Proceedings of the 16 th meeting of Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority (KSCZMA) held on 18.03.2017 at 11.00 A.M. at Room No. 252, 2 nd Floor, 2 nd Gate, M. S. Building, Bengaluru under the chairmanship of Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Forest, Ecology & Environment Department.

Members Present: As per the list enclosed

The Chairman welcomed the members present. All the files were placed before the Authority for perusal and the subjects were deliberated as per the Agenda.

16.1 A Brief Presentation on CRZ Notification, 2011.

Presentation on CRZ Notification, 2011 was made before the Authority by the Member Secretary highlighting the salient features of the said notification and the powers and duties of the Authority in enforcing the provision of the notification, 2011.

16.2 Confirmation of the proceedings of the previous KSCZMA meeting held on 08.07.2016.

The Proceedings of the previous KSCZMA meeting held on 08.07.2016 are read out and the proceedings were confirmed as there were no comments received from the members.

16.3 Action Taken Report on the proceedings of the previous KSCZMA meeting held on 08.07.2016.

Action Taken Report at annexure -1 was perused and the Authority noted the action taken.

16.4 Status of Preparation of State Coastal Zone Management Plan :

It was brought to the notice of the Authority that, preparation of Coastal Zone Management Plan (CZMP) as per CRZ Notification, 2011, has been awarded to the National Center for Sustainable Coastal Management (NCSCM), Chennai for Rs. 1,93,43,058/- on 02.11.2016. further it is also brought to the notice of the authority that the validity of approved CZMP as per CRZ Notification 1991, has been further extended up to 31 st July 2017 vide Notification dated 23.02.2017 of MoEF, & CC Government of India, New Delhi.

Page 1 of 61

16.5 Online Submission of applications for CRZ clearance and Monitoring of CRZ Clearances

It was brought to the notice of the Authority that, the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Government of India has launched a portal for online submission of applications for CRZ Clearances on 06.03.2017. The NIC division of MoEF & CC, Government of India is organizing a workshop in this regard on 20 th March 2017 at Indira Paryavaran Bhavan, New Delhi. In future the applications seeking CRZ clearances shall have to be received online and processed accordingly by KSCZMA. The Authority noted the same.

The Authority suggested to send Sri. Rajanna, Scientific Officer to attend the workshop on 20 th March 2017 at New Delhi.

16.6 New Proposals

16.6.1 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement work to Hejamadi Kodi Fisheries Road under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) in Udupi Taluk and District (FEE 281 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement work to Hejamadi Kodi Fisheries Road under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP). 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Hejamadi Kodi, Udupi Taluk and District. Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 171 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of the road project is 1.40 KM. • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 0.66 KM from P2 to P3, • Now they have requested CRZ clearance for P1 to P2 and P3 to P4 for a balance length of 0.74 KM.

Page 2 of 61

9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ - yes, specify the relevant III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ rules Notification, 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per para 8 III CRZ - III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III Specify relevant rules. CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification, 2011 the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for the improvement work to Hejamadi Kodi Fisheries Road from P1 to P2 and P3 to P4 for a balance length of 0.74 KM by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept. Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ - III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

Page 3 of 61

16.6.2 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Improvement to Tenka Yermal Fisheries Road under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) in Udupi Taluk and District (FEE 282 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement to Tenka Yermal Fisheries Road under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept 3. Location of the Project Tenka Yermal, Udupi Taluk and District. Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ of CRZ-III. (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 250 Lakhs. 8. Activities proposed • Total length of the road project is 2.45 KM • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 0.88 KM, • Now they have requested for CRZ clearance for improvements to Tenka Yermal Fisheries Road from P1 to P2 and P4 to P5 for a balance length of 1.57 KM 9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ - yes, specify the relevant III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of rules CRZ Notification, 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per para 8 III CRZ - III, (iii) (j) and para 8 Specify relevant rules. III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

Page 4 of 61

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for the improvement work to Hejamadi Kodi Fisheries Road from P1 to P2 and P3 to P4 for a balance length of 0.74 KM by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept. Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, as per para 8 III CRZ - III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.3 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement to Road from Malpe Thottam Gujjarabettu Fisheries Road in Badanidiyur and Tenkanidiyur village, Udupi Taluk and District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 283 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement to Road from Malpe Thottam Gujjarabettu Fisheries Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Badanidiyur and Tenkanidiyur village, Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Udupi Taluk and District. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification Outside the NDZ of CRZ III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 310 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of the road project is 2.00 KM • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 1.83 KM from P1 to P2 and P3 to P4, • Now they have requested CRZ clearance for improvements to Road from Malpe Thottam Gujjarabettu Fisheries Road in Badanidiyur and Tenkanidiyur village from P2 to P3 for a balance length of 0.17 KM.

Page 5 of 61

9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- yes, specify the relevant III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011 rules Construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges, roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Specify relevant rules. Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for improvements to Road from Malpe Thottam Gujjarabettu Fisheries Road in Badanidiyur and Tenkanidiyur village from P2 to P3 for a balance length of 0.17 KM by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.4 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept. Kundapura for Improvements to Road from Herikudru Temple to National Highway in Anagalli Village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 284 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvements to Road from Herikudru Temple to National Highway (NCRMP)

Page 6 of 61

2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Anagalli Village, Kundapura Taluk and Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Udupi District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 165.5 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of the road project is 2.12 KM • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 0.71 KM from P1 to P2, • Now they have requested CRZ clearance for improvements to Road from Herikudru Temple to National Highway in Anagalli Village from P2 to P3 for a balance length of 1.41 KM. 9. Whether permitted activity as Yes. per CRZ Notification? If yes, As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, specify the relevant rules (iii) (j) of CRZ Notification, 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges, roads , provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants may be permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per para 8 III CRZ - III, (iii) (j) of CRZ Specify relevant rules. Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for improvements to Road from Herikudru Temple to National Highway in Anagalli Village from P2 to P3 for a balance length of 1.41 KM, by the Assistant Executive Engineer,

Page 7 of 61

PWD Dept as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ - III, (iii) (j) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following con ditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.5 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvements to Road from Herikudru School Road to National Highway at Anagalli Village, Kundapura Taluk, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 285 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvements to Road from Herikudru School Road to National Highway (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Anagalli Village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. District. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land 6. CRZ Classification NDZ of CRZ-III. (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 58.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of the road project is 0.82 KM • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 0.70 KM from P2 to P3, • Now they have requested CRZ clearance for Improvement to Road from Herikudru School Road to National Highway at Anagalli Village from P1 to P2 for a balance length of 0.12 KM. 9. Whether permitted Yes. activity as per CRZ As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, Notification? If yes, (iii) (j) of CRZ Notification 2011, construction of specify the relevant rules dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities.

Page 8 of 61

10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of SCZMA. clearance is within the As per para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) of CRZ scope of SCZMA or Notification 2011 the above activity is NCZMA? Specify permissible. relevant rules.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for Improvement to Road from Herikudru School Road to National Highway at Anagalli Village from P1 to P2 for a balance length of 0.12 KM, by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.6 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvements to road from Bengri Naga temple to Trasi Gangolli Main Road in Gujjadi village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 286 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvements to road from Bengri Naga temple to Trasi Gangolli Main Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Gujjadi village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land -

6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996).

Page 9 of 61

7. Project Cost Rs. 54.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of the project is 1.04 KM • CRZ clearance already been issued for a length of 0.50 KM from P2 to P3 • Now they have requested to issue CRZ clearance for improvements to road from Bengri Naga temple to Trasi Gangolli Main Road from P1 to P2 for a balance length of 0.54 KM.

9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ - yes, specify the relevant III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of rules CRZ Notification 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ - Specify relevant rules. III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for improvements to road from Bengri Naga temple to Trasi Gangolli Main Road from P1 to P2 for a balance length of 0.54 KM, by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ - III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies.

Page 10 of 61

2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.7 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement work to Uppunda Medical Alvekode Fisheries Road at Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP). (FEE 287 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement work to Uppunda Medical Alvekode Fisheries Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Alvekode Village, Kundapura Taluk and Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Udupi District. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996. 7. Project Cost Rs. 162.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of road project is 1.80 KM • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 1.30 KM, • Now they have requested to issue CRZ clearance for improvement work to Uppunda Medical Alvekode Fisheries Road for a balance length of 0.50 KM 9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- yes, specify the relevant III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of rules CRZ Notification 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project . Management Authority

Page 11 of 61

(DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- Specify relevant rules. III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for improvement work to Uppunda Medical Alvekode Fisheries Road for a balance length of 0.50 KM by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept. Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.8 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement work to Yadthare – Paduvari – Customs to National Highway 66, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP). (FEE 288 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement work to Yadthare – Paduvari – Customs to National Highway 66 (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Yadthare – Paduvari Village, Kundapura Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Taluk and Udupi District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ areas of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 144.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of road project is 1.6 KM out of which, from P1 to P2 • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 1.18 KM.

Page 12 of 61

• Now they have requested to issue CRZ clearance for improvement work to Yadthare – Paduvari – Customs to National Highway 66 for a balance length of 0.42 KM. 9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- yes, specify the relevant III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of rules CRZ Notification 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- Specify relevant rules. III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for improvement work to Yadthare – Paduvari – Customs to National Highway 66 for a balance length of 0.42 KM by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept. Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

Page 13 of 61

16.6.9 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement work to Yadthare Market Road, Yadthare & Paduvari Village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 289 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement work to Yadthare Market Road, (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Yadthare & Paduvari Village, Kundapura Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Taluk and Udupi District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ areas of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 144.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of road project is 1.60 KM, • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 1.19 KM from P2 to P3 • Now they have requested to issue CRZ clearance for taking up improvement work of Yadthare Market Road for a balance length of 0.41 KM. 9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under As per the yes, specify the relevant provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) rules and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, of CRZ Notification 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details -

Page 14 of 61

12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- Specify relevant rules. III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for improvement work to Yadthare Market Road for a balance length of 0.41 KM by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Mangalroe, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011 , with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.10 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement works to Road from National Highway 66 to shiroor under bridge approach Road at Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 290 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement works to Road from National Highway 66 to shiroor under bridge approach Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project shiroor Village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 108.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of road project is 1.20 KM • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 0.90 KM, • Now they have requested to issue CRZ clearance for improvement works to Road

Page 15 of 61

from National Highway 66 to shiroor under bridge approach Road from P2 to P3 for a balance length of 0.30 KM. 9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- yes, specify the relevant III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of rules CRZ Notification 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- Specify relevant rules. III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for improvement works to Road from National Highway 66 to shiroor under bridge approach Road from P2 to P3 for a balance length of 0.30 KM, by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011,with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

Page 16 of 61

16.6.11 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement work to Yadthare – Alvegadde Fisheries Road in Shiroor village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 291 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement work to Yadthare – Alvegadde Fisheries Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Shiroor village, Kundapura Taluk and Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Udupi District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside of NDZ areas of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996) 7. Project Cost Rs. 166.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of the road project is 1.90 KM, • CRZ clearance has already been issued for a length of 1.01 KM from P2 to P3, • Now they have requested to issue CRZ clearance for taking up improvement work to Shiroor – Alvegadde Fisheries Road from P1 to P2 for a balance length of 0.89 KM.

9. Whether permitted activity as Yes. per CRZ Notification? If yes, As per the provisions para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) specify the relevant rules (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA)

Page 17 of 61

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance is Issue of clearance is within the scope of within the scope of SCZMA SCZMA. or NCZMA? Specify relevant As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- rules. III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for improvement work to Shiroor – Alvegadde Fisheries Road from P1 to P2 for a balance length of 0.89 KM, by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification, 2011 with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.12 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement works to Yadthare - Paduvari – Someshwara Road in Paduvari village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi Districtunder National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 292 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement works to Yadthare - Paduvari – Someshwara Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Paduvari Village, Kundapura Taluk and Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Udupi District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ areas of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 286.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed • Total length of road project is 3.30 KM and out of which, • CRZ clearance has already been issued from P1 to P2 for a length of 1.47 KM,

Page 18 of 61

• Now they have requested to issue CRZ clearance for taking up improvement works to Yadthare - Paduvari – Someshwara Road in Paduvari village from P2 to P3 for a balance length of 1.83 KM. 9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ- yes, specify the relevant III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of rules CRZ Notification 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, Specify relevant rules. (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deli berations decided to issue CRZ clearance for taking up improvement works to Yadthare - Paduvari – Someshwara Road in Paduvari village from P2 to P3 for a balance length of 1.83 KM, by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification, 2011 with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

Page 19 of 61

16.6.13 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement work to road from Thekkatte to Kome Fisheries Road (Subramanya Temple Road), Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 293 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Improvement work to road from Thekkatte to Kome Fisheries Road (Subramanya Temple Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Applicant Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Thekkattee to kome Village, Kundapura Taluk and Village/Town, Taluk, Udupi District Dt. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ areas of CRZ –I and CRZ- III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 181.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed Total length of road project is 2.10 KM. The GPS Readings of P1 of said road is N 13 0 32’ 52.3” and E 74 0 42’ 06.3” GPS Readings of P2 of said road is N 13 0 32’ 42.5” and E 74 0 40’ 56.4”. 9. Whether permitted Yes. activity as per CRZ As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) Notification? If yes, and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification specify the relevant 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain rules shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities.. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, Udupi on recommendations of 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has recommended the the District Coastal project. Zone Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of SCZMA. clearance is within the As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) scope of SCZMA or and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification NCZMA? Specify 2011, the above activity is permissible. relevant rules. [

Page 20 of 61

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for Improvement works to Beejadi Fisheries Road by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.14 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement works to Beejadi Fisheries Road in Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) (FEE 294 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Improvement works to Beejadi Fisheries Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Beejadi Village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ areas of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 190.00 Lakhs 8. Activities proposed Total length of road project is 2.15 KM. The GPS Readings of the project site is N 13 0 34’ 36.4” E 74 0 41’ 50.2” to N 13 0 34’ 36.9” E 74 0 40’ 39.7”. 9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, yes, specify the relevant (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ rules Notification 2011, construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities.

Page 21 of 61

10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of SCZMA. is within the scope of As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) SCZMA or NCZMA? (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Specify relevant rules. Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for Improvement works to Beejadi Fisheries Road for a length of 2.15 KM by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

[ 16.6.15 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi for Improvement works to Koderi Fisheries Road in Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District under National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP). (FEE 295 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Improvement works to Koderi Fisheries Road (NCRMP) 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept, Udupi, Sub-division. 3. Location of the Project Koderi Village, Kundapura Taluk and Udupi District Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification NDZ and outside the NDZ areas of CRZ-III (as per the CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs. 90.00 Lakhs. 8. Activities proposed Total length of road project is 1.00 KM. The GPS Readings of the project site is N 13 0 47’ 21.6” E 74 0 37’ 37.8” to N 13 0 47’ 07.3” E 74 0 37’ 55.7”.

Page 22 of 61

9. Whether permitted Yes. activity as per CRZ As per the provisions under 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) and Notification? If yes, para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011, specify the relevant construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain rules shelter, community toilets, bridges , roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local in habitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, Udupi recommendations of on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has recommended the the District Coastal project. Zone Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of SCZMA. clearance is within the As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ-III, (iii) (j) scope of SCZMA or and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification NCZMA? Specify 2011, the above activity is permissible. relevant rules.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for Improvement works to Beejadi Fisheries Road by the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 III CRZ- III, (iii) (j) and para 8 III CRZ-III B (viii) of CRZ Notification 2011 , with the following conditions:

1. Waste materials such as mud bitumen etc should be properly disposed in a scientific manner and it should not be dumped in water bodies. 2. The sand from the CRZ area should not be extracted and used for this purpose. The project proponent should source the material required from authorized quarry only. 3. Mangroves if any in the adjacent area should not be disturbed.

16.6.16 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Joint Director of Fisheries, Fishing Harbours, Malpe for construction of Breakwater /Guide Bund adjacent to the Navigational Channel at Gangolli Fishing Harbour in Kundapura Taluk -regarding (FEE 4 CRZ 2017).

1. Name of the Project Construction of Breakwater /Guide Bund adjacent to the Navigational Channel 2. Name of the Applicant Joint Director of Fisheries, Fishing Harbours, Malpe

Page 23 of 61

3. Location of the Project Gangolli Fishing Harbour in Kundapura Taluk Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. and Udupi District 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification CRZ-IV. 7. Project Cost 102.00 Crores. 8. Activities proposed Proposed to construct guide bund from 126m to 700 m on northern side and 0 to 900 m on southern side of Navigational Channel. 9. Whether permitted activity Yes, it is a permitted activity, as per CRZ Notification? If As per para 4 (i) (f) of CRZ Notification 2011, yes, specify the relevant construction and operation for ports and rules harbours, jetties, wharves, quays, slipways, ship construction yards, breakwaters, groynes, erosion control measures; are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 21.12.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per para 4 (i) (f) of CRZ Notification 2011, Specify relevant rules. the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for construction of Breakwater /Guide Bund adjacent to the Navigational Channel at Gangolli Fishing Harbour by the Joint Director of Fisheries, Fishing Harbours, Malpe as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under as per para 4 (i) (f) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:-

1. Ecologically sensitive areas like mangroves/mud flats/ turtle nesting areas/ Salt Marshes should not be disturbed. 2. Safe and scientific disposal of wastes 3. The materials required for construction of breakwater/guide bund should be source from outside the CRZ area. 4. Steps should be taken to prevent any pollution due to operation of machines.

Page 24 of 61

16.6.17 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Udupi Power Corporation Limited (UPCL) for Laying of pipeline for Sea Water Intake and Outfall for Proposed Expansion of UPCL from 1200MW to 2800MW at Yelluru Village, Udupi Taluk and District (FEE 5 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Laying of pipeline for Sea Water Intake and Outfall for Proposed Expansion of UPCL from 1200MW to 2800MW 2. Name of the Applicant Udupi Power Corporation Limited (UPCL) 3. Location of the Project Yelluru Village, Udupi Taluk and District Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land Existing land corridor (25 mts width) 6. CRZ Classification CRZ I , III, IV. 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed • Proposed new pipeline for 2800 MW TPP in existing land corridor in CRZ –I & CRZ III. • Intake pipes from land Fall Point (LP) to Caisson with option of off-shore pump house at proposed intake point in CRZ –IV at -6.8 meters CD and -650 meters from shore-line. • Outfall pipe to diffusers at proposed outfall point in CRZ –IV at 7.5 meter CD and -1750 meters from the shore-line. • Seawater requirement for TPP after expansion to 2800 MW, shall be 24,381 M3/Hr which is proposed to met from Arabian Sea. 9. Whether permitted Yes. activity as per CRZ As per the provisions under para 4 (ii) (d) & 4 (ii) Notification? If yes, (f) of CRZ Notification 2011, it is a permitted specify the relevant activity. rules 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 21.12.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details Earlier CRZ clearance was issued for laying of pipeline for the existing 2x600 MW unit by MoEF vide letter dated 18.05.2010. The pipeline runs to a total distance of 598 mts out of which 520 mts is in CRZ-III and 78 meters in CRZ-I.

Page 25 of 61

The existing corridor is 25 M wide all through, the existing intake point is 1430 M inside the sea and the outfall point is 670 M from HTL.

Due to operational constraints faced in the sea water intake system of the existing phase -1 sea water intake system will be designed to cater both phase I & II water requirements up to sea water intake pump house. • Seawater requirement for existing 2x600 MW units are 10,000 M3/Hr which is met from Arabian Sea. • For existing unit 87.6 MCM/year sea water is require. After expansion to 2800 MW, total intake & outfall of Sea water shall be 213.6 MCM/year & 175.2 MCM respectively. • Proposed intake and outfall coordinates have been recommended by NIO after Modeling Studies. • The 3 existing pipelines of 1.1 meter dia will be replaced with new pipelines of 1.4 meter dia for each of 2 intake pipelines and 1.2 meter dia for 1 outfall pipeline in the existing land corridor of 25 mts width.

12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of National clearance is within the Coastal Zone Management Authority. scope of SCZMA or As per para 4 (ii) (d) and 4 (ii) (f) of CRZ NCZMA? Specify Notification 2011, the above activity requires relevant rules. clearance from the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, with the recommendation of SCZMA.

The Authority perused the information furnished by the proponent and after discussion and deliberations, decided to recommend the proposal to MoEF with standard conditions to issue CRZ clearance for laying of pipelines within the approved land corridor of 25 mts width as per para 4 (ii) (d) and for laying pipeline for sea water intake and outfall, as per para 4 (ii) (f) of CRZ Notification 2011.

Page 26 of 61

16.6.18 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Removal of Sand by dredging from adjoining waterfront area of M/s. Waterways Shipyard Pvt. Ltd., at Sy. No. 53 and 56 of Balekudru Village, Hungarkatta, Udupi -regarding (FEE 6 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand by dredging from adjoining waterfront area 2. Name of the Applicant Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD Dept 3. Location of the Project Balekudru Village, Hungarkatta, Udupi Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s Sy. No. 53 and 56 5. Extent of land 150 meter length & 50 meter width. 6. CRZ Classification CRZ-IV 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Due to accumulation of sand, etc in the adjoining waterfront of project site, dredging is to be carried out for safety lanching of vessels. 9. Whether permitted Yes. activity as per CRZ As per the para 4 (i) (f) of CRZ Notification, Notification? If yes, 2011, construction and operation for ports and specify the relevant rules harbours, jetties, wharves, quays, slipways, ship construction yards, breakwaters, groynes, erosion control measures; are permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 21.12.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project subject to the Management Authority following conditions; (DCZMA)

1. Mines and Geology Department shall be intimated before work is to be taken up by the proponent and removed sand should be handed over to Mines and Geology Department. 2. The proponent shall follow all the rules and regulations which are in force at the time of execution of work. 3. The proponent should restrict the activity to the permitted depth and quantity of material. 4. The proponent shall take necessary action for safe disposal of waste materials.

Page 27 of 61

11. Any other details Estimated area of dredging is 150 m X50 M with 4 m depth. The depth required for the vessels to float is around 1.5 m to 2 m. Based on the above details, estimated quantity of removal of sand, silt and other materials is 30,000 Cum. 12. Whether issue of clearance is Issue of clearance is within the scope of SCZMA. within the scope of SCZMA As per the para 4 (i) (f) of CRZ Notification, 2011, or NCZMA? Specify Construction and operation for ports and harbours, relevant rules. jetties, wharves, quays, slipways, ship construction yards, breakwaters, groynes, erosion control measures; are permitted activities.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for Removal of Sand by dredging from adjoining waterfront area by the M/s. Waterways Shipyard Pvt. Ltd., as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 4 (i) (f) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:-

1. Ecologically sensitive areas like mangroves/mud flats/ turtle nesting areas/ Salt Marshes should not be disturbed. 2. Safe and scientific disposal of wastes 3. Steps should be taken to prevent any pollution due to operation of machines. 16.6.19 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Chief Officer, Municipality, Kundapura for construction of OHT (Over Head Tank) at Sy. No. 294/3P2 of Kasba Village in Kundapura -regarding (FEE 250 CRZ 2016).

1. Name of the Project Construction of OHT (Over Head Tank) 2. Name of the Applicant Chief Officer, Municipality 3. Location of the Project Kasba Village in Kundapura and Udupi Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. District 4. R.S. No.s Sy. No. 294/3P2 5. Extent of land 0.1.00 Acre. 6. CRZ Classification Project site falls in CRZ-II and at a distance of 25 mts from sea (as per CZMP approved 1996). 7. Project Cost Rs.1.45 Crores. 8. Activities proposed Construction of OHT to provide water supply facility. 9. Whether permitted activity as Yes. per CRZ Notification? If yes, As per under para 8 (II) CRZ-II (i) of CRZ specify the relevant rules Notification, 2011, buildings shall be permitted only on the landward side of the existing road, or on the landward side of existing authorized structures. Hence it is a permissible activity.

Page 28 of 61

10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 01.07.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details There is a fisheries road. Project site falls landward side of the existing road. 12. Whether issue of clearance is Issue of clearance is within the scope of SCZMA. within the scope of SCZMA As per under para 8 (II) CRZ-II (i) of CRZ or NCZMA? Specify relevant Notification 2011, the above activity is rules. permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance with standard condition for construction of OHT by the Chief Officer, Municipality, Kundapura as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 (II) CRZ-II (i) of CRZ Notification 2011.

16.6.20 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to Project Director, Project Management Unit Department of Ports & Inland Water Transport, Mangalore for “Community Coastal Protection Pilot Study Project” in Kirimanjeshwara Village-regarding (FEE 251 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Community Coastal Protection Pilot Study Project. 2. Name of the Applicant Project Director, Project Management Unit Department of Ports & Inland Water Transport, Mangalore. 3. Location of the Project Kirimanjeshwara beach site of Kundapura Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Taluk, Udupi District. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land Approximately 1.0 KM of coastal length. 6. CRZ Classification CRZ-I 7. Project Cost Rs. 40.00 Lakh 8. Activities proposed • This is a shore line management program to demonstrate soft coastal protection measure. • Construction & maintenance of a dune project with a minimum dune height of 4.35 m. • The sand volume required for the designed dune is 12,000-15,000 cubic meters. • Sand from the nearby sandbars is proposed to be used for the dune construction.

Page 29 of 61

9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 4(i) (f) of yes, specify the relevant CRZ Notification, 2011, erosion control rules measures is a permissible activity since this study project is connected to erosion control measures it may have to be considered under the same provision. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 01.07.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details -

12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per under para 4(i) (f) of CRZ Notification Specify relevant rules. 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations opined that this activity is connected to take up the suitable erosion control measures and decided to issue CRZ clearance for Community Coastal Protection Pilot Study Project to Project Director, Project Management Unit, Department of Ports & Inland Water Transport, Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 4(i) (f) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:-

1. Should not disturb mud flats /breeding areas, Mangroves etc., 2. The results of the project should be shared with KSCZMA.

16.6.21 Request for issue of NOC from the Commissioner, City council, Udupi for Construction of sewage treatment plant at sy. No. 262/1C1A1 of Kodavoor Village, Udupi Taluk (FEE 278 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Construction of sewage treatment plant 2. Name of the Applicant Commissioner, City council, Udupi 3. Location of the Project Kodavoor Village, Udupi Taluk Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s 262/1C1A1 5. Extent of land 1.5 Acre 6. CRZ Classification CRZ-III. 7. Project Cost 17.00 Crores. 8. Activities proposed To provide sewerage system for Malpe area by constructing of 2.80 MLD STP.

Page 30 of 61

9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per under para 3 (v) (c) of CRZ Notification, yes, specify the relevant 2011., facilities required for treatment of waste rules and effluents arising from hotels, beach resorts and human settlements located in CRZ areas other than CRZ-I and disposal of treated wastes and effluents; is permitted. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per para 3 (v) (c) of CRZ Notification 2011, Specify relevant rules. the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for Construction of sewage treatment plant by the Commissioner, City council, Udupi as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 3 (v) (c) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions;

1. To adopt Latest Technology and the treated water should conform to the latest standards issued by CPCB. 2. Treated Water should be reused and sludge should be managed scientifically as per the CPCB guidelines. 3. EC should be obtained from the SEIAA as per EIA Notification 2006. 4. To install online monitoring system as per CPCB guideline.

16.6.22 Request for issue of NOC from the Commissioner, City council, Udupi for Construction of raw water treatment plant at sy. No. 325/1 of Shivalli Village, Udupi Taluk (FEE 279 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Construction of Raw water treatment plant 2. Name of the Applicant Commissioner, City council, Udupi 3. Location of the Project Shivalli Village, Udupi Taluk Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s Sy. No. 325/1 5. Extent of land 0.65 acre 6. CRZ Classification NDZ of CRZ-III. 7. Project Cost Rs. 3.5 Crores. 8. Activities proposed To provide 24X7 Water supply system

Page 31 of 61

9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per under para 8 (III) CRZ III A (iii) (j) of yes, specify the relevant CRZ Notification, 2011, construction of rules dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges, roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage , sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants permitted activities. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per para 8 (III) CRZ III A (iii) (j) of CRZ Specify relevant rules. Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations opined that, this activity is related to water supply work and decided to issue CRZ clearance with standard condition for construction of raw water treatment plant by the Commissioner, City council, Udupi as per the recommendation of DCZMC, under para 8 (III) CRZ III A (iii) (j) of CRZ Notification, 2011.

16.6.23 Request for issue of NOC from the Commissioner, City council, Udupi for construction of Sewage water storage plant at sy. No. 124/5BP1 of Puttur Village, Udupi Taluk (FEE 280 CRZ 2016).

1. Name of the Project Construction of Sewage water storage plant. 2. Name of the Applicant Commissioner, City council, Udupi. 3. Location of the Project Puttur Village, Udupi Taluk. Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s Sy. No. 124/5BP1. 5. Extent of land Area of 0.10 acre. 6. CRZ Classification NDZ of CRZ-III. 7. Project Cost Rs. 17.00 Crores. 8. Activities proposed To provide sewage system for udupi city.

Page 32 of 61

9. Whether permitted activity as per Yes. CRZ Notification? If yes, specify As per the provisions under para 8 (III) the relevant rules CRZ III A (iii) (j) of CRZ Notification, 2011. construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges, roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage , sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local inhabitants are permitted activities. 10. The details of recommendations of The subject was placed before the the District Coastal Zone DCZMC, Udupi on 16.09.2016 and the Management Authority (DCZMA) DCZMA has recommended the project. 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance is Issue of clearance is within the scope of within the scope of SCZMA or SCZMA. NCZMA? Specify relevant rules. As per para 8 (III) CRZ III A (iii) (j) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity is permissible.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for construction of Sewage water storage plant by the Commissioner, City council, Udupi as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8 (III) CRZ III A (iii) (j) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions;

1. To adopt latest Technology and the treated water should conform to the latest standards issued by CPCB. 2. Treated Water should be reused and sludge should be managed scientifically as per the CPCB guidelines. 3. EC should be obtained from the SEIAA as per EIA Notification 2006. 4. To install online monitoring system as per CPCB guideline.

[

16.6.24 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Commanding Officer, Indian Coast Guard Station, Neval Base, Post office arga, for establishment of Radar Station at sy. No. 193 of Belekeri Village, Ankola Taluk. [FEE 319 CRZ 2016]

1. Name of the Project Establishment of Radar Station 2. Name of the Applicant Commanding Officer, Indian Coast Guard Station, Neval Base, Post office arga

Page 33 of 61

3. Location of the Project Belekeri Village, Ankola Taluk Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s Sy. No. 193 5. Extent of land Area of 20 Guntas 6. CRZ Classification NDZ of CRZ-III. (as per the CZMP approved 1996) 7. Project Cost Rs. 2.00 Crore 8. Activities proposed The proposal is for establishing radar station for coastal security network project at Belekeri port. Radar lattice tower with allied structures and offices. 9. Whether permitted activity Yes, it is a permitted activity, as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 8 III CRZ III yes, specify the relevant (iii) (i) of CRZ Notification 2011, weather rules radars is a permitted activity. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Karwar on 16.09.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of National Coastal Zone Management SCZMA or NCZMA? Authority. Specify relevant rules. As per under para 8 III CRZ III (iii) (i) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity requires clearance from the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, with the recommendation of SCZMA.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to recommend the proposal to MoEF, New Delhi with standard conditions as per para 8 III CRZ III (iii) (i) of CRZ Notification 2011.

16.6.25 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Project Director, Project Management Unit Department of Ports & Inland Water Transport, Mangalore for community coastal protection pilot projects at sy. No. 1483/A3 of Majali Village, Karwar Taluk (FEE 322 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Community Coastal Protection Pilot projects in Majili.

Page 34 of 61

2. Name of the Applicant Project Director, Project Management Unit Department of Ports & Inland Water Transport, Mangalore. 3. Location of the Project Majili beach site of Kundapura Taluk, Udupi Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. District. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land Approximately 1.0 KM of coastal length 6. CRZ Classification CRZ-I 7. Project Cost Rs. 60.00 Lakh 8. Activities proposed • These community coastal protection are study projects for demonstration of climate change in to costal protection and management. • It is recommended to construct a dune with a minimum dune height of 4.5 m. The sand volume required for the designed dune is 15,000-18,000 cubic meters. • Sand from the nearby sandbar at Kali River entrance is proposed to be used for the dune construction as removal of the sand bar will be helpful for safe navigation of fishing boats. 9. Whether permitted activity Yes. as per CRZ Notification? If As per the provisions under para 4(i) (f) of yes, specify the relevant CRZ Notification, 2011, erosion control rules measures is a permissible activity since this study project is connected to erosion control measures it may have to be considered under the same provision. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Karwar on 01.07.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? As per under para 4(i) (f) of CRZ Notification Specify relevant rules. 2011, the above activity is permissible.

Page 35 of 61

The Authority after discussion and deliberations opined that this activity is connected to take up suitable erosion control measures and decided to issue CRZ clearance for Community Coastal Protection Pilot Study Project to Project Director, Project Management Unit, Department of Ports & Inland Water Transport, Mangalore, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 4(i) (f) of CRZ Notification 2011, with the following conditions:-

1. Should not disturb mud flats /breeding areas, Mangroves etc., 2. The results of the project should be shared with KSCZMA.

16.6.26 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance to M/s. Mysore Mercantile Company Limited for “Storing Cane Molasses” at Sy. No. 1379 of Baada III (Aligadda) Village-regarding (FEE 1 CRZ 2017).

- Name of the Project Storing Cane Molasses 2. Name of the Applicant M/s. Mysore Mercantile Company Limited 3. Location of the Project Baad-III (Aligadda) Village, Karwar Taluk, Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. Uttara Kannada District. 4. R.S. No.s Sy. No. 1379 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification CRZ-III. 7. Project Cost 8.2 Crores 8. Activities proposed Construction of Storage Tank of 5,000 KL capacity for Storing Cane molasses. 9. Whether permitted activity as per CRZ Yes. Notification? If yes, As per provisions of Para 8 III CRZ- III B (iv) of CRZ specify the relevant rules notification, 2011,

Storage of non-hazardous cargo such as, edible oil, fertilizers, food grain in notified ports is permitted. 10. The details of - recommendations of the District Coastal Zone Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details Earlier CRZ clearance has been issued for storage of only Edible Oil, Plam Oil, Kerosene, Aviation Fuel, High Speed Diesel, Lubrication Oil, Furnace Oil, Low Sulphar Heavy Stock except Molasses, as per the decision of

Page 36 of 61

KSCZMA meeting held on 30.01.2016.

Now the project proponent M/s. Mysore Mercantile Company Ltd., has given representation requesting to review the decision taken and to grant approval for storage of Molasses, as the Molasses is not a hazardous waste. The project proponent has also stated that, there are three tank Terminals presently operating at Karwar for export of Molasses with CRZ clearance obtained from MoEF & CC, New Delhi. As per Hazardous waste (Management Handling) Rules, 2016, Molasses is not found in the list of hazardous materials in the schedule. 12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of SCZMA. clearance is within the As per para 8 III CRZ- III B (iv) of CRZ notification scope of SCZMA or 2011, the above activity is permissible. NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance with standard conditions to M/s. Mysore Mercantile Company Ltd., for construction of 5,000 KL capacity storage tank to store molasses since it is not a hazardous material.

16.6.27 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Dileep Devadiga for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 96/6B2 of Bada Village, Udupi Taluk- regarding (FEE 24 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Reconstruction of residential house. 2. Name of the Applicant Sri. Dileep Devadiga. 3. Location of the Project Bada Village, Udupi Taluk. Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s 96/6B2. 5. Extent of land 0.25 acre. 6. CRZ Classification NDZ of CRZ III. 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed • Proposal for reconstruction of residential house. • The plinth area of existing building is 56.88 Sqm.

Page 37 of 61

9. Whether permitted As per the provisions under para 8(i) III CRZ activity as per CRZ III A (ii) of CRZ Notification 2011, repairs or Notification? If yes, reconstruction of existing authorized structure specify the relevant rules not exceeding existing FSI, existing, plinth area and existing density and for permissible activities under the notification including facilities essential for the said activities are permissible. 10. The details of The subject was placed before the DCZMC, recommendations of the Udupi on 21.12.2016 and the DCZMA has District Coastal Zone recommended the project. Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of SCZMA. clearance is within the As per the provisions under para 8(i) III CRZ III scope of SCZMA or A (ii) of CRZ Notification 2011, the above activity NCZMA? Specify is permissible. relevant rules.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance for reconstruction of residential house by Sri. Dileep Devadiga, as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, under para 8(i) III CRZ III A (ii) and Para 6 (d) i & ii of CRZ Notification, 2011, with the following conditions:-

1. The proposed building should not exceed existing FSI, existing, plinth area and existing density. 2. This building should not be used for any commercial activity. 3. This building should not be sold or transferred to non traditional coastal community.

16.6.28 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance for M/s. Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Ltd., for laying pipeline to BS-VI Auto Fuel Quality & Associated Projects Facilities at MRPL (FEE 323 CRZ 2016)

1. Name of the Project Laying pipeline to BS-VI Auto Fuel Quality & Associated Projects Facilities. 2. Name of the Applicant M/s. Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Ltd. 3. Location of the Project - Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s - 5. Extent of land - 6. CRZ Classification CRZ-I & CRZ-II. 7. Project Cost -

Page 38 of 61

8. Activities proposed Laying of pipeline from MRPL unit to New Mangalore Port by MRPL in the existing Road cum Pipeline Corridor of MSEZ. Width of the Pipeline is 3.60 m. 9. Whether permitted Yes, it is a permitted activity, activity as per CRZ As per the provisions under para 4(ii) (d) of CRZ Notification? If yes, Notification, 2011, laying of pipelines, conveying specify the relevant rules systems, transmission line. 10. The details of recommendations of the - District Coastal Zone Management Authority (DCZMA) 11. Any other details • Environment clearance for construction of dedicated 70/100 m wide road cum pipe line corridor for movement of Corgo Crude and products between NMPT and MSEZ, has already been issued vide letter no: 21- 383/2007-IA-III dated 03-04-2008, subsequent amendments dated: 13-07-2012, 27-08-2014 and 18-06-2015. • MRPL has entered into an agreement with MSEZL for utilizing 10% of the MSEZL existing pipeline corridor which has already got the required Environment Clearance. • MRPL has submitted the proposal for establish BS VI Auto fuel Quality Compliance & Associated projects, along with project document including Form-1, PFR and draft ToR, as per the EIA Notification,2006 and MoEF has issued ToR for proposed project. • Further, MRPL has requested amendments in existing ToR due to additional tankage, Pipeline and others features, Appraisal Committee noted that, due to laying Pipeline to New Mangalore Port, the CRZ clearance to be obtained as applicable and prior SCZMA recommendation.

12. Whether issue of clearance is National Coastal Zone Management Authority. within the scope of SCZMA or As per para (4) (ii) (d) of the CRZ notification 2011, NCZMA? Specify relevant the above activity requires clearance from the rules. Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India.

Page 39 of 61

The Authority after discussion and deliberations, the Authority noted that MRPL has entered into an agreement with MSEZL for utilizing 10% of the MSEZL existing pipeline corridor which has already got the required Environment Clearance vide MoEF letter dated 13.04.2008. Hence, it was opined that separate CRZ clearance is not required since MRPL is laying pipeline in the existing MSEZL pipeline corridor. It was decided to communicate the same to the MoEF & CC GoI, New Delhi.

16.6.29 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Kali River ( SB-KL-1) in Karwar Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 84 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar ( SB-KL-1) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project Kali River in Karwar Taluk Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 600m 150m 22.23 A/9.00 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar Area Depth Quantity 22.23 Acre 0.60m 92,340m 3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstruct the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed. rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance is Issue of clearance is within the scope of within the scope of SCZMA SCZMA. or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 40 of 61

16.6.30 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Kali River ( SB-KL-2)in Karwar Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 85 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar ( SB-KL-2) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project ( SB-KL-2) Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 800m 200m 39.53 A/16.00 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 39.53 A 0.60 m 1.64.160m3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 41 of 61

16.6.31 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Kali River ( SB-KL-3) in Karwar Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 86 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar ( SB-KL-3) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB-KL-3 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 1100m 200m 54.36 A/22.00 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 54.36 A 0.60 m 2,25,720m 3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 42 of 61

16.6.32 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Kali River ( SB-KL-4) in Karwar Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 87 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar ( SB-KL-4) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB-KL-4 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 1000m 180m 44.47 A/18.00 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 44.47A 0.60 m 1,84,680m 3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 43 of 61

16.6.33 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Kali River ( SB-KL-5) in Karwar Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 88 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar ( SB-KL-5) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB-KL-5 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 1000m 133m 32.93 A/13.33 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 32.93A 0.60 m 1,36,458m3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 44 of 61

16.6.34 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Gangavalli river (SB- GA-1)in Ankola Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 89 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar (SB-GA-1) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB-GA-1 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 275m 138m 9.39 A/3.8 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost -

8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 9.39 A 0.60 m 38,988m3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 45 of 61

16.6.35 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Gangavalli river (SB- GA-2) in Ankola Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 90 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar (SB-GA-2) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB-GA-2 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 755m 100m 18.65 A/7.55 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 18.65 A 0.60 m 77,463m 3

9. Whether permitted activity as Yes per CRZ Notification? If yes, Sand bars which obstructing the movement of specify the relevant rules fishing vessels may be removed 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA) 11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 46 of 61

16.6.36 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Aghanashini river (SB- AG-1) in Kumta Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 91 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar (SB-AG-1) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project (SB-AG-1) Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 610m 165m 24.85 A/10.06 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 24.85 A 0.60 m 1,03,216m 3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details -

12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 47 of 61

16.6.37 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Aghanashini river (SB- AG-2) in Kumta Taluk of Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 92 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar (SB-AG-2) 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project (SB-AG-2) Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 950m 120m 28.17 A/11.4 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 28.17 A 0.60 m 1,16,946m 3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 48 of 61

16.6.38 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Aghanashini river (SB- AG-3)in Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 93 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Aghanashini river in Kumta Taluk, 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB-AG-3 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 850m 85m 17.84 A/7.22 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 17.84 A 0.60 m 74,128m3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 49 of 61

16.6.39 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Aghanashini river (SB- AG-4)in Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 94 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Aghanashini river in Kumta Taluk, 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB-AG-4 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 770m 106.9m 20.33 A/8.23 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 20.33 A 0.60 m 84,440m3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 50 of 61

16.6.40 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Aghanashini river (SB- AG-5)in Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 95 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Aghanashini river in Kumta Taluk, 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB-AG-5 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 660m 40m 6.42 A/2.6 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 6.42 A 0.60 m 25,086m3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 51 of 61

16.6.41 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Sharavathi river (SB- SH- 15)in Honnavar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 96 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Shravathi river in Honnavar Taluk, 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB- SH-15 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 500m 300m 37.06 A/15 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 37.06 A 0.9 m 2,02,500m3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 52 of 61

16.6.42 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Sharavathi river (SB- SH- 16)in Honnavar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 97 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Shravathi river in Honnavar Taluk, 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB- SH-16 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 1000m 100m 24.71 A/10.00 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 24.71 A 0.8 m 1,20,000m 3

9. Whether permitted activity Yes as per CRZ Notification? If Sand bars which obstructing the movement of yes, specify the relevant fishing vessels may be removed rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of clearance Issue of clearance is within the scope of is within the scope of SCZMA. SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 53 of 61

16.6.43 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Sharavathi river (SB- SH- 18)in Honnavar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 98 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Shravathi river in Honnavar Taluk, 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB- SH-18 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 550m 150m 20.4 A/8.3 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 20.4 A 0.8 m 99,600m3

9. Whether permitted Yes activity as per CRZ Sand bars which obstructing the movement of Notification? If yes, fishing vessels may be removed specify the relevant rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of clearance is within the SCZMA. scope of SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 54 of 61

16.6.44 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Sharavathi river (SB- SH- 19)in Honnavar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 99 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Shravathi river in Honnavar Taluk, 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB- SH-19 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 650m 150m 24.08 A/9.75 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 24.08 A 0.8 m 1,17,000m3

9. Whether permitted Yes activity as per CRZ Sand bars which obstructing the movement of Notification? If yes, fishing vessels may be removed specify the relevant rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of clearance is within the SCZMA. scope of SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Page 55 of 61

16.6.45 Proposal of removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Sharavathi river (SB- SH- 20) in Honnavar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District for issue of CRZ Clearance [File No. FEE 100 CRZ 2017)

1. Name of the Project Removal of Sand from Sand Bar of Shravathi river in Honnavar Taluk, 2. Name of the Applicant District Sand Monitoring Committee (CRZ), Uttara Kannada district. 3. Location of the Project SB- SH-20 Village/Town, Taluk, Dt. 4. R.S. No.s -

5. Extent of land Length Width Area Acre/Ha. 900m 120m 26.67 A/10.8 Ha.

6. CRZ Classification CRZ area 7. Project Cost - 8. Activities proposed Estimated Quantity of Removable Sand from Sand Bar

Area Depth Quantity 26.67 A 0.8 m 1,29,600m 3

9. Whether permitted Yes activity as per CRZ Sand bars which obstructing the movement of Notification? If yes, fishing vessels may be removed specify the relevant rules 10. The details of The proposals were cleared in District Sand recommendations of the Monitoring Committee meeting held on District Coastal Zone 07.01.2017 & DCZMC meeting held on Management Authority 28.01.2017. (DCZMA)

11. Any other details - 12. Whether issue of Issue of clearance is within the scope of clearance is within the SCZMA. scope of SCZMA or NCZMA? Specify relevant rules.

Before appraising the above sand bar removal proposals,the Member Secretary, brought to the notice of the Authority, Hon’ble NGT judgment in OA No. 111 of 2016 dated 27.02.2017.

Page 56 of 61

The 17 proposals for removing sand bars submitted by the District Sand Monitoring Committee has been placed before the Authority and it has been deliberated with respect to the observations made by the Hon’ble NGT in its order dated 27.02.2017 , and OM’s of the MoEF & CC dated 24.02.2011, 09.06.2011 and 08.11.2011. After the deliberation and discussion the Authority observed the following:-

1. Seven Member committee has not been constituted as per OM of MoEF & CC dated 08.11.2011, as provided in the OM, there should be two representatives one each from local civil society and local fishing community. 2. In the technical report submitted by the NITK, Surathkal, there was no mention about the actual presence of sand bars, depth at which sand bars are deposited and whether these sand bars are actually obstructing the fishing vessels or not. 3. In the technical report of NITK, ‘Kudrus’ which are naturally formed Islands have been proposed to be removed which is not allowed as per CRZ Notification, 2011.

In view of the above the Authority decided to inform the applicant accordingly and to get the revised proposals.

16.6.46 Appointment of Government Advocates to represent the State before various courts at Mangalore, Udupi & Karwar district with respect to violations cases:

The Members Secretary, brought to the notice of the Authority that number of violations cases are pending for want of Appointment of Government Advocates to represent the KSCZMA. Accordingly the opinion was sought form the Law Department and the Law Department has given opinion high lighting the provisions of the Karnataka Law Officers (Appointment of Conditions of Service) Rules, 1977, as follows:-

1. If the case pertaining to encroachment in CRZ area is a civil case, the administrative department may engage the services of the District Government Pleader/Addl. D.G.P.s as the case may be 2. If the case is a criminal case, the administrative department will have to engage the services of the Public Prosecutors and Assistant Public Prosecutors to represent the State in view of Sec. 24 & 25 of Cr.P.C.

Page 57 of 61

3. If the administrative department intends to engage the services of a Special Counsel, the same is governed by Rule 30 of Karnataka Law Officers (Appointment of Conditions of Service)Rules, 1977. 4. If the administrative department intends to appoint Special Counsel, then as per Rule 30 (2), the administrative department may consult the Hon’ble Advocate General if the appointment is in relation to a Civil Case and the Director of Prosecution if the appointment is in relation to a Criminal Case. 5. The Department can appoint Advocates for the above purpose by way of empanelment.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to instruct the concerned Regional Directors Mangalore, Udupi and Karwar to take action to send the Panel of Advocates for approval of the Panel for appointing the Advocates by the Authority.

It was also decided that the next meeting will be held on 05.04.2017 at Mangalore.

The meeting concluded with vote of thanks to the Chair.

Sd/- (P. Ravikumar) Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Forest, Ecology & Environment Department & Chairman, Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority.

(Vijay Kumar) Special Director (Technical Cell) & Member Secretary, KSCZMA Forest, Ecology and Environment Department.

No. FEE 255 CRZ 2016

Page 58 of 61

Meeting of the 16th Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority (KSCZMA) held on 18.03.2017 at 11.00 A.M. at Room No. 252, 2 nd Floor, 2 nd Gate, M. S. Building, Bengaluru under the chairmanship of Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Forest, Ecology & Environment Department.

LIST OF MEMBERS/OFFICERS PRESENT

1. Sri. P. Ravikumar, IAS., Chairman, KSCZMA & Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Present Department of Forest, Ecology & Environment, M S Building, Bangalore – 560 001 2. Principal Secretary to Government, Tourism Department, - Vikasa Soudha Bangalore. 3. Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Industries and Commerce Department, - Vikasa Soudha, Bangalore 4. Sri. Ramachandhra, IFS, Secretary to Govt. (Ecology & Environment) Present Forest, Ecology and Environment Department Bangalore- 560 001. 5. Sri. S.Shanthappa, IFS., Member Secretary, Karnataka State Pollution Control Board, Present No. 49, Parisara Bhavan, Church Street, Bangalore- 560 001. 6. Sri. Ramesha.C Project Development Officer, Environment Management and Policy Research Institute (EMPRI), Present Hasiru Bhavana', Doresanipalya Forest Campus, Vinayaka Nagara Circle, J. P. Nagar, 5th Phase, Bangalore-560 076. 7. Principal Secretary to Government, - Animal Husbandry and Fisheries Department.

Page 59 of 61

8. Sri. Ashoka Reddy, Director, Karnataka State Remote Sensing Application Centre, KSRSAC, BMTC-Central Office Building TTMC ‘B’ Present Block, 4 th Foor, Shanthinagar, KH Road, Bangalore – 560 027. 9. Dr. K.S. Jayappa, Professor, Department of Marina Geology, Mangalore Present University, Mangalore-575004. 10. Dr. Dwarakish G.S., Professor and Head, Department of Applied Mechanics and Hydraulics, Present National Institute of Technology, Karnataka, Suratkal, Manalore. 11. Dr. Jagannath L Rothod Associate Professr, Present Department of Studies in Marine Biology, Kodibag, Karwar. 12. Dr. Lakshmipathi M.T. Associate Professor , Aquatic Environment Management Department, Present College of Fisheries, Mangalore.

13. Sri Vijayakumar, IFS., Special Director (Technical Cell) and Secretary, Present Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority, Forest, Ecology and Environment Department. 14. Director, Directorate of Municipal Administration, Representative Bangalore 15. Shri. M. Dinesh Nayak, President, Sasyashyamala Vittal, Present Dakshina Kannada District.

Page 60 of 61

16. Sri. S.J. Chandra Shekar, Regional Director (Environment), Forest, Ecology & Environment Department, Present 1st Floor, C Block, Rajathadri, District Administrative Centre, Manipal- 576104, Udupi District. 17. Sri. Prasanna K. Patagar, Regional Director (Environment), Forest, Ecology & Environment Department, Present Meera Building, I Floor, Kajubagh, Karwar, Uttara Kannada District. 18. Dr. Dinesh Kumar Y.K. Regional Director (Environment), Forest, Ecology & Environment Department, Present Corporation Commercial Complex, I Floor, Lalbagh, Mangalore-575 003.

** *** **

Page 61 of 61