Champe Umn 0130E 16079.Pdf (2.435Mb Application/Pdf)

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Champe Umn 0130E 16079.Pdf (2.435Mb Application/Pdf) Multicultural Community Building in an Urban Neighborhood A Dissertation SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY John Champe IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Karen Ho June 2015 © John Champe 2015 i Acknowledgements I would like to thank my advisor, Karen Ho, and the rest of my committee, David Valentine, Jean Langford, and Doug Hartmann. A special thanks also to the Center for Urban and Regional Affairs at the University of Minnesota for some of my research on the neighborhood. For commenting on drafts of chapters, I want to thank Tim Gitzen, Nate Meyer, Amy Porter, Solvieg Brown, Marieke vanEijk, Susi Krehbiel Keefe, Karen kapusta-pofahl, Joe Esser, Sara Kaiser, Alex Bauman, and Dennis Moldestad. I’d also like to thank a few Champes – Sarah, Ava, Amelie, Richard and Sally. ii Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to the activists of the Whittier neighborhood. iii Abstract This is an anthropological ethnography of multicultural community-building among the almost all-white activists in Minneapolis’ largest neighborhood, Whittier. It shows the effects that the discourses, theories, and activities of these neighborhood activists have on the social structures that reproduce class, racial, and ethnic inequality. The first chapter analyzes the acrimonious battle over the opening of an apartment building for homeless. It shows the construction of the symbols at play, including Stability, Burden, Stakeholders, Gentrification, and Over-concentration of the poor. Chapter two explains how politics in Whittier became so polarized between competing factions of white, liberal, middle-class homeowners, who all share a love of their neighborhood’s diversity. The study also illuminates how the faction representing “homeowner interests” achieved dominance. Chapter three shows that while many paint Whittier as very dangerous, statistically it is not. The chapter explains the role that fear, exaggerated talk of crime, citizen crime patrols, media sensationalism, personal identity, and class conflict play in the creation of place and racial segregation. Chapter four explains how ethnic identities and class hierarchies are socially constructed through neighborhood campaigns, and also how the meaning of “diversity” itself gets produced. The chapter details how white and Somali ethnicities are manufactured by struggles over a Somali mall and the parking around it. Chapter five reveals the failures of democracy in Whittier politics, and argues that not only has elected, democratic governance failed, but that attempting it on the neighborhood scale is probably futile and destructive. Chapter six discovers that while the academic literature argues that Americans are largely ignorant of social structures that reproduce inequality, white Whittier activists of many viewpoints are actually cognizant of them, and of their own privilege. This study finds that the key to understanding the multiplicity of thought and policy on poverty and multiculturalism, is by investigating Whittier activists’ theories on neighborhood development. For example, activists opposing more subsidized housing in Whittier espouse that Whittier’s health requires more homeowners, fewer renters, and fewer residents requiring housing subsidies. This activism modified class hierarchy, re- imagining it along the lines of the type of housing one inhabits. iv Table of Contents List of Tables v List of Figures vi Introduction 1 Chapter 1: Building Diverse Communities by Stopping 19 a Housing Program for the Homeless Chapter 2: Case Study on How Politics in the Whittier 99 Neighborhood Become Polarized Chapter 3: “The Shooting Wasn’t Random” – Whittier is not Dangerous 167 Chapter 4: Fashioning Diversity and Ethnicity 241 Chapter 5: Attaining Democracy in Whittier through the Election 303 of Representatives is Neither Realistic nor Desirable Chapter 6: Knowledge of Inequality is Common 358 References Cited 404 Appendix 1: Study of the Studies of Whittier 416 Appendix 2: One Woman Explains her Activism 426 v List of Tables Table 1: Lydia Apartments Timeline 24 Table 2: 2006 Whittier Robberies 179 Table 3: Age of Robbery Victims in Whittier in 2006 180 Table 4: Race of 2006 Robbery Victims in Whittier 181 Table 5: Whittier and Minneapolis Population by Race 241 Table 6: Informant Positions on Subsidized Housing 379 vi List of Figures Figure 1: Examples of stock Neighborhood Watch Signs 217 Figure 2: Images of emptiness from the 50th & France website 271 Figure 3: Author with stacks of studies about Whittier 418 Figure 4: Various studies of Whittier 418 1 Introduction Everywhere one looks in the Whittier neighborhood of Minneapolis, white, middle-class activists are advertising multicultural programs. These schemes caught my attention because of my interest in the proliferation of the many and diverse forms of multiculturalism practiced today. In Whittier for example, the logo of the officially recognized neighborhood organization was “Where Diversity Becomes Community,” while their rival group was “Embracing Democracy and Diversity,” a neighborhood Baptist Church was “A Multicultured People,” and on and on. There are a wide range of programs in Whittier that talk about bringing together people of different types. All this activity begged the anthropological questions, what was happening that there was so much rhetoric and activity expended on “building diverse community” in one neighborhood? What did “valuing diversity” mean to disparate activists? What sorts of multiculturalisms were being practiced? What struggles were taking place between competing players? And what were the effects of all this. The Whittier neighborhood sits just south of downtown Minneapolis, between a poorer, mostly African-American area to the east across the freeway, a wealthier, 95% white area a few blocks to the West, and a growing Latino and Somali small business corridor to the south. The population is noticeably segregated by ethnicity, language, businesses frequented, and ownership status of home. In the late 1960s Whittier’s boundaries were established as Lake Street on the southern edge, Lyndale Avenue to the west, Franklin Avenue to the north, and Interstate 35W to the east.i Of its 13,000 to 15,000 residents, half are white, a fifth African-American, and another fifth Latino; there are also many refugees from the war in Somalia, some recent immigrant families from Southeast Asia, and many other ancestries. Whittier is the largest neighborhood in Minneapolis in area and population, and second in density only to its tiny neighborhood on its northern boundary. All of this diversity is treasured in different ways in Whittier, but in the academic literature there is a critique of multiculturalism that finds that some of its forms “merely” celebrate diversity through its cheery consumption, such as going to Scandinavian festivals and Vietnamese delis, rather than working to fundamentally change social 2 structures that reproduce racial/ethnic inequality (Fraser 1995). With the global rise of free-market neoliberalism (Harvey 2001), the enduring racial segregation in America, the ever-vigilant protection of white privileges (Lipsitz 1998), and the growing gap between rich and poor, I felt it was important to understand the significant and innovative roles that neighborhood activists were playing in these trends. While the whites in Whittier are mostly middle-class, the African-Americans, Somali refugees, and Latino immigrants spend little time in the places of the white social world that surrounds them. Even in the reputedly neutral space of the neighborhood meetings, where policies affecting all these groups is shaped, it is rare to find anyone that is not white, professional, or a homeowner. This dissertation investigates the relationship between neighborhood activism and (in)equality, through the process of multicultural community-building. It answers the question, what effects do the shifting discourses and contested programs of Whittier activists have on social structures that reproduce inequity? And what could be a more natural subject of research for cultural anthropology than multiculturalism and diversity? Writing over a century ago, Franz Boas was the most influential architect of anthropology in America, and given Boas’ liberal perspective on race and culture, contemporary anthropology would seem a natural for studying multiculturalism (Gelya 1997). Surprisingly though, it turns out that anthropology has had very little to say on the subject.ii A trend in contemporary academia is to be interdisciplinary, but my research study is interdisciplinary out of necessity, since the fields of Sociology, History, Cultural Studies, and American Studies have been the ones to tackle this thorny topic head on. Perhaps anthropologists do not find the need to discuss multiculturalism since they feel it is already embedded in their work? When it comes to the designing of multicultural programs in America, maybe this is why anthropologists have been disappointed that they have not been consulted by planners of such important things as school curriculums, government policy, economic development, international business relations, international peace plans, or corporate hiring. “Most of us have been sitting around like so many disconsolate intellectual wallflowers, waiting to be asked to impart our higher wisdom, and more than a little resentful that the invitations never come” (Turner 1993:411).iii 3 But while they may be eminently qualified in this
Recommended publications
  • R E V I E W Issue 7W 2
    1 R E V I E W ISSUE 7W 2 This issue of Corvus Review is dedicated to: Margaret “Marg” Josephine Pittman Feb 22, 1922-Feb. 13, 2017 EDITORS: Janine “Typing Tyrant” Mercer, EIC Luciana Fitzgerald, Fiction Editor COVER ART: C.F. Roberts Writer/Artist/Videographer/Provocateur/High -Functioning Autistic/Former Zine Publisher. Blog: http://cfrobertsuselessfilth.blogspot.com/ Art: http://cfrobertsuselessfilth.blogspot.com/ 3 4. R.Q. Flanagan 5. N. Sumislaski 6. T.L. Naught 8. A. Tipa 9. J. Riccio 11. D. Fagan 12. S.A. Ortiz 13. A. Cole 14. R.G. Foster 15. L. Suchenski 16. D. Tuvell 17. M. L. Johnson 18. S. Laudati 19. R. Nisbet 20. R. Hartwell N.F. 57. M.D. Laing 92. C. Valentza 23. M. Watson N.F. 62. S. Roberts 93. D.D. Vitucci 27. T. Smith N.F. 63. J. Hunter 96. J. Hickey 28. G. Vachon N.F. 67. N. Kovacs 99. J. Bradley 31. K. Shields 69. T. Rutkowski 100. S.F. Greenstein 32. J. Half-Pillow 70. B. Diamond 104. J. Mulhern 37. M. Wren 72. F. Miller 109. B.A. Varghese 38. D. Clark 79. K. Casey 113. K. Maruyama 39. P. Kauffmann 80. K. Hanson 119. K. Azhar 42. Z. Smith 82. J. Butler 120. Author Bio’s 44. J. Hill 83. R. Massoud 46. J. Gorman 86. M. Lee 51. B. Taylor 88. J. Rank 56. M.A. Ferro 4 On Taking a Complete Stranger to the Gynecologist Ryan Quinn Flanagan I have allergies and I have glow sticks and I have driven a complete stranger to the gynecologist, wondering about the sanitary nature of my passenger seat the whole time, playing it cool like Clint Eastwood with a cannon in my pants but soon feeling bad for the girl abandoned by family
    [Show full text]
  • Got Your Six Full Album Download Free FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH Partners with PANDORA for 'Got Your Six' Album Premiere
    got your six full album download free FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH Partners With PANDORA For 'Got Your Six' Album Premiere. FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH has partnered with Pandora for a first listen of the band's new album, "Got Your Six" , to be released worldwide on September 4 via Prospect Park Records in North America and Eleven Seven Music internationally. Fans will be able to stream the entire album including the band's current Top 5 radio smash hit "Jekyll and Hyde" between now and Thursday, September 3 at 4 p.m. PST. Said FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH guitarist Zoltan Bathory : "I'm an avid Pandora user, so I was very exciting when Pandora approached us and we learned that five million fans to date have created FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH stations on their platform — so working with them on debuting 'Got Your Six' seemed like a natural fit. We are looking forward to everyone hearing the new album and this premiere allows all those fans to access the new music for one week and pre-order the album." Added Lars Murray , SVP Music Makers Group, Pandora : "Rock radio is alive and kicking on Pandora and FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH is evidence of that. They have a large and active audience on the platform with nearly five million station creates and over 750 million spins to date, so we're proud to be home of the 'Got Your Six' premiere." The "Got Your Six" pre-order, as well as several exclusive album pre-order merchandise packages, are live at www.fivefingerdeathpunch.com.
    [Show full text]
  • Five Finger Death Punch
    Five Finger Death Punch Ícones do rock mundial se apresentam no Rio de Janeiro Hatebreed fará o show de abertura no Rio de Janeiro, em 10 de maio As duas bandas também estão confirmadas no line up do Maximus Festival 2017, em São Paulo, no dia 13 de maio Já confirmadas no Maximus Festival 2017, alguns dos maiores nomes do rock internacional aproveitarão sua passagem pelo Brasil em maio para se apresentar também em outra capital brasileira. Pela primeira vez no Brasil, a festejada Five Finger Death Punch, que desde o começo desta década é presença assídua nos principais festivais de rock de todo o mundo e vem sendo bastante aguardada pelos brasileiros, estará no Rio de Janeiro, dia 10 de maio, no palco do Vivo Rio, com abertura do Hatebreed. Os ingressos para os shows já estão à venda no site da Livepass. Confira mais informações no "serviço" abaixo. Infelizmente, a banda Five Finger Death Punch não poderá se apresentar em Belo Horizonte, no dia 11 de maio. A banda estará presente no Maximus Festival em São Paulo no dia 13 de maio. Para quem comprou ingressos pelo site da Livepass usando um cartão de crédito, o reembolso será automático. Todos os outros tipos de compras devem enviar um email para [email protected]. As duas bandas integram o line up do Maximus Festival 2017, que acontece dia 13 de maio em Interlagos, São Paulo, e que também conta com Linkin Park, Prophets of Rage, Slayer, Ghost, Rob Zombie, Red Fang, Böhse Onkelz, Pennywise, The Flatliners e as bandas brasileiras, Nem Liminha Ouviu, Dead Fish e Oitão.
    [Show full text]
  • Secretscienceofmagic.Pdf
    The Secret Science of Magic-INTERIOR-OUTLINES.indd 1 9/21/17 4:01 PM Published by PEACHTREE PUBLISHERS 1700 Chattahoochee Avenue Atlanta, Georgia 30318-2112 www.peachtree-online.com Text © 2017 by Melissa Keil Illustrations © 2018 by Brooke Smart First published in Australia in 2017 by Hardie Grant Egmont First United States version published in 2018 by Peachtree Publishers All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means—electronic, mechanical, photocopy, recording, or any other—except for brief quotations in printed reviews, without the prior permission of the publisher. Cover illustrated by Brooke Smart Design and composition by Adela Pons Jacket design by Nicola Carmack Printed in April 2018 by LSC Communications in Harrisonburg, VA 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 First Edition Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Keil, Melissa, author. Title: The secret science of magic / Melissa Keil. Description: First edition. | Atlanta : Peachtree Publishers, 2018. | “First published in Australia in 2017 by Hardie Grant Egmont.” | Summary: Told from two viewpoints, Sophia, seventeen, a Sri Lankan-Australian math prodigy with social anxiety, is panicking about her future when classmate and amateur magician Joshua proclaims his love for her. Identifiers: LCCN 2017021869 | ISBN 9781682630143 Subjects: | CYAC: Genius—Fiction. | Magic tricks—Fiction. | Social phobia— Fiction. | Dating (Social customs)—Fiction. | High schools—Fiction. | Schools— Fiction. | Melbourne (Vic.)—Fiction. | Australia—Fiction. Classification: LCC PZ7.K25187 Sec 2018 | DDC [Fic]—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2017021869 The Secret Science of Magic-INTERIOR-OUTLINES.indd 2 9/21/17 4:01 PM Melissa Keil The Secret Science of Magic-INTERIOR-OUTLINES.indd 3 9/21/17 4:01 PM he greatest card trick in history is known by many names.
    [Show full text]