The “Gospel” of Cultural Sustainability: Missiological Insights

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The “Gospel” of Cultural Sustainability: Missiological Insights The “Gospel” of Cultural Sustainability: Missiological Insights Anna Ralph Master’s Thesis Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School at Goucher College in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in Cultural Sustainability Goucher College—Towson, Maryland May 2013 Advisory Committee Amy Skillman, M.A. (Advisor) Rory Turner, PhD Richard Showalter, DMin Table of Contents Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... iii Chapter One—The Conceptual Groundwork ................................................................................. 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 1 Definition—“Missiology” .................................................................................................... 4 Definition—“Cultural Sustainability” .................................................................................. 5 Rationale ............................................................................................................................. 7 Methodology ..................................................................................................................... 11 Review of Literature—Cultural Sustainability................................................................... 12 Review of Literature—Missiology ..................................................................................... 14 Chapter Two—Historical Models of Cross-Cultural Mission Initiatives ........................................ 16 Ethnocentrism and Worldview ......................................................................................... 18 Mission as “Coercion” ....................................................................................................... 20 Mission as Protection ........................................................................................................ 24 Mission as Assimilation ..................................................................................................... 28 Mission as Adaptation/Accommodation .......................................................................... 33 Mission as Indigenization .................................................................................................. 39 Missionaries as Advocates ................................................................................................ 44 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................... 47 Chapter Three—Contemporary Models of Cross-Cultural Mission Initiatives ............................. 50 Mission as Contextualization/Inculturation ..................................................................... 54 Mission as Insider Movement ........................................................................................... 62 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................... 68 Chapter Four—Cultural Sustainability Case Studies ..................................................................... 71 Case Study #1—Various Missionaries, with the Mizos in India ........................................ 72 Case Study #2—Clair Good with the Maasai in Kenya ..................................................... 77 Case Study #3—Bruce Olson, with the Motilone Indians in Colombia ............................. 80 Chapter Five—Implications for the Work of Cultural Sustainability ............................................ 88 Implications ....................................................................................................................... 89 Best Practices .................................................................................................................. 104 Concluding Thoughts ...................................................................................................... 105 Bibliography ................................................................................................................................ 109 ii Abstract Christian missionaries were some of the earliest cross-cultural workers. The author, a former missionary and current student of cultural sustainability, notes a close correspondence between the passions of missionaries and cultural sustainability practitioners. Each field believes it has good news to share. Each desires to serve communities in ways that enhance their vitality—ideologically and pragmatically. Neither is satisfied simply to observe and document cultures; they have a desire to actively engage with people, helping to facilitate community-driven change that honors and sustains cherished cultural values. Both confront the powerful impulses of globalization. The author contends that these commonalities warrant an examination of Christian missionaries’ two millennia of cross-cultural experiences for insights which could benefit the emerging field of cultural sustainability. This research surveys the models employed by missionaries as they interacted with foreign cultures, both historically and in contemporary times. It describes three case studies which illustrate the application of cultural sustainability principles to work on the mission field. Finally, based on analysis of the historical survey and case studies, it offers a number of implications for the work of cultural sustainability and presents a set of recommended best practices. iii Chapter One The Conceptual Groundwork My enrollment in the Cultural Sustainability program at Goucher College came soon after my return to the U.S. following two years as a Christian missionary in Ethiopia. “Missionary.” My husband, son, and I did not fit the image that many people would associate with the title. We did not live in a hut in the bush, laboring to convert unsaved tribespeople to Christianity. Instead we lived in the capital city, in a modest house, and worked with the national Mennonite church leadership there, primarily in the arenas of leadership development and trauma healing. Our work took us to more remote parts of the country, but even there we focused on teaching workshops for church leaders. All of our contacts with other East Africans were an extension of that work. Our time in Ethiopia was brief, but had a profound impact on my thinking and understandings. I could not have anticipated in advance how it would feel to live for two years as part of a small minority group, and to have my Caucasian skin stand out in every crowd. To compound my discomfort, despite my best efforts, I was unable to master the local language on more than a rudimentary level; every interaction, therefore, relied on others’ English proficiencies and translation skills. Throughout our term, I struggled to understand the customs and expectations of that culture. Some of my most basic cultural assumptions were challenged as I learned about differences in communication styles, “telling the truth,” and concepts of time. It was humbling to be so foreign, so dependent. The Ethiopians were gracious and patient, but my heart longed to be able to enter more fully into their worlds. The two years were simultaneously very short and very long. This time in Africa offered many social and anthropological insights. Ethiopia is unique among its East African neighbors in some significant ways. Ethiopia was the earliest major empire to 1 officially adopt Christianity as a state religion, dating back to the 4th century.1 Due to centuries of isolation from the rest of the Christian world,2 the Ethiopian Orthodox Church developed as a unique, indigenous expression of Christianity which is a blend of Jewish/Hebrew, Christian, and primal religious beliefs and practices (C. Shenk 259-268). Contemporary Ethiopian cultural practices reflect a continuing commitment to this form of Christianity. Ethiopia also retains a distinction as the only African nation which was not colonized.3 This liberty impacted Ethiopian culture in ways which have distanced it from its previously-colonized neighbors. Ethiopia did not “benefit” economically and technologically as the other nations did. However, this isolation left it with traditions (such as music) and dynamics of power (including church structures) that are uniquely Ethiopian rather than adaptations of Western ideas. Ethiopia now finds itself, though, scrambling to catch up with the rest of the world, to integrate technological “progress” into a traditional culture. Missionaries, who span both worlds, often wrestle with how to introduce beneficial community development in ways that will respect existing cultural values and promote partnerships and community ownership. Our time in Ethiopia left me with observations and questions that continued to dominate my thinking. Nearly all of these concerned the nature of change as it relates to existing culture. Although the extent and speed vary, every culture inevitably experiences change. Defining the acceptability of the initiators and parameters of change can be challenging, even divisive. Every innovation that is introduced into a culture—African or American—comes at some cost. It is essential, then, to grapple with issues of agency and to determine who is in the best position to decide what is an “improvement” and whether or not it is worth any corresponding trade-offs. 1 Some Ethiopian legends trace the introduction
Recommended publications
  • A Christology for Frontier Mission: a Missiological Study of Colossians by Brad Gill
    Households in Focus A Christology for Frontier Mission: A Missiological Study of Colossians by Brad Gill Editor’s Note: This article was presented to the Asia Society for Frontier Mission, Bangkok, Thailand, October 2017. would like to reaffirm our strategic cooperation in frontier mission by examining a rather uncommon portion of scripture for missiological reflec- tion. Cooperation emerges from the objects we love, those purposes and goals we share, and I believe that in the epistle to the Colossians the Apostle Paul I 1 offers us a christological vision that grounds our mission in a common love. Colossians as a Missiological Statement Recently I was plowing through a new book by John Flett entitled Apostolicity: The Ecumenical Question in World Christian Perspective.2 The author explained how the growing pluriformity of world Christianity should reorient our understanding of the apostolic continuity of the church. I don’t usually read books on ecumenical unity, but this one had come in the mail (since I’m an editor) and something in the review had caught my eye: that the rationale for ecumenical unity over the past century had placed limits on cross-cultural engagement and the appropriation of the gospel. Those words have missio- logical implication. At one point towards the end of his book, in his chapter on Jesus Christ as the ground of our apostolic mission, he refers the reader to Colossians. If then you have been raised up with Christ, keep seeking the things above, where Christ is, seated at the right hand of God. Set your mind on the things above, not on the things that are on earth.
    [Show full text]
  • Ethnobiology in Mizoram State: Folklore Medico-Zoology
    Bull.Ind.lnst.Hist.Med. Vol. XXIX - 1999 pp /23 tc 148 ETHNOBIOLOGY IN MIZORAM STATE: FOLKLORE MEDICO-ZOOLOGY H.LALRAMNGHINGLOVA * ABSTRACT Studies in cthnobotany and ethnozoology under the umbrella of Ethnobiology seem imbalanced in the sense that enormous publications have accumulated in case of the former but only little information has been disseminated in case of the latter. While 7500 wild plant species are known to be used by tribals in medicine, only 76 species of animals have been shown as medicinal resources (Anonymous, 1994). The present paper is the first-hand information of folklore medicine from animals in Mizoram. The animals enumerated comprise 01'25 vertebrates and 31 invertebrates and arc used for treatment of over 40 kinds of diseases or ailments, including jaundice, tuberculosis, hepatitis, cancer, asthma and veterinary disease. The author, however, does not recommend destruction of wild animals, he it for food or medicine. Keywords: Folklore medicine, ethnozoology, wildlife, conservation, Mizoram. Introduction operation correlate with their customs and Mizoram is the last frontier of the ceremonies. One of the most important Hirnalyan ranges in the North-East India feasts a Lushai can perform is called and flanked by Bangladesh in the west, 'Khuangchawi' which involved a great deal Myanmar in the east and south, and Assam of money that only the Chiefs or a few we//- in the north. It has a total geographical area to-do people could perform (Parry, 1928). of 21,081 Km ' with a population of A man who performed such ceremony was 6,89,756 persons (census 19(1) and stood called 'Thangchhuah '.
    [Show full text]
  • Cleansing the Cosmos
    CLEANSING THE COSMOS: A BIBLICAL MODEL FOR CONCEPTUALIZING AND COUNTERACTING EVIL By E. Janet Warren A thesis submitted to The University of Birmingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Theology and Religion College of Arts and Law The University of Birmingham November 14, 2011 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. ABSRACT Understanding evil spiritual forces is essential for Christian theology. Evil has typically been studied either from a philosophical perspective or through the lens of ‘spiritual warfare’. The first seldom considers demonology; the second is flawed by poor methodology. Furthermore, warfare language is problematic, being very dualistic, associated with violence and poorly applicable to ministry. This study addresses these issues by developing a new model for conceptualizing and counteracting evil using ‘non-warfare’ biblical metaphors, and relying on contemporary metaphor theory, which claims that metaphors are cognitive and can depict reality. In developing this model, I examine four biblical themes with respect to alternate metaphors for evil: Creation, Cult, Christ and Church. Insights from anthropology (binary oppositions), theology (dualism, nothingness) and science (chaos-complexity theory) contribute to the construction of the model, and the concepts of profane space, sacred space and sacred actions (divine initiative and human responsibility) guide the investigation.
    [Show full text]
  • Jews and Christians: Perspectives on Mission the Lambeth-Jewish Forum
    Jews and Christians: Perspectives on Mission The Lambeth-Jewish Forum Reuven Silverman, Patrick Morrow and Daniel Langton Jews and Christians: Perspectives on Mission The Lambeth-Jewish Forum Both Christianity and Judaism have a vocation to mission. In the Book of the Prophet Isaiah, God’s people are spoken of as a light to the nations. Yet mission is one of the most sensitive and divisive areas in Jewish-Christian relations. For Christians, mission lies at the heart of their faith because they understand themselves as participating in the mission of God to the world. As the recent Anglican Communion document, Generous Love, puts it: “The boundless life and perfect love which abide forever in the heart of the Trinity are sent out into the world in a mission of renewal and restoration in which we are called to share. As members of the Church of the Triune God, we are to abide among our neighbours of different faiths as signs of God’s presence with them, and we are sent to engage with our neighbours as agents of God’s mission to them.”1 As part of the lifeblood of Christian discipleship, mission has been understood and worked out in a wide range of ways, including teaching, healing, evangelism, political involvement and social renewal. Within this broad and rich understanding of mission, one key aspect is the relation between mission and evangelism. In particular, given the focus of the Lambeth-Jewish Forum, how does the Christian understanding of mission affects relations between Christianity and Judaism? Christian mission and Judaism has been controversial both between Christians and Jews, and among Christians themselves.
    [Show full text]
  • Cultural Factors of Christianizing the Erstwhile Lushai Hills (1890-1940)
    Mizoram University Journal of Humanities & Social Sciences (A Bi-Annual Refereed Journal) Vol IV Issue 2, December 2018 ISSN: 2395-7352 eISSN:2581-6780 Cultural Factors of Christianizing the erstwhile Lushai Hills (1890-1940) Zadingluaia Chinzah* Abstract Alexandrapore incident became a turning point in the history of the erstwhile Lushai Hills inhabited by simple hill people, living an egalitarian and communitarian life. The result of the encounter between two diverse and dissimilar cultures that were contrary to their form of living and thinking in every way imaginable resulted in the political annexation of the erstwhile Lushai Hills by the British colonial power,which was soon followed by the arrival of missionaries. In consolidating their hegemony and imperial designs, the missionaries were tools through which the hill tribes were to be pacified from raiding British territories. In the long run, this encounter resulted in the emergence and escalation of Christianity in such a massive scale that the hill tribes with their primal religious practices were converted into a westernised reli- gion. The paper problematizes claims for factors that led to the rise of Christianity by various Mizo Church historians, inclusive of the early generations and the emerging church historians. Most of these historians believed that waves of Revivalism was the major factor in Christianizing the erstwhile Lushai Hills though their perspectives or approach to their presumptions are different. Hence, the paper hypothesizes that cultural factors were integral to the rise and growth of Christianity in the erstwhile Lushai Hills during 1890-1940 as against the claims made before. Keywords : ‘Cultural Factors of Conversion,’ Tlawmngaihna, Thangchhuah, Pialral, Revivals.
    [Show full text]
  • MISSIONS Don L. Meredith Harding School of Theology 2016/17 R.R
    1 MISSIONS Don L. Meredith Harding School of Theology 2016/17 R.R.016.266/P484. Petersen, Paul D., ed. Missions and Evangelism: A Bibliography Selected from the ATLA Religion Database. Rev. ed. Chicago, IL: ATLA, 1985. Subject index, with abstracts, of articles from ATLA Religion Database (1949-1984) and D.Min. theses from Research in Ministry (1981-84). Contains author & book review indexes. R.R.016.266/B582. Bibliographia Missionaria. Isola del Liri: Soc. Tip. A. Maloce & Pisani, 1933- . An annual classified bibliography of books and articles (primarily Catholic) on missions. Contains author/person and subject indexes. Vol. 1-49 (1933-85) published as Bibliografia Missionaria. R.R.016.266/I61. Thomas, Norman E., ed. International Mission Bibliography: 1960-2000. ATLA Bibliographies, 48. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Press, 2003. Contains 15,850 annotated entries for the most important missiological books published in English and a selection of those in each major European language from 1960 to 2000. Arranged under 20 sub-headings with a personal name index. To supplement this bibliography a "Selected Annotated Bibliography on Missiology" was published in installments (each including about 30 new titles) in each issue of Missiology (2000-July 2004) corresponding to the sub-headings in the published volume. *R.R.016.27/I61. International Christian Literature Documentation Project. 2v. Evanston, IL: ATLA, 1993. Indexes "printed materials (wherever published) that document Christian life and mission in the non- Western world." Indexes 18,635 monographs and pamphlets and 6,774 essays in 1,843 multi-author works. Vol. 1 is subject index and vol. 2 is author-editor and corporate name index.
    [Show full text]
  • [AJPS 3/1 (2000), Pp. 33-60] “TRUTH on FIRE”: PENTECOSTAL THEOLOGY of MISSION and the CHALLENGES of a NEW MILLENNIUM Veli-Ma
    [AJPS 3/1 (2000), pp. 33-60] “TRUTH ON FIRE”:1 PENTECOSTAL THEOLOGY OF MISSION AND THE CHALLENGES OF A NEW MILLENNIUM Veli-Matti Kärkkäinen 1. Introduction: Pentecostals and the Challenge of “Transforming Mission” Pentecostal mission has been successful, extremely successful when we look at the numbers. Whatever reservations one might have with regard to the calculations of D. Barrett2 and of others,3 there is no denying the fact that the advance of Pentecostal/Charismatic mission work has been astonishing. “A growth of from zero to 400 mission in ninety years is unprecedented in the whole of church history.”4 1 The first part of the title is taken from L. Grant McClung, “Truth on Fire Pentecostals and the Urgent Missiology,” in Azusa Street and Beyond, ed. L. Grant McClung (South Plainfield, NJ: Bridge Publishing, 1985), pp. 47-55. For ecumenical perspectives on Pentecostal missiology, see my “Pentecostal Missiology in Ecumenical Context,” International Review of Mission (July 1999, forthcoming). 2 See, David B. Barrett and Todd M. Johnson, “Annual Statistical Table on Global Mission: 1999,” International Bulletin of Missionary Research 23:1 (1999), pp. 24-25. 3 See, e.g., C. Peter Wagner, “Church Growth,” in Dictionary of Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements, eds. S. M. Burgess and G. B. McGee (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1988), pp. 180-95. (This dictionary will be indicated henceforth as DPCM.) 4 Walter J. Hollenweger, “From Azusa Street to the Toronto Phenomenon,” Concilium 3, eds. Jürgen Moltmann and Karl-Josef Kuschel (1996), pp. 3-14 (3). 34 Asian Journal of Pentecostal Studies 3/1 (2000) Pentecostals, however, would do well if they, instead of continuing to glory in church growth numbers,5 would have another look at the impending challenges as we are crossing into the third millennium.
    [Show full text]
  • “As the Father Has Sent Me, Even So I Am Sending You”: the Divine Missions and the Mission of the Church
    JETS 63.3 (2020): 535–58 “AS THE FATHER HAS SENT ME, EVEN SO I AM SENDING YOU”: THE DIVINE MISSIONS AND THE MISSION OF THE CHURCH TOREY TEER* Abstract: Presentations advancing an ecclesiology that favors the church’s ontology before its function have become more common in recent years. Further, mission models employing a Trini- tarian framework (viz., the missio Dei) have likewise become popular in contemporary conver- sation. This project explores the implications of the divine missions—of the Son and of the Spirit—upon the mission of the church while also drawing out some pneumatological emphases vis-à-vis ecclesiology. Specifically, I present a biblical-theological synthesis of the divine missions grounded upon Johannine language of “sending,” framed by Thomas Aquinas’s conception of the divine missions, and augmented by John Calvin’s notion of the “double grace” conferred via union with Christ. I then apply this synthesis to the mission of the church, showing that the church participates—analogically—in the Trinitarian agency carried out in the missio Dei. In so doing, I offer a unique line of reasoning that further supports the church’s ontology before its function as well as a Trinitarian framework for missions. Key words: pneumatology, ecclesiology, missio Dei, Trinitarianism, Johannine theology, Thomistic theology When the concept of “missions” comes up in biblical, theological, or ecclesial discourse, it typically takes one of two forms: the Great Commission (Matt 28:18– 20) or the missio Dei—though thE two arE not mutually ExclusivE. ThE formEr typi- cally refers to the work of the church to bring the gospel to unreached people groups around the world (often called “church missions”), while the latter rEfers to the triunE God’s redemptive mission to the world in which hE graciously allows the church to participate.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Also the Holy Ghost': Some Reflections on Pneumatology In
    ‘Also the Holy Ghost’: some reflections on pneumatology in Anglican Missiology Also the Holy Ghost: the Comforter. That is the rather dismissive way in which the Third Person of the Trinity appears in the Te Deum, one of the staple ingredients of the daily office in the Book of Common Prayer. The BCP also prints the doxology at the end of the psalms in the form ‘Glory to the Father, and to the Son: and to the Holy Ghost’ – the place of the caesura does rather give the impression that the Spirit is a bit of an afterthought. In fact, while classical Anglicanism is impeccably orthodox in the Trinitarian balance of its formularies, there is a clear lack of focus on the Spirit, in liturgy, theology and missiology. This is not really surprising given the emergence of the Anglican tradition from late medieval Western Christendom, where pneumatology was not a maJor theme. But nor is the situation invariably better in our own times. Consider, for example, the Mission Praise worship song There is a Redeemer, popular for its fervent devotion and eminently singable melody. The intense Christological focus of each verse tails off into a residual acknowledgement of pneumatology in the chorus: Thank you, O my Father, / for giving us your Son, / and leaving your Spirit / till the work on earth is done. The verb, ‘leaving’, suggests for me a functional, subordinating view of the Spirit, a resource kindly presented by Jesus to the Church to carry on his good work for the time being. An Eastern Christian might see this as the fully worked through logic of the filioque.
    [Show full text]
  • “Mission” and Missio Dei: Response to Charles Van Engen's
    1 UUCHAPTER 4 “Mission” and Missio Dei: Response to Charles Van Engen’s “‘Mission’ Defined and Described” Enoch Wan My response to Charles Van Engen’s “Mission Defined and Described” is organized in the following order: observation, evaluation, and suggestion. I shall endeavor to suggest a briefer, but more holistic, definition of mission that better reflects the Trinitarian impetus for mission. Observation Purpose and Presentation The stated purpose of the article is quoted below for the sake of easy reference and review: The purpose of this essay is to offer a brief historical overview of some ways in which the Christian church has defined “mission” down through the centuries, and to demonstrate how the various definitions have influenced the thought and practice of the Christian church’s ministries in the world. In this sense this essay addresses the PAST of what has traditionally been termed “missions” (p. ?). Van Engen is to be credited for having achieved the stated purpose by providing “a historical overview” of how the term “mission” has been defined, and he has successfully demonstrated how variations in this definition have impacted the thought and practice of the Christian Church. 2 The format of the presentation is quite creative and realistic. It begins with his meeting with the Global Outreach Task Force of a local congregation on a Sunday afternoon and closes with his attempt to answer Gloria’s question: “So, how do you define mission?” By using this device the author avoids the typical dry and boring historical narration, and provides a sense of realism in dealing with the questions, including details of place, personnel, and process.
    [Show full text]
  • Rih Dil Titi
    Rih Dil Titi “There! That’s the lake!” exclaimed my mother, pointing her finger towards the mirroring body of water laid flat across the plains of Tiau valley. It was an uncharacteristic of her to make any display of excitement. It had been an awfully long drive and we were all weary of the dusty Mizoram roads. We were returning from a friend’s wedding in Sialhawk, a small sleepy village in the east not far from Champhai, the district capital bordering Myanmar. And in the excitement of our celebration of young love, tradition and inspired speeches of eternal bonds, we had decided to take the scenic route to Rihkhawdar before returning back to Keitum. Yes, we were on our way to see Rih dil- the lake that symbolised love, life, death and the afterlife. I was excited because the place held within it the secrets and legends of everything that would meet a young man’s fancy. The scenic part was definitely accurate, but truth be told we were miles out of our way home and we had underestimated the distance; it appeared I had also overestimated my zeal for long drives. We stopped at Champhai, which is one of the few places in Mizoram where we find plains which are used for rice cultivation. The place is known to be hammered down by Chhura, a mythical figure in the Mizo folklore who is often attributed to many of the unnatural places found in Mizoram. We drove in excitement at the only long straight road sandwiched between the rice fields before ascending up again at the steep and winding mountain roads.
    [Show full text]
  • Download This PDF File
    The International Journal Of Humanities & Social Studies (ISSN 2321 - 9203) www.theijhss.com THE INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HUMANITIES & SOCIAL STUDIES The Darlong Folk Literature: A Study on Deification of Characters in the Oral Narratives of the Darlong People during the Pre-Christianisation Period Benjamina Darlong Research Scholar, Department of English, Tripura University Abstract: The objective of the paper is to study the paradigm of canonization in the oral narratives of the Darlong community aiming not at identifying the pattern. The materials of the article are primarily based on the oral tradition and orature collected among the community men and women in addition to the few documentations made in vernacular by different literary interested personage. The article trace diverge characterization as delineated in the folk narratives of the Darlong. The momentum of the canonization culminates in when deeds of the hero that are elements of crime in today’s perspective are hailed by the people thereby capturing many of their old practices. In the mean time, certain characters are exalted to the state of deity eventually perpetuating them. 1. Introduction to the Study The Darlong of Tripura belonged to one among the many communities of the Kuki-Chin group who are also known under the nomenclature of ‘Zo-Hnathla1’ or ‘Zo mi’. “The Kukis are one of the autochthonous tribes of Tripura. According to the 1971 census, the Kuki population in Tripura was only 7,775 persons. They are tenth in the numerical position among the 19 scheduled Tribes of Tripura. They do not call themselves as Kukis but Hre-em.
    [Show full text]