SEVEN

THE EXILE OF ABBOT HENRY GREGORY GREGORY, 1859–1877

Cardinal Barnabò rejoiced that the storm in the Archdiocese of Syd- ney had passed,1 but soon found himself again grappling with more problems in that quarter. The personal nature of the criticisms gave a barbed edge to the anti-Benedictine agitation in Sydney in the late 1850s. The chief target of these attacks was Henry Gregory (see fi g. 31), who, as of St Mary’s and of the Archdiocese, was Polding’s right hand man, the one responsible for the day-to-day government of the Church and for implementing diocesan policy and the ’s decisions. A combination of factors made him a vulnerable fi gure.

I

Born in Cheltenham in 1813, into a family of landed gentry, converted to Catholicism at the age of 11 and educated by the at Douai and Downside, Henry Gregory Gregory took the habit in 1833. Polding was his master and this was the beginning of a relation- ship which grew into an ardent friendship lasting the rest of their lives. Gregory was a member of Polding’s missionary party which voyaged to New South Wales in 1835. Polding became very fond of him, describing him from a vantage point much later in life as having been his ‘dimidium animae meae’, the second half of his soul.2 After in 1837 Pold- ing took him on missionary tours and entrusted him with a number of important assignments. On their return from Europe in 1843 Polding conferred the offi ces of Vicar General and monastic Prior on the thirty year-old Gregory. For his part Gregory repaid Polding with an intense and affectionate loyalty. Conscious of his ecclesiastical rank and social

1 Barnabò-Polding, 26 September 1860, SAA, Polding papers, Propaganda. 2 Polding-Gregory, 26 January 1870 and 6 October 1871, quoted in H. N. Birt, Benedictine Pioneers in Australia, (London: Herbert & Daniel, 1911), volume II, 360 and 366. 206 chapter seven standing, inwardly he lacked confi dence. Young and inexperienced, he had moved virtually straight from the at Downside to a raw colonial society, there to continue his religious formation and theologi- cal education in fragmentary fashion in the midst of early premature pastoral and administrative duties. He tried to compensate for his feel- ings of insecurity by adopting a manner of dealing with people that only succeeded in presenting itself as haughty and authoritarian. His pronounced gentry-class English speech and manners further handi- capped him in a community overwhelmingly proletarian and Irish. He held the Irish character in low esteem and they saw him as arrogant. His relationship with Polding bore the impress of Polding’s dependent personality. Polding tended to lean on strong characters, fi rst of all Ullathorne and then, after Ullathorne’s return to England, Gregory. Because of his own craving to be liked, Polding had a habit of distancing himself from awkward situations, leaving them to his immediate subordinates to with as best as they could. Because of his dignity as head of the in Sydney and his personal popularity, the critics of archdiocesan government in the 1850s were careful not to attack the Archbishop himself too strongly or directly. The Vicar General was an easier target.3

II

The Freeman’s Journal concentrated on Gregory from the beginning of its campaign but the criticism reached fever pitch after the Catholic

3 For Gregory generally and his part in the controversies of the 1850s, see M. Sha- nahan, Out of Time, Out of Place: Henry Gregory and the Benedictine Order in Colonial Australia (Canberra: ANU Press, 1970), passim, but especially, xiv–xv, 1–6, 10–14, 21–38, 42–75 and 123 and M. Shanahan, ‘Gregory, Henry Gregory (1813–1877)’, ADB, volume I, 473–4. See also D. Birchley, John McEncroe: Colonial Democrat (Melbourne: Collins Dove, 1986, 202, 207; G. Haines, ‘The Sydney Freeman’s Journal and the English Benedic- tine in New South Wales: The Criticisms within the Catholic Church, 1857–1860’, MAHons thesis, University of Sydney, 1970, 62; J. Hosie, ‘1859: Year of Crisis in the Australian Catholic Church’, JRH, volume 7, number 4 (December 1973), 346, 356; J. Leclerq, ‘Polding and Gregory in the Light of Monastic Mission and Friendship since Boniface’, Tjurunga, 15 (May 1978), 47–64; F. O’Donoghue, The of Botany Bay: The Life of John Polding, Australia’s First Catholic Archbishop (London: Angus & Robertson, 1982), 23, 37, 41, 57, 59; P. O’Farrell, The Catholic Church and Community in Australia: A History (Melbourne: Thomas Nelson, 1977), 78–9; T. Suttor, Hierarchy and Democracy in Australia 1788–1870: The Foundation of Australian Catholicism (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press), 76–8.