Border Restrictions to Contain Covid-19
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BORDER RESTRICTIONS TO CONTAIN COVID-19 A review of international approaches Genevie Fernandes Mariana Soto Pacheco Prerna Krishan Sandhya Narayanan Diva Fanian COVID-19 POLICY SERIES GLOBAL HEALTH GOVERNANCE PROGRAMME 29 May 2020 2 A review of international approaches on border restrictions to contain COVID-19 Summary: On 29 May, the Guardiani reported that 12% or 2000 immigration staff at UK’s ports and airports were sick with COVID-19 symptoms between in the first three months of this year, with more than half absent before the lockdown was imposed. Between January and March, UK recorded 23.7 million arrivals by air, land and sea, including 18.1 million arrivals by air. In early March, UK also saw an influx of COVID-19 cases rising from 85 at the start of the month to 32276 by 31 March. Despite the rising number of cases and the high footfalls of incoming visitors, UK is one of the few countriesii that has not yet adopted any major border control measures. Although, since early March, if any passenger in a flight to the UK, declares symptoms, a general aircraft declaration (GAD) must be submitted to allow for a public health risk assessment and any required action to be taken before disembarkation,iii and in early April, British Airways grounded all its flights from Gatwick Airport, and Heathrow Airport suspended all flights from one runway. It was only on 22 May, that the UK government announced that starting from 8 June, inbound passengers entering the country will have to complete a contact locator form, undergo a 14 day self-isolation and face spot checks by authorities, along with a fine of £1000 upon breaching this mandatory measure.iv What have other countries done so far with respect to their international borders? We reviewed government advisories, updates from the international air transport association, and news reports, and summarise the international border control–related responses of 27 countries from across Europe, North America, Latin America, South Asia and East Asia. Except for Mexico, all the countries have closed their international air borders since March or early April. Most countries (21) have done so partially, still permitting nationals, residents and certain exempted individuals to enter, while 6 countries (4 in Latin America and 2 in South Asia) have completely suspended international flights. The two countries in South Asia with complete international border closures i.e. India and Pakistan, have started operating their own repatriation flights. International flights in most countries are set to resume in early June. Spain will resume international flights in July, while Venezuela and Argentina will resume international flights only in August and September respectively. Six countries have not yet announced dates for reopening borders for international flights. Except for Brazil, all countries have adopted a host of screening measures at their international airports and these include: (number of countries that have adopted a measure): o Thermal screening for temperature checks (6) o Screening passengers for any symptoms through the use of questionnaires or health declaration forms (10) o Mandatory completion of a health declaration form which indicates the health status of the passengers including presence or absence of symptoms (7) o Mandatory completion of a contact locator form that provides the passenger’s contact details in the event of contact tracing or checks on mandatory self-isolation (5) o Mandatory submission of health certificate prior to boarding and upon arrival the country. This certificate indicates that the passenger does not have any symptoms or has tested negative for COVID-19, and can be obtained from the Consular Offices or online (4 – Bangladesh, France, Nepal and Pakistan) 2 3 So far, we only found reports of mandatory testing for all incoming passengers at the international airport in South Korea. All passengers entering South Korea with no symptoms are tested in walk- through testing booths at the airport, while symptomatic passengers are escorted to a separate section of the airport for testing and further steps include hospitalisation or isolation in a government facility. Additionally, Pakistan has planned to test incoming passengers for COVID-19 as soon as possible on arrival at a quarantine facility. Except for Mexico, all countries require incoming passengers to isolate for 14-day period and seek health advice and care upon developing symptoms. We did not find any quarantine-related information for Sweden. Passengers entering Norway have to follow a 10-self isolation at home, while in Venezuela, passengers that are suspected to have COVID-19 have to quarantine for a 30- day period. Most countries require passengers to self-isolate at home; government facility is offered in case passengers do not have access to a local address. In Latin America, most of the countries require passengers to quarantine in hotels or facilities organised and paid for by the government. We found reports of fines imposed for breaching quarantine in Colombia and Italy (£360-£2700). Violating mandatory quarantines in Colombia and South Korea can also lead to imprisonment. Overall, most countries reviewed, have acted early in adopting border control and screening and isolation measures. East Asian countries in particular have extensive screening measures in place, including mandatory testing in South Korea, while Latin American countries have will reopen their international air border much later than their counterparts in Europe. While these international border control and screening measures are a critical response for pandemic control, we will also need to protect airport staff particularly those at higher risk of exposure, by providing adequate personal protective equipment, training, and organisational support. See table 1 for a snapshot of the international air border control measures taken by countries. Note for Table 1: A partial ban means that all travellers are prohibited from entering the country with the exception of nationals and residents and certain individuals that meet a criteria such as diplomats or nationals of a few selected countries. A complete ban implies prohibiting all individuals from entering the country. Screening measures at airports can include thermal scanning of all passenger for fever monitoring, completion of passenger contact locator form for future contact tracing if required, and screening of all passengers for symptoms. It is important to note that while many countries screen passengers for symptoms, in some cases, they do so proactively, and in most cases, this is done when a patient notifies authorities about their symptoms. Quarantine measures include a 14-day self-isolation for passengers at home or a government facility, and a fine on breaching the quarantine in some countries. See tables 2-6 for a detailed description on international and domestic border control measures in countries in East Asia, Europe, Latin America, North America and South Asia. 3 4 Table 1: A summary of air border control measures by countries Region Country International Screening at airports Quarantine for air flights passengers Europe Denmark Partial ban Screening of 14-day isolation at 13 March – 1 June passengers for home symptoms Germany Partial ban Passengers to 14-day isolation at 16 March – 15 complete a contact home June locator form Finland Partial ban Screening of 14-day isolation at 19 March – Until passengers for home further notice symptoms France Partial ban International travel 14-day isolation at 16 March – Until certificate before home further notice departure to France and sworn declaration of health status Italy Partial ban Screening of 14-day isolation at 16 March – 15 passengers for home/ June symptoms government facility and breach fine (£360-£2700) Norway Partial ban Screening of 10-day isolation at 15 March – 20 passengers for home August symptoms Spain Partial ban Passengers to 14-day isolation at 16 March – 1 July complete a contact home locator form Sweden Partial ban No info available No info available 18 March – 15 June North US Partial ban Screening of 14-day isolation at America 16 March – 1 July passengers for home symptoms Canada Partial ban Passengers to 14-day isolation at 18 March – 30 complete a contact home June locator form Latin Argentina Complete ban Passengers to 14-day isolation at America 27 March – 1 complete a contact hotel (cost borne September locator form by government) Brazil Partial ban No screening measures 7-day isolation, and 30 March – 28 May 14-day isolation on symptoms Chile Partial ban Passengers to 14-day isolation at 18 March – 30 complete a contact home/ hotel (cost June locator form and sworn borne by declaration of health government) status. Colombia Complete ban Screening of 14-day isolation at 23 March – 31 passengers for home and August symptoms fine/imprisonment on breaching isolation 4 5 Region Country International Screening at airports Quarantine for air flights passengers Latin Ecuador Partial ban Screening of 14-day isolation at America 15 March – 1 June passengers for government facility symptoms / hotel Mexico No restrictions Thermal scanning and No quarantine screening of measures passengers for symptoms Peru Complete ban Screening of 14-day isolation at 16 March – 30 passengers for hotel (cost borne June symptoms by government) Venezuela Complete ban Screening of 30-day isolation for 14 March – 12 passengers for suspected cases June symptoms South Bangladesh Partial ban Health certificate 14-day isolation at Asia 24 March – 15 obtained within 72 home June hours prior to arrival indicating COVID-19- free status Bhutan Partial ban No info available 21-day isolation at 30 March – Until facility / hotel (cost further notice borne by government) India Complete ban Screening of 14-day isolation at 23 March – Until passengers from government further notice repatriation flights for facility/hotel (cost symptoms and borne by individual) classification into high/mod/low risk. Nepal Partial ban Thermal screening, and 14-day isolation at 14 March – 14 submission of a swab home June test PCR health certificate issued a maximum of seven days before arrival to the country.