In Review

A POST-RACIAL ERA? We’re not there yet, nor is it necessarily an ideal, says Li. “We want to know racial identities because those are the handles by which we begin to establish intimacy.”

Q&A Race Talk in the Age of Obama President Barack Obama’s rhetorical approach to race is one we see often in contemporary American literature, argues English professor Stephanie Li, in her new book.

Interview by Karen McCally ’02 (PhD) in 1995, after his election as the first black ther and a Mexican mother, identified pro- president of Harvard Law Review but be- foundly with the young Obama—a “racial Stephanie Li has been interested in fore he launched his political career. outlier,” she says, who, like she did, sought Barack Obama for as long as he’s been a The book won praise as a work of liter- guidance and solace in literature. political figure. An assistant professor of ature from the likes of Toni Morrison and At Rochester, she teaches undergradu- English at Rochester, she’s in good com- Philip Roth. And Li, a scholar of African- ates and graduate students in her courses pany among literary people who took an American literature who grew up in Min- on Toni Morrison, Race in American Fic- early interest in the author of Dreams From nesota as the product of an interracial tion, Narratives of Immigration and Assimi- My Father, the memoir that Obama wrote marriage between a Chinese-American fa- lation, and others.

14 ROCHESTER REVIEW January–February 2012 Adam Fenster

3_RochRev_Jan_2012_Review.indd 14 12/22/11 8:15 PM Sports

In her latest book, Signify- explicitly. But then she went on to state that that recognizes difference without harping ing Without Specifying: Racial she supported him because he manifested a upon difference. And that’s, I think, what Discourse in the Age of Obama quality that she identified as “wisdom.” happens when you know and love some- (Rutgers), Li examines Obama’s That was totally perplexing, because body within your family, within your circle rhetorical approach to race, Obama had not even finished a full term of friends, within your community, and you both on the campaign trail in in the Senate, and he’s one of our youngest understand their racial identity, you under- 2008 and in his written works, presidents. Wisdom is really not the qual- stand that’s crucial to who they are. But it’s alongside the works of novelists ity that we would attribute to someone of not the only component by which you rec- Toni Morrison, Colson White- his age and his experience. And as I demon- ognize their totality. head, and Jhumpa Lahiri. She strate to my students in the Morrison class argues that Obama, like these that I teach, when we look at Morrison’s How did race-specific, race-free lan- novelists, evokes race through larger body of work, we see that wisdom guage work in your family as you were coded language—in his case, a is a reference to the ancestor—an ancestral growing up? language that carries cultural figure that guides the protagonist and helps It’s hard, actually, to give specific examples. resonance for African Ameri- him or her to establish a close relationship There was just an understanding that we cans without explicitly naming to their own identity—in particular, their were very different. But as a young child, it race. racial identity. was also hard for me to know, is our differ- The wise ancestor is one of the key quali- ence specific to race? What do you mean when you ties Morrison identifies as essential to black Because my mother’s first language was say that Barack Obama is our literature. So for Obama to be identified as Spanish, she spoke with an accent. My first “signifying president”? “wise,” I think, is a code word for “black.” mother also worked full time, as a scien- Obama is distinctive not sim- That is, he’s invested in his blackness, he tist, which was different from most of my ply because he’s our first black understands where he came from. friends’ mothers. So there were all of these president. Even as a presidential ways that difference manifested in my life. candidate, his rhetorical strate- But it’s not only African Americans who It was hard to know. Were we isolated be- gies, I think, distinguished him employ this racialized language. Where cause we’re racially different, because my from other, previous black pres- else do we see it? mother’s an immigrant, because my mother idential candidates—from Shir- As I write in my book, we see it in the sto- works full time, because my parents are sci- ley Chisholm, Jesse Jackson, or ries of the South Asian–American author entists and none of my friends’ parents are Al Sharpton, for example. My Jhumpa Lahiri. Another great example is scientists? It’s hard as a child to figure out analysis rests on how Obama A Gate at the Stairs, the most recent novel what are the salient differences in life. uses and manipulates his ra- by Lorrie Moore. Moore is a white author But certainly I think race played a signifi- cial identity. So when I identify from the Midwest. In this novel there are cant role in that. I think race is part of how him as our first signifying pres- these wonderful scenes in which a young we understand people in society. We want ident, I’m identifying the way college student is taking care of the black to know racial identities, because those are in which he adopts racial code child of white adoptive parents. And the the handles by which we begin to establish switching according to differ- parents have convened a support group for intimacy. And so now I’m as forthcoming as ent audiences to maximize his parents of children of color, which includes I can be. I prefer to have my racial identity identification with the widest both white and minority parents. Tassie, known as quickly as possible. Because once array of voting populations. the babysitter, is taking care of these kids that’s out of the way, once those things can upstairs and listening to the conversation get known, that’s the only way that you can You compare Obama’s means downstairs. So she can only hear the voices. get past it toward some greater degree of of talking about race—which you call She doesn’t know who’s speaking what. And intimacy. “signifying without specifying”—to an ap- so you have this mixture of conversation be- proach Toni Morrison has long employed tween white people and people of color, and You also talk about some of the drawbacks and has called “race-specific, race-free” it’s all coded through the language. of race-specific, race-free language, par- language. What does she mean by that Race-specific, race-free prose is a kind of ticularly as they manifest themselves in phrase, and where has she demonstrated device which is being used not simply by public conversation. What are they? it in her work? black authors, not simply by Obama and When I identify race-specific, race-free lan- Morrison introduced the phrase “race- Morrison—though I think they’re the pro- guage as the language of intimacy, I’m lo- specific, race-free language” to refer to lan- genitors of this—but is an idea that’s being cating it and its uses specifically within a guage that carries cultural resonances that taken up much more broadly within con- domestic or a personal space. are specific to African Americans but is free temporary American literature. Once you start using it in a broader, more of explicit references to race. politicized, grander scale, it’s certainly sub- A wonderful example is the letter of en- In what ways do you, along with Morri- ject to problems. It can engender a sense of dorsement of Obama she made public in son, see race-specific, race-free prose as paranoia, that sense that everything is cod- January 2008. She rejected the premise an ideal? ed, that everything is really about race. I that she was supporting Obama specifically I understand race-specific, race-free prose don’t think that’s always constructive when because of his racial identity. She said that as the language of intimacy. It’s language it comes to deciding public policy.r

January–February 2012 ROCHESTER REVIEW 15

3_RochRev_Jan_2012_Review.indd 15 12/23/11 10:49 AM