When International Partnerships Go Wrong David Southwood Draws Lessons from a Crisis-Ridden Year for European Cooperation in Space

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

When International Partnerships Go Wrong David Southwood Draws Lessons from a Crisis-Ridden Year for European Cooperation in Space COMMENT CONSERVATION Advice for EXHIBITIONS Works by Damian MUSIC Darwinian algorithm OBITUARY Sally Ride, first biodiversity body from Hirst and Gunther von composes plausible US woman in space, the IPCC p.454 Hagens compared p.456 orchestral works p.458 remembered p.460 ESA/MEDIALAB Europe’s ExoMars mission aims to land a rover on Mars in 2018 to search for traces of life. When international partnerships go wrong David Southwood draws lessons from a crisis-ridden year for European cooperation in space. he recent discovery of the Higgs US funds from two major joint missions, projects while bearing in mind the possible boson by CERN, the European the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) withdrawal of players and curbing mission Organization for Nuclear Research and a planned mission to Jupiter. My suc- creep. Although it was the United States that Tmade up of 20 member states, shows how cessor, Alvaro Giménez, has already had withdrew as a major partner in the cases I international cooperation can lead to success worse: withdrawal of the United States from mention, the lessons are general and will in science that is otherwise unachievable. ExoMars, a Mars exploration programme. become increasingly important with the rise But there are challenges in working across All three cases played out differently. Each of large international collaborations involving borders. As the current crisis with the euro project holds lessons new players such as China, India and Russia. illustrates, political and financial problems NATURE.COM for managing future The nature of sovereign governments hit some partners harder than others. In my For more on collaborations, such means that rarely is an international agree- final year as director of Science and Robotic NASA’s Mars rover, as understanding part- ment to cooperate completely legally Exploration at the European Space Agency Curiosity, see: ners’ motivations for binding. A sense of solidarity among part- (ESA) in 2011, I had to face withdrawal of nature.com/curiosity joining, overseeing ners usually motivates them to remain 23 AUGUST 2012 | VOL 488 | NATURE | 451 © 2012 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved COMMENT committed, as with the JWST, for for life on the red planet. In this case, the US example. Cooperation between Europe and withdrawal has clearly damaged Europe’s ESA the United States on this infrared successor position, although not all the fault lies with to the Hubble Space Telescope began in 2002. the United States, which stepped in to help Europe agreed to provide the mid-infrared only in 2009 (see ‘ExoMars timeline’). instrument, the near-infrared spectrograph and an Ariane rocket as the launcher. The MISSION CREEP United States would provide the spacecraft Pulling together resources for a large and its operations, another instrument and programme is a long, difficult job with the complex deployable telescope. The Euro- numerous pitfalls. Projects start by con- pean instruments are now ready, but the US sensus-building. Compromise is the order side has seen financial over-runs and delays. of the day and so the first danger emerges: Launch is now expected in 2018, seven years features are added to win further support EXOMARS later than planned. from participating countries. ExoMars was TIMELINE In July 2011, after further escalations in vulnerable from the start. With participation How changing international collaborations budget requests for the JWST, a US House optional for ESA member states, and no for- have aected Europe’s next mission to Mars. of Representatives committee recommended mula to determine their share, each wanted cancelling the observatory. The Europeans an assured niche role before they committed. DECEMBE 2005 found themselves in the uncomfortable posi- So the ExoMars programme grew. European ministers approve agship ESA mission to Mars with Soyuz tion of having spent well over €100 million Expanding the scope improved the mission rocket launch in 2011. (US$123 million) with the possibility of no from a scientific and technical perspective, flight, and having no direct influence other but it became unwieldy and unaffordable. than moral pressure. In the end, delibera- The added complexity increased the risk JULY 2007 tions between the White House, Congress that some components would not work or First industry contracts awarded. Launch vehicles with more power and NASA — helped by diplomatic and might not be on time and budget. Vocal opti- than Soyuz are canvassed. political pressure from Europe — led to the mists dissuaded the prudent managers who project’s reprieve. wanted to drop modules to get more done. Instead, ESA sought new partners. JULY 2008 JUMPING SHIP The United States and Russia were ESA and NASA agree on joint studies towards returning samples from Mars. In February last year, the United States approached but didn’t sign up, partly because pulled out of a joint Jupiter mission, leaving of Europe’s need to stick to promises already Europe to go it alone. The mission was the made within the original European consor- JULY 2009 front-runner in a group of similar projects tium and because there was no joint goal for ESA and NASA approve under deliberation by the ESA science-advi- the potential partner to share. dual-mission Joint Mars Exploration sory groups. Fortunately, Europe had spent In 2008, I inherited the programme from Initiative (JMEI): an orbiter in 2016 and a rover in 2018 with US launch. only around €5 million on it. Because more another directorate. I went back to talk to missions enter the study phase than actu- NASA. The long-term goal of robotic explo- ally fly, this was not a disaster. But, without ration of Mars, as underscored a few years AUGUST 2009 the certainty of US involvement, long-term later by the 2011 US National Academy of Russia and ESA agree to planning by the Europeans was thrown into Sciences decadal survey, is to return sam- cooperate on two Mars missions: Phobos-Grunt and ExoMars. disarray. There were no alternative proposals ples. That will be expensive and cannot be involving only Europe. achieved by the United States alone. My The Europeans bounced back by resetting NASA counterpart, Ed Weiler, and I agreed OCTOBE 2009 the clock for entries to the competition, and that cooperation would be inevitable at JMEI scenario expands: an ESA by rethinking and reconstructing several some point in the next decade. Once this lander in 2016 and two rovers in missions with reduced goals. A final ESA was accepted, it was rational to start work- 2018, one from each agency. go-ahead for the Jupiter mission came in ing together as early as possible. May 2012. Costing €830 million, the planned The design of ExoMars was modified to DECEMBE 2009 Jupiter Icy Moons Explorer (JUICE) aims to suit common European and US goals and to European governments approve a fly past Europa and Callisto and then orbit allow sample return. It seemed a win–win €1-billion Mars programme with NASA. Ganymede and study its subsurface ocean in arrangement: ExoMars was able to continue, 2030. US scientists are anxious to get back on and the prospect of sample return from Mars board, and NASA has just found US$100 mil- moved closer for both US and European sci- APIL 20 lion to secure some participation. entists. I felt confident as the European side NASA cancels its 2018 rover as ExoMars, a €1-billion mission for Europe of ExoMars moved into the development US budget crisis hits. alone, is a different story. This February, the phase in early 2011. No one foresaw that United States pulled out, leaving Europe with the US priority for a joint Mars programme FEBUAY 20 2 a funding gap of up to €250 million and hav- would founder as soon as the next annual NASA ends its ing already spent more than €100 million. budget cycle. involvement in ExoMars. Given the committed industrial contracts, Although such let-downs are merci- cancellation would cost up to €400 million. fully rare, a similar thing happened around MACH 20 2 The flagship mission to send an orbiter 30 years ago in the first months of President ESA conrms ExoMars go-ahead and rover to Mars by 2018 started with Ronald Reagan’s administration. NASA, faced with Russia as main partner. purely European ambitions in 2005 — to with a funding crisis, was forced to choose develop regional expertise in exploration between the Hubble Space Telescope, the technologies and to apply methods to search Galileo Jupiter orbiter and the International 452 | NATURE | VOL 488 | 23 AUGUST 2012 © 2012 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved COMMENT of a more effective mission. The European GAIA mission to map and track the stars in the Galaxy, scheduled for launch next year, was targeted for cancellation because of a financial crisis in 2001, shortly after my appointment at ESA. A major descoping took place but the programme survived. I am sure it will be a success. Third, one needs to ensure that manage- rial risk inside programmes is minimized by making partners’ contributions as modular as possible. If one part fails, it need not hin- der the whole. Efficiency gains follow, and the programme retains the potential to change partners. Of course, discrepancies in schedule-keeping will leave open the situa- tion where one partner moves ahead of the other (as with the JWST), but the modular approach avoids many potential log-jams. Fourth, be aware that even the most thor- oughly crafted agreements between nations can be broken. It seemed unthinkable that NASA would drop a Mars sample-return mission deemed as a first priority in the dec- adal review, but it happened. Managers must always consider the possibility of cooperation breakdown as a risk.
Recommended publications
  • Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter Navigation Strategy for the Exomars Schiaparelli EDM Lander Mission
    Jet Propulsion Laboratory California Institute of Technology Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter Navigation Strategy for the ExoMars Schiaparelli EDM Lander Mission Premkumar R. Menon Sean V. Wagner, David C. Jefferson, Eric J. Graat, Kyong J. Lee, and William B. Schulze AAS/AIAA Astrodynamics Specialist Conference San Antonio, Texas February 5–9, 2017 AAS Paper 17-337 © 2017 California Institute of Technology. Government Sponsorship Acknowledged. Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter Project Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (Mission, Spacecraft and PSO) The Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter mission launched in August 2005 from the Cape Canaveral Air Force Station arriving at Mars in March 2006 started science operations in November 2006. MRO has completed 10 years since launch (50,000 orbits by Mar 2017) and to date has returned nearly 300 Terabytes of data. MRO Primary Science Orbit (PSO): • Sun-synchronous orbit ascending node at 3:00 PM ± 15 minutes Local Mean Solar Time (LMST) (daylight equatorial crossing) • Periapsis is frozen about the Mars South Pole • Near-repeat ground track walk (GTW) every 17-day, 211 orbit (short-term repeat) MRO targeting cycle, exact repeat after 4602 orbits. The nominal GTW is 32.45811 km West each 211 orbit cycle (maintained with periodic maneuvers). MRO Spacecraft: • Spacecraft Bus: 3-axis stabilized ACS system; 3-meter diameter High Gain Antenna; hydrazine propulsion system • Instrument Suite: HiRISE Camera, CRISM Imaging spectrometer, Mars Climate Sounder, Mars Color Imager, Context Camera, Shallow Subsurface Radar, Electra engineering payload (among other instrument payloads) 2/07/17 MRO support of ExoMars Schiaparelli Lander Overflight Relay PRM-3 4. MRO shall have good overflight pass geometry within the first 2 Sols after landing.
    [Show full text]
  • AE Newsletter 2020
    Colonel Shorty Powers Composite Squadron July 25, 2020 AEROSPACE Aircraft | Spacecraft | Biography | Squadron Gen. Ira C. Eaker A New Eagle Boeing to build new F-15EXs for USAF The Department of the Air Force and Boeing recently signed a deal worth 1.2 billion dollars for the first lot of eight F-15EX jets that will be delivered to Eglin Air Force Base, Florida. The aircraft will replace the oldest F-15Cs and F-15Ds in the U.S. Air Force fleet. The first two already built F-15EX aircraft will be delivered during the second quarter of 2021, while the remaining aircraft will be delivered in 2023. The Air Force plans to buy 76 F-15EX aircraft. The new F-15EX was developed to meet needs identified by the National Defense Strategy review which directed the U.S. armed services to adapt to the new threats from China and Russia. The most burdensome requirement is the need for the Air Force to add 74 new squadrons to the existing 312 squadrons by 2030. The General Ira C. Eaker was one of the forefathers of an independent Air Force. With General (then major) Spaatz, in 1929 Eaker remained aloft aboard The Question Mark, a modified Atlantic-Fokker C-2A, for nearly a week, to demonstrate a newfound capability of aerial refueling. During WWII, Eaker rose to the grade of lieutenant general and commanded the Eighth Air Force, "The Mighty Eighth" force of strategic The first F-15EX being assembled at Boeing facilities. (Photo: Boeing) Aerospace Newsletter 1 Colonel Shorty Powers Composite Squadron July 25, 2020 Eaker (continued) Air Force also seeks to lower the average aircraft age of 28 years down to 15 years without losing any capacity.
    [Show full text]
  • Exomars Schiaparelli Direct-To-Earth Observation Using GMRT
    TECHNICAL ExoMars Schiaparelli Direct-to-Earth Observation REPORTS: METHODS 10.1029/2018RS006707 using GMRT S. Esterhuizen1, S. W. Asmar1 ,K.De2, Y. Gupta3, S. N. Katore3, and B. Ajithkumar3 Key Point: • During ExoMars Landing, GMRT 1Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA, 2Cahill Center for Astrophysics, observed UHF transmissions and California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA, 3National Centre for Radio Astrophysics, Pune, India Doppler shift used to identify key events as only real-time aliveness indicator Abstract During the ExoMars Schiaparelli separation event on 16 October 2016 and Entry, Descent, and Landing (EDL) events 3 days later, the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) near Pune, India, Correspondence to: S. W. Asmar, was used to directly observe UHF transmissions from the Schiaparelli lander as they arrive at Earth. The [email protected] Doppler shift of the carrier frequency was measured and used as a diagnostic to identify key events during EDL. This signal detection at GMRT was the only real-time aliveness indicator to European Space Agency Citation: mission operations during the critical EDL stage of the mission. Esterhuizen, S., Asmar, S. W., De, K., Gupta, Y., Katore, S. N., & Plain Language Summary When planetary missions, such as landers on the surface of Mars, Ajithkumar, B. (2019). ExoMars undergo critical and risky events, communications to ground controllers is very important as close to real Schiaparelli Direct-to-Earth observation using GMRT. time as possible. The Schiaparelli spacecraft attempted landing in 2016 was supported in an innovative way. Radio Science, 54, 314–325. A large radio telescope on Earth was able to eavesdrop on information being sent from the lander to other https://doi.org/10.1029/2018RS006707 spacecraft in orbit around Mars.
    [Show full text]
  • Ulysses Awardees
    Ulysses Awardees Irish Higher Project Leader - Project Leader - French Higher Funding Education Disciplinary Area Project Title Ireland France Education Institution Institution Comparing Laws with Help from Humanities including Peter Arnds IRC / Embassy TCD Renaud Colson ENSCM, Montpellier the Humanities: Translation Theory languages, Law to the Rescue of Legal Studies Novel biomarkers of interplay between neuroglobin and George Barreto HRB / Embassy UL Karim Belarbi Université de Nantes Life Sciences neuroinflammation in Parkinson’s disease Geometric Constructions of Codes Eimear Byrne IRC / Embassy UCD Martino Borello University of Lille Mathematics for Secret Sharing Schemes BOUHÉREAU: EXILE, TOLERATION Didier Poton de Humanities including Derval Conroy IRC / Embassy UCD University Paris 8 - LAGA AND CARE IN THE EARLY MODERN Xaintrailles languages PERIOD Knotting peptides for DNA Fabian Cougnon IRC / Embassy NUIG Sebastian Ulrich La Rochelle University Chemistry recognition and gene delivery Automating Segmentation and Computer Science & Kathleen Curran HRB / Embassy UCD David Bendahan Muscle Architecture Analysis from Telecommunications Aix Marseille University Diffusion Tensor Imaging The Impact of Student Exchanges Social science and Ronald Davies IRC / Embassy UCD Farid Toubal on International Trade: The Role of University of Paris- economics Cultural Similarity Dauphine -- PSL Computer Science & Three dimensional audio and Gordon Delap IRC / Embassy MU Thibaud Keller Telecommunications musical experimentation CNRS – LaBRI Multi-scale,
    [Show full text]
  • Mars 2020 Radiological Contingency Planning
    National Aeronautics and Space Administration Mars 2020 Radiological Contingency Planning NASA plans to launch the Mars 2020 rover, produce the rover’s onboard power and to Perseverance, in summer 2020 on a mission warm its internal systems during the frigid to seek signs of habitable conditions in Mars’ Martian night. ancient past and search for signs of past microbial life. The mission will lift off from Cape NASA prepares contingency response plans Canaveral Air Force Station in Florida aboard a for every launch that it conducts. Ensuring the United Launch Alliance Atlas V launch vehicle safety of launch-site workers and the public in between mid-July and August 2020. the communities surrounding the launch area is the primary consideration in this planning. The Mars 2020 rover design is based on NASA’s Curiosity rover, which landed on Mars in 2012 This contingency planning task takes on an and greatly increased our knowledge of the added dimension when the payload being Red Planet. The Mars 2020 rover is equipped launched into space contains nuclear material. to study its landing site in detail and collect and The primary goal of radiological contingency store the most promising samples of rock and planning is to enable an efficient response in soil on the surface of Mars. the event of an accident. This planning is based on the fundamental principles of advance The system that provides electrical power for preparation (including rehearsals of simulated Mars 2020 and its scientific equipment is the launch accident responses), the timely availability same as for the Curiosity rover: a Multi- of technically accurate and reliable information, Mission Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generator and prompt external communication with the (MMRTG).
    [Show full text]
  • Let's Go to a Comet!
    Mission Rosetta Let’s go to a comet! Elsa Montagnon European Space Agency 1 What is left to explore today? 15th century Credits: ESA/AOES Medialab 21st century 2 Back to the origins… 3 What has happened since the big bang? Big bang 13 billion years ago ejects hydrogen and helium From elements to dust From water to heavy elements From dust to gas From solar cloud to the solar system: planets, asteroids, comets 4 How do we see the solar system today? Galactic Tides Nearby Stars Large Clouds LPidCtLong Period Comets Short Period Comets Galactic Tides Inner Outer Oort Oort Pluto Cloud Cloud ? Stable Stable Kuiper Belt 10 Gy 1 Gy ? 10 50 100 Alpha I, e 1000 Centauri 10^4 Ejected AU 10^5 3.10^5 5 Where are we going? Comet 67P / Churyumow-Gerasimenko 3-D reconstruction of nucleus based on 12 March, 2003 Hubble Space Telescope observations Nucleus diameter: 4km Discovered in 1969 Orbital period: 6.6 years Pole End Side Nasa, Esa and Philippe Lamy (Laboratoire d’Astrobomie Spatiale) - STScl-PRC03-26 6 A picture of the comet… Credits: ESA and European Southern Observatory 7 The Mission Rendezvous with the comet shortly after aphelion Follow the comet up to perihelion and beyond Deploy a lander on the comet surface QuickTime™ and a YUV420 codec decompressor are needed to see this picture. 8 The Journey Launch: March 2004 Launcher: Ariane 5 Rendezvous with comet: August 2014 Distance: 6.5 billions km Cruise duration: 10 years Mission duration: 2 years 9 The Cruise The comet is very far away.
    [Show full text]
  • CEAS Quarterly Bulletin Talented Engineers Are Needed
    The Quarterly Bulletin of the COUNCIL OF EUROPEAN AEROSPACE SOCIETIES 3AF– AIAE– AIDAA– DGLR– FSAE– FTF– HAES– NVvL– RAeS– SVFW–TsAGI • GENERAL • AERONAUTICS • SPACE • Issue 2 – 2009 • June • Editorial INVESTING IN YOUTH The future of Europe is in the hands of its youth: this is a basic truth. However, surprisingly, while we are full in course of the election campaign for the renewal of the European Parliament, we hear almost nothing about education and culture, and we see no proposals from the candidates on how to prepare the students and young professionals to live in an increasingly integrated Europe. The question is a very broad and difficult one, due to the large number of Member States and the diversity of languages and cultures; but this is all the more reason to concentrate great efforts on it. In the aerospace sector, the projects, more and more complex, are developed across several national borders and include the highest technologies. So, to overcome the Jean-Pierre Sanfourche numerous challenges which confront us in a fierce world-wide aerospace market, Editor-in-Chief, CEAS Quarterly Bulletin talented engineers are needed. Unfortunately, in the past two or three decades within Europe, there have been clear indications that the most brilliant students pre- fer careers in business and finance to those in science, technology and engineering. Action is clearly necessary to reverse this trend by taking the measures that will CONTENTS allow us to attract and then retain the best talent in the air and space activities. The GENERAL Pages organising Committee of the upcoming CEAS2009 Air & Space Conference in Manchester has taken an important step in this direction by including in the • The ASD President’s message 2 Conference agenda the launch of a new European Young Aerospace Professional • The life of the CEAS 4 (EYAP) forum.
    [Show full text]
  • List of Missions Using SPICE (PDF)
    1/7/20 Data Restorations Selected Past Users Current/Pending Users Examples of Possible Future Users Apollo 15, 16 [L] Magellan [L] Cassini Orbiter NASA Discovery Program Mariner 2 [L] Clementine (NRL) Mars Odyssey NASA New Frontiers Program Mariner 9 [L] Mars 96 (RSA) Mars Exploration Rover Lunar IceCube (Moorehead State) Mariner 10 [L] Mars Pathfinder Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter LunaH-Map (Arizona State) Viking Orbiters [L] NEAR Mars Science Laboratory Luna-Glob (RSA) Viking Landers [L] Deep Space 1 Juno Aditya-L1 (ISRO) Pioneer 10/11/12 [L] Galileo MAVEN Examples of Users not Requesting NAIF Help Haley armada [L] Genesis SMAP (Earth Science) GOLD (LASP, UCF) (Earth Science) [L] Phobos 2 [L] (RSA) Deep Impact OSIRIS REx Hera (ESA) Ulysses [L] Huygens Probe (ESA) [L] InSight ExoMars RSP (ESA, RSA) Voyagers [L] Stardust/NExT Mars 2020 Emmirates Mars Mission (UAE via LASP) Lunar Orbiter [L] Mars Global Surveyor Europa Clipper Hayabusa-2 (JAXA) Helios 1,2 [L] Phoenix NISAR (NASA and ISRO) Proba-3 (ESA) EPOXI Psyche Parker Solar Probe GRAIL Lucy EUMETSAT GEO satellites [L] DAWN Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter MOM (ISRO) Messenger Mars Express (ESA) Chandrayan-2 (ISRO) Phobos Sample Return (RSA) ExoMars 2016 (ESA, RSA) Solar Orbiter (ESA) Venus Express (ESA) Akatsuki (JAXA) STEREO [L] Rosetta (ESA) Korean Pathfinder Lunar Orbiter (KARI) Spitzer Space Telescope [L] [L] = limited use Chandrayaan-1 (ISRO) New Horizons Kepler [L] [S] = special services Hayabusa (JAXA) JUICE (ESA) Hubble Space Telescope [S][L] Kaguya (JAXA) Bepicolombo (ESA, JAXA) James Webb Space Telescope [S][L] LADEE Altius (Belgian earth science satellite) ISO [S] (ESA) Armadillo (CubeSat, by UT at Austin) Last updated: 1/7/20 Smart-1 (ESA) Deep Space Network Spectrum-RG (RSA) NAIF has or had project-supplied funding to support mission operations, consultation for flight team members, and SPICE data archive preparation.
    [Show full text]
  • Mars Science Laboratory: Curiosity Rover Curiosity’S Mission: Was Mars Ever Habitable? Acquires Rock, Soil, and Air Samples for Onboard Analysis
    National Aeronautics and Space Administration Mars Science Laboratory: Curiosity Rover www.nasa.gov Curiosity’s Mission: Was Mars Ever Habitable? acquires rock, soil, and air samples for onboard analysis. Quick Facts Curiosity is about the size of a small car and about as Part of NASA’s Mars Science Laboratory mission, Launch — Nov. 26, 2011 from Cape Canaveral, tall as a basketball player. Its large size allows the rover Curiosity is the largest and most capable rover ever Florida, on an Atlas V-541 to carry an advanced kit of 10 science instruments. sent to Mars. Curiosity’s mission is to answer the Arrival — Aug. 6, 2012 (UTC) Among Curiosity’s tools are 17 cameras, a laser to question: did Mars ever have the right environmental Prime Mission — One Mars year, or about 687 Earth zap rocks, and a drill to collect rock samples. These all conditions to support small life forms called microbes? days (~98 weeks) help in the hunt for special rocks that formed in water Taking the next steps to understand Mars as a possible and/or have signs of organics. The rover also has Main Objectives place for life, Curiosity builds on an earlier “follow the three communications antennas. • Search for organics and determine if this area of Mars was water” strategy that guided Mars missions in NASA’s ever habitable for microbial life Mars Exploration Program. Besides looking for signs of • Characterize the chemical and mineral composition of Ultra-High-Frequency wet climate conditions and for rocks and minerals that ChemCam Antenna rocks and soil formed in water, Curiosity also seeks signs of carbon- Mastcam MMRTG • Study the role of water and changes in the Martian climate over time based molecules called organics.
    [Show full text]
  • Solar Orbiter Assessment Study and Model Payload
    Solar Orbiter assessment study and model payload N.Rando(1), L.Gerlach(2), G.Janin(4), B.Johlander(1), A.Jeanes(1), A.Lyngvi(1), R.Marsden(3), A.Owens(1), U.Telljohann(1), D.Lumb(1) and T.Peacock(1). (1) Science Payload & Advanced Concepts Office, (2) Electrical Engineering Department, (3) Research and Scientific Support Department, European Space Agency, ESTEC, Postbus 299, NL-2200AG, Noordwijk, The Netherlands (4) Mission Analysis Office, European Space Agency, ESOC, Darmstadt, Germany ABSTRACT The Solar Orbiter mission is presently in assessment phase by the Science Payload and Advanced Concepts Office of the European Space Agency. The mission is confirmed in the Cosmic Vision programme, with the objective of a launch in October 2013 and no later than May 2015. The Solar Orbiter mission incorporates both a near-Sun (~0.22 AU) and a high-latitude (~ 35 deg) phase, posing new challenges in terms of protection from the intense solar radiation and related spacecraft thermal control, to remain compatible with the programmatic constraints of a medium class mission. This paper provides an overview of the assessment study activities, with specific emphasis on the definition of the model payload and its accommodation in the spacecraft. The main results of the industrial activities conducted with Alcatel Space and EADS-Astrium are summarized. Keywords: Solar physics, space weather, instrumentation, mission assessment, Solar Orbiter 1. INTRODUCTION The Solar Orbiter mission was first discussed at the Tenerife “Crossroads” workshop in 1998, in the framework of the ESA Solar Physics Planning Group. The mission was submitted to ESA in 2000 and then selected by ESA’s Science Programme Committee in October 2000 to be implemented as a flexi-mission, with a launch envisaged in the 2008- 2013 timeframe (after the BepiColombo mission to Mercury) [1].
    [Show full text]
  • A Clearer Final Frontier of the Sentinel Family of Earth-Monitoring Satellites
    COMMENT BOOKS & ARTS Station. His examination of other astro- nomical and exploration cooperation efforts is somewhat cursory, and there are small errors. The Rosetta mission of the Euro- pean Space Agency (ESA), for instance, is ROGER HARRIS/SPL not a solar mission, but instead will rendez- vous with and observe a comet. The lunar probe Chandrayaan-1 was a collaboration between India, ESA, NASA and Bulgaria; and unmentioned is the ground-breaking Double Star Sino-European joint mission. Failures in cooperation offer many lessons, and Moltz looks at the International Solar Polar Mission almost 25 years ago, as well as the United States’ 2012 pull-out from collaboration with ESA on Mars explora- tion. However, he misses the pivotal case of the International Gamma-Ray Laboratory (INTEGRAL), launched in 2002, the absence of expected levels of US support for which led to the first close ESA Science Programme cooperation with Russia. The distinction between cooperation and competition had, however, emerged decades before, with US refusal to launch the Franco-German com- munications satellite Symphonie. Europe learnt that it had to go it alone in using space for commercial or near-to-market purposes. Satellite deployment must be regulated to keep space usable and safe. Moltz accepts that space is important to commerce, but readers might query whether SPACE POLICY he sees how this may drive regulation. The European Union, the largest economic grouping in the world, is this year launching multiple spacecraft; these include members A clearer final frontier of the Sentinel family of Earth-monitoring satellites. The move is economic, and the use David Southwood finds that a study on safeguarding of space is evolving and increasingly focused space is shorter on cooperation than conflict.
    [Show full text]
  • Exploration of Mars by the European Space Agency 1
    Exploration of Mars by the European Space Agency Alejandro Cardesín ESA Science Operations Mars Express, ExoMars 2016 IAC Winter School, November 20161 Credit: MEX/HRSC History of Missions to Mars Mars Exploration nowadays… 2000‐2010 2011 2013/14 2016 2018 2020 future … Mars Express MAVEN (ESA) TGO Future ESA (ESA- Studies… RUSSIA) Odyssey MRO Mars Phobos- Sample Grunt Return? (RUSSIA) MOM Schiaparelli ExoMars 2020 Phoenix (ESA-RUSSIA) Opportunity MSL Curiosity Mars Insight 2020 Spirit The data/information contained herein has been reviewed and approved for release by JPL Export Administration on the basis that this document contains no export‐controlled information. Mars Express 2003-2016 … First European Mission to orbit another Planet! First mission of the “Rosetta family” Up and running since 2003 Credit: MEX/HRSC First European Mission to orbit another Planet First European attempt to land on another Planet Original mission concept Credit: MEX/HRSC December 2003: Mars Express Lander Release and Orbit Insertion Collission trajectory Bye bye Beagle 2! Last picture Lander after release, release taken by VMC camera Insertion 19/12/2003 8:33 trajectory Credit: MEX/HRSC Beagle 2 was found in January 2015 ! Only 6km away from landing site OK Open petals indicate soft landing OK Antenna remained covered Lessons learned: comms at all time! Credit: MEX/HRSC Mars Express: so many missions at once Mars Mission Phobos Mission Relay Mission Credit: MEX/HRSC Mars Express science investigations Martian Moons: Phobos & Deimos: Ionosphere, surface,
    [Show full text]