7
Dev. Reprod. Vol. 14, No. 1, 7-11 (2010)
Germ Cell Aspiration (GCA) Method as a Non-fatal Technique for Sex Identification in Two Bivalves
(Gomphina veneriformis and Tegillaca granosa)
Jung Sick Lee1, Sun Mi Ju1, Ji Seon Park1, Young Guk Jin2, Yun Kyung Shin3 and Jung Jun Park4
1Dept. of Aqualife Medicine, Chonnam National University, Yeosu 550-749, Korea
2South Sea Fisheries Research Institute, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Yeosu 556-823, Korea 3Aquaculture Management Division, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Busan 619-705, Korea
4Pathology Division, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Busan 619-705, Korea
ABSTRACT : This study attempted to verify the possibility of using germ cell aspiration (GCA) method as a non-fatal technique in studying the life-history of equilateral venus, Gomphina veneriformis (Veneridae) and granular ark, Tegillarca granosa (Arcidae). Using twenty-six gauge 1/2" (12.7㎜) needle, GCA was carried out in equilateral venus through external ligament. In granular ark, GCA was performed by preventing closure of the shells by inserting a tongue depressor between the shells while still open. The success rate of sex identification using the GCA method was 95.6% for the equilateral venus (n=650/680) and 94.3% for the granular ark (n=707/750). Mortality of equilateral venus, which spent 33 days under wild conditions, was 13.8% (n=90/650) while the mortality of granular ark, which spent 390 days under wild conditions, was 2.4% (n=17/707). Although we believe that GCA does not appear to cause death in equilateral venus or granular ark, the success rate in employing of this methodology may differ depending on the level of proficiency of the researcher and reproductive stage of the bivalve. This study concludes that GCA is a convenient non-fatal methodology, which can be employed to identify sex and investigate gonadal maturity in Gomphina veneriformis and Tegillarca granosa.
Key words : Germ cell aspiration, Gomphina veneriformis, Tegillarca granosa, Sex identification, Gonadal maturity.
(Wright & Lindberg, 1979), Mytilus edulis (Jabbar &
Davies, 1987; Burton et al., 1996) and M ytilus galloprovincialis
- (Mikailov et al., 1995).
- Information on sex, gonadal maturity and spawning
periodicity are equally important in artificial seed production of these organisms. Reproductive history and sexual maturation of bivalves differ in accordance with various environmental factors, including water temperature (Eversole, 2001).
Sex identification and gonadal maturity of bivalves are, in general, have been assessed through histological and microscopic analysis. However, such methods cannot be applied without sacrificing the organism. Previous studies have attempted to investigate the possibility of sex determination without killing the organisms in patellacean gastropods
Equilateral venus, Gomphina veneriformis and granular ark, Tegillarca granosa were selected as the case-study species for this investigation. These are ecologically dominant bivalves in eastern and southern coastal waters of Korea, in addition to being economically valuable. This study attempted to verify the possibility of using germ cell aspiration (GCA) method as a non-fatal technique in studying the life-history and reproduction of bivalves.
1. Experimental Bivalves
Corresponding author: Jung Jun Park, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Pathology Division, 152-1 Haean-ro, Gijangeup, Gijang-gun, Busan 619-705, Korea. Tel: +82-51-720-2487, Fax: +82-51-720-2498, E-mail: [email protected]
Equilateral venus, Gomphina veneriformis (Bivalvia:
Veneridae) and granular ark, Tegillarca granosa (Bivalvia:
8
Lee JS, Ju SM, Park JS, Jin YG, Shin YK, Park JJ Dev. Reprod. Vol. 14, No. 1 (2010)
(Figs. 2G, H and 3G, H).
2. Syringe
Disposable syringes were employed in this experiment.
Two needle sizes were used; 29 gauge 1/2" (12.7 ㎜) (Becton Dickinson, U.S.A.) and 26 gauge 1/2" (12.7 ㎜) (Sung Shim Medical Co., Ltd., Korea). The size of the syringe needle was identified with considerations to clam size, inner diameter and length of the needle. Consequently, we identified that 29 gauge 1/2" (12.7 ㎜) needle was not appropriate for extraction of oocyte due to its narrow inner diameter. Accordingly, the 26 gauge 1/2" (12.7 ㎜) needle
Fig. 1. Sampling area of the experimental bivalves.
was used in most cases.
Arcidae) were used in the experiment. Equilateral venus was collected from the coastal region of Goseong on the eastern coast, while granular ark was collected from Jangsu Bay in Yeosu on the southern coast of Korea (Fig. 1). In relation to appropriate organism size and experimental timing the methodology of Park et al. (2003) and Lee (1997) were followed. Adults of 25.0-34.9 ㎜ in shell length were used (Figs. 2A, 3A), while experiments began in July to coincide with the ripe and spawning season
3. Germ Cell Aspiration
Equilateral venus, Gomphina veneriformis has a welldeveloped dorsal external ligament in the posterior portion of the umbo (Fig. 2B, C), which enables the needle to be inserted into the mantle cavity. Insert the syringe needle into the gonad of the visceral mass through the external ligament of the hinge line in a single thrust at an angle of approximately 45° (Fig. 2D). The shells of the granular ark, Tegillarca granosa are normally opened within the
Fig. 2. Equilateral venus, Gomphina veneriformis. (A) and (B) External morphology and external ligament (El). (C) Morphology of socket and teeth arrangement. (D) Syringe needle insertion through the external ligament. (E) Aspirated oocytes by syringe needle aspiration. (F) Aspirated spermatozoa by syringe needle aspiration. (G) Ovary of ripe stage. (H) Testis of ripe stage. Ct, cardinal tooth; Lt, lateral tooth; Oc, oocyte; S, socket; Sp, sperm.
9
- Dev. Reprod. Vol. 14, No. 1 (2010)
- Sex Identificatioin by Germ Cell Aspiration (GCA) Method in Bivalves
Fig. 3. Granular ark, Tegillarca granosa. (A) and (B) External morphology and external ligament (El). (C) Morphology of socket and teeth arrangement. (D) Syringe needle insertion through between shells. (E) Aspirated oocytes by syringe needle aspiration. (F) Aspirated spermatozoa by syringe needle aspiration. (G) Ovary of ripe stage. (H) Testis of ripe stage. Oc, oocyte; S, socket; Sp, sperm; Sr, syringe; T, tooth; Td, tongue depressor.
aquarium (Fig. 3A). Although the external ligament of the granular ark is explicit and located in the umbo (Fig. 3B), needle insertion is prohibited by teeth which are regularly arranged in clusters (Fig. 3C). Accordingly, insert the tongue depressor into the area near the boundary of the shell for the organisms with their shells opened in order to prevent the shell from closing. Insert the syringe needle into the gonad of the visceral mass through the opened shells with a single thrust (Fig. 3D). observed over 390 days (July 7, 2006-August 1, 2007). The disparity in the experimental period between the two species was as a result of damage to the equilateral venus cage brought on by heavy wave action, thus making further continuation impractical.
5. Histological Technique
For light microscopy, the tissues were fixed in aqueous
Bouin’s solution for 18 hours and rinsed in running water for 36 hours. The tissues were dehydrated in ascending grades of ethyl alcohols and then embedded in paraplast (McCormick, USA). Embedded tissues were transversely sectioned at 5 ㎛ thickness and routinely stained with Mayer's hematoxylin - 0.5% eosin.
4. Mortality
Experimental organisms were reared in an indoor plastic aquarium for 3 days, where the 500ℓ seawater capacity was adequately filtered, aerated and kept at a salinity of 32.5‰ and a temperature of 20.5℃. Subsequently, the rearing experiment was carried out under wild conditions close to the collection area of the organisms. A cage where the bivalves could be prevented from escaping was installed. The bottom of the cage was securely inserted into the sediment in order to allow the organisms to be able to burrow. Equilateral venus was reared for 33 days (August 20, 2006-September 22, 2006), while granular ark was
Morphological and anatomical terminologies of Stachowitsch
(1992) were used.
1. Success Rate of Sex Identification using Germ
Cell Aspiration (GCA) Method
The success rate of sex identification using the GCA
10
Lee JS, Ju SM, Park JS, Jin YG, Shin YK, Park JJ Dev. Reprod. Vol. 14, No. 1 (2010)
Table 1. Success rate of sex identification and mortality with GCA
- Sex identification
- Mortality
Species
Success rate
(n)
- No. of
- No. of
- Indoor
- Wild
- inactive stage
- spent stage
- aquarium
- condition
Gomphina veneriformis 95.6% (n=650/680) Tegillarca granosa 94.3% (n=707/750)
- 2
- 28
32
0% (n=0/650) 0% (n=0/707)
13.8% (n=90/650)
- 2.4% (n=17/707)
- 11
method was 95.6% for the equilateral venus (n=650/680) and 94.3% for the granular ark (n=707/750). Results of histological analysis of the 30 equilateral venus, for which sex identification was uncertain, revealed that 2 were in inactive reproductively while the remaining 28 were in the spent stage. Among the 43 granular ark for which sex identification was uncertain, 11 were inactive while the remaining 32 were spent reproductively (Table 1). was employed in this study as a possible alternative nonintrusive technique.
It is generally very difficult to identify sex in organisms for which sexual dimorphism is not definitive, without having to sacrifice the subject. Previous studies have attempted to investigate the possibility of sex identification in shelled molluscs without killing the organisms. Wright and & Lindberg (1979) verified the sex of patellacean gastropods by extracting germ cells through syringe insertion into the internal organs. For these gastropods, the abdominal portion gets exposed when detached from the substratum, thus making insertion of the syringe easier in comparison to bivalves. Furthermore, insertion locations for bivalves are complicated by their shape and consequent linkage of the hinge at the apex of the shell.
2. Mortality with GCA
In order to find out the effect of GCA on the death of these bivalves, experimental organisms were reared in an indoor plastic aquarium and wild condition.
Mortality for both species, after having been cultured for 3 days in the indoor aquarium, was 0%. Mortality of equilateral venus, which spent 33 days under wild conditions, was 13.8% (n=90/650) while the mortality of granular ark, which spent 390 days under wild conditions, was 2.4% (n=17/707) (Table 1).
The equilateral venus has a well-developed dorsal external ligament in the posterior portion of the umbo, on the basis of the right valve. The arrangement of teeth on the inner socket portion of apex of the shell is a heterodont type displaying definitive distinction between cardinal and lateral teeth. The external ligament covers the empty space between the rear portions of the lateral teeth, thus making it possible to insert the needle into the mantle cavity.
The external ligament of the granular ark is located in the umbo, and is wide and definitive. However, the arrangement of teeth on the inner socket portion of the external ligament is a taxodont type. With the regularly arranged teeth in clusters, insertion of the syringe needle is problematic. Accordingly, needle was inserted after having prevented closure of the shells by inserting a tongue depressor between the shells while still open.
Extraction of tissues from the internal organs while the organism is still alive, is very difficult, especially for molluscs such as gastropods or bivalves with thick exoskeleton. Currently, fine needle aspiration (FNA) is applied widely as a methodology in pathological diagnosis of human beings. However, there are technical difficulties and consequent cost-effectiveness issues associated with non-proficient researchers that maybe working with a large number of subjects. The germ cell aspiration (GCA) method using syringe
11
- Dev. Reprod. Vol. 14, No. 1 (2010)
- Sex Identificatioin by Germ Cell Aspiration (GCA) Method in Bivalves
Confirmation of oocyte in bivalves is relatively easier than sperm. However, if the oocyte is not detected, definitive identification of whether the extracted tissues are somatic cell debris or sperm becomes difficult. In such cases, confirmation of sex is possible through the addition of seawater, which allows sperm to display active mobility. Although confirmation of sperm is much easier under a phase contrast microscope, observation under a general microscope is also possible with a low light level.
No mortality was observed for organisms reared in the indoor aquarium for 3 days, illustrating that GCA method can be successfully applied to bivalves. There were also relatively low levels of mortality for equilateral venus (13.8%) and granular ark (2.4%), both of which were reared for 33 days and 390 days respectively under wild conditions, following the application of GCA.
Burton SA, Johnson GR, Davidson TJ (1996) Cytologic sexing of marine mussels (Mytilus edulis). J Shellfish Res 15:345-347.
Eversole AG (2001) Reproduction in Mercenaria mercenaria.
In: Kraeuter JN, Castagna M (eds.), Biology of the Hard Clam. Elsevier, New York, pp 221-260.
Jabbar A, Davies JI (1987) A simple and convenient biochemical method for sex identification in the marine mussel, Mytilus edulis L. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 107: 39-44.
Lee JH (1997) Studies on the gonadal development and gametogenesis of the granulated ark, Tegillarca granosa (Linne). Korean J Malacol 13:55-64.
Mikailov AT, Torrado M, Mendez J (1995) Sexual differentiation of reproductive tissue in bivalve molluscs: identification of male associated polypeptide in the
mantle of Mytilus galloprovincialis Lmk. Int J Dev
Biol 39:545-548.
The possibility that the 13.8% mortality for the equilateral venus and 2.4% for the granular ark were due to the GCA application cannot be ruled out. However, we are confident that even if this methodology was partially responsible, in addition to other environmental factors, to mortality, the relative high survival rates of studied bivalves make it an appropriate technique.
Park JJ, Lee JY, Lee JS, Chang YJ (2003) Gonadal development and gametogenic cycle of the equilateral venus, Gomphina veneriformis (Bivalvia: Veneridae). J
- Korean Fish Soc 36:352-357.
- Although the success rate of GCA method may differ
depending on the level of proficiency of the researcher and reproductive stage of the bivalves, it has been assessed, through this investigation, to be a convenient, practical, and non-fatal method of identifying sex, gonadal maturity and spawning periodicity of Gomphina veneriformis and
Tegillarca granosa.
Stachowitsch M (1992) Mollusca; Bivalvia (Lamellibranchia,
Pelycypoda). In: The Invertebrates; An Illustrated Glossary. Wiley-Liss Inc., New York, pp 227-237.
Wright WG, Lindberg DR (1979) A non-fatal method of sex determination for patellacean gastropods. J Mar Biol Assoc UK 59:803.
(received 15 January 2009, received in revised form 28 February 2010, accepted 2 March 2010)