Design of Movable Weirs and Storm Surge Barriers
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
InCom Working Group 26 Design of Movable Weirs and Storm Surge Barriers ----- Final Report Version 6.7 1st August 2005 Design of Movable Weirs and Storm Surge Barriers – WG26 –PIANC p. 2 SUMMARY The PIANC InCom-WG26 (Working Group) performed a - Interactions between the technical aspects of a comprehensive review (state-of-the-art) of the modern weir/barrier design with environmental and aesthetic technologies, design tools, and recent researches used to considerations (Section 5.7) design and build structures controlling water level and flow in rivers, waterways, and ports (for navigation and flood - Procedure to assess the global construction cost of a protection). weir at the design stage (Section 5.8) - Design assessment tools for preliminary and detailed The WG considered regulatory structures of river control design stages (Section 6 and Annex A) weirs and storm surge barriers, focussing on the gate design. This includes: - Prefabrication techniques (Section 7) - Gates controlling water level and flow in rivers (even - Codes, rules and standards: at national and international those not navigable) and waterways (lifting gate, tilting level; including the use of the semi-probabilistic gate, radial gate, sector, etc.; designed in one piece or Eurocode format (Section 8) with an upper flap). These are MOVABLE WEIRS. - An extensive list of relevant technical books, web sites, - Gates controlling water level and flow in estuaries with and guidelines (Section 10). regard to high tides and storms (lifting gate, articulated, tilting, rolling, floating, sliding, etc.). These are flood BARRIERS. The present hardcopy WG-26 report is a reduced version of the full report, which is available on the companion CD- The WG Report focuses on the following aspects: ROM, attached to this PIANC hardcopy report (Directory /A2- REPORT WG-26 (Extended Version)/. - List of the recent movable weir and barrier projects (see Project Reviews), presentation of their concepts and The CD includes innovations, and the driving forces considered for selecting these particular designs (Section 2.1). - About 50 Project Reviews of movable weirs and storm surge barriers with various flat, radial, lifting, sector, - A terminology review of the technical terms and names and inflatable gates (Directory A1 on CD) used to define weirs and barriers (Section 2.2) - A PDF Copy of this Report (Directory A2 on CD) - Design Procedure for the design of weirs and barriers - Sponsor Company References (Directory A3 on CD) (Section 3). - Various additional information about Sections 3; 4; 5; - A review of the various multi-criteria assessment 6; 7 and 8 of this report (Directory Annex Section # on approaches that can be used to select the most relevant the CD) designs (Section 4). List of criteria for weirs and - Various technical guidelines (Directories B on CD) barriers, are proposed. such as - Technical considerations including environmental, o B1: PIANC’s “Illustrated Technical Dictionary” economic and safety aspects, for design, construction, (Locks, Gates, Dewatering services and Protection maintenance and operation (Section 5). from Ship Impact). o B2: “Design of Mobile and Marine Metallic - Structural considerations on various gate-types with an Structures using the Limit States and Partial Safety advantage-disadvantage comparison (Section 5.1). Factor Concepts” (France) & “ROSA 2000: - Technical background required to perform hydraulic Guidelines for the limit state design of harbour and and flow analysis of various gate-types (Section 5.2) waterways structures” o B3: Movable Weirs (Guide du chef de projet) - Interaction between foundation and weir-barrier o B4: Inflatable Weirs (Germany) structure (Section 5.3). o B5: Maintenance bulkhead types and Temporary - Control procedures of the gate operations and their and Demountable Flood Protection. Some maintenance (Section 5.4) technical reports are also given. o B6: Examples of rehabilitation Weirs - Survey of the temporary closure systems (e.g. o B7: Flood Protection in UK, bulkheads) used for inspection and maintenance o B8: Environmentally Considerate Lubricants (Section 5.5). - State-of-the-art of the risk-based design methods. With - WG26’s Meeting Pictures, Directory C on the CD applications to navigation weirs and flood barriers (Section 5.6) 5 Final Report, Working Group 26: Mobile Weirs, August 2005 (Version 6.7) Design of Movable Weirs and Storm Surge Barriers – WG26 –PIANC p. 3 DESIGN OF MOVABLE WEIRS AND STORM SURGE BARRIERS ENGINEERS/COMPANIES/EXPERTS (BASED ON THE SURVEY) PIANC WORKING GROUP 26 88 InCom 7. PREFABRICATION TECHNIQUES ...................95 CONTENT 7.1 DESCRIPTION......................................................95 7.2 EVALUATION OF ALTERNATIVES ........................95 7.3 SHELL CONSTRUCTION .......................................98 SUMMARY 7.4 FOUNDATION CONSTRUCTION ............................98 TABLE OF CONTENT 7.5 SUPERSTRUCTURE CONSTRUCTION..................100 WORKING GROUP MEMBERS 8. CODES, RULES AND STANDARDS .................103 8.1 APPLICATION OF NEW STANDARDS TO 1. INTRODUCTION.....................................................5 HYDRAULIC STRUCTURES ............................................103 8.2 SELECTED CODES OF PRACTICE, RULES, 1.1 AIMS OF THE WG-26............................................5 STANDARDS AND GUIDELINES WITH REFERENCE TO THE 1.2 WG26’S CD-ROM................................................6 WG26’S SUBJECTS .......................................................104 1.3 LIST OF PROJECT REVIEWS ...................................7 9. CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS....105 2. GATES OF MOVABLE WEIRS AND BARRIERS 8 10. REFERENCES ..................................................107 2.1 PROJECT REVIEWS................................................8 10.1 WEB SITES........................................................110 2.2 TERMINOLOGY REVIEW......................................17 3. DESIGN PROCEDURE .........................................22 Appendix A: NUMERICAL TOOLS FOR WEIR 3.1 SITE PARAMETERS..............................................23 AND BARRIER DESIGN 3.2 REQUIRED INFORMATION FOR CONCEPT Appendix B: LIST OF SPONSORS DEVELOPMENT AND THE STRUCTURE DESIGN................24 3.3 APPLIED FORCES ................................................25 3.4 NAVIGATION REQUIREMENTS.............................27 WG-26’s CD-Rom 3.5 OPERATIONAL REQUIREMENTS ..........................27 - About 50 Project Reviews of movable weirs and storm 3.6 PRELIMINARY DESIGN OF A STRUCTURE TYPE ....29 surge barriers (Directory A1) 3.7 RELIABILITY AND SERVICE LIFE .........................30 - WG-26 Report (FDF Full version), (Directory A2) 4. MULTI-CRITERIA ASSESSMENT.....................31 - Sponsor Company References (Directory A3) - Various additional information about Sections 3; 4; 5; 4.1 NECESSITY OF A MULTI-CRITERIA ASSESSMENT..31 6; 7 and 8 of this report (See Directory Annex Section 4.2 SOME HISTORICAL BACKGROUND .......................31 # ) 4.3 METHOD OF QUALITATIVE ASSESSMENT.............32 4.4 METHODS OF QUANTITATIVE ASSESSMENT.........33 - Various technical guidelines (Directories B): 4.5 OTHER GATE ASSESSMENT METHODS .................40 o B1: PIANC’s “Illustrated Technical Dictionary” 4.6 CONCLUDING REMARKS .....................................40 o B2: Guidelines: “Design of Mobile and Marine Metallic Structures” & “ROSA 2000: 5. DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS (PARAMETERS o B3: Movable Weirs (Guide du chef de projet - AND CRITERIA)............................................................42 France) 5.1 STRUCTURAL CONSIDERATIONS .........................42 o B4: Inflatable Weirs (Germany) 5.2 HYDRAULIC AND FLOW......................................50 o B5: Maintenance bulkhead types and Temporary 5.3 FOUNDATION AND CIVIL ENGINEERING..............55 and Demountable Flood Protection. 5.4 CONTROL, OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE.......60 o B6: Examples of rehabilitation Weirs 5.5 TEMPORARY CLOSURE ARRANGEMENTS............66 o B7: Flood Protection in UK 5.6 SAFETY, RELIABILITY AND RISKS.......................70 o B8: Environmentally Considerate Lubricants 5.7 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND AESTHETICS ....79 - WG-26 meeting Pictures, (Directory C) 5.8 COST (CONSTRUCTION, MAINTENANCE AND OPERATION)...................................................................81 6. DESIGN AND ASSESSMENT TOOLS................87 6.1 TYPES OF TOOLS REQUIRED BY 5 Final Report, Working Group 26: Mobile Weirs, August 2005 (Version 6.7) Design of Movable Weirs and Storm Surge Barriers – WG26 –PIANC p. 4 WORKING GROUP MEMBERS (InCom WG26) Mr RIGO Philippe (Chairman) (UTCB), Department of Hydraulic Structures, University of Liege, ANAST, Romania Department of Hydraulic and Transport, Mr. STOCKSTILL Richard Lawrence Belgium Coastal & Hydraulics Laboratory, U.S. Army Engineer Mr. ABDELNOUR Razek, Research & Development Center, Vicksburg, MS, BMT Fleet Technologies Limitée, USA. Canada Mr. WILKES David Mr. BULCKAEN Dirk Environment Agency, London, IMDC (Int. Marine & Dredging Consultants nv.), UK Belgium Mr. DALY Fabrice Acknowledgments Département Ports Maritimes et Voies Navigables Mr. Kawana Futoshi (Japan); Mrs. Laura Chapital and Mr. CETMEF, Alexandre Lagache (France) for their active contributions France and attendance at meetings. Mr. DANIEL Ryszard A. Mr De Ville V. (Belgium), MM. Beguin P. and Kovarik Ministry of Transport, Public Works & Water (France), MM. Yao S., Pena O. and Waller J. (US), Mr. Management, Civil Engineering Department, Rowe R. (UK), and Mr. Michael Gebhardt (Germany)