Jobs in the Creative Economy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE JOBS IN NEW ENGLAND’S CREATIVE ECONOMY AND WHY THEY MATTER Produced for the New England Foundation for the Arts By the Economic and Public Policy Research Group of the UMass Donahue Institute JUNE 2017 Table of Contents List of Figures 3 List of Tables 4 About the Findings 6 History and Contextualization of Creative Economy Research 10 About the Report 14 Definitions 18 Summary of Findings 22 Snapshot of the Current State of New England’s Creative Economy 22 Change of the Creative Economy Over Time 24 The Current Creative Economy 26 Creative Enterprises 27 Creative Economy Industry Groups 32 Creative Nonemployer Establishments 36 Geographic Analysis of Creative Economy Enterprises 38 Creative Occupations in New England's Businesses 41 Industries Employing Creative Workers 51 The Change of the Creative Economy over Time 56 Change in Creative Enterprise Payroll Employment Since 2007 57 Industries That Comprise the Creative Economy 60 Change in Creative Enterprise Employment by Industry Group, 2007-2015 63 Growing Occupations in New England, 2007 – 2015 70 Long-Term Trends in the Creative Economy, 2000 through 2015 72 Creative Workforce Characteristics 78 Demographic Characteristics 79 Creatives Count Survey: Worker Resources and Needs 83 Methodology 98 Acknowledgments 108 References and Related Reading 110 Appendix 111 Lessons Learned & Advice for Future Researchers 111 Appendix A - Creative Economy Profile Detail, New England and the U.S., 2007-2015 117 Appendix B - Creative Economy in the New England States 146 Appendix C - Geographic Analysis of Creative Economy Enterprises, 2014 192 Appendix D - Methodology: Creative Enterprises, Industry Codes 194 Appendix E - Methodology: Creative and Artistic Occupations, Occupational Codes 206 List of Figures Figure 1: Relationship of Study Components 15 Figure 2: The Relationship Between Creative Enterprises and Creative Occupations 16 Figure 3: Focus of Section on Creative Enterprises 26 Figure 4: Creative Economy Payroll Employment and Establishments by State’s Share of New England Total, 2015 29 Figure 5: New England Creative Economy Establishment Counts By Industry Group, 2015 32 Figure 6: Top 10 New England Towns by Number of Creative Enterprises 39 Figure 7: Creative Enterprises per 1,000 Residents 39 Figure 8: Creative Workforce By Personal Income, 2014 50 Figure 9: Creative Workforce by Household Income, 2014 50 Figure 10: Creative Workforce By Employer Type, 2014 55 Figure 11: Absolute Change in the Payroll Employment of Creative Sectors Compared to Other Industries with Embedded Creative Sectors Removed, 2007–2015 62 Figure 12: Change in Creative Payroll Employment by Industry Group in New England and the U.S., 2007 and 2015 66 Figure 13: Share of Total Creative Payroll Employment by Industry Group in New England, 2007 and 2015 67 Figure 14: New England Creative Enterprise Payroll Employment Compared to Overall Payroll Employment, 2000-2015 72 Figure 15: United States Creative Enterprise Payroll Employment Compared to Overall Payroll Employment, 2000-2015 73 Figure 16: Change in Creative Employment Compared to Independent Artists, Writers, and Performer Nonemployers, 2001-2014 74 Figure 17: Independent Artists, Writers and Performers Nonemployer Establishments in the New England States, 2001-2014 76 Figure 18: Independent Artists, Writers and Performers Nonemployer Establishments in New England and the United States, 2001-2014 77 Figure 20: Creative Workforce by Educational Attainment, 2014 82 Figure 21: Creatives Count Educational Attainment, 2016 83 Figure 22: Place of Residence of Survey Respondents, 2016 85 Figure 23: Groups Served by Survey Respondents, 2016 85 Figure 24: Relationship of Occupational Groupings of Demographic Analysis 105 List of Tables Graphic 1: Total Creative Economy Employment, Nonemployers from 2014 and Payroll from 2015 28 Table 1: Creative Economy Payroll Employment By Industry Group 2015 33 Table 2: Top Ten Industry Sectors By Payroll Employment in New England and United States, 2015 34 Table 3: Estimate of the Number and Employment of Creative Nonprofits with 2015 Revenues in New England States 36 Table 4: Creative Nonemployers by Creative Industry Group, 2014 37 Table 5: Top 30 New England Cities by Number of Creative Enterprises Per Capita, 2016 40 Graphic 2A: New England Creative Payroll Occupations (2015) and Creative Nonemployers (2014) 42 Graphic 2B: Occupational Location Quotients by State and Region, 2015 42 Table 6: Top Ten Creative Workforce Occupations in New England and the United States Ranked by Payroll Employment, 2015 44 Table 7: Top Ten Payroll Creative Workforce Occupations by Location Quotient in New England, 2015 45 Table 8: Top Ten Payroll Employment Occupations, 2016 46 Table 9: Top Ten Self-Employed Occupations, 2016 46 Table 10: Top Five Artist Occupations for New England and Its States, 2014 47 Table 11: Artist Occupation Location Quotients for New England and Its States, 2014 48 Table 12: Creative Workforce by Weekly Hours Worked, 2014 49 Table 13: Top Ten Industries That Employ Creative Workers In New England The United States, 2015 52 Table 14: Creatives Count Survey - Top Ten Industries Employing Creative Workers, 2016 52 Table 15: Share Of Income By Source, 2016 54 Table 16: Creative Enterprise Employment Change from 2007 Summary, Nonemployers to 2014 and Payroll Employment to 2015 56 Table 17: Creative Payroll Employment in New England, Its States, and the U.S., 2007 and 2015 58 Table 18: Creative Payroll Employment Location Quotient in New England, Its States, and the U.S., 2007 and 2015 58 Table 19: Creative Economy Employment within Two-Digit Industry Sectors, 2007 and 2015 61 Table 20: Absolute Change in the Payroll Employment of Industries Without Creative Sectors, 2007–2015 63 Graphic 3: Change in Creative Employment by Industry Group - Payroll and Nonemployer 2007 and 2015 65 Table 21: Top Ten Creative Industry Sectors by Employment in New England in 2007 and 2015 69 Table 22: Creative Occupations with Growth in New England, 2007-2015 71 Table 23: Creative Workforce by Age, 2014 80 Table 24: Creative Workforce by Race, 2014 80 Table 25: Location of Primary Workspace of Survey Respondents by State, 2016 86 Table 26: Ownership Type of Primary Workspace of Survey Respondents by State, 2016 87 Table 27: Location of Primary Workspace of Survey Respondents by Discipline, 2016 88 Table 28: Ownership Type of Primary Workspace of Survey Respondents by Discipline, 2016 89 Table 29: Expenditure Categories of Survey Respondents by Share of Total, 2016 90 Table 30: Survey Respondents’ Top 5 Resources of Importance for Career Advancement – Rank by State Including Ties, 2016 92 Table 31: Survey Respondents’ Top 5 Resources of Importance for Career Advancement – Rank by Discipline Including Ties, 2016 93 Table 32: Survey Respondents’ Top 5 Unmet Needs – Rank by State Including Ties, 2016 94 Table 33: Survey Respondents’ Top 5 Unmet Needs – Rank by Discipline Including Ties, 2016 95 Table 34: Residence after College of Survey Respondents Graduating in New England, 2016 96 Table 35: State of Current Residence and State of College Graduation of Survey Respondents, 2016 96 Table 36: Creative Employment Table from Page 6 of The Creative Economy: A New Definition 103 Table 37: Recreation of the Creative Employment Table from Page 6 of Creative Economy: A New Definition Using This Study’s Data Sources 103 About The Findings At the New England Foundation for the Arts (NEFA), It includes many industry sectors and occupations one of our missions is to strengthen the region’s cre- that contribute to the economic vitality and cultural ative economy through research that informs public attractiveness of a place. Creative enterprises employ policy. That is why we partnered with the Econom- workers with all kinds of expertise, and creative econ- ic and Public Policy Research group of the UMass omy workers are employed in nearly every sector that Donahue Institute (UMDI) to answer a few important powers New England, from the arts, to education, to questions. What are New England’s creative enterpris- technology and science, to major global brands. They es? Who are New England’s creative workers? How create what we listen to, watch, read, wear and buy. do they overlap? How do they vary by state and what And they play a key role in determining where we want role are they playing in the overall economy? By finding to live, work, and go on vacation. data on and accounting for creative sector employ- ment, income, demographics, and socioeconomic attri- There are nearly 310,000 people employed by the cre- butes, this report aims to provide a full story of creative ative economy of New England—working within an or- work and workers in New England. ganization or freelancing—who combined earn nearly $17 billion a year. This group is a more prominent part What we know is that the creative sector is not just of New England’s economy than the national average, creative enterprises like museums and magazines, and they comprise nearly as many as those who work or artists such as musicians, painters, and dancers. in either government or construction in the region. 6 | THE JOBS IN NEW ENGLAND'S CREATIVE ECONOMY AND WHY THEY MATTER How are these enterprises and workers faring? Those These trends present a great opportunity for new in the creative core industries and occupations, such ideas, policies and business models. The ability of local as theater and photography, are in a segment that is artists and creative workers to interact with and offer stable or increasing. But the rest are being impacted their products within their communities is fragile and by global trends in technology and changing consumer maintaining such markets requires purposeful action. habits. In New England, work life varies across geography and For example, as purchasing moves online, creative discipline, each place and creative worker has differ- enterprises face more competition and less connec- ent needs and access to different resources.