% 



94 : 12

% ".   

:  : $%& 

www.SID.ir 8!$ 

  

 @A  

?=

!"#

 

6!

"#$ /& !

  ! 



 5

/& !   

 07 

"#$

, -

 ? 4

VR A ; 

0

  , !   0"! 

  % $ -  

 0'

 

P.M.U.  , - 0 

 0B7 *+,



H !

 "!   "#$

4 % =

!  1-

-
! )   #!

( 3&4 "!  

94 :

9  

1

'  0   .

  

, - #$

 -. -.

   <

 DE4  -

()*+ 

Area Protection Protection Area

/4 $ 

   University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran



! 

     0

 

' .  0 G'

%&' ,$12 


Hamed Asadi, Majid Sanaye-Pasand, Mahdi Davarpanah Majid Mahdi Hamed Sanaye-Pasand, Asadi,

CI *+,

V   0"! 

-



School of Electrical & Computer Engineering, College of Engineering of College & Computer Electrical Engineering, of School  $  0 

    ;  /

"#$ ! - 



-

% $ ?  

Dynamic modeling, P.M.U., Dynamic load modeling, Transient voltage collapse, Longer term term Longer collapse, voltage Transient modeling, load Dynamic P.M.U., modeling, Dynamic  /& !

 !

 

2+, : 

-   of Power System Voltage Instability Based on Wide Wide on Based Instability Voltage System of Power



0, ! -

"
#$ Introducing a Novel Method for Real Time Estimation Estimation Time Real a Novel Method for Introducing   1 "! 

"#$

%&  real electric grid, Khorasan electric grid in North-East of Iran, is modeled by dynamic model of generators,of model dynamic by modeled is of North-East Iran, in grid Khorasan grid, electric real electric  6

Keywords: AVRs, governors, field current limiting systems and electric loads. The paper is continued by introducing a novel a introducing by continued is paper The loads. electric and systems limiting governors, current AVRs, field Khorasan on simulated is method Mentioned detection. instability voltage time real for VCI, called method, are analyzed. results and grid electric In this paper, the behavior of dynamic loads of a power system against voltage disturbances is investigated. Then Then investigated. is disturbances voltage against system a power of loads dynamic of behavior the paper, this In a Abstract "#$ voltage collapse, Real time voltage instability estimation instability voltage time Real collapse, voltage  2 ( 5

138

Archive of SID of Archive Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers – Vo1.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 Archive ofSID

&   

 A ]  KH" KH"        A C D   C <) <) @U-  <*U AD < ,  - ; 00

 !,

 W- ) ) < <* 

, F&

)

8%  KH" KH"

 h) <*,E

XH



q_ ,

 "

F ")

 5



 90 5 . . !H2n i4  ) )

K

)



) F& !/W !>) ? 11

<) -

1 . 86

J () C   

 ) 32

1>

 KH  .

K 

:  

)E ? ,E 1 9)

)  !

 U

O H

  A ?:) 32

!"#

40

 q_ ,

8 ,  4

Ir ,

 ) I/ X

D  KH O H 2 1 -

)

I6  4

1: 

70  ) > 1> J

)

P>

1> 00 1 # <)



P>



<*U



$E

)

 P> A

) ktW)  1  U !,;4 ! 1)

K

1

 1) KW

 ,

16

)



:

!*  KGD F&

i4  K

KH" KH" A  K! q

V" _

 O H O H

<8% KH"

!,;4 h) 

 )+, A

< u  

%&



 

< U/ KH" KH"

@%>   X? b,

A



 !-#a4 ! /

<*U  () 

1 <*U

 

F& 1 #

1> F

, J

W 

 )

  , 

 -

4 cNH

KH <U 7!

 H O H q_ ,

1

00 ?,

]2 

<

 F&

<) 32 !)E <, <*U

<

4

<*U

7

<)

!?, 2 00



AD cNH ! ) 



? C 1> 

<)  ,

 

, ?, @

KH" KH" .



?

"#$ 

<)  %>



) K

!*- 

9

!, 

 <) < ! A_-

!-)_ )

!

A

O H - 

0

.

7 <*U

K

!

F& ?, ?,

<*,E $U

K ) I

4

KJ <)



C -  I8   KJ ()

. V" _ 

!?,  U

? 1 )E L

<*U 3

<) q N

32 5:, ! /

)



. <) <*U

 H

!W&

A I ) ?, (/

1- <*U

?,

K Ir

IH

%N  <*U ! 5 @%>

.

:

!-)_ )

,

KH" KH"

  .  A) O  D 



A

!, . 

8 , < /?

  F& 

A !W& J I; I;

 1 K K  ktW)



!* <)

))

) A A !

10 !

 

2-  - - - -



A   K  >     cNH  1E 

)  g   ! ) C  A ) K )  f:) I#  A   W)

UN

 d   !4 ) O     U 1J ;)

)  1:

D  !"

]5[

.  ? 138 ) O H < ,

^_+- ]2 

K , f:)

 +)

 C    

<)

 < :

 <) I/ C <) 6 8 ) 

K 

0



%& :,

)

<

J F&

0- )

 /

O H

O H k-# <) i4

 <"

-# -

<)



)

X F

<

K>  < / F&  / A

""N-  <*U O H

*U

!"N ) J    <) <) .

N

!/4

1  1

3 "
#$

 <)

   ) 1: b,



@%> 1*  D  

@)

$7 



! U -

,  C  $   <) on-line

Z

 KW7

F

)  ! )

D  C 

. 5

 A <*U

! 

O H

1E !)

)      ! .

$6,

FUN

A

8 , 166_ 

) ) T&

 ) A . on-line

A B !*  ?  ) C

d



> b,

 2H

 5

.

 I"N-

<) )

() -  

< 

1)  > !  !,

  F

 <*U

]:H

1 #

,)  * ! PU- 1J

8 K/G

 ) <) !*-  ) H 36

]2.[



<) )

 

<*U 9 7 

XH

FUN )



<   

  h) <  <*U

) <) <)

) ?

8 , !

5 F&  / -



]

!,;4

]1[.

  & 

, F#a4 O H A- ]5.[

? .

78-  O H

 

F&

 OH f:) .  )  & K,E  < /+

]4.[ 

 ""N-

>j-

 A

  
 : 

1E 



*E @% A_-

E  D 

 C 



4

)

A) O !

 - /

^_+

@%>

  FD- @%>

$U -  )

 1E C 

 1E 36 ]3[ A < 9

)

 >

<)

,

K)

FUN <



K# <)



) F#a4  <)

F#a4



! GD 1E 

C`a#

V" _

1 K 

 U

K

!-)_

L  J  A) O

 XH   A*H A) O

<*U )  ! www.SID.ir

/ ?,

0-

 - 



?"J <) 

F& <)

? ! 6!
 

C  9)

) VW7

) 

];

 1-

) ? 

(/

A P !?B W  OH -

-



 0- 0-

.

D 

 C  ]7.[ !H !H



9:/ , $7

<  X? =

,E @U-

K  8 ,  +) 

I; <*U

  , C ,

E O H

  h)

) ) A A

   1-  ]6[

Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers - Vol.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 - - - ) <)

  3-

!

A

 ) & 0 ]; !"# P>

 

X? )  )

AW

<*U  

1U,  > 4 )E 1UJ -,O A 

<) )



?,



1 )-

w

00 9_

1> i)%

 KH b  X?Zj- )

4

K

K 1*

! . .

– C

-,O

 300 700 < /? A7  r ;) 85

1

) U,  )

.

<)

<*,E  2 2 | N

<*U

)

Cb - 6 5 9

!W&

 H  H  <) )+, <) ], ,

F#a4 www.SID.ir A7 <) W

 Factory 13.1 Factory K A) ) 8

 ,

K ]8.[ 9_ 5 

<) !

. 1

/& !

 H KH"

 . VR

F2

F2 :/ ! -,O

 I

<*U ) 2 5N- ? <*U

"#

60   -,O

<)

 b  . A 

 Fba



)

!* *H

!W& ))

!W& !

&  1 #

 8

2 <

)   )E )

00 1> @%>   -,O  H

 K

!W& .

800 KH 1- -,O w 1> <

K/G  00

1 F  ) –



<*U 1 1>

1-

!#, 3

!*,*

-,O



FWH%

-,O

.

<) 

8 ,  "!  !*-  ) b, -,O

 I I

<*U

2 ;) $6,

],



 P>

C:  C:

I

D 

.  U C:  C:  I8    !H8 ,

1 )-

 1E AD !

!,, D  ,O 8 F2

!

1)

  H- 

g*U ], 

A /? I6D-

<)

00 VR



H ! 85

 I ) "#$

,  8 , 3

 X   

w



A 

U . 6/ :/ <) P>

K A 

-  <*U X? >

 ?

x- -,O <" <"

  z)

A



.

 

 ) ,E 1-    ) H- XH

) K !J

1>

!"# A

. P>

F



 -D ,- )E )

!* 

 5z <  C 

<*U W ,?



P>

K

1> D  94 :

KH g/7

– . <*U

) z-

<*U z- F ")

W

00 1



 !)

 ,. 00 <)

3

!*   60

 1 )- -

EEE-DC1A 8 4

<)

H- I ?,

π 1



A-Z{

y z A  A) ) 8

 <*U  <%8, < 

Az X?

-,O

AD P  

2



!W&

C  F2 N <*U igsilent Power Power igsilent

    F )  385

 D  ) H 85  )     1 K KH" A  D F&   I

   D  - K

 )1(  ) <)

 %

) !

n 5 5

) 

) ) !,

N 

!,?

1 ) ! _H

A x   J < ,

i) Cb -

9 9 ( K# K# K#  9 9 K 

 !  -,O

5N-  

IH

FWH% ]9[ 1> 5 .

,  1E

5

 -

<)

kaL 

 

C

W !

      - . ) 1

Digsilent <%8, IEEE-G1  2  H ) 

I* 1

<)

y 

-

J

9:/  <)+

:xH

-A)

k

 H !J> ) )4(

! 9 9



( 8

 )

!8H

 ) ]; !/4



2 <) -

! C

 , ) O H 9:/ )

 

+ u

  /s

. F VR

 k )

r

 . J



 > D  

 +?  z

! 2 VR 2 A  (

.

R  <

 

XH )

<"

4

< ) O H 

<) A 3 !



A -

) !)    KUL

!8H  1+, C: 

-,O k 

 <)



 

. 1  D  i4 

!,E <

) I# <8&

A)-

A , XH

!  N   )

 !*,*  / <  )

1J A U, !



A 




!W&

KU ,  <* 

2H2 , Cb -

,  K )   )

4 ) 5

!, O H 1J

) NSI C50.13-1972 NSI

I*

1-

 )05.1(  1 .  :` 1E >

 <)

. 1J

N

<)



   

A /R A

)

. )2(

 - 

)

,- F#a4  I* <) 5N-

D 

X 

.

) 5N-

rated

 - 1- 1 Cb - 9 9 ! <,? AST O H



 -   

_)

<6_+

fd 5N-

:xH  5 K | |

 G

?

F  )

kaL IIkk 1+, 5N-  ) 

A x- ! ,.

!W&  H



2

) P

<)

  

 < <)

<,,



<) ]2.[   

-

05 J . !8H

K

K# -,O

8   - ) 1 

K 5N- KU ,

.

,

A 1J

 1- A

<U

1J

   . A 

  ]8.[  F A)- 2 ,

-  g6_+

i)%

!  ! −

* <) 0,.

1+,

VR <

-  

  A !WU4



)) I 

KUL 8

fd

A 

Fx- 

A)



)3( ? *

| |  O H  ,-

? - A)-



- A

"

8 K)Z  I 5N !

!*,*

< K

! N 

<) T 32 C

!, )4( "
#$ ( O H  +? .

 <,_) <,_)



> ) W    ) 

? K)Z

$-- 1J

<)







 -,O <) -;) <) ,  -

C

)

,



 )1( . 

!

K

]   K @)  %& )  ) A 

= :/

K)Z #

6  : U, W J b - 05   t :/ K XH - <) K <) <)

 4>  .  20  9 i)% <) 5 <  <)  <*U    1  5N- <)    1 C K

138

Archive of SID of Archive Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers – Vo1.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 Archive ofSID

.

    I  ) 30 < 1 <) C A 9 9 9 . 

 &   P1! *U +, R ? * ? 

 F&

 

 ! H S  <)   K -

!

 :, <) J

- 10 ) -

)

KH

/

<*U

70

/ 1E

 " C

A  2

  "#$

<*U -  20

7  O H

-  

k   I*

50 <)

() 00  -       O H

!

•- 





-

 9

-1 A)

)

 6 - 1- 1 !  -



 

5 6 10 <

<)

M .

/

77! 

O H

 f:) g") 0.

]  A)

77!   ""! ))  A  

,   <)

2"#



|*+,

   

€6> 7==

 /  ! O H 6-

-





C      -  

O H -

)  HP K)Z g%8,  )

k;W 

 !* *H



 <

!  / !

  +)

- 0,.  ,E

1 A / - !,

 !  $"%

9

1' u K - < !, )5( A /?

I  

,?

K  7 )

F&  *

k;W

.

8 ,

 I* A k <! 1

A

. *"# 

 

b, +  !   1-

, >

.   . ) k 



I  O H O H



]2.[ !

 2+E

1-  5-  

.

<*U 4-   ! / .   

8"$ K !

8"$

) I6  K/?   +)  +)

60 <*U KH

g%8, 0

! ! ! )  -

 <) z  <)  K & A

 +?  <*U K# ! )Z  138

- > 6

 %& A

7    



<6_+ 7    KH + u A .  

g%8, "
#$  < 1-  6

!  <  ) A

-

  1E -   A *n

 77!

 !

K# C:  C: 

U, . K#

9 

 . XH ) 

- 9!/  

!

 <) 

!

z

)

E

% =   H ! H

 +?

 < N

K  9 < /

+?   

n )

-

  

 5

 !

9 g6_+ .  8 <6_+

!

K , !,


 -

<! -

3- H !

O H

8 8"$ -



 m KUL 

 

= 1-

<)  +) < / www.SID.ir



2-   8"$

TP

-
    C 8"$ $ ω

ω D C

9   m



8

K & K & K#

K

g%) <%8,

 

)

Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers - Vol.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 <)  ) < :J

IU&

)  O H K)Z K C

<*U

I

J



A

K 4  +? C 

]10[

 <  FWH%

 H !*  !+/G P ! 

!,

 <)

8"$    

) <*,E  .;

O H K)Z ‚

D 

)

# 6-

F&

 

 H !*  5-

www.SID.ir K

,

? < ) )  1) !8D"- 4>

.

.



-

5  <"_-

!, <) 1- 

hUH  50

)

!* *H

O H  -

- 

!+? |N,

) ) .  

h K

.

A $  A  P- (  ) )

K)Z )

<) k;W K !?B A

 ! 

!

g6_+

g*U



! W 

|*+, O H  1> ! ,.



E



) 



G' K "/ - !*-  1E

) !+ <a>

 GD - - O H )

- 

)

5 FWH%  < /? 

B_



1>



],

!

!8D"- 

!   ) !

<)

60 !  .

> g*U 9_)  9_)

 -

 9 9 

?

]H () ,-

FWH% , A

 :/

K

5-  , ]2.[ <)  H # K •

 . 

!8H

- .  @) 1>  12

!*- 

KJ

 

 + 

<) J  <) 



5-  -

C

)   . 

)  !# ! /

!8H @A

!8D"-

C#

  

4 



?  P

! )  B7 #



 H O H

 

 

:J P





<- !

,)

!

I  1E ,. - ! ,.

. ) " _

!*-  )  ,- 2+E XH  V6, <  V  A -    0   <) z A B  h)  ) K ,

  4- 5-   V 5 .

1- ) O H O H Initial <U <U  ) P-V I

A ƒ7- n

P ! N 

IU&

+ u "#$ "#$

! / <)

liabad-400

A F+ u  nehbandan tabas azadvar istgah ghaenat-400 a kohsangi   A W) 8"$

<*U <*U

;)

) 

 #$

7- 

O H

<*U

IH

<) <

1  ")

 ! / <) )1(-

i)% 



 > $"%
 2 

   +)  / 

 94 : 94 :

 F O H !*  ! ) U* /4

/4 2 

+ u

 ,

 FUN 0 ];

J 

 , g

 

A J

 

! 

! C

 : 522 2

)1(

) 0,. . <*U O H

K P /

 +) ! N 

!4 O H <%8,

! 

? | 
 <)

.

)



! N 

F;W

5-  K)Z 1

X? . 

  < )



! W  

 ")     5-      

1>

 - W) ],



1

W4 - <) I*

Time (Sec.) Time

]11.[ )

F,,

<)

 ) A )6( "* 





f:)

W) - <%8,

O H 1 F <*U  

! N   )7( 



1-

K  

)

94 : 2 )

 I ,D C  ? 

# g

1

 F,,

 -

 

Initial

0. K)Z ? C:  G' 2  E .

P

)8( 511  ! <,Z

1> . I)&

) K - ? )

 .



 

 !/ , <*U



1- .

V+

!* 

], W

-

 1

<*U <)

!

, ! g <)

< C

1+,

"
#$ 1,

 )

) O H  +  i4   H

$



0,

  <"/a) ) )

%

]#

!H8 , !*  !





I 1 ! . 00

q_ ,

  K <%8, ! N  1 0 K . !*- 

%&



!>)

0 1.2 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 #

.

6  ) 

 )) 1- B otg (p.u.) Voltage 

 )   2 A  N    1 . 1*   P-  . C     !  C 1E

138

Archive of SID of Archive Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers – Vo1.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007

Archive ofSID

Voltage (p.u.)

1 0 0.85 0 0.65

Reactive Power (MVAR) .9

 1 100 200 3 400 500 6 <) ff- 00 00 ? 

0 0010 0020 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 0



5:,  

1J !,

I)&

0 0010 0020 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0

, !     F 5 1-

 V

)  UN >

-Q

< ,

1E

<`

!W& ?

9:/ 8

 

KH  H k a ghaenat-400 istgah azadvar t n abas i"%

O H ohsangi

liabad-400 ehbandan

<    N 

   

h) *U

 2H

Reactive Limitation Power

94 : ) O H

 D  +) !"N off-line



8    

Time (Sec.)

)  - C  ,

<

 



   <) / "#$

]12[  1- 94 :

< /? 

 J 5:, Time (Sec.) Time

1)

<*U ) <`

KH < ]12[

!*- 

7  , ! KW7

J  W4 ? 8

!W&

1:





K -

 <)+ A

) &  <

 , 

<*U

)

/ 7

O H <8

O H



: !2H !/W  !J- =

 

A h . AW- ) ! /

 , )

9 7

 

 .   .

 ) ) V &

I)&

<

tousS shirvanG neishaburG neishaburSG mashhadS1 mashhadG1 ghaenG shariatiG6 shariatiG2

) ) CPI !,

 <`

! 10-

 W  !  1 B <%8,

9-

A_- 8"$ A_-



Line . 8"$ F& < /? !>) <*U

W K D 

 6-

Voltage (p.u.)

 Voltage (p.u.)

0.65 0.75 0.85 0.95 1.05 1 I 

  !  | 1 KH" 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.2 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9   ) 0 1  >  * 1 -,O . !>)

138 0123456789 43 C 0 0010 0020 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0

. …>  < K

C

  <*U 2 , ! 8&  6

 %

%&  ,

$ <*U ! <*U O H

-,O ,

00

   ? <)



/4 !>) V+

kohsangi aliabad-400 ghaenat-400 istgah azadvar tabas nehbandan  I6  1 ) "
#$

O H

 32      )9(

K,

- F&   I ! W



 

H- 

* )E -D ,- 1  

 !

94 : . !* 

! W $7  ? !"# 1-

.

<*U

-



?,    1 4 94 : <,Z

Time (Sec.) Time

Tiem (Sec.) Tiem h)

1 ! W4

„D

! 1)

 ? <,Z

30

1- O H

_)

•- - W4

< N

)9(   )  &

/ I ?,



I I 

* :




) IH

 .

)10( <8&  )

/

 

I*

<8&

30 :

 ! /

.  

9:/

<) K  -,O 

-

!

45  1E 20 Z  www.SID.ir

20   aliabad400 t nehbandan istgah azadvar istgah kohsangi g 41

abas 2

haenat-400 ^_+ <*U

8-

 O 1+, - )  H

Z

< n

8"$ 1:

D 1

20 ]J



9- < !%  )  .

8"$

<8& <*U !

? K)- K  <) C ,

 

  )10(

Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers - Vol.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 … q  7- ( ? ! (

VH ,E b, #



, K / -;)

  : W  W ( !) J J 

0.

K ,

  , K  > C 8- I7D-

G

)



]5[ ]6[

   1E  )

4  W- 

CI



I)&  . )   1E   .

1: !7

!?:) P>

 )

V

. 

,E

SI

•, )  1B

C6- K  A 1 2

  !   KH

!,

<) V D

W www.SID.ir W O H

! 

 @%>

K

 ) 

< x- : -

   )

<,



KU ,



 ) )) C SI



 = A K  D-

VW- ) . DC    5 1-

? <)

V



K  )

   

S %>

 !4U- W *U

,

) A_- …> …>

)



< < I7



  E  <%8, 

f:) KU , / .

)

P> !H

A)

I"N- <*  O H 8 P> ) P>

) A,- _ ,  KH

 <) <

G  A

<

, ! GD

)   q

KH O H 00 < A

00  

!/W

/



4

!/W 4

8 , D  

 5 

#

!, 

))

)

! /  f:)



O H

 <)

 F,, !U--

<) 

O H

I*+

O H

   !,  ,

<%8, 





A *:, D , < ) 

< 1J O H Z <*U J

<)  KH" KH" )

<  1-

< 1:

1U,

<%8,

<)

 cNH

 <) A

 VW7

O H ) 36 W A

1U,



h)

K < K

E

P- ) . ) ! H  IN )+, F& )+,

! /

W

 / # 



C

<*U )

1- A n ?, IN <

> A- - - A,-

,J  $"u )

A <)

q_ ,

1 1E &

< *,

?,

.   !

.  

O H <) J 

VCI KH

<)

n h- h- P>

 h) !

]5[ ) K

<, F#a4 

h)



 >j- 

<*U )  .

b, O H

 -

  F 1E [ 7+ A  



Z

FUN

%> ! W

     <) 

 

<)

F

 ) ! )

 

8

x- 1) K I*+

A_-

 "# <*U #$    *n  *n

.

<, <, -)_ 1  n

#

UN )   

!

,  ) !   A 1-   KN < ]2  !>) A  I7D- <*U   A cNH - < K  F <) O H 1-

!H8 , 2

/4 346 351

F 22 41 (  

P> -

 

1E  % $

A

O H O H 

 W- ) 

KH <,

?  

 !/W I*+ < /? A

 , 

*"#

 

) |  

^_+ )

 -,O

  1-

FUN 1B < 8 < 

A *:,

!/ H8

<*U

) I"N-

)

!H8 ,

!

!,

) <  2



C

 ) 8 < >  

 !, F,* (



)

&

! h)

? 2    P> off-line

:  

"#$ OH -   )

<` !, )

) C  ,

.

I"N- !



,E

d

 n  <*U :, 

?  

) ^_+- & 



< /?



!, A *:,



 ") Z{

<)+ 

<, .

< <) +,

<) ) ?

4 : 

1E

 !-)_

8&

 

A 1 * F

!U  . - 

9 <





…> K I/ < ]; 

<, .

!) K 

F 5

)

1>

)

KW7 !

. 

U,

V" _

<) .

<,  O H <) 56/7 95/7 , )

P>   
 <

b,

!  ? )

1E

) ) 9:/ O H ) b,

J <*U



)

<*U

  

 r



K

) ]1.[

I"N-  - <

: 

A

. 



)  

<` IU& 1-  K/?

(

A_- J .

O H

C/  z)

A ,E K 

 A*

)

<, 

 1*

],  O H 

 

]14[

<   F <*U  <` ) ) . !>)

A*H

!z ?

 h)

 N 

K

X - 5n

A*H

!

_)

P>    Fb - K !U 

<) 

 !,N) 

ƒ%

<*U

 O H

 <) O H -V 9 L !

? P>

8 ,

 ! z,- <  < 1E P

) )5-1( J &

1>

W) 68/0 47/3 

) 1 n

) 1E 



. 

<*U 1 #



 

6- 1-

K>    K ]5[ -

=

!, ^_+ !

!  +

 

<, (

:  < /  !*-   A  < /? "
#$  <

F#a4 I

D 

I"N-

<,   …>

,- <  J

)5-2(



> z-  )

f:) i&  n

1* ,

, 

‡

Az *:,

<) . .   ! 5n 5n h) 1E

)

]

U, <)

.  , <*U O H

%&



!* f:)

. J 6 kW%& / 

U

, ,  <8& )   <  <) :  5-  !,  <U A

A   IH ]   <) z  hz)

138

Archive of SID of Archive Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers – Vo1.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 Archive ofSID

< <,, <,  !  F ) 50   F I <) ) < /? ! 1 <   < F

i <)

F#a4  

 U ,Z



 !-)_ * )% -)_   O H

< @)  KU , #

^ _

)13(   )  a4 1+,



V

!" 

I

A 5  ") A



 

 b,

 ,-  <U ) :  <,, CI *

/

50 1

<)

<*U

.

)

PN P.M.U.  

 <) A



1+, 

K <,  , 50 C 8-

PN  !H

I"N-

.

! O H 1E .  <) A

K )  

<,

<*U  <

)E < 





O H

 h) <)+

<, , <,



<)

)

0 6



)

K# < < A ! / K

! •, 

‹ , !"#

!

H8

<) ,

) O H  ) ! / h) J 5 1E <,,

1>

 off-line 1+,    > 

A

< /? 

?

KH" KH" <  r



<) <,,

 6

7 !, <) / & 1>  !,  

J



•,

h) A /?

K <,, ) )

< ) V  

<) )  

<*U

CI

F#a4

h) <,,

. 

.  cNH : 

K <

!- I*

V" _

];

h) ! )

) KH !-

<,?  <)

4 . K# .  <*U <)

b, <,,

A

 00 C 

$"%

8 O H

.

<*U 

.  . 10    b ,

85

<)

 C 

)

O H A

,

< /?

J ;)

  h)

8 , 

1E

!, )

  !

 9

!,  

/ 

94 :

< /?  A )

i)%

)6-1(   h) ,-



!-)_ 

/ 

)

9_)

/4 V

1>

 )  1> & b, )

J  K 

 >

6 < )

 8 ,

V CI

 A )

. . 

 )

A-

b,

! K

<,Z  < /?

F 8 , CI

F#a4

 2   ! U+ ! 

h)



 C 8-

C 2H 

‹ ,

<,

&



;) 



<,Z



1+,  . <*U . h)  

 & <*U "#$ 1+, A

K K# 1 <, !

 / #$ 1

<,, < C>

)E <) A

], -

!

h) !,

.

 )14( !" 1+, 

  A  <,Z O H <,Z .

, K



<, 1 <)

!"# I

Fn"/ I* I >j- 



•, )

) )14(

)11( = )12( J  @)

)15(  FD-

.

<, 

)

Š/ I* I* I* I*

!" !" / 4 500 O H O H  ) ) C < *,   h) 

( ?

  7-1- q <)

.

] ) 1E   5:, A

I/ F#a4  9   F A F#a4 < A  VCI  V & , . , 8 ,   W-  <,Z  SB,k,i  )

138 O H <)

 <) ) <,

> <,

< ) <,

 1E

5:,

;) 6 .  <)

! 5  

%& ,

V !" ik J  <

 

 - <



1- Z CI

= 

 

F

#   K#

   O H  50

! 

"
#$

h)

<"

  : 

J <,

 n

<) : 

  ,

]2 

ik



<, - 

<) <8& < 1E 8 ,  V

<8& 

O H  − 

 ,, K A B



1n



<8& <)

|)

VV A:2J



, <)  ! h) W1 ik 

]

)



!,N) ]?

]

 , <) 5 Bk -;) i  A* -

 n  h) i 

<"

<

< , ) V" _ . -  n iS FUN < ,

 ) , C kaL  



A

<"/

A !,N) < *, K

>j- KH

> |  h) <,

<,Z I/ A

 ! 

<) <) ^_+-

  V !, /

.

A

5:,

&

-

CI

 A- )  A 

!" A   



h) ]

!"# 

.

 !-)_ . /

<)

) ) W

 ) )  
 h) VW7  

:4  :



W  h) 50 

P

A- J .

<,, >



h) K/?

A



(/ A *:, < ˆ + 



FN7-

F#a4 J F

I"N-

<,

! O H ,- !-)_  )

)

 N



K 4  . ,N  A :



, !"#

11- b,  ? 5n www.SID.ir



h) /

<*U ! V

8"$ )


 ) <, <*,E A

$ 



 XH  CI



ka O H

 <) ! <) %N . 

5



  k,i

 ?



V  4 <)

W)

?

 n

$-- !,



k,i

<,

) 8 ( .

VH

! ! !

 -   <  

 ) )  )2(

Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers - Vol.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 ) 2  <) <)

  8-

<

  

& 0

<) O H O H 0

<

I*

 <, K: A 

<)

h !, !,

A  !,-

4 2

 

H *"# *"#  )16( E

1> F,, IH

K/+ FWH%

<

<

) ) 

K+ ,

1E   A  2H

,

CI

K A ,N)

E) Fx-  <U .

!"

f:)

,E K V I*+ >



 <*U  <

\

1E

)

. !

!>) <"

www.SID.ir <*U h) <  <,

D   :,  

I)& 

V" _   J

!

<`

F&

 b, , 

A7 > 1:/

5 5

I*+



 



 !>)

ˆ 

E -

< ?

) 1E

A X? ! !  K& ! '

A

.

1+, O H <*U A 

  , 1:

5:, ) 

!* <) P #

O H

<, !)

  ) . +

)

) 

! I"N-  

! GD





K )

 <)

A    . ;)



.

 K4D 

K 

X? F  F,,

!>)

K   / <*U

)

K  + 

1E

 8 , <)



<U !)

5 



F,, 

<*U <,,

*"#

<

   <*U 1-



<*U

 

A_- n

 ") CI <)

 H )

O H )  1-

(/ K

<)

 PN .  > V  

1-  , 5 5 =

<U

1+,

! GD   )

! K>   ?"J Cb -

 /

!*

1E

< F

 1>



 - 0   

J X?  , ]2 

<,

! K/? 1





!*  ) CI !*  KW7

. D  ],

)  <`  

) !-)_

)

A_- !,  <*U

V

KW7 

6 

A ) .

 ,- kaL ,   <) <*U

< >

F&

*"# X? 

.

A & <*U W

<*U <  E < /?

 

!,

?

,  ,  2H



< 8 !,

 . P ) 

= !,N)

)

 <*U

<) CI

O H )

]2 



. F&

 

O H

<)



<, V 

O H !>) 

)  1*

C

/ KN-   1> 

10  

<,?

J

f:)

0. O H < 

! GD A CI _-   n  ,Z *U   < O H *"# )   !/W ) ?"J  < Zj-   1 A V  , A ))   O H <*U <) > F; <

 

] ! ]

10 [  F&

2+,

)


 1-

7N

  !)

 D  83.






Voltage-Stability Voltage-Stability  *H  

-

,“ ć  !B,4 3X

“ ) D. Novosel,D. M. M. Saha, “Use  “ , -

ć CIGRE Task Force 38-02-10, Force Task CIGRE 1 M. Begovi

 H  !

  <,

-

ć, sevi I !*  "
#$

 !  ! 

%& 6    

[11]IEEE/PES, Power System Stability Subcommittee Subcommittee Stability System Power [11]IEEE/PES, Assessment: Stability “Voltage Publication, Special Concepts, Practices and Tools,” August 2002. [12]M.S.Sachdev, Technique “A for Real Time Detection of VoltageCollapse Power in System” 2004, DPSP, Netherland. [13]I. Musirin, Rahman, T.A. “On-Line voltage voltage fast using ranking contingency based stability and Transmission IEEE/PES (FVSI),” index stability October 1118-1123, pp. 2, vol. Conference, Distribution 2002. [14]M. Larsson, Rehtanz C. J. and Bertsch, “Real Transmission of Assessment Stability Voltage Time Systems, PowerPlants Power and Corridors, “,IFAC 2003. 9] ”Modeling of of ”Modeling [9] 1993 Phenomena,” Dynamic Including Collapse Voltage of Local Measurements to Estimate Voltage-Stability Voltage-Stability to Estimate Measurements Local of Vol. System, Power on Transaction in IEEE Margin,” 1999. August 1029-1034, pp 3, No. 14, software, 13.1 DIgSILENT of Guide [8]User's DIgSILENT company, German Protectionand Controlusing Wide-Area a Network of Phasor Measurements” IEEE TransactionPoweron 2003. Feb. 121-126, pp. No.1, 18, Vol. Systems, [7] K.Vu,M. Begovi [4] S. Larsson and E. Ek, “TheBlackout in Southern Southern in “TheBlackout Ek, E. and Larsson S. [4] Sweden and Eastern Denmark, September 23, 2003,” in Proc.PES IEEE General Meeting, Denver, CO, 2004. [5] Vrbic G. and Gubina,“ New A Concept of Voltage-Collapse Protection Based on Local Phasors,” 2, No. Vol. 19, Delivery, Power on Transactions IEEE 2004 April, 576-581, pp. Mil B. [6] [1] P. Kundur, Power System Stability and Control. New York: York: New and Control. Stability System Power P. Kundur, [1] 1994. McGraw-Hill, Voltage[2] StabilityNew C. W. System Taylor, Power 1994 McGraw-Hill, York: [3] U.S.-CanadaPower System Outage Task Force. in Blackout 2003 14, August the on Report Final (2004) the United States and Canada: Cause Recommendations. http://www.nerc.com Available: [Online].

138

Archive of SID of Archive Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers – Vo1.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 Archive ofSID

VCI  0.5 1.5 2.5 VCI 0.5 1.5 2.5 1 0.5 1.5 VCI2.5 3.5  0 1 2 0 1 2

1 2 3 4 0 % 0 0 %$ 

$ , ! 0 .2

@A @A 1

? 500 0

.4

12

12    2 0 .6 1000 V V+

3 V+ 0 .8 + Time(Sec.) Time(Sec.) Time(Sec.)

 

1500  1 4

V V

V CI CI CI 1 .2

5

2000 /4 /4 /4 1 .4

#$ #$

#$ 6 1 .6

2500

16- 15- Area6 Area5 Area4 Area3 Area2 Area1 14- 7 8"$ 1.8 8"$ 8"$ Area6 Area5 Area4 Area3 Area2 Area1 Area6 A Area4 Area3 Area2 Area1 rea5 3000 2 8

V CI 138 6  %& 

  "
#$

 V

-

+ CI 

 ! 3 7

6  -  94 :

,.7?



- "#$  


 13-

 8"$



3&6  www.SID.ir




12-

 8"$

 

Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers - Vol.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007 5  / nit 7 U

D

(MW) (MW)

 www.SID.ir Reactive Load easurement easurement M hasor 25 67 90 P 150 105 230 120 170 17.2 58.2 29.1 9.26 5.29 17.2 17.2 29.1 5.29 18 15 40 : 27.78 74.07 13.35 44.97 60.84 39.68 37.04 31.74 51.59 42.33 21.16 19.84 14.55 130 20 0 90 118 (MW) (MW) 3.97 26.45 6.61 4.48 2.56 7.94 8.33 13.23 2.56 9.26 14.55 4.092 26.45 30.42 19.21 13.23 7.94 13.23 3.97 0 9.605 2.65 Active Load PMU 1

attar sahel toosG toosG pardis tous63 tous63

shirvan fldkhsn

sarakhs beihagh bardskn feizabad sltnabad ghuchan sangbast golshahr

rashtkhr kashmar golbahar mehrgan nmyshgh mashhad abousaed gholaman dolatabad shariati63 salehabad

khajerabi6

neishabour

kohsangi63

trbathydarieh

� � Area Bus Name Bus

 



4.48 (MW) (MW)

  Reactive Load

 




  - 20

9.26 6.61 6.61 29.1 3.97 9.26 8.07 17.2 7.94 9.26 0 37.04 18.52 64.81 10.58 30.42 10.76 13.23 13.23 46.29 18.28 22.49 46.29 37.04 21.16 23.81 13.23 18.52 42.33 64.81 37.04 (MW) (MW)

2.65 2.65 9.26 1.92 6.12 2.65 6.61 0 3.97 17.2 7.94 13.23 3.97 7.94 0 2.64 3.97 11.9 6.26 1.32 18.52 13.24 6.61 2.65 2.65 2.65 17.2 11.9 10.58 

Active Load  -  !

  -

khaf solat ghazi tabas tabas sedeh ghaen jlgrkh jlgrkh ferdos taybad taybad jajarm jajarm dargaz bjnurd sangan

birjand

trbtjam trbtjam sabzvar sarayan

fariman fariman simnbjn istghazd sarbishe

gonabad dashtjvn

hajiabad "
#$ sahlabad

mchnelec davarzan bushruye

asadabad

kheirabad



nehbandan

%& 6 � � � � Area 138 Bus Name Bus

Archive of SID of Archive Journal of Iranian Association of Electrical and Electronics Engineers – Vo1.4- No.2- Fall and Winter 2007