Hot Rocks and Oil: Are Volcanic Margins the New Frontier?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FOR OIL & GAS ARTICLE Hot Rocks and Oil: Are Volcanic Margins the New Frontier? ASSESSING THE CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES OF FINDING AND EXTRACTING NATURAL RESOURCES FROM A VOLATILE ENVIRONMENT By Dougal A. Jerram Hot rocks and oil: Are volcanic margins the new frontier? VISITING MODERN VOLCANOES: LEARNING FROM PAST AND PRESENT Volcanoes evoke a classic image of a cone-shaped mountain exploding ash, or rivers of molten rock. The lure of the volcano is almost primordial. Looking back into the Earth’s past volcanic events—including some of nature’s most beautiful volcanoes and eruptions in the present (e.g., Bárðarbunga, Iceland; Stromboli, Italy; Pu`u `O`o, Hawaii - see Figure 1)—can shed light on the active cooling planet and the role volcanoes played in Earth’s evolution1. Figure 1: Understanding modern volcanic systems; a) recent volcanic activity at Bárðarbunga with fissure eruptions which fed lava flows (Sept 2014), b) sampling at the front of the advancing lava where it is diverting a meltwater river (Sept 2014), c) sampling lava flows at Hawaii1, d) the volcano Stromboli erupting at sunset1. Every new volcanic eruption is a real-time opportunity to capture exactly what happens over time and allows researchers to examine the resultant lava flows, explosive ash horizons and other deposits. The spectacular Bárðarbunga, for instance, provided examples of the erup- tion entering and diverting a modern river system that came down from the ice cap (e.g. Figure 1b). This eruption also became the largest in Iceland for over 200 years with the lava field covering 85 km², and an erupted volume of 1.4 km³ of new lava2. Older rock masses also provide clues of where ancient volcanic episodes occurred, their timing and their relationship to surrounding rocks and Earth history. Modern systems provide the key to understanding the past volcanic events, and geoscientists use the ancient dissected systems to help them understand what happens within and beneath volcanoes as they build volcanic constructions. 2 Examining modern volcanoes and the ancient volcanic past can offer insights into the relationships between volcanic rocks, the sediment/petroleum systems associated with them and the exploration potential in volcanic basins – between hot rocks and oil. Seeing how modern sedimentary systems interact with volcanic eruptions and the resultant deposits provides a direct view of how both competing processes act on one another. Studying the ancient deposits preserved in onshore segments of volcanic systems also allows analogues to be drawn with offshore exploration targets3. These insights, when applied with other research findings, can improve the understanding of exploration plays, reduce risk and lead to better outcomes. The next stage is to investigate the role of volcanic margins in present and future natural resource exploration. WHAT ARE VOLCANIC MARGINS AND WHY MIGHT THEY BE IMPORTANT FOR NATURAL RESOURCE EXPLORATION? Many of the sedimentary basins that have accumulated the rocks that can create, trans- port and store oil and gas in the subsurface have also been the sites of major volcanic episodes in Earth’s history. At punctuated stages in the past there have been large volcanic eruptions, termed ‘flood basalts’, which have been responsible for millions of cubic kilometres of erupted rocks, and similar amounts of frozen magma, stored in the plumbing systems beneath these ancient volcanoes. These events leave footprints on the Earth’s surface known as large igneous provinces (LIPs)4. These flood basalts and their magma feeding systems are often found intricately associ- ated with some of the major sedimentary basins. A look at the world map (Figure 2) with indicated basins and volcanics paints this picture5, and helps geoscientists define areas where exploration of the sediments will be affected by volcanic rocks along ‘volca- nic margins’. Hydrocarbons, as well as aquifer reservoirs, occur in many of these prospective volcanic basins. It is believed that many more exist and are yet to be discovered. Figure 2. World map highlighting the main mafic large igneous provinces, sedimentary basins and the volcanic basins where there is a good association of the LIPs with sedimentary basins4, 5. 3 ISSUES WITH VOLCANIC ROCKS AND EXPLORATION In order to get an oil or gas prospect one needs what is known as the ‘5 steps to heaven’. 1. Reservoir – the rock mass that has void space to host the hydrocarbon. 2. Seal – a rock that is impermeable to the migration of hydrocarbons. 3. Trap – a structure/orientation of rock strata that will trap the migration of hydrocarbons to the surface. 4. Source – an organic-rich sediment that will mature with burial and lead to the production of hydrocarbons (e.g. organic shales, coal, etc.). 5. Timing/migration – the set of events that allows the maturation and migration of the hydrocarbons to occur after the trap is in place so that they are successfully fed into the reservoir. How these ‘5 steps to heaven’ are found in a volcanic basin will depend on the timing of the volcanic events, the intrusion of the magma through the sediments and the development of traps prior to any charging of hydrocarbons. Hot magma can, in principle, act as a heat source to mature the petroleum system. For the most part, thick igneous rocks are thought to have reasonably good sealing properties. It is also known from exposed rock sequences that volcanic rocks can have a variety of shapes and geometries that create traps. Volcanic rocks, however, are unlikely to be source rocks as they do not contain organic material. So the volcanic system—from intrusions through the basins to the eruptions at the sur- face—can contribute multiple scenarios that can lead to a working hydrocarbon prospect6,7. The most common volcanic margins are those found at rifting settings. This setting can be used to further explore what types of exploration targets may be available. A schematic vol- canic rifted margin is presented as a 3D model and in cross-section in Figure 3 (with various aspects of the potential petroleum system highlighted in Figure 3b)5. Mixed sequences of hydro volcanic and lava flows are found along with associated sills and dykes which form the plumbing systems of the volcanic margins underneath. These systems develop where the rifting apart of continents coincides with flood basalt volcanism and creates LIPs. With continued rifting, the volcanic deposits are preserved on either side of the rifted continents. Examples of these are the North and South Atlantic margins with the North Atlantic Igneous Province (NAIP) and the Parana-Etendeka Province (see map in Figure 2)8. In the rifted volcanic margin model, hydrocarbon reservoirs can be found in common styles of trap (e.g. structural, stratigraphic, etc.) in structures and sediments that are above (supra) or below (sub) the volcanics. The volcanic rocks might not have influenced the prospect, but may now cause imaging and drilling concerns. The emplacement of the volcanics through their plumbing systems of dykes and sill can create fluid migration pathways where hydro- carbons are channelled. This can create structures where hydrocarbons may be trapped. The intrusion of the hot magma into organic rich sediments may also affect and enhance the maturation, leading to the generation of hydrocarbons. A picture, therefore, develops where the presence of significant volcanic material can both hinder and be advantageous depending on the circumstances. There is a certain asymme- try to the distribution of the volcanic and intrusive rocks in this rifted margin model. The amount and thickness of the units change from very minor — in parts of the basins where only the sills are found — to much thicker, where the thick lava sequences and associated sills are found (e.g., Figure 3b). The existing and potential exploration into these thicker zones, however, can prove prob- lematic. Technical issues include imaging within and beneath the volcanics and the prospect of drilling through thick lava flows. 4 Figure 3. Volcanic rifted margins; a) schematic 3D cartoon of the development of a typical volcanic margin, b) the resultant cross-section of a typical volcanic rifted margin (e.g. NE Atlantic Margin), with volcanic facies and possible hydrocarbon traps and migration pathways indicated5. IMAGING BENEATH VOLCANICS In order to confidently explore the subsurface, successfully imaging possible hydrocarbon targets is important. This is where volcanic rocks provide a specific problem, often termed the ‘Sub-Basalt Imaging’ problem9. Volcanic intervals in the subsurface, usually thick sequences of basalt but can also include relatively thin horizons, often masks the rock units below. When imaging the Earth’s interior with seismic waves, the volcanic units contain high velocity horizons, a massive range in high to low velocity in repeated cycles within the volcanic stratigraphy. They can have markedly irregular surfaces and geometries compared to simple flat sediments. All of these factors can reduce the transmission of seismic energy below, provide increased noise and also lead to ‘false’ layers/structures (multiples) in the data. Oil and gas companies looking to drill in these challenging areas need as much ‘visible’ data as possible before deciding whether to engage. 5 Two possible solutions to the Sub-Basalt Imaging problem are to: 1. Find better ways to process existing data to emphasize the signal that one gets in the ‘sub-basalt’ domain. 2. Better design and plan new acquisitions where thick volcanic sequences are known to present a challenge. Improvements in acquiring new data include: 1. The position and recording of the seismic source at specific depths in the water. 2. The types of source fired. 3. The types and position of the receivers used. For example: long offset arrays of receivers, bespoke 3D seismic surveys and even ocean bottom situated seismometers. These are all designed to reduce the amount of noise and enhance low frequency data, which is known to penetrate through the volcanics.