DOCSLIB.ORG

Appeal Against the Refusal of Planning Permission by the London Borough of Islington in Relation to Planning Application P2016/3477/FUL

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Appeal Against the Refusal of Planning Permission by the London Borough of Islington in Relation to Planning Application P2016/3477/FUL Appeal against the refusal of planning permission by the London Borough of Islington in relation to Planning Application P2016/3477/FUL Removal of existing closet wing pitched roof and creation of new opening in rear wall of closet wing; the erection of a single storey garden room to the rear of the existing closet wing and a flat roof unifying the closet wing and extension. Conversion of interior of existing closet wing interior from shower room to WC and corridor. On behalf of Francesco Muntoni Prepared by Mr Ben Redsell LLB (Hons) LPA Reference: P2016/3477/FUL Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................................. 3 Description of development site and proposals .......................................................................................... 3 Planning History ........................................................................................................................................... 4 Planning Applications ............................................................................................................................... 4 Policy Justification ........................................................................................................................................ 5 National Planning Policy Guidance ........................................................................................................... 5 National Planning Policy Framework ........................................................................................................ 6 London Borough of Islington Core Strategy ............................................................................................. 7 London Borough of Islington Development Management Policies .......................................................... 7 Canonbury Conservation Area Design Guidelines SPD ............................................................................. 8 Urban Design Guide SPG .......................................................................................................................... 9 Heritage Impact Assessment ........................................................................................................................ 9 Commentary ............................................................................................................................................... 10 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................................. 11 Appendix One ............................................................................................................................................. 12 0091-BR-Muntoni Introduction This appeal is submitted on behalf of Mr Francesco Muntoni, the appellant, against the refusal by London Borough of Islington against the awarding of planning consent and listed building consent (P2016/3716/LBC) allowing the removal of existing closet wing pitched roof and creation of new opening in rear wall of closet wing; the erection of a single storey garden room to the rear of the existing closet wing and a flat roof unifying the closet wing and extension. Conversion of interior of existing closet wing interior from shower room to WC and corridor. The application was refused by the London Borough of Islington under application reference P2016/3477/FUL, and by decision notice dated 23rd November 2016. The decision notice contains the following grounds for refusal: The proposed rear extension would fail to be adequately subordinate to the original building. Consequently, the proposed extension would harm the significance of the heritage asset. The proposed works are, therefore, contrary to Policy 12 (Conserving and Enhancing the Historic Environment) of the National Planning Policy Framework 2012, policy 7.8 (Sustaining and Enhancing the Significance of Heritage Assets) of the London Plan 2015 and Policy CS9 (Protecting and Enhancing Islington's Built and Historic Environment) of Islington's Core Strategy 2011 and Policy DM2.3 of the Development Management Policies (2013). Description of development site and proposals 32 St Paul’s Road is a Grade II listed building in the Canonbury Conservation Area. It is one of a row of early Victorian properties completed in around 1845, a three-storey house with raised ground floors above a basement; the front ground floor elevations are rendered with rustications; the rear elevations are in plain London stock brickwork. The importance of these properties is reflected by the care with which the architect has taken to put together the application and the Design & Access Statement. Most of the rear facades of the properties have been modified over the years - with varying degrees of success: single storey closet wings were added when siphoning lavatories became popular; in some properties a second storey was added to the closet wing; in others contemporary structures have replaced, or built out from, the closet wing. 32 St Paul’s Road is one of the few properties which still has the original tall, slim first floor stair half- landing window over a single storey closet wing. The design highlighted this feature by replacing the existing pitched roof of the single storey closet wing with a flat roof, increasing the proportion of the main volume visible from the rear. Permission for a single storey extension to the closet wing was sought in order to create a garden room and so provide a greater connection between the living space of the property and the garden. The proposed access to this garden room was via a short corridor next to a replacement WC. Given the listed building status of the property, it was felt important to keep a WC in the closet wing, so as to retain the original purpose for which that wing was added. Moving the WC elsewhere would have compromised the original layout of this Grade II listed building, and was not considered an option by the architects. 0091-BR-Muntoni In order to accommodate the WC as well as the new garden room, the extension had to be appropriately sized. If the total depth of the extended closet wing were limited, for instance, to 3.5m, then the garden room could only be 1.6m in depth. This was clearly unacceptable from an amenity point of view, and so a closet wing with total depth of 5m, which would allow a living room of similar size to the rear drawing room, was proposed. It was proposed that the extension and the closet wing be unified under a single flat sedum roof, so as to minimise the visual impact when viewed from the garden, or from above. Windows, cladding and rainwater goods were to have a natural finish, such as timber and zinc, to be agreed with the Conservation Officer. It was felt this approach would result in an extension which would have significantly less impact on the setting of the Grade II listed building than other nearby extensions allowed in recent applications. Planning History Planning Applications (Local Planning Authority References) P2016/0308/FUL Removal of existing closet wing pitched roof and creation of new opening in rear wall of closet wing; the erection of a single storey garden room to the rear of the existing closet wing and a flat roof unifying the closet wing and extension. Conversion of interior of existing closet wing interior from shower room to WC and corridor (Withdrawn). P2016/0382/LBC Listed Building Consent for P2016/0308/FUL above. (Withdrawn). P2016/1486/FUL Removal of existing closet wing pitched roof and creation of new opening in rear wall of closet wing; the erection of a single storey garden room to the rear of the existing closet wing and a flat roof unifying the closet wing and extension. Conversion of interior of existing closet wing from shower room to garden room. (Approved 10/06/2016). P2016/1654/LBC Listed Building Consent for P2016/1486/FUL above. (Approved). P2016/1497/FUL Installation of a shower room in the former coal store under the entrance approach, and a new glazed door to the void under the entrance stairs including lowering over existing floor levels. (Refused 07/07/2016) REFUSED: By virtue of the lowering and underpinning of the coal vault would harm the significance of the heritage assets of the Listed Building and Canonbury Conservation Area. P2016/1790/LBC Listed Building Consent for P2016/1497/FUL above. (Refused). 0091-BR-Muntoni Policy Justification National Planning Policy Guidance The Government issued National Planning Practice Guidance in 2014, replacing 7,000 pages of planning guidance that was previously published in separate documents. Together with the National Planning Policy Framework, the NPPG sets out what the Government expects of local authorities. The overall aim is to ensure the planning system allows land to be used for new homes and jobs, while protecting valuable natural and historic environments. Among the 42 different topics is a substantial amount of work regarding conserving and enhancing the historic environment. The conservation of heritage assets in a manner appropriate to their significance is a core planning principle. Heritage assets are an irreplaceable resource and effective conservation delivers wider social, cultural, economic and environmental benefits. Conservation is an active process of maintenance and managing change. It requires a flexible and thoughtful approach to get the best out of assets as diverse as listed buildings in every day use to
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 6 Parkgate Street, Dublin 8, to the Record of Protected Structures in Accordance with Section 54 and 55 of the Planning and Development Act, 2000 (As Amended)
    Conservation Section, Planning & Development Department Civic Offices, Wood Quay, Dublin 8 An Rannóg Caomhantais, An Roinn Pleanála agus Forbairt Maoine Oifigí na Cathrach, An Ché Adhmaid, Baile Átha Cliath 8 T. 01 222 3927 F. 01 222 2830 8th December 2020 (Revision A) To the Chairperson and Members of the Central Area Committee Initiation of the Statutory Process for the Proposed Addition of No.6 Parkgate Street, Dublin 8, to the Record of Protected Structures in accordance with Section 54 and 55 of the Planning and Development Act, 2000 (as amended). The initiation of the statutory addition process was agreed by the Central Area Committee of Dublin City Council at its monthly meeting on the 10th November 2020 PHOTOGRAPH OF STRUCTURE Introduction It is proposed to initiate procedures under Section 54 and Section 55 of the Planning & Development Act 2000 (as amended) to add ‘No.6 Parkgate Street, Dublin 8’ to Dublin City Council’s Record of Protected Structures. Proposal for Addition Minister for Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht on the 4th of June 2014. Request by Member of General Public on 17th of January 2019. Summary of Reasons for Seeking Addition Minister for Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht: List of recommendations for inclusion on the RPS of structures deemed as being of ‘Regional’ significance or higher identified during Stage 1 of the Dublin Survey carried out by the National Inventory of Architectural Heritage. No.6 Parkgate Street, Dublin 8, together with the neighbouring properties at Nos.7 and 8 Parkgate Street, Dublin 8 has been assigned a ‘Regional’ rating.
    [Show full text]
  • SOHO Design in the Near Future
    Rochester Institute of Technology RIT Scholar Works Theses 12-2005 SOHO design in the near future SooJung Lee Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.rit.edu/theses Recommended Citation Lee, SooJung, "SOHO design in the near future" (2005). Thesis. Rochester Institute of Technology. Accessed from This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by RIT Scholar Works. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses by an authorized administrator of RIT Scholar Works. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Rochester Institute of Technology A thesis Submitted to the Faculty of The College of Imaging Arts and Sciences In Candidacy for the Degree of Master of Fine Arts SOHO Design in the near future By SooJung Lee Dec. 2005 Approvals Chief Advisor: David Morgan David Morgan Date Associate Advisor: Nancy Chwiecko Nancy Chwiecko Date S z/ -tJ.b Associate Advisor: Stan Rickel Stan Rickel School Chairperson: Patti Lachance Patti Lachance Date 3 -..,2,2' Ob I, SooJung Lee, hereby grant permission to the Wallace Memorial Library of RIT to reproduce my thesis in whole or in part. Any reproduction will not be for commercial use or profit. Signature SooJung Lee Date __3....:....V_6-'-/_o_6 ____ _ Special thanks to Prof. David Morgan, Prof. Stan Rickel and Prof. Nancy Chwiecko - my amazing professors who always trust and encourage me sincerity but sometimes make me confused or surprised for leading me into better way for three years. Prof. Chan hong Min and Prof. Kwanbae Kim - who introduced me about the attractive
    [Show full text]
  • Architectural Access Board 1/27/06 521
    521 CMR: ARCHITECTURAL ACCESS BOARD 521 CMR 44.00: GROUP 2 BATHROOMS 44.1 GENERAL In all dwelling units required to be Group 2A units, (see 521 CMR 9.4 Group 2A Dwelling Units) all bathrooms and half bathrooms shall comply with 521 CMR 44, exclusive of the bold and italicized text which refer to Group 2B units. In facilities required to have Group 2B bathrooms, such as hotels, motels, inns and health facilities, the bathroom shall comply with 521 CMR including the bold and italicized text which refer to Group 2B units. 44.2 WHEELCHAIR TURNING SPACE Bathrooms shall have or be capable of having wheelchair turning space which complies with 521 CMR 6.3, Wheelchair Turning Space without coming into contact with any fixtures. See Fig. 44a. 44.3 DOORS Shall comply with 521 CMR 26.5, Width through 521 CMR 26.11, Door Hardware. Doors shall swing out, fold or slide. Doors may swing into the bathroom only if the door does not impede the wheelchair turning space. 44.4 WATER CLOSETS Shall comply with the following: 44.4.1 Location: The centerline of the water closet shall be located 18 inches (18" = 457mm) from the nearest side wall and at least 42 inches (42" = 1067mm) from the farthest side wall or the closest edge of an adjacent fixture. There shall be 42 inches (42" = 1067mm) clear from the front edge of the water closet to the nearest wall or fixture. 1/27/06 521 CMR - 185 521 CMR: ARCHITECTURAL ACCESS BOARD 44.00: GROUP 2 BATHROOMS 44.4.2 Height: The top of the water closet seat shall be 15 inches to 19 inches (15" to 19" = 381mm to 483mm) above the floor.
    [Show full text]
  • Residential Square Footage Guidelines
    R e s i d e n t i a l S q u a r e F o o t a g e G u i d e l i n e s North Carolina Real Estate Commission North Carolina Real Estate Commission P.O. Box 17100 • Raleigh, North Carolina 27619-7100 Phone 919/875-3700 • Web Site: www.ncrec.gov Illustrations by David Hall Associates, Inc. Copyright © 1999 by North Carolina Real Estate Commission. All rights reserved. 7,500 copies of this public document were printed at a cost of $.000 per copy. • REC 3.40 11/1/2013 Introduction It is often said that the three most important factors in making a home buying decision are “location,” “location,” and “location.” Other than “location,” the single most-important factor is probably the size or “square footage” of the home. Not only is it an indicator of whether a particular home will meet a homebuyer’s space needs, but it also affords a convenient (though not always accurate) method for the buyer to estimate the value of the home and compare it to other properties. Although real estate agents are not required by the Real Estate License Law or Real Estate Commission rules to report the square footage of properties offered for sale (or rent), when they do report square footage, it is essential that the information they give prospective purchasers (or tenants) be accurate. At a minimum, information concerning square footage should include the amount of living area in the dwelling. The following guidelines and accompanying illustrations are designed to assist real estate brokers in measuring, calculating and reporting (both orally and in writing) the living area contained in detached and attached single-family residential buildings.
    [Show full text]
  • Storage Closet
    WRD-01272 WRD-01518 60" wide double door storage closet 64 in H x 60 in W x 19.7 in D (163 cm H x 152.4 cm W x 50 cm D) www.honeycando.com | [email protected] | 877.2.I.can.do (877.242.2636) IMPORTANT! Plead read prior to use. This Honey-Can-Do 60 inch Wide Double Door Storage Closet is designed for indoor use. Please do not over-load. To prevent tipping, we recommend that you evenly distribute the weight throughout the unit. Please keep top hanger bar horizontal when in use. Please do not use storage closet for anything other than its intended use. Please do not allow children, husbands or pets to hang from or hide in storage closet. Please keep away from heat sources such as heaters and fireplaces. 2 PARTS LIST PART/ILLUSTRATION (QTY) DESCRIPTION (6) side supports (these holes Do Not pass all the way through support) (3) middle supports (these holes pass all the way through support) (5) tapered supports bars (12) uprights E (5) support bars F (1) cover G (1) tapered hang bar (1/8" thicker than support bar) H (1) hang bar (1/8" thicker than support bar) Thank you for purchasing a Honey-Can-Do Storage Closet! Please follow these step by step instructions carefully. Plan to spend about 35 minutes assembling your new closet. For assistance, please contact us at [email protected] or 877.2.i.Can.Do. Your closet will hold up to 50lbs when hangers are evenly distributed across the unit.
    [Show full text]
  • A Place for Everything in Your Saint Louis Closet Co
    Spring 2015 Cooking up Something Super for Your Pantry Second to the master closet, pantries are on the top of homeowners’ lists to organize with customized shelving and accessories; this is no surprise since the kitchen is often considered “the heart of the home.” Where does everyone wind up at a party…in the kitchen. According to Closets Magazine, when touring model homes, visitors spend more time in the kitchen than any other room in the home. Saint Louis Closet Co. has noticed that with the increase in popularity of purchasing in bulk from large box stores, there is more and more focus on storage of foods, paper goods, and even excess dishes and appliances. Saint Louis Closet Co. custom closets can truly make a difference in your pantry. Maximizing your kitchen pantry with corner shelving, platter dividers and adjustable shelving for the varied size items stored in pantries can make overall kitchen storage simpler. Chrome pull-out wine racks store wine bottles at a 15-degree angle to ensure corks remain moist in storage. Pull-out chrome baskets in various sizes are perfect for paper goods, chips, and recycling. And don’t forget tray shelves and basket-rimmed shelves for canned goods and small boxes. Once you’ve realized there’s a place for everything in your Saint Louis Closet Co. pantry…then everything will be in its place in your kitchen! Saint Louis Closet Co. offers free in-home design consultations for all areas of your home. Call us at (314) 781-9000 or visit us online at www.stlouisclosetco.com.
    [Show full text]
  • Proper Wardrobe Storage & Preservation Do's and Don'ts From
    Proper Wardrobe Storage & Preservation Do’s and Don’ts from the Experts at Garde Robe So, you have the walk-in closet you always dreamed of and assembled an impeccable collection of priceless vintage, haute couture, evening wear, footwear and accessories. Now, how do you go about protecting your precious wardrobe and keeping items in pristine condition? Never store your wardrobe in: • Basements, attics or closets where the temperature and humidity levels are inconsistent • Closed closets in your second or infrequently visited home • Closets that have an outside wall (these closets tend to have higher relative humidity) • Near a window with sunlight • Plastic or vinyl bags Your wardrobe’s worst enemies are changes in temperature, sunlight, moisture and material-damaging insects such as clothes moths. Heat - Particularly a problem for garments made from animal skins and furs. These fabrics require the natural oil to remain supple and prevent degradation and loss of integrity of the skin. Dry skins will eventually break down and becoming weakened and split. Sunlight - Dye fading. The first color to fail will be any dye with purple including many blue garments. Sun fading can happen in as short a time as a few hours. Be careful when hanging a jacket in the back of a car to prevent over exposure. Moisture = mold and mildew. Closets are generally dark places with little air movement. Add moisture and this is the perfect environment for the growth of mildew. Be sure to air out items that may have been subjected to high relative humidity before returning back to your closet.
    [Show full text]
  • Capsule Wardrobe’
    THE CAPSULE CLOSET PHENOMENON – A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDY OF LIVED EXPERIENCES WITH CAPSULE CLOSETS Thesis for Master, 30 ECTS Textile Management Giuliana Heger Thesis-id: 2016.15.05 Date: 3. June 2016 Title: The capsule closet phenomenon – A phenomenological study of lived experiences with capsule closets Publication year: 2016 Author: Giuliana Heger Supervisor: Jonas Larsson Abstract The idea for this paper resulted out of a curiosity for minimalist lifestyle concepts, namely capsule closets and the missing research about this topic as well as the importance of this concept for the society, the environment and the future of the fashion and textile industry. The study describes a phenomenological study in which the researcher explored participants’ lived experiences with capsule closets in order to provide a better understanding of the capsule closet experience. Fixed-interval diaries and semi-structured in-depth interviews with five women were conducted. Using descriptive phenomenological analysis, the researcher identified seven essential themes representing the lived experiences found in participants’ experience with capsule closets: 1) Feeling excited, enthusiastic and determined; 2) Feeling relived and satisfied; 3) Experiencing struggles and challenges; 4) Feelings of guilt and regret; 5) Feeling limited, bored and less creative; 6) Feelings of accomplishment and proudness; 7) Learning experience. These findings both support and contribute to existing literature related to this topic and provide new insights and add new aspects to the knowledge of the capsule closet experience. Keywords: capsule closets, minimalism, minimalist lifestyle concepts, mass consumption, phenomenology, lived experiences Acknowledgement This master thesis was written on behalf of the Master in Fashion Management at the Swedish School of Textiles in Borås, Sweden.
    [Show full text]
  • Closet Systems Add Value and Style the Easy Way
    CLOSET SYSTEMS ADD VALUE AND STYLE THE EASY WAY RubbermaidPro.com Rubbermaid Limited Lifetime Warranty Rubbermaid manufactures durable, high-quality merchandise. We warrant that, when professionally installed, our closet and garage systems are free of defects in materials or workmanship for life. MAKE A SMALL CHANGE FOR A BIG IMPACT Today’s demanding consumers want the most for their money. Closet upgrades offer homeowners a big value for a small investment. From basic to beautiful, Rubbermaid has the storage products homeowners want, and we also have the selling tools you need to satisfy your customers effortlessly. • Master bedroom retreats • Standard walk-in closets • Highly functional pantries • Traffic-ready mudrooms It’s so simple to create the ideal storage solution that will make a big impact on your business and your customers’ satisfaction. Rubbermaid is a Builder Brand Leader in Closet/Organization Systems Made in the USA BASIC WIRE Storage for Every Space The epoxy-coated wire shelving is: Rubbermaid’s basic white wire shelving is • Constructed from industrial-grade steel designed to provide sturdy storage options • Smooth with a glass-like finish that prevents dust buildup for every area of the home. • Virtually maintenance-free Good Options: Linen Shelving – A standard way to store folded clothing Wardrobe Shelving – A standard solution for hanging clothes and common household goods. in bedrooms and laundry areas. ADVANCED WIRE Functional Style For just a little bit more than the cost of a basic wire closet, consumers can enjoy greater style and functionality – and more value. Today’s homeowners want pantries that complement their new stainless steel appliances and closets that embrace trendy hardware that’s now standard in most new homes.
    [Show full text]
  • Planning Statement
    ! PLANNING STATEMENT 102 Cloudesley Road, N1 By David Rea Architects Proposed extension to rear closet wing, and glazed extension at basement level of this grade 2 listed house. SUMMARY OF CONSERVATION POLICY RELATING TO ROOF EXTENSIONS. The Barnsbury Area CA TEN policy document notes that (10.12) ‘ In considering applications for extensions and refurbishment, the council will normally require the use of traditional materials “. In policy 10.19 it is noted that “ rear extensions will be permitted on their merits and only where scale, design and materials to be used and in keeping with the existing property and where all other planning standards are met” From the above extract it may be deduced that the purpose of the policies is to avoid interruption of a regular rhythm that is part of the street’s design, or to attract inappropriate attention to roof level at the expense of the original composition. Closet Wing extension This proposal is in accordance with the consented addition and dormer window at 64 Cloudesley Road (Application Numbers: P110934 and P120051) and at 68 Cloudesley Road (Application Number: P122129). Two further extensions of similar design have been granted at nos. 94 & no. 104 Cloudesley Road. The proposal for an extension on top of the rear closet wing will not affect a terrace composition, the addition is proposed for the rear elevation above the existing closet wing. No. 102 being part of a terraced composition, and situated along the terrace, the rear elevation is not visible from any highway, and is hardly visible from within the rear gardens as it is substantially set back from the existing parapet edge of the closet wing.
    [Show full text]
  • Pantry and Fabric Pests in the Home
    E-486 10/08 Pantry and Fabric Pests in the Home Michael Merchant, Wizzie Brown, and Grady Glenn* ood and fabric pests can be found at some rodent nests. Carpet beetle adults are often found on time in nearly every home. Many of these crape myrtles and other ornamental shrubs and flow- F pests are no more than an occasional incon- ers. Once indoors, carpet beetles or clothes moths may venience; others can cause significant damage to food lay their eggs on woolen carpets or stored fabric items. or personal articles. If an infestation develops in your home, the advice below should help you manage it. Some insects feed primarily on plant materials Pantry pests and are usually found in stored foods in kitchens and Pests of seeds, grains, and spices pantries. Other insects feed primarily on products con- The most common pests in Texas home pantries taining animal proteins, such as hair, feathers, pow- are cigarette and drugstore beetles (Fig. 1). The larvae dered milk, woolen fabrics, leather and hides, and of these beetles feed on all kinds of plant material, in- some pet foods. Pests of animal products are more cluding beans, flour, grains, nuts, seeds, spices, to- likely to infest closets and areas other than kitchens. bacco, potpourri, cottonseed meal, dried flower ar- Both food and fabric pests can be found almost rangements, and dried fruits and vegetables. anywhere in a home. If you find the same kind of The adults are 1/8 to 1/10 inch long with cylindrical, insect repeatedly in a kitchen or closet, it is good evi- brown to reddish brown bodies.
    [Show full text]
  • Pantry Makeovers
    Cthe menu Storage tip: Place little-used vessels above and everyday goods right up front. Taking Stock Gourmet living in the Golden State begins with the Frances Janisch feel-good flavors behind those pantry doorsBY ANDREA STANFORD edited by alison clare steingold may 2011 C 77 menu FROM LEFT Pamela Salzman at cupboards as part of a primary mission to make the Beverly cooking with organic, locally grown, and whole, Hills home of a client. natural foods easy. “It all starts with a well- Pantry closet. stocked and perfectly planned pantry,” she Keeping healthy snacks quips from her own bright kitchen in Manhattan within reach. Beach as she plates a salad of dandelion greens and quinoa that she garnishes with herbs from her vegetable garden. (Indeed, Alice Waters and Michael Pollan count among the strongest influences on her food philosophy.) “It’s the foundation for more healthful cooking,” she says. “With the right items, you won’t have to rely on convenience foods.” Here, Salzman dishes some tips for getting started: LIKE WITH LIKE A pantry consists of categories: Whole amela Salzman loves a bustling kitchen. “I want it to grains, flours, legumes, fats/oils, sweeteners and baking essentials, be the most active part of the home—a place where nuts and miscellany, produce, and, of course, snacks. Salzman P people are actually preparing meals and gathering to prefers to work in groupings (for example, keeping baking share them,” says the nutrition and cooking instructor. When items together), though she advises perishables which spoil not leading in-demand classes (attended by the likes of L.A.
    [Show full text]