Complex I Deficiency Due to Loss of Ndufs4 in the Brain Results
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Complex I deficiency due to loss of Ndufs4 in the brain results in progressive encephalopathy resembling Leigh syndrome Albert Quintanaa,1, Shane E. Krusea,1, Raj P. Kapurb, Elisenda Sanzc, and Richard D. Palmitera,2 aHoward Hughes Medical Institute and Department of Biochemistry, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195; bDepartment of Laboratories, Seattle Children’s Hospital, Seattle, WA 98105; and cDepartment of Pharmacology, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195 Contributed by Richard D. Palmiter, May 5, 2010 (sent for review April 22, 2010) To explore the lethal, ataxic phenotype of complex I deficiency in least one intact Ndufs4 allele are indistinguishable from WT Ndufs4 knockout (KO) mice, we inactivated Ndufs4 selectively in mice, and they are sometimes used interchangeably with WT as neurons and glia (NesKO mice). NesKO mice manifested the same controls (CT). To examine the role of the CNS in pathology, we symptoms as KO mice including retarded growth, loss of motor restricted the inactivation of Ndufs4 gene to neurons and lox/lox ability, breathing abnormalities, and death by ∼7 wk. Progressive astroglial cells by crossing the Ndufs4 mice with mice neuronal deterioration and gliosis in specific brain areas corre- expressing Cre recombinase from the Nestin locus (19) to create sponded to behavioral changes as the disease advanced, with mice that we refer to as NesKO mice. We confirmed that Nestin- early involvement of the olfactory bulb, cerebellum, and vestibular Cre results in recombination primarily in the CNS by crossing the nuclei. Neurons, particularly in these brain regions, had aberrant mice with a Rosa26-reporter line and by PCR analysis of DNA mitochondrial morphology. Activation of caspase 8, but not cas- isolated from various organs (Fig. S1A). These data agree with pase 9, in affected brain regions implicate the initiation of the the known robust expression of Nestin in the mouse brain with extrinsic apoptotic pathway. Limited caspase 3 activation and lower levels in a few cell types in heart, kidney, lung, pancreas, the predominance of ultrastructural features of necrotic cell death and testes (19). suggest a switch from apoptosis to necrosis in affected neurons. These data suggest that dysfunctional complex I in specific brain Complex I Activity Is Depressed in Brain of NesKO Mice. Enriched MEDICAL SCIENCES regions results in progressive glial activation that promotes neu- mitochondria were prepared from liver and brain to measure ronal death that ultimately results in mortality. respiratory capacity. Normal rotenone-sensitive complex I ac- tivity was detected in submitochondrial particles (SMPs) isolated cerebellum | mitochondria | gliosis | neurodegeneration | vestibular from liver of NesKO or CT mice; however, complex I activity was nucleus very low or absent in SMPs derived from NesKO brain tissue compared with CT (Fig. S1B). Complex I–dependent O2 con- eural pathologies frequently result from dysfunctional mi- sumption by brain tissue from NesKO mice was depressed ∼50% Ntochondria, and Leigh syndrome (LS) is a common clinical compared with that in CT mice, whereas complex II and IV phenotype (1). LS, or subacute necrotizing encephalopathy, is activities were unaffected (Fig. S1 C and D). The loss of complex a progressive neurodegenerative disorder (2) affecting 1 in I activity was independent of the age of the mouse. These results 40,000 live births (3). LS is regarded as the most common in- with NesKO mice are identical to those observed in the brains of fantile mitochondrial disorder, and most patients exhibit symp- total KO mice (18). toms before 1 mo of age (4, 5). Several cases of adult-onset LS have also been reported recently (6–10). In vivo imaging tech- Nearly Identical Phenotype of KO and NesKO Mice. NesKO mice had niques such as MRI reveal bilateral hyperintense lesions in the a phenotype similar to that of total KO mice (18). By postnatal basal ganglia, thalamus, substantia nigra, brainstem, cerebellar day 21 (P21), most NesKO mice were smaller than control lit- white matter and cortex, cerebral white matter, or spinal cord of termates and reached a maximum body weight of ∼12 g at ∼P30 LS patients (6, 11–14). The lesions usually correlate with gliosis, (Fig. S1E). Resting body temperature of NesKO mice was ∼2 oC demyelination, capillary proliferation, and/or necrosis (10, 15). lower than controls after P30 (Fig. S1F). NesKO mice occa- Behavioral symptoms of LS patients can include (with a wide sionally experienced cataracts, ptosis, or optic atrophy. Even variety of clinical presentation) developmental retardation, hy- when their eyes appeared normal, the mice often had defective potonia, ataxia, spasticity, dystonia, weakness, optic atrophy, visual acuity as measured by Morris water maze, visual cliff test, defects in eye or eyelid movement, hearing impairment, and visual placing (Fig. S1G). However, even KO mice with breathing abnormalities, dysarthria, swallowing difficulties, fail- defective vision were able to distinguish light from dark (Fig. ure to thrive, and gastrointestinal problems (4–6, 16, 17). The S1H). Starting at ∼P35, NesKO mice developed severe ataxia: cause of death in most LS cases is unclear, and the lack of they had splayed legs, became unresponsive to a firm nudge, a genetic model to study the disease progression and cause of were slow and awkward at righting themselves, and sometimes death has impeded the development of adequate treatment. became so unstable they would lose their balance and fall over. Prognosis for LS (and most diseases resulting from mitochon- drial dysfunction) is very poor; there is no cure and treatment is often ineffective (5). Thus, a murine model of this disease should Author contributions: A.Q., S.E.K., and R.D.P. designed research; A.Q., S.E.K., R.P.K., and allow a better means of studying the mechanism(s) underlying E.S. performed research; A.Q., S.E.K., R.P.K., and E.S. analyzed data; and A.Q., S.E.K., and the encephalopathy and should allow a more facile investigation R.D.P. wrote the paper. of potential therapies. The authors declare no conflict of interest. Freely available online through the PNAS open access option. Results 1A.Q. and S.E.K. contributed equally to this work. Mice Lacking Ndufs4 in Nervous System Resemble Total Knockout. 2To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: [email protected]. Mice lacking Ndufs4 (Ndufs4 KO) in all cells develop a complex This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10. phenotype and die by postnatal day 50 (P50) (18). Mice with at 1073/pnas.1006214107/-/DCSupplemental. www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1006214107 PNAS Early Edition | 1of6 Downloaded by guest on September 27, 2021 NesKO mice >P40 were unable to maintain balance on a 7-mm- wide ledge, failed a negative geotaxis test, attempted to clasp a hind leg when suspended by their tail, and fell from a rotating rod very quickly, in contrast to CT mice (Fig. S1I). NesKO mice were very submissive and rarely vocalized even when stressed by handling, tail clipping for genotyping, or in response to a toe pinch (percent vocalization during toe pinch assay: WT, 91.7%, n = 12, P < 0.0001; NesKO and KO, 18.0%, n = 50, P < 0.0001). Some NesKO mice had spontaneous tonic–clonic seizures (∼1/20 NesKO and KO mice), whereas others developed seizures in response to handling (∼1/10 NesKO and KO mice), and the frequency of seizures increased with disease progression. In- termittent breathing irregularities were detected as early as P14 and included hypo- or hyperventilation, but most often involved Fig. 1. Vacuolation and vascular proliferation in NesKO and KO mice. (A) gasping activity. Between P35 and P50, the NesKO mice began to No pathology is observed in H&E staining of brain sections of CT animals (n = lose weight, their ataxia worsened, and they died shortly there- 5). (B and C) In contrast, both late-stage NesKO (B, n = 5) and KO (C, n =5) after. The only significant difference between the phenotype of mice show marked vacuolation in the VN (black arrows; Inset shows higher NesKO mice and complete KO mice is that the latter manifest magnification of indicated area) and, to a lesser extent, in deep cerebellar – a lag time between the exogenic phase of club hair growth and nuclei (white arrow). (D F) Vascular proliferation, as assessed by laminin the anagenic phase of the next hair cycle, resulting in ∼7-d pe- staining, was increased around the VN in NesKO (E) and KO (F) mice com- pared with CT (D). (Scale bar, A–F, 125 μm; Inset, 25 μm.) riod without hair or pigment (18), whereas NesKO mice had a normal hair cycle. An extensive summary of the phenotypes of KO and NesKO mice is provided in Table S1. with the behavioral score described (Table S2). Frozen brain sections from NesKO (n = 5) and KO mice (n = 5) at different Progression of Behavioral Phenotype. Having established that the stages, as well as CT mice (n = 5), were analyzed. A similar pattern major features of the Ndufs4 KO pathology are of neurological of activation in astrocytes and microglial cells appeared simulta- origin, we set out to define the brain regions affected by the loss of neously in the brains of NesKO and KO mice, with overt lesions in Ndufs4 and to correlate pathological changes in the brain with the areas where vacuolation was detected in H&E-stained sec- progression of the behavioral phenotype. A scoring system was tions. NesKO mice had a higher frequency of hemorrhages in established based on weight gain, body temperature, various midbrain, and of gliosis and spongiform lesions in the anterior measures of locomotor skill and activity, touch response, and cerebellum than KO mice. CT animals did not show astroglial trunk curl, rather than age alone, to account for the asynchronous activation and microglial cells retained a ramified morphology progression of the phenotype in different mice.