DOCSLIB.ORG

Cgcopyright 2012 Shauna Foley Fisher

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Cgcopyright 2012 Shauna Foley Fisher c Copyright 2012 Shauna Foley Fisher The Dance of Policy Argumentation: Recasting the Same-Sex Marriage Debate Shauna Foley Fisher A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Washington 2012 Michael McCann, Chair George Lovell Peter May Program Authorized to Offer Degree: Political Science University of Washington Abstract The Dance of Policy Argumentation: Recasting the Same-Sex Marriage Debate Shauna Foley Fisher Chair of the Supervisory Committee: Professor Michael McCann Department of Political Science This project is motivated by a desire to examine the patterns that evolve as activists and their opponents struggle to control how the public and policymakers understand a particu- lar issue at the center of contention. Competing activist groups fight in a context shaped by two important dynamics. As advocacy groups pursue change, or attempt to block change, they must confront the mobilizing activities of their opponents. The first question addressed by this project comes out of this dynamic. Do activists engage, anticipate, or ignore their opponents’ messages? The second dynamic is the characteristics of particular institutional venues. Activist groups encounter different sets of institutional processes while fighting for their side through litigation than through ballot measure campaigns, for example. This raises a second question. Do activists change their messages for different institutional are- nas and venues? Finally, the media are central to contentious politics, but are not directly responsible for policymaking. They are, however, partially responsible for making the pub- lic and policymakers aware of the messages and activities of activists on either side. Thus the third and final question motivating this project is: what is the role of the media in contentious politics? I address these questions through an analysis of press release, newspaper, and cam- paign materials from same-sex marriage activists and their opponents in California. My findings challenge common assumptions about the dance of contentious politics and have implications for concerns about deliberative democracy. I find that groups talk past each other more than they respond, engaging in largely separate rhetorical dances. Competing groups also pay more attention to those policy venues that appeal to their favored argu- ments, leading competing groups to devote attention to different institutions. Furthermore, these largely separate framing activities are done consistently regardless of policymaking venue. However, scholars and general audiences may be ignorant to this reality because the media construct, or “choreograph,” dialogue. While activists engage in an agenda set- ting game, talking about what they want, rather than engaging their opponents, newspapers construct a debate out of the largely separate framing strategies. In other words, the media choreograph a dance out of what are primarily separate routines. TABLE OF CONTENTS Page List of Figures . ii List of Tables . iv Chapter 1: Introduction . 1 Chapter 2: Talking Past Each Other: Press Release Framing of Same-Sex Marriage 29 Chapter 3: A Tale of Two Campaigns: Framing Same-Sex Marriage for Califor- nia’s Fourth Branch . 75 Chapter 4: Choreographing the Marriage Dance: Media Coverage of Same-Sex Marriage in California . 125 Chapter 5: Conclusion . 169 Bibliography . 177 i LIST OF FIGURES Figure Number Page 2.1 Time series graph of the counts of press releases collected per month across the time period 2004-2009 . 36 2.2 Time series graph of rights and rights related argument frames, 2004-2009 . 48 2.3 Time series graph of argument frames related to the separation of powers in a federalist government, 2004-2009 . 52 2.4 Time series graph of argument frames highlighting the potential impacts of same-sex marriage, 2004-2009 . 61 2.5 Time series graph of argument frames related to the legality or constitution- ality of same-sex marriage 2004-2009 . 67 2.6 Time series graph of argument frames related to family and children, 2004- 2009 . 68 3.1 Times series graph of rights and rights related argument frames during the Proposition 22 and Proposition 8 campaigns . 95 3.2 Time series graph of argument frames related to the separation of powers in a federalist government during the Proposition 22 and Proposition 8 cam- paigns . 103 3.3 Times series graph of argument frames related to family and children dur- ing the Proposition 22 and Proposition 8 campaigns . 109 3.4 Times series graph of argument frames highlighting the potential impacts of same-sex marriage during the Proposition 22 and Proposition 8 campaigns118 3.5 Times series graph of argument frames highlighting the legality and consti- tutional of same-sex marriage policy and Proposition 8 during and after the initiative campaign . 122 4.1 Time series graph of the count of newspaper articles on same-sex marriage in California from January 1996 through December 2009 . 134 4.2 Comparison of levels of argumentation regarding same-sex marriage in press releases and newspaper articles . 148 ii 4.3 Time series graph comparing arguments in same-sex marriage opponents” press releases and arguments attributed to opponents in newspaper articles, 2004-2009 . 153 4.4 Time series graph comparing arguments in same-sex marriage activists’ press releases to arguments attributed to marriage activists in newspaper articles, 2004-2009 . 156 4.5 Time series graph of argument frames highlighting the potential impacts of same-sex marriage attributed to activists in the media . 157 iii LIST OF TABLES Table Number Page 2.1 Count of Press Releases by Venue and Year . 35 2.2 Percentage of Press Releases by Venue, 2003-2009 . 43 2.3 Argument Frame Codebook . 47 2.4 Ranking of Frames by Venue Category - SSM proponents . 64 2.5 Ranking of Frames by Venue Category - SSM opponents . 64 3.1 Counts of Press Releases Focusing on the Ballot . 85 3.2 Argument Frame Counts in Ballot Related Press Releases . 88 3.3 Argument Frame Counts in Campaign Commercials . 91 4.1 Newspaper Article Sampling Scheme . 131 4.2 Newspaper Articles that Do/Do Not Explicitly Reference Arguments At- tributed to Pro and Anti SSM Groups by Category, 1985-2009 . 143 4.3 Argument Frame Counts in Newspaper Articles . 146 4.4 Proportions of Attention to Arguments in Press Releases and Newspaper Articles . 151 4.5 Ranking of Frames Attributed to SSM Proponents in Media by Venue Cat- egory . 160 4.6 Ranking of Frames Attributed to SSM Opponents in Media by Venue Cat- egory . 160 4.7 Sample of groups recorded as having at least one argument attributed to them168 iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS There is that saying about how it takes a village to raise a child. While I can not speak to child rearing, I can say that completing a dissertation and receiving a PhD can often feel similarly. I owe gratitude to so many, and fear I could never satisfactorily express my thanks in a way that does not rival the length of a chapter. But, I must try. This dissertation, like so many others, is the result of many years of work. I would be doing them a disservice if I did not start by thanking my committee members, The Gentlemen, who so generously devoted pieces of themselves to me during that time. He is now in Austin, and did not stick around to see this project through to the end, but I have Bryan Jones to thank for being in the original version of my committee and introducing me to a new body of scholarship that would remain important through the dissertation. Peter May is everything his former graduate students praise him to be: an incredible advisor and mentor. He willingly joined my committee in my last two years and supported me as if he had been around all along. George Lovell has been around from the beginning and is such pleasure to work with. He has been an enormous help transforming my project into something we all found more exciting. I look so forward to remaining a colleague of his as my career progresses. And then there is Michael McCann. It is truly a remarkable thing, getting to work with a person–an intellect–that one respects as much as I do him. I will never forget the first time I read Rights at Work as an undergraduate. I am not sure he fully appreciates the influence his ideas had on me so many years ago, before we ever met. Even at my most frustrating, Michael encouraged me, supported me, and promoted me. I owe it to him, if I owe it to anyone along with myself, to work on battling those demons. I did not always make his job as my Chair easy (in fact, I rarely did), and I only hope that I have made him proud. I can not do justice to the people and forces that helped get me here without going back to my years in Albany. It was there that I met Scott Barclay. I will never fully understand how he saw something in me so quickly, but Scott took me under his wing and introduced me to the world of academics. He became and remains an important mentor, friend, co- author, and colleague. Scott also introduced me to my intellectual family, the people I look forward to seeing every year at the Law & Society Meetings. There are so many incredible, smart people that I could in no way name them all, but I must at least recognize Anna-Maria Marshall. Even while still an undergraduate, Anna made me feel welcome. Throughout my graduate career she has been one of my best cheerleaders. I was lucky enough to be surrounded by an incredible group of fellow graduate students, who often became good friends, during my time at the University of Washington.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Academic Calendar
    > > > ACADEMIC CALENDAR 2005-2006 ACADEMIC CALENDAR FALL SEMESTER 2005 August 5 ExL registration begins for students within an 85-mile radius of the Kentucky Campus for fall 2005 31-Sept. 2 Orientation and Registration for new students, Kentucky September 6 Classes begin 6 Opening Convocation, Kentucky 8 Opening Convocation, Florida 13, 15, 20, 22 Holiness Chapels 16 Last day to drop a course with a refund; close of all registration for additional classes 30 Payment of fees due in Business Office October 18-21 Kingdom Conference Speakers: Asbury Community 21 Last day to withdraw from the institution with a prorated refund; last day to drop a course without a grade of “F” November 3-4 Ryan Lectures Speaker: • Dr. Miroslav Volf, Professor of Systematic Theology, Yale University Divinity School 18 Last day to remove incompletes (spring and summer) 21 - 25 Fall Reading Week December 4 Advent Service 6 Baccalaureate and Commencement, Wilmore 12-16 Final Exams 16 Semester ends JANUARY TERM 2006 January 3 Classes begin 5 Last day to drop a course with a refund; close of registration for addition al courses 9 ExL registration begins for students within an 85-mile radius of the Kentucky Campus for spring 2006 13 Last day to drop a course without a grade of “F” 16 Martin Luther King Day, No Classes 20 Payment of fees due in Business Office 27 Final exams, term ends Jan. 30 - Feb. 2 2006 Ministry Conference 2 Academic Calendar 3 SPRING SEMESTER 2006 February 3 Spring Orientation 6 Classes begin 15-16 Beeson Lectures Speaker: • The Reverend Jim Garlow, Senior Pastor at Skyline Church, San Diego, CA 17 Last day to drop a course with refund; close of all registration for additional courses March 3 Payment of fees due in the Business Office 9, 10 Theta Phi Lectures Speaker: • Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Trafficking
    San Diego County Edition Vol. 30, No. 3 March 2012 www.christianexaminer.com Cal Thomas Ministry Christian School Guide Losing liberty: A Abused children fi nd 13 San Diego County FREE slippery slope that refuge at residential Christian Schools is an avalanche ministry showcased page 7 page 10 pages 14-17 Human Traffi cking What is the church’s role in curbing this seedy side of American culture? By Lori Arnold EL CAJON — Ginger Shaw has spent the better part of two decades enmeshed in church life by leading Bible studies and training sessions, San Diego residents Burton and Kat Sue have left San Diego for a yearlong coordinating Vacation Bible School creative arts outreach for victims of last year’s earthquake and tsunami. He will and Angel Tree projects. These teach drawing classes, and she will offer gospel hula lessons. days she prefers the craggy asphalt of truck stops. “I was so inundated with what was Local couple to use going on in the church,” she said, adding that the Lord had some- thing else in mind for her. “He re- art and hula to bring vealed to me that I needed to get out there, and not just out of my comfort zone. He said I needed to spiritual hope to Japan get out there ‘doing the call I have By Lori Arnold you have to put your trust in some- for you.’” thing else because nothing material It was that command that led her SAN DIEGO — Ten months after is left.” to this place, where she straddles a monster 9.0-earthquake and sub- The San Diego couple, mem- her life between the comfort and sequent tsunami plundered Japan, bers of San Diego Japanese Chris- safety of her church and the seedy annihilating the landscape and life- tian Church, said they hope to use side of American culture—human styles of many of its residents, Bur- creative arts to fi ll the physical and traffi cking.
    [Show full text]
  • FFRF Sues School Districts Over Ten Commandments
    Vol. 29 No. 8 Published by the Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc. October 2012 ‘God should be in school with our children’ FFRF sues school districts over Ten Commandments The Freedom From Religion Foun- spoke to the “crowd” of 50, accord- Dawkins draws nearly 900 to convention dation has filed two lawsuits that con- ing to the Valley News Dispatch. “We God Delusion author Richard Dawkins accepts an Emperor Has test Ten Commandments monuments don’t want it removed. This is part of No Clothes Award on Oct. 12 at FFRF’s 35th annual national at Pennsylvania schools. One suit was our community. They’ll lock up the convention in Portland, Ore. For more coverage, see pages 11-14, filed Sept. 27 in U.S. District Court in churches and we’ll be just like a com- page 22 and the back page. (Photo by Andy Ngo) Pittsburgh against the Connellsville munist country.” Area School District for a marker at a At a similar event in Connellsville, edict, and Doe 2, a student at Valley In 2002, FFRF successfully removed junior high school. a woman told WTAE-4 that the monu- High School, along with Doe 3, parent one of the first such monuments FFRF, on behalf of two local “Doe” ments contain “God’s principles” and and guardian of Doe 2. placed on public property in the city plaintiffs, seeks a declaration that the should stay. “I believe that God should The Valley News Dispatch reported of Milwaukee. Actor Yul Brenner, who display is unconstitutional and should be in school with our children.” that Schaub came to a pro-Command- played Rameses II in the movie, had at- be removed.
    [Show full text]
  • Response Due February 6, 2017
    No. 16-______ ================================================================ In The Supreme Court of the United States --------------------------------- --------------------------------- DONALD WELCH, ANTHONY DUK, AARON BITZER, Petitioners, v. EDMUND G. BROWN JR., Governor of the State of California, et al., Respondents. --------------------------------- --------------------------------- On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari To The United States Court Of Appeals For The Ninth Circuit --------------------------------- --------------------------------- PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI --------------------------------- --------------------------------- KEVIN T. S NIDER Counsel of Record MATTHEW B. MCREYNOLDS PACIFIC JUSTICE INSTITUTE PO Box 276600 Sacramento, CA 95827 Phone: (916) 857-6900 Fax: (916) 857-6902 E-mail: [email protected] Attorneys for Petitioners ================================================================ COCKLE LEGAL BRIEFS (800) 225-6964 WWW.COCKLELEGALBRIEFS.COM i QUESTIONS PRESENTED The State of California now prohibits mental health providers from offering “sexual orientation change efforts” (SOCE) to minors. In so doing, the en- acting legislation (Senate Bill 1172) and the legislative history made repeated references to the religious mo- tivations of SOCE seekers and providers, and the Legislature noted that SOCE includes religious conver- sion, prayer and spiritual intervention. The text of the law does not explicitly refer to religion. Instead, the law states that “under no circumstances shall a mental health
    [Show full text]
  • ( Academic Catalog :: 2004-2006 > > > Table of Contents
    KENTUCKY FLORIDA VIRTUAL ( ACADEMIC CATALOG :: 2004-2006 > > > TABLE OF CONTENTS SEMINARY CALENDAR ..............................................................................................................................................2 STATEMENT OF FAITH ................................................................................................................................................7 GENERAL INFORMATION ..........................................................................................................................................9 ACADEMIC INFORMATION ....................................................................................................................................17 Admission Policy & Procedures..................................................................................................................18 Academic Policies ............................................................................................................................................22 Cooperative Programs....................................................................................................................................31 PROGRAMS OF STUDY ............................................................................................................................................37 Master of Divinity Program..........................................................................................................................38 Distributed and Extended Learning..........................................................................................................49
    [Show full text]
  • Waves of Worship Shared in an Email to Church Mem- the Haters Because, I Mean, Boy Oh Bers
    San Diego County Edition Vol. 31, No. 5 May 2013 www.christianexaminer.com Eric Metaxas Dancing in Heaven Entertainment Tiresome bias: Turning Carol Garlow loses Comedian walks away FREE a blind eye to evil cancer battle after from secular venues extended fi ght to foster Kingdom page 5 page 8 page 10 In the midst of tragedy, high-profi le pastors are the target of ‘haters’ By Lori Arnold LA MESA — Three days after announcing that his adult son had ended his protracted battle with mental illness by taking his own life, Pastor Rick Warren of Saddleback Church returned to social media to share other deeply troubling news. “Grieving is hard. Grieving as public fi gures, harder. Grieving while haters celebrate your pain, hardest,” the Lake Forest pastor wrote on his Facebook page. Matthew Warren, the 27-year-old son of Warren and his wife, Kay, Members of Church @ the Beach in Imperial Beach listen to the Sunday message. The congregation has traded pews died April 5 of a self-infl icted gun- and air conditioning for beach chairs and salt air. shot wound. “In spite of America’s best doc- Saddleback Church Pastor Rick Warren tors, meds, counselors and prayers has been the target of social media for healing, the torture of mental attacks since the death of his son by suicide on April 5. illness never subsided,” Warren Waves of Worship shared in an email to church mem- the haters because, I mean, boy oh bers. “Tonight, after a fun evening boy, these are people who are really together with Kay and me, in a in a dark place,” she said, adding Church @ the Beach makes a spiritual splash momentary wave of despair at his that many of the comments ap- Story by Lori Arnold really blessed us,” said Bell, who “The Church @ the Beach in home, he took his life.” peared to take issue with Warren’s Photos by Brittany Keener co-pastors the church with Eric IB is a fully functioning church,” After the incident, Warren con- stand opposing same-sex marriage.
    [Show full text]
  • Congressional Record United States Th of America PROCEEDINGS and DEBATES of the 114 CONGRESS, SECOND SESSION
    E PL UR UM IB N U U S Congressional Record United States th of America PROCEEDINGS AND DEBATES OF THE 114 CONGRESS, SECOND SESSION Vol. 162 WASHINGTON, WEDNESDAY, JULY 13, 2016 No. 113 House of Representatives The House met at 10 a.m. and was beaten, broken, or sad, as you can see It will be a minimum of 10 years be- called to order by the Speaker pro tem- by the smile on his face. fore Oscar can talk—that is just talk— pore (Ms. ROS-LEHTINEN). Even after spending 35 years in jail, to a parole board. It is now or never, nearly half of his life, he is a hero to f and President Obama holds all the many people in Puerto Rico and cards. We could not allow Oscar to die DESIGNATION OF SPEAKER PRO throughout the Puerto Rico diaspora. in jail. Obama must commute his sen- TEMPORE It warms my heart that people from tence. The SPEAKER pro tempore laid be- every walk of life now understand that A coalition, La Coalicion por la fore the House the following commu- the 35 years Oscar has served for Liberacion de Oscar Lopez Rivera, has nication from the Speaker: crimes that were not violent is too formed with lawyers, union leaders, long to be in jail. There is a elected officials, community leaders, WASHINGTON, DC, groundswell of support to tell Presi- July 13, 2016. and citizens from every walk of life in I hereby appoint the Honorable ILEANA dent Obama that, after 35 years, it is Puerto Rico and wherever Puerto ROS-LEHTINEN to act as Speaker pro tempore time to let Oscar Lopez Rivera come Ricans live in the United States.
    [Show full text]
  • The Public Eye, Spring 2009
    Looking Back at Proposition 8, p .3 TheA PUBLICATION OF POLITICAL R PublicEyeESEARCH ASSOCIATES SPRING 2009 • Volume XXIV, No.1 $5.25 New Tactics and Coalitions Take Aim at Planned Parenthood s s e r By Adele M. Stan P d e t a or the leaders and workers of Planned i c o s s Parenthood Federation of America, A F / c a z attacks from right-wing foes are nothing i P . C new. Almost from the moment that the s a l g U.S. Supreme Court legalized abortion in u o D 1973, the federation and its clinics have When young members of the LGBTQ group Soulforce visited Brigham Young University in April 2006 to been in the sights of right-wing activists, promote respect for gay rights, student Matt Kulish led them on a walk from the Mormon Temple (rear) most horrifically in 1994 during the har - to campus. rowing siege of a Brookline, Massachusetts, clinic when a gunman took the lives of two workers in the name of God. Indeed major anti-abortion groups Younger Evangelicals recently came together in a master coali - tion using old time pressure tactics aimed Where WillTheyTake the Christian Right? at stripping Planned Parenthood of its By Pam Chamberlain * 2008 was the third year of the Equality government funding (see box, pg .10). ast October a chartered bus rolled deep Ride, a project of Soulforce Q, the youth But a new generation is using new Lthrough the South, its passenger’s col - arm of Soulforce, an organization Mel media tactics to challenge Planned lege-aged young people drawing inspiration White cofounded “to cut off homophobia Parenthood,
    [Show full text]
  • John Corvino
    JOHN CORVINO Irvin D. Reid Honors College (313) 577-3030 Wayne State University [email protected] Detroit MI 48202 www.johncorvino.com EMPLOYMENT Dean, Irvin D. Reid Honors College, Wayne State University: since May 2018 Chair, Department of Philosophy, Wayne State University: January 2012 to April 2018. Professor since 2015; Associate Professor (with tenure) 2007-2015, Assistant Professor 2001-2007, Senior Lecturer 1999-2001, Lecturer 1998-1999. EDUCATION Ph.D. 1998 The University of Texas at Austin Dissertation: Hume’s Moral Realism (Director: A.P. Martinich) B.A. 1990 cum laude St. John's University, New York AREAS OF SPECIALIZATION Ethical Theory, Applied Ethics, LGBTQ Studies AREAS OF COMPETENCE Social and Political Philosophy, Early Modern Philosophy (especially Hume) PUBLICATIONS: Books Authored: Debating Religious Liberty and Discrimination with counterpoint by Ryan T. Anderson and Sherif Girgis, (Oxford University Press, 2017). What’s Wrong with Homosexuality? (Oxford University Press, 2013). Finnish edition: Mitä väärää on homoseksuaalisuudessa? translated by Kirsi Luoma; Like Publishing, 2014. Debating Same-Sex Marriage with counterpoint by Maggie Gallagher, (Oxford University Press, 2012). Books Edited: Same Sex: Debating the Ethics, Science, and Culture of Homosexuality, (Rowman & Littlefield, 1997). Journal Articles and Book Chapters: “The Kind of Cake, Not the Kind of Customer: Masterpiece, Sexual-Orientation Discrimination, and the Metaphysics of Cakes,” forthcoming in Volume 46 of Philosophical Topics. John Corvino Page 2 of 18 “Puzzles About Bigotry: A Reply to McClain,” Boston University Law Review, Vol. 99 No. 6, pp. 2587-2609. “Religious Belief, Discrimination, and the Law” and “Reply to Anderson and Girgis” [excerpted and adapted from Debating Religious Liberty and Discrimination] in Bob Fischer, ed.
    [Show full text]
  • Missing Voices
    University of Missouri Center on Religion & the Professions Missing Voices: A study of religious voices in Mainstream Media reports about LGBT equality By Debra L. Mason, PhD and Cathy Ellen Rosenholtz, MDiv. April 11, 2012 Copyright 2012 Center on Religion & the Professions 30 Neff Annex Columbia, MO 65211 T 573-882-9257 F 573-884-0977 [email protected] University of Missouri Center on Religion & the Professions Contents Acknowledgments 3 Executive Summary 4 Introduction 5 Methodology and Findings 10 Conclusions and Discussion 20 References 23 Appendix A: Detailed Methodology 27 Appendix B: Complete descriptive statistics and correlations 32 Appendix C: Codebook and variable descriptions 45 Appendix D: Positive and negative messages 53 Appendix E: List of sources 99 Appendix F: Researcher biographies 130 Missing Voices: A study of religious voices in Mainstream Media reports about LGBT equality | January 2012 University of Missouri Center on Religion & the Professions Acknowledgements This study had its origins in summer 2011 at the invitation of the Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD). This research significantly benefited from a literature search and past research by University of Missouri doctoral student, the Rev. Cathy Ellen Rosenholtz. Rosenholtz created the coding structure and enunciated the concepts used in the final study. Caitlin Giddings was an able and committed coder for all the content, helping us to assure accuracy and consistency. Director Ken Fleming and Program Coordinator Sarah J. Samson at Missouri’s Center for Advanced Social Research made sure the data were entered with integrity and accuracy. The Center on Religion & the Professions would also like to thank the University of Missouri for its support of this project.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Traditional Dispensational Social and Political Ethics
    Bruce A. Baker Council on Dispensational Hermeneutics Sept 14-15, 2016 at Winona Lake, IN Traditional Dispensational Social and Political Ethics — From J. N. Darby to Charles C. Ryrie From the White House1 to the Congress,2 from the pulpit3 to the Tea Party4 to the Iowa caucuses,5 the political influence of religious conservatives, many of whom are 1 “Pat Robertson’s resignation this month as president of the Christian Coalition confirmed the ascendance of a new leader of the religious right in America: George W. Bush. For the first time since religious conservatives became a modern political movement, the president of the United States has become the movement’s de facto leader—a status even Ronald Reagan, though admired by religious conservatives, never earned. Christian publications, radio and television shower Bush with praise, while preachers from the pulpit treat his leadership as an act of providence.” Dana Milbank, “Religious Right Finds Its Center in Oval Office,” The Washington Post (2001), http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/ wp-dyn/A19253-2001Dec23?language=printer (accessed June 24, 2012). 2 “On July 16, I attended Christians United for Israel’s annual Washington-Israel Summit. Founded by San Antonio-based megachurch pastor John Hagee, CUFI has added the grassroots muscle of the Christian right to the already potent Israel lobby. Hagee and his minions have forged close ties with the Bush White House and members of Congress from Sen. Joseph Lieberman to Sen. John McCain. In its call for a unilateral military attack on Iran and the expansion of Israeli territory, CUFI has found unwavering encouragement from traditional pro-Israel groups like AIPAC and elements of the Israeli government.
    [Show full text]
  • When Healing Doesn't Come
    San Diego County Edition Vol. 31, No. 4 April 2013 www.christianexaminer.com Mark Larson Eric Metaxas Community Did you hear? Sunsets Facing opposition: Ministry shares clothes, FREE and meteors speak to us Let’s be disliked for love, the gospel the right reasons page 4 page 5 page 7 When healing doesn’t come Carol Garlow clings to Christ and family in protracted cancer battle By Lori Arnold this doctor was telling my family. … He felt like my body was shutting down, or beginning to. I ne year ago, while Carol Garlow was came into the emergency room with some prob- sedated after a fi fth hospital visit in four lems, but I didn’t feel like I was close to death,” Omonths due to complications from che- she added, chuckling at the prognosis. motherapy, the doctor told her pastor husband, When she awoke in the mid afternoon, she was Jim Garlow from Skyline Church, that his wife’s confused by the group that had gathered around condition had deteriorated and she only had three her bedside and was wondering what was going to six months to live. on. Garlow called in the troops: their immediate “All of a sudden they heard from me, ‘Did I family, extended family and several close friends miss something?’” who had been their support system for her then Later she learned that while she was under se- fi ve-year battle with ovarian cancer. They all gath- dation her husband “just fell apart.” ered around her bedside awaiting the doctor to “If I had been awake I could have fought them fi ll them in on what was next.
    [Show full text]