DOCSLIB.ORG

The Converse of Abel's Theorem by Veniamine Kissounko a Thesis

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Converse of Abel's Theorem by Veniamine Kissounko a Thesis The Converse of Abel’s Theorem by Veniamine Kissounko A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of Mathematics University of Toronto Copyright c 2009 by Veniamine Kissounko Abstract The Converse of Abel’s Theorem Veniamine Kissounko Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of Mathematics University of Toronto 2009 In my thesis I investigate an algebraization problem. The simplest, but already non- trivial, problem in this direction is to find necessary and sufficient conditions for three graphs of smooth functions on a given interval to belong to an algebraic curve of degree three. The analogous problems were raised by Lie and Darboux in connection with the classification of surfaces of double translation; by Poincare and Mumford in connection with the Schottky problem; by Griffiths and Henkin in connection with a converse of Abel’s theorem; by Bol and Akivis in the connection with the algebraization problem in the theory of webs. Interestingly, the complex-analytic technique developed by Griftiths and Henkin for the holomorphic case failed to work in the real smooth setting. In the thesis I develop a technique of, what I call, complex moments. Together with a simple differentiation rule it provides a unified approach to all the algebraization problems considered so far (both complex-analytic and real smooth). As a result I prove two variants (’polynomial’ and ’rational’) of a converse of Abel’s theorem which significantly generalize results of Griffiths and Henkin. Already the ’polynomial’ case is nontrivial leading to a new relation between the algebraization problem in the theory of webs and the converse of Abel’s theorem. But, perhaps, the most interesting is the rational case as a new phenomenon occurs: there are forms with logarithmic singularities on special algebraic varieties that satisfy the ii converse of Abel’s theorem. In the thesis I give a complete description of such varieties and forms. iii Dedication To my Father iv Acknowledgements I would like to express my gratitude to all those who gave me the possibility to complete this thesis. I want to thank the Department of Mathematics at the University of Toronto for hav- ing me as a graduate student and, especially, our graduate coordinator Ida for constant help and attention. I am deeply indebted to my supervisor Professor Khovanskii for stating the problem, numerous stimulating discussions, encouragement and support throughout my graduate student life. It is a pleasure to acknowledge V.Timorin, the former student of Khovanskii, for a few but very interesting conversations. I would like to give my special thanks to my wife Xiaohan whose patient love enabled me to complete this work. v Contents 1 Introduction and organization of material 1 1.1 Introduction . 1 1.2 Organization of the material . 2 2 Rational functions, moment-type problems, applications 8 2.1 Rational functions and a moment-type problem . 8 2.2 Applications . 15 2.2.1 Structure of finite mappings . 15 2.2.2 Moment-type problem and Galois theory . 23 2.2.3 A GAGA-type theorem . 26 3 Abel’s theorem 32 3.1 A version of Abel’s theorem for abstract and plane curves . 32 3.2 Application of Abel’s theorem: plane geometry and Euler-Jacobi formula 44 3.3 Abel’s theorem: continuation . 48 3.4 Multidimensional Abel’s theorem and generalized holomorphic forms . 53 4 Differentiation rule 62 4.1 One-dimensional case . 62 4.2 Multidimensional case . 64 5 Main theorems: Converse of Abel’s theorem - Polynomial case 69 vi 6 Proofs of Main theorems 73 6.1 Sufficiency: Theorem 5.1 and Theorem 5.2 . 73 6.2 Necessity: Theorem 5.1 . 75 6.3 Necessity: Theorem 5.2 . 81 7 Applications of Main theorems and our methods 85 7.1 Preparatory Theorems for Chapter 9 . 85 7.2 Generalized holomorphic forms on complete intersections in Cn and CP n 87 7.3 Converse of Abel’s theorem - Rational case . 89 8 Cotes’ theorem an its converse 104 8.1 Cotes’ theorem . 104 8.2 The converse of Cotes’ theorem . 106 9 Hypersurfaces of double translation 109 9.1 Surfaces of double translation . 109 9.2 Multidimensional case . 114 9.3 Torelli theorem . 120 10 Appendix 125 Bibliography 132 vii Chapter 1 Introduction and organization of material 1.1 Introduction Abel proved in [1] that, under a holomorphic mapping of a complex algebraic curve onto the Riemann sphere, the trace of a meromorphic form is meromorphic, while the trace of a holomorphic form is identically zero. Newton’s student Cotes noted the following property of a plane algebraic curve. Let the number of intersection points of a curve with each straight line from a family of parallel straight lines be d (counting multiplicities), which is the degree of the curve. On each line of the family, we mark the center of masses of the resulting d intersection points. Then all the marked centers of masses lie on a single line. The Cotes theorem is automatically extended to algebraic hypersurfaces. In 1892, Lie [11] classified all the surfaces of double translation in a three-dimensional space. This classification is based on the Lie criterion for the algebraizability of a plane curve. The Lie criterion is the converse of Cotes’ theorem. Darboux [6] simplified the proof of the Lie theorem. He found another algebraizability criterion for a plane curve that is the converse of Abel’s theorem for holomorphic forms. Various converses were 1 Chapter 1. Introduction and organization of material 2 found by Bol [3], Griffiths [8], and Henkin [9]. Wood [19] devised a very simple proof for the converse of Cotes’ theorem for hypersurfaces, which was extended by Akivis [2] to subvarieties of any codimension. (Both Wood and Akivis dealt with the differential- geometric form of Cotes’ theorem as derived by Gauss’ student Reiss [14], but the original version of this theorem is more convenient for our purposes.) The converses of the Abel and Cotes theorems were treated as entirely different un- related assertions. We prove a converse of Abel’s theorem for holomorphic forms that straightforwardly implies the converse of Cotes’ theorem. Our proof is nearly as simple as Wood’s original argument. It is based on a general assertion (see Theorem 2.8) and differential calculus (see Proposition 4.6). Moreover, our proof can be extended without changes to the complex-analytic case. As further development of our methods, we prove a converse of Abel’s theorem for meromorphic forms. Intriguingly, our converse of Abel’s theorem for meromorphic forms unravels a new phenomenon comparing to the results of Henkin in [9]. In contrast to [9], precisely one extra case occurs – a finite union of lines passing through a single point on the plane. It turns out, that on a latter curve (more exactly on its normalization) there are forms with logarithmic singularities that satisfies the Abel theorem for meromorphic forms. Our theorem also provides the explicit description of all such forms. In the manuscript, it is offen that the proof of an assertion involving real manifolds, smooth forms, etc can be extended without changes to a complex-analytic counterpart which we would like to use. In this case we state the complex-analytic counterpart without giving the proof. 1.2 Organization of the material In the section 2.1 of Chapter 2, first we discuss how to reconstruct a rational function from the finite number of terms in its Taylor expansion at infinity. The function is Chapter 1. Introduction and organization of material 3 regular and equal to zero at infinity. We present formulas which go back to Jacobi’s paper on a rational interpolation [4], to thesis of Pade [13] in which he developed the theory of so-called Pade approximants, and later to the famous treatise on continues fractions of Stieltjes [16] in which he formulated and solved the moment problem on the positive semi-axis. As a by-product, we obtain the Kronecker criterion that describes all the sequences of complex numbers that occur as the coefficients in Taylor expansion at infinity of rational functions as above. Interestingly, a certain moment problem, similar to a problem in the theory of mo- ments, that arises in our discussion on the reconstruction of rational functions. It is the explicit solution of this moment problem that first yields to Theorem 2.8 and then to Proposition 2.18 which are crucial in our proofs of the converse of Abel’s theorem for holomorphic and meromorphic forms, respectively. In the following three subsections we collect various applications of the results in Section 2.1. In fact, this is not a complete list of possible applications as, for instance, the connection with the classical problems in the theory of moments is not presented. In Subsection 2.2.1 we prove Theorem 2.8. This is a very general assertion which is valid over any field. Then we prove a certain topological version of Theorem 2.8 for branch coverings. As a corollary, we obtain a sort of Weierstrass’ preparation theorem in the category of topological spaces (see Corollary 2.15). It is worth mentioning that locally a purely dimensional analytic space admits a branch covering over a small open disk in some Cn. In Subsection 2.2.2, we exploit the fact that the moment problem and Theorem 2.8 makes sense over an arbitrary field. We start by proving a certain lemma from Galois theory and finish with Proposition 2.18 which has a flavor of differential Galois theory. Proposition 2.18 is the key statement in the proof of the converse of Abel’s theorem for meromorphic forms.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Abelian Solutions of the Soliton Equations and Riemann–Schottky Problems
    Russian Math. Surveys 63:6 1011–1022 c 2008 RAS(DoM) and LMS Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 63:6 19–30 DOI 10.1070/RM2008v063n06ABEH004576 Abelian solutions of the soliton equations and Riemann–Schottky problems I. M. Krichever Abstract. The present article is an exposition of the author’s talk at the conference dedicated to the 70th birthday of S. P. Novikov. The talk con- tained the proof of Welters’ conjecture which proposes a solution of the clas- sical Riemann–Schottky problem of characterizing the Jacobians of smooth algebraic curves in terms of the existence of a trisecant of the associated Kummer variety, and a solution of another classical problem of algebraic geometry, that of characterizing the Prym varieties of unramified covers. Contents 1. Introduction 1011 2. Welters’ trisecant conjecture 1014 3. The problem of characterization of Prym varieties 1017 4. Abelian solutions of the soliton equations 1018 Bibliography 1020 1. Introduction The famous Novikov conjecture which asserts that the Jacobians of smooth alge- braic curves are precisely those indecomposable principally polarized Abelian vari- eties whose theta-functions provide explicit solutions of the Kadomtsev–Petviashvili (KP) equation, fundamentally changed the relations between the classical algebraic geometry of Riemann surfaces and the theory of soliton equations. It turns out that the finite-gap, or algebro-geometric, theory of integration of non-linear equa- tions developed in the mid-1970s can provide a powerful tool for approaching the fundamental problems of the geometry of Abelian varieties. The basic tool of the general construction proposed by the author [1], [2]which g+k 1 establishes a correspondence between algebro-geometric data Γ,Pα,zα,S − (Γ) and solutions of some soliton equation, is the notion of Baker–Akhiezer{ function.} Here Γis a smooth algebraic curve of genus g with marked points Pα, in whose g+k 1 neighborhoods we fix local coordinates zα, and S − (Γ) is a symmetric prod- uct of the curve.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Introduction 2 the Schottky Problem
    The Schottky problem and second order theta functions Bert van Geemen December Introduction The Schottky problem arose in the work of Riemann To a Riemann surface of genus g one can asso ciate a p erio d matrix which is an element of a space H of dimension g g Since the g Riemann surfaces themselves dep end on only g parameters if g the question arises as to how one can characterize the set of p erio d matrices of Riemann surfaces This is the Schottky problem There have b een many approaches and a few of them have b een succesfull All of them exploit a complex variety a ppav and a subvariety the theta divisor which one can asso ciate to a p oint in H When the p oint is the p erio d matrix of a Riemann surface this variety is g known as the Jacobian of the Riemann surface A careful study of the geometry and the functions on these varieties reveals that Jacobians and their theta divisors have various curious prop erties Now one attempts to show that such a prop erty characterizes Jacobians We refer to M Lectures III and IV for a nice exp osition of four such metho ds to vdG B D for overviews of later results and V for a newer approach In these notes we discuss a particular approach to the Schottky problem which has its origin the work of Schottky and Jung and unpublished work of Riemann It uses the fact that to a genus g curve one can asso ciate certain ab elian varieties of dimension g the Prym varieties In our presentation we emphasize an intrinsic line bundle on a ppav principally p olarized ab elian variety and the action
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter37.Pdf
    CONTENTS EDITORIAL TEAM EUROPEAN MATHEMATICAL SOCIETY EDITOR-IN-CHIEF ROBIN WILSON Department of Pure Mathematics The Open University Milton Keynes MK7 6AA, UK e-mail: [email protected] ASSOCIATE EDITORS STEEN MARKVORSEN Department of Mathematics Technical University of Denmark Building 303 DK-2800 Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark NEWSLETTER No. 37 e-mail: [email protected] KRZYSZTOF CIESIELSKI September 2000 Mathematics Institute Jagiellonian University Reymonta 4 30-059 Kraków, Poland EMS News : Agenda, Editorial, 3ecm report, Summer Schools ...................... 2 e-mail: [email protected] KATHLEEN QUINN The Open University [address as above] Mathematical Modelling in the Biosciences (Philip Maini) .......................... 16 e-mail: [email protected] SPECIALIST EDITORS EMS Poster Competition ............................................................................... 19 INTERVIEWS Steen Markvorsen [address as above] SOCIETIES Interview with Martin Grötschel ................................................................... 20 Krzysztof Ciesielski [address as above] EDUCATION Vinicio Villani Interview with Bernt Wegner ........................................................................ 24 Dipartimento di Matematica Via Bounarotti, 2 56127 Pisa, Italy A stamp for World Mathematical Year ..........................................................27 e-mail: [email protected] MATHEMATICAL PROBLEMS Paul Jainta Societies: The London Mathematical Society ................................................ 28 Werkvolkstr.
    [Show full text]
  • Discrete and Complex Algorithms for Curves
    Discrete and Complex Algorithms for Curves Lynn Chua Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences University of California at Berkeley Technical Report No. UCB/EECS-2020-42 http://www2.eecs.berkeley.edu/Pubs/TechRpts/2020/EECS-2020-42.html May 11, 2020 Copyright © 2020, by the author(s). All rights reserved. Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission. Discrete and Complex Algorithms for Curves by Lynn Chua A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Computer Science in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Alessandro Chiesa, Co-chair Professor Bernd Sturmfels, Co-chair Professor Kenneth Ribet Spring 2020 The dissertation of Lynn Chua, titled Discrete and Complex Algorithms for Curves, is approved: Co-chair Date Co-chair Date Date University of California, Berkeley Discrete and Complex Algorithms for Curves Copyright 2020 by Lynn Chua 1 Abstract Discrete and Complex Algorithms for Curves by Lynn Chua Doctor of Philosophy in Computer Science University of California, Berkeley Professor Alessandro Chiesa, Co-chair Professor Bernd Sturmfels, Co-chair This dissertation consists of two parts. The first part pertains to the Schottky problem, which asks to characterize Jacobians of curves amongst abelian varieties.
    [Show full text]
  • Notices of the American Mathematical Society
    CALENDAR OF AMS MEETINGS THIS CALENDAR lists all meetings which have been approved by the Council prior to the date this issue of the NOTICES was sent to press. The summer and annual meetings are joint meetings of the Mathematical Association of America and the American Mathematical Society. The meeting dates which fall rather far in the future are subject to change; this is particularly true of meetings to which no numbers have yet been assigned. Programs of the meetings will appear in the issues indicated below. First and second announcements of the meetings will have appeared in earlier issues. ABSTRACTS OF CONTRIBUTED PAPERS should be submitted on special forms which are available in most de­ partments of mathematics; forms can also be obtained by writing to the headquarters of the Society. Abstracts of papers to be presented at the meeting in person must be received at the headquarters of the Society in Providence, Rhode Island, on or before the deadline for the meeting. Note that the deadline for abstracts to be considered for presentation at special sessions is three weeks earlier than that given below. For additional information consult the meeting announcement and the list of organizers of special sessions. MEETING ABSTRACTS NUMBER DATE PLACE DEADLINE for ISSUE 768 August 21-25, 1979 Duluth, Minnesota JUNE 12 August (83rd Summer Meeting) 769 October 20-21, 1979 Washington, D.C. AUGUST 22} October 770 November 2-3, 1979 Kent, Ohio AUGUST 27 771 November 9-10, 1979 Birmingham, Alabama SEPTEMBER 19 } November 772 November 16-17,
    [Show full text]
  • A Selection of New Arrivals September 2017
    A selection of new arrivals September 2017 Rare and important books & manuscripts in science and medicine, by Christian Westergaard. Flæsketorvet 68 – 1711 København V – Denmark Cell: (+45)27628014 www.sophiararebooks.com AMPERE, Andre-Marie. Mémoire. INSCRIBED BY AMPÈRE TO FARADAY AMPÈRE, André-Marie. Mémoire sur l’action mutuelle d’un conducteur voltaïque et d’un aimant. Offprint from Nouveaux Mémoires de l’Académie royale des sciences et belles-lettres de Bruxelles, tome IV, 1827. Bound with 18 other pamphlets (listed below). [Colophon:] Brussels: Hayez, Imprimeur de l’Académie Royale, 1827. $38,000 4to (265 x 205 mm). Contemporary quarter-cloth and plain boards (very worn and broken, with most of the spine missing), entirely unrestored. Preserved in a custom cloth box. First edition of the very rare offprint, with the most desirable imaginable provenance: this copy is inscribed by Ampère to Michael Faraday. It thus links the two great founders of electromagnetism, following its discovery by Hans Christian Oersted (1777-1851) in April 1820. The discovery by Ampère (1775-1836), late in the same year, of the force acting between current-carrying conductors was followed a year later by Faraday’s (1791-1867) first great discovery, that of electromagnetic rotation, the first conversion of electrical into mechanical energy. This development was a challenge to Ampère’s mathematically formulated explanation of electromagnetism as a manifestation of currents of electrical fluids surrounding ‘electrodynamic’ molecules; indeed, Faraday directly criticised Ampère’s theory, preferring his own explanation in terms of ‘lines of force’ (which had to wait for James Clerk Maxwell (1831-79) for a precise mathematical formulation).
    [Show full text]
  • Schottky Algorithms: Classical Meets Tropical Arxiv:1707.08520V2
    Schottky Algorithms: Classical meets Tropical Lynn Chua, Mario Kummer and Bernd Sturmfels Abstract We present a new perspective on the Schottky problem that links numerical computing with tropical geometry. The task is to decide whether a symmetric matrix defines a Jacobian, and, if so, to compute the curve and its canonical embedding. We offer solutions and their implementations in genus four, both classically and tropically. The locus of cographic matroids arises from tropicalizing the Schottky{Igusa modular form. 1 Introduction The Schottky problem [11] concerns the characterization of Jacobians of genus g curves among all abelian varieties of dimension g. The latter are parametrized by the Siegel upper-half space Hg, i.e. the set of complex symmetric g × g matrices τ with positive definite imaginary part. The Schottky locus Jg is the subset of matrices τ in Hg that represent Jacobians. Both sets are complex analytic spaces whose dimensions reveal that the inclusion is proper for g ≥ 4: g + 1 dim(J ) = 3g − 3 and dim(H ) = : (1) g g 2 For g = 4, the dimensions in (1) are 9 and 10, so J4 is an analytic hypersurface in H4. The equation defining this hypersurface is a polynomial of degree 16 in the theta constants. First constructed by Schottky [23], and further developed by Igusa [15], this modular form embodies the theoretical solution (cf. [11, x3]) to the classical Schottky problem for g = 4. arXiv:1707.08520v2 [math.AG] 30 Sep 2018 The Schottky problem also exists in tropical geometry [19]. The tropical Siegel space trop Hg is the cone of positive definite g × g-matrices, endowed with the fan structure given by trop the second Voronoi decomposition.
    [Show full text]
  • The Schottky Problem
    The Schottky Problem Samuel Grushevsky Princeton University January 29, 2009 | MSRI What is the Schottky problem? Schottky problem is the following question (over C): Which principally polarized abelian varieties are Jacobians of curves? Mg moduli space of curves C of genus g Ag moduli space of g-dimensional abelian varieties (A; Θ) (complex principally polarized) Jac : Mg ,!Ag Torelli map Jg := Jac(Mg ) locus of Jacobians (Recall that A is a projective variety with a group structure; Θ is an ample divisor on A with h0(A; Θ) = 1; Jac(C) = Picg−1(C) ' Pic0(C)) Schottky problem. Describe/characterize Jg ⊂ Ag . Why might we care about the Schottky problem? Relates two important moduli spaces. Lots of beautiful geometry arises in this study. A \good" answer could help relate the geometry of Mg and Ag . Could have applications to problems about curves easily stated in terms of the Jacobian: Coleman's conjecture For g sufficiently large there are finitely many curves of genus g such that their Jacobians have complex multiplication. Stronger conjecture (+ Andre-Oort =) Coleman). There do not exist any complex geodesics for the natural metric on Ag that are contained in Jg (and intersect Jg ). [Work on this by M¨oller-Viehweg-Zuo;Hain, Toledo...] (Super)string scattering amplitudes [D'Hoker-Phong], . Dimension counts g dim Mg dim Ag 1 1 = 1 indecomposable 2 3 = 3 Mg = Ag 3 6 = 6 4 9 +1 = 10 Schottky0s original equation 5 12 +3 = 15 Partial results (g−3)(g−2) g(g+1) g 3g − 3 + 2 = 2 \weak" solutions (up to extra components) Classical (Riemann-Schottky) approach N Embed Ag into P and write equations for the image of Jg .
    [Show full text]
  • On the Schottky Problem for Genus Five Jacobians with a Vanishing Theta Null
    On the Schottky problem for genus five Jacobians with a vanishing theta null Daniele Agostini and Lynn Chua Abstract We give a solution to the weak Schottky problem for genus five Jacobians with a vanishing theta null, answering a question of Grushevsky and Salvati Manni. More precisely, we show that if a principally polarized abelian variety of dimension five has a vanishing theta null with a quadric tangent cone of rank at most three, then it is in the Jacobian locus, up to extra irreducible components. We employ a degeneration argument, together with a study of the ramification loci for the Gauss map of a theta divisor. 1 Introduction The Schottky problem asks to recognize the Jacobian locus Jg inside the moduli space Ag of principally polarized abelian varieties of dimension at least 4, and it has been a central problem in algebraic geometry for more than a century. In the most classical interpretation, the problem asks for equations in the period matrix τ that vanish exactly on the Jacobian locus. In this form, the Schottky problem is completely solved only in genus 4, with an explicit equation given by Schottky [Sch88] and Igusa [Igu81]. The weak Schottky problem asks for explicit equations that characterize Jacobians up to extra irreducible components. A solution to this problem was given in genus 5 by Accola [Acc83] and, in a recent breakthrough, by Farkas, Grushevsky and Salvati Manni in all genera [FGS17]. arXiv:1905.09366v1 [math.AG] 22 May 2019 There have been many other approaches to the Schottky problem over the years; see [Gru12] for a recent survey.
    [Show full text]
  • Period Constraints on Hyperelliptic Branch Points
    Period Constraints on Hyperelliptic Branch Points James S. Wolper Department of Mathematics Idaho State University Pocatello, ID 83209–8085 USA 29 June 2021 Abstract. Information Theoretic analysis of the periods of a hyperelliptic curve provides more information about the well–known but abstract relationship between the branch points and the periods. Here one constructs a canonical homology basis for a hyperelliptic curve that shows that its periods must satisfy certain constraints and defines an open set in the Siegel upper half space that cannot contain any period matrices of hyperelliptic curves. Introduction For decades now researchers have used algebraic curves to address questions in coding and cryptography. This raises interesting questions about the curves themselves based on Information Theoretic considerations. In one direction, suppose that Alice wants to tell Bob about a compact curve (ie, Riemann Surface) with genus g ≥ 2. By Torelli’s Theorem, she need only send him the period matrix, transmitting O(g2) complex numbers. The curve she is describing only depends on O(g) parameters, the dimension of the moduli space being sparse arXiv:2106.15696v1 [math.AG] 29 Jun 2021 3g − 3, so there is a lot of redundancy in her message. The period matrix is in the sense of [D], and should therefore be compressible. The perspective that the period matrix is a compressible signal is the central idea of the Information–Theoretic Schottky Problem. The attempt to apply ideas from Information Theory and Compressed Sensing [D] to the Schottky problem has led to many interesting experiments, conjectures, and theorems [W12]. These questions only make sense when the genus is large.
    [Show full text]
  • The Asymptotic Schottky Problem
    The asymptotic Schottky problem Lizhen Ji,∗ Enrico Leuzinger Abstract Let Mg denote the moduli space of compact Riemann surfaces of genus g and let Ag be the space of principally polarized abelian varieties of (complex) dimension g. Let J : Mg −→ Ag be the map which associates to a Riemann surface its Jacobian. The map J is injective, and the image J(Mg) is contained in a proper subvariety of Ag when g ≥ 4. The classical and long-studied Schottky problem is to characterize the Jacobian locus Jg := J(Mg) in Ag. In this paper we adress a large scale version of this problem posed by Farb and called the coarse Schottky problem: How does Jg look “from far away”, or how “dense” is Jg in the sense of coarse geometry? The coarse geometry of the Siegel modular variety Ag is encoded in its asymptotic cone Cone∞(Ag), which is a Euclidean simplicial cone of (real) dimension g. Our main result asserts that the Jacobian locus Jg is “asymptotically large”, or “coarsely dense” in Ag. More precisely, the subset of Cone∞(Ag) determinded by Jg actually coincides with this cone. The proof also shows that the Jacobian locus of hyperelliptic curves is coarsely dense in Ag as well. We also study the boundary points of the Jacobian locus Jg in Ag and in the Baily-Borel and the Borel-Serre compactification. We show that for large genus g the set of boundary points of Jg in these compactifications arXiv:0811.4059v1 [math.GT] 25 Nov 2008 is “small”. 1 Introduction The Siegel upper half space Hg is a Hermitian symmetric space of noncompact type which generalizes the Poincar´eupper half plane: g×g Hg := {Z ∈ C | Z symmetric, Im Z positive definite}.
    [Show full text]
  • The Schottky Problem
    THE SCHOTTKY PROBLEM Gerard van der Geer By associating to a (smooth irreducible) curve C of genus g > 0 its Jacobian Jac(C) one obtains a morphism M ~ A from the moduli g g space of curves of genus g to the moduli space of principally polari- zed Abelian varieties of dimension g. A well-known theorem of Torelli says that this morphism is injective. The image of ~{g in Ag is not closed , it is only closed inside A g,° the set of points of A g that correspond to indecomposable principally polarized abelian varieties (i.e. that are not products). For g=1,2,3 the closure of the image of Mg equals Ag . Since dimA g =g(g+l)/2 , dim M g =3g-3 (for g > i) one sees that for g > 3 dimAg > dim M g , and so the question arises how we can characterize the image of M in A . This question goes g g back to Riemann, but is usually called Schottky's problem. In "Curves and their Jacobians" Mumford treats the Schottky pro- blem and the closely related question how to distinguish Jacobians from general principally polarized abelian varieties. In his review of the situation at that moment (1975) he describes four approaches and their merits. He concludes that none of these seems to him a definitive solution. In the meantime the situation has changed a lot. Some of the approaches have been worked out more completely, while new and successfull approaches have appeared. This paper deals with them. I hope to convince the reader that Mumford's statement that problems in this corner of nature are subtle and worthy of his time still very much holds true.
    [Show full text]