DOCSLIB.ORG

Anderson, Major General Anthony and Jamaica Defence Board V

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Anderson, Major General Anthony and Jamaica Defence Board V [2018] JMFC Full 4 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA IN THE FULL COURT CLAIM NO. 2016 HCV 00066 THE HONOURABLE MS JUSTICE CAROL LAWRENCE-BESWICK THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE COURTNEY DAYE THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SHARON GEORGE IN THE MATTER OF A WARRANT ISSUED PURSUANT TO S.4(3) AND NOTICES ISSUED PURSUANT TO S.21 BOTH OF THE INDEPENDENT COMMISSION OF INVESTIGATIONS ACT AND IN THE MATTER OF THE INDEPENDENT COMMISSION OF INVESTIGATIONS ACT 2010 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE EMERGENCY POWERS ACT AND THE EMERGENCY POWERS (NO.2) REGULATIONS 2010 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE OFFICIAL SECRETS ACT 1911 & 1920 BETWEEN MAJOR GENERAL ANTONY ANDERSON 1STCLAIMANT CHIEF OF DEFENCE STAFF - 2 - AND JAMAICA DEFENCE BOARD 2ND CLAIMANT AND INDEPENDENT COMMISSION OF DEFENDANT INVESTIGATIONS IN OPEN COURT Walter Scott Q.C. and Matthieu H.J. Beckford of Rattray Patterson Rattray for the 1st claimant Nicole Foster-Pusey Q.C., Monique Harrison and Faith Hall of the Office of the Director of State Proceedings for the 2nd claimant Tana’ania Small Davis, Yanique Taylor and Mikhail Jackson instructed by Livingston, Alexander and Levy for the defendant Heard: 11th – 14th April, 2016, 17th May, 25th & 28th June and 30th July 2018 Judicial review - Retrospectivity of the INDECOM Act - Legislative Interpretation - INDECOM Act - Official Secrets Act- Public Interest Immunity - INDECOM’s jurisdiction - Disclosure - Warrants and Notices issued under the INDECOM Act LAWRENCE-BESWICK, J [1] This is an application by Major General Anthony Anderson as Chief of Defence Staff (“the CDS”) (as he then was), the 1st claimant, and the Jamaica Defence Board (“the Board”), the 2nd claimant, for judicial review of a decision of the Independent Commission of Investigations (INDECOM), the respondent. [2] The CDS is the officer in command of the Jamaica Defence Force (“the JDF”), and is appointed by the Governor General1. The Board has responsibility for matters including the command, discipline and administration of the armed forces.2 1 Section 170 Defence Act. 2Section 9 Defence Act - 3 - [3] INDECOM has taken the decision to issue a warrant3 to the CDS to enter Up Park Camp to have access to and enter offices, buildings and facilities of the JDF and to make enquires, and inspect documents, records, information and property pertaining to certain listed matters. Up Park Camp is described as the headquarters of the JDF4. [4] The warrant was accompanied by seven notices5 to members of the JDF and or its agents who participated in the execution of an order to fire mortar rounds into Tivoli Gardens and its environs during the State of Emergency in May 2010. These notices sought to compel the members to give evidence on oath concerning the operation. BACKGROUND Operations [5] In May 2010, the JDF and the Jamaica Constabulary Force (JCF) conducted joint operations in West Kingston in an effort to execute a warrant on a fugitive pursuant to an extradition request from the United States of America. During the operations, more than seventy persons lost their lives. There is the possibility that at least one of them died as a result of mortars fired by the JDF. [6] INDECOM as a commission of Parliament6 sought to investigate the use of mortars by the JDF on 24 May 2010 to determine whether there are any reasonable grounds to suspect that during the operations any member of the 3Pursuant to section 4(3) of the Independent Commission of Investigations Act 41st Affidavit of Antony Anderson in support of Notice of Application for Court Orders filed 8 January 2016 5Issued pursuant to section 21 of the Act 6Established pursuant to section 3 of the Independent Commission of Investigations Act. - 4 - JDF contravened the law and whether recommendations ought to be made by INDECOM concerning the operations. Correspondence [7] INDECOM wrote on 15 September 2011 advising the JDF that it had commenced an investigation into the fatalities that occurred in Western Kingston during the State of Emergency which existed in May 2010. INDECOM requested the CDS to furnish a report by 31 October 2011 with information on: a. The activities of members of the force b. The command structure that existed within the sphere of the operation c. An account of persons whose lives were lost including their names, when, where, and how they were killed. d. A copy of any debriefing notes, statements, diary entries, records and other documents collected, received or held by JDF force concerning these matters. e. A list of all personnel who took the life of a citizen together with the date, time, and place that the life was taken; the name of the deceased and the circumstances under which the deceased died. Almost four months passed without a response to that letter. [8] On January 10, 2012 INDECOM again wrote to the CDS requesting that the JDF respond to the September 15, 2011 letter and also to its earlier letter of September 13, 2011 which had been addressed to a Lieutenant Colonel of the JDF. [9] It was a month later before the CDS responded to INDECOM on February 9, 2012 submitting a report pertaining to the JDF’s activities being investigated by INDECOM. This report did not include details on the use of mortars. INDECOM - 5 - replied, asking for the additional specific information requested which the JDF should by then have had. [10] June 6, 2012 saw the Bureau of Special Investigations (BSI), a branch of the JCF, handing over to INDECOM, material from its own investigation of the operations. This “handing over” was in the form of a letter which included a list of police involved, statements of civilians, information on a missing person subsequently identified and post mortem examination reports. This investigation did not disclose or concern the use of mortars. On June 13, 2012 INDECOM again wrote to the CDS referring to the earlier letters which it had sent and also to the insufficient response which JDF had made. Local and foreign news media [11] Meanwhile local and foreign news media carried reports referring to the JDF having launched mortars in the West Kingston operations to break through barricades which supporters of the fugitive had erected to block entry to an area where it was suspected he may have been. [12] JDF in a press release informed that under normal circumstances it does not discuss details surrounding operational tactics or procedures, but because of the potential for speculation and misunderstanding it confirmed that mortars and bulldozers had been used as part of the May 2010 operation and sought to clarify the circumstances surrounding their use. Public Defender [13] The Office of the Public Defender had carried out its own investigations. It had received civilian allegations of bombs being used during the operation and - 6 - almost a year after its initial enquiries forwarded their files to INDECOM in August 2012. Further requests [14] INDECOM continuing to make requests of JDF, wrote on March 11, 2013 asking to interview senior officers who may have intimate knowledge of the operation. A particular officer was specified. In the ensuing months, INDECOM and the JDF had discussions concerning the ballistics analysis of the operation. Search Warrant [15] By December 3, 2015 a Ballistic Examination Report was available. Speculation was rife. A few weeks later, on December 22, 2015 INDECOM, utilising the Independent Commission of Investigations Act (“the Act”), wrote the JDF attaching a warrant7 and seven notices pertaining to the Joint JDF/JCF Operation in West Kingston, May 2010”. The warrant was to be executed at the JDF’s premises on Thursday, 12 January 2016 at 9:30 a.m. The notices required named members of the JDF to attend upon the Commissioner of INDECOM for questioning on oath. [16] December 30, 2015 saw JDF informing INDECOM by letter that a copy of their December 22, 2015 letter had been forwarded to the Defence Board. The new year brought an objection to a search of JDF by INDECOM. Objection to search warrant [17] The Attorney General’s chambers by letter of January 8, 2016, objected to the search of the JDF, referring to the Official Secrets Act and the perceived impropriety of the execution of a search warrant on the premises in all the 7 Section 4(3) - 7 - circumstances. The Solicitor General’s opinion was that the court should be asked to consider the situation because weighty and complex issues were being raised. [18] Within days, on January 12, 2016, attorneys-at-law for INDECOM indicated that the warrant was not in fact a search warrant. INDECOM had no intention of conducting a search of the headquarters, but rather, expected to be given access to the records and other items for inspection and copying as considered necessary and pertinent. The Official Secrets Act would not prevent such disclosure. Application for Judicial Review [19] Thereafter, the claimants filed Notices of Application for Court Orders8 for leave to apply for judicial review of the decision of INDECOM to issue the warrant and notices and seeking specified reliefs. On 20 January 2016, JDF was granted leave to seek judicial review. INDECOM, through its counsel, gave an undertaking not to execute the warrant or to give effect to the notices until the determination of the Fixed Date Claim Form filed in the matter. Certificate of immunity [20] Meanwhile, the Minister of National Security had issued a certificate of immunity dated 7 January 2016 certifying that no action, suit, prosecution or other proceedings shall be brought or instituted against any Officers or Ranks of the JDF in respect of the orders to fire and the firing of mortar rounds during the emergency period as defined and interpreted in regulation 45(5) of the Emergency Powers (No.2) Regulations 2010.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Jamaica-Wikipedia-Re
    4/15/2017 Jamaica ­ Wikipedia Coordinates: 18°N 77°W Jamaica From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia i Jamaica ( /dʒәˈmeɪkә/) is an island country situated in the Jamaica Caribbean Sea, consisting of the third­largest island of the Greater Antilles. The island, 10,990 square kilometres (4,240 sq mi) in area, lies about 145 kilometres (90 mi) south of Cuba, and 191 kilometres (119 mi) west of Hispaniola (the island containing the nation­states of Haiti and the Dominican Republic). Jamaica is the fourth­largest island country in the Caribbean, by area.[6] Flag Coat of arms Motto: "Out of Many, One People" Inhabited by the indigenous Arawak and Taíno peoples, the island came under Spanish rule following the arrival of Anthem: Christopher Columbus in 1494. Many of the indigenous people "Jamaica, Land We Love" died of disease, and the Spanish imported African slaves as 0:00 MENU labourers. Named Santiago, the island remained a possession of Royal anthem: "God Save the Queen" Spain until 1655, when England (later Great Britain) conquered it and renamed it Jamaica. Under British colonial rule Jamaica became a leading sugar exporter, with its plantation economy highly dependent on slaves imported from Africa. The British fully emancipated all slaves in 1838, and many freedmen chose to have subsistence farms rather than to work on plantations. Beginning in the 1840s, the British imported Chinese and Indian indentured labour to work on plantations. The island achieved independence from the United Kingdom on 6 August 1962.[7] With 2.8 million people, Jamaica is the third­most populous Anglophone country in the Americas (after the United States and Canada), and the fourth­most populous country in the Caribbean.
    [Show full text]
  • Ministry of Defence Acronyms and Abbreviations
    Acronym Long Title 1ACC No. 1 Air Control Centre 1SL First Sea Lord 200D Second OOD 200W Second 00W 2C Second Customer 2C (CL) Second Customer (Core Leadership) 2C (PM) Second Customer (Pivotal Management) 2CMG Customer 2 Management Group 2IC Second in Command 2Lt Second Lieutenant 2nd PUS Second Permanent Under Secretary of State 2SL Second Sea Lord 2SL/CNH Second Sea Lord Commander in Chief Naval Home Command 3GL Third Generation Language 3IC Third in Command 3PL Third Party Logistics 3PN Third Party Nationals 4C Co‐operation Co‐ordination Communication Control 4GL Fourth Generation Language A&A Alteration & Addition A&A Approval and Authorisation A&AEW Avionics And Air Electronic Warfare A&E Assurance and Evaluations A&ER Ammunition and Explosives Regulations A&F Assessment and Feedback A&RP Activity & Resource Planning A&SD Arms and Service Director A/AS Advanced/Advanced Supplementary A/D conv Analogue/ Digital Conversion A/G Air‐to‐Ground A/G/A Air Ground Air A/R As Required A/S Anti‐Submarine A/S or AS Anti Submarine A/WST Avionic/Weapons, Systems Trainer A3*G Acquisition 3‐Star Group A3I Accelerated Architecture Acquisition Initiative A3P Advanced Avionics Architectures and Packaging AA Acceptance Authority AA Active Adjunct AA Administering Authority AA Administrative Assistant AA Air Adviser AA Air Attache AA Air‐to‐Air AA Alternative Assumption AA Anti‐Aircraft AA Application Administrator AA Area Administrator AA Australian Army AAA Anti‐Aircraft Artillery AAA Automatic Anti‐Aircraft AAAD Airborne Anti‐Armour Defence Acronym
    [Show full text]
  • Contemporary Security and Defense Issues in the Caribbean 2016 1 Front Cover: a U.S
    Un-Governed and Un-Governable Spaces: Corruption and its Impact on Good Governance in the Threats to Democracy and National Security in Caribbean Jamaica Henderson P. Patrick George Benson The United Nations Law of the Sea Conventions Preventing Violent Extremism in the Caribbean (UNCLOS) and its Impact on the Traditional Maritime Francesca Caonero and Pernille Rasmussen Powers Operations in the Caribbean Wilbert Kirton Citizen Insecurity in Trinidad and Tobago and the Applicability of the Concept of the Mafia State Global Warming and Climate Change in the Caribbean Dianne Williams Pat Paterson Warring on Domestic Soil: Military versus Police Venezuela’s “9-Dash-Line” in the Caribbean Missions in Jamaica R. Evan Ellis. Valeen Calder Systemic Challenges in Law Enforcement: Examining the Social Context of Misconduct and Criminal Behavior within the Police Service of Trinidad and Tobago Netty-Ann Gordon ISBN: 978-0-9913377-1-2Contemporary Security and Defense Issues in the Caribbean 2016 1 Front Cover: A U.S. Army National Guard soldier holds the ensign of the United States alongside standard bearers of other nations during the Tradewinds 2015 exercise. A number of armies from Caribbean nations also participate in the Conference of the American Armies. Photo credit: Wimbish, Michael D CIV USSOUTHCOM/SC-CC (L) The opinions in this report are of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the William J. Perry Center for Hemispheric Defense Studies, the National Defense University, or the U.S. Department of Defense. The editors extend their sincere appreciation to the graphic designer Vivian Edwards for her help designing and assembling the book, and to the Perry Center research assistants Liliana Besosa, Sarah Albanesi, and Caroline Armstrong.
    [Show full text]
  • Antony Bertram Anderson, CD, JP, MDA, Beng (Hons) Major General Commissioner of Police Jamaica Constabulary Force
    Antony Bertram Anderson, CD, JP, MDA, BEng (Hons) Major General Commissioner of Police Jamaica Constabulary Force ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. Major General Antony Bertram Anderson was appointed Commissioner of Police of the Jamaica Constabulary Force (JCF) on 19 March 2018. Prior to this appointment, Major General Anderson served as Jamaica’s first National Security Advisor and, for six years, as the Chief of Defence Staff of the Jamaica Defence Force (JDF). Major General Anderson spent two years as the Deputy Chief of Defence Staff with responsibility for Force strategy, future plans and development; coordination of the National Security Strategy; and the implementation of the JDF's Strategic Defence Review (SDR). Major General Anderson served as Inspector General and later as Colonel General Staff, with responsibility for Force policies on operations, intelligence, training, and civil-military affairs. The Major General has held several command appointments throughout his career, including Commanding Officer for the JDF Air Wing and 1 Engineer Regiment (JDF). In 2006, Major General Anderson deployed to Trinidad and Tobago to head the CARICOM Operations Planning and Coordinating Staff (COPACS), which was established to develop the regional security plans for the Caribbean countries participating in the ICC Cricket World Cup 2007. He later became the first Regional Operations Commander and saw to the implementation of those security plans across the Caribbean. Major General Anderson has been guest presenter and panellist at: the United Nations Inter- Regional Crime and Justice Research Institute (UNICRI); Interpol Headquarters in Lyon, France; Organisation of American States (OAS) Inter-American Committee against Terrorism (CICTE); Washington-based Centre for Hemispheric Defence Studies (CHDS); and at the Halifax International Security Forum, Canada.
    [Show full text]
  • Jamaica National HIV/STI Programme
    JAMAICA NATIONAL HIV/STI PROGRAMME Monitoring and Evaluation System Operations Manual Jamaica National HIV/STI Programme Monitoring and Evaluation System 2007-2012 Document B: M&E Operations Manual Ministry of Health and Environment Jamaica Table of Contents Overview vii Acronyms 1 Introduction 2 Background 5 Developing, Implementing, and Updating the M&E Operations Manual 10 Data Collection, Flow and Use 13 Indicators 20 Policies and protocols 21 Appendix 1 – Indicator Reference Sheets for Core Indicators 21 Prevention Indicators 33 Treatment, Care and Support Indicators 45 Enabling Environmentsand Human Rights Indicators 53 Empowerment andGovernance Indicators 63 Appendix 2 – Required and Recommended Data Collection Protocol Instruments 63 Behaviour Change Communication 83 Medical Officers of Health, Contact Investigators, Laboratory Personnel, Epidemiologists, and Pharmacists 161 PMTCT Nurse/Nutritionists and Social Workers 173 NGO, Line Ministries and Other Stakeholders 183 Appendix 3 – Non-Routine Surveys and Studies 187 Appendix 4 – Reporting Timelines and MERG 187 Reporting Timelines 189 M&E Reference Group Terms of Reference 191 Appendix 5 – Release of Client Information Policy Manual 217 Appendix 6 – Monitoring and Evaluation 101 221 Appendix 7 – Glossary and References 221 Glossary of M&E Terms 231 References Jamaica National HIV/STI Programme Monitoring and Evaluation System v Acronyms ABC Abstinence, Be Faithful and Condom Use AIDS Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome ANC Antenatal Clinic ART Antiretroviral Therapy ARV Antiretroviral
    [Show full text]
  • National Security Policy for Jamaica
    i TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary ..........................................................................................................................iii A Vision for National Security for Jamaica ....................................................................................viii CHAPTER ONE: – STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS..............................................1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................1 Setting the context..............................................................................................................................2 The impact of international geo-politics ............................................................................................3 The global economy ...........................................................................................................................3 Transnational & organised crime .......................................................................................................4 Domestic political maturity and human, social and economic development .....................................5 Global environmental hazards and disasters ......................................................................................5 Summary of Jamaica’s security concerns ..........................................................................................6 CHAPTER TWO: – THREATS TO JAMAICA’S NATIONAL SECURITY .................................8
    [Show full text]
  • Alert 2016 Viewing
    © 2016 BELL HELICOPTER TEXTRON INC. SUPPPORTING CRITICAL OPERATIONAL READINESS The men and women of Bell Helicopter are proud to support the operational needs of the Jamaica Defense Force’s air support teams. They are an asset to the security of the Jamaican people and we understand the importance of their readiness to respond–no matter what the crisis may be. We look forward to continuing to support the Jamaica Defense Force. BELLHELICOPTER.COM Jamaican-Defense_Ad1P_7.5x10_160711.indd 1 7/15/16 11:17 AM BECOME A PART OF JAMAICA’S DEFENCE FORCE www.jointhejdf.com Choose from careers in the JDF Air Wing, JDF Coast Guard, Engineer Regiment, Infantry and Support Units (including Information Communication Technology, Medical and Legal). Minimum requirements for service as an Officer: » Jamaican nationality » Between 18 and 23 years old for the Regular Force and up to 28 years old for the National Reserve » Five CXC subjects [grades 1-3] including Mathematics and English » Language and two CAPE or ‘A’ Level subjects [grades 1-5] » Pass a Selection Board to include a full medical examination Minimum requirements for service as an Enlisted Rank: » Jamaican nationality » Between 18 and 23 years old for the Regular Force and up to 28 years old for the National Reserve » Grade nine level education » Pass entry tests to include a full medical examination SUBMIT YOUR APPLICATION: To join as an officer in the Regular Force SO1 J1 (Personnel & Administration) Jamaica Defence Force Up Park Camp, Kingston 5 Email: [email protected] To join as an Enlisted Rank in the Regular Force Apply at www.jointhejdf.com To serve part time in the National Reserve Administrative Officer Headquarters The Third Battalion The Jamaica Regiment (National Reserve) Curphey Barracks Up Park Camp, Kingston 5 CONTENTS 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Regional Security Symposium 2010.Indd
    CURITY 24-26 March 2010 SE AN San Juan IC D R I Puerto Rico E N H T P E S L I L I M G E E H N C D E R 3 SY MPOSIUM 3RD HEMISPHERIC SECURITY AND INTELLIGENCE SYMPOSIUM Administrative Information Please wear your conference badge at all times while the Regional Security Symposium is in session. This badge identifi es you as a Symposium participant and allows you access to the conference room (Grand Ballroom), breakfasts, lunches, refreshments, and social events. Please put pagers and other personal data devices (PDAs) on “mute” or “vibrate” mode while the Symposium sessions are ongoing. Lavatories are located to the left as you exit the main entrance of the Grand Ballroom. Smoking is prohibited inside the hotel; however, a designated smoking area is available outside. Should you need computer, or printer access, an administrative room is available at “El Yunque” Room”, located to the right as you exit the Grand Ballroom, down the hall to the end on the right. Additionally, the “Corporate Board room” is available for private meetings, located next to the Grand Ballroom to the right. Please see any staff member at the table situated outside the Grand Ballroom if you need to use the Board Room. Conference participants travelling without an escort (DATT or MLO), please confi rm airport transportation requirements with the Symposium Staff prior to the last day of the symposium. Staff members can be identifi ed by their conference badge. If you need any assistance during the event, please do not hesitate to contact them.
    [Show full text]
  • Lumber Depot Prospectus
    LUMBER DEPOT LIMITED Invitation for Subscription 141,247,500 Invitation Shares at J$1.20 Each Mayberry Investments Limited Lead Broker and Sole Listing Agent This document is a Prospectus dated 15 November 2019 that is issued by Lumber Depot Limited. A copy of this Prospectus was delivered to the Registrar of Companies for registration pursuant to section 40(2) of the Companies Act and was so registered on 15 November 2019. The Registrar of Companies accepts no responsibility whatsoever for the contents of this Prospectus. A copy of this Prospectus was also delivered to the Financial Services Commission for the purposes of the registration of the Company pursuant to section 26 of the Securities Act as of Friday 15 November 2019. The FSC has not approved the Shares for which subscription is invited nor has the FSC passed upon the accuracy or adequacy of this Prospectus. Any representation to the contrary is a criminal offence. LUMBER DEPOT LIMITED Invitation for Subscription 141,247,500 Invitation Shares at J$1.20 Each Mayberry Investments Limited Lead Broker and Sole Listing Agent The Company invites Applications on behalf of itself for up to 141,247,500 Subscription Shares that are newly issued by the Company in the Invitation priced at $1.20. Up to 70,623,750 Shares in the Invitation are initially reserved for applications by the general public, and up to 70,623,750 Shares in the Invitation are Reserved Shares that are initially reserved for applications by the Reserved Share Applicants as set out in Section 2 of this Prospectus.
    [Show full text]
  • Senator the Honourable Mark Golding Minister of Justice
    Presentation by Senator the Honourable Mark Golding Minister of Justice Intake 106 Passing out Parade Saturday 10 August, 2013 3:00 p.m. Moneague Training Camp, St. Ann 1 | Page Salutations/Protocol . Chief of Defence Staff . Distinguished Guests . Other Officers, men and women of the Jamaica Defence Force . Families and friends of the graduands Good afternoon. Indeed I am delighted to have been asked to serve as reviewing officer for Intake 106. Today, the 106th batch of recruits having been trained for service in the Jamaica Defence Force, take their rightful place among our noble citizens who have worn the uniform of the Jamaica Defence Force, and will stand up bravely and proudly to defend our country. They are not here on the basis of any sort of favour. Instead, these 131 soldiers, who started training on March 3, 2013 among 167 persons, have met the rigorous standards and have qualified to pass-out as soldiers of the JDF. This is an honour that has been earned with every drop of sweat and proven commitment, over twenty-two gruelling weeks of training. 2 | Page Strategic Defence Reviews by the JDF have identified that the manning levels of the JDF are one of its current deficiencies. While this batch of soldiers, and the passing out of successive batches, will contribute towards addressing these deficiencies and strengthening the operational capacity of the Force in the execution of its duties and responsibilities, with a net increase of 2,000 being suggested, the Force remains significantly under-manned. I must therefore use this opportunity to encourage Jamaica’s young men and women to give serious consideration to applying to the Jamaica Defence Force, especially in the face of harsh economic realities which have made job opportunities increasingly scare.
    [Show full text]
  • Country Information and Guidance. Jamaica
    Country Information and Guidance Jamaica: Background information, including actors of protection and internal relocation Version 1.0 May 2016 Preface This document provides general, background information to Home Office decision makers to set the context for considering handling particular types of protection and human rights claims. Where applicable, it must be read alongside other relevant country information and guidance material. Decision makers must consider claims on an individual basis, taking into account the case specific facts and all relevant evidence, including: the guidance contained with this document; the available COI; any applicable caselaw; and the Home Office casework guidance in relation to relevant policies. Country Information The COI within this document has been compiled from a wide range of external information sources (usually) published in English. Consideration has been given to the relevance, reliability, accuracy, objectivity, currency, transparency and traceability of the information and wherever possible attempts have been made to corroborate the information used across independent sources, to ensure accuracy. All sources cited have been referenced in footnotes. It has been researched and presented with reference to the Common EU [European Union] Guidelines for Processing Country of Origin Information (COI), dated April 2008, and the European Asylum Support Office’s research guidelines, Country of Origin Information report methodology, dated July 2012. Feedback Our goal is to continuously improve the guidance and information we provide. Therefore, if you would like to comment on this document, please e-mail us. Independent Advisory Group on Country Information The Independent Advisory Group on Country Information (IAGCI) was set up in March 2009 by the Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration to make recommendations to him about the content of the Home Office‘s COI material.
    [Show full text]
  • I N the Supreme Court of Judicature of Jamaica I N Miscellaneous Suit No. M-66 of 1995 Before: the Hon. Mr. Justice Smith, J. Th
    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA IN MISCELLANEOUS SUIT NO. M-66 OF 1995 BEFORE: THE HON. MR. JUSTICE SMITH, J. THE HON. MR. JUSTICE REID, J. THE HON. MRS. JUSTICE HARRIS, J. REGINA V. JAMAICA DEFENCE FORCE - Exparte Granville William Pitter -, Arthur Kitchen instructed by Messrs H.G. Bartholomew and Company for Applicant. Laxton Robinson and M. Harrison instructed by Director of State Proceedings for Respondent. HEARD: 8th, 9th, 11th October, 7th November, 23rd December, 1996 6th January and 30th May, 1997 I- SMITH, J. I have read the draft judgment of my sister Harris, J. and I am in agreement with the reasoning and conclusion. I wish only to say one thing. It is my view that this case concerns matters of military law and rules of procedure. This court can only interfere with military courts and matters of military law in so C.1 far as the civil rights of the soldier may be affected. See R. v. Secretary of State for War Exparte (Martyn) (1949) 1 All E,R, 242. The applicant is a member of the Jamaica Defence Force. The relief sought by him is "an Order of Certiorari to quash Jamaica Defence Force Part 2 Orders Serial ~0.37dated the 26th day of June, 1995, whereby it was ordered by the Chief of Staff and/or the Commanding Officer of the Support and Services Battalion that the Applicant re-engage in the J.D.F. for a further period of 6 years and 6 days." , i. - The grounds upon which the relief is sought are: (i) that the purported re-engagement is unlawful, arbitrary, null and void and in breach of :he Defence Act and the Defence (Regular Force Enlistment and Service) Regulations in that at no time did the Appli- cant agree to re-engage in the J.D.F.
    [Show full text]