Steve Bunker: the Civil War on the Western Plains
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
April 2018 Vol XXXIII, No 8 Thurs April 12 Steve Bunker: The Civil War on the Western Plains (Editor’s NOTE: Due to the snowstorm on March 8, Steve Bunker’s talk was cancelled and rescheduled for April. See President’s note for update on Ned Smith’s talk.) The War of the Rebellion in the West has been largely overlooked, overshadowed by dramatic campaigns in the East. But from western Kansas to New Mexico, and north to Minnesota, war was fought in encounters as strategically important as any larger battles in the East. Steve Bunker gets some helpful Confederate and Union forces not only fought bitterly with advice on gathering rations for his each other, but Mexican‐Americans and Native Peoples along regiment of 1st Maine cavalry with some of the first organized “colored” units, found re‐enactors. themselves caught up in a confused struggle of changing loyalties and conditions that did not end with the surrenders in 1865 back East. While heroes were made and new states were created, terrible massacres and what anyone today would consider to be war crimes were common. The Civil War easily bled into the subsequent Indian Wars, involving many of the same people. We can never cover the whole war in the West in one hour but we can examine some important events. We will talk about the Texan invasion of New Mexico and characters like Kit Carson and John Chivington; the tragedy of Chief Black Kettle; the Maine sea captain who anchored Kansas for the Union; the extraordinary march of the California volunteers, and the recent reenactment of a forgotten march and battle in what is now Wyoming. I will bring a couple of artifacts from that period for people to examine. ******************** Over 55 years ago, a teenaged Steve Bunker co‐founded the First Maine Cavalry, a reenactment and living history Kit Carson led the 1st New Mexico Volunteer organization that is active today. Infantry and trained the new men. In October 1861, he was made a colonel. The Volunteers fought the Confederate forces at Valverde, He was instrumental in the creation of the Civil War New Mexico, in February 1862. (Wikipedia) Museum in Baltimore, Maryland. He is former Department Commander, Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War. Currently he is working to place a memorial stone on the battlefield at Middleburg, Virginia, dedicated to the First Maine Cavalry. An infantry veteran of the Vietnam War and former merchant mariner, Bunker lives in Gray with his wife, Sharon, and two loud macaws. As you know, he has been a member of the Chamberlain Round Table for many years. JLC CWRT meetings are the second Thursday of each month: 7:00 pm Morrell Room Curtis Memorial Library 23 Pleasant St, Brunswick ME Weather Cancellations: Channels 6, 8, 13 If the Library closes due to a storm, the meeting will be cancelled. Members will receive an email notification of cancellation from the CWRT Secretary. 2 News from Headquarters From the President – Dan Cunningham We almost made it through the winter without canceling a meeting due to weather. Unfortunately, one of the blizzards that came up the coast in March came at the wrong time and our March meeting was canceled. For those of you who were looking forward to hearing Steve Bunker talk he will now be our April presenter. Ned Smith who was originally scheduled to talk is unable to make it and Steve graciously adjusted his schedule to take his place. Ned has been rescheduled for next season. Our current bank balance is in good shape, but please renew your memberships when they come due. Most of our large expenses for the year will occur in May and June, and if we want to start our 2018/2019 year with a healthy bank account we need you to renew your membership. In addition, it would be helpful if you participated in the book raffle and even the Adopt‐A‐Speaker program. Remember if you donate $50 towards the Adopt‐A‐Speaker program you are eligible to have dinner with the speaker of your choice at Richard’s Restaurant. You would pay for your meal but would have the opportunity to get to know the speaker personally and ask any questions you might have. Let’s hope for good weather for our April meeting. I hope to see you there, and in the meantime let’s hope winter finally decides to step aside and allows spring to come. 3 JLC CWRT Board of Trustees – 2017/18 President: Dan Cunningham (729‐9520) Vice President: Gardner Shaw (703‐472‐8618) Treasurer: Paul Lariviere (724‐2414) Secretary: Steve Garrett (956‐8729, cell 607‐9713) [email protected] Program Coordinator: Bill Attick (726‐4685) Members: Steve Bunker, Lucy Cunningham, Carol Manchester, Ken McAfee Treasurer’s Update – Paul Lariviere Quick Stats – March: Meeting: March 8, 2018 Speaker: Steve Bunker’s talk was CANCELLED due to Snow Storm Attendance: 0 Book Raffle tickets sold: 0 In‐Kind Donations: none Book prizes distributed: 0 INCOME: NET Income for March: $60.00 Memberships $113.50 $0.00 Book Raffle revenue NET Income this Fiscal Year: $50.00 Cash Donations $1,189.72 $3.50 Coffee Sales YEAR‐TO‐DATE $0.00 Book Sales Bank Balance, March 31, 2018: $5,285.11 $113.50 TOTAL Cash Income for Mar EXPENSES: $ 0.00 Speaker Dinner 4 Adopt‐A‐Speaker – Dinner Host Program In conjunction with its Adopt‐A‐Speaker setup, the JLC CWRT maintains a Dinner Host program. With this arrangement, members who donate to the Adopt‐A‐Speaker program at the “General” level have the opportunity to have dinner with a visiting speaker at Richard’s Restaurant in Brunswick. Under this program, the CWRT pays for dinner for the speaker, and the host pays for his/her own dinner. See the last page of the newsletter to enroll in the Adopt‐A‐Speaker program. Please contact Paul Lariviere (Treasurer) to make arrangements to host a specific speaker, at least one week before the program. Apr 12 Steve Bunker (Ned Smith to be rescheduled) Civil War in the West May 10 Elizabeth Hallett Mourning Customs during the Civil War Era Jun 14 Will Greene Battle of the Crater, Petersburg 5 Field Report Historical Perspectives from our Members Ulysses S. Grant and the Myth of the Yazoo Bender by Noma Petroff It is extremely hard to see how the Cadwallader story can be classed as anything but one more in the dreary Grant-was-drunk garland of myths. – Bruce Catton (Grant Moves South, p. 464) Grant’s reputation as a two‐fisted drinker is legendary. If there is one thing that people know – or think they know – about Grant, it’s that he was quite a drinker. I hear that constantly from people I meet. “Well, I really don’t know much about the Civil War, and I don’t know much about Grant, but there is one thing I can tell you.” “Oh, yes, what is that?” “He definitely liked to bend his elbow!” But, as historian James McPherson puts it, the problem is that most of what people think they “know” about Grant’s drinking is based on fabrication: Many wartime stories of Grant’s drunkenness are false; others are at best dubious. Grant’s meteoric rise to fame provoked jealousy in the hearts of men who indulged in gossip to denigrate him. Subject to sick headaches brought on by strain and loss of sleep, Grant sometimes acted unwell in a manner to give observers the impression that he had been drinking. (Battle Cry of Freedom, p. 588) Ulysses S. Grant’s rise to power was accompanied by attacks on his For his part, McPherson goes on to state that he thinks Grant personality from various quarters. A must have had some type of drinking problem, but it has favorite theme was alleged incidents of been much exaggerated. I’m not certain that I would even Grant’s drinking. go as far as McPherson does, but I think we both agree that most of the stories of Grant’s drinking are fictitious. So, it’s a problem for fans of the Grant’s‐a‐drunk perspective (or, in its most recent iteration, Grant’s‐an‐alcoholic). Most references to Grant’s drunkenness are simply generalizations. (There are many specific instances where Grant takes one or two drinks, but does not get drunk – but these don’t really meet the need for a story 6 about actual drunkenness.) After 1860, practically all the stories fall apart at the slightest pressure. Captain William J. Kountz submitted accusations of instances of Grant’s drinking at Cairo in January 1862, but with his reputation as an obnoxious, vindictive blow‐ hard (Grant had received a petition from 37 riverboat men, requesting his removal) the allegations seem questionable. And for anyone who takes the time to read Kountz’s thirteen pages of accusations, they will see that the charges quickly degenerate into the surreal. For example the idea of Grant – who hated to dance – getting drunk and going to a “negro ball” is simply not believable. (The full text can be read in John Y. Simon’s Papers of Ulysses S. Grant, Vol. 4, p. 110‐223, also available online.) Similarly, Major General Henry Halleck’s accusations to his superiors, after Grant’s victory at Fort Donelson, also do not pass the sniff test. Halleck wired McClellan, “Rumor has just reached me that since the taking of Fort Donelson, General Grant has resumed his former bad habits.” Comments historian Jean Edward Smith, “Grant was on the wagon and Old Brains knew it.” (Smith, Grant, p.