ANATOMY OF POLITICAL MELANCHOLY ATHENS CONSERVATOIRE
ANATOMY OF POLITICAL MELANCHOLY
CURATOR’S TEXT 2 ARTISTS KATERINA APOSTOLIDOU 12 MARC BAUER 16 SARA SEJIN CHANG 20 MARIANNA CHRISTOFIDES 24 DEPRESSION ERA 28 EIRENE EFSTATHIOU 32 MARINA GIOTI 36 JAN PETER HAMMER 40 SVEN JOHNE 44 YORGOS KARAILIAS 48 SPIROS KOKKONIS 52 ARIANE LOZE 56 ADRIAN MELIS 60 TOM MOLLOY 64 DIMITRIS MYTAS 68 JENNIFER NELSON 72 YORGOS PRINOS 76 CHRYSA ROMANOS 80 HANS ROSENSTRÖM 84 GEORGES SALAMEH 88 NESTORI SYRJÄLÄ 92 THU VAN TRAN 96 DIMITRIS TSOUMPLEKAS 100 BRAM VAN MEERVELDE 104
EDUCATION PROGRAMME 108 ABOUT THE SCHWARZ FOUNDATION ABOUT THE ATHENS CONSERVATOIRE 110 COLOPHON 112 Katerina Gregos / Curator ANATOMY OF POLITICAL MELANCHOLY
“Change happens when we decide - what we want, rather than what we think we might get.”1 1 — George Monbiot
What has happened to the state of contemporary politics? Wasn’t there once a time when politicians were driven primarily by unselfish - motives or altruistic intentions and entered politics to serve the public good — a time when politicians - were well-educated people, bound by moral integrity and high ideals? True, politics has always been - prone to corruption and the abuse of power, but in recent years it seems that self-serving private interests — or the interests of industry and business — have come to take precedence over the inter- ests of the wider electorate. - Citizens, it seems, exist only to be 2 managed, manipulated and - exploited, rather than served. - Political campaigns deliver mes- - sages of fear, rather than of hope or vision; scandals abound and mis- creants offer apologies without sin- - cerity and then quickly return to - ‘business as usual’. Voting is no longer about positive choice, but about accepting the lesser of two evils. No wonder that fewer and fewer people are turning out to - vote, while many of those who still do are disaffected. Moreover, many voters have been abandoning traditional main- stream parties while an ever-in- creasing group of people don’t identify with a specific party. As sociologist Stephanie L. Mudge - points out, “electorally, the ‘losers’ of ‘globalisation’ — that is, a whole 2 lot of people, including whole com- munities — ended up with no party that spoke for them2. In her excel- lent interview Neoliberalism from the Left she also discusses the cur- rent shift to the Right and how - these parties pretend to be repre- - sentatives of the disempowered and the disenfranchised; the most telling example of this of course, being Trump’s electoral victory in - 2016. However, she goes yet further to critique the Left for creating a political vacuum. She talks about one of the failures of the Left as being the espousal of “Third Way” - politics from the 1990s onwards; - i.e. embracing the politics of the free market, privatization and finan- - cialization more and more, while increasingly relinquishing the idea of the welfare state (one obvious example of this would be Tony Blair’s ‘New Labour’). “Culturally”, she suggests, “criticism of the neo-liberal order was marginalized 3 and hived off as a province of the - ‘radical’ left, rather than being the stuff of mainstream political dis- course — where it should have been all along”.3 - To make matters worst, we are increasingly witnesses to 3 the debasement of political lan-
1. George Monbiot, Our democracy is broken, debased and distrusted — but there are ways to fix it, The Guardian, 25th January 2017. www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/ jan/25/democracy-broken-distrusted-trump-brexit-politi- cal-system?CMP=fb_gu&fbclid=IwAR2RMtUgC6MYhmUU- TygcMrAUGHRVIwg576w1ar-p-HVp_zrLr7fAV1Lh7DA
2. Neoliberalism From the Left: An Interview with Stephanie L. Mudge https://jacobinmag.com/2018/08/left-political-par- ty-economists-neoliberalims-keynesianism 3. Ibid EN GR guage; the infantilisation and polar- - isation of political debate; the growth of a simplified discourse that panders to collective fears rather than addressing the real, pressing questions; the lack of accountability from politicians, and of course, ‘fake truth’ and ‘alterna- - tive facts’. Welcome then to the heyday of ‘psychopolitics’ — the interaction between politics or - political phenomena and human psychology. With Trump in the White House, Putin in the Kremlin, and Bolsonaro in the Brazilian National Congress psychopolitics has taken on a new, frightening, - meaning. No wonder so many of us - feel disillusioned. Philosopher 4 Lieven de Cauter calls this sense of disillusionment ‘political melan- - choly’: a sinking feeling borne from frustration, anger, despair, mistrust, sadness and hopelessness. This - exhibition is inspired by his text Small Anatomy of Political Melancholy.4 The disillusionment - with politics, government, state institutions and political parties is at an all-time high. For the first time - since World War II (which was preceded by similar political crises - of the 1920s and 1930s), we have reason to fear the disintegration of peace and the rise of aggressive nationalism. Clearly there is something pro- foundly wrong with contemporary - politics: it is not only a case of the moral and intellectual inadequacy - of politicians, but also the gaping - chasm between the aims of politi- cians and the needs of citizens. The foundations of democracy itself are at risk, not only from the rise of 4 demagogic populism in Europe, but also from the grip of financial insti- tutions, mega-corporations and - special interest groups which have the power to influence the political agenda. Politics, it seems, has become - hostage either to opportunists or to - people of power and special inter- - est groups. The education, culture, motives, capabilities and moral - standing of politicians don’t appear to bear much weight today. Greece, - of course, exemplifies the loss of sovereignty due to debt, where ordinary citizens have been forced to bail out a country driven to finan- cial collapse by government mis- - management and corruption of the political system (this is also due to the age-old clientelist relationship between state and citizens in the country). The longstanding eco- - nomic and political crisis in Greece has led to political disillusionment, - mistrust of institutions, a sense of collective powerlessness, and a post-ideological phase character- ised by apathy, individualism, and - resignation. According to sociolo- gist of law Ioannis Kampourakis: “This defeatism fits into a longer - trend in Greece, tracing back to the defeat of the communist left after - the post-WWII Civil War, of nostal- gia and glorification of a ‘struggle - fought, even if lost’, which has aes- theticised the contemporary apathy - as a form of political pessimism and melancholy”.5 In the case of Greece, and other European countries bound by aus- terity politics, political melancholy is also inextricably tied to what has been called ‘financial melancholy’. In a recent study by the Goldsmiths - College Political Economy - Research Centre, entitled Financial Melancholia: Mental Health and Indebtedness, Professors Dr. William Davies, Dr. Johnna Montgomerie and Sara Wallin point - out that, “the rise of mental health problems such as depression can- not be understood in narrowly med- - 5 ical terms, but instead needs to be understood in its political-eco- nomic context. An economy driven - by debt (and prone to problem debt
4. Lieven de Cauter, Small Anatomy of Political Melancholy http://crisiscritique.org/special09/cauter.pdf
5. Ioannis Kampourakis, Political disillusionment in Greece: toward a post-political state? https://www.opendemocracy. net/can-europe-make-it/ioannis-kampourakis/political-disillu- sionment-in-greece-toward-post-political-state EN GR at the level of households) will have a predisposition towards rising rates of depression”6. Their study 8 - on ‘financial melancholia’ demon- strates “the influence of inequality - on rising levels of household debt and depression”7 and “foregrounds the narratives of the indebted to interpret how being trapped by past - debts through present-day repay- - ment obligations manifests as psy- - chological and sociological prob- lems of indebtedness”.8 In many - European households it is now - widely acknowledged that, “house- - hold debt overhang cultivated dur- ing the boom years generates a persistent drag on economic renewal”9. To highlight the scale of - the problem of indebtedness, they cite figures, which show that there is now three times more debt in the UK and the US since the 1990s. - They also point out how “individual obligations to creditors rise as - state obligations to citizens fall”10 - and how the “combination of 11 finance-led growth with withdrawal of services and income support from central and local governments - to low-income households has led to households at the lower end of - the income distribution relying - most heavily on private debt to - replace public welfare”11. Their research shows, how credit does 12 not offer a way of getting ahead in - life but traps people in a vicious cycle of debt and how the ‘capillary power’ of debt, “that is, its capacity 13 to invade intimate relationships in - the family, community and one’s - own body” has devastating - effects.12 Finally, it points out how “collective and individual agency - 6 are constrained, suggesting that the logic of debt is as political as it is economic.”13 The artists in the exhibition Anatomy of Political Melancholy probe the human experience of this phenomenon and reveal its com- plexities, as well as reactions to it, translating it into resonant images. Looking at it from a personal per- - spective, to a national and even a global one, exploring its effect on - the older and the younger genera- tion and its presence in different parts of the world, they point at dif- ferent aspects of our current politi- cal discontent and allude to the very real but also elusive feeling of melancholy produced on an indi- vidual and collective level. How did we get where we are? How does this disillusionment with our pres- - ent condition manifest itself in our - everyday life? What responsibilities - do we also have as citizens? Can we imagine a way out? Is it possi- - ble that solutions exist closer to us than we think? Is it time to start - believing in the existence of alter- - native futures? A social praxis, for example, which goes against inwardness, ‘atomisation’ or indi- vidualism and re-thinks politics, social relationality and participa- tory ways of being a citizen. Anatomy of Political Melancholy probes and condenses the present - condition — often mistaken as one that is also the product of the con- sumerist ‘politics of content’. Studies suggest the exact oppo- - site: a politics of disillusionment due to the status quo. The exhibi- tion comes at a timely moment: both in Greece, with elections com- ing up in the country in October - this year; but also in Europe, with the continuing Brexit impasse as - well as European Parliamentary elections in May. The latter are - expected to change the EU’s politi- -
6. Dr. William Davies, Dr. Johnna Montgomerie and Sara Wallin, Goldsmiths College Political Economy Research Centre, Financial Melancholia: Mental Health and Indebtedness, London, 2015, p. 5
7. Ibid
8. Ibid
9. Ibid
10. Ibid, p. 10
11. Ibid, p. 37
12. Ibid, p. 36
13. Ibid, p. 11 EN GR cal dynamic, due to the rising num- ber of disillusioned voters and - those who are angry at what they - perceive as the loss of national sovereignty and the disempower- ment of national governments in a globalized world. In addition to this, - the major financial and economic - crisis that has created a first tier and second tier class of EU mem- ber states, and the migration crisis has led larger number of voters to - opt for the populist and anti-estab- lishment parties, creating an - increasingly polarized landscape in - Europe. - At a time when ideologies tend to divide people instead of uniting them; that condemn instead of bringing about understanding and respect, the exhibition attempts to map a contemporary pathology of politics. It aspires to encourage us to re-consider our political and civil responsibilities, to reject political - apathy and instead restore our con- fidence in the power of both our - individual as well as collective agency; if we want things to change we all need to start thinking of how we can become more socially and - politically active — even on a small, local scale. The exhibition high- lights the dangers of political apa- - thy and points to the fact that — contrary to what neoliberal dis- course says — there are still such 14 things as society and community, particularly in countries like Greece. It is too easy to become - resigned to the present malaise, to - become merely cynical. However, as writer and activist George - Monbiot argues, the stirrings of a new sociocracy are in the making.14 8 And there are alternatives. Some of the things Monbiot suggests — the - radical reform of political campaign finance and limitations on the power of corporations to buy politi- cal space; assistance to enable vot- ers make better-informed - choices — already exist. In - Germany, for example, the federal - agency for civic education pub- lishes authoritative and accessible guides to the key political issues, - and tries to engage with groups that usually shun democratic poli- tics. Another example is - Switzerland, with its Smartvote sys- tem, which presents a list of policy choices with which one can agree or disagree, then compares one’s - answers with the policies of the parties and candidates contesting the election.15 Monbiot suggests - that a new method, ‘sociocracy’, - could enhance democracy. This is a system designed to produce inclu- sive but unanimous decisions, by encouraging members of a group to continue objecting to a proposal until, between them, they produce an answer all of them can live with. It is clear that political practice has - to be rethought, not in representing pre-constituted identities, but rather in constituting those identi- ties. This requires new ways of unorthodox political thinking, a new sense of urgency about democracy’s strengths and weak- nesses, and an open discussion about the pros and cons of liberal democracy. And lets not forget, as writer Mark Kernan has pointed out in his article In praise of melancho- lia, that melancholy can “also act as a creative spur, building a hard won modicum of self-knowledge to - build on”.16 Anatomy of Political Melancholy thus attempts the diffi- - cult task of both capturing the com- plexity of the moment and asks us to imagine a better future.
9 14. George Monbiot, Our democracy is broken, debased and distrusted – but there are ways to fix it https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jan/25/democ- racy-broken-distrusted-trump-brexit-political-system
15. These are, of course, mature European societies, which is a prerequisite for the application of such new models. It requires creating the conditions for a new political education and a new political culture.
16. Mark Kernan, In Praise of Melancholia https://www.opendemocracy.net/transformation/mark-kernan/ in-praise-of-melancholia EN GR Afterthought: The political lethargy of citi- zens — a consequence of politi- cians’ disinterest in real and urgent - socio-political and cultural prob- - lems — is indeed obvious. But plau- sible solutions are far less obvious. - Our present pessimism, resignation and apathy could instead provide a - strong and positive incentive to - think again about certain deeply felt - injustices in society. The current state of affairs is precisely the rea- son we should try to square the cir- cle of practical possibility and ideal imaginary, of pessimism and hope. It is high time that we stopped banging our heads against the wall - and made a serious attempt at rig- orous analysis and the explication - of the possible roads out of our - predicament. This exhibition is both relevant and urgent. It picks up on a debate that witnessed all around us, every day, in Greece, in Europe, and globally. (K.G.)
Katerina Gregos is a curator, lecturer and writer based in Brus- sels since 2006. She has curated numerous large-scale interna- tional exhibitions and biennials. Most recently she was chief curator of the 1st Riga International Biennial of Contemporary Art (RIBOCA1): Everything Was Forever, Until It Was No More, which she also helped to set up. Since 2016 she is curator of the non-profit, Munich-based Schwarz Foundation. Currently she is also curator of the Croatian Pavilion at the forthcoming 58th Ven- ice Biennale. Selected projects include: The State is Not a Work of Art, Tallinn Art Hall, the Art Hall Gallery and the City Gallery — on the occasion of the centenary of Estonian Independence and part of the official programme Estonia 100 (2018); A World Not Ours, Kunsthalle Mulhouse — co-production with the Schwarz Foundation (2017); Uncertain States: Artistic Strategies in States of Emergency, Akademie der Künste, Berlin (2016); Between the Pessimism of the Intellect and the Optimism of the Will, the 5th Thessaloniki Biennial (2015); The Politics of Play for the Göte- — borg Biennial and Liquid Assets: In the Aftermath of the Trans- formation of Capital, for the Steirischer Herbst, Graz (2013). In 2012 Gregos was co-curator of Manifesta 9, In the Deep of the Modern, Genk. She has also previously curated two national pavilions at the Venice Biennale, Personne et les Autres: Vincent Meessen & guests, for the Belgian Pavilion — featuring 11 international art- ists (2015) and Speech Matters, for the Danish Pavilion at the 54th Venice Biennial, featuring 18 international artists. In terms of institutional positions, Katerina Gregos has previ- ously served as director and curator of the Deste Foundation, Athens; artistic director of Argos — Centre for Art & Media, Brus- sels; and artistic director of Art Brussels. Gregos also regularly publishes on art and artists in exhibi- tion catalogues, journals and books, and is a visiting lecturer at HISK: the Higher Institute of Arts in Ghent, and the Jan Van Eyck Academy, in Maastricht. ARTISTS
11
EN GR Born in Athens, where WEBSITE: she lives and works. www.apostolidou.com KATERINA APOSTOLIDOU
In If You Will Only Keep Your Eyes Open… (2017), Katerina - Apostolidou’s poetic, evocative - three-channel black-and-white video installation, images from a - stadium in a suburban park of Athens are juxtaposed with Rosa Luxemburg’s Letters from Prison. - These are letters sent by the Polish Marxist theorist, philosopher, econ- - omist, anti-war activist, and revolu- - tionary socialist Luxemburg (R.L.), who was murdered in Berlin, to her friend Sophie Liebknecht, wife of her comrade-in-arms Karl Liebknecht, while R.L. was impris- oned in Breslau from July 1916 to October 1918. In these letters, R.L. describes in the most sensitive and detailed way - everything she is able to observe in the nature around the prison gar- den. She gives passionate and min- - 12 ute accounts of the singing of birds, a trapped insect, the trees, the clouds — or ‘simply life.’ The texts at the beginning and conclu- sion of the video, and the concur- rent projection of images constitute a metaphor of the crisis we are experiencing today. In one of her letters (24 March 1918), R.L. asks Sophie to visit the Botanical Gardens and describe for her what she can hear, saying that - this would be the most important - thing in the world, over and above - even the Battle of Cambrai. When she says that a garden’s transition from winter to spring matters more than such a historic event, R.L. is urging us to look before seeking to change it. It is this statement about the precedence of life as a key commit- ment that If You Will Only Keep Your Eyes Open… seeks to verify through meticulous observation. In the course of a calendar year, it … - attempts to record elements of life - and signs of change that are not - immediately apparent as the sea- sons change in the neglected park, and thus reveal it as a place of transmutation where everything can change. -