Excavating Freytag's Pyramid Narrative, Identity and the Museum

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Excavating Freytag's Pyramid Narrative, Identity and the Museum EXCAVATING FREYTAG’S PYRAMID NARRATIVE, IDENTITY AND THE MUSEUM VISITOR EXPERIENCE David William Francis 2019 UCL Research Degree: Institute of Archaeology Dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy 1 I, David William Francis, confirm that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Where information has been derived from other sources, I confirm that this has been indicated in the thesis. 2 Abstract In this thesis, I attempt to trace the thread that links the theoretical concept of narrative to the museum blockbuster exhibition. I adopt a qualitative dialogic approach, exploring the topic of narrative from the perspective of both exhibition makers and museum visitors. Semi-structured interviews with museum professionals provide an insight into the strategies and practices involved in the encoding of narrative in museum exhibitions. Interviews with members of the public reveal how visitors decode exhibition narratives, while also illustrating the role museums play in the stories people tell about themselves. Narrative is a term that is often used in reference to museums but is frequently under-theorised. My case studies – three blockbuster exhibitions held at the British Museum from 2013 to 2015 – each approach the question of how is narrative as a concept relevant in helping us understand the critical issue of the museum from different perspectives. Drawing on the work of the Roland Barthes and the Mikhail Bakhtin, I investigate how concepts taken from literary theory such as plot structure and narratorial perspective might manifests themselves in the space of a museum exhibition. Using the concept of cultural capital taken from the work of the French Sociologist Pierre Bourdieu, I also explore the role a visitor’s social background and familiarity with museums plays in their decision to follow a narrative or reject it. Two threads run throughout my thesis. One is the use of the term narrative to describe the multimodal, multi-authored nature of museum-making. The other is the role museums play in the construction of narratives about the past. It is in the dialogue between the two narrative threads that this thesis seeks to explore and untangle. 3 Impact statement This thesis aims to contribute to the growing body of research into narrative and exhibition design. Its original contribution to knowledge lies in its dialogic approach, which brings together the accounts of museum makers who create exhibition narratives with the accounts of the visitors who experience them. It also contributes to the increasing level of research into how narrative theory can be applied to non-textual media. In adopting a case study approach, using the British Museum as a case it provides a particular insight into the British Museum’s history during a time when it was undergoing an important period of change under the directorship of Neil MacGregor. This research will therefore be useful to practitioners working within the field of museum-making, as it will allow them to reflect on their exhibition-making practices and how concepts taken from narrative theory can be applied to the interpretation of exhibitions. This is particularly true for myself, as I undertook my thesis part time while working as an interpretation practitioner. As a result, my research fed into my own work and my theories around narrative can be seen as manifested in a number of projects I’ve worked on over the course of the seven-years of the thesis. This includes a series of experimental exhibitions focussing in on single objects in room three of the British Museum, India and the World: A history in the world in nine stories hosted by the CSMVS Museum in Mumbai and Raffles in Southeast Asia hosted by the Asian Civilisation Museum in Singapore. Although the British Museum is my case study, a key aspect of my research has been sharing and contrasting my case with museumscapes and researchers involved in the study of museum narratives. This includes the Centre for Anthropological Research in Museums and Heritage in Berlin and the curatorial training school jointly run by the Beijing Paleozoological Museum and the School for the Study of Architecture and the Built Environment at Nottingham University. Through co-hosting a series of workshops involving both theorists and practitioners, I hope that this has allowed some of my research to filter 4 into both my academic colleagues’ research and fellow interpretation consultants’ practice. I foresee this leading to further dialogue, exchange and collaboration in the future. 5 Contents Abstract 3 Impact statement 4 Contents 6 List of tables 10 Acknowledgements 11 Chapter 1. Introduction 20 1.1 Unpicking the thread 20 Chapter 2. Narrative structure and the museum: critical perspectives 27 Introduction 2.1 Narratology and the quest to define narrative structure 28 2.2 Linearity and non-linearity in the museum 33 2.3 Walking the line 39 2.4 Defining the line 48 2.4.1 Defining the line – Narrative climax 48 2.4.2 Moving narrative forward – binary 52 2.4.3 Pace and dynamism 57 2.5 Objects of desire: Application of narrative theory to museums 62 Summary 64 Chapter 3. Narrative perspective and the museum: critical perspectives 66 Introduction 3.1 The shift towards perspective in narrative theory 67 3.2.1 Bakhtin and the dialogic 74 3.2.2 Museum as dialogic spaces 77 6 3.3.1 Perspective in other media 78 3.3.2 The riposte to narrative – the material turn against narrative 78 3.3.3 Perspective as existing beyond text 83 3.4.1 The multiple lenses of visitor perspective 86 3.4.2 Motivation and identity 91 Summary 103 Chapter 4. Narrative histories: The encyclopaedia and the blockbuster 105 Introduction 105 4.1 The revival of the British Museum 106 4.2 Encyclopaedic museums 109 4.3.1 The blockbuster reborn 121 4.3.2 Narrative perspective and the multimodality of museum exhibitions 127 4.3.3 The visitor, the blockbuster and commerciality 131 4.3.4 Political narratives 139 Summary 142 Chapter 5: Methodology / methods 143 5.1 Research questions 143 5.2 A qualitative case study approach 144 5.3 Research design 148 5.3.1 Selection of micro-cases 149 5.3.2 Recruiting participants 151 5.3.3 Narrative interviews with exhibition makers 151 5.3.4 Episodic group interviews with visitors 153 5.3.5 Observation 155 5.3.6 Documentary sources and reading the exhibition as a text 156 5.4 Ethical considerations and reflexivity 157 5.5 Analysis 157 5.6 Summary 159 7 Chapter 6: Disasters narratives and Life and death in Pompeii and Herculaneum 160 6.1 The space of the round reading room 161 6.2 The introduction – establishing a structure 166 5.2.1 Visitors and the everyday 171 6.3.1 Digital media and the reconstruction of reality in Pompeii and Herculaneum 178 6.4 Space and the house 183 6.4.1 The house and themes 186 6.4.2 Space and tone: Archaeology and the garden room 190 6.5 The exhibition climax: The death of the cities 194 6.5.1 The exhibition climax and the hermeneutic code 197 6.5.2 Aftermath – alternative endings 206 Chapter 7: Reinterpretation and Vikings: life and legend 213 Introduction 213 7.1 Reinterpretation and narrative 220 7.1.1 Reinterpretation and visitors 226 7.1.2 Reinterpretation and multimodality 231 7.2 Narrative – Journey and Climax 245 7.2.1 The ship as narrative climax 250 7.4 The Vikings and identity 257 7.5 Conclusion 263 Chapter 8: Anti-narrative and Defining Beauty: The body in Ancient Greece 266 Introduction 8.1 What might an anti-narrative approach look like? 266 8.1.1 Interpretation approach – the ekphrastic encounter 269 8.2 Exposition 283 8.2.1. Form into thought and non-linearity 288 8.2.2 Visitor responses to the non-linear space 292 8.3 The ‘turn’ 295 8 8.3.1 The overall narrative: a non-chronological approach 297 8.4 Act three – The shock of the new 303 8.6 Summary 314 Chapter 9 Narrative and the museum visitor: A comparative perspective 316 Introduction 316 9.1 Comparing the demographics of the exhibitions 321 9.2.1 The relationship between family and education 324 9.2.2 Cultural capital and education 327 9.3.1 Cultural capital and narrative 330 9.3.2 Abandoning the narrative 335 9.4 Visitors' own reflections on social class 341 Chapter 10 Conclusion – The end of the thread 347 Introduction 347 10.1 Structure 347 10.2 Perspective 351 10.3 Dialogue 355 10.4 The agency of narrative 358 Appendix 347 Appendix 1: List of staff interviewed for each exhibition 342 Appendix 2: Pompeii and Herculaneum: Visitor group demographic information 343 Appendix 3: Vikings: Life and legend: Visitor group demographic information 345 Appendix 4: Defining Beauty: Visitor group demographic information 346 Bibliography 347 9 List of Tables Table 1: The narrative structure of Labov and Waletzky’s model of oral narratives 50 Table 2: McKee’s (2006) model of the stages of cinematic narrative 55 Table 3: Barthes’ five narrative codes 58 Table 4: Barthes’ (1974) ten-part structure showing the unfolding of the hermeneutic code 61 Table 5: Summative evaluation data 320 Table 6: Breakdown of UK and non-visitor groups featured in my case study 321 Table 7: The frequency of visiting for visitor groups in my case study. 321 10 Acknowledgements I would like to thank my supervisors Theano Moussouri and Jeremy Tanner for all their hard work and support they have provided throughout the creation of this thesis.
Recommended publications
  • Full Thesis Text Only
    A DIACHRONIC EXAMINATION OF THE ERECHTHEION AND ITS RECEPTION Alexandra L. Lesk, B.A., M.St. (Oxon.), M.A. Presented to McMicken College of Arts and Sciences and the Department of Classics of the University of Cincinnati in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2004 Committee: C. Brian Rose (Chair) Jack L. Davis Kathleen M. Lynch J. James Coulton Abstract iii ABSTRACT “A Diachronic Examination of the Erechtheion and Its Reception” examines the social life of the Ionic temple on the Athenian Akropolis, which was built in the late 5th century B.C. to house Athens’ most sacred cults and relics. Using a contextualized diachronic approach, this study examines both the changes to the Erechtheion between its construction and the middle of the 19th century A.D., as well as the impact the temple had on the architecture and art of these successive periods. This approach allows the evidence to shed light on new areas of interest such as the Post-Antique phases of the building, in addition to affording a better understanding of problems that have plagued the study of the Erechtheion during the past two centuries. This study begins with a re-examination of all the pertinent archaeological, epigraphical, and literary evidence, and proposes a wholly new reconstruction of how the Erechtheion worked physically and ritually in ancient times. After accounting for the immediate influence of the Erechtheion on subsequent buildings of the Ionic order, an argument for a Hellenistic rather than Augustan date for the major repairs to the temple is presented.
    [Show full text]
  • The Frick Collection Staff As of June 30, 2008
    The Frick Collection annual report july 2007–june 2008 The Frick Collection annual report july 2007–june 2008 leadership 2 Board of Trustees, Council of The Frick Collection, and Young Fellows Steering Committee reports 3 Margot Bogert, Chairman 5 Anne L. Poulet, Director 8 Colin B. Bailey, Associate Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator 11 Patricia Barnett, Andrew W. Mellon Chief Librarian financial statements 13 Statement of Financial Position 14 Statement of Activities public programming 15 Exhibitions and Lectures 16 Symposia, Publications, and Concerts notable library acquisitions 17 Gifts and Exchanges 18 Purchases donor support and membership 19 Gifts and Grants 23 Fellows and Friends 30 Corporate Members and Sponsors staff 31 The Frick Collection 34 Frick Art Reference Library on our cover: Maiolica dish with The Judgment of Paris after Raphael, Fontana workshop, tin-glazed earthenware, c. 1565, The Frick Collection, gift of Dianne Dwyer Modestini in memory of Mario Modestini; photograph by Michael Bodycomb The Frick Collection Council of Young Fellows Board of Trustees The Frick Collection Steering Committee As of June 30, 2008 As of June 30, 2008 As of June 30, 2008 Margot Bogert, Chairman George C. Wachter, Chairman Lydia Fenet, Chairman Howard Phipps Jr., Vice Chairman Jonathan Brown, Vice Chairman Elisabeth Saint-Amand, Secretary L. F. Boker Doyle, Treasurer Caitlin Davis, Coordinator John P. Birkelund, Secretary Julian Agnew Irene Roosevelt Aitken Fiona Benenson Peter P. Blanchard III W. Mark Brady Genevieve Wheeler Brown I. Townsend Burden III Vivien R. Clark Kipton Cronkite Walter A. Eberstadt Anne Goldrach Paul Cruickshank Emily T. Frick Nicholas H.
    [Show full text]
  • Neil Macgregor, a History of the World in 100 Objects
    TERMINUS tom 15 (2013), z. 2 (27), s. 275–282 doi:10.4467/20843844TE.13.016.1573 www.ejournals.eu/Terminus NCEIL MA GREGOR, A HISTORY OF THE WORLD IN 100 OBJECTS, FIRST PUBLISHED IN PRINT IN OCTOBER 2010 BY ALLEN LANE IMPRINT OF PENGUIN BOOKS, PP. 640 Edition used for the review: Kindle Edition, 6 October 2011, Penguin KAJA SZYMAńSKA Uniwersytet Jagielloński, Kraków Only stable, rich and powerful states can commission great art and architectu- re that, unlike text or language, can be instantly understood by anyone – a gre- at advantage in multilingual empires. Neil MacGregor1 The book A History of the World in 100 Objects is a result of a multi-plat- form BBC and British Museum joint enterprise released in 2010. It of- fered an innovative look at history and the role of a museum, and was a great success in popularising knowledge, and history in particular. The whole project involved 550 heritage partners and comprised several me- dia outlets: a six-month long series of daily broadcasts by BBC Radio 4, a website through which individual users and other institutions could also contribute, uploading objects of their own choice, and finally, the book to which this review specifically relates. The radio programme drew 4 million listeners and podcast downloads amounted to over 10 million during the 1 N. MacGregor, loc. 3542/9008. Publikacja objęta jest prawem autorskim. Wszelkie prawa zastrzeżone. Kopiowanie i rozpowszechnianie zabronione. Publikacja przeznaczona jedynie dla klientów indywidualnych. Zakaz rozpowszechniania i udostępniania w serwisach bibliotecznych 276 Kaja Szymańska following year (only just over 5.7 million from the UK).
    [Show full text]
  • P36-37 Neil Macgregor.Indd
    MEXICO Moctezuma: Aztec ruler BY NEIL MACGREGOR DIRECTOR OF THE BRITISH MUSEUM n behalf of the Trustees of the British Moctezuma’s life and dramatic death are explained Museum, I would like to take this through a variety of stunning objects, generously opportunity to welcome President Felipe lent from Mexico, from monumental sculpture, gold Calderón Hinojosa to the UK on his and mosaic items to codices and European paintings. OState Visit. The British Museum has a long-standing Recent finds and research will shed light on Moctezuma commitment to the presentation of Mexican cultures, and offer a re-assessment of his reign and legacy. The millions have visited the Museum’s permanent gallery exhibition will allow visitors to rediscover the Aztec devoted to Mexico since it opened in 1994. world and trace the foundation of modern Mexico. 2009 is a particularly apt time to be thinking about The exhibition is supported by ArcelorMittal and has Mexico and its rich history in advance of the celebration been conceived in partnership with the National Institute NEIL MACGREGOR of the centenary of the Mexican Revolution and bi- for Anthroplogy and History (INAH), Mexico City. has been Director of centenary of Mexican Independence in 2010. The Mexicana is the airline partner and additional support has the British Museum coincidence of these two anniversaries will allow the come from Visit Mexico. The exhibition would not have since 2002. He is an world to reconsider the history of Mexico. It has offered been possible without the personal commitment of the honorary Fellow of New an opportunity for us here at the British Museum, in Mexican Ambassador to the UK, Juan José Bremer and College, Oxford and partnership with colleagues in Mexico, to examine his colleagues, the Museum is greatly indebted to them the British Academy, a afresh the role of one of the key figures at a pivotal for their help and assistance.
    [Show full text]
  • The Parthenon Sculptures Sarah Pepin
    BRIEFING PAPER Number 02075, 9 June 2017 By John Woodhouse and Sarah Pepin The Parthenon Sculptures Contents: 1. What are the Parthenon Sculptures? 2. How did the British Museum acquire them? 3. Ongoing controversy 4. Further reading www.parliament.uk/commons-library | intranet.parliament.uk/commons-library | papers@parliament.uk | @commonslibrary 2 The Parthenon Sculptures Contents Summary 3 1. What are the Parthenon Sculptures? 5 1.1 Early history 5 2. How did the British Museum acquire them? 6 3. Ongoing controversy 7 3.1 Campaign groups in the UK 9 3.2 UK Government position 10 3.3 British Museum position 11 3.4 Greek Government action 14 3.5 UNESCO mediation 14 3.6 Parliamentary interest 15 4. Further reading 20 Contributing Authors: Diana Perks Attribution: Parthenon Sculptures, British Museum by Carole Radatto. Licenced under CC BY-SA 2.0 / image cropped. 3 Commons Library Briefing, 9 June 2017 Summary This paper gives an outline of the more recent history of the Parthenon sculptures, their acquisition by the British Museum and the long-running debate about suggestions they be removed from the British Museum and returned to Athens. The Parthenon sculptures consist of marble, architecture and architectural sculpture from the Parthenon in Athens, acquired by Lord Elgin between 1799 and 1810. Often referred to as both the Elgin Marbles and the Parthenon marbles, “Parthenon sculptures” is the British Museum’s preferred term.1 Lord Elgin’s authority to obtain the sculptures was the subject of a Select Committee inquiry in 1816. It found they were legitimately acquired, and Parliament then voted the funds needed for the British Museum to acquire them later that year.
    [Show full text]
  • Greek Cities & Islands of Asia Minor
    MASTER NEGATIVE NO. 93-81605- Y MICROFILMED 1 993 COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES/NEW YORK / as part of the "Foundations of Western Civilization Preservation Project'' Funded by the NATIONAL ENDOWMENT FOR THE HUMANITIES Reproductions may not be made without permission from Columbia University Library COPYRIGHT STATEMENT The copyright law of the United States - Title 17, United photocopies or States Code - concerns the making of other reproductions of copyrighted material. and Under certain conditions specified in the law, libraries or other archives are authorized to furnish a photocopy the reproduction. One of these specified conditions is that for any photocopy or other reproduction is not to be "used purpose other than private study, scholarship, or for, or later uses, a research." If a user makes a request photocopy or reproduction for purposes in excess of fair infringement. use," that user may be liable for copyright a This institution reserves the right to refuse to accept fulfillment of the order copy order if, in its judgement, would involve violation of the copyright law. AUTHOR: VAUX, WILLIAM SANDYS WRIGHT TITLE: GREEK CITIES ISLANDS OF ASIA MINOR PLACE: LONDON DA TE: 1877 ' Master Negative # COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES PRESERVATION DEPARTMENT BIBLIOGRAPHIC MTCROFORM TAR^FT Original Material as Filmed - Existing Bibliographic Record m^m i» 884.7 !! V46 Vaux, V7aiion Sandys Wright, 1818-1885. ' Ancient history from the monuments. Greek cities I i and islands of Asia Minor, by W. S. W. Vaux... ' ,' London, Society for promoting Christian knowledce." ! 1877. 188. p. plate illus. 17 cm. ^iH2n KJ Restrictions on Use: TECHNICAL MICROFORM DATA i? FILM SIZE: 3 S'^y^/"^ REDUCTION IMAGE RATIO: J^/ PLACEMENT: lA UA) iB .
    [Show full text]
  • English for Specific Purposes 1 Esercitazioni (James)
    DISPENSA A.A. 2018 – 2019 English for Specific Purposes 1 Esercitazioni (James) Risk Recreation Ethical Tourism Cultural Heritage (051-2097241; nigel.james@unibo.it) 1 Contents Page 1 Writing 3 Guidelines on essay assessment, writing, style, organization and structure 2 Essay writing exercises 13 3 Reading texts (including reading, listening and writing exercises) Risk Recreation: Tornado Tourism (essay assignment) 20 Ethical tourism: Canned Hunting 28 Pamplona Bull Running 36 La Tomatina 43 Museums and the Ownership of Cultural Heritage: The Rosetta Stone, The Parthenon Marbles, The Mona Lisa 45 (essay assignment) The Impact of Mass Tourism: Venice, Florence, Barcelona 68 All the copyrighted materials included in this ‘dispensa’ belong to the respective owners and, following fair use guidelines, are hereby used for educational purposes only. 2 1 Writing Guidelines on essay assessment, writing, style, organization and structure Assessing writing: criteria Exam task: 500-word argument essay 1 Task achievement (9 points) Has the student focused on the question and respected the length? Fully answers the question in depth. Answers the question in sufficient depth to cover the main points. There are some unnecessary or irrelevant ideas. There are too many minor issues or irrelevant ideas dealt with. Shorter than the required length. Does not answer the question. Much shorter than the required length. 2 Structure and organization (9 points) Does the essay have a structure? Is there an introduction and conclusion? Is the body divided into paragraphs which are linked? There is a suitable introduction and conclusion. Paragraphs and sentences link up and make the essay easy to read and the text easy to understand.
    [Show full text]
  • 'The Wealth of Nations: the Health of Society': 60 Years of the Wolfson
    ‘The Wealth of Nations: the Health of Society’: 60 Years of the Wolfson Foundation Neil MacGregor OM, Director, The British Museum Lecture given at Wolfson College, Oxford, 8 June 2015, on the occasion of the 60th anniversary of the Wolfson Foundation Janet thank you very much indeed for that generous introduction, and thank you above all for inviting me to pay tribute to the Foundation and to your father and grandfather, and what the Foundation has done and what it represents. This is as you all know a year of anniversaries, and indeed June the month of anniversaries: 800 years of Magna Carta and two hundred years since the Battle of Waterloo, which has also cast along historical shadow. It is also, and for this evening’s purposes, above all, the 60th anniversary of the creation of the Wolfson Foundation, and the history of that Foundation is in the excellent booklet that has just been published, but I would like to pay tribute to its two founding figures, its founding Chairmen: the grandfather and the father of the current Chairman, Janet Wolfson de Botton. Isaac Wolfson, who was born in poverty in Glasgow in 1897, came to London to make a fortune with Great Universal Stores, and used that fortune, as you know, to endow the Foundation. And his son, Leonard Wolfson, who continued not just GUS, but also the Foundation, developed it remarkably. I never knew Isaac Wolfson, but I did frequently meet Leonard, and was the recipient of enormous generosity and encouragement, and also extremely testing conversations. It was always the first thing: this extraordinarily generous man, already committed to helping the institution that one was trying to ask for money for, always began with a very firm and ringing endorsement that the one thing he would not pay was VAT.
    [Show full text]
  • And KEEPING up with the PERSIANS Some Reflections on Cultural Links in the Persian Empire
    Working draft, not for distribution without permission of the author 1 ‘MANNERS MAKYTH MAN’ and KEEPING UP WITH THE PERSIANS Some reflections on cultural links in the Persian Empire Christopher Tuplin (University of Liverpool) Revised version: 9 June 2008 The purpose of the meeting (according to the web site) is to explore how ancient peoples expressed their identities by establishing, constructing, or inventing links with other societies that crossed traditional ethnic and geographic lines. These cross-cultural links complicates, undermine, or give nuance to conventional dichotomies such as self/other, Greek/barbarian, and Jew/gentile In the Achaemenid imperial context this offers a fairly wide remit. But it is a remit limited – or distorted – by the evidence. For in this, as in all aspects of Achaemenid history, we face a set of sources that spreads unevenly across the temporal, spatial and analytical space of the empire. For what might count as an unmediated means of access to a specifically Persian viewpoint we are pretty much confined to iconographically decorated monuments and associated royal inscriptions at Behistun, Persepolis and Susa (which are at least, on the face of it, intended to broach ideological topics) and the Persepolis Fortification and Treasury archives (which emphatically are not). This material is not formally or (to a large extent) chronologically commensurate with the voluminous, but unevenly distributed, Greek discourse that provides so much of the narrative of Achaemenid imperial history. Some of it may appear more commensurate with the substantial body of iconographically decorated monuments (most not associated with inscriptions) derived from western Anatolia that provides much of the material in the two papers under discussion.
    [Show full text]
  • Shedding Light on the Modalities of Authority in a Dar Al-Uloom, Or Religious Seminary, in Britain
    religions Article Shedding Light on the Modalities of Authority in a Dar al-Uloom, or Religious Seminary, in Britain Haroon Sidat Centre for the Study of Islam in the UK, School of History, Archaeology and Religion, Cardiff University, Cardiff CF10 3EU, UK; Sidathe@cardiff.ac.uk Received: 25 July 2019; Accepted: 26 November 2019; Published: 29 November 2019 Abstract: ‘God is the Light of the heavens and the earth ::: ’ (Quran, 24:35.) This article sheds light on the modalities of authority that exist in a traditional religious seminary or Dar al-Uloom (hereon abbreviated to DU) in modern Britain. Based on unprecedented insider access and detailed ethnography, the paper considers how two groups of teachers, the senior and the younger generation, acquire and shine their authoritative light in unique ways. The article asserts that within the senior teachers an elect group of ‘luminaries’ exemplify a deep level of learning combined with practice and embodiment, while the remaining teachers are granted authority by virtue of the Prophetic light, or Hadith, they radiate. The younger generation of British-born teachers, however, are the torchbearers at the leading edge of directing the DU. While it may take time for them to acquire the social and symbolic capital of the senior teachers, operationally, they are the ones illuminating the way forward. The paper discusses the implications of the changing nature of authority within the DU is likely to have for Muslims in Britain. Keywords: Dar al-Uloom; Islam in Britain; Deoband; ulama; tradition; authority 1. Introduction During research undertaken for my PhD thesis, authority emerged as a significant analytical category and became one of the lenses through which I examined the Dar al-Uloom (DU).1 Its relationship with the Islamic tradition, that of being anchored in an authentic past, results in intense competition among British Muslims who vie to present themselves as heirs of an authentic interpretation and practice of Islam (Gilliat-Ray 2010).
    [Show full text]
  • Winckelmann, Greek Masterpieces, and Architectural Sculpture
    Winckelmann, Greek masterpieces, and architectural sculpture. Prolegomena to a history of classical archaeology in museums Book or Report Section Accepted Version Smith, A. C. (2017) Winckelmann, Greek masterpieces, and architectural sculpture. Prolegomena to a history of classical archaeology in museums. In: Lichtenberger, A. and Raja, R. (eds.) The Diversity of Classical Archaeology. Studies in Classical Archaeology, 1. Brepols. ISBN 9782503574936 Available at http://centaur.reading.ac.uk/70169/ It is advisable to refer to the publisher’s version if you intend to cite from the work. See Guidance on citing . Published version at: http://www.brepols.net/Pages/ShowProduct.aspx?prod_id=IS-9782503574936-1 Publisher: Brepols All outputs in CentAUR are protected by Intellectual Property Rights law, including copyright law. Copyright and IPR is retained by the creators or other copyright holders. Terms and conditions for use of this material are defined in the End User Agreement . www.reading.ac.uk/centaur CentAUR Central Archive at the University of Reading Reading’s research outputs online Winckelmann, Greek Masterpieces, and Architectural Sculpture Prolegomena to a History of Classical Archaeology in Museums∗ Amy C. Smith ‘Much that we might imagine as ideal was natural for them [the ancient Greeks].’1 ♣ Just as Johann Joachim Winckelmann mourned the loss of antiquity, so have subsequent generations mourned his passing at the age of fifty, in 1768, as he was planning his first journey to Greece. His deification through — not least — the placement of his profile head, as if carved out of a gemstone, on the title page of the first volume of his Geschichte der Kunst des Alterthums (‘History of Ancient Art’) in 1776 (the second edition, published posthumously) made him the poster boy for the study of classical art history and its related branches, Altertumswissenschaft or classical studies, history of art, and classical 2 archaeology.
    [Show full text]
  • Neil Macgregor from Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    Neil MacGregor From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia 5 Robert Neil MacGregor, OM, AO, FSA (born 16 June 1946) is a British art historian and museum director. He was the Editor of the Burlington Magazine from 1981 to 1987, the Director of the National Gallery, London, from 1987 to 2002, and was appointed Director of the British Museum in 2002. He has presented three television series on art and the BBC Radio 4 series A History of the World in 100 Objects, which aired in 2010 and later 10 became a best-selling book.[1] He has announced that he will step down as Director of the British Museum on 15th December 2015. Biography 15 Neil MacGregor was born in Glasgow to two doctors, Alexander and Anna MacGregor. At the age of nine, he first saw Salvador Dalí's Christ of Saint John of the Cross, newly acquired by Glasgow's Kelvingrove Art Gallery, which had a profound effect on him and sparked his lifelong interest in art. MacGregor was educated at Glasgow Academy and 20 then read modern languages at New College, Oxford, where he is now an honorary fellow. The period that followed was spent studying philosophy at the École Normale Supérieure in Paris (coinciding with the events of May 1968), and as a law student at Edinburgh 25 University, where he received the Green Prize. Despite being called to the bar in 1972, MacGregor next decided to take an art history degree. The following year, on a Courtauld Institute (University of London) summer school in Bavaria, the Courtauld's director Anthony Blunt spotted MacGregor and persuaded him to take a master's degree under his supervision.[3] Blunt later considered MacGregor "the most brilliant pupil he 30 ever taught".[4] From 1975 to 1981, MacGregor taught History of Art and Architecture at the University of Reading.
    [Show full text]