Arxiv:1605.03945V2 [Physics.Optics] 18 Jan 2017 Maximum Absorption Cross Section Cabs (At Resonance) Ground Are Given in a Supplemental Material (SM)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Fundamental Limits of Optical Force and Torque 1 1,2 1,3 1,3 A. Rahimzadegan∗ , R. Alaee∗ , I. Fernandez-Corbaton , and C. Rockstuhl 1Institute of Theoretical Solid State Physics, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Karlsruhe, Germany 2Max Planck Institute for the Science of Light, Erlangen, Germany 3Institute of Nanotechnology, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Karlsruhe, Germany ∗Equally contributed to the work. Corresponding authors: [email protected], [email protected] Optical force and torque provide unprecedented control on the spatial motion of small particles. A valid scientific question, that has many practical implications, concerns the existence of fundamental upper bounds for the achievable force and torque exerted by a plane wave illumination with a given intensity. Here, while studying isotropic particles, we show that different light-matter interaction channels contribute to the exerted force and torque; and analytically derive upper bounds for each of the contributions. Specific examples for particles that achieve those upper bounds are provided. We study how and to which extent different contributions can add up to result in the maximum optical force and torque. Our insights are important for applications ranging from molecular sorting, particle manipulation, nanorobotics up to ambitious projects such as laser-propelled spaceships. PACS numbers: 42.25.-p, 42.70.-a, 78.20.Bh, 78.67.Bf,42.50.Wk,42.50.Tx Optical scattering, extinction, and absorption cross cations and implications of the optical force and torque sections characterize the strength of light-matter- in many areas. Examples are the opto-mechanical ma- interaction. They quantify the fraction of power a par- nipulation14–17, molecular or particle optical sorting18, ticle scatters, extincts, or absorbs1,2. To describe the or nanorobotics19,20. Optical force and torque are interaction of light with a particle, the incident and scat- also important in studying the angular momentum of tered fields can be expanded into vector spherical wave light21–24. Moreover, developing ambitious projects like functions (VSWFs). VSWFs are the eigenfunctions of laser-propelled spaceships, would benefit from an under- the vectorial wave equation in spherical coordinates. For standing of these limits 25. an isotropic, i.e. a rotationally symmetric particle, the In this Letter, based on the multipole expansion in amplitudes of the VSWFs expanding the incident and scattering theory2, we identify and analyze different scattered fields are linked by the Mie coefficients 1,3. terms that contribute to the exerted optical force and Each coefficient describes a channel for the light-matter- torque on isotropic particles; and derive upper bounds interaction and is uniquely specified by the total angular for each contribution. Next, considering these contribu- momentum (AM) number j, and the parity of the fields tions, the maximum of the total optical force and torque involved in the scattering process in the respective Mie is calculated. Contrary to the optical cross sections, the channel (MC). Depending on j and the parity, these MCs force and torque, in a general direction, contain terms are referred to as either electric (aj) or magnetic (bj). that are the result of interference among different MCs. If an isotropic particle is illuminated by a plane wave We start by analyzing particles that are characterized in a frequency interval where only a single MC is sig- by a single dipole MC. Afterwards, we consider homo- nificant, the maximum scattering cross section Csca (at geneous dielectric spheres supporting multiple MCs and 2 4,5 resonance) is (2j + 1) λ /2π . The maximum Csca is distinguish different terms contributing to the force and attained when the particle operates in the over-coupling torque. Finally, considering more general isotropic parti- (γr γnr) regime, i.e. the radiative (scattering) loss cles, the maximum optical force and torque as a function (γr) is much larger than the non-radiative (Ohmic) loss of the maximum non-negligible multipolar order is cal- (γnr). For a particle with a single electric dipole MC culated. Examples for particles that maximize each of (i.e., electric dipolar particle), the maximum scattering the contributions as well as the force/torque are given. and consequently extinction cross section Cext (at reso- The detailed derivations of the relations, supplementary nance) corresponds to 3λ2/2π [Fig. 1 (a)]. Similarly, the figures, and more information on the theoretical back- arXiv:1605.03945v2 [physics.optics] 18 Jan 2017 maximum absorption cross section Cabs (at resonance) ground are given in a supplemental material (SM). Here, is (2j + 1) λ2/8π6. It occurs if the particle operates in we concentrate on the presentation of the results and the the critical coupling (γnr = γr) regime, i.e. the non- discussion of the physical implications. The force and radiative (γnr) and radiative (γr) loss are equal. For torque values are all time averaged. an electric dipolar particle, the maximum absorption is Fundamental limits on optical force (electric dipole): 2 3λ /8π [Fig. 1 (a) when γnr = γr]. An arbitrarily polarized, time harmonic plane wave, Although optical cross sections are important in study- propagating in the +z direction illuminates an isotropic ing light-matter interaction at the nanoscale7–9, the op- electric dipolar particle. The exerted force is10,26: tical force and torque are further key quantities10–13, for which upper bounds have not yet been well stud- 1 kI0 F = ( E∗ p) = [α (ω)] e = F e , (1) ied. This is surprising considering the important appli- p 2< ∇ · c = z p z 3 2.25 1.5 2 0.75 3 Based on the definition of the absorption cross sec- 0 2.25 tion of an electric dipolar particle, Cabs,p = kIm (α) k4 α 2/6π27, N can be rewritten as σ (I /ω) C −. | | p 0 abs,p 1.5 Therefore, the torque is maximized at the maximum of 2 (a) (b) the absorption cross section (= 3λ /8π) and is equal to: 0.75 2 norm norm I0 λ 0 (N ) = 3σN ,N = . (5) p max ω 8π FIG. 1: (a) Maximal scattering, extinction, and absorption (Np)max is the fundamental limit on the torque exerted cross sections of; and (b) optical force and torque exerted on on an isotropic electric dipolar particle by a circularly po- an isotropic dipolar particle as a function of the loss factor, i.e. larized plane wave. The same bound is attained for an norm γnr/γr. The particle is illuminated by an arbitrarily polarized isotropic magnetic dipolar particle. N will be later plane wave (for the cross sections and the force) or a circularly used for normalization. Note that for an isotropic parti- polarized plane wave (only for the torque) at the resonance cle, it can be easily deduced from Eq. 4 that a linearly of a spectrally isolated dipole MC. polarized plane wave exerts no torque N = 0. Figure 1 (b) shows the maximal force and torque at resonance exerted by a plane wave as a function of the where p = 0αE is the induced Cartesian electric dipole loss factor, i.e. γnr/γr. In the over-coupling regime, Cext, moment, α is the electric polarizability of the particle, 2 and consequently the force is maximized. On the other I0 = 0c E0 /2 is intensity of the illumination, k is the | | hand, in the critical coupling regime, the Cabs and con- wavenumber, 0 is the free space permittivity, and c is the sequently the torque is maximized. speed of light. Alternatively, based on the definition of Multipole expansion: To extend our analysis to include the extinction cross section of an electric dipolar particle, 27 multiple MCs, we go beyond the single channel dipole Cext,p = kIm (α) , Fp can be rewritten as (I0/c) Cext,p. approximation. In the multipolar expansion, the incident The dispersion of α near a resonance can be expressed and scattered fields are expanded as1,3,29: by a Lorentzian line-shape as28: j α0 ∞ (1) (1) α (ω) = 2 2 , (2) Einc = Ejm pjmNjm + iqjmMjm , ωres ω iω (γnr + γr) − − − j=1 m= j X X− j where ωres is the resonance frequency, α0 is the resonance ∞ 2 (3) (3) strength, and γr = α0k /6πc is the radiative loss of the Esca = Ejm ajmNjm + ibjmMjm , (6) particle, respectively. The maximum force in Eq. 1 oc- j=1 m= j X X− curs when the particle is non-absorptive and at resonance (i.e. Im [α (ω)] = 6π/k3), where the extinction cross (1) (1) max where Mjm (r; ω) , Njm (r; ω) are the regular and section{ is maximized} (=3λ2/2π), and reads as: (3) h (3) i Mjm (r; ω) , Njm (r; ω) the outgoing vector spherical I λ2 (F ) = 3F norm,F norm = 0 . (3) hwave functions (VSWFs).i (pjm, qjm) and (ajm, bjm) are p max c 2π the amplitudes of the VSWFs expanding the incident and scattered fields. j(j + 1) is the eigenvalue of the AM 2 (Fp)max is the fundamental limit for the force an arbi- squared J , and m is the eigenvalue of the z-component trarily polarized plane wave can exert on an isotropic of the AM Jz. Ejm is a normalizing factor (SM ). electric dipolar particle. Due to the symmetry of The incident fields are assumed to be known. Their Maxwell’s equations, the same bound can be attained norm VSWF amplitudes can be calculated using orthogonal- for an isotropic magnetic dipolar particle. F is used ity relations. The VSWF amplitudes of a plane wave as the normalization factor further on. It is important to are given in the SM. Finding the scattered field ampli- note that (Fp)max depends on the resonance wavelength tudes is not a trivial task. However, Mie theory provides ( λ2) of the MC.