Feminist Analysis of Belly Dance and Its Portrayal in the Media
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FEMINISM IN BELLY DANCE AND ITS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA Meghana B.S Registered Number 1324038 A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Communication Christ University Bengaluru 2015 Program Authorized to Offer Degree Department of Media Studies ii Authorship Christ University Department of Media Studies Declaration This is to certify that I have examined this copy of a master‟s thesis by Meghana B.S Registered Number1324038 and have found that it is complete and satisfactory in all respects, and that any and all revisions required by the final examining committee have been made. Committee Members: _____________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________ Date:__________________________________ iii iv Abstract I, Meghana B.S, confirm that this dissertation and the work presented in it are original. 1. Where I have consulted the published work of others this is always clearly attributed. 2. Where I have quoted from the work of others the source is always given. With the exception of such quotations this dissertation is entirely my own work. 3. I have acknowledged all main sources of help. 4. If my research follows on from previous work or is part of a larger collaborative research project I have made clear exactly what was done by others and what I have contributed myself. 5. I am aware and accept the penalties associated with plagiarism. Date: Signature v vi Abstract Feminism in Bellydance and its portrayal in the media Meghana B.S MS in Communication, Christ University, Bengaluru Bellydance is an art form that has gained tremendous popularity in the world today. There are different kinds of bellydance such as folk, tribal fusion, cabaret etc. In a world and time where women‟s rights and respect has been the foremost of most people‟s concerns, bellydance with its barrier breaking techniques and methods have created controversies yet have also resulted in a form of dance that is beautiful and helps a woman celebrate herself. A feminist analysis of belly dance gives an insight into different viewpoints that gives belly dance its extreme contrasting reactions. Certain feminists believe belly dance is empowering whereas others believe that it degrades women and is a set-back for women‟s rights. Media disseminates information and has an influence over what people perceive. Various theories have provided an insight into the power of media and its impact on society. This paper takes a look at bellydance from a general feminist perspective and also forays into the media‟s portrayal of this dance form by using a qualitative method of analysis. Key words: Belly dance, Feminism, Media, stereotypes vii viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author wishes to express sincere appreciation to the Department of Media Studies for their extended long-term support and especially to Professor Suparna Naresh and Professor Sushma Murthy for their vast reserve of patience and knowledge. This thesis would never have been completed without the encouragement and devotion of my family and friends. ix x DEDICATION To my family and friends xi xii TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................... 1 Chapter 2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE .......................................................................... 9 Chapter 3 METHODOLOGY ........................................................................................ 13 3.1 Research Problem ......................................................................................... 17 Chapter 4 ANALYSIS ................................................................................................... 19 4.1 Expert Interview ........................................................................................... 24 4.2 Focus Group Discussion ............................................................................... 44 4.3 Content Analysis ........................................................................................... 50 Chapter 5 CONCLUSION ............................................................................................. 59 5.1 Expert Interview ........................................................................................... 61 5.2 Focus Group Discussion ............................................................................... 64 5.3 Content Analysis ........................................................................................... 65 Chapter 6 WORKS CITED ............................................................................................ 68 xiii xiv Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION According to feminist theorist Bell Hooks, feminism is a not an anti-men movement but one that seeks to go against sexism, its exploitation and oppression. (Hooks, 2000) The belief that feminism is about anti-men creates dissonances and problems in the whole hearted acceptance of feminism by everybody. A simple belief about feminism is that it is simply is about having equal rights and opportunities for men and women and the prospects for a woman to whole heartedly follow her choices and desires. A theory that covers various aspects such as politics, race, gender, the human body and so on, feminism is a vast and interlinks various other thoughts and disciplines such as psychology and literature. Belly dance is one of the oldest dance forms that have been recorded. The word „belly dance‟ itself brings to mind various images, most of them stereotypical, some of them true and others that are an insult to the art form. Most of these images include a skimpily clad woman moving her hips sensuously while reality is much beyond this. Belly dance has not been seen for the art form that it is but more as a means of titillating others and sexually attractive rather than sensual. Women who practise this art form in most cases have been looked down upon and have been thought to be a little too „free‟ or in some extreme cases, „shameless‟. There are people who see belly dance for what it is, a dance form that lets a woman express herself in various ways. It requires a certain level of comfort with the body and this in turn helps in liberating her. Apart from keeping a woman physically fit, belly dance also has a positive impact on self-esteem and body issues and helps a person become more comfortable and accepting of herself. Contrary to popular belief, belly dance is not restricted to just women, there are certain dance schools that involve men as well and there are various famous male belly dancers as well. Dance, on its own is a subjective art form. The beauty of it is that it allows everyone to have their own personal way of connecting, interpreting and expressing themselves. Bellydance is a subject whose history is highly contested and hence, has led to conflicting theories. There are many plausible theories regarding the history. Many believe that it is the oldest form of dance. Many believe that it originated in Egypt; some believe that it was spread by gypsies travelling from India. Bellydance is known by a lot of names for example, “dance du ventre” is the name given by the French which means “Dance of the stomach”. “Cifte telli” which is also the name of Turkish rhythm is the name given by the Greeks and in Egypt it is called “Raks/Raqs Sharki”. In order to distinguish it from “baladi” or country dance,the middle easterners called it “dance orientale”. It advanced through the influence of various areas and is still developing today as well. Some also refer to it as “Eastern dance”, “Indian Dance” etc. Bellydance has a lot of haziness associated with it mainly due to its history where it was allied to both erotic and religious elements. Many believe that it has origins linked to ancient fertility cults and rituals. Fertility rituals have existed in several ancient cultures. These ancient cultures also had a representative Mother Goddess under different names such as Ishtar, Aphrodite, Venus, Bhagvati and Isis. The main function that was represented by these Goddess was reproduction and in terms of the entire planet and not just human beings. These beings guaranteed that cycle of seasons and the growth of crops were steady, perpetuation of race and increase of livestock. The fortune of these cities and civilizations were based on the benevolence and happiness of their mother deities. None of these divine beings were celibate nor were the priestesses expected to be celibate as it went against their purpose. This was one of the commencements of temple prostitution which was hailed in its day and time. There is evidence of these practises in the writings of Plautus, Socrates etc. Sacred dancing was also a part of the ritual especially a particular form that placed emphasis on the abdomen which was the source of fertility. Even today in Egypt, custom dictates that the wedding could hire a bellydancer and to later capture an image with their hands on the belly dancer‟s stomach. This practise is no doubt a reference to fertility rituals. The Berber tribal birthing ceremony is evocative of these ancient rituals. A hollow is dug in the ground where the mother-to-be sits; she is surrounded by women who dance with repetitive abdominal movements while the woman gives birth. This dance was considered sacred and was not meant for the entertainment of men. Bellydance is traditionally performed barefoot, primarily because it connects the dancer directly to the Earth. This form of dance developed from traditional