MIDS Working Paper No. 237 RE-EXAMINING CULTURAL ACCOMMODATION AND DIFFERENCE IN THE HISTORIOGRAPHY OF SOUTH INDIAN CATHOLICISM CHANDRA MALLAMPALLI RE-EXAMINING CULTURAL ACCOMMODATION AND DIFFERENCE IN THE HISTORIOGRAPHY OF SOUTH INDIAN CATHOLICISM CHANDRA MALLAMPALLI MIDS Working Paper No. 237 December 2019 MIDS Working Paper No. 237 Re-examining Cultural Accommodation and Difference in the Historiography of South Indian Catholicism by Chandra Mallampalli (
[email protected]) Professor of History, Westmont College, Santa Barbara, and Visiting Fellow, Madras Institute of Development Studies, Chennai © Madras Institute of Development Studies, 2019 Published by Madras Institute of Development Studies 79, Second Main Road, Gandhi Nagar, Adyar, Chennai 600 020 INDIA Phone: 2441 1574/2589/2295/9771
[email protected] www.mids.ac.in RE-EXAMINING CULTURAL ACCOMMODATION AND DIFFERENCE IN THE HISTORIOGRAPHY OF SOUTH INDIAN CATHOLICISM CHANDRA MALLAMPALLI Abstract This essay explores the manner in which Catholicism adapted to South Indian society and shed its aura of foreignness. For the early Portuguese missionaries, cultural adaptation was not a priority and quite often was not desirable. Converts adopted Western clothes, surnames, and other cultural habits. But as Catholic congregations were established in regions farther removed from Goa, priests could not overcome natural tendencies of converts to observe local traditions. The Jesuits appear to have made a virtue out of a natural tendency toward cultural accommodation. Such accommodation is a distinctive feature of Indian Catholicism, but it is not the only development that needs to be accounted for. Against this heritage of accommodation, it is just as important to recognise and, if possible, explain the emergence of a distinctive Catholic identity.