation onon Michigan’sMichigan’s borderborder crossingscrossings && theirtheir importanceimportance ►►CurrentlyCurrently operatingoperating underunder anan implicitimplicit BorderBorder PolicyPolicy embeddedembedded withinwithin thethe StateState LongLong RangeRange PPllanan ►►WouldWould likelike toto adoptadopt anan explicitexplicit BorderBorder PolicyPolicy OverviewOverview ► EconomicEconomic ImportanceImportance ► MDOT’sMDOT’s VisionVision ► CurrentCurrent GGooalsals ► ActionAction PlanPlan ► PlanPlanss atat EEaachch CroCrossssiingng ► StrategiesStrategies ► TheThe NextNext StepsSteps MichiganMichigan vs.vs. MontanaMontana TransportationTransportation ElementsElements forfor EconomicEconomic GrowthGrowth TransportationTransportation ElementsElements forfor EconomicEconomic GrowthGrowth AA goodgood transportationtransportation system:system: ►►ProvidesProvides forfor thethe seamlessseamless flowflow ofof goods,goods, servicesservices && peoplepeople ►►IncludesIncludes aa goodgood freightfreight networknetwork ►►EnsuresEnsures basicbasic mobilitymobility ►►IsIs securesecure && providesprovides redundancyredundancy (Homeland(Homeland security)security) TransportationTransportation ElementsElements forfor EconomicEconomic GrowthGrowth AA goodgood freightfreight systemsystem has:has: ► SufficientSufficient capacitycapacity ► ConnectivConnectivityity betwebetweenen && amoamonngg modesmodes && facilitiefacilitiess ► ModeMode choice:choice: rail,rail, road,road,
    [Show full text]
  • Canada's Immigration Policy, 1945 - 1962
    G. A. Rawlyk CANADA'S IMMIGRATION POLICY, 1945 - 1962 IT CAN BE EFFECTIVELY ARGUED that the primary concern of any nation is to ensure its own survival. For Canada, the desire to survive as a viable political entity, inde­ pendent of the powerful republic to the south, and to make actual the tremendous physical potential of the country, has forced the federal government to be particu­ larly concerned with immigration and immigration policy. However, because of periods of serious unemployment and because the Canadian people on the whole, in W. L. Mackenzie King's famous words, "do not wish as a result of mass immi­ gration to make a fundamental alteration in the character of our population"'! the Canadian government from 1945 to 1962 has carefully pursued a relatively flexible policy of restricted immigration. As would be expected, when there was considerable unemployment, as in 1955, 1957, 1958, 1959, 1960 and 196I,2 the immigration authorities, by reducing the number of immigrant visas granted, placed a severe check on the flow of immi­ grants. It is interesting to note that, with only one exception (1957), whenever the yearly average of the percentage of labour force unemployed climbed to over 4 per cent, the following year witnessed a sharp decline in the number of immigrants.s But when there was a demand for workers, the authorities quickly removed many of the temporary restrictive barriers. During these years, all too infrequent in the last decade, the absence of restrictions made one member of Parliament remark, "If you put pants on a penguin, it could be admitted to this country."4 In spite of the evident great need for a much larger population, it would be irresponsible for any government in Ottawa to fly in the face of the opposition of the majority of Canadians by adopting a policy of unrestricted immigration.5 D.
    [Show full text]
  • Canada and the Legacy of the Indian Residential Schools: Transitional Justice for Indigenous People in a Non-Transitional Society Courtney Jung
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Scholarship@Western Western University Scholarship@Western Aboriginal Policy Research Consortium International (APRCi) 3-18-2009 Canada and the Legacy of the Indian Residential Schools: transitional justice for indigenous people in a non-transitional society Courtney Jung Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/aprci Part of the Other Sociology Commons Citation of this paper: Jung, Courtney, "Canada and the Legacy of the Indian Residential Schools: transitional justice for indigenous people in a non- transitional society" (2009). Aboriginal Policy Research Consortium International (APRCi). 295. https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/aprci/295 Canada and the Legacy of the Indian Residential Schools: transitional justice for indigenous people in a non-transitional society Courtney Jung 1 March 18, 2009 The framework of transitional justice, originally devised to facilitate reconciliation in countries undergoing transitions from authoritarianism to democracy, is used with increasing frequency to respond to certain types of human rights violations against indigenous peoples. 2 In some cases, transitional justice measures are employed in societies not undergoing regime transition. Transitional justice measures offer opportunities for re-inscribing the responsibility of states toward their indigenous populations, empowering indigenous communities, responding to indigenous demands to be heard, and rewriting history. Nevertheless, treating indigenous demands for justice as a matter of “human rights” is an ethically loaded project that may reinforce liberal (and neo-liberal) paradigms that indigenous peoples often reject. Whether transitional justice measures will serve primarily to legitimate the status quo between post- colonial states, settler societies, and Aboriginal peoples, or whether they will have transformational capacity, will depend in part on the political context in which they take place.
    [Show full text]
  • Fort Beausejour National Historic Park Aulac, New Brunswick Canada
    Fort Beausejour National Historic Park Aulac, New Brunswick Canada Issued under the authority of the HONOURABLE ARTHUR LAING, P.C., M.P., B.S.A. Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development Original Earthen Bastion of French Period Fort Beausejour National Historic Park Aulac, New Brunswick At the middle of the 18th century the dividing line between French and British influence in Acadia lay along the Missaguash River, one of the four rivers that drain the southern slope of the Isthmus of Chignecto. In 1710 New England militiamen and British regulars had captured the French Port Royal, thus in one engagement effecting the conquest of the Nova Scotia main- land. The Treaty of Utrecht, concluded three years later, formally transferred Acadia to Great Britain. But what was Acadia? The British hopefully believed parts of what is now New Brunswick were included. The French, confident that they would soon win back the Nova Scotia mainland, could not consider such a broad definition of the geographical limits of Acadia. They were determined to hold as much ground as they could. Time seemed to be in their favor. Against the weak and ill-disciplined garrison at Annapolis Royal and the few detachments occupying isolated posts in the peninsula, the French could send Indian raiding parties. While the British struggled against the harassments of the Indians, the population of Acadia—over­ whelmingly French—could be provoked to at least passive resistance against their alien conquerors. French power preserved at the Fortress of Louisbourg on Cape Breton Island and at the settlements of New France along the St.
    [Show full text]
  • Women of New France
    Women of New France Introducing New France Today it may be hard to imagine that vast regions of the North American continent were once claimed, and effectively controlled, by France. By 1763 some 70,000 French speakers based primarily in what is now the province of Quebec, managed to keep well over 1,000,000 British subjects confined to the Atlantic seaboard from Maine to Florida. France claimed land that included 15 current states, including all of Michigan. The early history of North America is a story of struggle for control of land and resources by Women in New France French settlers in Nouvelle France (New France in English), English settlers We know very little about the everyday lives of people in what in the Thirteen Colonies, and Native peoples who already lived in the areas was New France, particularly the women. Native women, from a that became the US and Canada. wide range of nations along the St. Lawrence and Great Lakes river system, had lived in North America for thousands of years before the arrival of French explorers. While there was a good deal of variety among Indian societies, most Native women lived more independent lives than did their European counterparts. In some societies, in addition to the usual child-rearing and household economy practices, Native women had real political power and could elect village and tribal leaders. New France 1719 European Women’s Roles European women’s lives, like those of their Native American counterparts, were shaped by the legal, cultural, and religious values of their society.
    [Show full text]
  • P:\HANADMIN\BOUND\Committees\27Th Legislature\2Nd Session 2009\HS Members-Presenter Pages for BV\HS Cover 100127.Wpd
    Legislative Assembly of Alberta The 27th Legislature Second Session Standing Committee on the Alberta Heritage Savings Trust Fund Wednesday, January 27, 2010 2 p.m. Transcript No. 27-2-6 Legislative Assembly of Alberta The 27th Legislature Second Session Standing Committee on the Alberta Heritage Savings Trust Fund Forsyth, Heather, Calgary-Fish Creek (WA), Chair Elniski, Doug, Edmonton-Calder (PC), Deputy Chair Blakeman, Laurie, Edmonton-Centre (AL) Campbell, Robin, West Yellowhead (PC) DeLong, Alana, Calgary-Bow (PC) Denis, Jonathan, Calgary-Egmont (PC) Johnston, Art, Calgary-Hays (PC) Kang, Darshan S., Calgary-McCall (AL) MacDonald, Hugh, Edmonton-Gold Bar (AL) Sandhu, Peter, Edmonton-Manning (PC)* * substitution for Jonathan Denis Department of Finance and Enterprise Participants Hon. Ted Morton Minister Rod Babineau Manager, Portfolio Analysis Aaron Brown Director, Portfolio Management Rod Matheson Assistant Deputy Minister, Treasury and Risk Management Tim Wiles Deputy Minister Alberta Investment Management Corporation Participants Leo de Bever Chief Investment Officer Douglas Stratton Director, Fund Management Group Auditor General’s Office Participants Fred Dunn Auditor General Merwan Saher Assistant Auditor General, Audit Division Betty LaFave Principal Support Staff W.J. David McNeil Clerk Louise J. Kamuchik Clerk Assistant/Director of House Services Micheline S. Gravel Clerk of Journals/Table Research Robert H. Reynolds, QC Senior Parliamentary Counsel Shannon Dean Senior Parliamentary Counsel Corinne Dacyshyn Committee Clerk Erin Norton Committee Clerk Jody Rempel Committee Clerk Karen Sawchuk Committee Clerk Rhonda Sorensen Manager of Communications Services Melanie Friesacher Communications Consultant Tracey Sales Communications Consultant Philip Massolin Committee Research Co-ordinator Stephanie LeBlanc Legal Research Officer Diana Staley Research Officer Rachel Stein Research Officer Liz Sim Managing Editor of Alberta Hansard Transcript produced by Alberta Hansard January 27, 2010 Heritage Savings Trust Fund HS-85 2 p.m.
    [Show full text]
  • Cricket As a Diasporic Resource for Caribbean-Canadians by Janelle Beatrice Joseph a Thesis Submitted in Conformity with the Re
    Cricket as a Diasporic Resource for Caribbean-Canadians by Janelle Beatrice Joseph A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of Exercise Sciences University of Toronto © Janelle Beatrice Joseph 2010 Cricket as a Diasporic Resource for Caribbean-Canadians Janelle Beatrice Joseph Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of Exercise Sciences University of Toronto 2010 Abstract The diasporic resources and transnational flows of the Black diaspora have increasingly been of concern to scholars. However, the making of the Black diaspora in Canada has often been overlooked, and the use of sport to connect migrants to the homeland has been virtually ignored. This study uses African, Black and Caribbean diaspora lenses to examine the ways that first generation Caribbean-Canadians use cricket to maintain their association with people, places, spaces, and memories of home. In this multi-sited ethnography I examine a group I call the Mavericks Cricket and Social Club (MCSC), an assembly of first generation migrants from the Anglo-Caribbean. My objective to “follow the people” took me to parties, fundraising dances, banquets, and cricket games throughout the Greater Toronto Area on weekends from early May to late September in 2008 and 2009. I also traveled with approximately 30 MCSC members to observe and participate in tours and tournaments in Barbados, England, and St. Lucia and conducted 29 in- depth, semi-structured interviews with male players and male and female supporters. I found that the Caribbean diaspora is maintained through liming (hanging out) at cricket matches and social events. Speaking in their native Patois language, eating traditional Caribbean foods, and consuming alcohol are significant means of creating spaces in which Caribbean- Canadians can network with other members of the diaspora.
    [Show full text]