Efficient Compression of PMU Data in WAMS
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SMART GRID, SPECIAL ISSUE ON BIG DATA ANALYTICS FOR GRID MODERNIZATION Efficient Compression of PMU Data in WAMS Phani Harsha Gadde, Student Member, IEEE, Milan Biswal, Member, IEEE, Sukumar Brahma, Senior Member, IEEE, and Huiping Cao Abstract—Widespread placement and high data sampling rate Archived data can be used for purposes like model validation, of current generation of Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs) in testing new wide area protection and control applications Wide Area Monitoring Systems (WAMS) result in huge amount that use PMU data, or training/testing disturbance classifiers of data to be analyzed and stored, making efficient storage of such data a priority. This paper presents a generalized compression typically used in system visualization applications that are technique that utilizes the inherent correlation within PMU being commercialized. data by exploiting both spatial and temporal redundancies. A Clearly, compression methods are necessary to archive these two stage compression algorithm is proposed using Principal data. Such methods essentially seek to maximize the Com- Component Analysis in the first stage, and Discrete Cosine pression Ratio (CR), and minimize the loss of data, which is Transform in the second. Since compression parameters need to be adjusted to compress critical disturbance information with measured by certain error metrics. The parameters chosen for high fidelity, an automated but simple statistical change detection any compression technique heavily depend on the nature of the technique is proposed to identify disturbance data. Extensive data. In case of PMU data, most of the data will be relatively verifications are performed using field data as well as simulated constant or slow-varying with overriding noise, but in case of data to establish generality and superior performance of the a disturbance the data will vary. The speed and the nature of method. variation again depend on the type of a disturbance. Therefore, Index Terms—Data compression, phasor data concentrator, any compression technique chosen to compress PMU data with phasor measurement units, wide area monitoring systems. high fidelity should be able to detect a disturbance and change the compression parameters for efficiently compressing any I. INTRODUCTION disturbance data, and be robust enough not to be affected by noise in the data. Validation of any approach should S Wide area monitoring systems (WAMS) grow to mon- therefore encompass real world data, including disturbance itor large interconnected power systems, the number of A data corresponding to major power system disturbances. Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs) has also been growing A lossless compression approach with slack referenced rapidly. For example, in North America, after the initiation of encoding (SRE) is suggested for PMU data in [4], where the the Western Interconnection Synchrophasor Project (WISP), voltage data are compressed with a maximum CR of 10:12. the number of PMUs installed in the Western Electricity This approach is heavily biased towards fidelity at the expense Coordination Council (WECC) system has increased from 56 of CR, and is not comprehensively tested. In [6] authors have in 2005 to 584 till April 2015 [1], [2]. The WISP shares used wavelet packet transform (WPT) to compress the PMU operational data with 97 participants over a secured wide data resulting in a low CR of 2 with root mean square error area network spanning the entire Western Interconnection (RMSE) of 3:68×10−6. A comparative assessment of standard [2] and has over 77 Phasor Data Concentrators (PDCs). In compression algorithms has been presented in [7], where szip WISP, almost every PMU feeds data to a PDC. The detailed algorithm is used to achieve a CR of 2:77 for voltage data PMU datas-flow and interconnections in North America are and 3:77 for frequency data, which are low values. In [8] an mentioned in [3]. The rapid increase in the number of PMUs, embedded zerotree wavelet based denoising and compression higher sampling rate of the modern PMUs, and more stringent method is introduced, but it lacks proper analysis, and doesn’t criteria for system integrity violations are expected to result perform well for real PMU data. Recently, a dimensionality re- in several fold expansion in the already large volumes of duction algorithm has been proposed by Xie et. al. [9] for PMU PMU data. As pointed out in [4], 100 PMUs having 20 data utilizing principal component analysis (PCA) subspace measurements at 30 Hz sampling rate generate over 50 GB for detection of disturbances, but the issue of compression is of data in one day. Higher sampling rate of 60 Hz or 120 not adequately addressed. Another real time event detection Hz in modern PMUs will increase this data volume to 100 and data archival scheme has been proposed in [10], where GB or 200 GB respectively. This means even larger volume PCA is used for event detection, and least square curve fitting of PMU data will need to be stored in PDCs, or transmitted is used for compression. It reports a relatively better CR of to Super PDCs. The NERC PRC 002-2 [5] requires that the 63:3 for voltage data, but with a higher normalized RMSE actual recorded disturbance data be preserved for 10 calendar of 0:176 for steady state data. Moreover, the CR reduces to days. However, all PMU data are finally archived by utilities. 4 for the voltage data during a disturbance event. This paper P H. Gadde, M. Biswal, and S. M. Brahma are with the Klipsch School of does not consider current and frequency data which are also Electrical and Computer Engineering, and H. Cao is with Computer Science recorded by PMUs, and will have different variations during Department at New Mexico State Univesity, Las Cruces, NM, 88003, USA. disturbances. In addition, it uses data from PMUs in a campus (e-mail:fphgadde;milanb;sbrahma;[email protected]). This work was supported by the National Science Foundation, CREST microgrid, and hence their method is not tested extensively for Grant HRD-1345232. large scale data from transmission systems, which have quite IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SMART GRID, SPECIAL ISSUE ON BIG DATA ANALYTICS FOR GRID MODERNIZATION different disturbance patterns than a microgrid. The aim of s this paper is to propose a generalized method that works with PL (P (n) − P 0 (n))2 RMSE = n=1 i i ; (2) any number of PMUs and significantly improves the CR while L maintaining excellent fidelity, and show the robustness of the method on extensive data from field as well as from accurate 0 simulations. MADE = maxfj(Pi(n) − Pi (n))jg ; n = 1; 2; : : : L; (3) With the occurrence of a power system disturbance, mul- 0 where Pi(n) and Pi (n) are the original and reconstructed tiple PMUs at different geographical locations are triggered data samples, respectively, from the ith PMU, and L is the simultaneously, capturing various snapshots of the same event. length of the data sequence. Note that Higher CR and lower Therefore, it stands to reason that the parametric signatures errors mean higher quality compression. of all snapshots would be similar. Thus, correlation among multiple local PMU data streams at the PDC can be exploited PMU 1 PMU 2 PMU N for the compression of data. Exploiting this crucial property of PMU data, in this work we use PCA to minimize the spatial Detect disturbance by comparing incoming sample redundancy among data captured by multiple PMUs. We with moving average using thresholds for V, f, df/dt further reduce temporal redundancies in the data by applying Discrete Cosine Transform (DCT) and Discrete Wavelet Trans- NO Sample ≥ YES form (DWT) on the principal coefficients (PCs). A method to Threshold? choose adaptive window length is developed to attain efficient Fix Data window Monitor SV and compression for both, normal as well as disturbance data. We length W = 10s determine W finally apply a classical lossless data compression technique on the data that are already compressed using the above approach PCA to make the storage even more efficient. DCT/DWT II. METHODOLOGY PDC ARCHIVE DATA Let Pi(n) denote the measured voltage, frequency or current data sample expressed in per unit at time index n recorded th Fig. 1. Block Diagram of proposed PMU Data Compression Technique by the i PMU with a reporting rate of fs samples per sec (sps). Let there be N number of PMUs in a geographical region, connected to one PDC. The block diagram describing the proposed approach for compression is shown in Fig.1. A. Statistical Change Detection The proposed method implements Statistical Change Detection In order to preserve critical changes in PMU measurements (SCD) to detect and isolate disturbance data. This technique due to disturbances, a higher fidelity is needed. However, will be described in section II-A. If no disturbance is detected, in an automated environment, it is required to detect the a fixed data window W of 10 s is used. This value is based inception and duration of disturbances, so the fidelity can on studies presented in section II-B, which shows that the be enhanced for that period. A statistical change detection 10 s window provides a good combination of data-fidelity (SCD) algorithm is used for this purpose. Instead of using and CR for normal PMU data. If, however, a disturbance is the standard 10 s window length, a variable window length detected, continuously computed Statistical Variance (SV) is that envelops the full disturbance is used for compression of used to select an appropriate W, which is used to capture disturbance data. The NERC PRC 002 disturbance triggering the disturbance details with higher fidelity, although with criteria [5] recommends either of the following to detect a some reduction in CR.