Instructors Guide: Adult - Foundation
Financial Capability Curriculum
Instructors Guide
Resources Feedback Reprinting Share Access Your Feedback, Order Resource & Comments & Additional Training Details on Student Guide Center Your Program Reprints
FinancialEducatorsCouncil.org FinancialEducatorsCouncil.org FinancialEducatorsCouncil.org /Course-Login /Feedback-Center /Reprint
www.FinancialEducatorsCouncil.org Copyright 2015 by the National Financial Educators Council.
All Rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
ISBN: 978-0-9797853-2-0
Printed in the United States of America
Requests for permission to make copies of any part of this book can be made to the National Financial Educators Council at [email protected] Read full terms and conditions of the usage of the instructor’s guides and PowerPoint presentations at http://www.financialeducatorscouncil.org/curriculum-cfei-terms/
No Earnings Projections, Promises, or Representations You recognize and agree that we have made no implications, warranties, promises, suggestions, projections, representations or guarantees whatsoever to you about future prospects or earnings, or that you will earn any money, with respect to your purchase of this financial education curriculum, and that we have not authorized any such projection, promise, or representation by others.
Any earnings or income statements, or any earnings or income examples, are only examples for educational purposes. There is no assurance you will do as well as stated in any examples. If you rely upon any figures provided, you must accept the entire risk of not doing as well as the information provided. This applies whether the earnings or income examples are monetary in nature or pertain to advertising credits that may be earned (whether such credits are convertible to cash or not).
Due Diligence You are advised to do your own due diligence when it comes to making business decisions and should use caution and seek the advice of qualified professionals. You should check with your accountant, lawyer, investment advisor, or other appropriate professional before acting on any investment information. You may not consider any examples, documents, or other content on the course or otherwise provided by us to be the equivalent of legal, accounting, or investment advice.
Nothing contained in the course or in materials available for sale or download on the website provides legal, investment, or accounting advice in any way. You should consult with your own attorney, financial investment advisor, and accountant with any questions you may have. We assume no responsibility for any losses or damages resulting from your use of any information or opportunity contained within the course, on the related website, or within any information disclosed by the owner of the course and the website in any form whatsoever. Visit www.FinancialEducatorsCouncil.org to review the complete earnings disclaimer and terms & conditions.
Table of Contents
FINANCIAL PSYCHOLOGY
LESSON TITLE LESSON DURATION ID (MINUTES) The Most Important Thing F1 10-30 How Does Financial Psychology Develop? F2 20-30 Where Did You Learn About Money? F3 20-40 Money & Emotions F4 20-30 Changing Your Financial Behavior F5 20-40 Dreams F6 10-40 Goals F7 10-40 Lifestyle Choices F8 20-30 Become a Life-Long Learner F9 10-20
Table of Contents
BUDGETING
LESSON TITLE LESSON DURATION ID (MINUTES) Wants vs. Needs B1 10-30 Money Management Styles B2 20-40 Can I Afford That: Vehicle B3 20-40 Can I Afford That: Renting B4 20-60 Let’s Learn to Budget B5 30-60
ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT
LESSON TITLE LESSON DURATION ID (MINUTES) Banking Basics A1 20-40 Banking Essentials A2 20-40 Debit Card v. Credit Card A3 10-30
CREDIT PROFILE
LESSON TITLE LESSON DURATION ID (MINUTES) What is Credit? C1 20-40 Credit History C2 20-40 Identity Theft C3 20-40 Table of Contents
LOANS & DEBT
LESSON DURATION LESSON TITLE ID (MINUTES) Good Debt v. Bad Debt L1 10-30 Cost & Benefits of College L2 20-30 Quantifying Your College Decision L3 20-40 Invest in Your Future L4 30-40 Funding College L5 30-40 How to Pay Off Debt L6 30-40 Car Loans L7 20-40 Loan Manager L8 20-50 Loan Qualification L9 10-30 Consequences of Default L10 20-30
Table of Contents
JOBS & CAREERS
LESSON TITLE LESSON DURATION ID (MINUTES) Identifying Passions J1 10-40 Career Changes J2 20-30 Resumes & Job Applications J3 30-120 Interviews J4 30-120 Growing & Shrinking Industries J5 20-30 Don't Get Lost In The Crowd J6 20-30 Prepare for Your Dream Job Today! J7 20-40 Networking in Your Field J8 20-30 Networking & Mentors J9 10-30 Table of Contents
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
LESSON DURATION LESSON TITLE ID (MINUTES) Be An Entrepreneur - Is It Right For You? E1 20-40 What is a Social Entrepreneur E2 20-40 Do You Have Entrepreneurial Mindset? E3 20-40 Internet-based Businesses E4 20-40 How to Start Your Internet Business E5 20-40 Calculated Risks E6 20-40 Creating a Social Enterprise! E7 20-40 Magazine Enterprise E8 20-40
ECONOMIC & GOVERNMENT INFLUENCES
LESSON TITLE LESSON DURATION ID (MINUTES) Taxes G1 20-50
Table of Contents
RISK MANAGEMENT & INSURANCE
LESSON DURATION LESSON TITLE ID (MINUTES) What's My Risk? R1 20-30 What is Insurance? R2 20-40 What Insurance Do I Need? The Basics R3 20-40 What Insurance Do I Need? Advanced R4 60-90 How Insurance Policies Work R5 20-40 Insurance Claims R6 20-40 How to Reduce Your Risk R7 20-30 Prepare for Disaster R8 20-40 Wills & Trusts R9 20-40
EVALUATING YOUR CURRENT RETIRMENT SITUATION
LESSON TITLE LESSON DURATION ID (MINUTES) Questions about Retirement S1 30-60 Retirement & Family S2 20-30 Retirement & Income S3 30-40 Retirement Plans S4 30-40 Table of Contents
INVESTMENTS
LESSON DURATION LESSON TITLE ID (MINUTES) Why People Invest V1 40-60
Introduction to Investing V2 20-30 Preparing to Invest V3 30-40 Compound Interest V4 30-60 Risk & Potential V5 10-20 Building a Team of Trusted Advisors V6 30-40 Types of Investments V7 30-45 The Stock Market V8 40-60 Investing in Real Estate V9 30-50 Investment Diversification V10 30-50 Investment Checklist V11 20-30
Financial Psychology
Financial Psychology
In this unit students will develop an understanding of how their financial psychology relates to achieving their financial and lifestyle goals. Students will explore these concepts by looking in-depth at how their personalities, goals, dreams, and emotions can affect their attitudes toward money.
Financial Psychology
LESSON DURATION LESSON TITLE ID (MINUTES) The Most Important Thing F1 10-30 How Does Financial Psychology Develop? F2 20-30 Where Did You Learn About Money? F3 20-40 Money & Emotions F4 20-30 Changing Your Financial Behavior F5 20-40 Dreams F6 10-40 Goals F7 10-40 Lifestyle Choices F8 20-30 Become a Life-Long Learner F9 10-20
Financial Psychology
The Most Important Thing
Duration 10-30 minutes
Lesson Overview In this lesson, students will identify and recognize factors in their lives that have impact on their motivations around finances and their desire to pick up financial knowledge.
Big Idea There’s a relationship between your values, emotions and personal finances. Your financial traits and habits impact your finances. Your values and emotions will influence your financial decisions There are factors that influence your decisions.
Essential Questions At the end of the lesson, your students should be able to answer the following: What motivates you to get money? Why do these things motivate you to obtain money? How does your motivation affect your desire to earn money? Can your motivation for money affect your wants and needs in life?
Skills To determine students’ motivating factors to become financially literate.
Vocabulary Motivation — drive to action or incentive to do something. Finances—Management of money and banking
Anticipatory Set Visually display this quote to students:
“Money frees you from doing things you dislike. Since I dislike doing nearly everything, money is handy.” ~Groucho Marx
Discuss the quote with students and ask them to share what they think it means. Have them write their answers in their student handbooks. Ask students to think about some things they dislike doing to facilitate discussion.
Explain that money gives us all kinds of choices. Say: “You could choose to hire someone to do the jobs you dislike, and then you in turn could use the time you freed up to do something you enjoy.”
F1 The Most Important Thing
Ask students to describe something they would choose not to do if they had all the money they desired. Discuss.
Lesson Explanation
Visually display the word “Motivation” to students. Then ask students to think about money. Ask: “What motivates you to obtain money?” Talk about their responses. For example, • Does their parents or children motivate them because they want to provide them with a better life? • Does the fact that they are affluent motivate them to stay that way? • Or does the notion that they don’t want to live in poverty anymore motivate them to work for more in life?
Ask: Is money is the real motivator, or is it what money can bring you that really drives you to pick up financial skills?
Read the examples below. Focus discussion on lifestyle, helping loved ones, free time, positive effect on emotions, and making the world a better place to live.
Explain how becoming motivated to get money so they can live a certain type of lifestyle plays a factor in their overall financial success.
SCENARIO1: JOHNNY Johnny lives in the city with his mother and three younger siblings. His mother works two jobs and struggles to pay their monthly expenses and buy food. At age 15, Johnny gets a job delivering newspapers in his neighborhood. He only earns $150 per month delivering papers. However, with his earnings he pays the electricity bill each month and saves money for his future. His motivation in life is not to have to worry about money. He is not concerned with being rich; rather, he just wants to have enough money so he doesn’t have to stress out about going to the grocery store, getting gas in the car, or having money for lunch. • What is Johnny’s financial motivation in life? • How will his motivation influence his lifestyle? • How do you think he will feel when he is financially comfortable?
SCENARIO 2: SAM Sam lives in a mansion on the west side of town. He has always had everything he could ever want. His parents own three coffee shops and two restaurants and Sam has never worked a day in his life. When he graduates from high school he plans to attend Princeton University. After college graduation, he plans to live on the money in his trust fund. His motivation in life is to have fun and not worry about anything. He knows money will always be there.
F1 Financial Psychology
• How can Sam’s personal life motivation affect his finances later in life? Talk about how these scenarios relate to motivation, and how motivation affects one’s desire for money. Highlight the fact that people’s decisions in life can affect their finances and that they are responsible for those decisions. Talk about how students can use their motivation for money to determine their wants and needs in life.
Share the example of Bill and Melinda Gates, who are billionaires. If they chose, they could never work another day in their lives. But they found motivation in helping people. They started a foundation to fight malaria and better the world.
• What motivates Bill and Melinda Gates? • If you were in their shoes, would you be motivated?
Lesson Activity: Money Motivation Instruct Students to complete the Belief Statement in the Money Motivation Activity in the Student Guide.
State the following to the whole group: “Your motivation to acquire money plays an important factor in your overall financial success, and developing financial skills supports both your motivation and the attainment of your financial goals. Developing strong financial skills allows you to:
• Live a certain lifestyle; • Help people you care about; • Experience the freedom to do what you want, when you want to do it; • Live without the stressors and negative emotions often associated with financial struggles; and • Make a positive contribution to society.” Explain that they are now going to learn a valuable technique that salespeople use to close a sale. It’s called the “Ben Franklin close,” and they are going to use this technique to sell themselves on learning about money.
Say: “The Ben Franklin close helps people logically evaluate the pros and cons of the action you want them to take.”
On the left of the T, have them write their “Reasons For” learning about money and on the right have them write their “Reasons Against.”
• Now give students a few minutes to write their “Reasons For” learning about money. Ask a few students to volunteer to share some “Reasons For.”
F1 The Most Important Thing
• Next have students write down their “Reasons Against.” Ask a few students to share their thoughts. (You’ll probably find that most of them are unable to think of many “Reasons Against.”) • Get students’ agreement that the “Reasons For” far outweigh the “Reasons Against.” Say: “The close is an essential element of getting people to take action. You just ‘sold yourselves’ on gaining financial skills.”
Wrap up the Money Motivation Activity with the following statement: “So we all agree that developing financial skills is a very important part of achieving the life goals we set for ourselves.”
Lesson Questions 1. What is the most important factor determining your overall financial success? a. Your current net worth. b. Accumulation of material goods. c. Developing financial skills. d. Freedom from want. 2. Which of the following supports your motivation to acquire money and attain your financial goals? a. Your dreams and personal goals. b. Graduating from school. c. Living without negative emotions. d. Living without stressors. 3. What is motivation? a. The drive to do something. b. Drive to do nothing. c. Lack of energy. d. None of the above.
F1 Financial Psychology
Lesson Review Instruct participants to complete the Essential Questions in the Student Guide. Obtain a firm acknowledgement from each participant that developing sound financial skills is vitally important. Discuss the impact money has on people’s lives. Draw special attention to lifestyle, family, friends, and giving back. Then ask the class to share things they will miss out on if they don’t handle their money situations.
Closing Activity/ Discuss the answers to the Essential Questions. Remarks Reiterate the importance of knowing what motivates you in life. Understanding motivation leads to financial literacy because motivation will shape how they save and spend money.
F1
How Does Financial Psychology Develop?
How Does Financial Psychology Develop?
Duration 20-30 minutes
Lesson Overview In this lesson, students will learn how financial beliefs and behaviors are related to the general psychological principles of needs, wants, and environmental influences.
Big Idea Your ability to change your behavior impacts your financial well- being. There’s a relationship between your values, emotions and personal finances. Your financial traits and habits impact your finances. Your values and emotions will influence your financial decisions. There are factors that influence your decisions.
Essential Questions At the end of the lesson, your students should be able to answer the following: How does Maslow’s hierarchy of needs relate to an individual’s financial attitudes and behavior and motivate you to get money? How does the concept of human conditioning relate to an individual’s financial attitudes and behavior? What level of Maslow’s hierarchy of need do you identify with in terms of your financial life? How has human conditioning shaped your financial life?
Skills Assess how different emotional states can lead to different actions being taken. You can assess external information to make informed decisions that align with your goals.
Vocabulary Hierarchy of needs Physiological needs Security needs Love and belonging needs Esteem needs Self-actualizing needs Human conditioning
F2 Financial Psychology
Anticipatory Set Ask students to complete the Warm-up Activity in their Student Guides. Give the following instructions:
• Pretend you have just received $1,000 to spend any way you please, with no strings attached. • Take a few minutes to write down what you would do with the money. • After you’ve figured out how you’d spend the $1,000, take a few minutes to explain why you’d spend it that way. For example,
o If you’re going to put it all in savings, what are you saving for? o If you’re going to buy gifts, what’s the occasion?” MASLOW’S HIERARCHY OF NEEDS Self-Actualizing Needs. The highest level of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs is self-actualizing. This is when people focus on personal growth, legacy, and making a positive difference. Esteem Needs. Fourth on Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs includes the desire for personal achievement, accomplishment, status, and earning respect. Love and Belonging Needs. These social needs include the desire to be accepted and loved, and share affection. Security Needs. The next level of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs includes the desire for safety and security. Physiological Needs. Maslow believed that needs such as food, water, air, and sleep are the most basic, fundamental, and instinctive. All other needs described in this hierarchy become secondary until core physiological needs are met.
Developed by Abraham Maslow in his 1943 paper A Theory of Human Motivation. Please note: This coursework is not validating Maslow’s theory. However, it gives us a good framework to understand the impact of finances on our lives.
Lesson Explanation Ask students to review the graphic of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs in the Student Guide. To facilitate in-class instruction, ask student volunteers to give examples from their own lives demonstrating each type of need.
Tell students: “Psychologist Abraham Maslow developed his Hierarchy of Needs theory in 1943. As we can see from the pyramid graphic, according to Maslow, the higher people climb up the needs hierarchy, the better their lives will be.
F2
How Does Financial Psychology Develop?
Now, where does a person fall on the pyramid when he or she is suffering from heavy financial stress? If you’re about to lose your home, you’re probably not thinking about self-actualization. Financial issues place you in the lower levels of need. You must address the issues before you can address the higher levels of need.
Tell students to take a minute to look over their answers from the earlier activity. • When you had $1,000 to spend, how did you spend it? • What need did that money fulfill? • If you were relieved to have money for electricity, gas, and rent your financial life probably centers on your physiological needs right now. • If you decided to save that $1,000 for retirement, you were fulfilling a security need. For in-class instruction, ask student volunteers to share examples (if they feel comfortable doing so.)
Say, “Now that we’ve seen how finances can fulfill different psychological needs, let’s think about how we’ve learned to use money to fill those needs in our lives. We’re going to step away from Maslow for a minute and talk about human conditioning.”
Humans are conditioned to move away from pain and toward pleasure. That makes sense, right? Let’s think about that on a financial basis. • If you take pleasure in your daily latte or your monthly manicure, it’s easy to justify spending your money on those things. • If your favorite place to be is the beach, it’s probably easier for you to save money to spend on gas and a rental board and boardwalk fries for your next trip to the beach. These all are financial decisions that move us toward pleasure—we’re using money to get what we want.
We also make financial decisions that avoid pain. The positive aspects of pain avoidance are things like using money to buy insurance to avoid the future pain of paying medical bills out-of- pocket; or putting money in savings to avoid the fear that comes when you get your paycheck and it’s less than you need to cover monthly expenses. The negative aspects come in when we avoid spending money wisely because it’s not as much fun as spending money on fun. That’s how we get into situations where we spend $4 a day on coffee but don’t have anything saved for retirement.
Often the difference between making smart financial decisions and foolish financial decisions comes down to whether we’re conditioned to think about money in terms of long-term pain and pleasure, or short-term pain and pleasure.
F2 Financial Psychology
• Someone who knows from life experience that it’s painful not to have enough money for rent or food or medicine will probably take steps to avoid that pain by saving, planning, and thinking about long-term stability. • Someone who has always been fairly comfortable in terms of meeting their physiological and security needs but uses money to reward themselves or loved ones—that is, someone who’s always used money to meet love and belonging needs—will find it pretty painful to cut back on spending money to buy gifts. Tell students, “Think back to the way you spent your imaginary $1,000 at the beginning of the lesson. What were your motivations? Avoiding pain, seeking pleasure, or both?”
Lesson Activity: Applying Maslow’s Needs Hierarchy
Instruct Students to go to the Applying Maslow’s Needs Hierarchy Activity in the Student Guide and reach each scenario. Then ask the class: • What level of need in Maslow’s hierarchy is each person trying to meet? • What do you think is motivating the person—seeking pleasure or avoiding pain?" Facilitate discussion about motivation and how it relates to a person’s needs.
• Clarissa’s hours were just cut at work. She has enough savings to make her rent payment this month, but the loss of salary will mean that she will have to choose whether to pay her electric bill or her phone bill. Clarissa cancels plans with friends to go to a concert and takes a weekend job babysitting to earn extra money. What level of Maslow's hierarchy of needs is she seeking to fulfill? Would you say Clarissa is seeking pleasure or avoiding pain?
• Every year, Bill’s neighborhood goes all-out on holiday celebrations. Every neighbor participates in a house-decorating contest, a cookie exchange, a White Elephant gift exchange, and the block party. Only one neighbor has ever opted out, and everyone gossiped about her at the block party that year. Bill doesn’t particularly enjoy the holidays, but he still plans to spend over $500 on neighborhood events this holiday season. What level of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs is he seeking to fulfill? Would you say Bill is seeking pleasure or avoiding pain?
• Melody is planning to start an after-school program teaching dance to underprivileged children. She hopes the program will help inspire children to work hard and find a passion for creative expression, just like she did when she started taking dancing lessons at age four. Now that Melody has a successful dance studio and a booming business, she
F2
How Does Financial Psychology Develop?
wants to pass the same opportunities along to others. What level of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs is she seeking to fulfill? Would you say Melody is seeking pleasure or avoiding pain?
• When Damien was growing up, his parents lived paycheck-to-paycheck. He remembers not having enough money for new clothes or shoes, and even a few times when they didn’t have enough to eat. Now that Damien is an adult, he has a good salary and a stable job. However, Damien always worries about what would happen if he lost his job. He still buys everything used and puts as much as he can into savings, just in case. What level of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs is he seeking to fulfill? Would you say Damien is seeking pleasure or avoiding pain?
Lesson Questions 1. Which statement best describes Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs theory? a. The rise to the top is slow. b. The rise to the top is rapid. c. The slower the rise, the happier the person’s life will be. d. The higher people climb, the better their lives will be. 2. Which of the following statements is NOT true about human conditioning? a. Humans move toward pleasure. b. Humans move away from pain. c. Humans make financial decisions based on logic rather than emotions. d. Humans usually make smart financial decisions by considering short-term pain and pleasure. 3. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs suggests that basic needs, like food, water, and shelter, must be satisfied before higher level needs, such as esteem and self-actualization. a. True b. False
F2 Financial Psychology
4. Humans are conditioned to _____ pleasure and _____ pain. a. enjoy; dislike b. accept; reject c. seek; avoid d. take; give
Lesson Review Instruct participants to complete the Essential Questions in the Student Guide.
Closing Activity/ Discuss the answers to the Essential Questions. Remarks
F2 Where Did You Learn About Money?
Where Did You Learn about Money?
Duration 20-40 minutes
Lesson Overview In this lesson, students will learn Lev Vygotsky’s theory of social impact demonstrating how family, society, and culture play a role in the development of an individual’s financial psychology. Students will identify factors that have influenced and reinforced their own mindsets about money.
Big Idea External factors can impact your financial decisions. Not all financial information is accurate or truthful. There are marketing messages that are influencing your spending. There are factors that influence your decisions.
Essential Questions At the end of the lesson, your students should be able to answer the following: How does culture influence an individual’s attitudes toward money? What is a More Knowledgeable Other in the context of financial psychology? Who would you consider to be a More Knowledgeable Other in your personal financial life? What have your More Knowledgeable Others taught you about finances, directly or indirectly?
Skills External factors can impact your financial decisions. There are organizations and individuals that are influencing your spending.
Vocabulary More Knowledgeable Other (MKO) Social exchange
Anticipatory Set
Ask students the following questions: • Who were your role models for saving and spending? • Who do you look to for advice about financial planning? • If you’re on the fence between buying something or not, what sways you?
F3 Financial Psychology
Instruct the students to complete the Warm-Up Activity in the Student Guide, listing the five top influences in their financial life.
Lesson Explanation Lev Vygotsky theorized that social interactions inform an individual’s cognitive development. 1 Rather than gaining greater understanding or more sophisticated thought processes simply by aging or figuring things out on our own, Vygotsky believed that we learn by first interacting with others and then internalizing those skills to use ourselves. Vygotsky also believed that learning was strongly influenced by a More Knowledgeable Other, or MKO. An MKO could be a parent, teacher, friend, or peer — anyone with a more sophisticated knowledge and understanding of the information from whom the individual could learn.
How does this theory relate to financial psychology?
Well, using money is a social exchange. For an individual living completely outside of society, money is nothing more than pieces of paper and metal discs. It’s worthless when you have no one with whom to use it. But if we add in another person, suddenly we can use money to buy and sell—to get things we need and want. Since money only has meaning in the context of a society, it makes sense to look at what our society teaches us about money and how we use it.
• So who teaches us about money? • Who do we consider to be our MKO of finances? Very few people receive financial education in school. Most young people rely on their parents to teach them money skills, but unfortunately few parents actually discuss money with their children. Instead, we pick up information about how we should use money by observing others; and some of the attitudes and practices we observe aren’t the best. At other times we seek out MKOs in the wrong places—like salespeople or friends.
• A salesman’s commission is based on getting you to choose his product. Do you really trust his motives? • And the guy in the next cubicle at work probably is not a financial professional. Why would you ask him for investment advice? The key to your own financial psychology is to use your money in a way consistent with your values, beliefs, and lifestyle. If your entire family gathers for a large holiday celebration every year and you wouldn’t miss it for the world, it makes sense to include the travel costs to attend that celebration in your budget. When you choose an MKO, make sure that person supports the
1 http://www.learning-therories.com/vygotskys-social-learning-theory.html
F3 Where Did You Learn About Money?
same lifestyle and values you have. It doesn’t make sense to choose a popular book on financial management as your MKO if the book espouses complete financial independence and autonomy and you place highest value on a cultural tradition of providing for relatives who are elderly, sick or falling on hard times.
• We also learn about money from more subtle societal messages. Ask, “Who’s heard the phrase, keeping up with the Joneses?” More than likely, nobody ever pulled you aside and said, “Hey, if you’re buying a car, you’re going to want to make sure it’s just as nice as your neighbor’s—maybe even nicer!” But you probably picked that message up through observation. • Then there’s advertising. Keep in mind that advertisers use techniques that work to sell their products. How often have you seen an ad that says, “If it’s a priority for your family’s budget, a trip to our amusement park is one of several equally-attractive options. However, the park will still be here next year if you can’t afford it now.’ Not too often, right? Advertisements play on social values that encourage us to buy. They encourage us to get things endorsed by celebrities, things that will make other people envious of us, and things that are fun and exciting to have.
Lesson Activity: Evaluating MKOs
Tell the student to look back at their list of top five financial influencers, and ask the following: • Are you happy to have these MKOs? • What have they taught you? • Are they living the lifestyle you want your finances to earn for you? For in-class instruction, ask students to share answers to these questions (if they are comfortable doing so.)
F3 Financial Psychology
Lesson Questions 1. Which of the following might be a More Knowledgeable Other (MKO)? a. A parent with financial expertise. b. A peer with financial expertise. c. Neither A nor B. d. Both A and B. 2. How do most people learn about money? a. Through trial and error b. In college. c. From their siblings. d. In grade school. 3. When choosing a More Knowledgeable Other to guide your financial life, you should choose someone who: a. Is a member of your peer group. b. Is a qualified salesperson. c. Has the same lifestyle and values. d. Has a background in financial psychology.
Lesson Review Tell students that we don’t learn about finances in a vacuum. Money is a social tool, and our attitudes, beliefs, and practices are heavily influenced by society. We all look to More Knowledgeable Others to inform our financial lives. The question is: are the MKOs we’ve chosen living with financial values that are consistent with the lifestyles we want for ourselves? Instruct participants to complete the Essential Questions in the Student Guide.
Closing Activity/ Discuss the answers to the Essential Questions. Remarks
F3 Money & Emotions
Money & Emotions
Duration 20-30 minutes
Lesson Overview In this lesson, students will learn how emotions and money are interconnected and will develop an understanding of how one can affect the other.
Big Idea There’s a relationship between your values, emotions and personal finances. Your values and emotions will influence your financial decisions. There are factors that influence your decisions. Financial decisions impact your future. Goals impact your finances.
Essential Questions At the end of the lesson, your students should be able to answer the following: How does my financial situation affect my emotions? How do my emotions affect my financial situation? Why is it important to know how money and emotions affect each other?
Skills Students will identify the correlation between money and emotions, and will learn to recognize differences and similarities.
Vocabulary Wheel of Emotions
Anticipatory Set
Read the following excerpt aloud: • You are at the mall with your friends. You only have $10 cash. You want to go to lunch with your friends but the cheapest item on the restaurant menu costs $15.
Instruct students to write the answer in the Warm-Up Activity in the Student Guide. • Make sure students only focus on how this scenario makes them feel. • They do not need to try to solve the dilemma. • Help them concentrate on feelings. Once they have completed the question, talk about their answers as a class. Focus on the feelings.
F4 Financial Psychology
Lesson Explanation Say: “Let’s talk about all the emotions involved with money and making financial decisions. Robert Plutchik’s Wheel of Emotions theory says there are basically eight emotions:
1. Trust → this also includes admiration and acceptance. 2. Fear → the feeling of being afraid, shocked, or scared. 3. Surprise → how you feel when something unexpected happens. 4. Sadness → feeling sad. Other words that describe sadness are sorrow, grief, and depression. 5. Disgust → feeling something is wrong or dirty. 6. Anger → feeling angry or enraged. 7. Anticipation → the sense of looking forward positively to something which is going to happen. 8. Joy → feeling happy, glad. Which of these eight emotions would you say are involved in financial decisions?
Explain how feelings relate to finances: • Describe how money can evoke any of these feelings depending on the financial situation. • For example: “If a person has a lot of money they may feel happiness and joy, where as a person who does not may feel stress and anxiety about not being able to pay their bills. There are, however, many unhappy wealthy people who are solely focused on money and miss out on time with friends, family, and life experiences because they were so focused on achieving their financial goals.” Talk about why it’s important to identify feelings and why they need to be aware of their emotions toward money as they develop their own personal financial literacy.
Discuss the fact that one of the main reasons why relationships and marriages fail is because of finances and failure to communicate about money.
F4 Money & Emotions
• Ask how they would feel if someone they were close to spent money on luxury items instead of bills, or vice versa. • This helps illustrate the concept of the correlation between relationships and finances.
Relate how emotions and money can greatly affect one’s personal health. • Ask students if they think it is healthy to constantly live under stress. • Tell them how a person experiencing stress or anxiety tends to have an elevated heart rate, which is unhealthy.
o When people are in stressful situations or carry anxiety they often neglect other areas of their life that help maintain good health—like exercise, good nutrition, and sleep. Now that students have identified how emotions and money are connected, they need to understand how to avoid negative emotions toward money.
• Ask students how they can avoid having negative feelings towards money. • Facilitate discussion, bringing in the following points when appropriate:
o Set up a savings and spending plan to avoid undue stress and anxiety. This will help you avoid not having money or relying on credit in financial emergencies. o Only spend what you have and develop a lifestyle that supports spending within your means. o Adjust your lifestyle to your means.
Lesson Activity: How Do You Feel About That?
Direct student to the How Do You Feel about That Activity in the Student Guide. • Divide students into four groups:
o Group A has all the money they want. o Group B has enough money to feel comfortable in an average middle-class lifestyle. o Group C is just barely getting by. o Group D is broke. • Have each group address the three scenarios described below using a skit/role-play activity. Give minimal direction to allow for student creativity. Make sure they answer the question about how they would feel in each of the three situations. SCENARIOS 1. Your girlfriend or boyfriend wants to go out for a nice dinner to celebrate your anniversary. 2. All your friends are taking a trip to Costa Rica for a week.
F4 Financial Psychology
3. A close relative is graduating from college and you want to buy her a great gift to honor her accomplishment. • Give students 10 minutes to plan their skits. • Have students perform their skits for the class.
Lesson Questions 1. Which of the following emotions could influence a person to make an incorrect financial decision? a. Fear b. Joy c. Sadness d. All of the above. 2. How can you avoid having negative feelings about money? a. Delay setting up a savings plan to avoid stress. b. Delay setting up a spending plan to avoid arguments. c. Think about your dreams and hope everything works out. d. Only spend the money you have. 3. Cultural values have little effect on the formation of an individual’s lifestyle and financial choices. a. True b. False 4. My personal emotions can be affected by my financial situation. a. True b. False
Lesson Review Instruct participants to complete the Essential Questions in the Student Guide.
Closing Activity/ Discuss the answers to the Essential Questions. Remarks Reiterate the importance of understanding how money and emotions relate to each other.
F4 Changing Your Behavior
Changing Your Financial Behavior
Duration 20-40 minutes
Lesson Overview In this lesson, students will learn how the Stages of Change model can be applied to modify their financial decision-making.
Big Idea Your ability to change your behavior impacts your financial well- being. There’s a relationship between your values, emotions and personal finances. Your financial traits and habits impact your finances. Your values and emotions will influence your financial decisions. External factors can impact your financial decisions. There are factors that influence your decisions. Financial decisions impact your future.
Essential Questions At the end of the lesson, your students should be able to answer the following: What are the Stages of Change according to the Transtheoretical Model of Behavior Change? What stage of change best describes your current approach to pursuing financial education and changing your financial habits? How do you plan to move toward the next stage of change in your financial life?
Skills Students will apply the Stages of Change model in their own financial decision-making process.
Vocabulary Pre-contemplation Contemplation Preparation Action Maintenance Termination
F5 Financial Psychology
Anticipatory Set Ask students to check the box next to the stage of change they feel best describes their current approach to pursuing financial education and change.