WALLS THAT CAN TALK...
DREAM, UTOPIA OR FANTASY?
TWO ROADS DIVERGED IN A WOOD, AND I, I TOOK THE LESS TRAVELED BY, THAT HAS MADE ALL THE DIFFERENCE...
ROBERT FROST
CITY MUSEUM FOR ISTANBUL by
ELIF ERTEKIN
A THESIS PROJECT SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE
VIRGINIA POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE AND STATE UNIVERSITY
IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF
MASTER OF ARCHITECTURE
APPROVED BY:
PAUL EMMONS
Commitee Member
JAAN HOLT
Chairman
MARCO FRASCARI
Commitee Member
SUSAN PIEDMONT-PALLADINO
Commitee Member
BRIAN KANE
Commitee Member
JUNE 04, 2004
WAAC ALEXANDRIA, VIRGINIA COPYRIGHT 2005, ELIF ERTEKIN
i
ABSTRACT
MY THESIS; “ CITY MUSEUM FOR ISTANBUL ” TELLS THE STORY OF ISTANBUL . THE PROJECT; FROM ITS PLANS TO ITS ELEVATIONS AND SECTIONS IS DESIGNED BY A CLEAR UNDERSTANDING AND CLASSIFICATION OF THE CITY AND ITS LONG HISTORY. EVERY DETAIL THAT HAS BEEN INSERTED IN THE BUILDING HAS BEEN USED IN ISTANBUL, IS A PROOF OF SOMETHING THAT BELONGS TO THE CITY AND THE TASTE OF ITS PEOPLE. THE MOST STRIKING CHARACTERISTIC OF THE MUSEUM IS; ITS GIANT AND POWERFUL WALLS. THE IDEA OF USING WALLS CAME FROM THE FACT THAT ISTANBUL WAS FOUNDED AS A WALLED CITY. FOLLOWING THE HISTORY OF ISTANBUL, I PICKED UP THE MOST IMPORTANT ASPECTS OF THE CITY AND WITH RESPECT TO THEIR ORIGINAL FUNCTIONS, I USED THEM IN MY DESIGN. THE CITY WALLS WERE JUST THE BEGINNING; THEY HELPED ME TO DIVIDE MY SITE INTO DIFFERENT PARTS, DEFINING SPACES AND HANDLING EVERY FUNCTION IN THE MUSEUM. FROM EXHIBITION AREAS TO COURTYARDS, OFFICES TO THE CAFETERIAS EVERYTHING HAPPENS BETWEEN THE NARROW, HIGH AND MASSIVE WALLS. THEIR APPEARANCES AND THE MATERIALS CHANGE DEPEND- ING ON THEIR RESPONSIBILITIES; THAT IS HOW THEY START TO TALK AND WHERE THE JOURNEY OF ISTANBUL BEGINS...
CITY MUSEUM FOR ISTANBUL
BY
ELIF ERTEKIN
ii
DEDICATION
THIS BOOK IS DEDICATED TO MY FAMILY WITH DEEPEST LOVE AND APPRECIATION; TO MY MOTHER ISIK ERTEKIN TO MY BROTHER ERGUN ERTEKIN AND TO THE MEMORY OF MY FATHER ERDOGAN ERTEKIN
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I WOULD LIKE TO THANK ALL THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE HELPED ME ALONG THE WAY COMPLETING MY DREAM; FIRST AND FOREMOST, I MUST THANK MY MOTHER ISIK ERTEKIN AND MY BROTHER ERGUN ERTEKIN FOR THEIR EXTRAORDINARY PATIENCE, SUPPORT AND ENDLESS LOVE. WITHOUT THEM, I WOULD NEVER HAVE MADE IT. THANK YOU FOR KEEPING ME STRONG, BELIEVING IN ME AND LETTING ME DO SO EVERYDAY. I LOVE YOU BOTH.
I WANT TO THANK MY THESIS ADVISORY COMMITTEE; JAAN HOLT, PAUL EMMONS, MARCO FRASCARI, SUSAN PIEDMONT-PALLADINO AND BRIAN KANE. JAAN; I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR OUR CONVERSATIONS, I ENJOYED EVERY SINGLE WORD OF THEM AND I LEARNED A LOT FROM YOU. THANK YOU FOR SEEING ME EVERYTIME I NEEDED YOU AT MY DESK, MAKING ME STRUGGLE WITH QUESTIONS AND ALWAYS HELPING ME FIND OUT THE RIGHT SOLUTIONS. PAUL; THANK YOU FOR ALWAYS ASKING ME THE RIGHT ISSUES AND KEEPING ME ON TRACK WITH MY INITIAL THOUGHTS. EVERY DISCUSSION WAS A FULFILLMENT FOR ME, AND WORKING IN A BIG SITE WOULD NEVER HAVE BEEN SO ENJOYABLE IF I WAS NOT WORKING WITH YOU. MARCO; YOUR STORIES WERE ALWAYS AN INSPIRATION FOR ME AND THEY ALWAYS LEAD ME TO AN ANSWER WHICH TURNED OUT TO BE AN ENJOYABLE JOURNEY. SUSAN; THINKING ABOUT MY CITY ALONG WITH YOU, MADE ME FIGURE OUT THE ESSENTIALS I NEEDED; AFTER EVERY CRITIC I HAD WITH YOU, I REALIZED A NEW CONCERN TO PRESENT IN MY MUSEUM. BRIAN, MY COURTYARDS AND PLAZA WHICH GAVE ME SO MUCH PLEASURE AT THE END, IS A RESULT OF OUR LONG DISCUSSIONS. YOUR BELIEF IN MY LANDSCAPE DESIGN MADE ME MORE PASSIONATE TO FIND A SOLUTION.
AS FOR THE PAGES THAT FOLLOW, I MUST THANK THE INDIVIDUALS WHO CONTRIBUTED MANY LONG DAYS AND NIGHTS OF FRIENDSHIP, ADVICE AND ASSISTANCE FOR MY FINAL SHOW; JENNIFER JOHNSON, ALEJANDRO SANTOS, NATALIA GARCIA MONTAGNA, GEORGE MAKRINOS, MAGDELENA EUGUES, LUCIA GENOUD, PAUL KOMAR, CAROLINA DAYER, IRENE NAPFLIOTIS, CECILIA DE LA VEGA, LAURA CROCE AND CLAIRE ANDREAS. I WOULD LIKE TO THANK YOU ALL, I WILL ALWAYS REMEMBER THE TIMES THAT WE SHARED TOGETHER.
FINALLY, I WANT TO THANK ISTANBUL- THE BEST PLACE TO BE- FOR INSPIRING ME TO COMMIT TO AND RESPECT ARCHITECTURE.
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PRELUDE:
TITLE PAGE .............................................................................. i ABSTRACT ............................................................................. ii DEDICATION................................................................. ............ iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................................ iv
PROCESS:
CHAPTER 5 DIFFERENT CHARACTERISTICS OF THE WALLS
IDENTIFICATION OF THE WALLS.......................................34
THE JOURNEY INSIDE AND OUTSIDE OF THE WALLS............37
THICKNESS OF THE WALLS.............................................39
CHAPTER 2 INTERPRETING THE CITY
CHAPTER 1 THE ESSENTIALS OF ISTANBUL AND THE SITE
THE CITY...ISTANBUL................................................. 1 THE WALL............................................................... 2 CITY WALLS OF ISTANBUL.......................................... 3
VICTOR HUGO; THIS WILL KILL THAT...........................4
THE SITE DISTRICT...BEYOGLU................................... 5 THE SITE................................................................. 6 SITE PICTURES..........................................................7 WALLS SURROUND MANY THINGS................................ 8 THE MAIN PERIODS OF ISTANBUL................................ 9 THE PROGRAM..........................................................10 THE WALL AND THE SITE........................................... 11 DISTRICTS OF ISTANBUL............................................ 12
WALLS HAVE FEELINGS.............................................. 13
THE SITE AS A MAP................................................... 14 NAMING THE WALLS.................................................. 17 INSIDE THESE WALLS................................................. 18 RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE WALLS.................................21
THE FLOW OF THE WALLS OF THE CITY.........................22
THE PLAZA AND THE ENTRANCE................................ 23
PROPOSAL:
CHAPTER 6 AND THE WALLS TALK
CHAPTER 3 THE FIRST STOP
- THE FINAL SHOW ... WALLS TALK.........................
- 41
FIRST STOP IN THE JOURNEY OF THE CITY.................. 24
THE CONNECTION................................................... 25 WHAT WALLS WANT TO SAY........................................ 27
DETAILS OF THE CITY................................................ 49 FINAL SHOW............................................................ 58
POSTLUDE:
CHAPTER 4 WORDS OF THE WALLS
CREDITS....................................................................................60 VITA........................................................................................ 62
LAYERS OF THE WALLS.............................................. 30
TWO DIFFERENT SCALES OF THE WALLS....................... 31
PARTS OF THE MASTER PLAN.......................................33
v
THE CITY OF ISTANBUL
ISTANBUL, ONCE KNOWN AS THE CAPITAL OF CAPITAL CITIES, IS THE ONLY CITY IN THE WORLD TO SPAN TWO CONTINENTS, AND THE ONLY ONE TO HAVE BEEN A CAPITAL DURING TWO CONSECUTIVE EMPIRES; BYZANTINE AND OTTOMAN. IT IS
ONE OF THE OLDEST AND GREATEST CITIES OF THE
TODAY, EVEN IF IT IS NOT THE CAPITAL OF TURKEY ANYMORE, ISTANBUL REMAINS ITS LARGEST CITY AND VIBRATES WITH THE ENERGY OF A MODERN METROPOLIS. IN ADDITION TO BEING THE COMMERCIAL CENTER, THE CITY ALSO CLAIMS ITSELF AS THE ARTS CAPITAL OF THE COUNTRY. SUPPORTING A MIXTURE OF HIGH AND POPULAR CULTURE, ISTANBUL MAINTAINS WORLD-CLASS MUSEUMS AND ANNUALLY HOSTS A SERIES OF INTERNATIONAL FESTIVALS EACH CELEBRATING ONE OF THE PERFORMING OR VISUAL ARTS.
WORLD WITH ONE ARM REACHING OUT TO ASIA AND THE OTHER TO EUROPE. THROUGH THE HEART OF THE CITY, RUNS THE MARMARA SEA KNOWN AS THE BOSPHORUS. DUE TO HER GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION, ISTANBUL HAS ALWAYS BEEN A FAVORABLE SETTLEMENT FOR HUMAN BEINGS STARTING FROM THE EARLY AGES. THE CITY HAS BECOME A CENTER WHERE VARIOUS CULTURES AND RELIGIONS ARE COMBINED, SURVIVED AND SUCCEEDED EACH OTHER AND ITS BEAUTY LIES IN ITS ABILITY TO EMBRACE ITS CONTRADICTIONS; ANCIENT AND
MODERN, RELIGIOUS AND SECULAR, ASIA AND EUROPE, MYSTICAL AND EARTHLY ALL COEXIST IN THE CITY. THIS CULTURAL STRUCTURE WHICH ENABLES A GOOD NUMBER OF ELEMENTS THAT CONTRADICT WITH EACH OTHER AND YET EXIST TOGETHER EVEN ONE IN ANOTHER, IS A PRODUCTION OF AN ACCUMULATION OF LONG HISTORY. THE CITY HAS BEEN CONQUERED, FOUGHT OVER AND REBUILT MANY TIMES OVER THE CENTURIES. THE HISTORY OF ISTANBUL DATES BACK TO THE 3RD MILLENNIUM BC.
1.3. .Esma Sultan Mosque
1.1.Galata Tower
1.4. View of Golden Horn
1.2. Location of Istanbul
1.5. Sultan Ahmet Mosque
TODAY, THE CITY DEFINES A GREAT CITY, NOT ONLY WITH HER POPULATION AND THE AREA SHE COVERS BUT ALSO WITH THE VARIETY OF CULTURES SHE BRINGS TOGETHER.
- 1.7. Taksim- Beyoglu
- 1.6. Courtyard in Beyoglu
- 1.8. Dolmabahce Palace
1
THE WALL
...walled towns are unique inheritances from times long past and should be treasured, maintained and safeguarded from neglect and destruction and passed on to perpetuity as irreplaceable timestones of history...
Piran Declaration
THE WALL DEFINES TERRITORIES, IT DIVIDES TWO SPACES, EACH OF WHICH HAS A DIFFERENT CONTENT. THE BUILT WALL SHOWS THE ACTUAL WAY IN WHICH TWO DIVERSE AREAS MEET, THUS INTERPRETING THE STRONG RELATION BETWEEN THEM.
WALL 1. (n) an upright structure built to enclose or divide a space, especially one side of a room or building 2. a continuous structure of masonry or other material forming a rampart and built for defensive purposes. 3.(V..) to provide to surround, or protect, with or as if with a wall
IT IS WITHIN WALLED CITIES THAT THE LIFE OF CIVILIZED MAN BEGAN ,THE WALLS GUARDED HIM AGAINST BARBARIAN FOES, BEHIND THEIR SHELTER HE FOUND THE SECURITY NECESSARY TO HIS CULTURAL DEVELOPMENT, IN THEIR DEFENSE HE SHOWED HIS FINEST QUALITIES.
2
CITY WALLS OF ISTANBUL
1
2
3
3.1.Cross section of the land walls
The collage showing the growth of land walls over the years
LAND WALLS CONSISTED OF 3 PARTS; A MAIN WALL (1), A LOWER FRONT WALL THAT WAS ADDED IN 447(2), AND A TRENCH (3) THAT WAS DIVIDED IN SECTIONS AND COULD BE FILLED WITH WATER. ISTANBUL’S LAND WALLS, ONCE AN IMPENETRABLE FORTIFICATION STRETCH SEVEN KILOMETERS FROM THE SEA OF MARMARA TOWARDS THE GOLDEN HORN AND THEY DATE BACK TO THE FIFTH CENTURY AND THE REIGN OF EMPEROR THEODOSIUS II.
MY RESEARCH FOR MY THESIS STARTED WITH THE QUESTION:
WHAT THE WALL DO ?
3.2. Land walls of Istanbul
WALLS ALWAYS AMAZED ME BECAUSE I SAW THEM AS THE PRIMARY ELEMENT OF A BUILDING. I RESEARCHED DIFFERENT TYPES, TEXTURES AND MATERIALS OF WALLS THE I AND THE IMPACT THEY CREATE ON PEOPLE’S PSYCHOLOGY. IT BECAME MORE AND MORE AMAZING AS I MOVED ALONG WITH THE QUESTION IN MY MIND;
DO WALLS REALLY HAVE FEELINGS ? CAN THEY TALK ? IF SO ... HOW ?
3.3. Power of the walls
3
VICTOR- HUGO; THIS WILL KILL THAT
I ALWAYS BELIEVED IN THE POWER OF ARCHITECTURE. EVEN LONG BEFORE I CHOSE MY PROFESSION, I WAS AMAZED BY THE BUILDINGS SURROUNDING ME. I ALWAYS THOUGHT ABOUT THE EVENTS THEY HAD WITNESSED AND I HEARD THEM WHISPERING. IT WAS ONLY MY PERCEPTION, MAYBE A WISH; BUT I WAS A CHILD THEN AND IT WAS A COMPLETE MYSTERY FOR ME. WHEN IT WAS TIME TO MAKE A DECISION ABOUT MY PROFESSION, MY FUTURE LIFE I MAY SAY, I DID NOT HESITATE TO STUDY ARCHITECTURE; TO UNDERSTAND, TO DESIGN BUILDINGS AND TO BE A PART OF THE SPECIAL WORLD WHICH TURNED OUT TO BE SO DIFFERENT AND MORE AMAZING FROM WHAT I KNEW SO FAR.
CONSIDERING THE FACT THAT MY THESIS SHOULD HAVE BEEN AN ANSWER TO MY CURIOSITY IN ARCHITECTURE, I WANTED TO DESIGN A BUILDING WHICH CAN TALK TO PEOPLE IN EVERY SINGLE DETAIL AND AS A WHOLE. I WANTED TO PROVE THAT ARCHITECTS, EVEN IN THE 21 CENTURY, HAVE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF EDUCATING PEOPLE WITH THEIR DESIGNS AND GIVE A SOUL TO THEM.
4.3. The walls of Karnac
ST
VICTOR HUGO’S NOTRE DAME, WHICH IS FAMILIAR TO MOST OF US, CONTAINS A SPECIAL CHAPTER IN SOME SPECIAL EDITIONS. THIS CHAPTER WHICH IS NAMED THIS WILL KILL THAT ; CONTAINS HUGO’S CONCERNS ABOUT THE FAST PUBLICATION OF BOOKS. HE ARGUES THAT, UP TO THE FAST PRODUCTION OF THE BOOKS IT WAS ONLY ART AND ARCHITECTURE FROM WHICH WE COULD LEARN ABOUT HISTORY.
HE SAYS; ... THAT ARCHITECTURE DOWN TO THE 15TH CENTURY WAS THE PRINCI P A L REGISTER OF HUMANITY ; THAT DURING THIS PERIOD THERE DID NOT APPEAR IN THE WORLD A THOUGHT OF ANY COMPLEXITY WHICH WAS NOT WORKED INTO A BUILDING ; THAT EVERY POPULAR IDEA AND EVERY RELIGIOUS LAW HAD ITS MONUMENTAL RECORDS ; THAT IN FINE ; THE HUMAN RACE HAD NO IMPORTANT THOUGHTS WHICH IT DID NOT WRITE IN STONE . AND WHY ? IT BECAUSE EVERY THOUGHT BE IT RELIGIOUS OR BE IT PHILOSOPHICAL , IS INTERESTED IN PERPETUATING ITSELF AND BECAUSE THE IDEA WHICH MOVED ONE GENERATION WISHES TO MOVE OTHERS AND LEAVE ITS TRACES .
4.1.The portrait of Victor Hugo
HIS ARGUMENT WAS CLOSE TO MY INTENTION OF DESIGNING A BUILDING WHICH COULD TALK TO PEOPLE. EVEN THOUGH I AM NOT OPPOSED TO THE FAST PRODUCTION OF THE BOOKS, I INSIST ON THE FACT THAT THE BUILDINGS SHOULD BE SEALED WITH THE IMPORTANT ASPECTS OF ITS AGE THAT THEY SHOULD GIVE MESSAGES TO PEOPLE AND THAT ARCHITECTS ARE RESPONSIBLE TO MANAGE THAT.
THE ARCHITECTURE CONCEPT, WHICH IS THE CRUCIAL ARGUMENT IN OUR DESIGNS, SHOULD BE THOUGHT OUT CAREFULLY AS WE ARE ABLE TO REACH PEOPLE BY OUR CREATIVITY. THIS IS THE MAGICAL POWER OF THE HISTORICAL BUILDINGS, THE ONES THAT WE FALL IN LOVE WITH.
4.2. The illustration of Karnac in Notre- Dame
4.4. The Parthenon in Athens
4
THE SITE DISTRICT...BEYOGLU
- 5.1. Location of Turkey in the world map
- 5.3. Location of Beyoglu in Istanbul
5.2. Location of Istanbul in Turkey
THE DISTRICT OF MY PROJECT SITE (4), BEYOGLU, IS ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT DISTRICTS OF ISTANBUL. IT WAS AN OPEN SPACE WITH CEMETERIES AND ORCHARDS UNTIL THE BEGINNING OF 19TH CENTURY. ITS PROXIMITY TO THE TRADE CENTER , GALATA, MADE BEYOGLU POPULAR AMONG FOREIGN PEOPLE LIVING IN ISTANBUL AND THEY SHAPED THE NEIGHBORHOOD IN A VERY EUROPEAN WAY. THE MOST STRIKING PART OF THE DISTRICT IS; PERA, WHICH REACHED ITS PEAK IN THE MID- TO LATE 19TH CENTURY. THE PLACE WAS A CENTERPIECE FOR ART NOUVEAU BELLE EPOQUE STYLE. FRENCH WAS SPOKEN, TOP HATS AND TAILS WERE REQUIRED IN THE NEIGHBORHOODS. TODAY, PERA WHICH IS ALSO KNOWN AS ISTIKLAL STREET OR TAKSIM AS WELL, STILL GIVES A TASTE OF ISTANBUL’S OLD DAYS. THE STREET IS A PEDESTRIAN STREET WHICH IS APPROXIMATELY THREE TO FOUR KILOMETERS LONG, IS COVERED WITH COBBLE STONE AND EVERYDAY IT HOSTS COUPLES WHO COME TO RELAX AFTER A LONG DAY, TOURISTS, YOUNG STUDENTS AND ANYONE WHO WANTS TO TAKE AN ENJOYABLE AND PEACEFUL WALK. THE PLACE IS AN INDISPENSABLE SPOT FOR THE PEOPLE OF ISTANBUL.
PERA IS AND HAS ALWAYS BEEN THE FOREIGN QUARTER AND THE SCENE FOR THE CITY’S BALLROOMS, THEATRES AND NIGHT LIFE. TODAY, THE STREET IS FULL OF NICE CAFE’S WITHIN COURTYARDS, RESTAURANTS, SHOPS, BOOKSTORES, MOVIE THEATRES AND MUSIC STORES. IT IS POPULAR AMONG PEOPLE OF ALL AGES AS EVERYBODY CAN FIND SOMETHING IN THIS STREET FOR THEIR TASTES. THE TRAM IS THE ONLY TRANSPORTATION ALONG THE STREET BUT IT IS ALSO A PLEASURE TO WALK FROM ONE END, TAKSIM SQUARE (1), TO THE OTHER, TUNEL(2).
THE REASONS WHY I WANTED TO WORK IN THIS NEIGHBORHOOD FOR MY
THESIS:
1. ITS POPULARITY AMONG PEOPLE LIVING IN ISTANBUL. I WANTED TO DESIGN MY MUSEUM IN SUCH A FAVORABLE PLACE THAT PEOPLE WOULD EVEN COME ACROSS TO THE BUILDING BY COINCIDENCE.
5.4. Istiklal street marked with red
2. TO FOLLOW THE REALITY OF THE CITY ITSELF. BEYOGLU IS THE CULTURE & ENTERTAINMENT CORE OF THE CITY SO IT WOULD BE THE MOST SUITABLE PLACE TO DESIGN THE CITY MUSEUM FOR ISTANBUL. 3. THE PRESENT IMPROPER USAGE OF A PRECIOUS LAND. I WANTED TO GIVE THIS PLACE BACK TO THE RESIDENTS OF THE CITY.
5.5. Galata region and the tower
5.6. Pictures of Istiklal street that date back to early 1900’s
5
THE SITE
N
MY THESIS SITE IS LOCATED PARALLEL TO FAMOUS PERA (PAGE #5) AND SURROUNDED WITH VALUABLE HISTORICAL BUILDINGS. I STARTED THE ANALYSIS OF MY SITE BY DETERMINING THE MAIN PEDESTRIAN ACCESS TO THE SITE WHICH ALLOWED ME TO FIGURE OUT THE CRITICAL POINTS. AS CAN BE SEEN CLEARLY ON THE
RIGHT HAND SITE IT SHOWS THE CONNECTION BETWEEN MY SITE AND PERA WHICH IS A PASSAGE WAY THAT ALLOWS PEOPLE WALK THROUGH. THE
STREET SURROUNDING MY SITE ON THE EAST IS OPEN TO CAR TRAFFIC WHICH CAN’T BE CONSIDERED A PRIMARY STREET. ON THE OTHER HAND, THE WESTERN SIDE OF MY SITE HAS A HEAVY TRAFFIC AS THE ROAD DIES INTO A HIGHWAY. PERA PALACE REPRESENTED WITH # 3 ON THE ANALYSIS IS ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT STRUCTURES OF ISTANBUL. IT IS A FAMOUS HOTEL
USED TO BE KNOWN AS BEING THE FINAL STOP OF THE PASSENGERS OF THE FAMOUS
2
1
6.3. Historical picture of the site (The site is the green space)
4
3
6.1. Insurance map of Pervititich showing my thesis site with number 53, 1926 first site analysis
ORIENT EXPRESS. ANALYSIS ALSO SHOWS THE LOCATIONS OF THE PREVIOUS BUILDINGS BUILT ON MY SITE.
MY SITE IS ALMOST EQUAL TO A SOCCER FIELD AND DOESN’T HAVE A STEEP SLOPE; 6 METERS (9 FEET) FROM ONE END TO THE OTHER, BUT HAS CONSIDERABLE SLOPE DIFFERENCE WITH THE HIGHWAY; 10 METERS (30 FEET) ON THE
6.4.The picture looking towards the street (site is on the left)
SOUTHERN PART OF THE SITE WHERE PEOPLE CAN FIND STEEP STAIRS REACHING FROM THE PEDESTRIAN CURB OF THE HIGHWAY THROUGH MY SITE. THE AERIAL VIEW OF MY SITE AND THE
SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOODS CLEARLY SHOWS HOW DENSE THE CITY IS AND WITH ITS SIZE AND LOCATION HOW IMPORTANT MY PROJECT SITE IS.
Closer look of the site and the neighborhood
6
6.2. The site and the dense appereance of the city
SITE PICTURES
1
2
3
10
4
9
4
5
1
2
7
8
3
5
6
6
8
7
- 9
- 10
7
WALLS SURROUND MANY THINGS...
BUILT AND REBUILT, CONQUERED, LOST, RECONQUERED, REESTABLISHED
AND REGAINED, EMPIRE FOLLOWED EMPIRE, SULTAN FOLLOWED SULTAN. BUT THE HEARTBEAT OF ISTANBUL HAS REMAINED UNCHANGED.
The impression I wanted to give to people with my walls
- A study for the connection of the walls
- Sketches regarding the possible entrance solutions
- Enclosed or disclosed by the wall...Which one is better?
8.1. The appereance of Pera
8
THE MAIN PERIODS OF ISTANBUL: 6 HISTORICAL LAYERS
1
THERE IS ONLY ONE CITY IN THE WORLD THAT SPANS TWO CONTINENTS; ISTANBUL. THE TRUE MERGING OF EAST AND WEST, ISTANBUL STRETCHES ACROSS BOTH EUROPE AND ASIA. THE CONTINENTS ARE SEPARATED ONLY BY A THIN STRIP OF WATER; THE BOSPHORUS. AMONG ALL THE BEAUTIES OF THE CITY, THERE ARE LAYERS OF DIFFERENT CULTURES ON TOP OF EACH OTHER. THROUGHOUT MY RESEARCHES, I CAME TO A POINT WHERE I DECIDED THAT THESE CULTURAL LAYERS SHOULD BE THE KEY POINT THAT I SHOULD PRESENT IN MY MUSEUM. DURING OUR DAILY LIVES, WE; THE RESIDENTS OF THE CITY, CANNOT REALIZE THIS AMAZING HISTORY AND SINCE EVERY NEW CULTURE IS CONSTRUCTED ON TOP OF THE PREVIOUS ONE, IT IS HARD TO MAKE A DISTINCTION BETWEEN THEM. AFTER GIVING THE DECISION OF THE POSSIBLE LOCATIONS OF MY WALLS IN THE SITE, MY NEXT STEP WAS TO MAKE THE CULTURAL DISTINCTION CLEAR IN MY DESIGN WHICH I LISTED AS;
1- GREEK PERIOD ( 7TH CENTURY);
WHAT IS NOW CALLED ASIAN ISTANBUL WAS PROBABLY INHABITED BY PEOPLE AS EARLY AS 3000 B.C. IN THE 7TH CENTURY; GREEK COLONISTS LED BY KING BYZAS, ESTABLISHED THE COLONY OF BYZANTIUM; THE GREEK NAME FOR A CITY ON BOSPHORUS. EVEN THOUGH THERE IS NOT MUCH LEFT FROM THE GREEK PERIOD IN ISTANBUL TODAY, SOME STRUCTURES CAN
STILL BE OBSERVED AND THIS PERIOD WAS THE START FOR THE LONG STORY OF THE CITY.
2
2- BYZANTIUM PERIOD ( 306 AD- 1453)
IN THE EARLY 100’S BC, THE CITY BECAME PART OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE AND IN 306 AD, EMPEROR CONSTANTINE THE GREAT, MADE BYZANTIUM A PART OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE. FROM THAT POINT ON, THE CITY WAS KNOWN AS CONSTANTINOPLE. THE ATTRIBUTE THAT MADE THE CITY SO DESIRABLE, ITS INCOMPARABLE LOCATION FOR TRADE AND TRANSPORT BETWEEN THE CONTINENTS, WAS ALSO ITS DANGER. FOR THE NEXT SEVERAL HUNDRED YEARS, PERSIANS, ARABS, NOMADIC PEOPLE AND MEMBERS OF THE FOURTH CRUSADE (WHO FOR A TIME ALSO GOVERNED THE CITY) ATTACKED CONSTANTINOPLE. THE BYZANTIUM PERIOD LEFT THE CITY SO MANY DELICATE TREASURES AT THE END.
3- OTTOMAN ( 16TH CENTURY) PERIOD
IN 1453, WEAKENED BY ALMOST A CONSTANT BATTLE, THE OTTOMAN TURKS CONQUERED CONSTANTINOPLE. RENAMED ISTANBUL, IT BECAME THE THIRD AND LAST CAPITAL OF THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE. IT WAS THE NERVE CENTER FOR MILITARY CAMPAIGNS THAT WERE TO ENLARGE THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE DRAMATICALLY. BY THE MID 1500’S, ISTANBUL, WITH A POPULATION OF ALMOST HALF A MILLION, WAS A MAJOR CULTURAL, POLITICAL, AND COMMERCIAL CENTER. THE 16TH CENTURY IS THE MOST REMARKABLE PERIOD OF THE EMPIRE BY ALL MEANS. IT CAN BE SAID THAT THE CITY WAS UNDER THE FRENCH AND THE ART NOUVEAU EXPRESSION ON THE EUROPEAN SIDE AS WELL AS BEING CONSISTENT WITH ISLAMIC ARCHITECTURE IN THE REST OF THE CITY. IT WAS SULTAN SULEYMAN THE MAGNIFICENT HOWEVER, WHO BROUGHT THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE TO ITS PEAK. THE FOURTH OTTOMAN SULTAN TO REIGN, FROM 1520 UNTIL 1566, HE PRESIDED OVER THE MOST POWERFUL STATE IN THE WORLD. A REMARKABLE MILITARY STRATEGIST, HE MORE THAN DOUBLED THE OTTOMAN LAND HOLDINGS HE INHERITED FROM HIS FATHER. HE ALSO BROUGHT A PROFUSION OF ELEGANT MOSQUES, BATHS, SCHOOLS, FOUNTAINS BY THE HELP OF SINAN THE REAT ARCHITECT.